ML19344B433

Summary of 800909 & 10 Trip Rept W/Id Natl Engineering Lab at North Anna 2 Re Inservice Testing Program for Pumps & Valves

ML19344B433
Person / Time
Site:	North Anna
Issue date:	09/29/1980
From:	Cappucci A Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:	Bosnak R Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
NUDOCS 8010200650
Download: ML19344B433 (4)

Text

hhhhh NI NN,y& f~'b,'zl?w.3-hkIk ih;h h h5MN Nhk n..

~n

.m~

e e - wm

. a (m,~m ww n.w kkf5l$h;w !$, y&w, W; fbcmn, w khhf

• l ipl ' ^ ~

N

?

$ ?!l

,,. M::W WW ~ u m

'".v~

7,

., a.

e

T w%.W,;.~.m m v.

w :n:.r.

/ e d

.c r. r,. A

..e

^, c.

w.

q m-e

~

s i

'a_

h U; l " _

. )..

.O M M7M@%Q M j f M b 4;] MEETING:

SUMMARY

iDISTRIBUTION: j 7-s p' Ac a

c'g:,a e 2,

m p-w,,w )n....'&

~m. ;.

.."m e %,, ~ K.. g ",' <,,,;

,~.>.z.,

ut o

> e

. c w - / w.;%

~ :,c1 e;

$ $ G f NRC.;PDR C M M # M % N g C b ^:'.VENoonan %,

e z.

t af a G.,; Learb

x..

3 n.

v

, 4

..s.,

t g.-

S W o 'liPDR t Q

(

K jS.?Pawlicki1

$+g g f dla

~

SIC /77 4 ;

1,

V.sBenaroya 3 T

ff W MRR~Re Q ng S 7 3 L,'.'~

?ZORosztoczyi

~

A W V mc,%" O > " E,m~'

SDT Muller M

E Haass -

i g % LBf1 Weading W 9

~

o -

g

~

k,.:NM, J H.; Den. ton E.Ef? Case Q : %e

~

Tx -

nR.'Ballard 't

~

L';"c

~ -,

~ SW.GRegan'

&_ m,R. DREisenhu. t.W;+. 9:,

W

^

IPJ Check;.-

S T

5 J

~.

~

v; h, cR.;Pur e,'.

s...,: '

'~

- D.6 Ross e..-

Ce;f M B._70 MYoungbloo..d!

U.<

M A.? Schwencerk

Rf -Sa terfield

' < ~.r

-t-4

w..-

w' 3 % ;;JDM111er) $

~ -

V FKRosai

~

n

a

.L rag a,.~,

0.: Parr;.

@lN m

m rG Lainas W.

M

= c X WEButler, -

g 4

if.:JgR.tVo11mer J_ *

- W. ; Kreger <

m e

4 g, ^:W P.iKnighti '

%

• T.'Murphys

-RAHouston

~

$hg<jR.YBosnak_'

e

. F.3SchauerJ cL.iRubenstein

& p: 4V RS E.JJackson?

i iT. Speis

? Project 1anager; /. LDhomerick W.:Johnston, A

W Q^ JAttorney, DELD: -

JU Stolz H

~

S. EHanauer.-

~

? ~'

lM # Rushbrook ' J

,,< M OIEl(3).

. V

'W. Gammill 1ACRSs(16)1 e

W

, (R.NTedesco d N

'F..Schrocoer

'05

' 'W.

D.. Skrivhol t' 4n:

~ M.: Ernst a

i.y W' QNRCJParticipants:

R.;Baer 7 ;;

9~y..

C. Berlinger a jA.;;Cappucci, DE",

-K* Kniel LR.= Kirkwcod, DE/ s G. Knighton m

C JA. Thadani

~

M C

~.f..

m D. Tondi w

n' w -

s,

,.p"MX, a'di..

Ne

.v"

.,+

c

? :- d :

g-4 n

g.I b e

n7:

..a TP C:.

.w

,4,

~

6

.<.s y

y q ibcc: [ Applicant &LService? List

,*.0.

(

J.,g

,, ':) >-

^

g 6

W cr r

p4

A,..

('",

T N

7<

^

y f ;;;.' T rll ^

1..z 1 -

n.

y

.,e'

.c

=

i J

• 1

_.~ n -

,:,g

>>g?

m.1..s >. A.;.,

o.-

m g.j'f - ' \\

';-~ y c

Q S ~g w +'

's e3 m

Y \\

[

d

^

-.a.

'g y

?.-

b

4.. ; ;.' 4"5,

r

.:, m.

s, a..

.$Q..

.yJ ' s

' l.:. :Q+ f.1 g;. -%sD,A

-4:

J

?

l

~

m.-

.s.

A:

a,u

.'ak....,,~

x y

, ~O Q,p[ Q.*W.?n',;:

- -. *p:'r s.x~ '^4R _ y3 (

4 s

.., f,,- (

"'$ * ' /[ ;,?. '

' $,}r m <e

. ) '; jQ,...

_ };

S t

y

.w-

.ac c

L._.

,.mn. -uo,g a ~,': ^', ;

. m... :

m.

v,,

.- - ~.

=

n. m ;% m~

m m. u -

mr s--s

+

a. < - -

.m

-'?

.. ~-

A*

w&,f W'S-$ ll}.*:,Yh'?j\\

k-l r

- 'k '.

6 s

.- ~ r.c ;

^

7 '. ' ' - j.,

1. 3 j'

'4 3

f

.c s.n

.'.-v.;N Q, E.?4 fl Yf. ft; m w 9: &.

b; -

.c..

2. Q l ns

.~,.

{

k kh{

(f De Mg

' 3". _' '

m,#.

m-

'a b

_r c... s umeTe2 sTATas,

y V

SNUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

~

N rs. '~.,

d;

1. r ha,e S '~ ^

unnenuesvoeto.c.seems.

T.

2 '

L;;N Q %;. ' ' - ': #-

[

~

hn..

w va

. r.x.n pgb%.p{.M y ] lt

{

SEpfg; gj980!

- I I

~

't ks

v

-

m

~

nu. ~

w m.D r m

.2

/w 1

'l

, w

~,.C'W

,,. _,_As

~

go V MEMORANDUM.FOR:a Robert"J.;Bosnak. Chief?

~

p g s.

f M Mechanica1jEngineeringl;8 ranch,LDEe

~

n x

,.y

.. Q

,i g 'A FROM R

• 1.

TAnthorty?JuCappucci(~~.1

,g :

'as M-i

- Mechanica1 J Engineeringj. Branch. - DE1 y

~

^

M #;$ 5 Q

F.

. %!E (l^

1 THRU:3 s 5 v MHerbert L.iBraemerFSection Leader; gr n, i

.

• k Mechanica12 Engineering' Branch, DE:.

1 c -

SUBJECTh

[ TNIPJREPORT$FORlTHE-REVIEW 0F4HE NORTH' ANNA UNIT 2.

'f i lNS ERVICE ' TESTING : PROGRAM FOR.. PUNPS " AND.VALVEh lj 1

w

^

4

?lx.

J.

D; 0gfSeptember: 9 andi10,11980, a meeting was held at the North-A 7

s e

P to,discussi d.f L'aboratoryJquestions that the staff and its; consultants '(Idaho NJtional Engineering'-

4

.INEL) hadLeoncerning(the Inservice Testing Program (IST) for' pumps H

• jand valves'.s i

J

~'

' ~'

e

+

Meeting Participants!

- l 77:

SUSNRC"

^

IINEL5 VEPC'0 n.

~

E fA$cappucc:i,DEJ tT.?. Cook.

S. Eisenhart E. Kann J

' - :RUKirkwood,{DE" J. Haneks

!D. Heacock?

V. West-

{

~

. J Theili,consee was given~ a bEief:introductionioutlining the agenda and the methods -

'aused forthe documentation of, questions 7and. responses. This was'followed by 2

Sdetailed ' questioning bhthe NRC and!its consultants:concerning specific pumps and!. valves cin'the North:'Annaf Unit No. 2, program. - Significant discussions and observations ~are discussed-below. -

3 y

~

i

.(1)DVEPC0;has Lagreed;to test the PORVs:according;to your memorandum to Youngblood-on May:.16.11980 "takingfexception to'the stroke timing requirement because

~

Lof_ system designaThey cannot at the fast closing times required during s".

~

low temperatere operating condit;onst VEPC0 will submit a request for relief

. :on t,he resubaittal of. their -IST program.

i (2)$TheLPORV block valvesfwillibe fu11: stroked-exercised in accordance with the

~~

Technical Specifications l(T.S.'14.4.3.2.2)..

~

S

,n..

Gm(3)';VEPC0frequested that we consider char.ging'the standard technical specifications

> f id D, fori: pressure isolation valves ~ by McJiring: testing, ~ prior to entering Mode 2 Yg _

s(startup);instead'of prior to entering Mode 4 (Hot Shutdown).. We = agree with Athis ' position because it facilitates 'a more er.aningful' leak test at higher

• RCSipressurec. -

~

7 y

a k

d ya -

. ryU[,

a

~

j s

s N M;;[

@~ *i

,f

.m I a

^[

• -l} J j}

a

,, g <

p.

. g:

mg;','

dy.

~7"Q p7

- o

;.n..

a.

M

.v y

~

Y, s kq,33g;g' ;; g g.

+y 3:33 c ;

f-e k

9e

. ;.~

s

,~e

$hj,. ~. -,, !tI?'l$h'@N;KKl$?m$]#. ) '. f

~

,.~,..,...,

!? l' 7~

V

_, b. %

+

(

r 5

$w$ : ~ L '

Ol$% i I ?

l'

~

m { e?".r. m

>k, 5-);-

- c

.u m

r.

p(u' i

w I->

;

gg

.3 7 r

Y z <.,,.

c r;

- : -c

.;J. ~b. < i, rm; s.. M ' i e,

uc

,.; w. c 4

lf 1 > a

. cs

~',_.,h.,;.

o 7

4 s

m

,~

g.

m 4,.

t o 4-l'I

. 3 m.Q:,iR,o,b'ert J.'1BosnakW:.

' We

s 1

.2 2 -j s

+

a.. -

....z.;

O i

q

. a w ;-

.e.

.w.

=

~

+

i

.t, q:.,

x., m..

s:j Q 3,' 4)L.u,VEPC0 has; agreed to sutait their revised?IST

~-

~

e m..

y._

s--

[

g.

.v

(

' J Uponfcompletion?of the ISTireview ' meetings -a debriefing' wasTheld'in the tffice 2

p%,, ofzthe;stationvanagertR? Cartwrights,

~

• .e w v.

-+ c a

w,-

g.

^

.t-Q$[

~

t

~

9

- Anth c

1 Jr.-

' Mechanical ngineeri Branch-p' Division ~of Engineer 1 w

t'?cc:: H. Brammer. DE1 F.!Cherny'DE c

iR.. Kirkwood,' DE'.

-V.. Nerses, DE :

A; Wang. DEJ c=

AW Dromerick, DL M-iT ' Speis. DSI k R. Lyon. INEL a

. NEB Members d

t f

I

5 A

e g..

A t

+

J la P

hs

< ' ?

.-tu

,'q.

S

+

4' I

i [j L))-;

x

~

,4

~

~

1

,g^'4-s t

• '}

f, 3;..,-

V

,Y.

,v' g

• L 4*

T y

,[

s

.a s %

?

~

'.mg

.[

b _

.L.

o y'.*

Y

=.

.,r. :

1

)

y

\\

~

4 s

,.,f

... > ~ "

s i

a-l } n-

{_'_Y,**

h y

-4,

[

9 ?,. -'(

- 1s

(.[ '.,'

.*W,,

';? -

[

^

s y

c. ~

.s u

' s,h:,

L'!:!%' W,,.l> &.W{.{n, _. _

TF

'. ( (;3:;

• ~

> ;,' ; ^~

lr

e

' QS:- 3:J

y& pt. Jg wm

' y;%

c t

+ - -

M N M dJ O HD FergbsE O ~ h N N :

~ %' ' ' '

~

t

~

i i

~

n

~

b

~

a

~ % :y Executive.Vice Presidenty : Power?.

L TN fVirginia:Electris: AlPowerjCompany W

L-

$/t HP.%0.;Boxi266661 N' 1;RichmondfVirginlaM23261

~ ", ' '

, u

~

d

~

y

- s

~

s

~m.

Mc

_ ccs f.

_.l

4 '

~

EMr.' Anthony;Gambaradellaa s

Jg' 10ffice;of the' Attorney General'

~

9

% ' %. 711rSouth!!2th4StreetHRoom-308:

~

9 Ric.hmond,Virginiau23219~'

,s I

'.RNhafd: MNFosier/Esqh_

'2

1. ^

N L

Musick,,Williamson.iSchwartz; C

L ste~avenworth 8 Cope, P. C; SP. O. Box 4579: ~. L i

1.W L86ulder Colorado l80306L p

Michael W.

Maupin, Esq h Hunton, Williams,iGay & Gibson-

]'

n

' P.~ 0; -Bot 15351....

? Richmond,1 Virginia 23212 c

~

- IMrsSJune[ Allen, President.

H

' North Anna Environmental' Coalition.

il105i-C-011ve Street ~.

. 4 sGreensboro,JNorth-Carolinas 27401; 4

LMrs. Margar'et Dietrichl

~ Route-2LBox.568.

-Gordonsvil19,1 Virginia 1 22942-f

.Mr.: James C. Dunstan?

y

.StatetCorporation'Connission

~

j i"

Coinsonwe'alth;of Virginia-

-BlandoniBuilding

'. J

RichmondL Virginiai 23209(

(

'Alani.Rosenthil',Es$

S

~

.4

! Atomic; Safety and Licensing" Appeal Boardi

~

1, s tu. S." Nuclear. Regulatory Consission!

m tWashingtonO DLC. ;20555 _

W ~ Dr;) cJohn!HEBuckP M~ _y Di, SO Nuclear? Regulatory. Commission;CAtomic'safetyand$icensin j

7

~

.a Df>V. ; Washing tonX DMC.120555:.

J&-

~

~

eg -

y 3 92-y W -; Atodiic' Safdiy and Lic'ensing BoaYd Is! anel J

=

n 1u

~ U.4SdNiiclear Regulatory. Commission a

T ' hf Washington, D.JCi20555 it' s

0 2

hE %;..b TM WOh' ster <[ :.

in A)U. ; $ E Nucl earJ Regul a to ry" Commi s s'i on ?

j n

O M 'f "P.TO.VBo n128 4. _~.

s

,' o AM: Spo.tsivaniaEVirginia-l2_2553i H

.m

, s m

g-l !ff5

' ?

.. ' ~

• *U

} k'.

Q:g nM,' QJl%wl< JQ * -

o r,,,.

i

.:V-r 73

' % ^

s

c yrw

.y.fyyj,[f f 3.%y,Qyn n. ;&;

n

. y 4

-G -

1y. y u u-

j. m 4

- Q

.#'; J_

'"n^

gyy,

y_ j n.

+,

___ _