ML20006D847

Seacoast Anti-Pollution League Brief in Support of LBP-89-32.* Statement of Issues Provided.Svc List Encl

ML20006D847
Person / Time
Site:	Seabrook
Issue date:	02/05/1990
From:	Backus R BACKUS, MEYER & SOLOMON, SEACOAST ANTI-POLLUTION LEAGUE
To:	NRC ATOMIC SAFETY & LICENSING APPEAL PANEL (ASLAP)
Shared Package
ML20006D838	List: ML20006D835 ML20006D847
References
LBP-89-32, OL, NUDOCS 9002150128
Download: ML20006D847 (3)

Text

_

%. Osg f r, .

February 5, 1990 00CMETED USNRC-UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION <

90 FEB -9 Pl2:39 Before Administrative Judges:

ifflCE OF SECRElARY G. Paul Bollwerk, Chairman OCKETING A SlifVICI.

BRANCH Alan S. Rosenthal -

Howard A. Wilber i

In the Matter of ) ,

) Docket No. 50-443-0L i

~ PUBLIC SERVICE COMPANY )

OP NEW! HAMPSHIRE, et al. ) (Offsite Emergency

) Planning Issues)

-(Seabrook Station, Unit 1)- )

I ,

SAPL'BRIEP IN SUPPORT OF LBP 89-32 STATEMENT OP ISSUES

1. WHETHER THE ASLB ERRED IN REJECTING PORTIONS OF SAPL' CONTENTION EX-12, PERTAINING TO THE ADEOUACY OF RECEPTION /DECCNTAMINATION CENTERS AS REVEALED IN THE JUNE,1988 EXERCISE.- (ORDER OP-DECEMBER 15, 1988).

2. WHETHER THE ASLB ERRED IN GRANTING THE APPLICANT'S -

MOTION- IN LIMINE AS TO SAPL'S PREPILED TESTIMONY ON -

RECEPTION / DECONTAMINATION CENTERS ON JUNE 13, 1989.

(APPENDIX TO SAPL BRIEP,'DD. 58a, 58b,-and 58c).

(TRANSCRIPT REFERENCES 25233-87).

3. . WHETHER THE ASLB ' ERRED IN FINDING THAT THERE WERE NO - -

FUNDAMENTAL 'PLAWS IN THE = NHRERP BASED ON THE PERPORMANCE AT THE' SALEM - RECEPTION CENTER DURING THE GRADED EXERCISE (PID II, PARAGRAPHS 12.3-12.33, SLIP OPINION, PAGES 518- <

522).

4. WHETHER THE ASLB ERRED IN ITS RULING ON JUNE 26, 3989 IN' EEJECTING THE TESTIMONY OF SAPL WITNESS DR. BELTON BURROWS ON THE ISSUES OF MS-1 HOSPITALS ON THE GROUNDS THAT THE ' TESTIMONY SHOULD HAVE BEEN SUBMITTED AS DIRECT TESTIMONY. (APPENDIX TO SAPL BRIEP, op.91-102).

M 9002150128 900201 ,

{DR 'ADOCK 050 g 3 ,

m

, =- -

W ,,< ,4 W

, Ly.

F $5. - WHETHER THE ASLB ERRED IN REJECTING A SAPL CONTENTION, F ' DESIGNATED JI 56, AS TO THE INADEOUACIES OF THE DECONTAMINATION SHOWERS (PID II, PARAGRAPH 9.46, POOTNOTE 63, SLIP OPINION AT PAGE 383, REPERENCING TRAN.

191341).

6. WHETHER THE ASLB ERRED IN UPHOLDING THE PEMA " REBUTTABLE PRESUMPTION" AS TO-THE IMPLEMENTABILITY OF THE NHRERP ON THE BASIS OF THE TESTIMONY OF RICHARD DONOVAN IN LIGHT OF EVIDENCE THAT MR. DONOVAN DISCARDED PEMA EVALUATOR REPORTS ON THE EXERCISE AND SUBSTANTIVELY ALTERED THE PEMA PINAL EXERCISE REPORT (PID II, PARAGRAPHS 1.37 AND 1.38, SLIP OPINION, PAGE 10, AND THE PARAGRAPH 1.68, SLIP OPINION, PAGE 34).

7. WHETHER THE ASLB ERRED IN RULING THAT THE 20 PERCENT p PLANNING STANDARD POR RECEPTION / DECONTAMINATION CENTERS WAS RES JUDICATA AS TO THE SPMC LITIGATION (PID'II, PARAGRAPH 9.49, SLIP OPINION, PAGE 384). -!

Respectfully submitted, Seacoast Anti-Pollution League l By its Attorneys, 1 BACKUS, MEYER & SOLOMON l 2 By: -

Robert A.'Backus, Esquire 116 Lowell Street P.O. BoxJ516 Manchester, NH .03d105 g (603) 668-7272- ;i DATED: February j83_,.1990 l 1

I hereby certify that copies of the within Statement of i' Issues have been forwarded to the parties on.the attached service list. j l

. ) g /pA Robprfvh. 46ctus, Esquire E

l2 l-

i

_2_

w. j 4 , ,.A . __._.._______ _.___ .a

y 3 7

.a Alan,Si:Rosenthall Docketing & Service Sec. SAPL '

Atomic Safety.and Licensing -Office of Secr:tary 5 Market Strect. ,

Appeal Panel' US NBC. Portsnouth,' NH 03801-  ;

US NRC ' Washington, DC 20555 WMD USNRC Washington, DC 20555-E

% FEB -9 Pl2:39 W Howard A.' Wilber S George W. Watson,' M g f h f hGeorge Dana Bisbee, Esquire.

~ 'Atmic Safety and Licensin9 Federal Emergency BRANCH Attorney General's Office Appeal Board Management Agency State of New Hanpshire 3 US NRC-. 500 C Street, S.W. Concord, NH '03301 ,

Washington, DC . 20555 Washir.gton, DC 20472  ;

G. P;ul Bollwerk, III, Chnna. Edwin J. Reis, Esquire Sandra Gavutis Atmic Safety;and Licensing ' Office of Dcec. Iagal Dir.

. Town of Kensington ,

Appeal ~Panelt US NRC Box 1154 US NRC Washington, DC 20555 East Kingston, NH 03827 Washington, DC 20555 Kenneth A. McColl m John Traficonte, Esquire Senator Gordon J. Hunphrey Atomic Safety and -Assistant Atty. General US Senate .i

' Licensing Board One Ashburton Place Washington, DC 20510 US NBC? 19th Floor Attn Gordon MacDonald (Washington,:DC'20555 Boston, FR 02108 x, . . .

~ = Richard F. Cole- Judith H. Mizner, Esquire Atomic Safety and; ,

Atmic Safety and Licensin9 79 State Street Licensing Appeal Board Board Newburyport,FR 01950 Panel

.US NRC_.. US NRC

Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC 20555 .

= Ivan W. Smith, Chrmn.

Paul McEachern, Esquire Atomic Safety and

'Atmic Safety and Shaines & McEachern Licensing Board Panel

' Licensing . Board 25 Maplewood Avenue US NBC

'US NRC P.O. Box 360 Washington, DC 20555 ,

Washington,.DC 20555 Portsmouth, NH 03801

Diane' Curran, Faguire Thmas Dignan, Esquire

- Harurn, Curran & Tousley Ropes & Gray 20001 S Street NW One International Place .'

! Suite 430 Boston, FR 02110 Washington, DC 20009 4