ML19352B266

Responds to 810622 Answer to Sj Gadler 810601 Ltr Requesting All Const Activities Be Suspended.Addl Contentions Re Magnetic Pulse & Jurisdiction Over Soil Discussed

ML19352B266
Person / Time
Site:	Midland
Issue date:	06/25/1981
From:	Marshall W MAPLETON INTERVENORS
To:	NRC OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY (SECY)
References
ISSUANCES-CM, ISSUANCES-OL, ISSUANCES-OM, NUDOCS 8107010374
Download: ML19352B266 (2)

Text

. -

u. . wg . -

. -- __g.. y - -

(~

l,4 E N 0 %,L L > N A P S H A L L qg I' ' - ~ '

W ^ * ---

ROUTE 10 o J, m g {w g MICLaC sz u. e pag g g.

M&rann:n./.~wnwng=? m e .

. .__ - l D OCKET I4 Uf/.CER Cac76182 176 06/25/81 ICS IPPBhGZ CSP WSHs PRODA UMON.1hhNb D 5 174953091'HGM TQ8N MIDLAho MI 715 06 25 1123P EST }

o i UUs t i Udig b mN s

00CKETIN3 AND SERVICE SECTIch, C 's OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY US NGCLEAR HEGULATORY COrMISSION -

DPda USNRO h9 ~

,uSHINcTCN QC'20555 9: JUN 3 0198; y @

J h  ! -

IN THE MATTER OF CONSUMERS PCHEF COMGANY HIOLAND PLAATS UNITS 1 ANC 2 00CKETS huFBERS 50-329 0F AND GL ^

50.330 0F AND OL g...

IN RESPONSE TO N.R.C. STAFF 66-22-81 ANSWER TO JUNE 1 1981 LETTER pre STEVE J. GAOLER, A TECHNICAL CCNSULTANT TO ThE MAPLETON INTERVENCRS, THE FILEC REQQEST HITH THE LICENSING BCARD CHAIRMAN TO SLSPEND ALL CONSTRLCIICN ACTIVITIES, AT THE MIDLAND SITE. THE N.R.C. STAFF ATTORNEY IS EHRCNE0VS, "THE FEASONS PURPORT TO BL ADCITIONAL CONTENTIONS" CORRECTION, MR, GAOLER, PROFES$10NAL ENGINEER, F0F AND -

UPON BEHALF ~ 0F THE MaPLEToh INTERVENCRS HAS RECUNDANTLY, THROUGHOUT * .

THE ENTIRE LITIGATIOh FROM ITS INCEPTICN UNTIL THE LdTTER HAS' STATED THESE CONTENT 10sS THE CUESTICN 03 " MAGNETIC Put.SE" ITS DANGERS, ANC HOW THEY IATENDEO 70 CEAL hITH THIS CANGER WAS RAISEC 8y GACLsR UPCN THE HEARINGS TIME AFTER TIME, AND THE R6COR05 NILL SC SHOW. MORE0VER '

THE GUESTICNS'UF JURISDICTIch, OVER THE' SOIL, CONGRESS 10hAL c-DELEGATION IN THE INSTANT CASE MAPLETON INTERVENORS EELIEVES IS DELEGA1ED EY CONGRESS TO TkE E.P.A. IS A MATTER FOR CISCUS31JN ALSC, THE MAPLETON INTERVENORS CCNTEND THAT JURIS0ZCTION SY CONGREGS, WAS .

DELEGATED TO N.A.C. FOR APPLICANTS SENEFICIAL USE OF THE SURFACE OF 2 THIS PARTICULAR~ PARCEL Of FLOOD PLAIN, ON A NAVIGABLE STREET AND TkE AQUATIC SOIL OF SAID FLOOD PLAIN AND "THE FEE SIMPLE INTEREST IN THIS rr PARCEL," dAS DELEGATED BY C0hGRESS TO THE. EPA;AS TO' JURISDICTION, THAT T

~

HE ADMINISTRATRIX IN PARTICULAR AND'NOT THE SECRETARY OF THE ARMY CCRP OF ENGINEERS CALL IT A POCT QUESTION IF YOU'WILL, THE HAPLET0h ~ -

INERVENORS BELIsVES JURISOICTION OVER THE SOIL IN THE INSTANT CASE IS -

DELEGATEC EY THE PREVAILING AUTHORITY OF CONGRESS AND CONFERRED ON

~

THE EPA nMC TO DATE >AS FAILED TO EXERCISE AND DISCHARGE THEIR DUTY ACCDROINGLY. IN COMPLIANCE AND CONFORMITY WITH SUCH CELEGATION OF t PahER AND CISCHARGE'THEIR' OBLIGATION TO'OATE IN THE INSTANT' CASE. THE

MAPLETON IhTERVENORS TAKE EXCEPTION, TO STAFF ALLEGATION OF COL GAOLERS "UhTIMELY FILING". RESPECTFULLY REQUEST THE COURT TO HOLO IN ABEYANCE UATIL STAFF CAN SH0h PROOFS.SATISFACTCRILY THAT THEY'CAN SUBSTANTIATE THsIR ALLEGATIch3 ACCORCINGLY COL GAOLER PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER HAS STATED, CONTENDEO AND RE= CONTENDED, THE DANGERS TC THE

$9p .e. .

d HEALTH AND SAFETY AND GEN $RAL hELFARE"0F THE PUBLIC.AT LARGE ONLE$$ A f MEANS COULC'8E $ATISFACTORILY AGREED UPON, TO ALEVIATE THE'0 ANGERS Of ~

cm, "MAGhETIC PUMPS". THIS IS NOT, AN ADDITIONAL CONTENTION, BY NO -

STRiTCH OF THd IMAGINATICN, TO REPLY BY MAILGRAM. SEE REVERSE SIDE FOR WESTERN UNION'S TOLL - FREE PHONE NUMBERS (

i 8197 010 3 M G- - -

. g,.. ,. ~~; . . - c.- ~ . ... . ..: q c m (

0 g W-ru '.nWE"k$%$;CW'.kWOWL& ~

_. . U .; _/ :-h u.x- n :=t2 23%G CONCLUSION

> TMERE IS TPEREFORE IN COPPLIANCE WITH THE FOREGOING, THE MAPLETON INTEVENORS REUVEST TPE CCURT TAKE TMIS MATTER LNDER ADVISEMENT UNTIL ST AFF CAN FURNISH BETTER OASIS TC RECOEST inE COURT TO DENY. TFE CONTENTICNS OF COL GAOLER THE RECOROS WILL REFLECT CCL GAOLERS CONTENTIONS AS ABOVE STATEC, AND MORECVER THEY MUST EE DEALT WITH IN TFE INTEREST OF PUSLIC HEALTH AND SAFETY, AGAIN I URGE YOU TO TAKE THIS MATTER UNDER ADVISEPENT.

RE3PECTFULLY SUeMITTED.

~~~

I AM AND REMAIN VERY TRULY YCURS, ~~'

fSIGNED) *ENCELL MARSMALL, PRESIDENT MAPLETCN INTERVENORS ROUTE 10 MICLANC P! f8640 CC: ACPINISTRATIVE JLCGE RALPH S DECKER, ROUTE 4 BCX 1900 CAMERICGE HD 21e13 DR FRECERICK P CCnAN, 6152 NCRTM VERDE TRAIL APT d-125, BCCA RATON FL 33433 FW ANK J'KELLEYs ATTORNEY GENERAL STATE MICHIGAN, STEWARD M.

FREEPAN, ASST' GEN GEN ENVIRONMENTAL PRCTECTICN DIV, 720 LAa BLCG

~

LANSING, MI 46913, '

FS MARY SINCf. AIR 5711 SUMMERSET ST MIOLAND MI 48640 FICMAEL I MILLER, ESC, ROM A LO G ZAMARIN, ESC ALAN S FARNELL, ESQ ISFAF, LINCOLN AND BEALE, 1 FIRST NATIONAL PLAZA 42 FL CHICAGO.!;.

60603 ATCMIC SAFETY ANC LICENSING 90 ARC PANEL u.G. NLCLEAR REGULATORY C0FMISSICN W ASHINGTON OC 20555 ATCMIC SAFETY ANC LICENSING APPEAL 20ARD PANEL U.S, NUCLEZR ~

REGULATORY COMMISSION WASMINGTON OC 20555 COCKETING AND SERV!CE SECTION, OFFICE OF TPE SECRETARY U.S.

NUCLEAR RE4ULATORY CCMMISSIQh, WASHINGTCN CC 20555 JAMES E BRUNNER, ESG CONSUMERS POWER CO 212 DEST MICHIGAN AVE ---

JACKSON PI 4920f MS BARBIRA STAMIRIS, 5795 h0RTH RIVER FREELAND MI 48623 -

MR STEVE GACLER, ESQ 21'20. CARTER AVE ST PAUL MN 55108

• ENDELL H MARSHALL, VICE PRESIDENT PIDWEST ENVIRCNMENTAL PROTECTION ASSOC ROUTE 1C PICLANC 10 48640 l JAMES R KATES 203 SCUTH WASMINGTON~ AVE SAGINAW PI 48605 JEANN LINSCEY BAY CITY TIFES 311 5 ST BAY ClTY PI 45706 PAUL C RAU OAILY NEh5 124 MC DONALD ST PICLAND PI 48640 MS ELLEN M BROWN COLSEL FCR NRC STAFF NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION WASHINGTON DC 20555 l

l 23:30 EST MGMCOME I (,

I 1::.-

4EPLY BY MAILGRAM. SEE REVERSE S10E FOR WESTERN UNION'S TOLL - FREE PHONE NUM6ERS (

l