ML19341C544
| ML19341C544 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Grand Gulf  |
| Issue date: | 02/20/1981 |
| From: | Dale L MISSISSIPPI POWER & LIGHT CO. |
| To: | Tedesco R Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| AECM-80-78, AECM-81-78, IEB-79-27, IEB-80-06, IEB-80-6, NUDOCS 8103030725 | |
| Download: ML19341C544 (54) | |
Text
o
]
MISSISSIPPI POWER & LIGHT COMPANY Helping Build Mississippi P. O. B O X 164 0. J AC K S O N MIS SIS SIP PI 3 9 2 0 5 February 20, 1981
\\f roa S
i NUCLEAR PAOcuCTION DEPARTMENT
\\
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Division of Licensing g
g R0 digst g.
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission p.
Washington, D.C.
20555 u.s, Attention:
Mr. Robert L. Tedesco, Assistant Director b
Dear Mr. Tedesco:
'b
SUBJECT:
Grand Gulf Nuclear Station Units 1 and 2 Docket Nos. 50-416 and 50-417 File 0260/0277/L-860.0/L-401.0 Response to Request for Additional Information AECM-81/78 This letter and its attachments constitute Mississippi Power &
Light Company's interim response as requested by Mr. Robert Tedesco's letter dated December 12, 1980, concerning IE Bulletin 79-27, IE Bulletin 80-06 and potential design deficiencies in bypass, override and reset circuits of engineered safety features.
Our current schedule for submit ting a response to the NRC addressing the actions contained in IE Bulletin 79-27 is June 1,
- 1981, with any design changes or procedure modifications being fully implemented in accordance with a schedule to be submitted with our response.
The balance of this letter, Attachments 1 thru 5, is devoted to a partial response to IE Bulletin 80-06 and potential design deficiencies in bypass, override and reset circuits of engineered safety features with our complete response to these items to follow within sixty days of the date of this letter.
Should you have any further questions regarding this matter, please advise.
Yours truly, s'
4
/
/
L. F. Dale O
Nuclear Project Manager MRW/JDR:Im Attachments cc:
(See Next Page)
O 81030307Oh Membec Middie South utilities System I
m
~
a MISSISSIPPI POWER & LIGHT COMPANY l
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission AECM-81/78 Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Page 2 cc:
Mr. N. L. Stampley Mr. G. B. Taylor Mr. R. B. McGehee Mr. T. B. Conner Mr. Victor Stello, Jr., Director Division of Inspection & Enforcement U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission i
Washington, D.C.
20555 Mr. J. P. O'Reilly, Director Office of Inspection & Enforcement U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Region II 101 Marietta Street, N.W., Suite 3100 Atlanta, Georgia 30303 Division of Reactor Operations Inspection i
Office of Inspection & Enforcement U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.
20555 r
1 i
I
ATTACHMENT 1 Response to actions contained in NRC Bulletir. 80-06 entiled " Engineered Safety Features Reset Control" ITEM 1 Review the drawings for all systems serving safety-related functions at the sch'ematic level to determine whether or not upon the reset of an ESF actuation signal, all associated safety-related equipment remains in its emergency mode.
RESPONSE; Schematic diagrams for all systems identified in Attachment 2 serving safety-related functions were reviewed to determine whether or not, upon the reset of an ESF actuation signal, all associated safety-related equipment remains in its emergency mode. documents the results of the review for each 1
system. Additional information for each component will be provided in our final response to be submitted within sixty days including equipment description, equipment number, automatic signal from the engineered safety features (ESF),
actuated function / position, function / position after ESF reset, Bechtel schematic numb er and remarks. For components not in compliance with the acceptance criteria, proposed modifications or justif; cation for use as-is are documented in the form of GGNS Field Reports which are summarized in our response to Item 3.
ITEM 2:
Verify the actual installed instrumentation and controls at the facility are consistent with the schematics reviewed in Item 1 above by conducting a test to demonstrate that all equipment remains in its emergency mode upon removal of the actuating signal and/or manual resetting of the various isolating or actuation signals. Provide a schedule for the performance of the testing in your response to this Bulletin.
RESPONSE: Test procedures are being developed at this time to test each safety-related system identified in Item 1 above to demonstrate that all equipment remains in its emergency mode upon removal of the actuating signal and/or manual resetting of the various isolating or actuation signals. All testing related to this Bulletin will be completed as part of the pre-operational test program prior to Unit 1 fuel loading.
ITEM 3:
If any safety-related equipment does not remain in its emergency mode upon reset of an ESF signal at your facility, describe proposed system modification, design change, or other corrective action planned to resolve the problem.
RESPONSE: The safety-related equipment that does not remain in its emergency mode upon reset of an ESF signal is identified in the GGNS Field Reports referenced in Attachment 3.
The proposed system modification, design change or other corrective action planned to resolve the problem is summarized below:
(1)
ATTACHMENT 1 PROBLEM #1 (Field Report IB21-0013)
B21 Nuclear Boiler System-Nuclear Steam Supply Shutof f System EXISTING COVFIGURATION: Bechtel schematic E-1160-52, Rev. 2 contains logic that indicates valves E12-F060A, B; E12-F075A, B; B33-F019 nd B33-F020 will reopen upon resetting from an isoi tion signal if they were open originally.
PROPOSED MODIFICATION: General Electric is to correct this problem via a generic engineering change authorization. New switches and relays will be added via this mechanism so that af ter an isolation, positive operator action will be required to reopen these valves.
PROBLEM #2 (Field Report IE51-0003)
E51 Reactor Core Isolation Cooling System EXISTING COVFIGURATION: RCIC/RHR steam supply valves E51-F063 and F064 may not fully meet the NRC criteria as E51-F063 will automatically re-open when RCIC steam isolation Div. II is reset, if its control switch is left in the open position.
E51-F064 may automatically re-open depending upon its control switch's position when a Div. I isolation signal is resat.
E51-F064's hand switch is a "close", "stop" which can only have its key removed in "open."
In addition, there are no alarms that indicate whether the switch is in "open" or "stop."
If the hand switch is left in the "open" position, E51-F064 will autcaatically re-open after a Div. I isolation is reset.
PROPOSED MODIFICATION: General Electric is reviewing this problem on a generic basis for all BWR's.
Corrective action will be based on the resolution of this problem by GE.
PROBLEM #3 (Field Report N62-0001)
N62 Condenser Air Removal EXISTING COVFIGURATION:
Bechtel schematics E-1150-06, Rev. 10; E-1150-08, Rev. 9; and E-1173-21, Rev. I contain logic that indicate the mechanical vacuum pump-high steam line radiation signal will close the inlet valve resulting in a pump t: ip.
Since the mechanical vacuum pump hand switch has maintained contacts, the pump will restart when the high radiation signal clears. Thus, this equipment does not remain in its emergency mode upon removal of the actuating signal.
PROPOSED MODIFICATION: Redesign mechanical vacuum pump to have starting relay R-25 remain energized thru seal-in contacts rather than hand switch contacts.
(2)
)
0 4
I O
ATTAC:! MENT 1 i
PROBLEM #4 (Field Report P44-0005)
P44 Plant Service Water System EXISTING CONFIGURATION:
In the event of a loss of of fsite power and a LOCA occuring at the same time, valves P44-F067D, F054B, and F042B do not remain in the post-LOCA (closed) position after the LOCA signal has been cleared. Thus, this equipment does not remain in its emergency. mode upon removal of the actuating signal.
PROPOSED MODIFICATION:
Redesign control circuitry on Bechtel schematics E-1228-07 and -08 by adding an auxiliary relay to I
take the place of IP41R25 an Bechtel schematic E-1225-02 that requires operator action to reset the controls af ter a LOCA has occurred.
1
)
PROBLEM #5 (Field Report IP75-0021)
P75 Standby Diesel Generators l
EXISTING CONFIGURATION: The standby diesel generators do not remain in their emergency mode when the ESF LOCA actuation signal from the load shed and sequence (LSS) panel is reset, i
It is noted that the LSS panel cannot be reset unless the ESF LOCA signal from the LPCS sytem, Division 1 or RHR system.
Division 2 to the LSS panel is first reset. An example of a sequence of events that could take place would be:
1.
The LPCS (or RHR) ESF LOCA iignal has been reset and neither high drywell presse,e nor low reactor water level is present.
2.
The LSS panel is reset to allow restoration of certain loads locked out during LOCA by the LSS panel.
3.
The diesel generator will come cut of the emergency mode and trips are no longer bypassed.
If a trip had been present and bypassed prior to signal reset, the diesel generator would trip as soon as the LSS panel ESF LOCA signal was reset.
PROPOSED MODIFICATION: Bechtel is reviewing this problem and will initiate appropriate rurective action.
PROBLEM #6 (Field Report P41-)
P41 Standby Service Water A summary of the contents of this Field Report will be provided within sixty days of the date of this letter.
I (3)
ATTACHMENT 2 l
l Systems Reviewed B21 Nuclear Boiler N64 Offgas B33 Recirc N65 Offgas Refrigeration System C11 CRD P11 Cond/ Refuel. Water C41 Standby Liquid Control P21 Makeup Water Treatment C51 Neutron Mon.
P41 SSW l
C71 Reactor Prot.
P42 CCW C85 Seisair Instr.
P43 TBCW D17 Process Rad. Mon.
P44 PSW D21 Area Rad. Mon.
P45 Floor / Equip. Drains D23 Drywell Mon.
PS2 Service Air i
E12 RHR P53 Instrument Air E21 LPCS P60 Sup. Pool Cleanup E22 HPCS P64 Fire Protection E30 Sup. Pool Makeup P66 Domestic Water E32 MSIV Leak. Cont.
P75 Standby Dies./ Gen.
E61 Comb. Gas Cont.
R20 480 V AC Fil Fuel Hand. & Vessel Serv.
R21 4.16 KV AC F41 Vessel Int. Vibr.
R22 6.9 KV G33 RWCU T31 Aux Bldg. Fuel Crane G41 FPCC T48 Standby Gas Treatment L21 125 V DC U41 Turb. Bldg. Vent M41 Ctat. Cooling X77 Diesel Bldg. Vent M51 Drywell Cooling Y47 SSW Pumphouse Vent M71 Ctat./Drwl. I&C Z51 Cont. Room HVAC N19 Condensate Z771; Emer. Swgr/Batt j
N21 Feedwater T46/
Room Vent N62 Cond. Air Remvl.
Z92 Cont. Room & Emer. Light t
l
,.,, -,~
,-e.,
t.
l ATTACIDENT 3 PESPOISE TO NPC PJII.ETHI 83-06 i
Centrol icgic at the Elmentarf/ Sche::atic le.'el has been revis<ed for the folicwing system (s), ard is f0t:nd to be in confomance with 3 C II Bulletin 80-06 criteria:
t i
EE M ER SYS'ID110. & MAME
!GIE/ CASE E.') ? -
(4 ?C '% f'.\\..,.,,, _
4) 6 r :.
t9llQ } 5 C
...o a
,P e 4
.# + /-
.~, ATS w w_ _
J C %~ SL.( - u c ___ ':, X--.
f,
% '.\\ s % t C.
s'
..e
_: e f
1 i
Centrcl logic at the Elsnentarf/ Sche.itic level has been reviewed fer the foll wing systs:1 (s) rd corrective design ac-den is regt :. red l
fer c::nfernance with NPC IE Sulletin 30-06 cri~ada.
Design change l
regt:est has been initiated i:rder Field Facort as i.dicated belcw.
- u.LD
.VsTR i
SYSTEd 10. & !GIE cIPCR2 20.
1GiEM Y oz,]rd, p GC/ - SOTC
/2C1-00o 5
(
~
v l
l 1
i
l
.c e dSE ~C NPC 3C*.J CI S0-06 Cent:cl logic at the Elc.ent.rf/Scheatic level has been reviseed for the follcwing system (s), and is femd to be in cenfccance with NPC II Bulletin 80-06 criteria:
MBE SYSTE410. & MME lG2E/CATE l'9D f y erub s H1. &l i2-10-80 ld It'II -
I A bd - Off Cras nt M
,, -is-jo IAJGC - CffCas %,.
rr1. !&
iz.ie.re
/
P * - 4 : - / f _S: n E i M
im IV47-S S tr) 'Po r,,olmeuse Ye,,tilld,o.,,
>>f. rW iz ->s-fo Cent cl logic at the Elcentrf/Scheatic level has been reviseed for the felicwing systan (s) and ccrrective de.ign acticn is req & ed fcr ceniccance with NPC II Eulletin 30-06 criteria. Design chance
-wt has been initiated = der Field F.eper. as indicated helcw. '
FIEID Fr/ILE SYSTEI10. E !GIE FEPOE 10.
lGIE/U S IPHI-5(w.dbv Serbec (AlaYer 711.g & f n.io.fg i
, {Q u
0
I l
FETE ?3 !TPC St.'.* ~ 7Ci 30-36 Centrol logic at the Elc.en ary/Scherstic level has been reviseed for the following system (s), and is fee.d to be in ecnfecance with E 3: Bulletin 30-06 critaria:
T O 'ER SYbT1 !D. & !GRE lGIE/ CASE
'/11 / il il
- 1,
_,3 t ria.n n s, rs w,. ) l -
OnI a
~i ~
8:13 Arsh::.sc2 C.ari2.cus.4 %
$44 no /NI5 BJ fdl WW oviss:~<<k >
d ald?7cri Atl
- $r mc 1.']n 9 M 7/
Cc%'/7hiv'MM, W"% h kN"'W bri l.l w i If @
L 4IV,w4 siss7'sk~pwrr/ncu p c<urt'a Cent:01 leg c at the Elec.nta. y/Scheatic letel has be reviseed for the folicwing system (s) and corrective design ac icn is re? dred for ccnforance wi.h E 2: Bulletin 30-06 cri-* a.
Cesign change regmst has been initiated tr. der Field Ee;:cr. as indicated belcw.
m Fr/m'ER SYSTDi20. & Et2 FEPORT 20.
3GlE/CId2 d;2./
duai.awr** &aa:C.
BJll - cx/.3 f//ath c:u abs /JC t
_ o o M o Al luu
4 I
EE.~ prise TO 2r!C ET. MOT S0-06 Centrol logic at the Ele.enta:// Sche.atic level has been revie,ed i
for the follcwing systen (s), ard is fcird to be in cenic:=ance with IIPC IE Bulletin 80-06 criteria:
amza SUIE4 !D. & SU}E BWF./r.EE 3
nz c,.~Jc..L, aL A Ak2
- M4 i
t Cent:ci Icgic at the Els encary/ Sche.atic level has been revie.ee:
for che folicwing systen (s) ard correc ive desien acticn is required for conforance with tiPC 2 Bulletin 80-06 criteria.
Desicn chance
~
cequest has been initiated urder Field Facor: as irdicatad'helcw.
- M REVIz G SYSTDi :D. & SWE REPORT 20.
!WE/t;cI i
i 1
D~"D D W J 6'ilo
\\'
s.fL $_
.A lf bo 4
1 1
,l I
1 i
FISPC:ISE "O E LUt. i 30 -36 I
Centrol logic at the Elcentary/Sctmatic level has been revisqui 1
i for the fc11cwing system (s), and is fetzd to be in ecnferance wic:t E i
II Sulletin 30-06 d teria:
1 1
i
~
1 I
FE' C E R SYSIEM 10. & 1"d2 lG24E/CAEE l
l PIl con n n v1 & 4tcus. *4G tJAYER Ne$Au M la f!PU l
TA A4574 4 4 I ra A A b d
(
I l
i l
l
[PG0
$w **ta s ! r od PCC L fLpANu2 U f SC v
\\
4 NlA N$ G lllfb'o
_I N 9 co~arnsarE i
y i
su sue tv atorso EG uts* M C k r Centrcl icgic at de Elenencary/Schs acic leve]. has been revis,ed for the fellcwing systr. (s) and cerrac-hie design accien is reqc. ired for conic =ance with E 2 Enllet_n 30-06 cr teria. Design change
_ m t has been initia*.ad e. der Field Recert as indicated belcw.
1 1
- W FECER i
SYSTDi 20. & !"JE REPORD 10.
!GLE/t;CE i
l t
1 4
1 1
y u
-. ~...,,,.
.\\
i
._ SENSE 70 }E 3r~ 7;T 80-06 Centrol logic at de Elecentarf/Scheratic level has been reviewei for the folicwing syste (s), ard is fcund to be in cenfczrance with B3C IE Bulletin 80-06 critaria:
?rcIhn
~
S*lS'IEM !D. & BWE BWE/DATE P M Ib,.,4-;e WJ.c 0 d.
%o Am
" hp/r
$ss ou hs
- l'f/!n S h
- N*x llAl
- ** f'a o
- <ao
- G33 - L)-e IAl,b.e Chu.1p % L.
C w.,. A,
i tiw c9g s....:, M k.- - N /A G
. A.
idiw?
t
-[* fret.1e]_ hsJ t0
_4
,sb llll$O 1,
. x/. l.
s tor w 1
i
(
cenw.,11cgic at de Elemntary/ Schematic level has been ~.vieeed for the icilcwing systen (s) ard cerrac-dve desi p ac-den is reg,: ired i
fcr cenicrnance with N?C II 3'"etin 80-06 criteria.
Desip dange request has been initiated under Field Paper: as indic2:ad belcw.
i
- M
?2]EEhD S*lSTEM l0. & !WE
?E?CRP 10.
WEr_;dE i
i i
i
s 4
i f
PESPC:!SE T NFC Br" "'If 90-06 Centrol logic at the Els::enta:y/ Sche.atic level has been reviseed for the following syster:t (s), and is fee.d to be in cenic=:ance with NPC II Bulletin 80-06 critelia:
won Smr4 to. s me as/cies 64/ &c 61 (co w n h. J % s 7 2 a A a 'c o i
O 1
1 4
1 l
Cent:ci logic at de Elsentary/ Sche.atic level has been revieaed for the fclicwing syste. (s) and corrective design ac icn is re71 ed fer cenicraance with NPC 2 Bulletin 30-06 critaria. Cesica chance request has been initiaced e. der Field Paper as indicated be'.cw. '
~
TII:.D EGE I
!WE/D;CE f
, 3 *9 l (Wjf,/&Y // Y Y ** CC$ Y
{!
GA
?AN?bW l
i o
1 I
I l
i 1
J e
D**
~T oo o
m 1
FREE ':0 !T!C 3LU.2"Oi S0-26 Cent:::o1 logic at de Els::entrf/Scheatic level has been reviseed for de follcwing systsa (s), ard is fot:nd to be in cenicrance wid :E E Bulletin 80-06 dteria:
~.
2125G SYSISt10. & ENE G2E/r.x2 E-W~ Nff, 8M M/A kW/.
r A7-9f/
N$- MF #WWE & GM A7-9 9 Q
//
55'/ - leniyet he,e NP,&c t~k
/ ~ - Q
'p!-
'M-5^rs Gm Awe
, :., n v;-
- cic w'ps l{r&Gj Cent==1 lcgic at de Elcenc rf/Scheratic le',M. has been reviesed for the fellcwing systr. (3) ard cci:~ac ive desip ac,.icn is required for ccnferance wid NPC E Sulled 30-06 deeria.
Cesi p dange regmst has been initia ed t:4=- :"a7A Papert as irdicated belcw.
7 FEVEER SYSTD110. s !GIE FEPOPT 20.
!GIE RATE l
l l
1 FISPC::.~:::.' To E EC*'721 80-06 Control logic at the Els enta://Scbs.anic level has been reviewed for the follcwing syster.1 (s), ard is fct:rd to be in cenic=ance with 2K E Bulletin 90-06 criteria:
FE'EG S'S C 4 !D. & E T WE/CACE r.3z Msw as
/bAL A.m.
A de/a '.
AA,> L, iu, f.,t a
A121 kJahr 1J,~
s v
Centrol icgic at the Elerenta://Scb=mtic isvel has be reviewed for the folicw r g systa:t (s) ard corrective design action is rqc. ired fcr cenfen ance with SFC E Sulletin 30-06 d_eria.
Desicn chance rage.est has been initiated t: der Field Fagr. as 1.dicated'belcw.'
F." D IE E ER S'ISTDi 'U. & EE FIFORD 3D.
BWE/C;CE sLu3Ab w
i 4
i RESPC:sI: T tric CT B0-06 Cent:o1 logic at the F.lenentary/Sc.5matic level has been reviesed for the following systera (s), ard is found ec be in cenic:mance with :E 2 Bulletin 80-06 dteda:
i seen Sys:sa to. a m e nem L21-12T /250 \\1DC. GA'ITEt2tES, CME'stDG Tew, h=Ue
/2-to 4 o M41 - CXNtr Coeu kJG I
.'~ 12 -io - to
=
O l
i 4
i i
Cent:cl logic at the F.lenentary/ Sche atic level has been reviewed for the folicwing systen (s) ard cc rective design acticn is required fcr confez=ance with NPC 3 Bulletin 80-06 criteria. Desicn chance squest has been initiated under Field Pap:rt as indicated belcw.'
~
.m n
- ran SYSTEM 10. & ET REPORD 10.
1GIE/D?C i
1
- \\
rAO
.o a
oof b
bg [
D D
r D
La
---e
~, - - - - -,, - -,
.,.,--g-
,e
1 1
i i
l 1
1 ESPC::sE 73 it;C r 72: 30-06 Cent:cl logic at de F.le.entarf/ Sche.atic level has been reviseed for de folicwing systan (s), and is fetr.d to M in cenic= r.ce with l'C IE Sulletin 30-06 critaria:
Fr/II:E.
SYSTE:410. & 1G2E
!G2E/t;G h-h 4~
Srr kre r w n y s, % s n-AUA/@
- 2) - -
r a
y-Cent:01 lcgic a*
"a 7'emntarf/ Sche.anic level has been reviseed for de fellcwi.g systen (s) and cc:rective design action is req & ed fer cenic ance with tric H: M 'enin 30-06 cri aria.
- esign dange request has been i-itia ed tr. der Field ?eper as indicated belcw.
FC PrCs.
SYSTEM 20. & WE FEPCE 3D.
!WE/TZ2 fAA
$dM Sna./b>fy1st f
eOE~
WAmg/f;&
wehubw ~
l lb.,e-ferws lOs m-
?-44 nea L
$ fuha 44 S
( Ana/d -
oe SFX-)-2-766 Dsrs) 7bi%
y a-DTD 7 0 'T L ft ll
. ] 3X oL
_ _ -. -,.. =
l 1
s.
i i
i 1
h I
)
4:SPCSISE FJ 57C 3CETT 80-06 1
Centzel logic at de Ilmer.tarpSchumatic le/e1 has been revis<ed i
for the fol.lcwing system (s), ard is feed te be in conferance with !GC
]
IE Bulletin 30-06 cdtaria:
i
.TEEK j
j SYSE!M 10. & E T
!WE/Cr2 5.2 l Icto hwan Dre $nnu 792Ar }n /2"/C-do
/M
?Y3 bha, Bu:th Can./>a/n w /O Aac>, /2w~so m
n i
i 4
4 1
I i
1 i
Centrol logic at the Eirentarf/ Sche atic le/el has been revis<ed j
f:r the following systen (s) ard corrective desien acticn is r@ed I
for conferance with 2;PC IE Bulletin 30-06 criteria. Cesign change request has been initiated r?- Field Pe:cr: as 1-dicaref helcw.
t I
FD!ID
.'E:' E G".P..
i i
SYS'IDi 20. & !G2E PEPCPT 20.
!G2E/t;4 E 1
i
)
4 t
i i
a 1
1 1
4 i
i i
D**]D *]D'T}$
1 a o Ju o M A.S tru _2 1
4 i
h
=
.F~TEZ 7J 2TPC Et.7'72130-06 Cent:cl logic at the Elements:f/schecani level has been reviseed 4
for the :clicwing system (s), ard is found to be in ccnfccanca with NPC E Bulletin 20-06 criteria:
!WE/CA"2 P52-f* e n 'o e. Nx 5 a J-e Ml.//k
//-
/ //fl 6 L
?5 3 - Tosleviw.>d ke Svs A -
Ml/hc~/bt' yb /?)/'[/N d11 - En? ka /$3lM0 'o & Si c h*m l/l Asf
-,ph /2//f $
AYS/~
b/?:/W!/l b5 Wy
!/s h l, 8 yh
/[ h Centrol icgic at the Elemntary/schecani level 333 3een reyi.eved
,cr the :clicwing sy3 tan (s) and correc-dve design ac den is m h
.cr con: caance with NPC 2 aulletin 30-06 critaria.
Cesien enar e
.vt has been initiated under Field Paper as i.dicatad'helcw.
- D
?E'On SYSTD120. 5 !WE pgpor yo,
)gggy-.3
J i
i FISPCN5E TC :'!C 3CC.Cni 80-06 Cent:cl icgic at the El ment rf/Sch e atic level has been reviseed for the fellcwing sysm (s), ard is fet:.d to be in ecnfc=tance with NPC II Bulletin 80-06 criteria:
BrJIEE SYS"'E410. & WE WE/EATE f$l 119C5 64~<rt. Gfn)ff1170$
i -rll, s.~..s-~
01 logic at the Elemntrf/Sebeatic level has been revieaed Cent:
for the fellowing sys*a (s) and corrective design ac ica is reg: ired fcr confc=ence with NPC E Sulletin 80-06 cri. aria.
M icn 2.ance
~
request has been initiated under Field Paper: as indicated belcw.'
rd rT/IE C S*lSTE420. & E E FEPCE 20.
W E/ TATE D**]D *D'T)[@
ooM oh 2.Altdo l
.T.SPCNSE TO NPC SIZ11TDI 80-]6 Cont =cl logic at the Eisentary/ Scia rJ.c level has been r= Mewed for the follcwing systact (s), and is fcc.d to be in ecnic=ance with 2GC II Sulletin 80-06 cri*r _a:
.TSER SYSE41D. s EvI tw,Elrx2
$$I YlS h~5 f % ik bnDsin
// /llfD l
Nr Ib 0l Surk O Ga Y
////yll6 YL
$' 9 lbi i $441 if il /3l&
>r
/
v g
E i
Cont =cl icgic at de Eleerf/Seb.sacic level has been :=M ewed for the folicwing syste:t (s) and correceive desicn acticn is reg h for cenfc=ance with 'iPC IE Eulletin 30-06 c-iteria. Desip. chance request has been initiated c a-Field report as i.dicated belcw.'
a M
EWA.
SYSTD120. & !wE REpor 10.
!w.sm
[~h f Ca u dk/)
t I
l
t Qe[N 2ESPC2:SE "" li'!C S'J~C! 30-M Cent:cl icgic at de Elr.entary/Sd.r.atic level ba.s been revissed for de felicwing system (s), and is fetmd to be in confc=ance with diFC IE Bulletin 80-06 criteria:
PEVma SYSTEM 2D. S ANE
!G2E/CMI EloI (owJusfi44& W
&0 Il--!1-&*
Cent cl logic at de Elren.2.:y/Schmatic level has been revieaed fer ce felicwing system (s) r.d ccrrec-dve design acticn is rege. ired fer ccnferance wi-h h7C E 9'11enin 30-06 criceria. Design change reqc.est has been initiated t= der Field Reper as i.dicated belcw.
i M
BEV 3 G SYSTEd 20. & !WE FEPOIC 3D.
SW E/tA rr AlfoL CCN0eMot MA Levn Vnt.
N h 2. C oo l.
o f M e
s i
l l
I
i i
O
.x".PC:.e y s... e. _.- - -.- _. 30_., a.
u Centrol logic at the Ele.enta:j/ Sche.a_i: level has beer. reviseed i
fer the felicwing system (s), and is f:und. be in cenic= ance with E E Eulletin 30-06 critaria:
.-: v w2
~
SYS~EM 3D. 5 ANE LWE/DA"E Illi ZC$[3 Q. \\W t/0$l8U a.
6 Cent:01 lcgic at the Elementa:y/Schmatic level has been revieaed fer the fellow ng system (s) ard c=rrective desie.n ac icn is rec aired fer ccnf = nance with !;PC ~.r Sulletir. 50-06 critaria. Desicn chance request has been initiated under Field Faccr as i-dicated'below. ~
- w Fr/IE: e SYSTIM :D. & :W-E
?sCR :D.
- G ;.E, C c z i
1 i
D"*
3}
J1 oo o
v.
n 1
4 I
-- SP"..e.. m_. n.... _:.- - - -.. 2 0..,.
Cent:cl icg:.: at de Elea. tar //Schr2:i: level has 'een revis ef for de felicwing sv.sa (s), r.d is fot:.d _c be in ecnfo:rance with !K 2 Bulletin 80-06 c:_teria:
. SEER SYSTE*4 :D. & G2E plE/CA"E
.C3/
/VaeIma /Tlarlibrlm
'1.11 Ain
/ 5 Si v-V s
/
Cent:cl logic at de Elemntary/Sc'.r2:ic level has been re'r easi
--_V-.., sys*a ( a-) =.d
-. *.., a. des.' ~.. =c # ~..-
4-ec ' ed se,
.o.
a for cenforunce with K 2 Bulletin 30-06 cri_ar.a.
>_ sign dange rec.uest has been i.iciatai under Field Fe cr as L.dicated 'reles.
m v
e -
. d bo
.m.
s m.,e_/mm mh e.pd *.D. b sm o.c-py
.O
. 6,-s ets w..
e e
M 1
I I
i
1 l
1 i
1 1
i w,E. ~..._
- n. s..._c : - - -..
20-.~,:
-.. ---- n -- a. -.e
, -. ~, a.~.r.- --- =
-ee..
=-., a,.a
=-
for de folicwing systen (s), ard is for.d c be in cenic=ance c6 3GC E Eulleti. 50-06 criteria:
E/IZG'.R SYSIE4 :D. & SG2E IGlE/0A'IE
/ ~Z-7 E bR-29-2)
OmN b $ fe..~ Adra 8 ** #
/ $
/
/
Cen=cl logic at de I:lenen.'_:y/Schs.aric level has been revieaed for de felicwing systa (s) a-2 ce rec _ve design acticn is re:cired for ccric=ance with !GC 2 Bulletin 30-06 criteria. Desicn dange request has been i.i-dated r. der Fi=1" Reper as i-dicated belcw.
Fr/5:ER -n Sr.IInd :D. & :O E RE:PCR D.
- G;Er.xE e
l l
1 i
l
- m. _',ic..e
- m.... c. _: v- - - _-~_.. :0 s.y
.~
Cent:01 logic at de Elc.enta-//Scnr.a i; lerel has been revlesai for de follcwing system (s), and is fct.=d 2 be in ecnf =.r.ce 'dth SFC IE Sulletin 30-06 criteria:
FEVIE3ER SYS~E:4 :D. & EE 132E/DxI l' 17 Paxess basAnna Noa,ne.ioc.
.a k ////P/
//
ID?-l A <.e. L.~ ea 4.a. oc e,.
M.
/ - > i,
</&/or
'ID 2 5 SR.%.seu._ Yca troc.ia 6 f
Y"Y 1/s/g/
A J? I bt I1= t f T~o e, Iluo u a t. Eoa,maa r l
i
~
/ TII fL4nws b.ns b la Juv4 ks bLb4 b
k i/s/8 i
/
//
Y Cont =1 logic at te Elenentary/Schr2:ic level has been mi eeed l
for de folicwing systan (s) and ce rective design acticn is recnired fcr ccnicrance wit FrC 'I Bullenin 30-06 cri_ar.a.
Desica chance
~
recuest has been ini_ia-#
-da-74 al" Oecert as indicated belcw.'
mil' - o.
---n Sim :D. & WE FIPCFC c.
- p;sg:;cz MM 1
l l
f I m a a.
a.
, \\.0oi
\\ h
I
- e.. w wv.
- s...:.c :4 ----.~t
- n,,:
.V
. s Cen.rcl icgic at 9.e F.ir.enrf/Ed.r2 ic level has beer. reviewed for the felicwine sv.sa (s), rd is fee.d.c be in cenfomance with 1E E Bulletin 80-06 ri eria:
?EVG3'ER SYSSM 10. & 33EE
!GF?rm
~.
f Cent:cl icgic at.he F.lemencary/ Sche::stic level has been.=_viesed fer the fellcwing sysm (s) rd c=rreceive design accicn is req & ed fer c=nfer: nance wi-h NPC 2 Bullecin 50-06 crir_a. Cesign d.ange rect:est has been initiated = der Field Paperc as i.dicate ' elcw.
c
- D
?rrh SM4 :T
'J_E
.EPCR" 10.
!G;Erm D
J b\\
O a
,M a
4 l
.0_.,.:
- e f e.r s... r v -.--..
level has been raviseed Cont:01 logic a: d e El c.enta:f/Schra_i:
'.e
_4.
~~~._#
.=.ce.".._5 '. T
_v.-
'.e.'o1 W..3 s,rs-,.en (s), and is
~
u
,~
T;. Sulletin 30-06 cri'sria:
.SIINER SYS'ZE'410. & SWE lW!E/DE E-d o de $rw
/1
,1 o w. w-$
r.- n/a..:J i
/ 6,2/
v
/
V Cent ol logic at de Elrentarf/Schratic level has been revieaed
.e.e,_1 W_.3 s:s m. (s)
=A
~-
e_'ve _ des _4
.=.c __4... _4 - er, i -e_
o.
fer ccnfo:..nce wid :iPC II Sulletin 30-06 cri 4 a.
Cesign chance v
..o. r _. _ as
_4..e_4.._=_ s_
.e_u_s.
gc.m..m,_ 3eo_..
_4,4 4 3 a_...a_._
- .4 o, _2
=. a...,
sYsmi :n. & tws
=IPc.c :n.
- wcan I
CD d
l D**D
"]D'3'V'&
o Ju.1.$ b we
P.-..e
.., w....v---.-
. 3 0_., e-Cen=01 logic at de F.lrentary/Schr2_i: le.e'. has bee. = ;iesed for de following sysma (s), and is f:=d c be in 0:nfc=ance wi2 MFC 2 Eulletin 30-06 criteria:
FEVEh9.
IG2E/CAS SYS~Di !D. & GlE
~
id I '1 ?cm el' Ikp: h < i._. r. [
ll i:
,I 1
C ncol logic at de Elex=ary/Scheati: Ir,el has been revisee:1 for de folicwing system (s) and correc ive design ac-4ca. is req & ed for conf =ance with NFC 2 9merin 30-06 cri a-ia.
Desi= dance regm_st has been initiated = der Field Facc= as i.dicated belcw. ~
~
- D
.Wo2.
S'.C4 20. & GIE FEPCP :D.
- G1E/"E e
6 E:-..:
y s -c _:.- - -- _.. 2 0_.s.:
'.evel h's been rer_ seed Cen rol icgi: at d e Elc.en~'.:// Sche a i '
-.._#_-.._'".-a - _ _ '. '. ':'
w,. e.c 11 c,g4 ~. 3 s'f.e. ten. (s). a.ad~ is
_#.t '.d.~^..e.5.
~^-
_w F Sulleti.". 30-06 c-ite.ria:
.T2.2 SYSD1 10. & T-lE G2 E/DA"I W.'2.0 4 go t)Rc Dis I~.
f W A= > v] J
/~/4-8t t
Cent:01 lcgic at de F.le entary/Scheati: level has been rev_a ci vs (s) a.d
__ e 've #es_4.. a
__d a,.. _4s _-
,4-ed e,,.
w. - 3 3,g"_.~,
2 O.a
.Jo",
4.
3,.4 _,
,e5.4 CO 4...
,_o. 4_w \\JiC M, 3L. i _* o_,. 4 a
3
,-o
/.,
.a
. -. -. ~.
_ - - -.. ~e _ _ s,-.4._.A 4. eg e_1, g.
- a g,., 4._.4.,._ sg.~.c,.,. -- 4.1 :
_4.
,.eq es4.
o.,,
-;3 ri 2
. ~ y,f.-,,Lah D.f.'3 A
,1... $ s.4cb
-- n.... s.-.G.
.U
.e e
D " " 10
- lD ~Tlf
~
M e M J]l l
l
wSPC..e m.. e...,.
z-..._..
n-.,e.
. et Q n=01 logic at de Elener.:n. Tcha.2:i: lei.el has bee. rev ued L
for de folicwing sysa (s), and is N.r.d
- be in conic =.r.ce wie ;g IE Eulletin 30-06 rite.ria:
.=.=.~--n.
u SYSTE4 :D. & NJ' E tws/c;s
_[.X E - D te s e\\ 6 e.we,.ab M eo wt NV A-(
% n ith t \\'t \\ Bl I
Control logic at de Elemnta:// Sche. tic level has been revieasd for de fellcwing system (s) and conec-ive design action is re= ired fcr confor.unce with tilt II Sullatir. 50-06 cri_eria.
Cesica d ance recues has been initianad
. der Field Recer as i.dicated belcw. '
- :..u,.
cu S'.~. "Si :D. L liAI2
- == w.e.n-c.
. b.r.
/.we,.
-~r
~-
=*
e l
D TF D
C ]DW N
- A s JLA
~__
~
IRC' gf*#
.pa..r h
'i 1
1 i
.ESTRE 'M }?FC 3Cl.ETIN 8C-06 centrol logic at the Elsentrf/Schmatic level has baen reviewed for the following systen (s), are. is fotrd to be in ccnfor.r.ce with 3GC IE Sulletin 80-06 criteria:
FEV2aB IG14E/" 4 SYSIDi 50. & LNE Y
/ 2./ 4 / -
/55 UE//C hdWS
~,f/
/
r4
/
/
Control logic at the Element rf/ Schematic level has been revieaed for the fellcwing systan (s) and corrective design ac::icn is recuired for cenic=ance with IEC II Bulletin 80-06 criteria.
Design change reg.:est has beer. initiated = der Fiald Faccr: as i.dicated belcw.
zW RE7I5:ER SYSTE4 20. & !WE
.WE 20.
!GI4E/ CAT" s
4 66 l
(
l
ATTACHMENT 4 Remainder of response requested by Mr. Tedesco's Letter of December 12, 1980 to NRC Staff Position itemized as follows:
ITEM #1: The overriding
- of one type of safety actuation signal (e.g.,
particulate radiation) should not cause the blocking of any other type of safety actuation signal (e.g., iodine radiation, reactor pressure) for those valves that have no function other than containment isolation.
ITEM #2: rhysical features (e.g., key lock switches) should be provided to ensure adequate administrative controls.
ITEM #3: A system level annunciation of the overridden status should be provided for every safety system impacted when any override is l
active.
(See R.G. 1.47.)
ITEM #4: The following diverse signals should be provided to initiate isolation of the containment purge / ventilation system:
containment high radiation, safety injection actuation, and containment high pressure (where containment high pressure is not a portion of safety injection actuation).
ITEM #5: The instrumentation systems provided to initiate containment purge ventilation isolation should be designed and qualified to Class IE criteria.
ITEM #6: The overriding or resetting of the ESF actuation signal should not cause any equipment to change position.
REQUEST: Accordingly, you are requested to review your protection system design to determine its degree of conformance to these criteria. You should repo-c the results of your review to us within 60 days of receipt of this letter, describing any departures from the criteria and the corrective actions to be implemented. Design departures for which no corrective action is planned should be justified.
RESPONSE: Systems serving applicable safety functions were reviewed for conformance with the six items contained in the NRC staff position above. The results of this review are documented for each affected system in Attachment 5 including any departures i
from these items and planned corrective actions documented on the referenced Field Reports. A table will be provided showing compliance with items 1 through 3 for all safety systems within sixty days of the date of this letter. The accident parameters, automatic signals from the engineered safety features in item 6 are to be listed in the table to be provided in sixty days for the detailed response to IE Bulletin 80-06 actions referred to in Attachment 1.
The tables to be provided will show that diverse signals in item 4 are provided to initiate isolation of the containment / purge ventilation system. The instrumentation and control systems provided to initiate the ESF in item 5 are designed and t
4 e,,
- ~ - - -
---.,-.-__----~r
ATTACIDENT 5 3910 TO:
Mr. C. R. Hutchinsen FPon:
M. A A < d hs,,
STARIL7 TEST SUPEPNISCR SN: Mditional Pasponse to NPC Bulletin IE 80-06 DATE: 2 / 2- '$ l Itss 1 through 6 under NPC STAFF POSITION, pages 3-4 of at+2c h.t to NBC letter dated 12/12/80 fran Mr. R. L. Teddsco of NBC to Mr. J. P.
McGaughy of MFC have been evaluated as recues+ad and are satis:.M as mdicated belcw for the following system (s) for which I am the assigned responsible Startup Test Supe.m.risor:
All six itms are satisfied without necessity fer design a.
change, for the follcwing system (s):
SYSTE4 MPL/NAME INITIAL /DATE 5Al bet) ft:tssuro 00 rs $3 t au 291HM / /-2 9-d /
i n III /,YatI h'anel!,no d %.% ?!cdGem v4m/ 2 ~2 97
/
m
/
/
/
b.
Field Peport(s) as listed belcw have been (cr are being) issued requesting design change (s) as necessary fcr cc:plete ccnfcmance to the six subject itas, fcr the follcwing system (s):
SYSTEM MPL/NAME FIZID REPORP NO.
INI'"IAL/ TATE
/
/
/
/
/
l h // 7MCd Ne
/ /-2 7-J /
SIG7GL'RE DAT2
t, MEMO 10:
Mr. C. R. Hutchinson FROM:
NN L6(M tb STARICP TEST SUPER'/ISCR SUELTECT: Mditicrul Pesponse to NPC Bulletin IE 80-06 DATE:
2.- 7_- & /
It s s 1 through 6 under NPC STAFF PCSITION, pages 3-4 of attachment to NPC letter dated 12/12/80 fran Mr. R. L. Tedesco of NFC 'A Mr. J. P.
McGauctry of MP&L have been evaluated as requested and are satisfied as indicated below fcr the following system (s) for which I am the assigned.
responsible Startup Test Supervisor:
All six items are satisfied without necessity fcr design a.
change, for the following system (s):
SYS3M MPL/!aME INITIAL /DATE Ekl Co 4UST'IGLs C-45 Ccd C.
4/ M / 2.-2-P /
/
/
/
/
b.
Field Peport(s) as listed below have been (or are being) issued requesting design change (s) as necessar/ fer cc:plete conferunce to the six subject items, fc".c the folicwing system (s):
SYSTE4 MPIADE FIED REPORP NO.
INIT'AL/DATE
/
/
/
/
/
~
2 m
SIGan~RE DATE
MDO 10: Mr. C. R. Hutchinsen d N, LRl4l/Al
^
FPCM:
STNCUP ITST SUPERVISCR 4
SLWIrI: additional Response to NBC Bulletin IE 80-06 DATE:
Items 1 through 6 under NFC S"MF PCSITION, pages 3-4 of attachment
]
to NBC letter dated 12/12/80 f2 cra Mr. R. L. Tedesco of NBC to Mr. J. P.
McGaughy of MP&L have been evaluated as requested and are satisfied as uv tmted-belcw fcr the following system (s) for which I am the assigned a
responsible Startup Test Supe';viscr:
All six iterns are satisfied without necessity for decign a.
change, for the following system (s):
SvSIs4 MPImxE INITIA unnTE C //
.2 Rci c
/)fM 2/s/8/
v i -
/
/
/
4
/
b.
Field Report (s) as listed telcw have been (cr are being) issued requesting design change (s) as necessary fcr emplete ecnfor: nance to the six subject iteras, for the following system (s):
SYSTD4 MPLAGME FIEED REPORT ?O.
I?II"'IAL/DATE
/
4 1
/
4 1
/
/
/
i i
/
SIGGIURE CATE 1
f 5
MEMO 'IO:
Mr. C. R. Hutdinson FPCM:
STARTCP TF.S* SUF JISCR SL%~ECT: Mditicnal Paspense to NBC Bulletin IE 80-06 DATE:
Itecs 1 through 6 under NRC SDFF POSITICN, pages 3-4 of attachment to NRC letter dated 12/12/80 fran Mr. R. L. Tedesco of NRC to Mr. J. P.
McGaughy of MPJ.L have been evaluated as requested and are satisfied as indimted belev for the following system (s) for which I am the assigned respx.sible Startup Test S%M scr:
All six items are satisfied withcut necessity for design a.
change, fer the following systen(s):
SYS S MPL MAME INITIAL /DATE
~2 32 COMTEtt b EMEE. lim l b /I-t9 8i L '2. \\
\\?5 l2.*50 N DC
% / \\ - \\ct-8 \\
M41 Co(TTAINMi$X bt<s 15 / t-%-9
/
/
b.
Field Peper (s) as listed belcw have been (or are being) issued requesting design change (s) as necessary far coplete conformance to the six subject iters, for the folicwing systa:t(s):
SYSTEM MPLMAME FIEID REPCE NO.
INr"IAL/DATE
/
/
/
/
/
=~/
/- 3.4- ?!
PJ
MDO TO:
Mr. C. R. Hutchinson bcco.a ka.s e
FFCM:
STARTLPTEST 'SL7ERVISCR l
SL W : Additional Response to NFC Eulletin IE 80-06 DATE:
Items 1 through 6 under NRC STAFF POSITION,'pages 3-4 of attachment to NBC letter dated 12/12/80 fran Mr. R. L. '1bdesco of NFC to Mr. J. P.
McGaughy of MP&L have been evaluated as requested and are satisfied as indicated belcw for the follcwing system (s) for which I am the assigned responsible Startup Test Su;:entiscr:
a.
All six irms are satisfied without necessity for design change, for the following system (s):
SYSTD4 MPLAGE ETITIAL/DATE O2I b v.d b ec)c h +
m 2.m h[Yb //M MO v
c_,
a
/
/
/
/
b.
Field Peport(s) as listed belcw have been (or are being) issued requesting design change (s) as necessary fcr cc:plete confor:rance to the six subject items, for the follcwing system (s):
SYSTD4 MPL/NAME FIEID REPORT NO.
DTITIAL/DATE
/
/
/
/
/
~
em
(
i
,m
,A u.aG-e
/
/ /2.fc/ O i
(f SIGaIUFEj CATE
ME2iO TO:
Mr. C. R. Hutchinsen
[
FPOM:
/#
STARTCP TEST 5UPERVISOR g
SUB7K. : Additional Response to NRC Bulletin IE 80-06 DME:
Iterrs 1 throuch 6 under NPC STAE7 POSITICN, pages 3-4 of attachment to NBC letter dated 12/12/80 frczn Mr. R. L. Tedesco of NRC *w Mr. J. P.
McGaughy of MP&L have been evaluated u recuested and are satisfied as iMimted belcw fer the folicwing system (s) for which I am the assigned' responsible Startup Test Superiiscr:
All six iteres are satisfied without necessity for design a.
change, for the following systc:n(s):
SYST94 MPL/NAME INITIAL /DM'E
//r-4'l EML 8eL QonM A;--
[W///f//f/
v
/
/
/
/
b.
Field Pepcrt(s) as listed below have been (or are being) issued requesting design change (s) as necessary fcr ccxmlete ecnferrance to the six subject iters, for the following system (s):
SYSTE4 MPLAME F M n REPOPT NO.
INI'JAL/D/L"'E
/ Y~N W 4 [ & J/2 8(/ A d S / W 5
/EUf-M/
W//lLllP/
f
( 8EING-issceo-ner Petsennv hoithew)
/
h
/
/
/
hlU k Y /l3/lW j
< Des SIcum P
MD10 'IO:
Mr. C. R. Hutchinsen FPOM:
/OS Nl,e < m.-
STARTCP TEST SUPERVISOR SUBJE T: Mditicnal Pesponse to NRC Bulletin IE 80-06 DATE:
Iters 1 through 6 under NRC STAFF POSITION, pages 3-4 of attachnent to NPC letter dated 12/12/80 frcm Mr. R. L. Tedesco of NFC to Mr. J. P.
McGaughy of MP&L have been evaluated as regaested and are satisfied as indicated belcw fer the folicwing system (s) for which I am the assigned respcnsible Startup Test Su;erriscr:
All six itars are satisfied without necessity fcr design a.
change, for the following systen(s):
SYSE24 ME INITIAL OME
- // - I C@
J- :fev /. -
mu //-Q?;
WI P1 dhv %,:e < //Jnf~
n.:.:- //- ?- y
/
/
/
s b.
Field Paport(s) as listed below have been (cr are being) issued requesting design change (s) as necessary for ctrplete ccnformance to the six subject iters, for the follcwing system (s):
SYSTE4 MPI/NAME FIEID REPOFT NO.
K as/DATE
/
/
/
/
/
) 71 EJN
/ /~ 9- ?d
~
DATE SIGa"LTE
1 MDO 'IO: Mr. C. R. Hutchi. m FPOM:
L,E,ich w hya,,
^
S" M" TEST SUPER 8/ISOR SE: Mditional Response to ST Bulletin IE 80-06 DAE:
Items 1 through 6 under NT STAFF POSITICN, pages 3-4 cf attac.%ent to ST letter dated 12/12/80 frcra Mr. R. L. Tedesco of NT to.t.
J. P.
McGaughy of MP&L have been evaluated as recuested and are satisfied as i.nMcated telcw for the following system (s) fer which I am the assigned responsible Startup Test Su;xtMscr:
All six items are satisfied without necessity fcr design a.
change, fer the following system (s):
SYSTEM MPLAGME M *IAL/CATE C.-A\\- % d % k%eh Cedtvh
$GE
/ IlQi?lRI 8
U E R ic h 9ve ss: t mQen Sovev Tff
/sl29hi o
/
/
/
b.
Field Pepert(s) as listed telcw have been (or are being) issued requesting design change (s) as necessarf fer ctrplete conformance to the si.x subject items, for the following systa(s):
SYSTEM MPL/NAME D REPORr NO.
MTIAL/ LATE E 51-bedor Ccn hbh:%
E5(- COO [
36E / //294f C.m%g j
/
/
/
+ b ijd4 gww @ hph, tc-u.. d i-
.SMm,
/
- iheh, SIGWILTE d
DATE
.vDO '10:
Mr. C. R. Hutchinson FPOM:
Aldf4 bE STARIt? TEST SUPEEWISOR St.3.TE.T:
Mditicnal Pasponse to tE Bulletin IE 80-06 DAIE:
Items 1 through 6 under NRC STAFF PCSITION, pages 314 of attachment to NPC letter dated 12/12/80 frcra Mr. R. L. Tedesco of NFC to Mr. J. P.
McGaughy of MP&L have been evaluated as requested and are satisfied as indicated belcw for the following system (s) for which I am the assigned-respcnsible Startup Test Super /iscr:
All s2 ites are satisfied withcut necessity for design a.
change, for the follcwing system (s):
SYSTEM MPL/NAME INITIAL /DATE lr.ok7tA'. Asc'sA'caufiks) /4Td3
'))f Y ///>*ik/
u Nu M At A n 2 l x % 2./
~/)!Y /s/L9/?/
/
/
/
/
b.
Field Report (s) as listed helow have been (cr are being) issued requesting design change (s) as necessary for ccmplete confermarce to the si.x subject items, for the following system (s):
SYSTEM MPL/b4E N n REPORr30.
INITIAL / TATE
/
/
/
/
/
^
lD ed' U / Y
(
s m m uas exTE
s i
i MDD 'IO: Mr. C. R. Hutchinson 1
FPCM:
STARIUP TEST SUPTII;'OR SUETEI:T: Additional Response to NRC Bulletin IE 80-06 DATE:
Items 1 through 6 under NRC STAFF POSITION, pages 3-4 cf attachwit to NBC letter dated 12/12/80 frcm Mr. R. L. 'Mdesco of NPC to Mr. J. P.
McGaughy of MP&L have been evaluated as requested and are satisfied as ine'irated below fcr the following system (s) fer which I am the assigned, responsible Startup Test S M scr:
All six items are satisfied without necessity for design a.
change, for the following system (s):
SYSTD4 MPL/NAME INITIAL /DATE 9 l"7 k"ecess b,.vnn a MJ, ecW 4 14 //[w/P/
, d u s O L, hf T)2 l f-5%
m od b
c I
h 2 3 SA R M.L fM <*-no d ke a,, o,m sn hb /obslct
/ /
/
/
b.
Field Pepcrt(s) as listed helcw have been (er ara being) issued requesting design change (s) as necessary fer camlete confcz=ance to the six subject items, for the following system (s):
SYSTD4 MPL/NAME FIEID REPCRT NO.
INTFlL/DA".E
/
/
J
/
/
/
~
l
/
/r Z 2 / bdW p=uaE
/,mTE
O MEO 'IO:
Mr. C. R. Hutchinsen
[M, d. hiMcF FE M:
STARILJ TEST SUPERVISCR
SUBJECT:
Additional Pesponse to h7C Bulletin IE 80-06 DATE:
Items 1 through 6 under NPC STAFF PCSITICN, pages 3-4 of attachnent to NBC letter dated 12/12/80 frcm Mr. R. L. 'Ibdesco of NPC to Mr. J. P.
McGaughy of MP&L have been evaluated as recuested and are satisfied as i:v'imted below fcr the following system (s) for whi.ch I am tM assigned responsible Startup Test Sw/iscr:
All six itars are satisfied without necessity for design a.
change, for the following sys*m(s):
SYSTD4 ML/NAME INITIAL /DATE EE I "L /ded e)w.* 1 A E.~,.,I
[
/ I-p p
/
/
/
/
/
b.
Field Peport(s) as listed below have been (or are being) issued requesting design change (s) as-remssary fcr ccrr.plete confccance to the six subject iters, for the following systen(s):
SYSTD4 MPLAM N REPCRP NO.
INITIAL /DATE s
+
[
/
/
/
P e', L ' ' t.
//*
- SIGATGE CATE
i s
y..
_w_
$33P.Ev 9.T ~ -
- .-s ~.,
MDO IC: Mr. C. R. Hutchinson
' ' ~
- f/ MCI O
FPCM:
STARIt? TEST SL7EWISCR
' Sts: ;dditicnal Fesponse to NBC Bulletin IE 80-06 DATE:
Iterrs 1 through 6 under NBC STAFF PCSITION, pages 3-4 of attachrent to NBC letter dated 12/12/80 frcm Mr. R. L. Tedesco of NBC to Mr. J. P.
McGaughy of MP&L have been evaluated as recuested and are satisfied as indicated belcw for the follwing system (s) for which I am the assigned respcmsible Startup Test Supeniscr:
All six items are satisfied withcut necessity for design a.
change, for the folicwing syste(s):
SYSTD4 MPLAW4E ETITIAL/DATE l2 2]
S/ P u' GO T V G 't V NT.
/ YS*)f) s
/
/
/
/
b.
Field Peport(s) as listed belcw have been (or are being) issued requesting design change (s) as necessary fcr ecnplete confor:rance to the six subject iters, for the following system (s):
MSTE4.6E FIELD BEPORT BO.
Err?2/DATE l
l l
/
/
,. ).W%
/ I O ?\\
v SIGRTL7E
/ CAE_
)
e o
, ~ -.
q
l l
l
's l
l MCO 'IO:
Mr. C. R. Hutchinson FPCM:
STARICP TEST SUPERVISCR i
SUBJTI: Mditional Pesponse to NBC Bulletin IE 80-06 DATE:
Items 1 through 6 tr. der NPC STAFF PCSITION, pages 3-4 of attachnent to NBC letter dated 12/12/80 frm Mr. R. L. Tedesco of NPC +o Mr. J. P.
McGaughy of MP&L have been evaluated as recues*wd and are satisfied as indicated below for the following system (s) for which I am the assigned responsible Startup Test Superviscr:
All six ites are satisfied without necessity for design a.
change, for the folicwing systera(s):
SYSTD4 MPLMOE E N ATE O W n
/),m uei/ Ga4+u M k iohelec
/PF3 Ell shun J /<-
ph i //r W
/f?/
/dI'S H$e-l b/P/
/
/
b.
Field Pepcrt(s) as 1.:.sted belcw have been (or are being) issued requesting design change (s) as necessarf fcr emplete ccnfer:ance to the six subject ites, for the folicwing system (s):
SYSTD4 MPL/NAME E REPCRT NO.
DTITIAL/CATE
/
/
/
/
/
/
SIQJCL7E CATE
-. f u....
i91-3h2*.v
=rer..
- s..: N '
yao n): M:. C. R. Hutch.L.sen f/ N[
O FPCM:
ST;an,7 TEST S'cPEWISCR SN: ; ditional Fespense to NBC Bulletin IE 80-06 CATE:
Items 1 through 6 under NBC STAFF PCSITICN, pages 3-4 of attachment to NBC letter dated 12/12/80 frcm Mr. R. L. Tedesco cf NRC to Mr. J. P.
McGaugny of MP&L have been evaluated as recuested and are satisfied as indicated belcw for the follcwing system (s) for which I am the assigned respcnsible Startup Test Suremtiscr:
All six iters are satisfied withcut necessity fer design a.
change, fcr the follcwing systents):
SYSTEM MPLAGbE UNTE l 2. ~7 '~)
S P P e-60
[V 6R
\\/NT-ll
[]
/
/
/
/
b.
Field Peport(s) as listed helcw have been (or are being) issued requesting design change (s) as necessary fer canclete cen:cmance to the six subject iters, for the follcwing system (s):
g 3733, e q N REPORT NO.
INI"TJ1/DATE l
/
l l
/
l l.
/ I O ?)
v SIGGTURE
/ CAC
)
s
. M TO:
Mr. C. R. Hutchi:tsen FPCM:
STARrUP TEST SUPERVISCR SLWEC": Mditional Pesponse to NRC Bulletin IE 80-06 DATE:
Items 1 thrcugh 6 under NRO STAFF PCSITION, pages 3-4 of attac.%2nt to NFC letter dated 12/12/80 frun Mr. R. L. Tedesco of NBC to Mr. J. P.
M::Gaughy of MP&L have been evaluated as requested and are satisfied as indicated below fer tre following system (s) for which I am the assigned responsible Startup Test Superviscr:
All six items are satisfied without necessity for design a.
change, for the foll:: wing system (s):
SYSiri MPLAmME INITIAL /DATE
\\
[
/
x
/
/
\\~.
/
~
x,
/
/
b.
Field Peport(s) as listed belcw have been (or are being) issued requesting design change (s) as necessary fcr cc:plete confc:rance to the six subject items, for the following system (s):
SYSTD4 MPLARME FID REPCRT NO.
DTITIAL/ TATE l$l lMf( $ l;r W i < :- ;~) '
ll
,'L
/
/ ~
/
/
7.?
._ /
SIGaIL7E DATE
1 O
.vDO 10: Mr. C. R. Hutchinsen J, N. IM / AI 7pon.
STARTUP TEST SUPERVISCR SUBJTI: ;dditional Response to NBC Bulletin IE 80-06 DpCE:
SIAM 8I Iters 1 through 6 under NBC SIAFF PCSITION, pages 3-4 cf attachment to NPC letter dated 12/12/80 frcm Mr. R. L. Tedesco of NPC to Mr. J. P.
McGaughy of MP&L have been evaluated as requested and are satisfied as iMimted below fcr the follcwing system (s) for which I a:n the assigned aspansible Startup Test Super /iscr:
All six itses are satisfied without necessity fer design a.
change, for the folicwing systen(s):
SYS'ID4 MPLAGRE INITIAL /DATE C51 A3Earasa,wea coeid e SM / EN 8'
/
/
\\
/
/
b.
Field Report (s) as listed belcw have been (cr are being) issued requesting design change (s) as necessary fcr emplete confer:rance to the mix subject items, for the following system (s):
SYSTE4. 6 v.E FIED REPCRr NO.
INIT M7TE
/
/
\\
/
N
/
~
/
'] // d h h
/ Sd'Ad 3 I g
sic:GcCRE CATE
MDO 'IO:
Mr. C. R. Hutchinsen f f6f d d,[
M t:
SERIG TFSr SUFCVIISCR SLL M : Miiticnal Respense to NBC Bulletin IE 80-06 DL"E:
Items 1 thrcugh 6 under !E SDFF PCSITICN, pages 3-4 cf attac.ht to ? E letter dated 12/12/80 from Mr. R. L. Tedesco of STC to Mr. J. P.
M::Gaugtr/ cf MP&L have been evaluated as requested and are satisfied as indicated below fer the folicwing system (s) for which I am the assigned respT.sible Startup' Test Su;xtrviscr:
a.
All six items are satisfied withcut necessity for design change, for the following sys*m(s):
SYSTD4 MPLAME INI'"IAL/DLE W-1m f.4 9 e tJs4 C GM / l-l q. g r
/
/
l
/
l f
/
l b.
Field Report (s) as listed belcw have been (or are Ming) issued requesting design change (s) as necessary fcr emplete confc=ance to the six subject items, for the following sys*a(s):
SYS~rd MPL M E N REPCRI NO.
INITIAL / TATE
/
/
/
/
S
/
fn l
l ~ l? " Wl m
SmaaE care
MEX) T: Mr. C. R. Hutchinsen LO.N. D enasA\\h FPCM:
STARIL7 TEST SUPERVISCR SUBJH.7: Mditional Response to NPC Sulletin IE 80-06 Io nwo,q \\ \\ S B l DATE:
Iterrs 1 through 6 under NPC STAFF POSITION, pages 3-a of attachmer.t to NBC letter dated 12/12/80 fran.vr. R. L. Tedesco of !GC to Mr. J. P.
McGaughy of MP&L have been evaluated as regmsted and are satisfied as indicated belcw fcr the following system (s) fcr which I am the assigned respcnsible Startup Test Su;:erdscr:
All six iteres are satisfied without necessity for design a.
change, for the following system (s):
M/DE"E SYSTEM MPLAAVE u
[,Q k._
/
q-%
l i P75 - $bA b ;e,\\ C,ewmLu, v
l'OI-Die 5.e\\Ocwm W 3 4.W M.ln4N hoh.- / l-9-h 6E51-C.c Al be % M\\l C.
l,b
/ M-6 t
/
/
b.
Field Report (s) as listed below have been (or are being) issued requesting design change (s) as necessary fcr coplete ecnfer:rance to the six subject iters, for the following system (s):
SYSTS4 MPLAAVE N REPCR" NO.
I:ETM/DA"'E,
/
/
/
i
/
/
I s
tu
/ l-R - E \\
- ~
SIGWIURE DATE i
l
1 I
i l
l l
i l
MDD ':0:
Mr. C. R. Hutchinsen E. L ein o favia FPCM:
i STARIt'P TSST SLTENISOR l
SL"dTET: Mditicral Response to 57C Bulletin IE 80-06 I
l STE: I /7 TI Ites 1 through 6 under NRC STPFI PCSITION, pages 3-4 cf attachment to NPC letter dated 12/12/80 frcn Mr. R. L. Tedesco of NPC *w Mr. J. P.
i McGaughy of MP&L have been evaluated as recuested and are satisfied as indicated below fer the following system (s) for which I am the assigned j
respansible Startup ' Inst Su;:erviscr:
a.
All six iter:s are satisfied. without necessity fcr design change, for the following system (s):
SYSTD4 MPLAM INITIAL /DATE 1
j
$l 6? Y YT Y/l J $jf f
CT'
/
/
/
/
3 i
j
/
b.
Field Report (s) as listed below have been (cr are being) issued requesting design change (s) as necessary for ccmplete confor:unce to the six subject iteras, fcr the follcwing system (s):
SYSTD4 MPLA&M1E FIEID REPCRT NO.
INIh"'E
/
/
4
/
/
/
~
/
/
l l$
/
' UPET
/ DATE' S
-._ _ -