ML19339B737
| ML19339B737 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 10/23/1980 |
| From: | NRC COMMISSION (OCM) |
| To: | |
| References | |
| REF-10CFR9.7 NUDOCS 8011070613 | |
| Download: ML19339B737 (6) | |
Text
,,. v, m.._ _
- f. *g th, %WR-. ~..,a,.J,;,.c....
- ~
Qvk'&m?f & ff& &.~.. Y f. R S 5 &~lf W I
- hi.&.,&s.,l!iW
.e
-v
. w w.
w.~ w.
yA
%2:$
J.y >itM{$lY$.%$ffq&.
^
C W $< se. G M. ? S $ 5 M Z E; 4 6 - 5 :5 6 %
.u n
=.mt
~
T T:
w,,,,,.
?'T &g.
YS/@&
f'NUNAR73GULATORT COMMISSIONP
@/
w d(F.m d.Wnap v2ch.; W WC*W @Y@ Y W'
s.d..c
.~
D a:hU:-QhhE YihYfnw Ehi W S
?> 5 BW 5I5 p f( [V
'h. 5 p.-
y.
gr. w,y w m
- n r:
r
~
& k *OS;h7A M YYkN$
$h:$k'Yw
~
h~ f.h$MNkN,.M7
. %g$'M5C"W~ehEw$
N..$Tm. _
_9x??.?.'.:
Nh*
2,i:- G..
'Q*M:
.Mu wM~WYY i
h~' v-,,4 M
'.*M-yk
= W~
Ny 5h'kh[h/h g -
7 b
~
~
M T & ; h k k b.h.C h~ k, %
h 84-V
(
/-
s.wim ar9 4.,% Le ?*
L MAO'g;;:.&&WWMP~%p%WW'MM )h9.:
M ;y% W:MW>
M
%*k
~k;;'kW Q k. X$.&Lg Mi.+ktcp hgpu$ 6,hciMt w&n %.w. x m'Mf.4..cB % gt5'p # 6 *&
n
'. M.H M &s%2g g %.. 4.,,q %;y,h W p%,,l~, h.p (Wm.x,r~s., m x e m
--ww@yQ.,T.;.-
WM E.%. w.:d 6.,.W... & e, m.. W.
n g
...n...,n v
~ ~.,,4. w.*E* M M, w. W
@@C g
.q.gf
~
~
. mon -
5?
Yh Y g
Upep..~. v w %% W-W N &w $$wWl 2 5 & Y,W &i Wh5*% l~: &~ WC W N N &- w w w~
_ 7n "',.e &mte cfr.. ;w~PUBLIC MEETINGw.w w4kCGw:-~~~.%? '
h Mww.m
-~
' C " _,
._. d _.
' '_ i,
- 2:.n..
-w
.m..un.: ~ m;. ~
c
- .c;g, nw.e, y -- !
,. M w---
e.% ;
m,~. r,,.q, %, - w.a_
2
- sw G W.... 1a.s.N - ve.w:.Q;,. M f AFFIRMATION SESSION 80- 4,6. q :% w., c ; ? a;y., M. 4 ; ? W ~
-m me uv
-e-~~.
i
+
.,...., p. g m. w. n.c. m w p. :.n g A. m,... c ~; m.
.w;.
- m.. =..
8
.m ir.w. w.. ~.,s-w.,w.
3,.m.<a..m.. h rpa.
_u
. - e?Lr3 ;;.-,...
~
L
.w
.w.gc,.,, y.e a
-,s
\\ n.
.J.wn.w& 2 =i a..: An.&,,n- ~ :.niu -
~
m,, g
..; e
-, n 1,
a
- c. m ;; p m m.y a-n:- :
- -- - ~
r%= ", Q.
- .~
u r
' Y.' :'Qq f,W;- q.;
R.'
(,%,
l 4:W:
p. A,g..C.p;:1:
x.
.. omm p.-m w ~ 1, s.a..h+n.=.---w
.x,.x.w <., s.yy.w,
y m. g.2 e
- v. a.
- -.c.m.
.g
- ,... - wm wp~6&&m,
~
n A
eM4
.. fW W,." 3 77
?~
y.5:r-
~
,..,.c.,
N r-q-
qw s.. - m~
- .m;: a+g",.ww w' m-nw -.
z;cy.
- W...Wm;.gn.
ED'. ns L
- e. n'. w r-w: &=.n.*%qe.m.qp;u sig su ~ : :
,;.u m...-
.v c **/
x r
m.e w$ e!hW%,.y 2. - w o%i% u m. - =g f.tdr. M a.W.My;Qpyge., -
+ +,.
~
g*
4%c.
WW
/ :-P..
---~.L
.Le mse
.W*st > MMMW+' N ~ ~ -
MAW.aN[,
w u
.n _ -
- )p..a.=.
u.a.4,.w,. _
k=
=:=g e.p: a.s -g m\\
WL
.-?G J
A vf.**;*ZA Wsf'WW'8AW! $^?ll&~5" :$hWU'g?.. A ~h%_a$w n. -~- v,-n.,---,- - -.,M,&" *-0,9' $l. --
OE$S%R f* W
.d.a$?$&.
i MWE$&
.&W$' $W, i. &s';.' , lad ?!%> ~.$,.$&.&$15&
.DIQ Q p@7SA*SWOctober '23F'1980M PAES:'w1M3 '
'a*-
OR$dEV,2%,
z;'$ Y lm.:. m.....u.S *&f
&&.U ?
vc-.
u Q
.,, ~ ~.. _, _ ' ~.. - -
m n ~~ an$.
(y.
.. f -(.l.
.,., I
.,, _ _ hy:.
_u-'_
gg g f #pWWg6_ _
g-MM
[N g'__..n==m
~
T**. W4-5..e.,,%
- * &_;,'** Q eT W C
^^ ~ 'F* Sil
^
19%@
~ j
-WlbGW*,,T***'WI[.
6 9% MP@= e
~
M. %~2'f CQMl'f'2.f'J?'*W:'l';'.
re' e.,e i;. '
.- ;.e 4 :4% R
. - ~ -
ya m9 '%
' - a2 'em AJ W: E.--%'.";~7 ~ ~~ ^ '. ?n-~
F W -
..n
. n,w
,n
'm:':.%
%F b
..aw.m ww"'*kk.a.~-
,w-.-
l b
b h
.*N'."""*'"N.' *^*
~.~ nvy;%= 2gh, ~,-b a
-w.e'. [f-m,.e. -
. m.f ykic. my-- w g n sw
. n. er --m w4,t'*-' 'E"","w'.
W n ; e,p q v u ne Mm.v... wm., m. Q*s. %CrA w *-._,;.:; g 2.. i. -r9.y & - a..,4*be
,. ms, r-iW":M..,M.--
%,. m+=;.wu -h.n.m&. ng.p,.-5.y..
p. w =. y _;:., M.$ %.; #rV~g n y.
z t
ru M c
- 3 b'Q~'.%
.r -
r
-=4. L.n?W.~, W 4 hs s ga*V? 68 w*=g
.&'% % = 7 ! D G : Y-2 :. u. rg. w.-+-*_x. - v.
-s
,, w 7m s-m
^
~ -
b' 1
\\ w mw3, <.mAy.,,,r 4,y.r.nQp-ww~.. m p544.Y. p~$.'s$.*
.*h $w&. w....n~,,,e.m.z,2e p. :,w'..
w.m..M,.*q
- m. m,. m. ~...mm....
t p.e. a,m.
.*s r.r.L"g4.:w rw W ~n r
m.g....y m,, m.u p.
+>e.'- ~ r.
1 4m zp,:.: ~. w, Au
.n,.- M%m y-..
-pQ., pes o.~tdu,.
c G,
M'L rbfxwMMWEmMN+WM..~~ %..mwr.m..,m~M, w w. n~=8.'.'$,$p
&= ;~ 4+M, ;kT*br$*&. hec: C mm,2.Bk -Q' &.),$d4"" sq.4
,,M. W..
.y, y
s 2 *mL:.M o*"=% $.; & m m u..
- XL.L.R*,1
~.
.e Q:.
~"
B Q
p
.aa s. ab:,c.,p,,"_. ~. +.K,.w.s:mn.e, vww~ ~ yr~ %e
~ nWo HM
~
t.
)
~
w w
p--
,.m.
x -,.... M., ~ g..,+:, n. -n,.e m
-z mm..m.4.r,,,..
,~
.m,,..
i m.
,e
.s,f:vg.
M[d 1
w v
c +d th_A 6 e k-[.,,.
. *: e.
'ic
'f.i
.s
.* ' ~,'Q kl'^
- m -
'.$f%57v.*A *hN**
%*[,,~.? *' ' ? % n *+ '
~ L*' L 2,"~"'*: * ** ~.* *.-% E
' ~,'TY?..
J '*?tM,..* '.S.$. m$7~$m"'%ac a.< n,Nf. -lD.:M.s$bE.,-C TM+;NN.OMY".~"-
r-
-p..
..,.a@~'.
,. ' y,
-8 %'"#UT nan.M?N,.Z
~~
n
- w.. :,.
.ps
- ..n
- y+' *.S.%
.y* :. g -.w*
V.w
<.n.n y%s i n r
. % %' w up2 *,. #Ye g h.e.,.m.a,.,~..4Q4wd.}~,~ -t il L.-.. x 4 - %.i i.-d-no n.~..+. - a *
.,+m m
/1.-a
+
6 i
y A.%.r;.y,e -9.? ~,m~x.. -\\%.,
q e'
P.+ rd.,, ', ;,v" %y* p','.M.
.-,.q..m 4bi f 'i,.a.2u.
m,*#***" w'.o y'= L' '***-P,., ** wA"8=. **M. '",..
e m. C L>.7 e., ~ hn.s d,
+-...'F,
,.
- p
%.a.n&L.p:m.s,. m(=.N.u s.efr.x m.* -dr'd:<~"*r' -
m #,A +.,mA girf#.,
.o.4 w
. m,JAa #-#3
~. e ; m+
w w...,. s.%was we r
sy '
.gn 1 +..a fm w.a -
.,s,,~%%m s.
%g-6
~
.s c m
w -+. -,
~ u.a.:.
~
m -- -.
7 u
~
=^t*
g.,...
w s** eme*% e.w y W4
- erg.m+. As.m
%2W f
m.3 u..,
.,..,,w..p
- m y_/ '
b i.<
Ghy.).sp'.M har '
~ e d
ewe a.e4 Y *-
4 N
. w ww4
&y -p'y w,,M % d+ ksq $n=eswers.+.*J
<a 4oQ,k.74 W;- - ~ hQQ%,.
.-g+wn w.w*
p >Q-qw*:,$,r#4mirdif.Q
==imess rmd.
r t
bA k~:b.g %.s%p%
4^A9 g.
44 wm a tM.w' A 4 u avw qp r-.h
- m"d*J. h h [ *,. -
w c, JQ3a u s kl.
E W
8.s hb g.=amena wa.m,n,':m..
~a-x %m a,m. am w
Wn.
s v
= m cx2aa2 m.a 9
,m. -
. g-p w#he.gs. v-upgc.
vs.
i p-c - e g,a w a
W
- Talachc$e,.
202Qi.554d2345 b%p.
c sa a-
- w. _
s2 L.
4
.+
~ J, W, %_. W, W.W WW W W W@ W M m
c.naT&Ww97%e %. x&.
v4
~
t W
s y
m,p
+ph =&WNg#q@GM.
i f d h m.?Qu a r e m e m r m m w s w e r m,h ~:L
?
2.n
/
~
~
~
a 1
1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
=
2
- NUCLEAR BEGULATORY COMMISSION 3
E.
PUBLIC MEETING
= = -
AFFIP.MATION SESSION 80-u6 5
6 7
8 Nuclear Regulatory Commission Poom 1130 9
1717 H Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C.
10 Thursday, October 23, 1980 11 The Commission met, pursuant to notice, at 2:00 p.m.
12 PRESENT.
13 JOHN F.
AHEARNE, Chairman of the Commission 14 VICTOR GILINSKY, Commi'ssioner PETER A. BRADFORD, Commissioner 15 STAFF PRESENT:
16 SAMUEL J. CHILK, Secretary 17 18 19 20
~
21 U
=
24
- =
25 l:=::
ALDERSON REPORTING COMPANY,INC, 400 VIRGINIA AVE., S.W., WASNtNGTON, D.C. 20024 (202) 554-2345
...-__~._.. _. _.. _ _
El*
DIScr.A2 cot j
l i
.=.
iis.~
nis is an u=cfficial :a= scrip: e f a. =ae d = ci :ha Unicad S:a:es. Nucles; RegvJ.a c:/ Cc--d esien held c=.
, fl /9A i=. the Ccum:1ssion's. cffices a: 1717 E.Strea:, N. W., Wash 1=gten, i
D. C.
ne mea:1=g. ras open :s public atte"d=nca a=d observa:1on.
i
. - Bis. ::a=se:1pc has ser beest reviewed, c=rree:ed, er editad, a=d.
i: =ar centair i=ac=uracies.
"he. ::a= script is i=:a= dei scle17 for ge=ers.1 ' #c:=a:1c=al pu peses.
A.s p cvided by 10 C1"A 9.103, it is ser pa: cf he fc==al er < #,:=al record of deed cien of de =a::ers discussed.
Expressic=s of epd-den 1
.his ::anscri t da no: necessa ly reflect fi=al de:e:=1=a:1c=s er b=' d a.fs.
Ne pleadd r er c:her paper =ay be "d'_ed.rJ.:h the C - ' esic=. in a=7 prec zeding as the resu1= ci er addressed :c a=7 state =e== cr ar;.:=e== cc=-ded ha.%, azcape as de Cc dssion =ay au:horfra.
e 4
9 e
w Q
0
2 1
E E 9 C E E D 1 E 9 5.
2 CHAIRMAN AHEARNES The Commission meets this 3 afternoon for an affirmation session.
The secretary will 41ead us through it.
5 MR. CHILK The first one is SECY-80-3F'sA, 4
6 proposed revision to 80-365, fees for withdrawu applications 7for cps, OLs, and other approvals or reviews.
The j
8 Commission unanimously has approved !or publication in the 9 Federal Register a proposed interpretive rule which 10 clarifies what fees vill be collected when a review is 11 completed, of an applica tion is completed, o r the 12 application is withdrawn.
N 13 Would you please affirm your votes?
i <
14 (Chores of ayes) 15 MR. CHILK:
The second one is 80-223A.
The 16 Commission has unanimously approved an amendment to its 17 rules of practice to conform the regulations regarding 18 adjudicatory reviews with its internal operating procedures, 19which authorize the Commissioners ten working days to review 20 decisions, and so f orth.
21 Would you please affirm your votes ?
22 (Chorus of ayes) 23 MR. CHILK The third one is80-375.
The 24 Commission has unanimously approved a Faderal Register 25no tice f o r a proposed rule which amends the NRC regulations
'..gz ALDERSoN REPORTING COMPANY,INC, p
400 VIRGINIA AVE., S.W., WASHINGTON, D.C. 20024 (202) 554-2345
.m.
?
3 1that specify fracture teughness requirements for nuclear 2 power reactors and requirements for reactor vessel material 3 surveillance programs.
iis 4
Would you please affirm your votes?
5 (Chorus of ayes) 6 HR..CHILK4 Thank you, gentlemen.
That completes 71t.
8 (Wheret.pon, a t 2404 p.m.,
the meeting was concluded.)
9 10 11 12 N
13 i #
14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24
- r. ;..
25
=:::-
ALDERSoN REPORTING COMPANY,INC, 400 VIRGINIA AVE., S.W., WASHINGTON, D.C. 20024 (202) 554-2346
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION This is to certify that the attached proceedings before the iiiD Commission Meeting in the matter of:
Public Meeting - Affirmation Session 80-46 Date of Proceedins.:
October 23,.1980 Docket llumber :
Place of Proceeding:
Washington, D. C.
were held as herein appears, and that this is the original transcript thereof for the file of the Cc= mission.,
Linda Behrens Official Reporter (Typed) t.
1
.s / / 6 L=&
Cfficial Reporter (Signature) e 9
e.w=
J a..
e
.m
_ _ _ _ _ - _ -.. ~ _ -
~ f. c, UNITED STATES f
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION WASHINGTON. D. C. 20555 4
seotember1s[19eo CONSENT CALENDAR ITEM sscy_30.u3x i
I For:
Che Commissioners Frcm:
James A.
Fitzgerald Assistant General Counsel Subiect:
CONFORMING AMENDMENCS TO 10 CFR 2. 786 (a)
AND 2.206(c) l i
Purrese:
To solicit Cermission approval or an amenc-ment to 10 CFR 2.876(a) and 2.206(c) to i
conform the regulation regarding adjudi-catory review time with the internal Cem-
.-ission procedures.
Discussion:
Cn April 30, CGC submitted proposed amend-ments to 10 CFR Part 2 to extend generally the times for Ccamissioner acticn on deci-siens under 10 CFR 2.206(c), 2.786(a), and 2.786(b).
SECY 80-223 (April 30, 1980).
Cpen consideration, the Ccmmission approved only the amendments to _2. 78 6 (b) to provide 30 days (instead cf 20 days) for Ccamission action when a cetition to rev-iew is filed and to 2.786(a) to clarify that action under 10 CFR 2.786(a) is automatically coextensive with 10 CFR 2.786(b).
Those amen <iments are new effective.
45 Fed. Rec. 45890 (July 8, 1980) (Attachment 1).
Since those changes were approved, the Com-mission has expressed a desire to have ten working days (i.e.,
tue weeks) to censider items in the normal course of Ccomissicn re-view and action.
He believe that the recent amendment to 10 CFR 2.786(b) will be suf fi-cient in
'k
- -- 1 case to cermit receipt of ansue draftin?
DUPLICATE DCCUMENT the Ccam ghe ma}t Entire document previously
- cr CGv entered into system under:
existing k
2.206(c)
$0()C }96 6f(o f
(Py(Hn
~
g
!g m n No. of pages:
Y ; W " "C'//,
6 bs Centact:
"2
- ark E.
Checko, GC l
- -43224
._ g
.-,-n-.
yg 3
N IINITED STATES NUCLEAR h.20LATORY COMMISSION August 7, 1980 SEC'/-80-375
-~
WASHINGTON, D', C. 20555 CONSENT CALENDAR ITEM For:
The Commissioners Fron:
Robert B. Minogue, Director, Office o rds Development Thru:
Executive Director for Operations 9
Subject:
10 CFR-Part 50--GENERAL REVISION OF APPENDICES G AND H, FRACTURE TOUGH-NE,SS AND REACTOR VESSEL MATERIAL SURVEILLANCE REQUIREMENTS Purcose:
Inform the-Commission of the need to amend Appendices G and H, and obtain Commission approval of a notice of proposed rulemaking.
Issue:
Proposed modification of NRC regulations involving the requirements for fracture toughness of the reactor coolant pressure boundary, including surveillance of neutron radiation embrittlement of the reactor vessel beltline materials.
Discussion:
Appendix G, " Fracture Toughness Requirements", and Appendix H, " Reactor Vessel Material Surveillance Program Requirements," have undergone only limited revision in over six years of use.
In this proposed general revision, the requirements of Appendices G and H have been updated to be more consistent with current technology and pertinent National Standards.
Some of the proposed amendments are intended to clarify the applicability of these requirements to old plants, those built to an ASME Code earlier than the Summer 1972 Addenda to the 1971 Edition, which often require consideration of proposed alternatives to specific requirements.
Two of the proposed amendments modify requirements that have proved to be unduly conservative, and a number of other amendments shorten and simplify these regulations by replacing technical detail with references to appropriate National Standards.
The proposed amendments also address a procedural issue involving the need for an exemption when a licensee proposes an alternative action to that described in the regulation.
These arsendments describe two routes that may be followed.
In s 50.47, which would take the place of 5 50.55a(i) in making Appendices G and H a part of the regulations, the exemption route is described.
Proposed alternatives may be used when an exenption is' granted by the Commission.
The applicant must demon-strate that his request meets the requirements of $50.12, and he must demonstrate that (a) the specified requirement would result in hardship i
without a compensating increase in quality and safety, and (b) the pro-i posed alternative would pr
~
The keyword, " adequate," i achieved by the proposed a DUPLICATE DOCUMENT would be achieved by folle j
nevertheless acceptacle.
Entira document rreviously 1
posed alternative, which a entered into sg em under:
hdOIDd b
Contact:
P. N. Rancal1 ANO 443-5997 No. of pages:
g qf9:l'S?.8 q