ML19338C079
| ML19338C079 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Midland |
| Issue date: | 11/02/1971 |
| From: | Lowenstein R CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.), LOWENSTEIN, NEWMAN, REIS, AXELRAD & TOLL |
| To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8007310663 | |
| Download: ML19338C079 (3) | |
Text
e
.. c
.~ 4.
( _,yrf.',,h:.
~
-~
_,g. ~c,,_ in
- 2.,
em 3
/
4
- 7..
l()
&w
~w UNITED STATES OF' AMERICA-
- rd-
~'
.\\ q
,~.,
=-
LATOMICLENERGYJCOMMISSION-:
b ;;
y/,
3<.,N
.s
'N. w-g "Tk,j m,,
.s
- In thelMatterz,of
}-
-- )
l CONSUMERS a POWER': COMPANY,
-).
~ Docket.Nos. 50-329 '
1
)-
~
50--330 (Midland iPlant,1 Units.l. 'and 2)
- )
- jpp1/
-APPLICANT'S MOTION.TO-STRIKE THE WRITTEN TESTIMONY ' OF DR. ' CHARLES W. HUVER' j
-On September.28, 1971,-the Mapleton Intervenors filed the writtenitestimony-of'Dr. Charles W.
Huver.
Although the-
+
-Mapleton:Intervenors,~in theif letter to the' Chairman of Septemberi28,.19.71~at p.
2, characterized his testimony as
~
" environmental evidence,"-it was clearly-radiological evidence t
~ which, 'if ? allowable"at all, was l required-by paragraph I A-2 (c)
.of the Board'c' Order to'be filed by Sept' ember 15,-1971.*
i Dr..-Huver!s. testimony dealt-with the effects of liquid
- radioactive' waste'dischargest and thermal. discharges from--nuclear-power plants ~on fish and-human beings.- While this.. testimony. is:
very interesting, it clearly he.s nothing to'.do with the proposed, 1 Midland plant which is designed-for essentially zero. radioactive-
.liquidtwasteLrelease and:the discharge:of cooling water from the~-
e
- For +r poses'00Tthis1 motion, we put aside.the factfthatJ Cthe,; evidence:was ff.'ed!13-daysSlate.
We also~put'aside the.-
factLthatHContenth.s'3'and 41of the;Mapleton_Intervenors, as
' to which.thef order permitted them.to-submit ' written evidence,
s aid e.nothing l abou.ti the rmal* dis ch arges..
l
,* m,.
sk gi 3 %
u R
-.= "3
-,.. p...
w.+
..~
r -
w--
-3
~+,w q
x.
y, F
ff
~
[
-r
.e
~-2i
' cooling}pondltoltheTittabawasseeRiverat~atemperaturewithin-
- . one degree Farenh'eit; ofithej river.. temperature l ati the' point of ;
m idischarge.-DSee Amendments:201 and 21 to the PSARiand Applicant's.
[
, environmental?.stibmission' of June ~21, 1971-tio Dr. Peter McLrris',
Director < of 1 the -Division of.. Reactor. Licensing.,* '
i The Tab' surdity - of1the.Mapleton Intervenors' filing of testimony tiotally unrelated to the -proposed, plant fat issue (in this proceedingican only.be explained by either th'eirifailure'to l'
' read the-basic' materials in the record concerning the design and,
-featuresTof the proposed plant or their desire to.use the.
-testiiniony forJpropaganda purposes in the Midland area.. Whatever i
the~ motive, however,L t is' improper to-encumber'the; record with i
T I
such patently irrelevant material.,
' Applicant-therefore moves'that the written. testimony.of.
- Dr. Huver,? subscribed and sworn toon September.14, 1971', bet stricken. -
L.
1 f:
LDated:L Novembe'r: -2, 1971
. Respectfully submitted,.
I<
~
t W cLA w
t-
- LOWENSTEIN ' AND -NEWMAN.
H i - e-1100 Connecticut.. Ave'., -.N.W.
I Washington, ; D.C., 20036 -
.j (l
L Off Couns'el:1-
~
': Robert: Lowensteini
--Attforneys forf Applicant -
' 1 Harold.PkGraves Consumers: Power' Company'.
L John K.JRestrick-
-l L
'JeromeiE.JSharfman-
')
O 1 Richard G.JSmith9 L
e s
h
. *New[dataJavailablein: Applicant'sLSupplemental Environmental-E ie _ ; Report -at :pp.t4'.14-6'and 14.'4-7'show's-that the river temperature.
~
_ lwouldfremain'ctheTsameJafter the:Ldischarge intofit of-the cooling 1 c
itpond: water.-
p
,g' g
m Y
~
y s.
s
~
f f 7
i<
T
+
e E
I r
a' +I
)
'1
. ( J _,.5, p
.['
[
.g m_,,
, ;,,,, g, g,g,.
,e
- a --
z.
[.
0
\\
UNITED STATES OF AMERIC5.
~ ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION In the Matter of
)
-)
CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY
)
Docket Nos. 50-329
)
50-330 (Midland Plant, Units 1: and 2) )
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies. of the " Applicant's Motion to Strike the Written Testimony of Dr. Charles W. Huver", dated November. 2,.1971, Ein the above-captioned matter have been served on the following in person or by deposit in the United States mail, first class or airmail, this 2nd day of November, 1971.
Arthur W. Murphy, Esq., Chairman Milton R..Wessel, Esq.
Atomic. Safety and Licensing Board Kaye, Scholer, Fierman, Hays Columbia University School of Law and Handler Box 38, 435 West ll6th Street 425 Park Avenue j
New York, New York 10027 New' York, N.Y.
10022 Dr. Clark Goodman James N. O'Connor, Esq.
Professor of Physics The Dow Chemical Company
. University of, Houston 2030.IXxe Center
)
3801 Cullen Boulevard Midland, Michigan 48640 Houston,-Texas 77004 Myron M. Cherry, Esq.
n Dr. David B. Hall 109 N.
Dearborn Street L
Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory Suite 1005 l
P.O. Box 1663 Chicago, Ill.
60602 Los. Alamos, New Mexico 87544 j
Algie A. Wells, Esq., Chairman L
William J.
Ginster, Esq'.
Atomic Safety and Licensing i
Suite l4 Board Panel Merrill-Building U.S. Atomic Energy Commission Saginaw,. Michigan 48640;
-Washington, D.C.
20545 i
James A. LKendall,- f Esq.
Stanley T. Robinson, Esq.
3 135 N.'Saginaw' Road Chief, Public Proceedings Branch Midland, Michigan 48640 office of the Secratcry-of the Commission Anthony Z. Roisman,.Esq.
U.S.' Atomic Energy Commission iBerlin,ERoisman and Kessler Washington, D.C.
20545 1910 N Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C.
20036 Irving Like, Esq..
200 West Main.StreetL Thomas F. Englehardt,-Esq.
. Babylon, New York 11702
'U.S. Atomic Energy Commission
' ^
-Washington,, D.C.
20545 2,,
= - -.
erome E. Sharfman h
=
a.u.
+
,