ML20005B378

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Comments on NUREG-0769,DES Re Facility.Peak Demand Growth Rate in NUREG Is Erroneous.Addition of Unit to Util Sys Will Result in Consumer Rate Increases
ML20005B378
Person / Time
Site: Fermi DTE Energy icon.png
Issue date: 07/01/1981
From: Ryan Alexander
AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED
To:
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
RTR-NUREG-0769, RTR-NUREG-769 NUDOCS 8107080144
Download: ML20005B378 (1)


Text

.

e N

?

/%

~ July 1, 1981 N

Director, Division of Licensing a JUL 0 7 Bg]n. r.

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 9 m unuuus Washington, D.C.

'20555 7x sky /

N f'

Sir:

s 4

I would like to offer the following comment regarding the

" Draft. Environmental Statement related to the operation of Enrico Fermi Atomic Power Plant, Unit No. 2" NUREG-0769 I.

Demonstrable Need NEPA requires that alternatives to the pronosed action be adequately considered.

One such alternative to this plant has been neglected: not adding new production capacity is a p ime candidate for recommendation in this DES.

Nearly a 400% error was made 'in the projected growth rate in peak dem 7d in the Detroit Edison system, to wit a projected figure of 7.9% yearly growth versus the actual 2.1% figure during the ytars 1970-1980.

NUREG-0769 at 7-1.

This writer agrees with ttaff that this trend will likely continue.

For some reason, though, any further analysis of that trend and its concomitant results were omitted from the DES.

Charting out more projections for the present decade would undoubtedly spell doom for Fermi 2.

This writer expects such a table to reveal a negative growth, which would effectively vitiate the need for an additional 1150 net megawatts electrical.

Staff has circumvented this feature and what little there is to the showing of need rings quite hollow.

The timely addition of this unit to Detroit Edison's system will result more probably in prompt consumer rate hikes.

iI.

Clam Biofouling Staff has not accounted adequately for the presence of the Asiatic clam Corbicula fluminensis.

It is present currently in Lake Erie and both its biofouling capacity and its tolerance to conventional biocides are superior to the organisms Staff did consider (fungal and bacterial growths, DES at 3-7).

This writer suggests that both the 513 kg/ day chlorine requirements and the dechlorination requirements are invalid.

In conclusion, this writer would request a copy of page 4-4 of the DES, which was incomplete in his copy of the DES.

Thank you.

Sincerely, gopf/

Robert Alexander 4327 Alconbury #3 Houston, TX 77021 (I Jd 1

8107080144 810701 P PDR ADOCK 050003417 H

PDRL

+

_ _ _ - - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _.