ML19344A212
| ML19344A212 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Midland |
| Issue date: | 05/08/1972 |
| From: | Cherry M CHERRY, M.M./CHERRY, FLYNN & KANTER, Saginaw Intervenor |
| To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19344A205 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8008060560 | |
| Download: ML19344A212 (3) | |
Text
,
~
q;
,,,/.
p..
(_-
s us,,u f,thq,,.,
- ,VN PECD. & UTIL. TAC '4 3ff 33g f\\
l t
. ;6972
- c-, '
- 3' s
sQ,N % [S UNITED STATES OF AMERICA M l to' ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION l-IN THE MATTER OF
)
)
CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY
)
Docket Nos. 50-329
).
50-330 MIDLAND PLANT. UNITS 1 AND.2
)
l MOTION OF SAGINAW VALLEY, ET AL. INTERVENORS
'TO MAKE CERTAIN FINDINGS WITH RESPECT TO THE STATE ~0F THE RECORD Saginaw Valley, et al. Intervenors, pursuant to the-rules j
of practice or the Atomic Energy Commission and in light of the Motion of Saginaw Valley, et al. Intervenors with Respect to ECCS Issues also filed today, move-the Board for the entry of orders:
A.
That Applicant and the Regulatory Staff have failed
-to demonst rate reasonable assurance as to the effectiveness pf ECCS; B.
That'since the construction permit ma'y not be is' sued wi::hout a demonstration of reasonable assurance as to ECCS, there is no need for an environmental-hearing which could in no event purge the record of-inadequate technical support for ECCS; and C.
-That.the application is dismissed and the matter
~
remanded-to'the'AEC1for further proceedings not inconsistent
- with~- this ' order.
The': grounds' for this motion are at leas: as follows:
EU08060j(Q
' ~
t 1.? The-record of the rulemaking proceeding aptly demon-
~
strates that.~ECCS: effectiveness ~has not been demonstrated;
' t 3 2 '.
The.rulemaking docket testimony _ indicates that
.g 1 pressure' vessel failu.re'is'not an incredible 1 event;.
=
~3.
This1' Board earlier ruled that'if pressure vessel i
failure-;were credible, it.could not and~would-not issue a construc-tion ~ permit.-
Respectfully submitted, SAGINAW.' VALLEY,. ET AL. IN ERVENORS f'
. _. =
yh
.{.
/
1 e-Myroird/1. Cherry l
DATED:
May 8, 1972 1.,..
e 4--..
~
4 i? y:-_
j-E.;
7.*:
h:.. "
w:
'.1'1
..7.*.~."..
'.:~.: ' ',.;_
~
.: =
-2.
e O
s r
1
.w
.'.m
,s..
A i
a
I.J 1-
~.=
y: -
5 grsl.
"'.r
[,-
- " :.T:5
+
e 9
CERTIFICATION
['
=
J gh I certify that copies.'of the; foregoing document-7.[":
were mailed, p.os'tage, prepaid,.on May 8, 1972 to. members o~f
.:=, : =:
=={
m.
the.' Atomic Safety /& Licensing l Board,fthe Secretary'of th'e
(-:
Atomic 3 Energy Commission..and allicounsel'of record.
~
~
(n i
' =...
Myron M.-Cherry.
l
.:ss l
is F
.t e,
.. a
=d
, -.s.
.s c _e+e.
".T.".
~ : T..
-.d_~.-
l 7.
.J.'
[.-
"f;. ?
K
"' ;;u;: -
- = :=:
)}s~h-[
~
f.;
g-j' b-s'
.3 s
.'7.'
~
(.'..
r-6-
4.. -
t 1 ~
e
~
'+. ;,',,
+
>: W
-n~n V
' OE.?"
S' l
3 v~.
"t s
~
- e.. _
A 1
r a
.a.
-