ML19347A845
| ML19347A845 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 06/16/1980 |
| From: | Berkow H Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Rehm T NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS (EDO) |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19347A846 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8009300392 | |
| Download: ML19347A845 (1) | |
Text
j
)
er n
^
ykn A
D
[G0 Q@JU l
l 9
D i
i WJ DISTRIBUTION:_
Central File BSnyder j
MAB Reading BGrimes HDenton RYollmer m 161980 ECase HBerkow l
DEisenhut AFerguson (NRR-4085)
Dross SHanauer s
i i
RMattson i
J T.~A. Rehn. Assistant for Operations j
letmANDLBt FOR:
Office of Executive Director for Operations -
x+
~ me v l
FMBk -
'i' % Norbert N.' Bertow. Chief A, '
Hanagement Analysis Branch.
9
.Piming & Pmgres Analysis Staff, Illut c
3
SUBJECT:
E: IRR WWENTS ON DRAFT P01. ICY AND PROCEDURES l
w
.rca Pest amEWE
. - a
~
w.1
- ;;; b.~ lt.y!q&. 4:
~ k..:
L Y
.c
... +
These,.a===ts respond.te year. request of June 5. 7
^
.v
- s. t... c u.,...y m
The intent of this document is not clear. ~ It appears te suggest that peer' review is good and provides same broad guidance on the subject.
But it doesn't really require such review and leaves the extent of i
review to the judgement affindividual managers. If this bulletin is intended to.iecrease the use of peer reviews, it probably wn't.
~
l We suggest that a clearer' distinction be made between peer tuview fbr technical work and that for-policy issues. Peer review of technical work including that which forms the basis for policy decisions, is usefbl. Peer. review of policy issues.nornelly is 4
c ehtained through, sencerrance..whichishould be adequate.
t,a
.x y,
~w.g ww w,
.z.,,. u:,
~'m f
~
Abide frW these comM have'ne"dgnificant ' objection to' the
~
8 f.,.$~;1,,,
,c,.,...
.,/j O.. DMQ h, N 'q..
.. -,"..,v
~',I *, f..
J-
.4,.
,. m
.p.,,..
r.,, y%.Myiina.l. Signed be.G_ ~ ?n. _-
... (. Q g,, %- %,~.1 r..
o n
s._,
g
- emw.,
4 s.
- m s.
g ':W SC..b.e:w+
- 1.
- 3
~ f '.,..s;;,';
v....y.
73f, _
3.
. g ^^, 4
.;.j.j g, -
',,:,. s.../ W^ L g*.,K..; *,Jierbert. N. Berkov. g.
i.
+~_,q..<~.Q'.,
f,. w f.4
- lmly +,.,a.. ' s.
/
.G
)
s A
>q '
m.
y ys -+ f.o
.-N c.
w.# " 's% Y:Y s W ~ ~W p. y'..;Q M*v R',n'1: ft ' *
' %; W+- g'p;_W.b. :rdih^bG.
J:
~
.. ~ J+ h,'..,
- g, ',. ~s,;
? wit:.&
K h
4 No ief
' [N'
- c.g-E(A.%g/J1anniAnnegament Analysts B
~. -
l W'..{,1 m,c
+
j
/"". *;Nfed'.g?if59;4.L-f. f.
- .,,,
- .t'$.,ng.4fregrarAnalysts, Staff. Ista "f
9iMl 5
W
,,g
. n. ? *-* *.g[:f'K*;,{\\,Q.;
\\
,~ f M
i e m
~
.y*
=q %}p.' & g: +&. --
Y.. _.
c.;* ' %,
'./.,gs; S.,..
i
%.(./<K 4%.g 7W i
- *. s, a.y v.. A.:(j:',*%v'.
4
,n
- ;)%.K %q. J.-
i pf** * *T - } y, f W'.;*.p'.Q.
4 7.Q 4.,. '*Q. 5. p
. * ' ' ~
'5 a -J. :(@4 ( Q@~y*&;
, n.; Q g. y
.g.p4;. y,...,
"' ~
d-
.f
.~
c f
-e 'nW*><,:qaz;mgy,..:. "
D n?-
.:s y; g:';$T &JQ
. Q Qw p[4il *p' b% ]sli' 4. & 3 :."QNg.'r** *
- w. 4.,,,q.y,Q.. _ v _ g.. g qm
.,, - ? ? [g.. y h:[p:'N
- Q
,,, :.. y
_',4 4[,
['s5.j,f,~..*:Q
. :. s ;l(f, g%,.QGr's C y, y'Yvmy. s f>s_'.p':g
- v t
,- ; J, i s:. 2.Q: y ;..&-
.? yo.
_ s w
-r*<>:
...h
- u. '.
- . ~a
,,1
<c s os.e
+.g.s -
. p
. N...,4..sc.;. {p / ',
pe%
~c
- s. ?
- i
+u re 3 s o g 0 0 9 3 0 0,,$. < p
,L ; M,4
. p.
1.g.. m ;,g ji y.,e l.w ;,g.
J
,4
~.
y h,w.
- _.-vis
+,
,. ~
i w
_u
,,, s. y, ;.,
, e.
s r_
J"'
7
_ g,
,e
,s
'.-n
^
' OFFICE h....
.q
.............].7-.'.
...H.B. e..r.k.(o.i L
SURNAMEp
. 6./... I.v.../. 8. 0..
Oaru
- U 1979 289 369 -
N tc FORM 318 (946) NRCM 0240
? *'.S. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICES s.~..
.,,..,,.As_
"'-~.4"'
A...--
v
._; e w
. - - -.