ML20008D474

Intervenor Exhibit I-MAG-105,consisting of State of Nh 890130 Voluntary Responses to Town of Hampton Informal Discovery Requests Concerning June 1988 Joint Exercise.State 890316 Ltr to Commonwealth of Ma Re Exercise Encl

ML20008D474
Person / Time
Site:	Seabrook
Issue date:	05/25/1989
From:	NEW HAMPSHIRE, STATE OF
To:	HAMPTON, NH
References
OL-I-MAG-105, NUDOCS 9003050162
Download: ML20008D474 (9)

Text

7mya-105 I ATTACHMENT 7 d4 -g V3hy/--db D f&

V 7*

4/z5/r7 m

h

. 003Elsay 3'), .35, USNRC 30 JW 18 P4:30 UNITED $!ATES OF AMER:0A NUCLEAR REGULATORY COME 5SIQXETMv DucxtimG s sytcl.

Before the Nuclear Regulatory hyggg'ission f

)

In tne Matter of J Docket Nos. 50-443-OL

) and PUBL:0 SERVICE COMPANY OF 1 50-444-OL NEW HAMPSHIRE (Seaoroom Station, " nits 1

) (Off-Site Emergency

) Planning Issues) aa.d 2 )

)

THE SiATE OF MEW HAMPSHIRE'S VOLUNTARY RESPONSES TO THE-!OWN OF HAMPTON'S INFORMAL DISCOVERY REQUESTS

'ONCERN NG THE JUAE, 1984 JOINT EXERCISE AS TO PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS

, All exercise-related documents retained oy the State of New Hampantre nave been availaole to all parties since July, i956.  !

4 3ecause exercise-related documents also have been made availa:;e r, tne Applicant at a single location, the Nes Hampshire Office of Emergency Management transferred control legs and all other state l i

documents relating to the June 1988 Exercise to tne same location fr l convenience of the parties. This transfer occurred shortly after t,-

Exercise.

)

1 1

9003050162 090525 L PDR ADDCK 05000443 0 PDR tj't/(n {U(

A -

,. g.

.h

,$,/Q @, !: .p a , ., .

-f '

, , (I _f f

-)i  ; ,

?'- . .,y

.;j j 1it- 'E i  : a- ]y

-r

.ya j y 1 3< 9 f

c c- ,

+

g ,.5, g. i I 5f ,

_ ' '; ' .r0 y

.;.n . g g . 4-1 3 $ ,

.no 4 l :g. .

+ b' nf;j =

?. AA

.'s t _

. 3 { f. t .-

j' _

.4 -

' I j

• i -f g:

.% s

-t

-6

• \s -!

l(

3s

.,c,

,f

( -if <

f n.+., , i

.u-k -.I -,

g O'-

g

') ;i

.( I 1, L' 2 .'

di @, .,

0 1

-g h

,l +

ik i

y ;]

.t. ,

1 e D

.l -

{

g i. ' k

o , #

%f I t

-a r

h 4 i  ?

+ +

s t. .

,'{[ t p

-i

..l (

, 't

'l

, g, a n: ,

• I

< 1

< ,x;...

, I --

3 N t4 .

M1 ,

? D b l

,o g& + -:,

N 9 &

- s.

. ,h .c!

eW'o m 9,,. , @

[

q g ' (7 ~

<.I,

-I

~

,  ;^ _

W' ~

k": ef . . ' . - .u., ' fi! a:

/ ya f- til h Da:.' E o= ' $8 -N ,

r.,. . .

~ ~ '

^ i) h ,

- IY I l .'

• s f-_

u e $ ,

y. ' -

9..y . .' ..y 4 q% P

'i g

1 .-

p o s b$

w

'b) s r.

g 1 d

w '

[

,' EO %- ,: -q 'l

1. m- u g i= 8-m -s Lk Td S,i

- - n: " D- .D. >

U"O 2 1

K

, n.

-.Ei j i <,o** ..: . m, E., -18Q ww g- pf, a 52. 4_ o c3..y " {e-1

-6 44 c3 3- o a:;

,$7  ;

t i r- , ,. 1 E<-

1. %h. l 1 1

-j

E $/6( ,

e 1

ANSWERS TO SPEC:F:0 ;7ES ::Ns

n t e r roes to ry No,.,_J, -

Identify all teacners who performed or participated in i protective esen, state:actions for senool cnildren during tne Exercise. Far  :

i (a)

The nature and extent of the participation er f;n:::::'

(c) The purpose of the performance or participation t

(c) The senool(s) for whien eacn teacner performed or participated -

(d)

(e) The section(s)

Whetner in tneof_the State'sNHRERP tested opinion the or exercise::

performance or <

participation was adequate, and the basis for tnat opinions  !

(f)

Whether,a log, record, or other documentation i

encerning eacn teacner: ene Exerctse participation was prepared by or on oehalf tf (g) 1 to answer this intccrogatory. Identify and produce all documents upon which y

)

Response

To tne cest <nowledge'of ne State of New Hampsnire, no teaene_rs i participated in demonstrating protective actions for scnce; ent;dre.. 1 1

muring tne Exercise of tne New iampsuite Radiological Imergency l

Response Plan  ;

(* hereinafter "NHRERP Exercise * , as senools were . t

)

in sess:en. l

\

l l

1 l

I h

l 1

I

dlj/(Aj l

g :nterrogatory No. 2 Identify all administrators and secool personnel otner tea.. )

teacners who performed or part:cipateo n protective act:tns for sencoA children during the Exercise.

For eacn, state:

(a) The nature and extent of tne partic;pation or funct; i

(:) The purpose of the performance or partic;patton; (c) j The schoolls) personnel performed or participatedi for whten each administrator an: seneo (d) The section(s),of tne NHRERp tested or exercised (e) ';hetner in tne State's opinion the performance or participation was adequate, and the easts for enat opinions (f) '4hetner a log, record, or other documentation concerning tne Exercise participation was prepared by or on cena;f :

' eacn administrator and sencol personnelt -

(g) :dentify and produce all documents upon whien you re; ;

to answer enis interrogatory.

Response

a) The NHRER? Vo'.;te 43, Department of Education (* DOE *)  :

procedures, outline tne not!!ication pathway for seneols within ene r

EP:. A listing of Department of Educatioa personnel is contained in'

'.'olume 4B, Attacnment .' of the NHRER'P. DOE personnel wno part:-tpated in tne exercise are listed in the exercise logs. Osils gere pace to each senool Supervisory Union Superintendent.

, , , A ;isti..

of SAU contacts is contained in Attachment 1 of the DOE procedures wn;en are located in Vol. 4B. '

All listed SAUs were contacteo. The state also incorporates and aoopts the Applicants' Voluntary Responses to TOH's Internal Discovery Reduest (hereinafter

' Applicant's Response'), Response 2(a), and concurs with informat;en previoed therein.

c) Tne ' purpose of ene participation" was to demonstrate, for purposes _of the NHRERP Exercise, the State's capability to notify school supervisory cersongel. The State also incorporates and ad:pt.

Applicants' Response t.o. 2(o).

+

c) (1) SAU 16 g -

Exeter nigh Senool Exeter Junior Hich School __ _a

c m

Gelllp

- ; ncoln St. Sence.

Main 30. M.dd.e'Senoo; Region 'S Vocational Sencol Swasey Otneral Scncol

lewfie'.ds I.'emen:ary Sencol Strate.am "emorial Senool l'

(2) SAO 21

(--

iinn acu n

.t:: Migh Senool r

Academy .*unior dign School Centre 3: noel Marsten School Seacroom Ilener.tary School (3) Portsmou n Superintendent of Schools

?

Por:snoutn Senior High School .

Po::smouta Elementary Senoc1 ,

3racKe:: Elementary School Sherourne E.'ementary School Dondero Elementary Senool Little Harbor Elementary School New Franklin Elementary Senool Wentworth Elementary School (4) SAU 17 1 Sanoorn Regional Middle School Newton Memorial School Sanoorr Regional High. School Sakie Seneci (5) SAU 50 l

I l

Tl j lb t

'I

- 3:eenlan: Cen:: 1; 5enos;

- Rye Elementary ,

- Rye JJnto: Hiin Scncol i (6)

Phi;.'ips Exete: Academy, George T;;<e:,

ean of Fac;'

y (No far:ner indentification avni;at'e). .

P ocedures d) See: Response :o Oa) suora.

In addition to :ne pt:ce:.:e ;

'isted in Response No. 2a), NKRERP Section 2.6 saa demons::a:ed.

e)

As :ne Exercise Repor: f or :ne .'ane .'sd3 NHRERp Exe::;4e states,"The3:steof);ewHampanitedemons: rated:neacilityand resour:es necesaary :o ;mp.emen: ?:atective Actions for school cniid:en." See:  :

FIP.A !<e:::se Report, Septemoer 1, 1986, p. 171.

)

The 5:ste of New Hampshire is aware of no legs ~otner than

nose comp.'etec cy :ne pepartment of Education represen:at:ye a: :e State IOC. Tnese 'egs a:e availatie to all parties a:

n e a a..e >

ocation as mater

als made availas'e for discovery oy :ne App;;can .

31 Decemen:ation is contained in :ne fo'iowing documen:s on;:n nave seen made avai'aole :o :ne part:es at ene same .oca:;on as :..:-

decaments vo'antarily produced by tne Applicant: '

(1) New Hampshire Radiological Response Plan '

(2) FEMA Exercise Report - Seacrook Station 1988 Grade:

Exer:ise t

(3) Participating local Emergency Operations Center '.::.

t (4) Controller Reports fo: :ne participating touns

. i ~; :

i 4.

To j /&

l 0

• l..terrogater,'No. 5 -

, i 1

For each school in the New Hampant e EP:, ; gen t . g.. j

.' communications durina the Exercise cet,,een e,neners nI +3'.- --

~

personnel and the State s' Na - Mame**i *, it s agent s o' -$ 2-. ., --- . 3 ? ?f

~

concerning protective actions for senool children. W i '~~ "' ** As E e -'

eacn communicacion:

• l (A)

(c) ':entify tne person mak'ng ene communication;

.he metnod of communication;  ;

(c) Time; *

(c) Purposet (e) Recipient; q (f) Response (i)

(n) Any actions taken as a result of ene com.,.nica::f,3 e g,,-

to answer tnis dentify and produce all documents apon wnten +vt-interrogatory.

Response ~

A s.

Communication and exerCiJe logs of the local liaisons at the'!!'

and of the transportation coordinators at local EOC's, as well as ,

tnese for tne !FO and State EOC, contain this information. Th6he occuments are currently available to the parties at tne same locat;t: ,

as tnose documents volantarily produced ay tne Applicant. ,

i The State also adopts and incorporates Attachment 1 of ene-Applicant's Response.

t i

l- ,

1

ry C ". r.. n t

J % ;nogsvart obwu i

-' ( twoes.16 J' e* esi ss ' we. . d.

it u rcest.Ra John P.. Arnold-. THE 5T.s ' OF NEW HAMPSHIRE d " ^ * *n e tu urs h : :

eMR n x.unerr

• rur v c,aur ,rsu.a.

) P t R r.Y h WW.\ EO ' wi.n.c e .estm., s, n u .

W' ,'; l Ed'a!I ! iXLTEI- ^'

e r: m ..e r a u w ,,o rR.a A, JUEM) t koc/l v' A -

nase nau - &

-c &

~ r.un.ve an.sur:u

.flmisfNT P (sit s6y iRJ .. m n,.y y in sy s,2 ,.s

. i, tjg,gp p y.,3.3;gy

( *  ;;

f ,* ATM86.Y -

j (v4. , g,,- I

-a nrt nr.ssen r

s".ratt Au i u.:sa u s ur

]

THE ATMRNEYGENERAL Ml; gg.ug3, TXVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION BUREAU 4

STATE HOL'8E ANNEX <

G CAPTTOL STREET CONCORD. NEW HAMPSHIRT (M01.<D97

.m.,.3  ;

'i '

,.r March 16, 1989 Mr. Matthew Brock Assistant Attorney General

' Nuclear Safety Unit -;

Departmentsof the Attorney General-t

^ Commonwealth of Massachusettes John W. McCormick State office Building 1'Ashburton Place.

, Boston, Massachusettes 02108-1698 Ret  !

Clarification of June 1988 Exercise Matter  ;{

Dear Matti In further clarification of our; conversations, I offer the j following with respect to the State's answer to Interrogatory #2 concerning the identity of administrators and school personnel

who performed or participated;in protective actions.for school l

children during the June 1988' exercise of the NHRERP- )

l

'In our response to Interrogatory #2,a., the Stats incorporated Attachment Discovery Request.

l'of the Amelicants Voluntary Response to TOH's_ Informal-Attachent 1 contains a chart with the'left hand column entitled " School" with-15 entries made below. You have asked whether the State of New Hampshire contacted and dealt j with more-individuals.than are listed in our response to

' . Interrogatory #2 which incorporates Attachment 1. The answer is no. -The calls recorded by entry numbers 10, 11 and 12.of. Attachment :l 1 were simulated.. Telephone calls were placed to the school's-

. listed by entry numbers 13 and 14, and contact was made to the individuals ~noted by the attachment.' Understand that exercise controllers inserted data giving the number of students for a particular facility as is noted in Attachment 1 in the last column as you read'from left to right.

[

.., l

-- = ^ ^^ ~ " '~^ " ~

g,;g.7,

-'_ V ~4(,n s ,,-+att sr == (1yl jyyJ .

, <tauses:16,'es sess? wo.:

T:

g ,

Mr. Matthew Brock '

March'15, 1989

.Page~2 I have been assured that Attachment 1 is a result of a thorough examination of controller logs, and indicates all simulated and  ;

,ttempted contacts made-to schools as part of the June 1988 exercise. .

~

Based on'the foregoing, I am confident that the' State's response-to Interrogatory $2 is a comprehensive listing of all contacts made to school personnel as part of the June 1986' exercise. I trust this

. clarifies this issue for your purposes.

3 Sincerely r

(_me[e- 4 Geoffrey M. Huntington Assistant Attorney General Attachments GMH/aml ,

cc: Geoffrey' Smith, Esquire, Ropes & Grey "

P f

'f

' Ik 1

1

__ _ _ - . _ _ _ - -