ML19347A839

Requests That Georgians Against Nuclear Energy Petition Be Reconsidered in Light of New Data Projecting Excess Capacity of 40-46% After Plant Completion.Requests Hearings Re Need for Power & EIS Suppl.Atlanta Journal 800822 Article Encl

ML19347A839
Person / Time
Site:	Vogtle
Issue date:	09/25/1980
From:	Flack G MYER, BOWMAN, STROUP & FLACK
To:	Harold Denton Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
NUDOCS 8009300375
Download: ML19347A839 (3)

Text

. - . _- _- __ - - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

=

, ,e JOHN M. MYE9 THOMAS A. BOhiAN isis NaAs.aY SUR. DING ROBERT"H.STROUP A ozon YA so' sos GARY IrL ACK 4o4/ssa.ios4 OTTORNEYs AT L.AW

• September 25, 1980 Mr. Harold Denton Director, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Phillips Building Room T 202A Washington, D. C. 20555 Re: Docket Nos. 50-424 & 50-425

Dear Mr. Denton:

j l

Georgia power has recently advised the Georgia Public Service Com- l mission that it anticipates substantial excess capacity during this decade. Contrary to data previously submitted to you, Georgia Power now projects excess capacity ranging from 40-46% after the scheduled completion of Vogtle 1 and

2. An article from the August 22, 1980 Atlanta Journal discussing this matter is enclosed.

Georgians Against Nuclear Energy (GANE) agaia asks the Nuclear Regulatory Commission to reconsider its decision on the above dockets based on this new information.

GANE requests hearings to assess the need for power from the two Vogtle units, and the need for a supplemental Environmen-tal Impact Statement to account for the new information, as required by the National Environmental Protection Act. The new forecasts of Georgia Power support the position already stated by GANE in these dockets. Similarly, the new data undermines the factual basis of the decision of the Commission.

Accordingly, GANE respectfully urges that its entire petition in these dockets be expeditiously reconsidered by the Commission in light of the new data.

~

l Very trul ours,

)g})[

N Gary flack S

/ I GF/1 Encl.

cc: Mr. G. F. Trowbridge l Mr. W. E. Ehrensperger l

8009300375 6-

. . , . .,7-..-..- __ -

.

• e il fe uS 12 e.uuW

" Actuel Annual Geoween in

,,,,,,,,,,lS. year Profestiene of Oeeweli se - - in Peelt Elessnety Domensi a Peek Elecenmey Demend , , ,

i -

i, I:- "mn  ;

m

.a.

r m

'e 2

m

,, mm

. ... e a . , ,, e .

v- - - ao m.. .n .

..s, ~-.

ft +. .

n _., r x

~

y r\

m.. .y

e. . .- + .m m_ e se. .o-.

.: .1 m

.  ; . r w, . -

em .-

, 2

. .n ,. ,, ,. .r, ,e ,, ..o r, ,. ,, ,. ,, ,. ,e -w

,,m----:.a=" . G ,.m,,__ _ . - . . - . . _ . s. ..n- ~ - --- . ,-

^

• 3

..G

~a L,- N.*:*N; a ..

~

' T , i. 'E ~* * -

a 4' W r

, m.= re :L , . I R f . f-g * ' k } .y ~ .c M '* -.

_nr-r-<.<.e d gemum,  ; . .. @ ' - * -

M

. g; - - - - - - 1 .

-. - * - - - - .. e p _ . . _ , _ . _.

y

. -_ _ ~

~ l_'~._'_ i-59.nr4w - ~.

. ,es.xa m .,, .JudCh--- - - -

r 3: .

-;_ .- = . . . . . . ..

_a- __-

o - % . '.- .. .

.u,,.} y ,' --*2 y@$"-

~ - hg1E- -I[-~s3

• 5:.C.a...e ~ ' ... ,. . ,. ,

'-Qg,~;.&**'u p . D M m

gW!Eh_ ra.=_M-

. p.-

M . QN.MM w e. e E 4 y' 8 M t!MlhMW9N.1!LGN#8#.M'Wh$, w.- , .. c I #.% .

The Pubuc Service Conunisolon refused to let Georgio Power charge customers for piente under constnaction, We the Vogtie PLent Ga. Power Reserve to Cost Consumer Excess capacity is nearly twice what firin will need in '80s

.. 8,*?."

i "*** Projections of Reserve Generating Capacity

• la propering for Seat 3 beareas se Geer

• a Geeres Peows laime Is veer farerast s,,.,,,Pa,,wlgs,in,,m,,

, dig,,==,,t=a of eiertrmty demand taeacaias tae stdaty wid 46.15% as or% na prosecue peas demaet piaanse genersung 43 pu, esses - ""I "'" capanty, aos tae ress;tmg reserve surgum tawe a6*rsus twice as mera reserve genersung 4t.y9%

• NM""em"'ina.Nu p'aIter ine es.

g Q g ,p,,,,,,

4e 3* 23 % i = pnmena = numa suan said me cues capanty. becesse emetriary raias are .'. 7 I* .s ' . 31.,s,2%

empany cae eine me due me W basse se iae cess of beskhat and aversung gg ygg. _ . . 35.31% "

As 14 af the new farettsL Geor$a 3

738.91% .l [--

a pans of me piams W entium euusee wu u

.Peews too management mu uses comeew "

V- + E. 4 C ,L gen,mg as 3733 mulaos per year causarscuse D -*- N' 'f.f^ '*

~~-

4 * '. C**.

progras 30 ** Hooveur. Edewes sauf my der.mos to 2,, .' '4-- ** -"#

1 f ne preteruns could also make '

F N 2 '* * - 3' .; g the as constractas program esead have te diffnesit der Ceargia Powe* to e.it Pethe more ._.,; be sande m.4 me agreemset af its partnere e Service Commissise apprwat et a propened 33

Agesell '>' (.'. ". P %*

I<' C". 2  ;% Ge plaats Ogletaeres Peeer Carp es.ca see.

33.333 (,'-  ;,*y  ;, ; ' h'

• pises pww to rural electrie esaperumt t!w 1210 edhes band and preferred siset meus  %*. .+.

em mama. (,

.: v, _- .. u teamenpal Electn y -y f- is m.

• s en.cs m,e ety,eeees Astnerity ofans Geersta, Ramerve casacity is es arasest of else. 20 i -

• *' suhues us c.iy og n ii.m trtnty a eulste B power piassa cas queersia

.aeve ine massem amaamt of eiertnesty its comaners are especes is amena as any me

'80 '81 '82 '83 '84 '85 '86 '87 '88 '89 '90 s, e, oe ,,e power ca. h*"

• • '* ""8 WJ * **d *"*

• Asineesmo of eene,eseg esseespy les eneses d peessted posti elesertery ,,,,'*g'L'"'""'d,,',",,,,",

Q8'"ne merce e asesse . can esme es me g,,,

enktys p ama bresa down er must sie, rum.

msg (w massistiaere er because et aar er Baet easA *1'he compaavi revuse de-emelear Tee eats plantofbeeg Coures Powers teilt aser ss.e bdhas is elsew to aermat maad forwast e ese mere is ame vita eme>

esser pellouse regulaussa a ir 'yneesere are Alsacogn Georpa Power says it asees a essened to este esamemal operstaos - is Ha nrreas ferseast, Cauca Peen es. mate ed greeta waset erincs d uw esapa.

pans that pena commes - the maanriene ey a reemrecuss program kan adversies se reserve casacett of betwees 29 partent ame 25 1944 and 18tv. De fear eats af a R$ bdlies amont et eartnet? ua tuseamert esmaat the pam

• permL capas chty a teespecs a et pomes re coaWire.s ps.at soar Fervyta saseid sa ear.: soiea eseesor parros - mu meresse at a

- .aar,e serve im a st.,.se - percent.in 1983,. eli 1941,1H4,1987 ard IMS reepse' rete ed 3.3 partees per year between 1988 and

. ae. .esm.,es Band sad the rewrw mars. forwasu ater po om rame o Pe se *'.teme.m.si s . c.ucy p- equemuens' os. for Geer.

e l Geor Preeiassiv.Cesrpa Peeer had ferocast a ni and esat the total eens of eiertricity from ees - u e.ca P.uer's last, ra,te cast ce cartrg e gto esteriater.hl.ed.e.sta.the PS.C.a e,en.

-- ,.- ..aa ,s= e.ma.o.-- ,Pic.re - , . -- esem.w e-d pu-i e,

m.a,.c.e.re, Pe e, w, e e,e - inad use.r .vem.d - a..a- ,e ==.

v y go - 3aa.ma. - ,s.e e enem- ars -4 a

-a - . - et- a ->w ,s .e ,e sue, -

im  !

i

. .C8erS.a n ei PeoeFS

- roteret martile mit.be seisservict.e ce, eme ,14 par. tert e.ach year. As.forcess. have bees tiis.spe.n aseet Do.dd.esg plaass is sai mge3 - .p.ais. erange e.e., -- ie . .n e - u nneo p.,

ev ne si.e , es.

,ww.

, .st-se e-r- -

l sw Pe.w . .-, -em m.Bm m .e e-., .se . . . mi = c.w.a Pe.w oe g w re.wn. em.

coes.,.e, me,esi - coa.s .Pe.,. ,.,too, a

.,orma .e.

wouve, , .sso,,.e.m.as,.,

p.,

o a o.c.ow.st. e. - pmPro.

m.op - .e-.. w asasa u-t

.. a.,e a .ne. a n - - ma,c w.

- -. -were ptaasse ey em ~ ust .se . .as p p'amia man. forwa . em ,em.o tes .,,e oses.u,. aa,ser, is .a .er. ooem - . cew ASTOL tae 1960s and early the company 3 preistuem lascate a M per* uses samed 47 male Ceasemers Utahty Cana" cues remerte capanty east year, d the weainer set bletar Sert Sn POMR,11D

. - m .. . .

1 Powerc m ~ro  ;

ne - ,mp u- . c.e,n Peew. ,m use seus ameen m Lerus et manm.c serwasu ani.av es um grau mes.presen ue s:4 - ans e uw e

. .ee.

talat personal .tems taat Geertans e De aele is seend a Legler laid he teusven Georg. Peeers forecasung e

a l' meeos e at a state of the art ' invet I l -

j D

D . n.ey,, ia,n,s inser , taas s.e, ve,ry smotelyna,e \fy ca,ad,.4 . aggrat,s,al D i .

'l'j,

g. ,o wec u.i.r .

3,,,,

b I' 't

}6 tj \'

Li '

t.egier and .e ewma rwamen e en assety .flusse-es."

ma se me deve=sre revu.se W t a lses-serm pree.cuem ter de omre . pasaeeneneyu emeer. ite aae . wn useesc.oerv.a as mesiPeows sa emot

, - . - - - - - - - - - , , - - - - - - , , , - . - - , -