ML19340D300

Supplemental Response,Submitted to Ferc,On DOJ 800917 Petition to Intervene.Doj Position Is Irrelevant to Approval of Supplemental Offer of Settlement & Should Be Denied W/O Prejudice.Supporting Info & Certificate of Svc Encl

ML19340D300
Person / Time
Site:	South Texas, Comanche Peak
Issue date:	11/25/1980
From:	Stahl D CENTRAL & SOUTH WEST CORP., ISHAM, LINCOLN & BEALE
To:	Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
Shared Package
ML19340D297	List: ML19340D296 ML19340D300
References
EL79-8, NUDOCS 8012300229
Download: ML19340D300 (23)

Text

-

\\ \\ i,. :,

.v..

r.v.

r%

.C. =. n= me.C., Cr

.-s.r %, a w a... s

.r. 4 3 G v.

o r c.: v a* =. m - v. C a.v.v... 3 3. a N erd re...- -s or

.s ws w

v v3 g.y

)

a.,

..i e-wg A.. 4 w.

y

...eoe w,

a...: tvK.3. a..C ma

)

c w

s.,~. w 7 4 s.

w sy w.

w

. CWe..

w w

~y a..v,

)

's C c k e. N. w.

7'. '/. - O

~~~

a C

.C. C "m ".w a. s. e...

T..' e "w.. _'

O o

w Wes:

exas " ilities CC==.anv

)

= %d"b.TJ.

'A".".'=C."=

L.t" mt ".- w.?.*.4 '.'*T. n*

• Q^

m.

9 A n's

• V

.C 'V..S

• T V T S im..*, ' /

F. M.V.T ".4..C m

• U

.i

.C m * *T.C.

9 7 3. A' 7.*..V.i.*.b. T

• 1"' ^ v.0

• V '.' ?.C,

/*,h. *

m. t*7

.'.J 7*. * ".'

• O h. *

^v.7 mUT

-w.

. As.

o.

.w "Y.4..

s V * * *-*%

.n..

..e.. t --s.t*T w w.c a rT T. /*t..

• T n* "V ;

m. a vm; L.7

• r*

Q 9

v w

.' s O C s

.S. e "V -. 4.. =. 4 Q

D.-_.

k.,e.

.'/p c*

3..=. a. s "w y a.-

.e...

a

.y.

rn..s 4..as

.4 _7., A a..4.4,,c......

e,

,., e. ws4.

.r. eave.,.,

.. e...m.e s vi j

.w.

.'if.' s w e. s

^.,

• h e ~' a..d. _4 ^ *,.. w a.- a.

.#.4 ' e d " V, 4.

.w.g..

7. o.., 4_ _4.. e o.

y

.A.

s C "..'. W e s '

w".*.*y =."._ des ( " "~ SW " ) r

'se ".ax=s

...e c. _ ;

3. 7

_w

~

4._.4 4.es w.,4fa".. des, S C"

". ". a X = s

.7..' e c - d.- C *^C -e - = * ' v a. ed v..

c,-

y

'.e

..w.'.d.

"v._3' _4 v,

.v.=d _;.=

_r _' a. "....e - C+

e.=

4 v a.

( ".c..e.c /.ve."w " ),

o w

w

.'... d " ". e D e.*f a _- ~-.e..

7.. e.. ; V.

6,.. 4.e.,.e. 4 *.*. C.# *aXas ( " C f.*C " }

~ "*

w.

_7/

n' - 4..4 s...=. _' v a I, n 3O.r " ).

0.

Oc.*".,e_

a r.' 9 8 0 r -.e

.o - a s.i d.'..~. ~

U

-. _ s L..-4. s.4.

w...e D e 4.

4

. me v.. s

4....

.w4

,a..

e

._444 e 4,.

a w.

w.

n %,., 4i. 33.4, n) 3..

. h e ""*.,". #

h=*. because

(.n a r. r_.%e n w

4 3..

aa.., g 3

..a..

w-a 4,.e aeeK's 4.n*e-i,,eC*.#.".*

....-4..3

.w

.w.

w %.7

.s

=c"we, ha.

3.. a. s.4 d 4.*. c. vudce

_w4.

-,. c.. e _2.,..

~

.. a y,

- le C.a. -ha.

c a.~..i * #_C..

.". a d

.a. '.s.=. ".,

.4

• v.

.C

^

CSW.-asee

..# " '.' v..-a.'.-"es

.a

_3

k. a.

_=_ awa.d

^

s " y.' a..a....

ha.

n'.a.s w e.*.

,..,. k.a.

t a.. d..d. ",.

^#

v' " s

• _d * =. ' k. a.

_4,

-1/

• he Presidinc Judce did no: Consider DOE's answer Cecause t was not time,v. :llec..

8012300 N

.g 24 e we.n

.ha

. g L.e. A. u..n. v gg. 4.e

..g.e, g.4.. g..9 g..4.:.4 gf

~

w a

o

.w.

,cg_4 4.

.w..

_4..4 3. g_4 -

_4

. k.. _Jg

.-,c..A4.,.c,

2.. a y

y a ef y-.

ge-4.-

e...a

.bg s

4 w a

.. _9

.-a..ha.g.4..~;

e

.,.g

_4.m y

7 Oc o e 9..a., 19e0. -/

w h*... 7 m. m ne C.., a v,._4S S.4.m.,

-.9 I

O. owe C-

,a....,

G..

/

w.

93

... C w.,S.

_ _4, w. _43C a m

y o.

s..

• )

1.".d

• .

• X = S U' _#.'.' *.# e 5

( c g w.

m. a. x a 3

0..-,i,, o. r..,

"w. 4. 3 Nc3. 1 no *

-..C 4.

w Gene a._4

,. N a..,

a, 31 (C

.we.ea*X s.,.. a

.= _1 e C.

4.

c

.. ~...

w

..y s. a __* c.., "... 4. a-.' =.. d.' )

t' N. ".- ' e a

'ae :. -' =.. -v.

v..,... _4 C O:- 4 SSion Occke: ScS. 50-495A, 499A, 4 55 A and 44 6 A). )

CS*4 Se. S aA,

. 4..

uw4 w,e.4..ves

.w...a

• . w.e

,C5.4

_4

,,..S. _4

-_S X

.y.

7

.ha - gw..e g. _4.qc,.-... a... e n i,, 43

.-., g a. p 4.,. n, gg 1.m._ 4.: 4. A a

m.

y.

y y

4 8.7 8 *.*.= ". *.-.

^, a f "r.' Va _l s'.','.#

h =.

s' ' * "y y.7 = 7. a.. *..=.'. O.#. #. e v.#

s" e...T e..er...

" u " ~ a. S. S,

• -b. e.'- *..# ^ e,

• ha" *he ecueS*.

C.

c..c g.,.*

• e ". *..#_'.' V, a

. g vy. a "18 v..S

_4 e., 4

. /a.

-D, Ae 4.A. 4 k.C...

w, w.

.'- a..".

W a #

.b..e s~'*.y y. e m a.*..= i C##e' o#.

i

.,.>.;. 4 _4, e

.#.*.S b, e.#.". ';"*

y

.c g.

1. e...

S..... ayy-mym.A wy.w.e c-- J S S.4C,..

o--

(

t

.J..-

C,.,.

e.,.

5 q-.. a. S. 4..,. -.he O_:.:.e

.s se. 7 amen..,

3

.a I

i

.s-g,AeA 4g

o.. 4 4 e.,

.A.m

~.,g g y a g ya.na, 3..g 4 g yy i

1. ^

".1C

• mee ". 'b..e e#

• b. a,.

• .b.e y-**yC S ed ', C ' ".

8.- * *, ". 'l e C *..#C ".. S w,,

i j

l

(

-..w i _4 -.

4,.

eS.. S.,, A.,... A C.: ;"; ::a-b e C,,.,.,S e a 3 1.,..,, 4 VG f-.

1

.n a m e _ v n' C.'.. =.-,, n e *..#.

.S,

a v,

.~~^da.

^#

4.. e.- ~ ~...e r *.*. r.,

".. _= v o.--m-~~~=.=...'..'ve.

.= #..= ~. '_~ ~ e S

_'ack_'.~.c,

. '. ~. DC '.

=..~w~or na._* c r.S f.

and becauSe DC intercennectionS may have anti-competitive

.e 4

e.-

,.,..e c. _4, n S

,a.sem.S nn. a S S,.,,

4

.. A w.4.. u..sC.

s _4n., u i

i l

i

-2/

A Mo icn f0: leave Oc file has been filed with theSe i

Su=. =. lemental Cer=nents.

i f --

3_

WCt.e ee._

o..w5

.. 4

__,y S _4 4.'.=..

b_ e. e #. #. S w "._4.' e o. C S _'..e.

.~

--,"ed,

• h..e e.-,eC Sed DC

. we

._4SkS

.-,... e _

4-.,

a'" S.' C a

,e

.4.n he r.w,4-u __. 4

...eS.

w 4.._.

neC.__4 nS

..C.

e u thCugh SCme C Justice'S CC.:mentS SuggeSt that v.#

.n' e

..,o, C S e c'

.,C

_'...e.-.~ ~ ~.e w,..

e e__4.ye

-..S

-".-.4.-.

4 e

_4.

.4

.S

_ '.. 4. S e ' _# w-"._'

.=.4 v e. S e _' v. a.# # a.r..-..e._4

_4-~..,

s ~ S._4.e

~

e

"..as..Cw a",a.nd

7. a.d.

( _4 #.

3 ev a.-

.h.e.' d )

• k..e C S _4 ~._4

~.'..a*

b.a.

s"C

-. e..e _= _ _4..g x

4.. e.- -.. a.. _' ~ ~.S m a v. k e.=.. _i - ~,~ ~. a,.

_4..d ~. e.

.s. =

r

- a c.

4_4.7-5 0 -..,b.,e.- 2,', 7 0, 8 0

.v 4.

.w.e y. esc

-..e

.3-.

f.

.. a ".S..' ' a.,

e : e _=. a d ' v.

=. d e C _' =,.=..- "h..=.

= c a = - " - --

. a".-.i k =.-*..,

r

_e.......,

... S. 4. =..#Ce5

.= S S e.-.

'.a.

.b..e

~.~~, yC S e d C

_d.~. ~. a.-

.,m... e.. d

. S

3. S S,

w.-....

.3-_4

. 4 S4...

._4 4.C-S.4S. e 4.

w.

ile o..

a.. *' 4 * **",. S *..' a W S,*. '. S * ' e i*,. a.1. V. b a.i.4 a Ve s

• b.a '. #.y.' C.e.*.'.4 7",

m

7. 8

.#C ". i C.

.'w" 4.'1

• E., C * *. * '."'..d '."' ". S w.,C _' #

e. a. S e..*..= Sour.de.-

C ' 4 v,, #..-

'"e

-a

~.#

k.e a.' e._.' -,,Cwe.

.4..d".S..-;

.d.a.

k.e f

e_** S y.

• ."..# */ a.

• b.e

1. .,.l.' C W.4.C.

a.*" a.

3 w g _.w.y g g.

e.

a..'

a..' *.# * *"'.' S

• e 7

3w a

• a. s S e-eES. X

.X

e. f 5

.v

..K

.m

• ^.

ake

..b.e "yCS.4*4 1

".a*. We DC We WC".'.A 4

eC'_#C.,

" V,

.#. *. S e.l..#, 4S a S.#. *.".".* *..#.C n

%.4 w...w.e

.2 4.

,,S.

7aWS.

m.s.4e 4nCC.S4 S.,

9 e y a

• e."..

W'".'.' #

~.1C *..

.he 4.e.Se CCn..d.4.._4C.S 7

m.he S.4 3 n_4 4. 4 3

C e. e.

w4S 4.SSue 4 S

-.a.

_4._ C.S.4

....d

.w e.

,,, S

-,Cm_4 *:Cle.m...., w L. _4 1 4 a.

4..e.S....

4

.e__

.. We ncunu.. %.as

.4.yC

..- n e n. 4.. C,. Ww..e w 3

I l

We

.w 4

,.'g

.wL.

a vg

.4..*.e"

^.nn e '.**.#,.,n a#3 y..

m t

ba.w7y Ce..e

.w.a

.4.e...,eC.4.n.

ge 4

. e - - n.

n e e.4..,

. 4. S.he beS.

. u. 4.,.X a.e.

ev Tha*". ' S an issue We're c. rec.ared to 'itigate l

Cver at ?ERC.

l t

1 W

W W

W t

t

-m--T-'w-

- ~.

A

_4-Che Department believes that the DC inter-

..e

..neC.4.,... _4s 7.e.ee 1h.3 neC 4,.. -.,

w,

..e

.w4.,.k

.w,... w43,-

be

.-...e

_4 n. e _..,,.e c. _4 -,

n pro-ccmpetitive.

Chat will create some o y. c -."._4 ~.4 es #..-

_4...=

a-.a.a.

owe

- ar.s'e-s e.

.w eX.4 s. %e.4c.E.

-.a.,

C_4 2.1

-aa_.

.e es. %.ay

.4O

".a..i s ~."...- t'.g "..

w w

We

.w4..g.

a.. aC

_4.,.

ne..:

.a.

.+e_e 4>

a 2_4 _4_.:e e c.

of opinien, :

seme extent, between the parties as 00 whether AC is better than DC.

a c,..s _4 d a.. 4..

.d a..e 4. 4.~.,

~4 e

".4 = "v e = s k a. d T.

- "w ww...w..

4. ' s

.4

• .ha. -* k.' 4 c 4..

e.- a.e. 4..

as s _4.7c.

e-e

.~ ~. ya-a.

_4 _ w d ~.". an a'C

. 7: c... h a. D"

_,,c, a s a.'

proposal.

~4e haven't said Oc FIRC that we

ppose CC in the sense that we'd rather have no

, i 4.. e..

.e n.

4 4......O.,....4,.

.u.~,_.

,e

.. _. /

a n

e. e.. e b e _'.4 =.v a s.".a'

..he

f..., oc s a d DC 4.~.e.--

_4c.

...._4

.w w.

a..

e

,.,.ee. _4.__4,.e,

a.,. _4,

re 4._4ye,.

_4 s.# *p.' V,

..,.,,., a w o

we _5 _4. y e g. h. a. a ".'

_4*.'~.a.'-'.'.'*...e'.'.*.*._40..

wCC_',#

1. .= ',,*C.. C ^,..*ee "._4

• d e V.e.

Che weakness in ~ustice's position is the erronects s.,

,_4.

.w,.

.n.

u,.. 4...s.

_4 'u e s e=bc.d 4 a.d.i.

he a

-,, w, 4 - 4... a s ' s,.ar.d a- ' ' ' # O t':..',.- = c. "- 4 _ e a s.h o w.d..,, *".a' ~5e f

.,fesed a.e.,,,e. _ef es...s he w,..,._4..e.

so...._4on

___m.he e

eerspective of the antitrust laws.

Indeed, this Commission has d

a.

=d

• ".a a "

ub_'_4.

4... =.~ a.e * " s *.= n d a - d-.an be me. no wd ".s.an -

I 4

a. 4

-~~.+-a.

_4. 4 ve e " # a_c.s, wh e - a. o he-es4*4ve

_4..,,

eva.

s.,..a.

-e i

benefits outweigh these effects.

Re Missouri Power and I.icht Co.,

2 6 PT.*,R 4.h 3 6 5, 371 (FERC 1979); see Ncr hern Natural Gas Co.

v.

??C, 399 F.2d 953, 961 (D.C. Cir. 1968) and cases cited therein.

Since j

4 l

i i

l 1

i.,8.

,X...-.s w.-

.__.a..s w-

_4 p.

/

. a..s c..; f,. a.,, 2 a,s,

..y

' ' ' ' + = *

=

.a

- -,,+, -

_a

..n._e,

_3_

t

.,s 4.e ag ees w.a. a 3

.4

.,e,,.._4.....

w_e__

we

.,_c~

,e.4

4ye,

..e e..e.4 4. s a.,.d s_4.e.w.e -

.4

.e

...,., 4......._4 _* i _ es..

4.n c.w.e w

a sw

.-. ea

.a...' ve a..a' v. s _4 s

..".a. w.d.'.' we

.d.

k.e rub.'_.

4..e.es.,

".a.

which Jus ice seeks would be clearly ina=. =. ro riate.

Where, as he_.e,

., ex..g_4.,e.

_4.,.g..w3e s a.a..

a t,._,

_4.. a.e. e parties in differing circur. stances are involved, no single s o.' u..d a..i s _' _i k e.' v.

s b e.. r..'

a.'

e ve.-v. o, c _d..

.' ~. 4 e w,-

I if an agency were required to apply such a standard, the a d d.a.' s...*..' v e

- o. e s s w - "..' d "e

,=__=_'v.

e 2 "., _c 'a sk..u 4 f

+

..k. e _- =_ _3.- a. ' e

.4.. e.-

- =.. a d a s.- a. r.,. " _3 _ _4..

.,. a. e s.a.' "..d...

'. a.

would be the "best" frem any one perspective, but a resclusion

. ".a. w-"._' '. 'e ". c ad ' v. a. e,..=.".'a.

arub.'.4 4...=.. e s.

v.' ewoo d..

ar.d e "_d.a

'a k.a a - _ _de. s

_4.. ~..~..' v e d.

x.

• • suas.iva..= ". k.o _ _i _ v.

".. =. wa..i

."._4.. c.=. ~. 4

~ ~.., e '..' *._* v a_

on e_-.s "nd.e.

a,ub.'_'

.d...=. es. s..=n a_' d.oes.nc..ec."d e

d

".a. a ",.,ased. s e. ~..' e m e... e b o d v. _ =.. - -._d a _'

e s.' " '..d -. c.'.

-e

.'. s.w. " a. s c e s --.n ~.e - a.... e

".e Da,ar me.. c'

1. -~

g _.-

r_

,4. _ %. 4.i

...,. ;. 4.m 4

.,nse 4..A e.s

.4.,.

v., s. 4 e

.4. s e. _ 4 7

a.. a._d. --.s. a -..d..s

.=..d

~. ".. =. c '

..ha.

.- u_-.s _.. ae r. ~. 4.. c. s uc.h.

dudgments.

Section 5(e) of the Clav. ton Act, as amended bv.

s

...e r_._4._._

s P_,ce4.._. es

.,,d e._,_4.e.. _es a.

9 e *.,, s-

,, e w

U.S.C.

516, g ss Dnited States District Courts an independent duty :: determine that any consent judgment p cposed by Justice is in the ublic interest.

In applv.in1 this standard the dis rict courts have held that they need not determine whether the proposed settlement is the best settlement pcs s _3 ".' e e.".-. e aer-v_d.le, x

4^

.e w

• S e ^ '.'.' *.*.'..d5 S *.* '., 4, e '.* *.,

'w'..d '.". e d 3 *.* a,. a S V.

3 1 = a #.'..*.

(a.

.v.a S S. '.c /.:, ), a uS..i.e

.- a, c S e d 3syy.

"t..'a:

u.4.*.*.. e,

w" O d,,,

o a

a y

a

. 58.

4..

.. 4

.*.w 4

.w. 4.

ha4 S S.. ? e A.

.e.m

.i e S S

.w.a a.i.t

.. d

'.e.de".-ae was

.w..e

.- a.'.4. e.# asked #..-

4..

5

.-*y'.'....,

.w-.e

,ag..-

s.

A o..y

.g

.. eseC wy a 4..

e..m.

C m en.4 ng m

-- s wry w.

SS.,

. 4. S e.i..e ha.

w.e Se 1e e 4.5 4

.w.e

., k.1 4,. 4

.e

.S.,

y-w, A g,

n.1 A 4..w.

s a.4.a.

w..

nogg t S

.A...y e.,

A...

. qe yk...hg s....

. h. 4 S

4. S. k.. w,e S

%C S S.4 w i. S.. 9 o.m e.

.w 3.

,.C,.,1 A w

y w

b d

4..#, S av,,

• b.e

'""w* V e."...~ e *. *. h a d

.. ave, e e.".

• "., *." a.d.7 e w k.. 4..e A a

.94 1

ha A-e

...e C o,.

45 o.m.

mw w-

.e. e *... 4.7 C, b.e Case.

~. '.".i s # e.a." *.*..#.7 "; w.h.e

'*.e **

3w

. t.4.w 4.

.he e.h.S

.e u

..4 eve 4 4S

• n e 5 8.

1....E...

w.

o

g. fu3.14, 4.

. e.- a. S *..

".d a S.#.* a.'.' V.

"S.

.' '."$0 k E ".

k.g yg.s.9.i

.4.... g. -.

%..yyg.

4.

4 g.9.i..,

.w.

y.. w.

.w.

y.4 * %.

$.4

. geog g,

% g *. y.a.w g

g

4. $. f g

. A ge..s.q q

.o w y

c. lass.

s O C'.?. 3 '.y y'. a.

"t '.

C -

.ie....dn e,

.#..- '. e. c a..

'- k. a.

.'... a.. v e.

• w. ' S a

,:. %.. 5e 9

..., s,A 6

A4 S$a :.,,

4

.4w w.

.e S

..s....

4.

A., a.

4..u.

S a.d a..

l l

c -

,, S 2.

., w..

..S.

. e 4 e

._s.a l

s.ic. a de#endant do everv.: hine. that oe. cSe:S ma.v wiSh.

G.4.'.' e..a ca.u.' d a.' w a v. S da.- m. e. _4.7 c. ~ ~ ~. a..

a'

-w ceint, however, comeS where an agreement ceases

~. ~.,.me.=. comf. - Se.

m..be.,,,,.. e e.n,e a

. v.A

.n.

Se.

,e.,,.e

., s.4n44 n

.n a..

.A

.o..w

. ~ ~ y - ~~. ' S e

.#.-. r

k. a. " a' e f.- =. S e... de c.- a. a..' -.=. Sa #

S. a -. *.. v.

,w.

s 14 e.4,

a.,. A

_4 4

. k..

,, b.'.4,

4.

. 85 n.

.%.e a.

nA,C.4.

C.

a y,

w

.wy 906

?.3'.y

. a

'/ ' s.

J.' d ; e n'.' d -.' -5. ' a-

. e a S w-..* -'.g wa S

"- ~.e d 8

w y

.a..1 weA 4 79 4..eA.c.a.e5 v.

U.. a. _4 m. a.1

.3 e a A m m S._s.e.e Cw.

ae.A m*

..w e4o e.Suy..'.n /. t, (c.p.

r.

i.g e.

1.,a / g ')

m,....a

4.. gr.4 eA 3.a.e5

~

y t

l

=.13 ggy.ie g..

ta.

439

?.

D,o. -. 1.*).* 3,. 2.a'.')

(N. D.

a e

t s

ow.y ry v.

.w

..wyu j

1 l

.i 9 a o. ).

N.v..

i l

l l

jW

-.2

.~ n g. 4 n g

_4 5 q _1.s 4.

43 w.g

-.gn 4n.g v....wg.

n.

g, 7

.e.gfe 5e g.A A..

• m.y oe.i 4

4.

n 4..*.

."l e C,, w* *.*.* a *.".4.". ";

3.4 A g

• w

.e aC.

4.

e 5

• s a

.w

. ( w-i

.s.o. 4... S.

..Se

...A.

e S.

me. 4 3..

w S.4 e, we

.Se 4..-

a

,. Se.

4..A.;

e.

,. e w.eS...4.,.

w

.n y.

. ya. c....*.oe

.n

( n C..c a )

4

.w6

-.. w i _. S.w.

2 wa e.4.

4./..

e....,

-4 f-.

w my vo -.

.'... #.#

• a *.' a * '. a *. ** b. e

." e ";..

..#. * . S

.v. A e.*." a.' A e "y*.4.*. *. *.**.

n' "y.'..#

• a b.'.

• y C"d; e ".. w' # " h e w* *.C..' S "**

• X.' a.d ".

W..";

• ha. "f.-yCSe# 4 " #

m *..*.

• h s,

y 4.

. 4

. e '~* **. # * **

• b.a.

• • #.*" "*. *_*"' S ~. a.*. *. *. S a.*. #

W..";

. ' ~. _#5

. '. ".

• b. e b

a yy.y....

f w14 4

.e

.S.=.

n 4.._

D.4.. 4. _ S.4C M a.. a.i.,

e.w.a e

v.

a f.

'V-6 4.

e

,S

,4 4.

e 3.__,,

a

.i a.s..a 4..C..w.

_34

..w.. Los..

.*. * . 5. d. e.** * # D,V w' "w S *..d

• e.

4

-.. e...= ~.# V

• S * '. '. '. ', " '.e

• • • "w**'*, S a.' a * *..E.'.' V.

3 f.

y

.e 7.AS 1.1 4..

w TX3 4 la.J. e.#

F.

< e. 4 4 g/ e

• a,

s'*

.. e.v e. S

.i..

v..,

.y w w..S.# #. *.* e # bV.

a.' *. *. _"*. a * # V8

^#***

A e ";.' S *. *.* 4.*.# # * * *

• a~

• b..."*.

• ^*

w..g

*e d ~ " ".

• e X "y e "' S e

1. *.'." V.

" ". * *. '.#

• d "; a *..# *

• WC" _' ~#.

a w..

a,.

s.3..... _4S S... A 4

..,.4..

k.e.

-o.

4

_4./..

e y

y r9,

.,. X 3.a A r,.

N.. n.

...w

+.

_4. e A :,

,..S

..,.4

• 11 e.v C.

t.

r.=.c. o "e ),

.L3 or.7,3,

w1.,S 4.e S..., eC.

4.

.w.

%_.4.o. c,,

,.g. ; g. 4..m. 4 a.'.S, " h e D *."y a.** C a.*.*.

C.#

w "wS ~ d.* e

~

-i

"..aV e

• .h e w#

• C *. *.* a *y *y _' V, gb e.dw.g. A. 43 a.34a***

... a..

e a.1.1

,.duc.

4nes

%e,....Se e.n'e Aee. A.E

.S w.

y

'.a*

e.

4.*. a

., y, 3.4. 4

, " e " ' " S e ' 4

'a ; a *_d..q

• " ".' S y.

• * ". y w* ** R *. *. # e.# e.'"1dC.*S

,

• S e.'.*. V ".' V.#..*1 C.

• W a.*.*. V,, ~ ~ W C

.w.

...S*w***a*e*.*.*.*.'"'.'.'"'#

".".e

• s e *y a *"* 3 8..* ' S. e S C'* *** e 5,

WC"'#

w.

".e a"Se

• b.e y C S S _' ' _d _' d. ~r

".a*.

.he CC"**. Wa"'#

nC: Crder t.his re2.ie# even i#

he GCvernment

.,E.4 eA

4.. a

_4.,.,., 1A be a,Se Ae.s.e 4a 3

y.

w y,C S.4.* * * *. *

• a.* *3'*"- _# _* * -

g3 g.AM e d

".."4e.d.*.

4..*..# * # l '

• ".".4 * #.*1 q 4*

t. e..' *

"".a *. ECy.' C V e

• S " " S *.

C, C '" *.

=. -

~.

4

. 4 n.g 4.6.g y. u.

n.hg 2.24gg g

.e..

.4g a

f.

4.,.t 4 _4 a..

a..:a,,

S.

3

@g

.2i.'.

.e 4. 4.i 1..

4

. b. g [

. 4 = 4.y e.

,a

.e q. *,Q.R*/.

, *. 1 o **

• • C) a n

r w -. ;..,

f...

.. -; r

.. g,. g 3.. g,.,g 4g3u.A--

.4 e,

4.

. 4.w i.t 4

. A

.c.

.eS "..

y..

a.

w S 4.. S.a.eA C.a S ( w. %,. C,.9 4 e...4. 4.- N..,.

-. _ :: a c.

%.%),

is...

,.a S n.

S.4 A. a..,. a A aS

.... k.a me 4..

~

2.

11

.4...a.1 n

.2 2 7. e.. 4./ e ~.~ 2 e...' 8 m*....

=..~wWe ve., beC="Se

~

. e.".# * # ***'w'. 'e S'*bS *.*.* **. *.* # a.'.' V,

. e.=..,.. #

.w a.

e c.' ' 'v a.' e.**. *. *." ^*b. a *. S * g.b.. 4.**. *"b.e"'~.~*y.'.*.'...,

ke,'a..'S e S.4 4._: _

w w

1. 4,. :

..14 se ~me

.a_'.'e

. aw m w

..'ve c.. e....-v.

b.e ; "d e..., a r. d # 4.. a.'.' ";

becauSe appeals #011cwing a trial cou'!.d delay

.wg

w.,4

'..c.

e.#.#

• c 4 ~. e.- =.'.i e.' # c a e e..' - d

~., # v a. a. S,

b. e.=..'. a. -..a.4 v a.

e.'

.' a.'....

..b.e

m. e_.d ~ 5 waS.- a. d a...- a. d.

7 80).

-.2,.,...s.

(.y a y

,e,,

.2 m

....,.gg.:...,

-. a.

w' w S..d

• , a5.=.

ww.,,.

4 S e *.k.i.1c.

.'. r S e S...d..e.

S..=..a..d a. ' S 4-4

.. yer.,. w..e

a.,

2 w

b. e.=.,f. ~ v a w.' a Se...'eme.n. ur.de.-

b.e =. d...S.

' ~

c

o. c.e...

c.'

b.*.

~ ~ " ' _'.-.'...=..-=S.

S~.a..'.a. ' ~..' =. ~=..= a'

• .a n.' S ' ~c,oSe? c.

f

..n e

.h.e L.wi.4.,.

,., Se 4.4..;

.S 4.

e.4... ?

. J... n S.,.a5eS A

f v..

4

.e mS. S. 3 m. A 3. A

e. 4. k. a.

n 4.

.S.

Q..p o.A... o, S aA 5 p., a.1 4..e5 A _4.

a.

, A ~4 n.;

4g n,,a..

...4..

c.e c.n e.g.4 4 g 4 n.;.k. e

~.A 4g n

s.

a.,

2.

f...,.

4.SyS a A.

w L.. A...,

C. :

4.u.A. 7._4.4..

4.

S a :a..

y...

e n g. 4 e y.4.,. g

.3 g g.. ? * ~ e...

".'.'..d S

~1

• a*.#. "b. S =..d 4...c,

• .e

• bv.4. CMS s

.Ege.

. k.g.,. i p.m e g g g.

c=.. e

_# * # */ e.'.*.".*f a. a. e 'f' a. am '

4.4

.f i n A.4.,

.s.i a. ' *.".-*.*. S. -

• C a *.d..d.1 S,

W.b..d.'. e " b.e V. a.- * ^..' v.

e..* T, he.*a.'

7 y

f 4..e.. n

. a e 4,.

s* -,.,C e o A 4 n e... A e

3. T.*t. 3 '.

4 2

is.

n

.w y.

.he a a?,gy we Se 1e.e.

.,eC..

SS 4

,. 4.T 4.1 y...

a 4

,S.

S. 4., S WO L.1,.4

3..ea

.C 5%. e3

.y.,.-

1".S.*~~.S y

w..

yy

. C.' *.

^#

.??Y.

s" a.#.#.

a.w.,.,.... ".e

*"

• S e.~. ~ p.*. 0 e *.d #. C,.

.T.'. S *,

"."b.*.

w.

f..

4 e

.Se 1 4.._,S..... -. S. 4.

.w.a m e i.s L, S 4

.5 a

a.i.

g,% S ne 4

w.

w

.u.e C.9 4...4,S C.

.vi qo~ s.g.22 43 n.w.g3 n eA a.

g n_a.n s

an.

f

_g_

~. 4... g.

.n cne.

.w.a.

,n..z,

g..A.

$ ~.g.a.:.

"L :. 3,

4 C9.2_4 u.a s....

.a

..y

_4 s.. 4. _1 e s a._44 ae_4

• e 'v'*. *.".# =~..d ** ~

a.*. d s "s "y *y c *". _4.*.~, a a

.y y

s e *. *.' e'e.". *."

• b.a

• _d.

b, e _'.i. eve s *"* *y.*" a s e.". *.".S a.*.

C V a. a. '

• C. " 4

• a.b _i e

. e s _,.. 4

.n.,.

a a

-M. a X. aA n

ac.a; d.t a u..,

0e

,A,

.ne y..

, -y g

' a.

a 4.

E..,.1CgCLs..

s.n'a.

se.

o u.e

.e ke.= ~ e s s _4 n.

r n

a

• ' s.. _' -. C,* ur *. _4.. a.. =...' *.-" s *. s " _4

,- bc *b. b. ave ar. _4.*.deye.nde.*.

s

.a... y 3 a33n.. b e.' s e _' "< a s ~'*..= *.

• b.a.

s e *" *. ' e2'...* ". *.

.d s

_#.*. *he 4..

a - "y * *a V e

". ". e ". a *.

• _# * *~ C.#

uk _5_4 4...3

-D e.

4.e"." a v, y.

y y

e a

,y 4.A e *.,.,

n' o O. 4y a..

e e A, a.7

,... _.. s s..,.. _* A w e

u

.w yy.

s *.*.a..# = **.#

b.. a.** *.

• e v~.* *'..' # s s # ^ *'. s b.'.".,' ' '..' #

".')**.

D e

.**e*" _i _**a_ #

3

• *"a. "yOsed s e *."*..' p e*'.* *. _is "b.e b e s *. 'h a *."

1. e.e " #. e wh.a.*.*.b.a*" ***

7 s

7

,,. 1.A.

w...e be a.**.

a'.'"._# a,. v a d,

b'*.*.

W.h.e

• ha..**, _i a O k _i.7 y' a*. 'he CVE.a.

l

_4,.....,

.h. a s e *. *..'. a. *. *. **. *.

_d s W.' *.*.b. d ** ** h a.

• • e a "b. e s c.#

" h e *y'u b.'.d

• y

_4 e.-as*. a.7-wh a

".a.**

_4.

.# 3 e C." _* *..= h.' a.

~. '. ' e.*.*.~ " h a. ****Csed y.,y C J.e A4 w4 3 g _4c,.

_4 g cg o '. g... h. a g

m..y g - g.. a. u.p. n s.

u. 4 3 y..

i

. _= 3

.d

.-.=.' o s *. s e v e.a.

.v e a. s, _=.n.d

.'.a.= a... c, a e d *he a-__4e s

.4..

l

~a y

l 4/

l a.3.. s..-,,

._4

.,.,u s _ _4. 4 s, _4, n s.4.,.c e

h., _..

.s._4 s C, 4 ss_4.

as well as at other federal and state regulatory agencies

...g s

,*e

~~.,~- s.

n'.#

• e. n en.~.' v. a v.ea- ~' no.c.~*.41-

-..A

.a,A.. _. _,

~~

e

.4 a.s kv

• h e

.4... v a ' v a. d.

'.*._d _'.d..d. e s

• .o

. a. 4.. a '.e

' b._' s _' _4

• d, a.4. ~.,

• ustice seeks to intervene and request a hearing on one of the r.a 4,.- _4s s u e s w b._4,..b. b..ad s o s e..'., s.' v,

.d_ _eed

• ne a_-._4es -

i 4 y

.h,.

.... e n:..h e

.4

.,. -~..n e

_4 n,. s.

', e m, s....

. A.

.. ~

.. - ~.

4./

Related cases include Central Power & L*ch: 00.,

Decke:

No.

9558 and "exas Power & L:.cn: Co., Docket No. E9578.

l l *2a k.p-*"w..'

. =.. '. k.,e c a " S e w~ ". S.4 e

.'.c e S ~.~..

G.dve..

'.4.S

.e y.

yCSe

'C _'..*..-^ ".e**.4.*.S

_d.

h a.S e.' V *. 5 d

_w

.w

...,..A o

34.gg w g. 4..

.e w.e 3 3.,,.A..

A g ot+2... n=,

. a.4.*

88 ay

.s

.s S.w.-. 9 A.,

,C 4SS..e Ww.4 w

.. S w...

SS.4.. _4S w14.a..A.

.wa 4

6 o

~ '. d S S~a e

~#

-hese

.. S.4 A.S 3 *.

'..d S

..d. e.

C ".S e's'" e..*.' v.,

y e.4.4k. e......

.m.

1 eave

.,4.,..erv.. ShOofA s,S.4 e*S O,. ed.4.,.q S

-w 7

y.

h., e.'. a..de d..

.d

'.. e.= v a. -.=....84..

4...e..'ene k.e ev=.

".e C

S.e.. - -..dae5

.%-. a 7 7.-a,tle

..*.e

.:.: '.y-y ' e. e.~.~ = ' O. # e.- ^. # S e. ' e--

~w.

.e.. a A

e. a.,. A.S

~he

,Se

.n.

..- u.e - y -e., C..d.4.,.g S a

e 4

.C e A.e.

u.n.

Ay,.,.4.a. a n n..

. y n a ny y.n.4

, ~.4 O..v n

4.4 9

m s

e i-- I

/

s i

nC J C'1 t. i N[Ah

' W..

One of the A :: neys fe:

Cea,'. a.'

o. we. a ' '..',"... C-e..v.

a

?'..blic Service Cc==. anv. of Oklahoma Southwestern Electric Power C0=pany

. eS. *

• x = a-

'w' ~..d.'.i..' e S

- - a..v.

n

-y

.mc.n..,

s_hC,,,

.y

, = mnr One Firs: National Pla:a Suite 4200

Chicace, I*

60603 312/558-7500

.33.O w. ec.4..... n.i...,., S..e.

Suite 325

' dashing On, D.C.

20036 2C2/333-9730

.... D

a... S 0,.

n.v.= n. C n, va. :

.a :

3.?.?. OR_? ". W _T wm -...e..c. C h.

-nuw-r e.sGv. w e G ~v La. n. Rv.

r en e..w.n.

Central Power and L:.c.h: C==c.any

)

Public Service Company of Oklahoma

)

Southwestern Electric Power Company

)

Dockee No. I::. 79-8 Wes: *exas Utilities C =pany

)

C r.o.*. ? ?. ?. C a' *. ? C?

s?RV~."w*_

~

herehv. certifv. tha:

have his dav. served the

~

forec. cine. document ec.on all c.arries in this proceeding in accordance with the requirements of 51.17 of the Commission's Rules cf Practice and Procedure by delivering copies in person er by ::w.iling ccpies therecf by first class postage crec. aid mail.

/$.

, lbed]w A Jon-A 0:n6y

..h, CL.. = ::.asr cS a,M,

.w o

1120 Connecticut Ave., N.W.

Suite 325 Washing:On, D. C '. 20036 Dated:

November 25, 1980

)

0 M]D M A

1 j

e O J\\\\ &

bt us nn

.A.

w t%.f.

e..mm e,

m

...g=.

+

=. _. _..

w. V.V... _....

.wA..%

...e 4

h. 6 J%..

R.

o 6

e e

e e

e e

e m

e e

e e

m m

e e

e 4

1

.k

• .. h. e

.s... a.=

4.'

1

$3.

s.*.. S.

g

= -y

=m eJ... i gJ

..= = = = y ; n. g.

w

.g r.

=. e. g.

g i 3

W -.%

ot s

n..,. g, - m.,

I

.g.

4

.p N

) r T.

.. O.*.. 'v 6..~ Z w M.-

Oest

...i..

=

=.9...a

'1 e.

n w

...a w

3

. '.i as. 0..*..

-a

• 3 4

4 W.

..r... *

• V.O.=%%=./

• a O. r. e :- O.

s 1

P.Ts.s-=. O. 1 *.

p.

4

]

=

=

N

/

9$

O. = =. 4 o r.

?,*. 4. e 7 g

[.g... b.

== m.s.

% s p.

5 c$

2 N

,e

_y

- 4 7

• • C..

....a..

..9.g

.g...

a..

2.

.+..g..%... w.

,..g..

.-....... J

.4

.f i

at. a j

. "... *t at. n U

=

f e.

...s.=. =..'=. a " a s..*/.

.O. =.s =

a..=.=..=.4.=

.O. s =..*..=.=.,

s

-5, i

• • ..e 2

} '4 a.,

4 l

e

-j

,a e

e m

{

4 e

e m

m s1e r.

.w-

.v.... 4...

=

=

1 *!

.,.1.*.Q

? s -

.*g*e 5 *.

4 a.b.'~*.s...

a 35

}.*. I a.

• ,=. o S

.s.,

.v..s..-f _.s.

a 1

J i

M.

1 I

1: 4

= = _.,= s. v., n.

be_.

~.,.

= =. ^.

. 3.e.

.,..,,a.,J.

.s..

O.

3. l,a 3.

).

a k. e

. s.k.a _, _. 4

... _ 3.

e..,. 3 I

[g 1 3,

]f I.

.._..s a.

=.

.V *%..C '.J 1.*.*..V----"*S..,

• b. E.4.

3

- O

=

10,

4

]

l

• gw.* *:"T,

.V.g o

r=.

.C"?..**,,,*.>.i a

?

ly

=

n r

20,

.v....r.r -. n.er:

.u...., S

- e-

.I l

• 1 4

....g..,.

-4

-8 n;" t *.s;%% a, t, O

• i 4

f

...w.

,..g..g...

99

.. e.

w

%.r..%.A, 6

.-.s s

.M = o..

... er..V.,

p

...g.

g O.o,;.*g..

. w 4 2 g.4.

7 a

p M

U. m..*an

.e.

6

• • e. b., e S.J s,

s.( 2. _.

• 3.

J.,

r

.=.*4 d

'D

_j h.

M S.g)..N.

1...

M

. =.

t' Oe L

fi 9

q my l

Ju L' Ja ur I

l.,

.._._4

.. - ". S ed S e._' *_..*....= c.. *. e.. e...

a _4..,..__,

"S "...w."*-

i

.4 "r " S S.d.b..' *.

g-.-*.SSSS 5 " ~.~.

w a

3, a,

,4

=..,.. w a.

V.

a 39,

....w 4

.v.r..

.r.=w= e

.e.n,7.

v.....

a a ;

t 4

I

.g ec..

• a n S _...,. 6. a

w...e. _. e.. t S S _.e..A a

y -.

f 1

4 1

. w 3_-

4. 5 5 * *..

o.

a

)-

r-n

. i

..w w

.w

• e.'..?.,

....s.

.s,...

, =a T.u.n.o.v..

r-..

Se.

W

,...e 1

.o o.

c 3

"9

".ese

=

.j.

4.

4. g

.'.a-**"*.#.**.**','.'.'*.'a.d

".. *.. *-*"'".**.*~d#.-'.';'

n f

7..

=

a g. _ t.... g. -.. y g g.*. g o.

.n, 7

.n 1

g.

r.,q.:..-..c v...

g _4 _.w.,

.,,.4.

.v.

S a*.," e _ S 10 j

(

a=.=

t d

......s 3.

1

. 4 _ x.

.g7e...."'.'~.*..*<.'.'.,,,..'..'.4_'*.S,

.=. S W e _ _, *;* * '.*.**

),i a..

l

..a 5

~ ". *.

". *.. * " *a.'**'.'..'.*..-_#**".S*.

=.,.,

jS.4 a

y.-.-

1

.g

e..-

.m..,. s.g

.s.g y

...A_4

. y.-...

A.

9. _* y A g.eg

.4, j.: j w

4 4. 4.

_4 w

i 5

)

._w.

.m__

.Xp.

4

. -,, g g i.

e. : %;.v,

.v. _ ~. 0..

....a,.w.

t.

• ,. o.

t..c, H,

s

.+

W.

1 j o-v a,.

.e

.= =....:..e..

v. e g.

c A.

a ". * * ' - ' V,,

.#.". 3 C '*.

h t

n.

4

}

.. 7.., -s

• d 4. y s b-.w j/ '. ' e "..'.' '.S *-

_w. *.ya _...e.. ' e. -......-.m

_; 4..

3.,

P

~

I j.a 3

_s _.7 */

"...*.S be*_.*.~".e".*"....*"~.#~*d.'a.~~~..".*.".~-#.**..

W8 3

l l

. w..... n /".*

.ES a- *.*.4 j C,

.- w...,..,.

...... a i

=

3

=

'I

f i

..w..-

.s h, C ' *...".a..

G# 7 *.

• • S a t.,

S.g j*

,ar,.. e.v n e.

.v.

- - r;.

..., g,

a.e g.

s.

'.ll v.c"- ~.4*wS

'. *..'s C / '.'.,C

.4S S " *-,

.*..4.".

W e "...= ~< *. S * *-.*.

=- - - -. a. d ll a

wg u...s.yg w.

.A 4--

.v.

s.;

4..

.4-.

.._4....

e g

S w ".e

..e

.w.e a, g g

- ~

y 4

i 1

m 1

- y. - ; e _-

.s k,,g.

4.

c :,,.

2 l

l e.==.*.*w%t.om.

y e _..y y 1.*.,

.y,...

.. C V._.

e.. = *w.

4 w -

y;

.n f

...--v..-

4 1

j 4,

l

". a

... S e ~,. ~ "..#.'. 4.*..*. S

.#.^

'.. ~ ~.

.,.,. 3 y.

, 2., _. j ee i

~

~. -

4, b

=

11 d

AUEMEBaarAET2FJc%--h

D**D

?"D W~

w es aa 1

I I

i i

_...e_-..

,e.<

_ _a

-. u... e.

. _.. s - _a..... a... > _.se e.

ae-_.v.

.e

_-_..se

-_...s,

.. ^...=_..

w.e r

4 s

.., _. -.., - _2 -,. 3,

'.es se,... _ =. ". e s.. '.

e _=..

'... v.. ~.....ve.

4 1,--

.a se

_..,.e a

a 1

.u- _v. s.

.v.---_-.e..

., - ae.

.e-... _ _-..-. '.. -.a.

-u a

N w e

_.... _ _ s _ _- _ s e.. _- _.,

.- - es _'. __'_. a

,. 3 _- _s,_..,..

1 a

-~

1

., l - i._,,,

=

i

.e M

g d-

_ u.,.e,a-

...'s

.d_w,

.u.m... r..u._.s_- w. y..

_2 g

,. t N

I

_w.

. a _ _..,. s

+

3.-

,-, x_,_... 4 e

u_,_,_,,

t t,

-.. a,ia -...

-r.--....- _ u. a -,

u_,i-

_-,a.

u,,.

, - - - ~

, c <

-.. g,-

~~

.,3 ;,,. -... _, _,. _., _ _, _.,

s.- =.....

_ s.. -

T 4

,_. e_ _.. _-.,.

2._4_,a

=.. _

i 1

.. =. = _ =.... _..,.

... e

_, e _, _ u., -.a.....- z...,.,

___-....u.-.._

1,.,

.... _..,._.a..,

g,.

..e 1_.,.

n a. p._

n

.. =..

1 a

4, d '

- '.....s v

.e

u.,

,,.s e w =.. _= ~..=.

a i

i.,,.... g,.._;.._.,....,

= r e.n.,

>.., u,.

, -....,__..,a a

3 e.

g x

,.....e

_z...

.,,.i

.e.,....a...

__u......a.,

.i s v

t e_&_

i

u. t, a__a _ _t.. ig -._a...

-,_,,...._g a.

_a...:....., _.

..u.,.. w,,,

= _ _

o

..i 3 :.,, _. _.., _... g..,.

.x.,...

.,..,,,_., g,

..,, - - e._, _.

a 2,

,a :.,..

a_.,. _,.._:. -.,_

.: a__a _, __:.. g n....,,_,-.,_.,_._;

~

}

'ss.' ~.

w.a d 's ar..-. _'a...- se_ u '......

.-._e_d...,

4 -

l w.,.,_-._.,.-..... _..:..., -

.e._,_...,s

_-.,._..e.

l l

. _s_a_,sa

.... _ _ 4,,-._. e s.

a :. -. s,.. : _.u.

4 l

J I

_...,_.c., =., e.

t, 3 cw

., _,. _4 l

in i

a sc.. -...-

.s.2,_...

u.e.n.

l a.-...

e.,_ s s a_ _a _... a.,. a._. _. a

., a.

4

1

. u.e w g a.

_.g.

1

.o

.,t.-

.=....92_*.

en.. $ 3 g a *..

,..g e

aw.

a r

1 4

, C 5.._4 1

. e

.a.,.

1. a.

., V..

.w.

j

.w.

._.. a.e.

e.

., gX.. S.

W a

9 1

5.#.*."*.***.d..''..#...**.S.'.S..**.*.

.#. a e.'.#,

.w....

3, 4.e.***."..".*'*..#^..,

• ~

• _a a 1 1

. 4..

. b..

g.....g.

• ggg.

m k..

],,

.. g. g.g,9a

..w..

a.

j

)

...,,a:....

,..,.. -..,,.....~.._..a.-..,

e.

j 3j at a

4 g ]

%.4.3 4g g.... 4 g b..,.

_4.

,. g J_...J g

J..

• ,. 4..*.J.

g

.J

.N....

J 4

.e.,..-.4...'e".**._**.*.b'"...#~~b.

'4 e b.'.' .';" '..

• 4 ES 4"*y*'.'.'"..***.*..

.....u j

,e l

.J

.e~.~..#..**.

.' S "y" _'.' "' d.*.*;* *_ e ".". * -

=g

• g k J =.V.

_ b..g.

3

.w

• e g

s

.9 4

4 4

.... m..m. e. e. s. m.

.i. $. %..

_ %.,.o.

m. m

.s..o..... m... e. =. _4 =. m.

• g g = %..d y

I

. nw y

a' e

-====f-

• 4 J _.3

_. 4.e. g......t._..

.... g_. a.

..=. w.._

7g

]

b.,g a..

mb.g f.

...~.

a.

... a 7..,

1 1j

,.,r_ + v s e..v.-.....

7..y

..,.. _t a.

w.

S..

e 4.

wy a,. -.

1i j

• e..***_"._*".,w"

• *** d e

• S e '" ' - -* *.*.. 5.'...' ~. 8 5,

.#.. * ". e.' *. *. C..e... '.'

i., s t

.a 3

4

-44..

6,i2 w r =* * = *-.

d

=

E 1

.v; r,. g ~..

= E.e.4 i i..,

y,....

=.....

• We he'd*V*-

1 2..

.2 3

. 5 *.*. *.,

• ".b.*.

4i

, n

. u..

e_

n..

1.::

.. a -..

4

. e *.-*%' '" k.

_4...

a.

" e.*" *, * " "... *

~

t. m-2 g

1

~~

m

/ 3

,,,3 c.

.__.,s._.....

. _ w.,3 w

.,,. w,...

4. e

.C. C ". *.* ' e.*.

s l

u-

).

.. a. 4.

.; 7

..g

- - 4 _...

w49

,..ga

.__4s w =._w;..v i.v..u.---...

gw.. 4., w g,

,.1 4....

.c j.:.:. A 4

1

...wi..Se.

Ia d.

y x.

r:

..=*.*Se*.-c.=.'..'._=".'.'..d..*;* -.-'..'=....s, l

a0 '

.V.:..

?n'.:._vn'."..

'A r,..' d 7

a

l e

, _. = _

.a,.a*a*a

.*:.,a.'..v, b.e

.a w...a

.. w e

.e. 2.._....,

w w

m.

we 4

?

b

---S..,...

... S.:.. _..a.

-. s i

i

~~ L

-rn.-.:.v.n-v..

v. _.....:..

.gw..a.

.A

,4.. i.e. g _? _.. -..w.._ g a

f.

w 4

c,.,

.... re C.

...,S_..._.

.e 1

us

....,. =

... e a-

. ~~

o N

e

. N.e.m..

9 3

• F a

nw, 0

m-. -

,., g 1

=

w.s. u..s l

ym

~ss. - ~w~ v.i..

v. nA..

u.

.w,

. u.. y4 A

]

s aw.

_-. j..,..

-..g 8

..,ge a w....g w...

4.

.gg-.

~

j e

.3

., _wg..g g -

.. ne.. c....... <. 2

.. a. g,. e., " '..'.

w, w

3.4.a g e g g A

4

.e "" e 4.d.#.'..*..V. "p".*"'.**S

• • * *M e d,.

" Y,

- '., v" I

.."*...--.'.'..'e~....

w ys...v.=g v-- - ?:.

=. w.. 2 w,. g

.a 2

gg.'.

4,.. w.

.w,.

". e e

i ei I

.r '

n

.J..... g e.*..**..#

.. ' ' <. ***.8**.**._*"

m.g g

,g

. _..,. g g.. A = w...=.4 w..

.. =

e g '

c

.f y.-

.....~%c/ wC,

'~

, e g -. 4....

w ngg -.. %.. g

e. v n..e -... g o. ;... ; g.-.

• n a.

a.

4 y

g

.w f

3.,

4....i. "e #,

m' ".Y,.-..

".".a.. W *. " * " P.,

n

._..,. 24.g7 gg4.

S g.t.y. e g

3.

3,

N 1

4

.#....*.*..* *.. ".'.' "....

• S,. ";,

We.

e

,Q )

=. C W e ". * *, '. ".

w e'"*- "."#~

b i,..,..

• i44

.4 y w..

w.

e *:* L ~ ~ *..*". *" ~. * - - '

a

=

,1 a w--

.. - g.

g..; g. ; -,. g. :. 4...

Sg,...

_.e, 33..- Se*S - - -

1. 1 -

-..~

I 4.

yw...:. *.

.. ". * - S 2 *.*..#..*

.# *.#S

..; w w.

ve 3,.,

=

p-

~.;.

-..e..:

sw 9

.w..;..

J.

j.=, y

~..~ y *,

n-o.

.v..

r.n. y.v.s=..

I 4

..r v.. ;

w-1

[

v

-; 4 n

• no g...

--.~y-.t..

4-..

,. a.y,

u.

gg...e g

..o

~

3C.

~ ~...

y S

3 i

-, u.

3

.a 4

.u. :.,,,, S e..a5 2. S ;.. e;..

... a a.

]/

t, w.

y...-...

a a.-

t.

• G.

a _. 4

. _*, =

..wi.

,... _ _4. A 4..

._w. p.._.. _.. o. o e....,*eg A.J..

e-

-w-

.c Ic j

==

y 7.

Iay

-x5

..gg

....g.-.

4..g.

g

o.w. 4, o g o. '..

m., q.4.........

4.

i

. w y

w..

e.:..

_w

,w-g y

~...,..,

e..

sw i

t

-., -1 a _..'.*..'.'..,..~., - ' ;* S -...e'.a 'w d,/ '.'.V. 8

'.e deyar.. e...,

".. a5

- a...

-w L..,

y w

y

"...W "E."; _ S a- "

• S 4.. ' S -.'.. ; ~. *

"y ".

4...

.S.

g 4., 4..e

' S 1

}

-.--..A4-

-w.

9...c, g..w.

-.3

. 4 4... ~;

85

~..". e * *..- *. y c.*, S.'..'. '. G

~

2e

)

y..-

g.

1 25 l 4 SsueS v.

. 38..

-=v, S C. * -. C *. *. e '. ; S c.'. d.

.ev*-

e..',

~

y.

i e

a

i

,D r

D W'

gl

-- g i *l 'S

+

k L,

J 1

,d J

a, 4*

g

..g

' --= -*

d-4S

• -d-*--

.4-

.. 4_,.4--

5--

1 3

~~ - - - - - -- ~~

~

~ ~ ~ - ~ ~ ~ = ~ - - = ~ ~ - ~ = - - - ~ ~ -~

1

• • e~'".**.*..'".."."*~;.**.~..*..*.*/*.

S w-~..'.*_. _.y.8..*...* "* *. S _* ;....

a. g.. *-*;*..* *. -

..a..

g a

t w

"b.;.v_%e.v.--.e..

m..w._45 _4. a..e

.,a4..w.

e..

e a.

?

- - r

-r-4 a

v 4 ;

St

_ _. *.<e.

'.._va.

_S

' _# _ _ _' a.

J..'. S -" 5 3 _'.-..... '..

-".._#S

_ a"

". m.

. 4 _4S w.- =.. e.

.l

_A 3.4 4..

.%.,!~, w.

_4 u.g

. a.x_.

u..; a.

,,.a. a A 4

. wg,

.a

.e yw y.,.

e r-t :

N

.w,_

_w.

e y a -~~ e.. "..*.S

..S..k e..

.'.. ? ? T ",

• ".*V,

1. .*...'. S e *..*.... ' e

-e e

..~

c c

4

-t..

.. S4 S..

c f,..;

3 i

i

'd e # '."'. '.

• 4 E '*.

~. ~. ' ; e. ;,

_ _- *,. _5

"'.S..

_8_'"*_

.I, i

n l.

i.

3.

_.,e..,

_4.

g3 a

.e.

s..

a, 3 3.

4.,..*.. y,

__w 9

.... _..,. w...,

...w.

t.

__.. e.

_._. e.%.~...

3 a

y i

y

=

1 9

n

,.,- a e _,.k.

4

.c 4

i l

4

.4.w

. 6..

e. _s,.

M..-.._...

. -. _i.*...._**y S t

_4..=_4,;

a.

a.

n...

i.

i 8 72. ~ ~ < *, a b.._= _'.#

a aw a *, 5.".",*_** #

_. - "e..*.*"..".*.*..*.*..e,

.w.

s...,.7 _:

j: j i.

I'

~

a'.

• 4e...a'

.'..=<a_

,,.. _4S #.'. '.-

_d

' c >..

r

3.. j.

i 4

i 1.=,

a. g - -- a

.e

..u.

_7,_

..a_,

a ;...,. _.

.. ; ; s e

_w

-w

..... ~.

a.

g r

l 3*,

jg

_?,, q g.

.b.. n..w, t.

_?. g _:.

e,

.#. a~.. '. ' '

'"".".**..'.'8.'.'.',.*.*.$._*.*

a....

j 4

r:

i, u

SL._.;

.4.4 w

+= i ss 3 a

v_.

a 3

ma 2...

A.._

3..e.

4 y

,o S aV,, ' ' '..

.v....

.s %c....:..

s.

s 4

., L. _

.e a~.4. 4.

.w

-.:...._._A.

g.,.

e.

4. S 1.g a r b 4 g. s _.,

w.

2, pw aw b

4 t

~ rm

_ u..,. a

.u-

_4

_ a.

., S., 4.......C.. _ A.

a..,._. a a

a. 4._._.,. _4.

_4 S.4S.,..

a n.

4 3

.a.._.u.

._a..-

4

_ 4. _.. S _.

__aS,.

I 4

4 _ m. a.7.:,

b.. ". ' * *.

_4

_ e _-

. p _ 4 o L

l

• *'4 j

.v.")

.?.**b.e.:.-./ *s" Mm.

. J.

i

_a w e t in t..

j

.i 4

..C t.

_ ue

_4

.S_4S,

.. _4. u.

u.,_ c

._4 _.. S

.1*45.

?

m

.I a

a 4

i 4

t..

. b. 4..

S.

y4

- v. a - : v iy

.v..

e t..

m.w. g

.e s

J

'T i

e5,

-wL e S

• d.w..]

,d e L *? e

_..w. e S e *,.

, 2,. a'a

_4.,.* a.,

b_. _.. S e v.

.S.

s w.

~

4 L

j 1

1 1

.D T D

"D TY J'

Ji j i

J

.u_

a

.-=<

4

-.i.

}

,..,g

3..

e ^^"..*.v..

.* *..*. ; 5

.*.. "...'. ~.~..*.*."yC..* S.

.~.5".

~.. ~ w.'...

1 I

a. m

$ w.

g,. g 4

.s.

ye..E 4**a.

8

a.

• J

..s..=.

J,. a..

"..b. a.= a

.s o

.3.-

.wr v

i s.gg y.ag J. h. 3.

.'S

", e ';* *; # . "" -". *

-**eS*.*.'.'.,

".,a..'#****

4 I

?

.V Q.. %1 "b."". ". O.

• .. b. e

3. X eJ

. h. 4.e

3..s.

y..s d**

..s J

1

.3.,

.4 g..;...

.s g

a.gg.

w y

4 N

h

..yi

.m

.J.s. =.

.'..e, b.. a m

.n..e

b. 4

• e.

.s

. J'.O. T.. * *? '*%.'1'*.

.V."...

.p e

gg g

.,4

=0

,a.

.y. o. -...

e.

g, m,...

e.

S ".. -.. '.. ~.. *. *

"7' ". " S e.. * *.*

.\\4

=,

--r y w -..

n.

?

"g

-l 4.

.w. s. %./. s

..o w.*4..2.

..s.

. s..

.a 4

4 y-,

....s

,b Q

.J.

N

.a.

....a...- -..

3 -.a ss... a.

.a 1

g

.a...-...a......

.s.

y 3

4 1

~

3 10 J

~.~..~.e,...#....

'de.".'.._".."..~4..'.' ".,ey~..~.~..y*..'..'.**..

~4.'

=

I t,.

,...=..x.

.....m.

.,,.m.-..

.... a..e

-. ' ' m.a.

~ '. s.a.-..e. s ='* -

=. = =.

g

. m.

e..s.. a yy.--.

~

...a y

• C>

4 ee

.a.4 2. f.. aX4c.. %e.:

.a.

i.,

'd a.

b. 4.

• e.

..b..s..

b. a.

b. a. g a.

..b..-=.,..b.

.s.=.

• g*;*

.a

.J.=.

b. n.

a e

. i. ;

4.2 1

~

l 3

4..=...,,.

4.

. k. m,

.s

.....,n w....

m_

4 a

,y 1

"*. *.~

}.:

a..v.

.n.=. *., b e.*40 * *. _". a

.S.-.'.*.*.

.S...

~. ~ ~4".**".*..-

.'. w'.. '. -.

y t

%.,,2...

43

..,...J

.j en

. 4. n. m s

3

..-..p.

• e 4

f i *

• j. I a..

g 4w

.o

..s..

J

...g 9

e.

6/

=*...

1

-.. ~

w....u

. m,.

.9 i

}

d

=

f. 3..s, S 8.

. P

=

• (

-.J n

a.

• Ja.%.,

.4.

sw

. w'\\

g a. me.

A.$

3.f 1

. 4..n.a,

• f*

pg**.

. s 'e. a

= = *.

e 4,

• • a

= **

.y... e *.

.b. s.. n

.m.

6.3

.o

o..s

..g a.

=..=..s..

...s., n.

. e*.......

a]

4 4

= * = ;...-*.f e.u m.1..

• f a. g,

%...s.. a.,

gy m...

O..,.,.

?gg. b.. 4

• c. r

.s e a

a.

.v..

n..

.r j

'l

. '.... =.. " ~. ~. ~..... '. ". "

5-

• ". *. "., e S.

s

.'...O.*=aa..m**..'*..=.

2 C. 4. J b.g -

3

-. =.

.'ib

==

.r e

=

e 4

1

..-.J.

%. g.....,. A o.

e.'"..#.*,**...

~ ~. ~4 w" ' ' # ", *.

". *. **S.,

• • g

.,b. g.

.. y 4

. e e..a

. c.==. S.-.

..e 89 C.

g

..o...,

. a a3.

a ALC ERSON R E"3CR-'ING COM P AN Y. IN C.

-.~

D 'f l y}

I P

l a m 6g; A.

i

....=

i I

A y..g a..ya.

u 1

p. :. 2 4.

4 a.

n.,.,.

1 J

e. 4 2..

4.

2.... 4 4.

..ww.

a

.S.,. A -..T.e.

j We.. &...

• +

4 u-

-.G y-..-

.e....g..

4...

gS3.4.

.... C 5 a..

..e aw 4,

..b-w 4.i.

4, yy y..

y

• t a ~.

a 7.

~.:' " * ".. * * -

., g.,.

de "...*. *w**..". ' ~. $,$ #. '.*

.~

g.

4...

4..w..

Aw y.. y =.

a

.y 4

I

.'.".~.a..'....."...'....

... ' e * *y* *y

• S e.' ".'.'".

"c". *.

a" e **.S e

"..S ~ V6'#

• * ". *. * "..a**e

.~

a w

w 4

g 1

-s N

1

~

4.

. g g

4 n...

mu.,.r.

n.

.. o

. g g.4 4

. 4 a.

.m.o

~e

. i

u.,.

a.

y

.w o

3 J o

4 4

5

.C'.*'..'..~.

... ~ ~.. -

44

.b....-

.g 1.:,.

y

,. C.. A 4,, -.:

. a. 4.

j 3 s

)

a...

v.,.

y,.

..a..v., gg.

.2 2g....

,._c......a

...a g.,y.

=-.

, i x

N l

i

)

9 m.-

s-

• "?.O.C.

m y

nj

• T.r*.

• O t.,r*.y.y --

• T ;.

• • ,4 s... -....

.T..

. 6. g.

gg.

a-t

.g---

~. -

10 1 n

f i

l c,.s. =..

m ll 4 e

3 4

• m.

'.{ p.

b. 3.r o.

=..e.

S a ' '-

I

.V O..

T..* *.: O

• Y. 4't.9"e.*.

g.4.*.*

J. <..

,.. =... =

• a e

4 1

a-d a. e.=.b..

3...b..* A.

=. *.

• b a.

b.* 4 *. p g

2

?. ?O./.*

. h. 3.

• e.'*

4 =.. = a = -.= =

o. *.= =. 4-3 gg e

}

• e

".a *.* *.

a" a..#

.T '.:. '.:." ~".a.

• a**.

-. *- # e ** s W a.

~. "... '. *. *. ". ". *

.... *... */~.*=* * * " *

,4 4,

g g

g.

.i.

~

=

4

. obi 4=

m{

4...s..

e

=. g.

4.

.E.q

=

a.

I

..h.,

. g.4.J.g. 4

a.. '. o m.

g y---

9 a.....

32 4 g a 3.

A w'"

.a.

..o.m.

4.

4

.f 4.

....b.=.

4 m

e. a-,,

} g, 7

,<...y

w j

O

.ba b.. s.. a.

5 a.4 J

• b..s.. f

..b...a.

.,g gj 3 a et-5

1. Y..r'..* T..A'.n* *.*t

.V.**..*.77...*

• b. & *. 8 **

g.. g=.

• / d'. *

• b..s' o.

g3

=.a.

?. ?.T.(.* *.

4 J b

i i.

a oi

• 2 g.

j

"' 4 J 5 a*/

.?*" T.'*~ '.

A4J g m..

T O..."".

d g

y e..

T..*,', : ;

7.r= s' m.

, m.l.

3, i..

~..

=

20,

1. .= e~..=..v *4.v - -..=.

n.

-. a s-. 4.... 4.. -

..'~s..

v..-

i

.r 4

...=..

.w..a.. 43..". e "y' C S.#. ~..'. * *.

m.j l.

.: 4.,.:.

..E.

g.

f

.W

... 4

)

8

. g3 3.e. a g.

.-., r..

= e.

.~g,z g..

.3-a p

.B 9

c..: ;.......

...a e

mw

.. 3 v 3..

s

. e.....c..

.a

\\

.aka..b. o.

g s..e 6.

4-..'..

f..

a r. *.. t..u W.

.v. -. :..

"....a-m.e,

.e w

A I

h e p.6 S.4 4.

h.. g. S 3.

1. 1.C.,

4 1

L

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICif.ING SOARD In the Matter of:

S S

HOUSTON LIGHTING & PCWER S

NRC DCCKET NCS. 50-498A CCMPANY, THE CITY OF SAN S

50-499A ANTONIO, THE CITY OF AUSTIN,5 and CENTRAL PCWER AND LIGHT S CCMPANY S

(South Texar Project, S

Unit Nos. I and 2)

S S

TEXAS UTILITIES GENERATING S

NRC DCCKET NOS. 50-445A CCMF.TNY, et al.

S 50-446A (Comanche Peak Steam S

Electric Station, S

Unit Nos. 1 and 2)

S CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, David M. Stahl, hereby certify that copies of the foregoing Reply Comments of the Central and South West Companies to Comments of the Public Utilities Board of the City of 3rcwnsville, Texas oppcsing Preposed Settlement License Conditions were served upon the following listed persons either by hand delivery or by deposit in the United States mail, first class postage prepaid on this 3rd day of l

December, 1980.

. $s;4 h? =[T ^ %

A !.Ty h - A t t o r n e y V l

l l

.vA.,.N.eG.. -,

.2 u.a.

Marshall I. Miller, Esq.

Roy ?.

Lessy, Jr., Esq.

U.S. Nuclear Regula:Ory Cc==ission Michael 3.

Slume, Esq.

Washing cn, D.C.

20555 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory C==.

Washington, D.C.

20555 Michael L.

Glaser, Esq.

1150 17th Street, N.

W.

~4illia= C.

Price

" dashing:On, D. C.

20036 cha~ir an and Chief Executive v.s.a _a n e.-

Shelden J. Wolfe, Esq.

Central ?cwer & Light Co.

U.S.

Nuclear Regulate s; C0==ission

?. O. Scx 2121

~4ashington, D.C.

2 35 Corpus Christi, Texas 73403 A::=i: Safety and Licensing G.

K.

Scruce, Gen. Manager Appeal Scard ?anel City Public Service Scard U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Cc==issi0n

?. O. Sex 1771 Washington, D.

C.

20.555 San Antonic, Texas 73203 Chase R.

Stephens (20)

Mr. Perry G. 3rittain Occketing and Service Secticn President U.S. Nuclear Regula:Ory Cc==ission Texas Utilities Generating CO.

• 4 ashing:On, D. C.

20555 2001 Bryan Tcwer Dallas, Texas 75201 Jere=e D.

Salt: an Chief, Antitrust and Indemnity Group R.

L. Hancock, Director U.S. Nuclear Regulatory COnniscion City of Austin Electric Utility Washington, D.C.

20555

?.

O. Box 1089 Austin, Texas 78767 J.

Iricn Worsham, Esq.

Merlyn D.

Sampels, Esq.

G. W.

Oprea, Jr.

Spencer C.

Relyea, Esq.

Executive Vice President Worshd=, Forsythe & S a=c. els Ecus:On Lic.htinc. & ?cwer Cc.

2001 3ryan Tower, Suite 2500 P.

O.

Sex 1700 Dallas, Texas 75201 Ecuston, Texas 77001 Jen C. Wecd, Esq.

Michael

. Miller, Esq.

..n.,cge

.4.,sen,

-sq.

va=es a.

Carney, ssq.

Mat hews; Newlin, Macfarlane & Barret:

sham, Lincoln & Seale 1500 Alame National Building One First National Plaza San Antonic, Texas 73205 Chicago, Illinois 60603 Morgan Hunter, Esq.

J. A. Scuknight, Esq.

Bill D.

St. Clair, Esq.

Bill Franklin, Esq.

McGinnin, Lockridge & Kilgere Lcwenstein, Newman, Reis, Axelrad Fifth Flecr, Texas State

& Toll Bank Building 1025 Connecticut Avenue, N. W.

900 Congress Avenue Washing:On,. D.

C.

20036 Austin, Texas 73701 R.

Gcrden Gccch, Esq.

Ocn R.

Butler, Esq.

Baker & Sct:s 1225 Scuchwest Tower 1701 Pennsylvania Avenue, N. W.

Austin, Texas 78701 Washing:On, D. C.

20006

e.

4.s, r.os.

v c,

. e.

a_.

-y W.S.

Rebsen Richard C. Sa10 ugh, Esq.

Scuch Texas Electri City of Austin

?.

C. Scx 1086 C0cperative, Inc.

Austia, Tsxas 73767 Sam Rayburn ?cwer Plan C0mplex Post Office 151. 9ee-Joseph 3. Kncets, Jr., Esq.

Nursery, Texas e<

eync., c.s, sq.

Nicho,as s.

.s s

Debevcise & Liberman Rcbert C. McDiarmid, Esq.

1200 17th Street, N. W.

Rcher: A. Jablen, Esq.

WashingOn, D. C.

20036 Marc R. Peirier Speigel & McDiarmid Den E. Davidson 2600 Virginia Avenue, N.W.

City Mana7er Washing cn, D.

C.

20036 s-..? c.J A.. s.4 a4u P.

C. Sex 1083 Revin 3.

Prat:

Austin, Texas 73767 Texas A::Orney General's Office

. C. Sex 12543 Jay Galt, Esq.

Austin, Texas 73711 Lceney, Nichcis, Jchnsen 3 Eays r-v.a e,u c..

, 4...

w 4 3 1 4 rn =... n u-..e.-.,

an Cklahoma City, Oklahoma 73102 Frederi

'd. Rit:s, Esq.

Law Offices of Ncrthcut: Ely Rncland J. Plucknet Watergate Building Executive Director Washington, D.

C.

20037 C--

4.-,e n,..

o n.w.e

,. _.e 5cuchwest, Inc.

Wheatley & Wellesen 5541 Eas: Skelly Drive 1112 Watergate Office 31dg.

Tulsa, Oklahoma 74135 2600 Virginia Avenue, N.W.

Washington, D. C.

20037 Jchn W.

Davidsen, Esq.

Sawtelle, Gceds, Davidsen 5 Ticl0 Jcseph Ru berg, Esc..

1100 San An:Onic Savings Building

- d--us Counsel San An:Onic, Texas 73205 Counsel for NRC Staff U.S.

NRC Washingt:n, D. C.

20555 Dcuglas F. John, Esq.

Linda L. Aaker, Esq.

Akin, Gu=p, Hauer & Feld Asst. Attorney General 1333 New Ea=pshire Avenue, N.

W.

P. O. Sex 12543 Suite 400 Capitol 5tation Washington, D.

C.

20036 Austin, Texas 73711 W.

N. Wecisey, Esq.

Rchert M. Rader Dyer and Redford Conner, Mccre 5 Corber 1030 Pe:rcleum Tcwer 1747 Pennsylvania Ave., N.W.

Corpus Christi, Texas 73474 Washington, D.C.

20006 Dcnald Clements Melvin G.

Berger, Esc..

Gulf States Ceilities C0mpany acnald Clark, Esq.

?. O. Scx 2951 Antitrust Divisien, Energy Seat =cnt, Texas 77704 Section Rcem 3308

--..s~---.,

,J. 4.

4,4

..a.

Washing:On, D.C.

20530 -.

Charles G. Thrash, Jr., Esq.

Jeseph J. Saunders Esq.

E.

W.

Barnett, Esq.

Chief, Public Counsel &

Thecdore F. Weiss, Esq.

Legislative Section J. Gregory Copeland, Esq.

Antitrust Section 3aker i 3cets U.S. Department of Justice 3000 One Shell Pla:a P.O. Box 14141 Ecusten, TX 77002 Washington, D.C.

20044 Donald A.

Kaplan, Chief Robert E.

3athen Robert Fabrikant, Asst. Chief R.

W.

Beck & Asscciates Energy Section P.O. Sex 6317 Antitrust Division Orlando, Florida 32953 C.

5 Depart =ent of Justice Washington, D.C.

20530 Mr. G. Ec7m'n King West Texas Utilities Company Nancy Luque

?.O.

Sex 41 Susan 3. Cyphert Abilene, TX 79604 Ronald E. Clark Frederick E. Par = enter Jonathan Feld, Esq.

Antitrust Division Weil, Gotshal & Manges Energy Section 767 Fifth Avenue U.S. Department of Justice New York, NY 10022 Recm 3413 414 lith Street, N.W.

Washingten, D.C.

20520 i

l t

er y

c.-

--*-w

-,9-9

-.y-y,

.~.

y

,c 4-,-~

-