ML19352A025
| ML19352A025 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Midland |
| Issue date: | 01/12/1981 |
| From: | Jackie Cook CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.) |
| To: | James Keppler NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III) |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19352A024 | List: |
| References | |
| 11006, NUDOCS 8102250483 | |
| Download: ML19352A025 (2) | |
Text
1
.O V
Consumers Power Jernes W Cook Vect Pressdent - Projects. Engsneenng and Construction General offnes' 1945 West Pernett Road, Jackson, MI 49201. (517) 788 0453 January 12, 1981 Pr J G Keppler, Regional Director Office of Inspection and Enforcement US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Region III 799 Roosevelt Road Glen Ellyn, IL 60137 MIDLMID PRCLTECT - SUPPLEMENTAL RESPO:;SE TO TDFRACTION 50-329/78-03-03; 50-330/78-03-03 (ERR 0NEOUS ELD INSPECTION RESULTS ON CABLE TRAY SUPPORTS, LOWER CABLE SPREADING ROOM) FILE:
0.h.2 UFI:
73*60*13 SERIAL:
11006
References:
(a) CPCo Response to IR 50-329/78-03, 50-330/78-03; Serial Hove-89-78; dat ed June 7,1978 (b) CPCo Final 50.55(e) Neport on Seismic Cable Tray Supports; Serial Hove-16L-78; dated September 8,1978 (c) NRC IE Inspection Report 50-329/80-30, 50-330/80-31 The infraction described above was initially responded to by reference (a).
This supplemental response is provided to clarify the record as to the date full compliance was achieved. The initial response indicated that all of the required actions should have been completed by July 1,1978 and noted that completed corrective actions and the date of full ec=pliance would be stated through submittal of the final 50.55(e) on the Seismic Cable Tray Supports.
The final 50.55(e) report was submitted on Septe=ber 8,1978 by reference (b),
and it stated that all the cable tray support velds in question would be in confomance upon co=pletion of the inspection (and repair as necessary) required by the disposition of Nonconfomance Report (NCR 1360) for undercut conditions using the acceptance criteria given in Specification Change Notice No C-30h-8003 It was expected that the actions vould be completed by November 1, 1978. NCR 1360 had corrective actions accomplished and was closed on November 2, 1978. However, during subsequent review for closure of the infraction in March 1980, an ancmaly was observed by the NRC Inspector on the closure of an earlier Bechtel NCR (No 987) associated with the subject.
The anomaly was that NCR 987 did not indicate that other necessary rework had been accomplished but only that the oversize velds had been accepted as is.
Thus, there was no documented evidence that the nececsary rework had been accomplished on other velds identified as nonconforming on NCR 987 This NCR was therefore reopened on March 6,1980 to address the condition. The NCR was redispositioned, had necessary actions accomplished and was closed on October 10, 1980, which now constitutes the date by which full co=pliance was achieved.
15 2 8102250h
2 Serial 11006 The Region III Inspecter, during a Site inspection Octeter 7-10,19S0, reviewed the documentation and hardware associated with thin infraction and the correcticn thereof and has determined that we are new in compliance with requirements. This ite: has remained open with the NEC pending formal notification of when full compliance was actually achieved.
This letter conctitutes that notification.
DRK/Ir CC: RJCock, NRC Recident Incrector Midland Nuclear Plant
{