ML19344A136
| ML19344A136 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Midland |
| Issue date: | 06/18/1974 |
| From: | Jenny Murray US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC) |
| To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8008050691 | |
| Download: ML19344A136 (3) | |
Text
%iAJk
??:h s:;g;1 N ' 2-%p ;7 %
' M e.
WMJP;
,y 3,,L'.
- c.,, %.
n
~,
~
N" 7'..
?' RQ.
r e, -" 4. ;W; y.s w,.W %
~o.,
ft:
yY s " ::;?. - mg
~
- %;n
^"
m.q
- . e w
p,.w n.
Ce
.l! TAf N ?Q -
&&& ~
a.x x;
c
' " % ?:
'n Aky$
~
a.:p y a n
. A 9;Q i Q ti.; '
.?
wp end,"
M
,s.
~
g; - '
E., 7, it a_
e,.
w y
M f
[V, F
f b
e e,' q UNITED-. STATES OF AMERICA-
-- 1 ATOMIC EllERGY' COl411SSION
^
r
- 3. ~
s
[.-
BEFORE THE ATOMIC SdFETY AND LICENSIN'G BOARD
{2
~
l,,
In.the Matter'of' I
h-
^
CONSUMERS POWER C0ffANY:
Construction Permit.
I Nos. 81'and 82
]~
(MidlandPlant, Units'l and 2),
t J
AEC REGULATORY STAFF'S RESP 0flSE TO'
~
O
~" MOTION OF CONSUMERS POWER C0t:PANY -
m o
T0' IMPOSE THE. BURDEN 0F PROOF ON-
~
W'
' THE PROP 0NEllT OF AN ORDER SUSPENDING, REV0 KING OR OTHERWISE 10DIFYING CONSTRUCTION PERMIT NOS. 81 and 82" I
Underl date of June 10,1974,' Consumers Power Company (" licensee"T)
~
.has ' asked thelBoard to place the " burden of pro,f" upon the pro-
- ponent-of the show cause order involved in this proceeding.
.Section 2.732 of_ the Comission's Rules of Practice (10 CFR 92.732)'
-4 provi. des as follows:
~
9, "Unless otherwise ordered by the presiding officer,
- the applicant or the proponent of an order has the burden of_ proof."
- }
s
'In view of this' provision, the -Staff believes it clear that the
" burden' of proof", used in; the sense of the ultimate' risk of non-3
- (
3persuation 'is proper *y that of any proponent lof the show cause
~-
1, e.
'g 7 -~ :
- +
x, y
~
.y u q ;y/c
. l8008.060s c.
u J
nm _ y #
y r
.w w; w.
s s ~ g>;. t J.,
.s
~e c
>g.
- m
.,x'-
- p n F
2x
- ... u.
- p
, a:7 m
--J g
y, g,-A.
b-mxm
,m-E e
J g MrMM
'3 ma.ssa@ w e m$$O M M' W 2 s-l
- n
- e. n} q :. m. w r e &r m ggh.m w:g/s.yd,'
e, m
ww
- m
. p g
' j%
M '
%* ? ff?.? '. V Dir56.gy e p %.e. g.-, 9 ~
4 y
i yMp
?V.:. ) ?. ?f*M*Q,j; r. 2 ;
Mi. YQ.%
- [ L ;i. / ^ g jkN[l.,
^?'ys?.2 y ;%4 I
, py 3 : ;
y.. ;m.
3. = -
c.,.
q.y(.;
.m.
{#g%p..r
~
?.i "r
@-. h--
N j
- r..
m-
....-;.s
..v.
N- + %..
. 9..V s
~
- g. g....,
%,J
- 8 2.mc.4 -
k.$g
~'
[
. u. y..m.7,. #u.
ap,,.
r
- g 4
5 h.h$ $ [ Y.. l l'fj.f.lla-
- 3
,._ ;, 7
- . q,g. u n;rg;,..
'y
+
. n..
.. y _,
i hp.;, -
.' f.j -
.,'4
.M c.
~ ; J J h[ r ; '+,,
y
. y n%3,6 # A.. '..,
1
%.1
'. i.
N.... y; g '
4 e
No.%. -
r
- ' f - +,
' it 4 %
esicst
-t ;
, L gg n '
9 i '
'g s.. j,,.
ifasP
....>i..
M_. @, Q.
- ep
- r..
v,m,f
- f
- s..
m hY.
s
. _ g (-
- [h y. Q '., -
. ' ' ^
- '..g > c ~.
- F f)p x
L s
'lp g.;.'
n..f.r. y ' 4f J.
"g. 'A,n.g r. i.
p a..~
~ p :,y.
e s
44 (4:
yy_. f, ly.
.: g * ? ~
...r.
'~ x.4
?
,s.? 2.:. ;
c
'... ?
e 4
-a N
w,a,+,,.>.",y y- :m.. %.
%~,.,
-.c s-
. + :. x
. a<..r :
- 1 m.
~
, y,,
.., s ;.
1
.+
['
3 J\\ji.
,jjg h. yn:mi.
.il N M
f 7,A..'; w'.' E 'g, 'gng.,'p. ' -, [ '., m,
- g. y ;s.i rg.q4, :
4gs- - -
g :
. q q gg a s w. g-y n,, m,
w y
>r.
y of - m, a,.
.T j
x
$ gde_.
- g[
~~'
l..fk%
$X g
4 D'Y2. Af u%
r m
- I'.*',..>
,s.
- M.*h...*
,,,. [
. As,*
3 9
".ayz w(a w a,,y[ $.e 4
4 s,
2 ~
l..
'h t
i gygg.
y 3
4 n 7 -:'.c y, x m
g
,,. 3. q.,' ' 1;
+IT
. /d.).'
9 4(ig W ' 24 '
?'"h i
A a t a,. a A s S e' n5 a,' p~.. W,
~
~
- gg ge1'9 L
% g ge s.g g w.,
L M N$kk
$[
m,_hd rkit9 qy f-
~
Nh*%Qk m hte: son-M W w $r u n g@@w, u$fh%
[
[
9 98 N7 r$ M N 3NIfds dS E
9
$n 9.
e x
e v.m en sw n.x n
c *. 5y 541f 4 7 M d p.: g.,w Q.
,, y,4.: % m-N g g ;4 4, 4 {. 9 qm s & a Q V f n
- c.s% %x $ " i J:(
s@
- 4 4
K
,c.ng#A:
~2 r
1 y
v 2I k
4
,,t p
y,.
@ h
- E..-
9 yk:: Mi 5
? MF**R$ tin l" J f' g W W c g 4 % E y e ':Mdu469 4 vs F W h y F 4 R 2 N
+ +v s ~,% r 1 Yn g
,,.c
- .y.u.
n
%m.u.i Q !&w:: M M;;. $x,;, W; &:..- gz <_ W, c.w
- 4:: -
W W
- , a.,. - g,,., e.
cp n+
~
,7 m.. y.. ~
y.. w.
a2 -
r
+
,: n<, ww. w m
.c e
w wA a. ~ m. B -_ -
w,.
- n~ s
- r-4. _.
- <s. t ~-
?
- e J. ;, r,p.... W'c.,%
a
.w.
%,.+
.c'9,
., :n i..,
=~.-',; '
m
+
4,I ;.. ~
.c r
+,
a
- s:."**;.
' ri is
-i 3:
4
,,,% r% w..eg c
.Yy
.,s
~ ~
s
~',.
u.
- m. -
- u a-.
- e' s
e ~-
e)
A
.r...-.r.a u
Y{A$. i,9 8 -
r
}
Y A
.+
., r
+
.t e gy - :n '
a
., =
w y
0, g-c i
- g n.
1 n' 7
, _.m v,.-
- w
- v. <.
m,,,..:
e o
s m'm.R ~ $l.r y.z,
Qs-g
'x..
9:.
x - 1
- 2 ;.e.
-. [ -- ~
. y l-
. e.
~.
r
- n,
,y.
.i :. - :. 3 m..--
c
+
y,.
.e.
,2
., y..,..~.
- . e.
u.
4
~
\\
3
. f, (. 1p;N
.-, +.
y.
s r e;.~ -
0 order-and fnotLthat, of-the' licensee.- LIn this! connection itShould be; u4 r
1.
s,
~
_ g-k.g ;
. noted that the:RegulatoryiStafflisinot the proponent.of this show?
' 'Mgs z
W.
te,
.s.-
qQ- -. -. _
cause order.f as has been brought:outlon more' than oneloccasionj(see,'
1
. h.,
j
~
h'
~~ '.'e".
-e.g., prehearing.tran' script,.page 49). - In.allLevents', bec'ause"of L s
b ko th'e cleari
' of l'0 CFR -52 732 ' the Staff sdpports 'the'
~
A-
~
E,
' 4.
, licensee..'s reques,.t.
i.
o<
- d A
.s.
Respectfully submitted,.
, c m
4
~
s
~,.
w A
h F
am slP. Murray,Jr.
P,
- Counsel Lfor.'AEC Regulatory Staff Dated at Bethesda, Maryland,
. this 18th day. of fJ,une,1974.
! =
'8
(
Y A'
i 4
i L
w*
q o
s I
.j m
[.
e h'
i 4
h'-
e A
S i
q w
8 K.
',7
(
- i..'
4
(
c
.sa 1
f '" ) f ', g ^
+
4; i.Q.
+;
- y
, + - -
n '-
{A _..,;,
a
_ t
-s.'.
L, (t j, :
e s
p'
.s d
""g'
.,,~. -
'a u.g
%,ju ' 4'
, 7 ;n.,
e y
__{
a
[.y; m.
- .., s -
,s'w,9 ;$,- - ; ' ;
..y w
/
p N..,
s 2
s
.,,~>'9 w
g e
,sr ic 1
vy wg
~..
....<s
,.9" N-[ ' k h,
+
s.'
3
_s b
. 1 i
4.
Iw.,_~
,1,,.w.,a.,hl.
.v.
..,1
(
v m., y
,n h~#.i' ) f_b.
(', l..
- .'; j.
_' 3.; )] h-Q l.L vW A D
,. m.:
y Rg ;; t,
, + g);Q -
\\
,,, y )
i
.%;' w" N
- e ~ 2 a As
^
l.
f y
zf.;'
y
$% ^'
11.s k
- wa b
b f f %y v y w +G y?f f k M.[a d yl*.N am)&%f..?QQ MM[, "(,
n g;
C Q, e a.C 26.w' q,W,,%m:
' g :
3 z-
. -- f;+ ~y,z QG5]4FN,fk$.l M M
QX&.
L f-
+
ff[
.y., ; ;. J & ~ L %
4[f~q&mllw%e, y ' *w< s ;, f:._,
D-m e
c m
_ za s
Ja
~t."',
,s,.
- e x'Y
- , p -
r,
, yl ", '
~ " ' '
e s
- y. :%.,,w~y - ~
3 y
,c.,
W
_x u ;' '
7*
_ :y
,y g.9 -
m:
~
~
RW, 3,G,y ;;o T cq,:3 -
m:
.=
_~
,? a W" - CUNITEDl STATES:0F?AMERI'AL Mp%/@4 Q~C,. m :- ' '
a C
c?-
/
fATOMIC: ENERGY: COMMISSION; N
^
w v.
.w s
y
-+9
=
W+g><
~
' ~
- s J
f c
NkT,
^,,, ?8EFORE THEiATOMIC" SAFETY.AND LICENSING BOARD-r e,2 v, a
~
5 w2 R
W c%
{Inithe Matter ',of)
..)1
+
v;'s p%4
%g
,w
~,
a Mb 1CO'NSNMERS POWER COMPANYJ 4 f.
' M.
7 -
Construction' Permit s
a Bc-A LNosG 81_and 82c
~
~
bl
< f(Midland; Plant, UnitsEl J
M:w.
'Dandf2.).V gg,
%. I,
^ '
c'
- m;
. M
- CERTIFIC TE-OF SERVI'CE!
[
I hereby. certify: that : copies.'of "AEC: RegulatorysStaff's' Response;to' y
~
' ^; %
- Motion'of Consumers 1 Power Co. to ImposeLthe Burden.ofs Proof-oni the, e-Proponent of an< 0rder? Suspending,' Revoking-orJ0therwise; Modifying
_ m J,
Construction,PermitiNosb81 and.82't dated June 18,1974, in the cap-:
tione'd; matter, have been served'on the following;by hand delivery or
^ 4 E
a
- by depositEinEthe UnitedJStates, mail, firstl class or air mai1~, this o'o m
N_.w il8th ' day; of: June,1974:1
~
y Michael'Glaser,'Esq., Chairman'
- Michael I. Miller, Esq.
1 a
StomicSafetyand:LicensingiBoardi
.IshainFLincoln & Beale A
4..,*
-1150.- 17th Street, NW1
~
'One'First' National Plaza 1
W
. Washington KD.C.i ~20036 Chicago, Illinoisi 60670 8
H Mr. Lester Kornblith, Jr.
-Laurence M.. Scoville, Jr..
~
1 Atomic Safety and Licensin'g-Clark, Klein : Winter,' Parsons & -
Board Panel.
Prewitt c.;'
U.S. Atomic Energy Comission
.1600 First Federal' Building' j'
Washington, D.C.
20545' 1001." 3dward Avenue 1
s Detroit Michigan ~48226-
?
Dr. Emeth A. Luebke-s c
Atomic _ Safety. and' Licensing Myron M. Cherry,' Esq.
. Board Panel.
Jenner and Block n;-
U.S. " Atomic Energy. Comission-
- One IBM Plaza-.
A, Washington,'D.C.: 20545, Chicago, Illinois 60603 4
Secretary.
Atomic Safety. and Licensing '
~
.U.S. Atomic' Energy: Commi_ssion-
- Appeal? Board
'e ATTfh ~Mr.; Frank'WJ Karas' j
Chiefi Public Proceedings. Staff U.S. Atomic Energy.Comission Washington, D.C.
20545 Washington, D.CL 20545 o
?
~.. ;
S-
.y
. James N. O'ConnerD 0 ;'
-Thec0ow Chemical Co.
~
.,y','.
- 2030 Dow Center:
s<
C'
- Midland [ Michigan l48640 s
4 y _ m. - 1.J.'
A-
-- 1
. ~,.
fNY~"
s;
,?
~
$4s P. Murray, Jr..
' ]0 ci @ ".
- &?.
Counsel for AEC Regulatory Staff.
w' lM '
y % S & !} '
A
,+
~
~
-4.
o.
N E.Y A eg s
~.
- > * ?'Y
.-Q;N
-q
.o. m J1
_8;
.; G 'M' :,
4 g-f Y
k: '.
MN N ir d'
f U
%2,_.* Q MWlh
'.e
~
c.
L
[d; nx* >p w n g'[%j "W
^
u;-
~
r x
i',
., 9o
.gg N qp
%( -
= p (, jg '
~ -
y h
I'
?
i.
p et,. ; J
,,f
+,
Ry l(fg ?&';Q(. 'QT'J?N f f &' s J Gk'.TW*
. ' h ;gdY 7, L y
.4'
~
r6s 4
i cQ