ML20004B630
| ML20004B630 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Crane  |
| Issue date: | 05/20/1981 |
| From: | Weiss E HARMON & WEISS, UNION OF CONCERNED SCIENTISTS |
| To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8105290202 | |
| Download: ML20004B630 (5) | |
Text
6\\
h.
8 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA N" N
- UCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 6
'" -Q BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD LT'#t 54 MAY 211981 e
,E!
rm cc.:, e e: 3 D* khe: 1 ::=.
)
B:t-~
c M
In the Matter of
)
g s
)
g' NETROPOLITAN EDISON COMPANY,
)
Docket No. 50-789 et al.,
)
Restart
)r{}
(Three Mile Island Nuclear
)
Station, Unit No. 1)
)
c
)
i UNION OF CONCERNED SCIENTISTS REQUEST TO TAKE OFFICIAL NOTICE Pursu ant to 10 CF R 2. 74 3 ( i ), UCS recuests the Board to take official notice of the failure rates fo.r diepel generators as reported in WASH-14 00.
That figure, which is derived from Appendix III, Table III 4-2 on page III-47/48 is as follows:
-2 1
- 1) failure to start:
from 10 to 10 ^ per demand.
The median
-2 is 3 x 10 per demand with an error factor of 3.
2) failure
-2 3 x 10-4 to 3 x 10 per nour.
The to run, given start :
median is 3 x 10 -3 per hour with an error f actor of 10.
These are technical or scientific f acts within the knowledge l
of the Commission as an expert body and nence sub]ect to official notice within the terms of the rule.
Our review of the record l
in connection with ne preparation of proposed findings disclosed 1
that these facts are not currently on the record.
i i
l A copy of tne referenced tabic from liASH-1400 is attached.
B.:
s O
n I..
)
E11yb-R. Weiss HARMON & WEISS 6
1725 I Street, N. i!., Suite 506 9589 810529019%
Sh 4
T
' 1 Was hington,
D.C.
20006
( 202 ) 533-9070 Council for the Union of Concerned Scientists DATED:
May 20, 1981 D
' Q W.CMCE WW,)2.t c,. M %. 3.,
s, g$... f'.' &
T e!.
). - < -
- st f
- Sy
',4 g.
1
(, 5
/*. % Aj'g' )4 h
. s.
' ~ *
- W-k 2
p3v..
' ' Y, C TABLE Ill 4-2 Montinued
- 4. cf-
4**
~
. I W,p V -,
s.
Nma u w.a1 arrer
,r s !* [.b.
Cc: ponents rai;ure Mode Assessed Range
%.. y.t ' %, '
Median Ftetor
-4 4
. f'. r. 1y,,k.,.6' y
ly.',
^
~
- I?7.
Transfer ert: Open Circuit r-['.,..~.e-
.V3 g- :. < _
primary or 3x10
- 3x1C-6/hr 1x1C*g/hr 3
[-[
e-(. '
secondary, ) :
Short primary to e,*
-7 3x10
- 3x10.s/.r 1x10.g/hr 3
c'*w n *
-~ :
secondary, ),:
3
-s'.
p p '7 '
5. "., ' r.
'.';f.7;{ q.~
,.M,.,. s solid state Devices. Hi
.u,a r-.4
. gmg..., a c Power Appli-g
'r cations (diodes.
transistors,
- [;.' sv.,9x
.tc.):
ratis to functio..
- '.'-,,j t.;
1;y-
~7
-5 3x10
- 3x10 /hr 3x10'0/hr 10
." V l :
- . ?M-Q.'. l.i, o
- x,;
7 ;+
-. =.
1.
- - c%w -
.n rails shorted.
7 1x10",
- 1x10 _/hr 1x10/hr 10
-5
.N f ~ &
- 'f"*5 ^
A,
^. f
- f.
g%ch.
T.
Solid State
.s se g.
Devices.
.-. -f * % e. ' c.
5:
,A* Power
- - ~. - -.c
, s 4.y..
..,"7,-
Applicaticns: rails to function,
-5
~0 1x10"7 - 1x10 /hr 1x10 /hr 10 1,2 4.
rails shorted:
1x10'8 - 1x10/hr 1x10 '/hr 10 Ii 1. -
j j
. ~ - ~ = =. t ' -., v, Diesels T ;,,
h.* [j :d. g *,
'd.
(Complete gg, plant):
railure to start, M ',,
h ga
-2
~1
-2 O
1x10
- 1x10 /d 3x10 /d 3
S [.
, f. ',4,
d
.g -
. [W, railure to n,. y
- M. V - 3 run, emergency t
.w
. l--
Jh%; -..f conditions,
,w
-A-given start, IMf.m. (f 3x10 /hr 3x10 /hr 10 A s 3x10 h.g 't, '.
e,.
o we g,
W%
..J-k.. * ;- % "" ; -
Diesels r
e.>
. ~
(Engine
. e,. --.p.'b J
^
only):
rallure to run,
% e. '
-., G.,
S 4 '.c/ e W
.7 A*
err.ergency con-nr y*
ditions, given w
q'
- A*
-s
.. " -t
-5
-3
-4 3x10 /hr 3x10 /hr 10 start, 1,:
3x10
-W
,,jt ' p
.e f
K n
+.
n%,[;(h%%W:w#
3
, +A, sa
- .m:0 y
. h 0
.q.S4
?y
~
- f-w'. w._*,
h 9 S
s ggf 2 p#*M3
- Q
-N.tT $/
W.-Nyggg-@h-'.g.
i.
W &
,Q -
- y. &
' q,.....
"%(g
+.
,di
.xs w.. i
f.
..p,*e=
.y*
. c=.r. = r.
w.=m
.....n s.* 1.. a e
,.. * * = '
- .* e.* * *
- C #* '- Af jg
.,, =
- * (' /* * * $.Q.
O.. 7.,,*J {?.?.en* *A V O.*
V.
6..
J' L*
9 w...,--
p,.-
n.
D.* A
- 7 n
.s. c L.. e.. c' y
s i a %*
a v M E *w c..,
r*;s.- S,, '". L e.n. g C.
n a V..
e.
.,a
..M S.
.~..s MAS 2.:10m,'
wi
)
In the :datter of
)
- r..,
g w.
)
y METROPOL2 TAN EDISON
)
Docket No. 50-289 Restart COMPANY, et al.,
)
(Three Mile Island
)
Nuclear Sta. tion, Unit
)
)
No. 1)
)
~
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that a' copy o.s
.h e " U,. 4 o. o. Conce'"n'ed Sc**a* 'ses e
led
- 1'-s*
c1 ho*-.4 ce" w.as ma~'5e g$1ioding Request to Take O'.#.4
.4a1 1981 to ~
pre-paid this 20th day of May, Secretary of the Coi:nission (21)
Mr. Steven C.
Sholly 304 South Market Str.eet U.S. Muclear Regulatory Com:nission Mechanicsburg, PA 3.7055 Washington, D.C.
20555 Chief, Docketing & Service Attn:
Section Jordan D. Cunningham, Esq.
I Tourtellotte, Esq. (4)
Fox, Farr & Cunningham James A.
Office of the Exec. Eegal Director 2320 North Second Street U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Coi::nission Harrisburg, PA 17110 l
l Washington, D.C.
20555 Fried ?. Berryhill Karin M.. Carter, Esquire Coalit ion for Nuclear Pame Assistant Attorney General Postpone.-an.
..,w 2610 Grendca Drive
.:- s o
- r.
- 3. -., u _,,,
Wil:.inc.. ton, De.la.are 197.0
=.. v. n-.
.7. a.:.; e' 1 7-7og i
.a..,.. :
..., o.z
... - =
Wal e W.
Cohen, Consumer
- 3. e,_,
D9 Fare'"nt Of'IMSti 0 o
m.,. 4 3' South Beaver Street S t r a'*-'D d f r V 59:are 14 Ch s
i
'icrk, Pennsvivania 17401 PA 17127 Harrisburg, N
P00R ORIGINAL P
a* "P'**
- 7*.
D$.
- YY
. DIY.. <
e
~
~.
I M+
6N
- w
.~
~ Cert. of Service Docket No. 50-289 Robert L. Knupp,. Esquire Chauncey Kepford Assistant Solicitor Judith H. Johnsrud County of Dauphin Environmental Coalition on P.O. Box P Nuclear Power 407 North Front Street 433 Orlando Avenue Harrisburg, PA 17108 State College, PA 16801 John A.
Levin, Esquire Robert C. Pollard Assistant Counsel
' Chesapeake Energy Alliance Pennsy.1vania Public Utility 609 Montpelier Street Conm.ission Baltimore, Maryland 21218 Harrisburg, PA 17120 Theodo.;e Adler Marvin I. Lewis Widoff, Reager, Selkowitz 6504 Bradford Terrace
& Adler Philadelphia, PA 19149 3552 Old Gettysburg Road Camp Hill, PA 17011 Ms. Marjorie Aamodt Ivan W.
Smith, Chairman RD #5 Atomic Safety & Licensing Board Coatesville, PA 19320 U.S. Nr ' ear Regulatory Commission Washin.
1, D.C.
20555 Linda h. Little Dr. Walter H. Jordan L. W. Little Associates 881 W.
Outer Drive 1312 Annacolis Drive Oak Ridge, Tennessee 37830
- Raleigh, orth Carolina 27608 l
George F. Trowbridge, Esquire Ms. Jane Lee Shaw, Pittman, Potts &
R.D.
- 3, Box 3521
{
Trowbridge Etters, Pennsylvania 17319 1
1800 M Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C.
20036~
i Robert W. Adler
?
Dept. of Environmental Resources j
505 Executive House P.O. Box 2357 j
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17120 I
in
,~
' ' l., l [ 7%
?8
-22yn r,.
neiss
?.
$k
- Y
.i1
..