ML19341A876
| ML19341A876 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Midland |
| Issue date: | 01/27/1981 |
| From: | Bradley Jones NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE LEGAL DIRECTOR (OELD) |
| To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| References | |
| ISSUANCES-OL, ISSUANCES-OM, NUDOCS 8101280593 | |
| Download: ML19341A876 (31) | |
Text
//n/r/
g33 ye 7/ F1 % 3?
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of
)
)
Docket Nos. 50-329-0M CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY
)
50-330-0M
)
Docket Nos. 50-329-OL (Midland Plant, Units I and 2)
)
50-330-OL NRC STAFF'S RESPONSE TO CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY REPLY TO MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER 1
This Response to Consumer Power Company's (Consumers) January 9,1981
" Reply to Motion for Protective Order" is filed in accordance with the Board's January 22, 1981 Order granting the Staff's Motion of January 16, 1981 requesting leave to file the response.
Consumer's alleges that the Staff's motion is defective because specific instnces where the questioning of Mr. Kane was argumentative, abusive, and oppressive were not identified in the Staff's December 4,1980 Motion for Protective Order.
The Staff was not able to provide a catalog of Mr. Zamarin's conduct with respect to Mr. Kane because all the transcripts of the deposition of Mr. Kane were not in the Staff's possession.
Now having all the transcripts, the Staff will provide that catalog in Appendix "A".1/
1/
The Staff will endeavor, however, to point out a few of the more egregious examples of Mr. Zamarin's conduct at this time.
A full catalqg of abuses appears in Appendix A.
In Volume I, page 23 lines 5-25 and page 24, line 4, Mr. Zamarin refused to allow the witness to finish (Concinued) 8101ggo 3
i 1
In a footnote on page 3 of Consumers' Reply they claim that "no mention or hint that Mr. Kane would not be produced for resumption of his deposition" 1/
(Continued) his answer.
Mr. Zamarin repeatedly interrupted Mr. Kene's answers and Mr. Kane had to request to be allowed to finish.
Other examples include, but are not limited to: Volume I, page 45, line 16 and page 61, line 5; Volume III, page 36, lines 14-2f, page 38, lines 9-25, pages 39, lines 2-12.
In Volume II, page 40, lines 4-22, the following exchange occurred between NRC Counsel and Mr. Zamarin.
"Mr. Paton:
I don't think you have to talk in that tone of voice to the witness.
Mr. Zamarin:
I will talk to him any way I want.
I want him to answer my questions.
Mr. Paton:
You are getting pretty hostile this morning and I don't see that there is any need for it.
Mr. Zamarin:
I don't like the witness being flip with me.
I want him to answer my questions.
Mr. Paton:
I believe you are being as flip with him as he is with you.
Mr. Zamarin:
You have to answer my questions that I ask, that is the way it goes.
Mr. Paton:
He is answering your questions fairly, and you don't need to browbeat him or get hostile with him.
Mr. Zamarin:
I will act the way I feel I should act, and it you don't like it take him out of here."
It did eventually become necessary for the Staff to remove the witness.
Another example appears in Volume V on page 204, lines 21-25 and Page 205, lines 1-7.
Mr. Zamarin not only threatens the witness, but admits that was his intention.
The exchange follows:
[Mr. Zamarin] Q.
You'd say it is.
All right.
Well, then, inaybe you had better tell me all about those conversations, what he questioned and what aspects he questioned.
(Continued)
l was made and that " literally out of blue" during the deposition of Mr. Hood counsel was advised Mr. Kane would not be available. These statements in Applicants response are inaccurate and could be misleading.
Immediately after the deposition of Mr. Kane closed on December 3,1980 Mr. Zamarin was in-fomed that there might be sore problem with again making Mr. Kane available.
Therefore, Mr. Zamarir, did have knowledge that Mr. Kane might not be made available for additional questioning.
During the deposition of Darl Hood, which began 45 minutes af ter Mr. Kane's deposition ended on December 3, 1980, Mr. Zamarin was infomed that Mr. Kane would not be made available for further questioning.
It was later decided to make Mr. Kane available 1/
(Continued)
Mr. Paton: Well, I don't know.
Mr. Zamarin: He just said Lyman Heller is responsible for every-thing he does, now.
Mr. Paton:
You say he'd "better" tell you.
He understands the question, but he might possibly not understand the word "better."
It sounds a little threatening.
But, in any event--
Mr. Zamarin: That's the way I meant it.
As a final example in Volume II, page 85, lines 1-7, Mr. Zamarin directly threatens the witness with sanctions if he follows his attorney's advice.
Mr. Zamarin stated:
"You say you refuse to answer the question and your reasons are stated in your advice from Counsel because what I do is I will go in and I will present to the Board my opinion that your refusal is unreasonable and if they sustain me then perhaps we will be able to get wome kind of sanction for that, so if you are going to refuse to answer, say so."
Appendix "A" will provide additional examples of Mr. Zamarin's conduct, which, taken as a whole, amounts to oppressive questioning of the witness entitling the Staff to a Protective Order under 10 CFR 2.740(c).
for one additional hour so that Mr. Zamarin would have an additional oppor-tunity to conclude the deposition of Mr. Kane.
In the same footnote on page three of Consumer's reply it is claimed Consumers's counsel's statement about needing one more hour was made in jest. This interpretation is not shared by NRC personnel that were in attendance.
Both the statement on December 2 and December 3 appeared to be serious estimates to NRC personnel who were present.
On page 4 of its Reply, Consumers stresses the significance of Mr. Kane's role in the Staff's investigation. Mr. Kane is not the only person from whom Consumers can get information on the geotechnical basis for the Staff's position.
In fact Mr. Kane is but one of 5 geotechnical engineers Consumers has deposed.
Consumers claims that Mr. Kane asked for clarification 189 times during his deposition. This may be true, but an examination of those questions reveals that the vast majority were either unclear or ambiguous and needed clarification. Whether this is the result of careless phrasing of questions or a misunderstanding of the technical considerations in geotechnology on the part of Consumers' counsel, Mr. Kane has a right to clarify unanswerable questions.
_2[
The others deposed were: Jane Simpson, Corps of Engineers, Nov. 19, 1980; Lyman Heller, NRC, October 9,1980 and December 5,1980; Hari Singh, Corps of Engineers, December 18 and 19,1980, Jan. 21,1981, Jan. 22,1981; Bill Otto, torps of Engineers, ---------- Jan. 19, 1981 (also Ron Erikson who is a geologist on January 20,1981).
i As for the claim that Mr. Kane gave information beyond what was asked for, an examination of those answers shows he was in almost every instance explaining his answer so Mr. Zamarin could understand it.
The complexities and length of Mr. Zamarin's questions clearly explain the necessity for Mr. Kane to ask for many questions to be repeated.
As for the Consumers' claim that Mr. Zamarin had to repeat the question 559 times to get an answer, this amounts to double bookeeping.
In fact, in their accounting system, Consumers attorneys have counted the clarified questions (189) as repeated questions also.
It should be noted that in the majority of cases where Mr. Kane asked for clarification, the question was changed to clarify it and Mr. Kane promptly answered the question.
In addition, on numerous occasions Mr. Zamarin, apparently not liking or perhaps not understanding Mr. Kane's answer, repeated the question. This repetition is one of the basis for the Staff asking for a Protective Order.
In addition, where the Consumers alleges that many of Mr. Kane's responses were incomplete or unresponsive, it is clearly a matter of interpretation of Mr. Kane's answer.
A reasoned interpretation of the answers reveal that most of Mr. Kane's answers were appropriate to the question asked.
The Staff notes the misleading nature of Consumres' ac ounting method and in Appendix "B" which corresponds to Consumers' Appendices I and II point out specifically the ways in which they are misleading.
The Staff agrees with Consumers' statement that "The objection that an official is too busy to be deposed must be weighed in a balancing test.
[ cite omitted]."
However, Staff's motion is not based solely on Mr. Kane's 3/
Applicant's Reply to Motion for Protective Order, January 9,1981, page 6.
l f schedule, but is based on the abusive conduct described above and in Appen-1 l
dix A to this response.
Even if the Staff's sole reason for asking for the i
l protective order was Mr. Kane's schedule, Consumers has not met the balan-cing test they describe.
They have not alleged that information which Mr. Kane can provide them which would not have been obtained from other sources, in particular Messrs. Otto, Singh, Heller, and Simpson whom Consumers has deposed.
They have failed to demonsteate the prejudice to the Applicant which would tip the balancing test in their favor.
When the weight of Mr. Zamarin's conduct is added to the scale it is clear that the Protective Order should be granted.
II.
Consumers Claim for Costs. Fees, and Expenses The Staf' should not be required to provide costs, fees, and expenses to Consumers if the Protective Order is denied.
Consumers reliance on 28 U.S.C.S. 2412 and Rule 37(a(4) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure is clearly misplaced in this proceeding.
In any event, Rule 37(f) excepts the United States unless otherwise provided by statute. NRC regulation 10 C.F.R. 2.740(c) provides that:
If the motion for a protective order is denied in whole or in part, the presiding officer may, on such terms and con-ditions as are just, order that any party or person provide or permit discovery.
It is not clear this provision provides for the awarding of costs against the Staff.
10 C.F.R. 2.707 provides for sanctions against any party not complying with an Order of the presiding officer.
In the present case no order has been issued by the presiding officer with respect to compelling the deposi; ion of Mr. Kane.
This section would, therefore, be inapplicable and it does not appear 10 C.F.R. 2.740(c) provides for sanctions.
In addi-tion, in order to
l.
recover costs Consumers would have to show that they were entitled to depose Mr. Kane.
Under 10 C.F.R. 2.720(h)(2) Consumers would be entitled as a matter of right to depose only those members of the Staff which have been designated by the Executive Director of Operations.
The executive Director of Operations has not designated Mr. Kane as such a person.
Although 10 C.F.R. 2.720(h)(2) provides that the presiding officer may require a named individual be made available if he has direct personnel knowledge of a material fact not known to witnesses made available, this has not occurred as yet.
Since, as a matter of right, Consumers is not entitled to depose Mr. Kane the awarding of costs would be inappropriate.
Even if such sanctions were available cgainst the Staff, Applicant has clearly failed to demonstrate that such sanctions would be just.
As demon-strated above and in Appendices "A" and "B" the Staff had ample justification for asking for the Protective Order for Mr. Kane.
The length of questioning, method of questioning, and Mr. Zamarin's conduct all lead to the conclusions that not only is the Staff request for a Protective Order justified, but the Protective Order should also be granted.
l
8-CONCLUSION For the above reason the Staff requests that their motion for a Pro ~
tective Order be granted.
In the event that the Order is not granted the Staff maintains that no costs should be awarded against the Staff.
Respectfully submitted.
e Y / t)
~
Bradley'W. Jo Counsel for NRC Staff Dated at Bethesda, Maryland this 27th day of January,1981.
n i
i i
4 APPENDIX "A" Note: Two categories are provided below in support of the Staff's Motion for Protective Order of December 4,1980.
The first category for each volume comprises examples of argumentative or abusive conduct which together constitute the oppressive conduct entitling the Staff to a Protective Order under 10 C.F.R. 2.740(c).
The second category for each volume is repetitive questioning, which not only contribute to oppressiveness, but could also constitute annoyance. A second grounds for issuing the Order under 10 C.F.R. 2.740(c).
Volume I Oppressive Questioning Page Lines Page Lines 23 7-24 Continuing 24 1-4 124 7-21 Repetitive Page Lines Repeated Page Lines 30 17-22 31 13-17 114,115 22-25, 2-4 116,117 16-25, 1-12 123 1-25 124 1-6 134,135 18-25,1-7 137 3-21 O
. Vo]ume II Oppressive Questioning Paae Lines Page Lines 36 4-16 40 2-21 78 14-16 84 21-25 Continuing 85 1-8 160 2-21 161 1-25 One incident 162 1-12
. Repetitive Page Lines Repeated Page Lines 31 11-16 30 18-25 42 7-25 42 6-9 61,62 14-25,1-11 61 2-13 83 6-8 82,83 22-25, 1-4 Volume III 0ppressive Page Lines Page Lines 6
19-25 7
9-25 Continuing 8
1-14 36 10-25 Continuing 37 1-4 s
38 17-27 Continuing 39 1-12
Repetitive Page Lines Repeated Page Lines 24,25 15-18, 1-7 27 7-20 Volume IV Oppressive Questioning
_Page Lines Page Lines Repetitive Page Lines Repeated Page Lines 23,24 21-33, 2-12 24,25 13-22,7-13 113 12-16 113,114,115 18-21,1-22,1-6 162,163 13-22,1-5 163 6-11 Volupe_V Oppressive Questioninq Page Lirms Page Lines 204 17-22 Continuing 205 2-8
.a.
. Regetitive Page Lines Repeated Page Lines 195 17-22 196 1-7 251 7-18 251,252 20-22,1-2 254,255 21-22, 1-7 255,256 21-22-1-9 l
273,274 14-22, 1-7 274,276 8-18,6-18 333 15-19 333 20-22 346 6-9 346 10-14 Volume VI Oppressive Questioning P_aae Lines Page Lines 363 4-10 404 1-15 405 1-2 Repetitiv.e Page Lines Repeated Page Lines 374 11-15 374 16-19 398 3-8 398 13-22 2
e i
APPENDIX B The tables following indicate where the exchanges identified by Consumers as delaying the deposition of Mr. Kane or as indicating Mr. Kane's uncooperativeness do not, in the Staff's view, indicate any uncooperativeness or delay attributable to the Staff or its witness. The fourth and eighth columns are the Staff's responses keyed to the letter codes identified below.
AA - asked and answered - the same question or essentially the same question had previously been asked and Mr. Kane had answered.
AQ - answered question - where Consumers indicates incomplete or rambling answer, in the Staff's interpretation Mr. Kane adequately and properly answered the question.
UQ - unclear question - Mr. Kane asked for clarification of an unclear or ambiguous question.
NR - question not repeated - where Consumers indicates question repeated, question actually clarified or otherwise changed to a different question.
l i
-~
--e
NRC NRC PAGE LINES RESPONSE RESPONSE PAGE LINES
RESPONSE
RESPONSE 4
15 D, clarification UO 4
17 A
NR 5
4-5 D
AQ 5
7 A
AQ 6
3 D, clarification UQ 6
6 A
NR 7
8 D, clarification UQ 7
10 A
NR 8
9-10 D, clarification UO 8
13 A
NR 9
20-22 D, clarification UQ 10 4-6 A
NR 10 16-18 D, clarification UQ 10 20 A
NR 11 14-17 D
11-12 25, 2-7 A
13 7-10 D
13 14-15 8
D AQ 14 10-15 A
AA D
14-15 23-25, 2-3 A 15 20-22 D
AQ 16 5-7 A
AA D
AA 16 12-15 A
AA D
AA 16 19-20 B
AA D
AA 17 7-22 A
AA 20 4-7 D, clarification 20 9, 11 A
20 16-17 D
20 19 A
21 15-16 D, clarification UQ 21 20-21 A
NR 21 15-17 D, incomplete AQ 24 6-13 A
AA 22 11-17 D, clarification AQ 22 22-24 A
NR 26 16-20 D
AQ 27 4-5 A
NR D
27 9-10 B
29 5
D, clarification UQ 29 8-14 A
NR 30 23-25 D, clarification UQ 31 4-5 A
NR 31 7-9 D
AQ 31 13-16 A
AA 33 4-6 D, clarification UQ 33 9-15 A
NR C(16-20)
AQ 37 4-7 D
37 11-12 B
40 18-20 D, clarification UQ 40-41 24-25, 2-4 A NR D, clarification UQ 41 6-10 A
NR 41-2 24-25,2 D
42 6-7 B
43 13-16 D, clarification 43 18 A
D, clarification UQ 43 25 A
NR D
44 3-5 A
D, clarification UQ 44 7-8 A
NR 44 16-20 D, clarification 44 21 A
44 16-20 D, clarification 46 19-21, 24-5 A 45 3-5 D, clarification 45 7, 9 A
D, incomplete AQ 45 12 A
AA 45 22 D, incomplete AQ 45 24 A
46 12 D, clarification UQ 46 14 A
NR D
47 15-16 A
NRC NRC PAGE LINES RESPONSE RESPONSE PAGE ' LINES
RESPONSE
RESPONSE 47 19-22 D
48 2-3 A
49 5-7 D, incomplete 49 11 A
NR D, incomplete 49-50 24-25,2 A
D 50 5-6 B
D, clarification 50 9-13 A
NR D, incomplete 50 20 A
NR 50 22-24 D, incomplete AQ 51 5-9 A
NR D
51 12-13 B
D, incomplete 51-2 24-5, 2-3 A
50 22-24 D, incomplete N
53 18-22 A
AA D
53-4 24-25,2 A
AA 52 15-17 C(18-20)
AQ 53 7-10 D, incomplete 53 12 A
NR 55 5-7 D
55 10-11 B
56 24-25 D
AQ 57 6-8 A
NR 58 13-14 D, clarification 58 18 A
NR 61 19-23 D, clarification 61 25, 2-3 A
63 20-21 D, clarification 63 23,25 A
64 6-9 D
AQ 64 12-13 A
NR 64 18 D, incomplete 65 4
A NR D, incomplete 65 11-13 A
NR 65 22 D, clarification 65 24 A
NR 67 20-23 D, clarification A0 Paton 68 5-8 A
NR 69 9-10 D, clarification UQ 69 12 A
NR 71 5-7 D
71 13-14 B
73-4 25,2 D
74 4-6 B
74 13-14 D, clarification 74 16-18 A
76 8-9 D, clarification A0 76 13, 15 A
76 19-20 B
c (4-8)
A0 78 4-7 0
78 13-14 B
78 21-25 D, Paton objection 79 13-14 A
79 23-24 D, incomplete AQ 80 2-3 A
AA' 80 18-21 0, clarification UQ 80 24-25 A
NR D
81 10-11 B
87 10-14 D, clarification 87 16 A
NR 89 8-10 D, clarification 89 12 A
NR 89 16-17 D, Paton clarification 89 22-23 A
D, clarification' UQ 90 4
A NR 90 19-21 D, incomplete AQ 90-91 25, 2 A
NR 91 4
D, incomplete AQ 91 6
A NR 93 15 D
93 17-18 A
94 16 D, incomplete AQ 95 18 A
fir 94 3-4 D, incomplete A0 96 9
A AA 97 22 D
A0 97 24 A
NR
_E_
1 NRC NRC PAGE LINES RESPONSE RESPONSE PAGE LINES
RESPONSE
RESPONSE 100 4-5 D
UQ 100 8-10 A
100 17-20 D
100 24-25 A
D 101 4-7 A
102 20-23 D, clarification 102 25 A
103 17-20 D
AQ 104 4-5 B
D, Paton objection 104 20-21 A
D, clarification UQ 104-5 24-5, 2-4 A
NR 105 18 C,(20-22)
AQ 106 16-18 D
106-7 25, 2-3 A
107 17-22 D
A0 108 2-3 B
D, clarification 108 8
A 110-11 25,2-6 D, clarification UQ 111 9-10 A
NR 111-12 25, 2 0
112 4-5 B
114 7-15 D
AQ 114 18 A
114 20 D
UQ 114 22-23 A
NR 115 12-13 D
115 16-17 B
115 20-22 D
AQ 116 16-23 A
AA D
117 5-6 A
AA 117 13-18 D
117 21-22 B
118 4-9 A
NR 118 16-17 B
119 4-8 A
AA 117 13-18 D
121 16-20 A
NR 122 8-9 A
119 14-15 D, clarification 119 20, 22 A
123 5-8 D
AQ 123 12,14 15,18 A NR 123 22-25 D
AQ 124 7-12 --
A AA 127 2-6 C(7-18)
A0 130 10-11 D, clarification 130 13-14 A
NR 130 17 A
130 19 A
130 21-23 D
131 6-7 B
131 14-15 B
131 24-25 D, clarification AQ 132 6
A 64 6-9 D, incomplete 134 18-21 A
AA 64 18 D, incomplete 135 8
A AA D, incomplete 135 13 A
NR D, incomplete 137 4-6 A
AA 140 7-8 D, incomplete AQ 140 10 A
NR 141 16-18 D, incomplete AQ 142 2-3 A
D, clarification 142 7, 9-10 A
NR 143 18-20 D, clarification 143 22 A
148 22-24 D, clarification 149 3
A NR 149 6-7 D
149 11-12 A
150 22-23 D, clarification 150 25 A
E
NRC NRC PAGE LINES RESPONSE RESPONSE PAGE LINES
RESPONSE
RESPONSE 3
16-23 D
AQ 4
2-4 A
NR D, incomplete 4
15-18 A
5 16-17 D
AQ 5
19-20 A
D, incomplete 5-6 22, 1 A
NR 6
3-4 D, incomplete A0 7
9 A
NR 8
14-17 C(20-21)
A0 9
15-16 D, clarification UQ 9
18 A
NR 9
21-23 D
AQ 9-10 22, 1-2 A
NR 13 13-16 D, clarification 13-14 18-22,4-6,10A NR 14 20-21 D, clarification UQ 14 23 A
NR 15 3-8 C (15-25,1-3)
AQ 19 12-14 D, incomplete AQ 19 16 A
AA 20 25 D
AQ 21 8-9 A
NR 22 3-5 C(6)
AQ 25 6-8 D
25 18-19 B
26 12-16 D
27 5-6 A
D 27 20-21 A
28 24-25 D
28 7-8 8
NR D
28 12-13 8
30-1 24-25 D
AQ 31 11-12 A
AA 33 9-12 D
33 16-17 B D
35 5-6 B
C (15-19)
AQ 36 4-14 D
36 20-21 B
37 7-10 D, clarification 37 12-13 A
NR 39 24-25 D
UQ 41 2-3 A
42 6-8 D
AQ 42 10 A
AA D
42 13-16 A
NR 43 5-7 D, incomplete 43 8
A NR D
43 12 A
NR D
43 20-23 A
NR 44 15-17 D, clarification UQ 44 20-23 A
NR D, incomplete 44 25 A
NR D, inconplete 45 3
A NR D
45 5-6 A
NR 45 14-18 0
UQ 46 8-17 A
52 10-11 D
UQ 52 13-16 A
54 3-8 D
UQ 55 7-9 A
1 57 8-10 D
57 21-24 A
59 5
D, clarification 59 7-8 A
NR l
D, incomplete 59 13 A
NR 60 9-11 D
AQ 61 14-17 A
AA 63 15-17 D
63 20-21 B
64 8-11 D
64 16-17 B
D, clarification UQ 64 20-22 A
NR l
l 1
1
NRC NRC PAGE LINES RESPONSE RESPONSE PAGE LINES
RESPONSE
RESPONSE 65 8-11 D
65 14-15 B
67 12-14 C(16-17)
AQ 68 21-25 C_(5-8)
AQ 71 17-20 D
71-2 25, 1 B
72 18-19 D, clarification 72-3 24-5, 1 A
73 15-16 D
AQ 73 21-2 A
NR 75 9-10 D
75 13-14 A
77 19-21 D, incomplete UQ 78 8-10 A
NR 80 4-6 D, clarification U0 80 8
A NR 80 21-22 D, incomplete AQ 81 12-14 A
NR 82 22-25 D, clarification 83 3
A D
83 5-8 A
AA D
83 17-18 A
AA D
85 1-12 A
AA 84 21 D
A0 84 23 A
AA D
84-5 25, 1-7 A
AA 85 9-12 D, incomplete AQ 85 16-17 A
NR 85 23-25 D
AQ 85 5-6 A
AA 84 14-16 D
AQ 86 8-10 A
AA 87 23-24 D, incomplete AQ 88 8-9 A
NR 92 17-21 D
92 24-25 B
94 16-17 D, clarification 94 19 A
95 14-18 D, clarification UQ 94 20-21 A
NR 95 23 D, incomplete AQ 96 4-5 A
98 10-19 0
98 23-24 B
D, clarification 99 5-9 A
NR 102-3 23-25,2-5 D AQ 103 13-17 A
NR 105-6 24-25 D
106 6-7 8
105 15-17 D
AQ 106 12-13 A
NR 112 3-4 C(5-9)
AQ 113 15-17 D
AQ 113 21-22 Paton 116 7-9 D
116 13-14 8
116 19-21 D, clarification 116 23 A
D 117 11-13 A
AA 117 24-25,2-4 F 118 8-9 B
120 15-16 D, clarification UQ 120 18 A
NR 121 4-6 D
121 7-8 B
123-4 25,2-3 D
124 5-6 A
129 16-19 D
129 22-23 8
D 130 3
A NR 132 16 D
UQ 132 18 A
NR 139 10-12 C(15-22)
AQ 140 7-11 S
140 15-20 A
141 3-5 C(7-9)
AQ 141 10 D
AQ 141 23-25 A
NR D
142 7-8 A
NR 142 23-25 C(5-9)
AQ
_E 139 10-12 C(15-22)
A0
NRC NRC PAGE LINES RESPONSE RESPONSE PAGE LINES
RESPONSE
RESPONSE 147 17-18 D, clarification UQ 147 20 A
NR 149 14-15 D, incomplete AQ 149 21-23 A
AA 155 16-22 0
156 2-3 8
156-7 23-25,2 D
157 6-7 B
D 157 12-16 A
D, clarification 157 19 A
159-60 24-25 D
160 4, 7-9 A
160 20-23 D
AQ question objected B 164 18-19 D
164 21-22 B
165 9-10 D
AQ 165 21-22 B
166 2-6 D
166 10-11 B
167 9-10 D, clarification U0 167 11-12 A
NR 168 5-6 D, clarification UQ 168 9
A NR 170 9
C(16-18)
AQ 171 7-10 D
AQ 171 15-18 A
171 22-24 C (9-13)
A0 176 9-12 D
AQ 176 17-19 A
NR D
176-7 24-5,2-7 A
179 3-8 D
179 11-12 B
181 6-9 D
A0 181 11 A
NR D
182 19-22 A
AA 182 5
D AQ 182 7
A AA D, clarification 182 9
A AA D, clarification 182 11-14 A
AA 183 9-10 D
183 12-13 B
183 15-16 D, clarification UQ 183 18-19 A
NR 184 8
D, clarification UQ 184 11 A
NR 183-4 25, 1 D
AQ 184 13-15 A
AA 184 18-19 D, clarification UQ 184 23-4 A
NR 184 18-19 D
186 12-14 A
D 186 18-25 A
NR 185 4-6 D
185 10-11 B
D 185 13-19 A
NR D
185 24-5 A
NR 185 4-6 D
187 13 A
NR D, incomplete AQ 187 20-23 A
NR D, clarification 188 2-5 A
NR D, incomplete 188 14-17 A
189 10-11 D, clarification UQ 189 13 A
NR 189 16-21 D
AQ 190 4-5 A
AA 194 16-17 D
A0 194 20-23 A
AA 195 13-15 D, incomplete AQ 195 17 A
NR 196 20-23 D
196-7 25,2-4 B
198 22 D, incomplete AQ 198 24 A
NR 200 5-6 D
200 11-13 B
D, clarification UQ 200 19, 21 A
NR D
201 8-17 A
NR D
202 11-20 A
NR E
D
NRC NRC PAGE LINES RESPONSE RESPONSE PAGE LINES
RESPONSE
RESPONSE 203 20-22 D
203-4 24-25, 2 B
204 20-22 D
204-5 24-25, 2-4 A NR 206-7 25, 1 D, clarification UQ 207 4
A NR 207 6-9 D, clarification 207 12-14 A
VOLUME III 3
14-24 D, clarification 4
4-12 A
NR 4-5 24-5, 2 0
5 8-11 A
6 6-7 D
AQ 6
9 A
AA D
6 17-18 8
8 5-7 D,Paton ob,iection AQ 8
17-18 A
8 20-21 D
8 23-25 6
9 12-15 D, incomplete 9
17-18 A
D, clarification UQ 9
20 A
NR 10 22-24 D, clarification 11 2
A 11 20-21 D, clarification 12 5-6 A
D, clarification 12 7-8 A
NR 16 10 D, clarification UQ 16 12-13 A
NR 17-18 25, 2 C(6-10)
AQ 20 8-10 D
AQ 20 14 A
AA 21 15-17 0
AQ 21 23-25 A
AA 22 E-9 A
NR 22 15-16 D, clarification 22 18 A
22 20-22 D
23 2-3 B
D 23 21-22 B
24 3
D AQ 24 5-8 A
AA 24 15-18 Paton objection 25 12-13 A
D 27 7-10 A
NR 28 2
D AQ 28 4
A AA 28 23 D
A0 28-9 25, 2 A
AA 29-30 25, 2-4 D
30 8-9 8
31 19 D, incomplete A0 32 5-7 A
NR 30-1 24-5, 2 D
AQ 32-3 21-25, 2-7 A NR 35 3-8 D
35 12-13 B
40 18-19 D, clarification UQ 40-1 25, 2 A
NR 411 7-8 D, clarification 41 10 A
41 16-18 D
41 22-23 B
42 5_6 C(10-12)
AQ 42 13-15 D
42 17-19 B
43 8-10 D
43 14-15 B
45 17-19 D, clarification 45 21 A
47-8 25, 2-6 D
AQ 48 8-9 A
AA 49 23 D, clarificaticn UQ 50 2,4 A
NR 51 11-18 D
51 22-23 A
52 22-24 D
53 5-6 A
53 9-12 D
53 16-17 B
54 12-14 D
54 18-19 B
55 25, 2 D
AQ 56 6
A NR D, clarification 56 10-11 A
D, clarification UQ 56 13-14 A
NR
NRC NRC PAGE LINES RESPONSE RESPONSE PAGE LINES
RESPONSE
RESPONSE 57 14 D, clarification 57 16 A
58 5-9 0
58 13-14 B
D 58-9 20-25, 1 A
NR 59 6-7 Paton 59 12-15 D-59 19-23 A
60 21-24 D
61 8-11 A
NR D, clarification UQ 61 14-15 A
NR D
62 6-12 A
NR 63 13-17 D, clarification 63-4 23-25,2-8 A
NR 64 14-17 D
A0 64 22-23 A
AA 66 11-12 D
AQ 66 22-25 A
67 17-19 D
AQ 67 23-24 A
NR 68 7-9 D, clarification 68 12-13 A
NR 70 12-14 D
A0 70 20-22 A
AA 70-71 24-25 0
71 6-7 B
74 7-8 D, clarification UQ 74 10 A
NR 74 13-16 D
AQ 74 20-21 8
75 2-4 0
75 9-14 A
D, clarifica+ ion UQ 75 16 A
NR 76 21-22 0
76 25 A
'77 11-13 D
AQ 77 15-16 A
AA D
AQ 78 6-9 A
AA D
A0 78 11-12 A
AA 78 19-20 0
UQ 78 22 A
NR 79 10-11 D
AQ 79 20-21 8
80 21-24 C(4-9)
AQ 81 10-11 D
AQ 81 17-18 A
AA 82 11-14 D
82 16-17 A
84 6-7 D, clarification UQ 84 10 A
NR 85 14-15 C(16)
AQ 87 4-10 D
87 12 A
87 16-18 D, clarification UQ 87 21-23 A
NR 88 9-10 D, clarification 88 13 A
4
NRC NRC PAGE LINES RESPONSE RESPONSE PAGE LINES
_ RESPONSE
RESPONSE
VOLUME IV 6
8-19 D
6 21 B
7 12-15 0
7 17 A
D A0 7-8 19-22,1-2 A
NR 8
9-10 C
AQ 8
15-18 A
NR D
AQ 8
4-10 Asked Paton 4
14-16 D
9-10 21-22, 1 A
D AQ 10 4
A D
10 6
A NR D
10 8
A NR 11 15-17 D
UQ 11-12 22,1-2 B
NR 13 12-15 D
13 19-20 A
14 5-8 D
14 10-11 B
15 12-13 D
00 15 16-18 A
NR 18 9-15 D
UQ 18-19 22,1-7 A
NR 21 7-8 D
21 10-11 B
21 15-17 D
UQ 22 1-3 A
NR 22 15-18 D
23 17-19 A
NR 23-4 21-2, 1 D
AQ 24 13-17 A
AA D
AQ 25 3-4 A
NR C
AQ 25 8-11 A
AA 27 3-8 C(9-10)
AQ 28 12-15 D
AQ 28 18-20 A
NR 29 16-18 D
UQ 29-30 22, 1-2 A
NR 30 4
A AA 30 6-8 D
UQ 30 11-13 A
NR 21-2 31 2
A AA 31 4-5 D
UQ 31 7
A NR D
UQ 31 9
A NR D
UQ 31 12-13 A
NR 32 12-13 D
UQ 32 15 A
NR 35 8-9 S
AQ 35 11 A
NR 38 12-14 C(39,3-8)
AQ 43 18-20 D
UQ 44 13-14 A
AA 45-6 16-22, 1 S 46 6-10 A
53 13-15 D
A0 53-54 19-22,1-3 A
NR 54 11-14 D
54 16-17 B
D 55 4-5,7-10 A
NR 56 7-8 S
UQ 56 11-12 A
NR 58 3-5 D
AQ 58 11-12 Paton request 61 14 D
AQ 61 18-19,21 A
NR D inc.
62 5-6 A
NR 62 8-9 D.inc.
62 11 A
NR D.inc.
62 15 A
NR D.inc.
62 17 A
NR J
NRC NRC PAGE LINES RESPONSE RESPONSE PAGE LINES
RESPONSE
RESPONSE 62 19-20 D
62-63 22,1-2 A
63 6-9 D
AQ 63 16-17 B
D AQ 64 6
A NR 65 1-4 D
UQ 65 6,10 A
NR 67 18-22 D
UQ 68 4-6 A
NR 69 15-20 D
AQ 70 2-3 A
AA 70 11-18 C
UQ 73-4 21-22,1 D
74 6
A 74 10-12 C
AQ 76 5-6 D
UQ 76 10-13 B
NR 78 8-9 D
AQ 76 16-18 A
NR D
AQ 79 13-15 A
NR D
AQ 79 19-20 A
80 3-4 0
80 7-8 B
D AQ 80 10 A
NR 80 15-20 0
81 3-4 B
D 81 8-9 B
C,0 AQ 82 4-8 A
AA 84 2-4 D
84 7-10 A
86 9-10 D
86 13-14 B
88 5-8 S
UQ 88 12-14 A
NR 97 10-15 D
UQ 97-8 22,1 B
NR 100 11-16 100 20 A
AA 102 4-6 0
UQ 102 10-16 A
NR 104 21-22,1-4 D UQ 105 13-15 A
NR 107 21-22 D
AQ 108 2
A NR 109-10 20-22,1-2 D UQ 110 7-13 A
NR D
UQ 110 16 A
NR 111 9
S UQ 111 11-12 A
NR 111 15-19 D
111-12 22,1 B
D 112 4-5 A
NR 113 18-19 D
AQ 114 1-5 A
AA D
114 8-15 A
AA 115 8-9 D
115 15-16 A
NR 117 16-18 D
UQ 117-8 21-2,1 A
NR D
118 3-5 B
D AQ 118 11-14 A
NR D
AQ 118 16 A
NR D
118 20 A
AA 120 16 C(20-22)
AQ 121 1-3 D
UQ 121 5-6 A
NR 122 9-12 D
AQ 122 20-22 A
AA 124 5-7 D
UQ 124 10 A
NR 125 11-14 D
125 17-18 B
127 4-6 D
127 11-13 A
131 19-20 D
UQ 131 22 A
NR
NRC NRC PAGE LINES RESPONSE RESPONSE PAGE LINES
RESPONSE
RESPONSE 135 2-4 0
UQ 135 7-8 8
14-16,19-21 AS NR l135 136 1-3 A)
NR 137 13-15 D
UQ 137-8 22,1-2 A
NR 138 10-12 D
UQ 138 15-16 A
NR 142 1-4 C(7-8)
AQ 143 6-7 D
AQ 143 10-12 A
NR 145 12-17 D
AQ 146-7 19-22,1 A
147 17-20 D
UQ 148 11-15 A
NR D
AQ 149 5-9 A
D 149 11-12 B
151 18-21 D
AQ 152 2-3 A
NR 152 10-12 D
UQ 152 15-17 A
NR 154 7-13 D
A0 154 19-22 A
NR 155 11-12 D
UQ 155 14-16 A
NR D
UQ 155 19-20 A
NR D
155 22 A
NR D
156-3 A
NR 157 11-14 D
UQ 160 4-8 A
NR D
161 1-6 A
161 15-19 D
UQ 162 4-6,8-10 A
NR 162 13-16 D
AQ 163 7-9 A
AA 163 12-13 D
163 17-18 A
NR 164 18-20 D
UQ 164-65 22,1-2 A
NR 166 14-16 D
166 21-2 A
167 5-8 D
167 10-11 B
167 16-19 D
UQ 167-8 21-2,1-4 A
NR 168 9-13 D
UQ 168 16-18 A
NR 169 17-18 D
UQ 170 2-5 A
NR 170 13 170 15 A
NR 171 2-3 D
UQ 171 6-10 A
NR D
171 15 A
NR-174 7-16 D
UQ 175 3-4 A
NR 175 13-18 D
UQ 176 2-9 B
NR D
176 14-15 A
D 177 8-12,15-16 A NR 18-19 180 16-18 D
D 180 20 A
NR 181 2-3 D
AQ 180 7
A NR 182 4-6 D
182 9-10 A
183 2
0 UQ 182 9-10 A
184 4-5 D
AQ 184 7-8 A
D 184 12-13 A
NR
NRC NRC PAGE LINES RESPONSE RESPONSE PAGE LINES
RESPONSE
RESPONSE 190 20-22 D, clarification UQ 191 3
A NR 194 13-15 D, incomplete AQ 194 17 A
NR 195 17-18 D
AQ 196 1-2 A
AA 196 4-5 A
AA 196 17-19 D, clarification UQ 196-7 22, 1 A
NR 197-8 20-22, 1 D, clarification UQ 198 4-6 A
NR 198 17-19 D
AQ 200-1 22, 1-2 A
D, clarification 201 5
A D, clarification 201 7
A 201 15-17 D
201-2 22,1,6-7 A
202 12 D
202-3 14-22,1-7 A
NR clarification for Paton 203 14-18 A
clarification for Paton 204 3-7 A
D 204 18-20 A
207 5-6 D,incompl ete A0 207 10-11 A
NR 207 19-20 D
AQ 208 4-5 A
AA 209 7-8 D
A0 209 10 A
NR 209 12 D, incomplete AQ 209 15 A
NR 209 17-18 0
209 21-2 A
210 8-9 D, incomplete AQ 210 11 A
NR 213 13 0
213 15 A
D, incomplete AQ 214 1
A AA D, incomplete AQ 214 3
A AA 213 19 D, clarification UQ 213 21 A
NR 214 18-19 D, incomplete AQ 215 3
A NR 215 7
D, incomplete AQ 215 9
A AA 216 21-2 D, clarification UQ 217 2
A NR 218 6-7 D, clarification 218 9
A 220 11-12 D, incomplete AQ 220 14 A
NR D, incomplete AQ 220 16 A
- IR 221 3
D.
AQ 221 5
A 221 20-22 D
222 3-4 A
222 7-9 A
222 12-13 A
NR 222 22 A
NR 223 6-8 D, clarification UQ 223 11-22 A
NR 225 20-22 D, incomplete AQ 225 15-17 A
NR 227 16-18 D, clarification UQ 227 20-22 A
NR D, clarification 228 14-17 A
NR D, clarification UQ 228 19 A
NR D
228-9 22,1-6 A
'f
NRC NRC PAGE LINES RESPONSE RESPONSE PAGE LINES
RESPONSE
RESPONSE 233 12-13 Q
AQ 233 16 A
AA D
233 19-21 A
NR Request by Paton 234 5-6 A
Request by Zamarin 234 17-18 A
235 19-21 D, incomplete 235 1-2 A
236 21-22 D
AQ 236 5-6 A
238 2-3 D
UQ 238 5-6 A
NR D, incomplete 238 10 A
238 15-16 C
238-9 22,1 A
AA 239 4-5 D, clarification U0 239 7
A NR 241 3
D, incomplete AQ 241 5
A NR 246 3-4 D, clarification UQ 246 6-9 A
NR 247 10 D, clarification UQ 247 12 A
NR 247 20 D
248 4-5,7 B
251 7-10 0
AQ 251-2 20-22,1 A
AA 252 15-17 D
252 19-21 3
253-4 21-2,1-4 D 254 6-7 B
254-5 21-2,1-2 D, clarification 255 4
A D
255 8-10 A
NR D
255-6 21-2,1 A
AA D
256 3
A NR D
256 7-8 A
AA 258-9 22,1-2 259 5-6 Paton D
259 11-12 A
NR D, incomplete AQ 259 20 A
NR D
259 60 22,1-5 A
260 10-11 D, incomplete AQ 260-17 A
NR 261 7_10 D
261 13-14 B
D 261 3-4 A
NR 261 9-10 D
262 2-5 A
NR 262 11-13 S
262 15 A
D 262 17-20 A
D 263 5-6 B
D 263 14-19 A
NR D
264 17-19 A
NR D
265 16-19 A
264 11 D
264 13 A
266 16-17 D
AQ 266 21 A
NR D, incomplete AQ 267 6
A NR D, clarification UQ 267 9
A NR 268 5-8 D
268 11-12 B
268 19-21 D
269 2-4 A
269 17-21 D
270 1-2 B
270 18-20 D
270-1 22,1-2 B
271 10-12 C(16-19)
AQ D
271-2 14-22,1-4 A
NR D
274 8-16 A
AA D
275 13-17 A
D 275-6 21-2, 1 B
NR D
276 6-14 A
NR D
276-7 21-2,1-2 A
NR
_E_
i
NRC NRC PAGE LINES RESPONSE RESPONSE PAGE LINES
RESPONSE
RESPONSE 278 4-6 278 11-14 A
NR 279 5-6 D, clarification UQ 279 8-10 A
NR D*
AQ 279 14-15 A
AA 282 8-11 0, clarification UQ 282 13,15 A
NR 282 18-20 D, clarification UQ 282-3 22,1-2 A
NR 283 16 D, incomplete AQ 283 20-21 A
AA 284 4-5 0
284 10-11 B
284 18-20 D, incomplete 284 22 A
D 285 7-10 A
D, incomplete 285 20-22 A
NR D, incomplete 286 5
A AA D, incomplete 286 7-8 A
D, incomplete 287 8-10 A
AA D, incomplete 287 20-21 A
AA 286 14-15 D
286 17-18 B
D, clarification UQ 286 20 A
NR 289 7-8 D, clarification UQ 289 12-16 A
NR 290 18-19 D, incomplete AQ 291 1
A NR 289 7-8 D
UQ 291 5-7 A
D, clarification 293 10-13 A
NR 293-4 21-2,1-5 D A0 294 14-16 A
NR D, clarification UQ 294-5 19-22,1-2 A
NR D, clarification 295 5
A 288 1-2 D, incomplete AQ 295 8
A D
295 11-12 A
NR 288 1-2 298 15-16 A
AA 296 7-8 D, incomplete AQ 296 11-12 A
NR 299 l-3 D
AQ 299 5
A NR 299 19 D, clarification 299 21 A
301 5-8 D, incomplete AQ 302 16-17 A
AA 301 5-8 D, incomplete AQ 304 7-8 A
AA 302 19-20 D, incomplete A0 303 5
A NR 303 11-12 D, incomplete AQ 303 17-20 A
NR 306 1-2 D, clarification UQ 306 4-6 A
NR D, clarification 306 11-13 A
308 6-8 D, clarification UQ 308 11-13 A
NR 309 20-22 D
310 6-10 A
NR D, clarification 310-11 22,1-3 A
NR D (Jones clarif) 311 6-10 A
317 3-6 C (9-12)
A0 317 13-18 D, clarification UQ 317 20-21 A
NR D
318 2
A 319 5-8 D
319 11-14 A
D, clarification UQ 319-20 21-2,1-3 A
NR 6-9 D, clarification 320 14-19 A
AA 322 10-11 D
322 14-16 A
D, clarification 323 2-3 A
322 4
D 323 17-18 A
NR A Repeated Question
NRC NRC PAGE LINES RESPONSE RESPONSE PAGE LINES
RESPONSE
RESPONSE 325 12-13 D, clarification UQ 325-6 15, 17, 20-22, 1 A
NR D
326 15-17 A
327 18-19 D, clarification 328 3-4 A
D, incomplete U0 328 9-11 A
328 14 D, clarification UQ 328 17 A
NR 329 11-12 15-16 D, clarification UQ 328-9 18-20, 3-5, 7-11 A
NR 332 5-8 0
332-3 21-2, 7-2 A
333 15-17 D, incomplete AQ 333 20-21 A
AA 334 8-9 D, incomplete AQ 334 11-13 A
NR 336 5-6 D
336 9-10 A
337 5-6 D, incomplete AQ 337 9
A NR D, incomplete A0 337 16-17 A
NR 338 9-14 D
338 16-17 B
339 18-22 C, D AQ 341 19-22 A
343 8-11 D
343 13-14 B
346 6-7 D
346
~10-11 A
AA 344 7-8 D, incomplete 346 14-16 A
AA 346 18-20 D
AQ 347 4-7 A
AA D
347 9-10 A
AA 348 2-4 D
AQ 348 20-21 B
349 5
D, clarification UQ 349 7
A NR 350 17-18 D
351 1-6 B
D, clarification 351 10-13, 15-19 A
NR C 352 (2-3)
AQ 352 14-17 A
NR 353 10-13 D, clarification UQ 353 17-20 A
NR 354 10-13 D
354 16-17 B
354-5 21-2, 1 D
355 7-0 A
NR D
355 12-13 A
AA D
355 15-17 A
AA 6
NRC NRC PAGE LINES RESPONSE RESPONSE PAGE LINES
RESPONSE
RESPONSE Volume VI 366 8-9 D, clarification UQ 366 12 A
NR D
AQ 367 6-8 A
NR 368-9 20-22 D
UQ 369 5-8 A
NR 369-70 18-22, 1-4 A NR 371 9-11 D
UQ 371 13-15 A
NR D
372 9-13 A
NR 374 11-13 D
AQ 374 16-18 A
AA 374 20-22 D
375-6 21-2, 1-3 A
D 375 6-7 B
D 376-7 19-22, 1-3 B NR D
379 16-18 A
AA D
379 22 A
NR 380 8-11 D
380-1 19-22, 1-3 A D
381 14-15 A
D 381 20-22 A
D 382 7-10 A
D 382 19-21 A
383 12-18 D, clarification UQ 384 2-3 A
385 3-4 D, clarification UQ 385 7-8 A
NR D
AQ 385 12-14 A
NR 385 18-19 D
AQ 385 21-22 A
NR 386 21 C (387 (1-3))
AQ 21-22 A
NR 387 4-5 D
388 20-21 A
390 1-9 C(10-15),D AQ 391 5-6 A
D UQ 391-2 18-22, 1 A
NR D
392 18-20 A
NR D, incomplete 393 18 A
NR D
394 3-10 A
NR 397 14-16 D
398 1-2 B
D 398 13-15 A
AA 401 3-4 D
401 6
A 402 1-2 D, incomplete AQ 402 5
A AA i
)
a a
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COPEISSICd B,EFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of
)
)
CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY
)
Docket Nos. 50-329-0M & OL
)
50-330-0M & OL j
(Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2)
)
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of NRC STAFF'S RESPONSE TO CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY REPLY TO MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER in the above-captioned proceeding have been served on the following by ceposit in the United States mail, first class or, as indicated by an asterisk, through deposit in the Nuclear Regulatory Commission's internal mail system, this 27th day of January,1981.
- Charles Bechhoefer, Esq.
Ms. Mary Sinclair Atomic Safety and Licensing Board 5711 Sumerset Street U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Comission Midland, Michigan 4B640 Washington, D.C.
20555
- Mr. Gustave A. Linenberger Michael I. Miller, Esq.
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Ronald G. Zamarin, Esq.
U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Alan S. Farnell, Esq.
Washington, D.^.
20555 Isham, Lincoln & Beale One First National Plaza Dr. Frederick P. Cowan 42nd Floor 6152 N. Verde Trail Chicago, Illinois 60603 Apt. B-125 Boca Raton, Florida 33433
- Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Frank J. Kelley U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Comission Attorney General of the State Washington, D.C.
20555 of Michigan Steward H. Freeman
- Atomic Safety and Licensing Assistant Attorney General Appeal Board Panel Gregory T. Taylor U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Comission Assistant Attorney General Washington, D.C.
20555 Environmental Protection Division
)
720 Law Building
- Docketing and Service Section Lansing, Michigan 48913 Office of the Secretary U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Comission Myron M. Cherry, Esq.
Washington, D.C.
20555 l
1 IBM Plaza Chicago, Illinois 60611 i
i
J James E. Brunner, Esq.
Consumers Power Company 212 West Michigan Avenue Jackson, Michigan 49201 Ms. Barbara Stamiris 5795 N. River Freeland, Michigan 48623 Mr. Steve Gadler 2120 Carter Avenue St. Paul, Minnesota 55108 Wendell H. Marshall, Vice President Midwest Environmental Protect on i
Associates RFD 10 Midland, Michigan 48640 Ms. Sharon K. Warren 636 Hillcrest Midland, Michigan 48640 BradleyW.Jonef Counsel for NRC B'taff