ML20005A842

Protective Order Describing Procedures for Disclosure of Highly Confidential Info.Certificate of Svc Encl

ML20005A842
Person / Time
Site:	Bailly
Issue date:	09/06/1978
From:	Marshall P U.S. DISTRICT COURT, NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS
To:
Shared Package
ML20005A832	List: ML20005A831 ML20005A839 ML20005A842
References
76-C-3830, NUDOCS 8107010358
Download: ML20005A842 (8)

Text

,

.w, < : ::. '

~$.s'. ,-:;. b 8: M Attachm~nt@.NJ' +7e U. .p,.. P.: m ' m.:a ..-Q:

w :.u,t.<,,- .L

. ,. . .,:. (- '*i -

.. :.Wn$?

g n.;f.a'.* : . : .;,. 4,.';&. .;E&

o e/n.  ?-

\

V  ; . . .

. w..

w,W.m. ty ~p@4. v. ..

.re d7,mse.<..Q.sn.r Mi E'...,. :gh ~ ~ .@s s.] , 'L;- ( -

p

~

,f.r . w cM u,W SY'

.p.m : ~

M.

• hlh.[ '. ,. . .FOR m Tu us::ss s:x::s 0:s a:c: c:ca: q.

.v 1%L,Jw4-w.-e ". m <: TE vzz.As:=2a MC2:2:M 2:v:s::s

373:0 07 IL*,DC'.3 / ROAyy,. >4.-;m j

a g; w.

yd ;:.w I-

. te 3.. ,.: .g ,:3

.  :;s t y$

nA

- : 4. .

N.r. , .gopbitWs.- %u x ,ng s. ,r,. /.V..,

. .. - t .- , - . <:

• <.  ; .,; 1gwg@...s,

.h.t 1 s .. .b.u .G.ed 0

anii:t Antit==st' Litiyaties a,.. . i . .. .; i. .

)

v' Seas *ia"Ia,n+fl.

/

3 . +.

- ~N...<,Q br .

. ..g.~.~g:.;;qi . . .,w, . n..t n .'&.y. ..L . . 4M

,. t . ,

'o, m ) h 3 %,o;3 3 g .** Q, K Q'wm*..y ._,

3 ---- MTCM L trwG M dg*

E ~ma . k.m&@m a;it M @. <.:t.~ %&.v. ..,t~. , . ' ?.- u , ,  ::'e . 's Ny js . ,q.c

).

, :s:.

.g - f ' g .:

W. f y ;#c,,Mati.ngheds'a'.,Ilac.=1C e} :3- ..

- ;. 5 .

?! . . r .-

)

Csepc:ation, .. D , pw 2 .

} '. .

c 1.m, . e..r... ~q e:: T

.,,,,.M..a w.

)im.d.y%...,y, s ..

i. W. s . . . . . t. .

. 71aistiff, 3- so. 75 c 3830 d p ti . i.*-%, .ci . ,p h :.< .

.v.

g.

...w., . .$s D..,7 r q.y ,M' [ U.*[' 1-I ; N '

4j f. . ,, ,,+

).

r  ;

<rm s i

. . . . c. . ,.

W' *f s * (y.n rh.m. .s : .e .. a. . 'I' l?? ' .~ *

, I*[*

.' V. . nle kD.' .'"y'jiF$ M. \ O*. .iG kAlgCft . :ln .y 1#.31ttdk.St 41 .e )

'.e. :-. .

-'U-d ' * "

p m z,.w'd h ef:l --

V'* t

- ..  ; , n. ; 4 . .

' Y ^ ;. ;f k.cP . , .

t t

!Y,. :4if.. qy%! ** ". ;@..

6 .*

l..!.PSIp .. . '

. ,6, 2 , ,'

) d.

Defendants. (** ? ; s*-

4, e . c. e - - *  ? .) *t'.,,,..

..,. f1 f.L. e 1. tfis lQ . g'b. A ' f-l/. ./-

. . ..c .

• .-[f. * .* * * 'M y ..s...

. 4 ..,,.. v. n.u . . .

h **' '

..I' . I ; .

.y.ic d;.kn a v,w: . , ,, . ;. ..y .

.h0. ,,.,,, . . .

, ..... y 3 .

) . ,. : .m. ,- .  ;.y t

%,"3.Tiv' , ?Is :s 'Tusss ee valley Andority ) Master Ti3 a No. - + a W.k.P%its,1'.;.r,;U:anium ,itk Aatit=sst. I.itisatica ) f.'

. eg?M. n p..r..

24.,=..: = . . * -

. w

.. .. c.; .n,

. W ?**g.1 4, sr i ~ :g :.,:,

. e ..

.\,

N.D9.M D .$.'L 7 Il

. . s. .s.

$ *'t aAi 5

• /RC"!O***T! C7CER

.g. : .- c,y. .*

?- . ; -5t . ' '[' , I. ~

.=; sc=M.'4ed.@~-3,

r. .,,7. m S. 'Q.g .?. q i h P

'l.'

h.1;. . . 3,

- . - /

@, $. 4 3 .d/ 7. _.. j. ""up .1 J. .

6.

D*. ~ %:sunt to aule 2s (=) of em r darti aules of *

..[

g[

U 4 -: % i w r pY:T' i: i

i

• t.~ltW 7:Ocad- d "Ci- 3, and d' stipuiAtion of *14 Parti *s, O 13 HDC3!

• T

'h b.. : s .a s' O ,s . w - .

g; .', , . .

? M

y'w . . m

• s .=4.im' .J 1 . . .j .' .."

9 -

y '

i;

.:% . 3 .1. -n,...,.,

,3. a. a ..* -

' rt; n.

p@.c  : [ '

l

...;, r ii .- -

- 1/ W.22 %3ed in Q:3 Ord30, the VC d

• d".,C'.::.sn22 *

.i

7. p[b. .p'.y' 3 ,

- 6 -

s 4~s l

". I,,=.J.m .'..

23 eau 4.11.'.frittan,  ;

etCOrded C g:17h1C :.4tt2: StAl"::XC4T9 , + l

.'t.' ":.. :' Sh ,

h.f.fh..h'.f" .h. . . ..c.-1T.d139i bia.t403*.'4:3e t Dt 1.L.i d E=.AO2d 4,

4. .. . h. 9. .s.e"'. . . ;. . :... .

asa .*

.. r, t.* , ist5:039at3ry d4 - ". i. .{,,

I"

. - ~ u ; . . . . ,. ,s ' [.-t. h Ed31'l(  ?.! o ..,-

E.3 d. *R270 "+3 42 OS RIO dO'a p.! I; :f. ; * * ** E

• t

• -.a.* 80 EI PIO ECOd bY OAY $

h*Y:@Oc$ ~7paxty c= son pa:ty in th .,.,.. .

ir.

,[. .

~*

.f g , a.

esu acticas whetaar pursunt to Rnla 34)' . - +[ .t.; ,

d. h.j ,. eh N;t.f t'y.M.bpoena,[o by agreement, ,

+

-c depcsition :1=scripta ed extihitsJ',] ,Q q?d p .s.cMandJany Portions .of =Y court F= Par *f:****S which ect* p

'*^

,Lr

.gn : '; rW'.- ,

-r ' "' -*

O ...

• :F F t

+.

M.s rs. p. @ + e.

'N 437 Of to . b 9TCb3T.

.z an

.t,.- .

'. t.,.. w,i.-

a* ;t>[

..  ; -. p r.

Al dDCUSSOISe II tOI,E AAEE b3 dE s r qfg.$.' -a

. .s

.+,'

. ...T .

'Od iO 2OIISII2b ] .[Ia-A."

. r ut N b.: '.

1. . . .. T-. e shall: he used solely for that p:ssecutica and/or defensa of . ,3; e

<.3

=== ,f . 's * ; .f a. g g., l

. " i .1 . n '[1 1 2.A n,

. .a - y

• ?.5$.?e3 s 4.t3a.. -...tt.o

y. ...;*g, ..

m?.v.,

..J.. . se .

We ( s,"l I' ;L

• • 5 ; t 5 - .

'y '

. r.+ I'lA h .i r

• p gg p . ' **1c -

c rg'" 9.4 y.. .. *Tu:v, 'd ' .f' s*'"

. 44

. e. .

, _ '. p nm, , %y .,a,,;,.t 4

+r -

. .Wi ' n- f. .{ ; .a "3. *y.... .:.c . .

$ W.% '. ' . .;,

b '.; - . . g-

~ ..

4

&h- .. -

8107010 3 3 1!; G

J, . , , . ...  :. .'* . * :,n.:.:, -

=

. a p +.: ;;p'S (,ft,~.C * *;(,:. ,

k .:.>.,..~ e

.g

.,u @..r p'.n -

t. . .

r- .. ..

J . ~..

g.r , .

-' 3. Any party or aca-party p =ducing doc =ents la g .m. .. :. ...<

,K p ;)

,r?d u.;..

,.r-these actions which e= tais er disclose trade secrets, un-E:qcg 'N[,.$y&j[,' , . ,

.u j. } 9:. Pu.blished finascial data, tech =clogi=al devel=p=ents, bn

'?

.c 4.,s . . .#. .

,,H. '- h

e

.or cost infs:=atios, ;;; duction er sales ferseasts or st=ategy, )

-QddD).] r. uranian discoveries, uran 1=m :sserves; the tar =s of execu:s=y

,eSm w r. ,e.

.w' n n u: 7

, M. <.:s. ,e e.s s

, contracti, or other shilar coc=ercia11v sensitive.information I8 y:< ...4, . . -:i;;i..w^ N. a, non-public natu=s, "may designate such doc.unests as highly.

.w- n. . .

,,@ u-J . T "m confidantial, which doc.:mer.ts shall be so sa=ked.

.r .c.

p.r 2

~.

.s ' . .. ..

F,-s. -". .< .. .. .

"* -.'. ., . ' _. .s. T . .

4. Asy party =t men-party givi=g testimeny in g.3. h.:. .,. .

u )g . hase

.n.7acticas ,- .

say designata that portica of his tasti= cay das~med w-le.s /.2.%.. .N.. m;.; - . to be highly confidastial by advist=g the repc tar of such fact.

g g43C6 ';.P . .[ The rapo:%ar shali, separately trasseribe those portions o( the

.7 $ELC *.

pC.';Q.T[?

Q tastimony so designated, shall mar.M the f ace of the trassc= *.pt y[m,y",;&:."

~ sais , M ~ accordisgly, and s1 ~; fila the tra=se:ipt u=dar seal with the

$i;[?2iiiiCc

~

l h'!...Nu$: J~Cl****

3 w w , .

3.2 E e ; '.r '~ <

• 31- xighly ee:.fienstial documents say be :=fa :3d 3

!%.U-7k]y.'Tf'..

).L. ( is inta==ogat==y ansvers , =ctie=s, briafs, and =ay be u. sad in .

c a .-?1 .

.(. '((.;,. ... ._. .. ]pm depositices and .arkad as deposition a:h. Sits is these actic=.a. '

c. . . - .-

.- ,n*l, .,. i ' However, no such doc = ment shall be used for any of these purposes

,.. .= , . . .. .

t.. .',. '.,' :. Q . ' -

. ;. 6. . .

unless it, a= the per-N of the court paper whers it is zuvsalad,

!- -;.' 1 4 ., . .

is aW.ataly ma hed and separately filed unda: seal vish the

) :'.T -i .* '. . clark. , , .

., .~.a......- .

.'f . (. 2

xcept with ths ; for writtan ecusent of the par::y e p.3 .

l l-

[" -

or non-pa:ty asserting highly confidential t: ears. ant, no, document s - -

designated as highly cendidential and no info:mation c=ntained ,

x. . ,. . r .

theraiu =ay be dis; closed to any pers,en other thass -

t e

7 , .- .

'wGiE */. ~g. ..

, w.i * . .

^

.(ae, '

}e .

,.,.'g ,. ,.

Sa

.g

. .. 4 7. ,

3 ,: .s.,.. ~ p. . . & -

1 ~.'.

l

e?

'. -

i ~

..e

~

3.' ',Q.!'!,"). .W , i J " .. ,

u. .g -u--- - 2: . . , - ~ .:

pbg.m. A .). ;.y:.1:

l c - .t -

u s g .. :. - -

( .( p'.. n .<.g 0.;y.- J< ' -

. 3 ._/ .

f9' A. Cou=sel for the parties in case ac ions

a. .ar. .

fgg 9. .y. . . n. ;f T.Qe.e" a

.x 5. ; ." - i e.

~ who meet the conditis..s of ea agraph 9 of this order. '

\

i y.Lj.*yp.,.. ..<

e

.f. ~

g 2.f . ..

3y).r .y -

employees of such c=ussel who are actively engaged is

&(m%-lf;n.m,h(fM;..'

, , m s. ,y. ' .

a

.'n.

assisting counsal is .the , preparation of Lase actions.

(G &. .hL*+ , .,:

7s.g,8:;.?-.J,,:,

C Persons coticed !== depositions er designated hi+:6,y v . .,.h@f ;

.g.

• p.

.'~

as trial witnesses and their counsel to the extant deemed a

.O.s%.:,&..:n:.

p. ..y b6 . .m, . . .; .,; L, necessa y by cou= sal for th.e wit = esses' preparation for h.,.~..:, : w:.l . v . tastisocy. Such persc=s shall be ;;7ridad with a copy of -

.r.r . - '

h(D.+[:$w'}. '. . -

this olds: and advised that they are bound by it.

v .t...% w,i~,0.!. u. .; .,

p%.sg.F.M.

lFE' p. These perse=s specified in parag aphs 7 and I

...u g -. w . . i[*

}Iid 1,.

2 m. iQ f. .f,j.... , . .

vbo amet the condit! ms of those paragraphs and paragraph 10.

g aq e. a. . ~ . . . . -

...,.r,..,.; 7.

Highly ce=fidential doc.ments may be shown to ,

".. AEK:rt: -G . . '

c _g,f.;',-24'. outsida cer-s.tita=ts and..arperts :n.a.ised for the p gse of ShS-?r # t W ,: . . - .

%V Ie Jngl,;.). assisting ins.the p sparatie. of these actions upon the following

, .C_. ... .

D,.e. ,25. .,?f.h,!. 7..... ..tams . . . asd condia. ions: .

n.ua2q. .q:.' -

• i.- -

dla !P.r..'  :< .i:

2 ,.

..p *

1. 3e'ere ca).ing discicar.:s, :Aa.pa r r3t C3t112

s. I .1,G.' ..m .f.yan greecan is 'triting (per tha fc=:n attacAad as Ixai. bis A) a

=-

7 .T N NQvam: .c . . .

f.eu.

p J .i

?TN.';.l. ~., .

v. g. < ..

'3 Q.p: .. .u,,ny, ?:

f=tza the outside arps or ec=s111tast designa*4g the docu-

p. .. ~T:' ments c: maearials to be disclosad vi.h part.i=h-i:y, and m-,2 s.-

L_s.C. tv..

-E ret:iting that be or she has read a copy of this P:stective Q . < :s. g . . . .f.~'n" ..

?

c ,.

A :.C.'. ' 0:dar aEd aq:ses to be bocad by its p ovisions; and

%g.  :.: .

. . n.,. .j s .

If the Court rar21:ss that the identity of outside f :. ' 3.

g . g. - T..;. .

5:;;. ~, . experts anc consultants be disclosed, a copy of all ag:se.

m .:.. . . - . -

y. ' . r., o.: ,

l .,. ,- -

ments to be bound whi t have been axecut.ed by such persons s.. . . .

s-I.I ".[.

sball be 2n:nlshed to all pa: u es :sc essing same.

WM:.Lu' . h. -

P.w

%. . , , .c.+v>.

. .w.. . . .

h Ma 2..  :*<.m e,'. . * ** =]=

• ET.m-f$d.$.Y.

"EN...

hc. .*. , -

... .s 8 49 't . . *. . ., .. -

?00R BRML .

0 g ,_ . , , , ---

r .

w ee.

se-@..5 . .j. . .

.w. . .,. q:

$fif.C.. T. ..

1. 4e

.s

. T ,g. ('_;.'TT.C~4pJ

$, M. . M. t99. qi

. ' s, ,.. .t / [. . - 7 ls ..

4: .. .

.x.,9, .g.

.c...,. ci .,;.

~ s. .

,s. p. w . '.

,.1 . , . ,.

. 9  ?.

9' 9 , J. Mi.3 4.,rD.t.

q. w. .i .Q$.. . .!.(lpf. ,)n .-W.~,.

.J. p% . c<. .R.

p .?; q.i .

t,.'

m3-$; .Wighl'y ct.afide.. dal dec,::ents =ay be edisc 16s

c. . 4. :

"j(.'t y ' -. employ.ees ofl partita lavolved 'selalys.is.

r N p- 4 4 .4 . k .n.. .-

.7 one o=( = ore a_ spects'of .

J f' -

h. L .,9u.ho: ;aksi {j ,h...t. gyili=g,J .

.s t h ' t '

,- w -

i I q* wJ 7:da,taland/ori; designing pecg:s:

,$,.4j'g. .

v

,#.  :--s y

ih, Q+.].

Mth. apt.

g '*-4 te M 4

.grf*g[ .; g; , th 't.;C east 3ction.g.1* d ' .k ' , incinding tha perfoma,s ,w+t s;; . ,.

• .  ?.

n.S.

nce of sgch duties.in salatfor.-

t -

t

%gm 4 m

w.gK, -Qg.gd.

.n,. .a. .es bb h.s .a .~

. . .F  :

n c~,4 .

eMrdgartyjeentractors perfo

..< m. c . ., . a. e mist o M.m. 'g r%;

,. k! [*r. g..,p.U,,. .e .u.; *:.foF,00s* Q:

23:S partkaS. ~

. or =cre of these fu=ctions; '.-

4 e ** j:Df* . ^ W.t

g. t ,

. i .1 ..L n...n y;. w ;A ,[ h. .h* .:. ,

f.V,* :$ I

. . . ar s.*"4 t

w'> -

. - .> [,. ..

, ,j I g h, Eighly COafid4Atd&1 dCC".24Mt3 ~

.- 'O Me r. ~ .*i.r s 3 - - #* 8 -

. - d 3&T ,De disc 1CStd, [tO $

Q g M,w.m.3g.-EIM. q; ' coun.:. ;'7se . vbo r (1) . fila an . .

. a.- w ,...

3 "s appea.ruca for any pa:Ty is these actio=si dl -

(..N M. y g .:a .%'... 1. M.N,.,. .r an. m. ... . 3,2f arek.sctive

~

• • u .n .  ;

4 ; ". .: . . . .

g n .

4.

.a

.b 7.

N' ^[ C *,~ ,Q o

• g. @. 4 c ssd

. Q l

$,%.3,. $e . .G,;N.r;>.x%'.

.EW -:

3E4..dirse.: but'.a.nly p

, n. .

u ' %. 'onith.s -

'condi. . tions

• • ~

that such con =selj 13 y shall

- no

- .. .*'- I,.

tly or:dadi:=ctly, asy it.for=atica f:=m the hig hly 'confi -;:-

, ......;.,2..

e.. %s -. ..

...: . 2 .es

_ a i4%m...~ M 7 dM M 'a, A N ,t* Of 4 Cth*: Party n DC: PE 27 1: .-

i, g w! G

. #. p ,

m v.: .J cc: t tiEiE witkl

?

m%. . CW.",C;.I_k,,am-l@2

?. p2. W @. & n .c  ; 7 ", m" ~: .

~#.reial negotiations ==garding 3 x

3 t X

g. -:: m.: - sactors or otharvise. violate the, provisions of paragr J.p$g

%. . 4 g ".fm@m. , yg  : v

.,. ee neM i.* w* , lA I capt for. cou sa1 !c '

aph j .

.n +w. m- - 2, , s. . '

e.

c:. . m., h.c.,.and ., . cutsida , , gb@wr <exp..s.v,. .iy the pa .ias is these actionshy u v.n&.p -

g. . . < . ..

arts a=d emessitaatz cov==st by he provisions I*%y4,. u m. m.. 4.;n.. , b, ;.: ,;g wW o. .. -f'paragrap ..hj7 hersof,

,, , s

. r .,;-, .: . ,7' . : n' ' . '

.- ; 4 .- .

b,e.sgg$*1!.N$

r.

QM b '! .ht:9Cf -tO etCSive

. s .

&cCSSX ed nadar the ta=as 2 um .n.sg . ~, ... ,

.p

.,k-c..

.t 6 to high.17 condid&Stial doc == tat 3

[$ .7 ff Mt.e,v:, .g)',. J^: m be.'gfa3tSdIsCC8ss tD DDSE TlRtil SU:D p*2soM h&S Shall.-

• .v J. ; .. .. . P . . -

=9ad thiS Q:dSr."

t.h.%.

g.b .r.. .3h. 8Dd AgT%#I 3... s .* m 13 Nt1td3T D b4 bcDEd by kAE8 $p%

hh

.9 :-. . * . , . .[ 'as',

[ . .

NS ICT3 Attached

..=

.,.N.y ., . s. . .

s - . . it $I. ., . CDunsel shall be tsponsible for 341st2 O g  %.

-} .

r ,. , .

p= . . .

..... & ligt f al.1.peZ$oSS - ..

3

h. , :5' p,i n b. ?. c a. v F -  ;' ..s ,s ,

• tO WhCEE s4Ch doc'25 Gats aa 3 w ,O*3 *p. 4 413C10 Sed ash

~

,. ...m

.a- . .

t .

f .r.h . Well SS.Copi&S Of agreemeAt3

s. signed by them. To i ... .

Ws,y s .s D. '- -@..+

.. . TOod ranse n

W.shown, 'such list asd ag se=snts shan be availabla for ins

.,,= x;. . . . .' C; ;., . .;* '

e,,

.. s: .

i:R._ 2M.19..%_. . by couns;el. for o..

ther parties u . on S.

W*

4

,y

.kq,

'u t .'

.:.e. . ga.t:

.e?wv.

o z

n' p , 4 , . . ~ ' f, a . ;;-.. p.

j..

. pon ordar of this Court. .

a.

1

'p.;,ts. 3 ... j . - p.. -

g

. . - , s, d y:.ur.. C ' '?I U. 4r5. **V.% e vc ,,

... 4;. t . + .*. i- .

3e. . s. . .

s .

f,' b,.

I-

} 6' ' ' q, T. 5 .

n.n, * '.w.s' r . ' " Q2 d'.@h'MN@u *d "/.'s..

@: M 4

%j . *.. ,=

. - nc , . -

.).; Y. Q. . ,.:n ~ 5~A' V-c.ix . -W.-t 4

,. Qq d. ...y

.'f.t *iet.g-% - .c..,v 3

? y% . ,

ca

, 81 - * ..

.,s ,

~+.-r-*

• w-

&.kvl.Q.%;. '.,c . .- , -

n,p...,. .,.. o u . . . .

pa . 7..-: Pg . y.. - '

y..*y .;,' o:

s>

n. . -. / -

11. Whasever a pa. ty ob jects to the designation of ty.

@e

...e..

3.;w,.r...-3 p.... .

E* ..A doccaent as highly ccafidentit1, it 'ay apply to the Court -

%.'.,(.c.,.,...;,'..

se:.c .a.. s- . - .

L' . .: for a ruling' that the dec=ent s'.all not de so treated, giving W.:: "' .! , .

$0%:(?p!?.;- .-; ;fp no'. ice to the party ar non-party p =ducing the decusant. Until m.+ . . . , . . v. . .- .

%:.w w - a .

this Court anta:s an orde.r. changi:q the designation, the doc =nent

.%m%.s . . . '

..s -

Sh all be giver. the highly confidential t= eat:nent initially .

<p~. r. w: .~.-ryh

. .. . . I.

-n .

J'  % .o!:. '

assigned to it and provided for it is +'s order.

.Y.,.i.n .e... .vs.._

12. The Clerk is diced ad to . send a espy of this orda:

EhyA.,:

<. . . . ... 2.

. . .t :. . . .

to counsel of == cord scareaca pa=sy"to these.assions.

.r'. 4. .

t .w..~ .fr.. .

'\$gy.xw W. t4.e:A '. 3 .

13. The p =visicas of dis order shall not to..aisate

~

i ,sd,b.p . ., at t;he ecselusion J

of these acticas. Doc =ests desig=sted highly

..Q:, .x.. m..<

&Mn._: 3:

sr T:v t .v, . confidant *.ial and all copies of sama. (otha.;: than ex.hibits of t .w

4.62 ..:; .L . record) shalA be rets= mad to the pa. ty or pe:sca pe=ds=ist such

.- .m. ... ..  :

se:vinc  :: m . -

.. doi:maasts when. the last.of. thana acticas is c=nchaied.

_n.<m m_. ... . .6 . W, . a, 14. Now'g is this c dar shall prevent or othervi.se rn ,.x. .

.. .. s.

g$j U.8. e:

5 rastrict any coc= sal ::22 :ssdari .g advice to h'2 '

ant sad, v 4-es,] s G.a . .

in the course thereof, :slyi=g ga:arally ca his e- '" # '

c.$. 5 ..

.--: .  : r:.

h. D . .t, :- . of itsms designated highly condidential: 7:=vided, bewever, -

=m g - -

ywW. .. .

.., , . . ~ . > .; c .-

. that is randari=g such advica and othsevise r-er- ,'ca*.g with such eliant, cet=.sel shall not =aha specif1 8is=1csura of any i ..-s.9 :.

@a.N,

~

1 & .*,.g . , .

-item so designated.

,:IpS'i 9. ,n, ..

.. s . 3 .

i Qf.:. :

j

15. yhis C dar replaces all non-pa==y protactivt

,1).*h g. [- . ordars heretoform anta=ed is these actions; provided, however,

" ';[p, cir.,

that all docunants, depcsitions and deposition exhihits of such

..++ .  ;

.[j- .

• aan . parties .s hall.de t=eated as highly c=nfidantial documents  !

• .whose t:matzent is governed by the provisions of this 0= der.

. a s-.;,; ,

b .

~.y .e. -

~

h .sme. - . . . .

w. , - s- - ,

. 1 4 . .gL

.

w: .

.,m.,....,.

.. e * .

. . , , w .

.f '-

?0M CUlNL O 'O.6 . ,,

"E *O O . . .g -6O, h g 9 ,

- - _ _ . . - - - - . ,.- . , . . ._ . , . - - . --.-- .,,,---.-%-1

<e o.nn,,

.,r.

r u . .v 4s . . .:,,-.,

.: - -m ....~w.r

- u t :+ %w qt.4,-9:. :. kN% 4. 7.p. .

.3:: .. ; ,

-p

. c. ..z; ..;: ~ ..sf r -n.

t s k 4 e u r: '

! u$s . p 1gti t:r.:, $m . 91 .L. .S &O .-< I G A $ yg

. i .V . F W; .. T+:;.5 .;;6 HM 3.T. .m. 3 ..w & 7 0 %,. , .t

.T.p J, - A-  ?-

m .

<.i. .a q .s 2:c -..m,. 3 . .,

y 1 .u' n , . ' , - ~ v - -

u. . . .n" '.

n 4..

,: .r%

n. e t:.xe. -:

that de:..e.ssts are prod.sced,5y. ynM,g. ,W.

. r 2 ~, ggl{,mg. e4:, l'f...ps@u.;. e.; p .&y '%1.n %uG;.v?. '. ', t. .Y t 1 ~.t .

?

$  ; . n the aven: '

1. 1 E M.-t:1

? ui%;sa.- .'d .y.' < > * -.

F: . ;

Tw ,,'(TFE. rodu R,, neii s +,.t ; Parties-@t -

..og .c 3 .d .,r . . .s

. =4...hif.1:1gatien"

.x

- 9,

- U1=h a,'have . s.: . 3 %s

. M.)tvi=usly. t . #- .,. . w

- y aa h pit 5 4t... .

e M . hg on, includi=g.W*stincheuse err .14= :ce'ntraced::q* W r.2

& *, -i.5 i.; ~...

M.$.$..isoceM,11hiva,,

,16.d M. ..M,. 'il. M..W .T M;'k

• ?

y

.p.; 4:.E; Q"loriN hD H 35 c.D lvi.) a5n-cue.Jsn,.. .

p R.2H4+h:b,restinemouse $LitiC** CT & .

<- L. L c ua DEW, I

[%@h,M.b:. L.a,5 n

^

F M N:U:n M $ l.- ie co w a-len. No'. 4.h %f;t, M 7 w ., ' 4~ W k e ." . 75-23 m M...Cti i6N.9,'Q.d . . -

s W

%c.nd &. &: ":: W: 4e- *;< 4 .

. . k. t - . . l1. '::: ..

V  !. ..<:

n )%,sq [Q.;33r.? com.mo. nM.. a. /s ,9' llegheny Cty .., 7.E. ) , - th,s (provisicajs '.2u %.W+ .-'

- 4k Jef .4.th.ii. tM I

%,q;%, ,.iy;m.p .

.e J :2:::

-b. -+ .a s.

S,

• s-y

'

! .*y-j,a,y.s

,c . ;r d . 1:: P Ot*: V;>.a 131** C*:4',o. rQ.tshall cont =ob. 'f5uch.-dollcv.=ents previopsly.l. c;;;i M.,.,. . .,.: g; .i :g;- 1 j v .~,.. .

. # . wy. . .

o

.- + .% 2 f 3. ~.s. .

.. ...,4....

m. . n  % s . .

!

• df y

g3A kg.c.~3 M,:j,-.desig:Qtad@pMially e M.3 ,n .1,-

~

g..c, wc. .

, ,,. a n. , . . ===fidential and7 highly.

.~.

m .. a w. c==fida.v_Lal~

.s,.

v .,; . t w t.g ,

~4 - s. ' %

E @iMb5.ri $. 1:.be,' considagadgE:..,this . .gda: C:dar als highli ~:=fidansi't1.dec=marM;.,.e,.

7 y,.tv.;. A My . . [

p" .p. ... J. . . s4. ,

> h. .u. ;;-c. .w;9,,. .

. Ai.M,  ; C1M f!

C& tic 3 13 Ch&Og4d hy:Ol".dET Cd =.his lC+ T.* eff.,,h, ,L~..n

<. -.[.@li ,I

h. N' -

.s s kp .:: .:,'.,[*. .'.! .) ,l.' ~.., N..... ,sg:  ! . CETb

a. . 7

• - . In ~ - - '- *-

~. . : ,, '. ~ -

• u. .. . c .

. - - an. . 4 ~~

k . g,.a..U n t we ..-a .

e... e . .

IOC4."y {fithIth;a 7:CvisiC33 . ' . . . 1ph 11' hSZECf. ' HCW4,T22'r, . ? .

3

• D.k d I: 'dh.I.Y., .' ,'M.' 12 &%CN.

+

?? : T 'l  ? ;*'" d " Of P[&2ET

' .J i l f .c.

I*3.Y[,5 the pa.=ty f:=n whose filas ti.he docM.cn.l.:s[l. nfs,E' . k

[. .lg}3.$e L d l8:1 1*::

MM u..y.. ..r

.,(..

2

(~[.6. ..g.n as d

? g t {l n.

• . asy.; such}. d. emts . e

' ~'

- s. r 3

t'*].'~~ iut .

341 dCC%353t2 a3 d Sh&.1 k:l.l'.% 5 2

• '5].

Dd*.C3d Shall. .SVi69 MihVfrih s  : '.[

t k%;gk_9.:..y&,Y. N4'.OII

.' & 3 : n d a 'h ': ;:< ==EI11y))  : .

. F. .

~w :1 ..:

i d=.1stt tha his.h17, *'Hanti11 or special1t. c==fidential dus g=ag7.i

. 4 i t b.., .,,?.E. M. A.  :

h. .;- 3 i,

• ; p.. s 1  :?

,p- .. .y , y.e,s. , n.

f.

x.  :: .:,: ,

, o. . . . . , . .

[

*., "gb a. ' #.i QQ '. t$ ~

dO Y.e MS$t tbI CII.S.E IO )&I17IE.. k,. M :l 2, .p t-n.A.e..v.v.hp * .m <.. n' :m.v r-Q m? - ; t . %n +-

i. r . . .., * . 't"- W .

. :.* 18.,*

.b ' ~

I* =* S3 Na Cb AII OCS dII TENO SpMIA11y CEE ,.b.:. .d. I

. .,, g .' b,

• C .; oms, 's1 [.L :{; e'A'} .. : M, 2 f

w .)...;

E==iA1 0= O=3 vhi=h IuCh ASikUItiOU ,.hAII "f)],

e .

.3,. 4 , .:. .,

)

- u,.:.f:' ' ':. ~:/ . : .

. :m : m.h ckyChlY ~ , ~- n be gove==ed by the p:=visisas of pt:2q=upi2LI.n N

I.l. ' C b'$$g bessisd 'latadMA11 '2N ,, , L ., '.S

"- * ' ' "*

• j

.b"

's "'t. e ~,

f i S...w,R $ E E . h.w .of this C: den;U '. . .,

. ;g.1;f. 1,3 ~~. -

N :.

y . g .,n. O 4 - . . m.u.n. , . .ly

._ . E t - ..T.. ,

, ;; + .m m.m. .

' e.- i{?;p17d.;,,Nothing is this C:dar s' prsv==t.a=y pa..ty.ic @ ,y J-j 'yQ'f.'r

.' %e } ,.t.*. ..b . a

+

.t . ye  % . ,..,e .$.,.:

1:

l. .,

. . ;,... ...  :, . :.- so- .zr

~

fh3w- ...sa.rq:; 300 2p22:7'. d.rc"R.f 5sek.i.ng 2C.A* ' 4 catian of ' ** $ C= dei *. c f cza chh. ...2i- C., .p'.ctd

E

" iE ED.m:M.  ; m} '..L.,d egt.+.A..,,

.s .

. nJ: .

. 4 -

.'t : i-5

.r ,

ing.*t3. .[d13CC997 Whia.h it bells *#ta to he othe: Yt .c~ 4l i=propa  ; a.t,:;z. %g8' ,. 7..j$

N ~ , .~^  %- ,.

kmh.J,&, w,. f.

. # to

. 3 y '?;*4

.4. . a a, e.

- eg

~

q. . !.n

.o]; l E .., :,- % :..

l- ..<, .2

. y:. r* .. .

. '-lll 1 +> (z.

, + - .;,.',:

q

. . ..~.;. 3QL i

• 4.; . -

.- i

.f - *4.~. e 7 sse . s.. $. '.A, *y*g>  ; ,. ,1- q.c.g.:. . - _.n

1. e . , ,;

. 1 .u m.% . - ..

e f,+.~,.Mq.,.

W Se^1

~'

C% .'. 8 -

h ,

4, d. i ,

a -

1.' ,g t .r.

g,pbe. 3, N 4.. ~ % . -

.1 e % i. P':! fj Tr '.- , -w.~. e --

• .>: ;- 3:. 'm.s n .n e . { .g -4 t. -

. 4g- /*

. . t .

. h.. *. e :a....e-a ..c:1 ,: .}s. - . - 4 .g, .,e

.4. ..g . . ., 4 ,,

E 5

.[ N *.  !

f. d a. .n n: san.s.1, , - p. ,. s.-. .(g

- m . p.,.

,.h= - e:

q: .4. . % . . ... ,k .. . ' .

.g * . .P: ant,2,cs n.m._ma, .gc ..r. 1,

- . . ." ,q%. .,, %, q. *: .UJ, pist=ict 47udge, , -

+ - - ?W . tg.'.; v,.

t, 'tg * ,4.. ' ..

h. s. =.--- . z a .,,,,== ,' > - . , ,

h.'.3,,..

.r

,e e . , . - - .4 -

w-

- ,w . . . .

rg g3.. ,$J" ;

,.,I 4 geQ.** @ y: a. 'j./i ", ,* j

• .. ;;i sg .'.t.ia '

f  : h #

- .i

.?

. ij

,,9 y.;

rar e :*8'J ib 4 .*, e. . T . .,.. . }

..e*, g. - ,

• W r.T..o*.$" ,?~e A* .

g%p.

t

.a. .,y , 'E.*,, .- . -" C..s 8'p;e.in

. .. ,, g: ly .'y .f '., . .. .g ,.

r

([ e.1xa T

.. . , . ' E j 9-

' .' 4 D.

[**

~

.: .;. . '";2J' . '

T. .,

< ** P.'t ,.,;4 53

- ' r; . " . (3. * . 'Q< . J. J.,1, g ..*

- . .. * *1

. '.* . .. , f. h. .i 't+J,

.if.e t$ a.3.f .

p*W - er

• e. : -

.c a

,. 4 J."$ M . .y..-dT 9 a. l8,, .)

i i .. b k ..*

, E V' -

[1. ',

• J ,j sL j .

1. %r;,;&o m c- =s

-t

.' 3. /

. . Q.: - 1+ .: i.s,!L . .k:" j.2 ,.. .,,

y }: .

.y^y g%A.a ._ y

.r . p .s

• . . 3 em 9an.

s a

5 % i' %u.,( d J ri u-i

? --

~~ ~ == - . . . .. _ . ,

l 1 1

' ~ - - ' - - ---

.------,i.-w .p__,__ , . , _ _ _ _ _ , , ,

s l

l UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

, NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION I Before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board In the Matter of ) Docket No. 50-367

)

NORTHERN INDIANA PUBLIC SERVICE COMPANY

) (Construction Permit

) Extension)

)

Bailly Generating Station )

NLclear 1) )

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify, this 22nd day of June, 1980, that copi6s of the Affidavit of George A. Roupe have been served by mail, first class and postage prepaid, upon the following:

Herbert Grossman, Esq. William H. Eichhorn, Esq.

Administrative Judge Eichhorn, Eichhorn & Link Atomic Safety & Licensing 5243 Hohman Avenue Board Panel Hammond, Indiana 46320 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Diane B. Cohn, Esq.

Washington, D. C. ~0555 William P. Schultz, Esq.

Suite 700 Dr. Robert L. Holton 2000 P Street, N.W.

Administrative Judge Washington, D. C. 20036 School of Oceanography Oregon State University Atomic Safety & Licensing Corvallis, Oregon '97331 Board Panel Dr. J. Venn Leeds U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C. 20555 Administrative Judge 10807 Atwell Atomic Safety and Licensing Houston, Texas 77096 Appeal Board Panel Maurice Axelrad, Esq. U.S. Nuclear Reguiatory Commission Washington, D. C. 20555 Kathleen H. Shea, Esq.

Lowenstein^, Newman, Reis, George & Anna Grabowski Axelrad and Toll 7413 W. 136th Lane 1025 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Cedar Lane Indiana 45303 Washington, D. C. 20036 w _. _ _ , _ -- - - _ . .

Dr. George Schultz 806 E. Coolspring Road Anne Rapkin, Asst. Attorney General Michigan Cit *r, Indiana 46360 John Van Vranken, Environmental Control Division l 188 W. Randolph - Suite 2315 Richard L. Rcabbins, Esq. Chicago, Illinois 60601 Lake Michigan Federation 53 W. Jackson Boulevard Docketing & Service Section Chicago, Illinois 60604 office of the Secretary U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Mr. Mike Olszanski Washington, D. C. 2055.4 Mr. Clifford Mezo Local 1010 - United Stephen Laudig, Esq.

Steelworkers of America 21010 Cumberland Road 3703 Euclid Avenue Noblesville, Indiana 46060 East Chicago, Indiana 46312 Robert J. Vollen Steven C. Goldberg, Esq. c/o BPI Office of the Executive 109 N. Dearborn Legal Director , . . . Suite 1300 U.S. Nuclear Regula'ary Chicago, Illinois 60602 Commission Washington, D. C. 20555 Edward A. Firestone General Electric Company 175 Curtner Avenue - M/C 823 San Jose, California Attorney for General Electric Company DATED: June 22, 1981 e

@ G -y- ae , - - - ---- - y