ML19332D473
| ML19332D473 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 11/16/1989 |
| From: | Hoyle J NRC OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY (SECY) |
| To: | NRC OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY (SECY) |
| References | |
| NACGEN, NUDOCS 8912040017 | |
| Download: ML19332D473 (44) | |
Text
,
4,4 UNITED STATES c
y' NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION o
wAsniscToN. o.C.20sss kg.....g
)
OFFICE OF THE November 16, 1989 SECRETARY t
MEMORANDUM FOR:
Committ ana ment Secretariat t
FROM:
John
. Hoyle l
f.
Advise' Committee Management Officer
SUBJECT:
NRC INPUT FOR ANNUAL REPORT TO THE PRESIDENT l
Enclosed are completed copies of GSA Forms T-820-H and T-821-H t
for each of the Federal Advisory Committees of the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission and the agency summary sheet (T-822-H).
This material is submitted for inclusion in the Annual Report of the President for FY-1989.
i Your records should reflect that the NRC's Advisory Committee Management. Officer is:
John C.
Hoyle Assistant Secretary U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.
20555 Telephone:
(301) 492-0599 l
If clarification of the attached report information is necessary, please call Mr. Hoyle or Mr. Bates on 492-1963.
l
Enclosures:
1.
Summary Sheets (T-822-H) 2.
Forms for Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards 3.
Forms for Advisory Committee on the Medical Uses of Isotopes L
4.
Forms for the Advisory Panel for the Decontamination of L
TMI-2 l
5.
Forms for the HLW Licensing Support System Advisory Committee 6.
Forms for the Advisory Committee on Nuclear Waste i.
7.
Forms for the Nuclear Safety Research Review Committee l
8.
Forms for the Special Committee to Review the Severe Accident Risks Report Ofof 8912040017 891116
s*
o ANNUAL REPORT -
REVIEW OF FEDERAL ADVI50RY COMMITTEE 5 IN Tf R AGENC w REPOR T5 CONTRO NO.
t t
AGENCY
SUMMARY
oso4-et A-XX INS 1 RUCTIONS: Complete onc form pet egehCy W$th0 TOT ALS corneo from all GSA Forms I-820-H sho 1-821-H io be submittee tot itse ftscot yest (10-01 to 9-3OL
1989 SECTION A - TOTALS FROM OS A FORM 8 T-Ste-H ITEM NUMDER T[
DAT A ELEMENTS TOTAL OF ALL COMM11 TEES 4
NEW *YES*
NUMBER OF NEW COMMif f EES 1
BA.
TERMINATED *YES*
NUMBER OF TERMINATED COMMiliEES 1
A. DIRECTED BY L AW
]
- 8. AUTHORIZED BY L AW 11 COMMi11EE Au1HOnt1Y C. AGENCY AUTHORif y 6
D, PRESIDENTIAL OIREClivE A. AD HOC 2
14 COMMilfEE TYPE B. CONilNUING S
C. PRESIDEN11AL A. NAtlONAL POLICYIISSUE B. NON-SCIENilFIC C. SCIENilFIC/IECHNICAL 6
15.
COMMITTEE DESCRIPTION
- 0. GRANT REVIEW E. REGUL ATORY NEG01tAllON 1
F. OTHER I
16A.
REPORTS NUMBER OF REPORTS 65 l
A. OPEN 70 D. CLOSEo 5
17.
MEE 11NGS C. PARTIALLY CLOSED 17 D. TOTAL 157 DAT A ELEMENIS CURRENT ACIUAL NEXT ESilMATE A. PERSONNEL PAYMENTS (1) NON-FEDERAL MEMBERS 8 367.660 0
458.843 (2) FEDERAL MEMBERS 8
5,739 8
5,739 (3) FEDERAL ST arf 81,662,521 01,767,570 18, COMW11EE COST (4) NON-MEMBER CONSUL T ANTS 8
82,090 8
141,683
- 3. TOTAL TRAVEL AND PER Di[M 8
320,449 8
391,370
- c. OmER 8 338,080 8
428,900 D. TOTAL 82,776,539 8 3,194,105 i
19.
FEDERAL ST AFF SUPPOR1 YE ARS TOTAL FTE YEARS 30 3
31 1
e e
- GENERAL SERVICES ADMINISTRATION
, __ GS A FORM T-822-H (Ravs 7 -ra n
i f
p WECTMNI 5 - TOTAL 5 FIN 3M 95A FORM 5 T-521-H DATA ELEMENT 101 AL OF ALL COMMif f EES
. ; FEM NUMBER fI 5.
101AL MEMBERS SERVNG 71 tJUMBER OF :.:::aaER:
69 SECfl0N C - AGENCY helethte Mt0 FILE OATA h
NSTRUCilONS: ON $[PARATE Atl ACHMENTS PROVIDE THE f 0LLOWING DAT A:
- 1. OCCUPAflONAL GROUPS:
~
LIST THE TOTAL NUMBER OF MEMBERS BY THE TWO-DIOff OCCUPAflONAL CODES AS PROviDED IN Af f ACHMENT 410 THE MEuORANDUM OF INSTRUCilONS.
See 8tt8Ched list l
- 2. INDUSTRY GROUPS:
LOT THE 101AL NUMBER OF MEMBERS BY THE 1WO-DiGif INDUSTRY CODES AS PROVIDED IN Aif ACHMENT 51O THE WEMORANDUM OF INSTRUCilONS.
See 8ttached 11St I
sECTION D - CERTFICATION prUnduulNO OFFICIAL OR DEstDNATED FEDER AL OFFICER 540N ATURL DATE fifLE:
NAME:
COMM6T TEE MAN AGEWNI 0FF ICER 510NAIVRE DATE fifLE:
NAME OTMrR CONCuuRING AGENCY OFFIC6AL ElON AlvR E D A TL fifLE:
NAME:
I P
(
i i
GS A FORM T-822-H BACK(AEV. 7-89)
e t
'{
t j.
j l
I i
Department or Agency:
NRC Section C
'1.
Occupational Groups:
Total Number of Members by occupational Code Od2de No. of Members l
5 27 6
1 i
7 2
8 12 l
10 2
12 9
13 1
14 4
17' 13 t
i i
?
f 2
b l
l' l'
[~
Department or Agency:
NRC Section c 2.
Industry Groups:
Total Number of Members by Industry Code Code No. of Members 1
6 2
31 3
22 4
5 5
7 I
i t
.t I
1 f
1 i
I L
ANNUAL REPORT REVIEW OF FEDERAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE
- '"'""[' * '$','['"' ""
g, INSTRUCitONS: Compiele one form for E ACH Committee existmg eny time Ovemg the fiscal yest numetais (Month, car, year). It accitional sesce es necessary, use Section I,
- Remarks
- on the tevette,110-01 to 9-30). Cite Att estes er t pumum CA AaNCv
.,isCu viar-NRC 1989
- 3. CO uunt On EvaCCmint owi n....s r.ie,e.
Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards SECTiON A - COMMtTTIE STATUS
- 4. 45 THIS COMM11 TIE NEW DUR444G f tECAL 4LAR)
- b. CURRENT CHAltIER DATL
- e. EXPECTED BENEW AL
- 1. EXPECTED I(RMIN AllON DAIL DAff CATE D vis Do 12/23/BB 12/23/90 NA eA. HA5 IHt5 COMMilitt Bited TERMsNAIED DURING eB. !#Ec tf 4C TERMmallON AUTHCNttIY (if by 6ew, ec. AC TU AL TTRMIN A140N DATE f tSCAL Ytakt (if *Vis*, complete stems eB ene eC) tite U.S.CJ C VIS
@NO NOTE: It box 90 or 9C is checkea, compiele stems 10A and 100 and previos a praat explanation en "Reanerts',
- e. AGENCY RECE""8 EDA 140N FOR CEMII(L IOR NLK1 5 65G AL 4 E AR 10A. 45 LEGi5tallON RIOUIRFD 100. 45 suCH LEGt5LA160N TO Minot OR ffRMINA1(?
P(NDINO OR IN ACf(Of
@ A. CONTINU(
[B.M(DO(
] C.1[RM tN AT(
C Yts CNO CviS CNO SECTION B - COMMITTEE AUTHORITY AND TYPE ll. E5TABLI5HMLN1 AulHOR41V Rhec, ONLt ones
@ A. SPtCtflC ALLY DIREC1(D BY ( AW B. AUTHORittD BY LAW
] C. A0(NCY AUTHOnliY
[ 0. Ptt$10(NTIAL DISfCilV(
U. 5PECsF6C LEIA8tl5Ht4NI AUTHORif t til ey new, ts. LIFf CT Wt DAll. w
- 14. COMMtITEt TYPE (Cnect 1 ITHER A or B. a's C, el sne U.S.CJ AU T HORIT Y aparepriate) 42 U.S.C. Sec. 2039 & 2232 1957
- w. otscwuoN w COuuiset (Cn.c, ONtv or.,
O A. An HOC g a.CONnNumo O C. retsiotNuat A. N AT ION AL B. NON SCitNilfIC f f CHNIC AL OADVISORYPotscynssut 9000aAu Pa 00A AM 0.ORANT
(.kf0VLATOaY
- f. OTHtt ADVisoe Y A0vitotV ttvitw Nf 0011 ATION (SecticW SECTION C - COMMITTEE ACTIVITY DURING F18 CAL YEAR lea. ;OT AL NUMBER OF tot. 4 651 EL90R T 161LLS AND D ATt5 (MontN cay)
R(POR16 47 SEE ATTACHED
- 17. NUMBER OF MElilNGS L.U4345 UF ALL MtliNGs c= N cap
'A. OPEN B. CLOSED C.FARitALLt CLOSED D. 10TAL (A
- 0. C)
SEE ATTACHFD 52 5
13 70
'D^**o'"'"^6"*"****""*'***'
$ECTION O - COMMITTEE COST NO1Et Express costs m whoto coilers. (DO NOI use cecimals, K M, N/A, or leave blant, indicate 'O*, if apphcabiet
- 10. DESCRIPilON CURREN1 NEA1 FtSCAL YEAR FISCAL YEAR 1Actuat)
(E s tima te)
(1) NON-FEDERAL MEMBERS 316,948 367.625 A. PERSONNEL (2) FEDERAL MEMBERS (Protated seistv)
PAYMENTS (3) FEDERAL ST AFF (Protated salary) 1,353,763 1.425.303 (4) NONMEMBER CONSUL T ANTS 41,217 101.683 (1) NON-FEDERAL MEMDERS B. TRAVEL lbb 6/3 190.350 (2) FEDERAL MEMBERG AND PER DIEM (3) FEDERAL ST AFF 9,150 9,400 (4) NONMEMBER CONSUL T ANTS C. otte R (rents, user criarges, greenics, ormime, meieme, etc.)
27.118 35,250 278,956 350,000 l
- $ 2,183,025
$2,479,611
- 19. FEDERAL ST AFF SUPPORI YE ARS EXPRESS N FULL 11ME EOLAYALENT (FlO YEARS use6 DECtMAL 1016tE tlE AREST ltN1H (e g. 0.0)
(FIGURE $+00LD CORRISPara lo 00LtAR C051 N ifEM 18AQ), ADOVE,)
my m n an v. n
e s
. d
' i s
t
}
o.
SECTION E - COMM11 TEE ACCOMPLt%HMENTS AND JUSTFICATION
'A (Complete this sectiott ONLY f or committees where stemt 4 *NO*. CA *NO*. ano 9 A
- Continue
- are chectoc)
FDA. DE50R IBE HOW IHL COMuslitt AC COMPL i5nt 5 615 F'URPOSL I>v EHOW ahG IHL tFFICI OF COM8.asillt ktFOR15. ADY 4GL. Ok &ECOMMLNDAllOh$
ON AOLNCY OPit AttON$. $[ A$ $P(CiflC A$ POS5tBLE AND INCLUDt woRELCAD INDICA 1DR$ A$ APPROPklAT[.
t i
SEE ATTACHED
)
{
t it MBER SH IP IN IERM5 QF POIN15 QF VIEW REPRI5fNTED AND FUNCilON$ F(RFOR64D.
i SEE ATTACHED l
FUC. DEBCR 5t THE FRt0VENCY OF MilitNGS AND THE RELEV ANCE 10 CONilNutNG THE COMMIIILL.
SEE ATTACHED M. IKPLAIN WHY THE ADV tCE OR 4NFORMA160N C ANNOT BL 06T AINED FROM OTHER 50VRCLE.
g i
4 SEE ATTACHED I
FOL. tF APPLtCABit. [XPLAIN WHY 4I W AS NECESSARY 10 CLOSL AND/OR P AR16 ALLY CLOSE COMMill(( ME L I INGS.
SEE ATTACHED '-
SECTION F - REMARKS F t. REMAnts 5
t GS A ronu I-820-H BACK mtv. 7-0
};
h NRC Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards SECTION C 16B.
i s
Report Title Date ACRS Action on the Proposed Amendment of.10 CFR 50 Appendix J.
10/11
" Primary Containment Leakage Testing for Water-Cooled Power Reactors" t
0 Preapplication Safety Evaluation Report for the Modular High-10/13 Temperature Gas Cooled Reactcr Licensing of all Chemical Isotope Enrichment, Inc. Facilities 10/13 Safety Evaluation Re 11/22 Safe Module" (PRISM) port for the " Power Reactor inherently Design ACRS Action on Proposed Regulatory Guide 1.9, Revision 3, 11/22
" Selection Design, Qualification. Testing, and Reliability of Diesel Generator Units as Onsite Electric Power Systems at Nuclear Power Plants" ACRS Action on Proposed Regulatory Guide. Task No. EE-006-5, 11/22
" Qualification of Safety-Related Lead Storage Batteries for Nuclear Power Plants" Equipment Qualification-Risk Scoping Study 12/20 Proposed Experimental Program on B&W Once-Through Steam 12/20 Generator Thermal-Hydraulic Performance 3
Code Scaling, Applicability, and Uncertainty (CSAV) Methodology 01/19 f
for Determination of. Uncertainty Associated with the Use of Realistic ECCS Evaluation Models l
Draft Final Rule on Standardization and Licensing Reform, 10 CFR 01/19 Part 52, "Early Site Permits; Standard Design Certifications; and Combined Licenses for Nuclear Power Plants" Safety) Evaluation Report for the Sodium Advanced Fast Reactor 01/19 (SAFR Design Resolution of Generic Issue 43, " Air Systems Reliability" 01/19 Mark 1 Containment Performance Improvement Program 01/19
~
NUREG-1150:
Resolution of ACRS Comments 01/23 Final Rule on Standardization and Licensing Reform 10 CFR 02/15 Part 52, "Early Site Permits; Standard Design Certifications; and Combined Licenses for Nuclear Power Plants"
4 '
f.L
. c i
NRC
.g.
Advisory Committee on-Reactor Safeguards-Report Title Date Further ACRS Comments on-Implementation of the Safety Goal Policy 02/16 Further ACRS Comment on Proposed Resolution of Generic Issue 99, 02/16
" Improved Reliability of RHR Capability in PWRs" Proposed Resolution-of Generic Issues 70, " Power Operated Relief 02/16 Valve and Block Valve Reliability," and 94, " Additional-Low-Temperature Overpressure Protection for LWRs" Safety Research Report to Congress 02/17-Review of the Peach Bottom Atomic Power Station Restart 03/14 Additional Applications of Leak-Before-Break Technology 03/14 Containment Design Criteria 03/15 Proposed Severe Accident Research Program Plan 03/15 Proposed Resolution of Generic Issue 101,"BWR Water Level 04/11 Redundancy" Proposed Final Resolution of Generic Safety Issue 103, " Design 04/11 for_ Probable Maximum Precipitation" Proposed Amendment to 10 CFR 50.61, " Fracture Toughness 04/11 Requirements for Protection Against Pressurized Thermal Shock Events" Proposed Resolution of Generic Issue 115, " Enhancement of 04/11 Reliability of Westinghouse Solid State Protection Systems" Proposed Resolution of Generic Issue 82, "Beyond Design Basis 04/11 Accidents in Spent Fuel Pools" Proposed Final Rulemaking Related to Maintenance of Nuclear 04/11 Power Plants Generic Letter Related to Occupational Exposure of Skin From 05/09 Hot Particles Generic Letter on Safety-Related Motor-0perated Valve Testing 05/09 and Surveillance
-NUREG-1150, " Severe Accident Risks: An Assessment for Five 05/09 U.S. Nuth ar Power Plants" NRC's human Factors Programs and initiatives 05/09 Operating License Application for Limerick Generating Station, 05/11 Unit 2 I
T p
7 4
b,x j[
' y'%.
W
' NRC'
-3 E.
Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards t,N P
Report Title Date USl A-17, " Systems Interactions in Nuclear' Power Plants" 06/13 p
y Proposed Gene"ic' Letter Regarding. Service Water System Problems 06/14' y
Affecting< Safety-Related Equipment h
Boiling Water Reactor Core Power Stability 06/14 L
Rell' ability and Diversity.
~
06/14 Proposed Resolution of Generic. Issue 128, " Electrical Power 06/14 g
Reliability" w,.
NRCThermal-NydraulicResearchProgram OG/15 b
Proposed-Commission Policy Statement on Education for Senior 06/15
[..
Operators and Shift Supervisors at Nuclear Power Plants Proposed Staff Actions Regarding the Fire Risk Scoping Study 07/18 (HUREG/CR-5088)
- Proposed' Resolution of-Unresolved Safety Issue A-40, " Seismic 07/18
-Design Criteria"
. Proposed Resolu' tion of Generic !ssue 79, Unanalyzed Reactor 08/15 Vessel'(PWR) Thermal Stress During Natural Convection Cooldown Electric. Power Research Institute Advanced Light Water Reactor 09/12 Requirements Document Proposed Resolution of Generic Issue A-29, " Nuclear Power Plant 09/12 Desi~gn for Reduction of Vulnerability to Industrial Sabotage Emergency Plan for Full-Power Operation of the Seabrook Station.
09/13 1
- Unit 1.
1 L
17E. DATES OF ALL MEETINGS
' Full Connittee Meetings 10/06-07 02/09-11 06/08-10 11/17-18 03/09-11 07/13-14 7,
12/15-16.
04/06-08 08/10-11
- 01/12-14 05/03-06 09/07-09
' (Continued) q.
i g
r._
e/
NRC Advisory Committee on Reactor; Safeguards SECTION C-17E.
DATES OF ALL MEET 1 HGS (continued)'
L Subcommittee Meetings Y
10/4 06/07 (2)
.10/5 06/20-
-10/26 06/21 6:
11/15-16 06/22
~12/06-
-07/12' (2) 12/07 08/09 (2) 12/12 08/17 12/13 08/29-30 12/14 09/06' 01/05-06 09/12 01/10 09/19
- 01/11 (2).
09/20 p
01/26 09/26
~
01/27 09/27 02/08
-(2) 09/28 02/28.
03/01-02 03/07 (2)-
7:
03/08 03/15-16 03/23
-i 03/29 (2)
'I 03/30 04/05 04/11-12 04/18-104/19 04/20 04/21-04/25 04/27~
i 05/03 (2) 05/10-11 05/23.-
I
-05/24 L
.SECTION E
-i
)
20A.
/!
.The Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards (ACRS), established by statute in i
1957,_provides advice to the Commission on potential hazards of proposed or existing reactor facilities and the adequacy of proposed safety standards. The i
Atomic Energy Act of 1954 also requires that the ACRS advise the Commission with l
respect to the safety of operating reactors and perform such other duties as the Commission may request.
Consistent with the Energy Reorganization Act of 1974, the Committee will review any matter related to the safety of nuclear facilities specifically requested by the Department of Energy (D0E).
Also, in accordance with Public Law 95-209, the ACRS is required to prepare an annual report to the 4
U.S. Congress on the NRC Safety Research Program.
[
a F
NRC.
-..[
Advisory Committee on_ Reactor Safeguards i
iThe ACRS reviews requests for preapplication site and standard plant approvals, each application for a construction permit or an operating license for power
. reactors, applications for licenses to construct or operate test reactors, and
, substantive amendments to such licenses.
Consistent with the statutory charter of the Committee, ACRS reports, except for-classified reports, are made part of the public record.- Activities of the
' Committee are conducted in accordance with the Federal Advisory Committee Act which provides for public attendance at and participation.in Committee meetings.
The ACRS membership,' which is drawn from scientific and engineering disciplines, includes individuals experienced in reactor operations, nuclear reactor systems, electrical engineering, chemical engineering, civil engineering, materials engineering, mechanical engineering, nuclear engineering, reactor design, heat transfer and fluid flow, thermodynamics, reactor physics, and probabilistic j
analysis.
y During fiscal year 1989, the Committee completed its' annual report to Congress on the overall NRC Safety Research Program and other closely related matters and reported to the Commission on the hollowing specific areas:
Containment Structural Integrity Equipment Qualification-Risk-Scoping Study Embrittlement of Reactor Pressure Vessel Supports Fire Risk Scoping Study Human Factors Research Program Plan I
{
4 Individual Plant Examination Program I
Inservice Inspection of Boiling Water Reactor Pressure Vessels l-Integration Plan for Closure of Severe Accident Issues k
i Piping Integrity Safety Goal Policy Implementation Plan I
5evere Accident Management I
Thermal-Hydraulic Phenomena The Committee's activities during this period included reports on the licensing of the ALChemlE isotope enrichment facility, the Power Reactor Inherently Scfe Module (PRISM) design, the Sodium Advanced Fast Reactor (SAFR) design, the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) advanced light-water reactor require-ments document, the Modular High-Temperature Gas Cooled Reactor, the Peach Bottom Atomic Power Station restart, the operating license apolication for the Limerick Generating Station, and full-power operation of the Seabrook Station.
l 0
3
j
+
+
y.
,: M
.NRC.
Advisoryj Committee on Reactor, Safeguards -
a
'The Committee:also variety of issues, provided: special. topical reports to the NRC 'and others on a including:
p Experimental Program on B&W Steam Generators V
NUREG-1150-Severe Accident Risks:' An Assessment for five.'U.S. Nuclear Power Plants e
Implementation of the Safety Goal Policy Leak-Before-Break Technology NRC's Severe Accident Research Program Plan NRC's Human Factors Programs and Initiatives o
t Boiling' Water Reactor Core Power Stability Reliability and Diversity NRC's Thermal-Hydraulic Research Program l,
. Fire' Risk Scoping Study i
In addition,'the Committee provided advice to the NRC on proposed rules,-
criteria,: and regulatory guides, including:
i Proposed Amendment of 10 CFR 50, Appendix J, " Primary Containment Leakage Testing for Water-Cooled Power Reactors" t'
Proposed Regulatory Guide 1.9, Revision 3 " Selection, Design, Quali-fication, Testing, and Reliability of Diesel Generator Units as Onsite Electric Power Systems at Nuclear Power Plants"
. Proposed Regulatory Guide, Task No. EE-006-5, " Qualification of l
Safety-Related Lead Storage Batteries for Nuclear Power Plants" Draft Final Rule on Standardizetion and Licensing Reform, 10 CFR Part 52, "Early Site _ Permits; Standard Design Certifications; and Combined Licenses for Nuclear Power Plants" Resolution of Generic Issue 43, " Air Systems Reliability" Proposed Resolution of Generic Issue 99, " Improved Reliability of RHR Capability in PWRs" Proposed Resolution of Generic Issues 70, " Power Operated Relief Valve and Block Valve Reliability," and 94, " Additional Low-Temperature Overpressure Protection for LWRs" Proposed Resolution of Generic Issue 101, "BWR Water Level Redundancy" Proposed Final Resolution of Generic Safety Issue 103, " Design for Probable Maximum Precipitation"
y
- t
's j
NRC-1
- Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards Proposed Amendment to 10 CFR:50.61, " Fracture Toughness Requirements 7
'for Protection Against Pressurized Thermal Shock Events" Proposed Resolution of Generic Issue 115, " Enhancement of Reliability of Westinghouse Solid. State Protection Systems"
~ Proposed Resolution of Generic Issue-82, "Beyond Design Basis Acci-dents in Spent Fuel Pools" Proposed Final Rulemaking Related to Maintenance of Nuclear Power Plants
~*-
Generic. Letter Related to Occupational Exposure of Skin From Hot Particles Generic t.etter on Safety-Related Motor-0perated Valve Testing and Surveillance USI:A-17, " Systems Interactions in Nuclear Power Plants" t
Proposed Generic Letter Regarding Service Water System Problems Affecting Safety-Related Equipment Proposed Resolution of Unresolved Safety Issue A-40, " Seismic Design Criteria" Proposed Resolution of Generic Issue 79, Unanalyzed Reactor Vessel (PWR) Thermal Stress During Natural Convection Cooldown Proposed _ Resolution of Generic Issue A-29, " Nuclear Power Plant Design for Reduction of Vulnerability to Industrial Sabotage-In performing the reviews and preparing the reports cited above, the ACRS held 12 full. Committee meetings and 58 subcommittee meetings and met with the Commission occasions to provide direct advice and discussion of the issues in the reports noted above.
The Nuclear Regulatory Commission, on the basis of the technical review functions outlined.in the statutory mission of the Committee, appoints ACRS o.,
members from the scientific and engineering disciplines with three prerequisites in mind:
outstanding scientific and technical ability, balanced and mature judgment, and willingness to devote the time required to the demanding work involved. The pool of persons so qualified is limited.
At the end of September 1989, the Committee included six members from academic institutions with nuclear and nonnuclear backgrounds and'four members who have retired from active
. employment with nuclear backgrounds.
There has been a conscious effort to obtain members trained in both nuclear and the nonnuclear disciplines who have had. considerable experience in various fields needed to evaluate proposed design, construction, and operation of nuclear power plants and related facil-ities.
This permits and fosters a concentration within the Committee of scien-tific and engineering proficiency, together with a diversity of viewpoints and perspectives, which provides assurance that adequate, independent open dis-cussion and analysis of the potential hazards of nuclear reactors and the adequccy of safety standards can take place.
s t;
v.,
lNRC-Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards During FY 1989, the membership included those experienced in reactor operations, nuclear reactor systems, electrical engineering, chemical engineering, civil engineering, materials engineering, mechanical engineering, nuclear engineering, reactor design, heat transfer and fluid flow, thermodynamics, reactor physics, and probabilistic analysis.
To provide for public involvement in the nominating process for ACRS members, the NRC issues public announcements soliciting nominees to maintain a list of-candidates for appointment of members when vacancies arise.
In the past, nominations have been received from the public, including organizations such as public interest groups and technical societies, and we expect this interest to continue when future vacancies are announced.
Further, the diversity of view-points presently represented by current ACRS members is broadly based from the standpoint of special fields of interest, employment experience, ar.f scientific or technical specialty.
These membership characteristics provide the committee with a balance of highly qualified technical experts in the nuclear and non-nuclear fields necessary to carry out the Committee's statutory requirements.
20C.
The ACRS and its subcommittees held 70 meetings during FY 1989.
The number of meetings-held is directly related to the number of reactor projects referred by-the Nuclear Regulatory Commission to the Committee for review; the number of generic issues which arose during the year; the number of criteria and guides
-referred to the Committee for review and comment; the number of DOE and D0D reactor projects referred; the number of special reviews requested by the NRC and Congress; and areas of particular interest / concern to the Committee. The full Committee normally meets once a-month for a three-day session to consider projects, generic and special reviews, and criteria and regulatory guides that
'are ready for full Committee consideration. ACRS subcommittees meet as neces-
.sary with licensees, NRC staff, and others to develop information for the Committee on the particular matters under review and to identify-those matters warranting particular attention by the full Committee.
If the Committee is to continue to meet the requirements of the statute which established it, and the later additions and amendments, it will need to continue to meet at a similar frequency in the future.
200.
As established by the Atomic Energy Act of 1954, the Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards is a group of part-time experts mandated to perform certain t.
specific functions and provide advice to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission with
-regard to the potential hazards of proposed or existing nuclear facilities and the adequacy of proposed reactor standards. The Committee is unique in that there exists no comparable body composed of acknowledged experts in the field of nuclear reactor safety whose Congressi with independent advice in this area. gal mandate is to provide the Commission The Commission necessarily has its own N
The Kemeny Commission recommended that the Committee members continue as part-time appointees and stated their belief that the independence and high quality of the members might be compromised by making them full-time Federal employees.
a NRC
-9
~ Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards; expert staff on whom it relies in the day-to-day regulation of nuclear power facilities. However, there is no other advisory committee, either within the Commission or in other agencies, with the current, broadly based knowledge of the.ACRS which could be called upon to provide advice to NRC for independent assessments of reactor safety issues, in' addition, since ACRS members are primarily part-time advisors with other full-time interests and activities in related fields, they generate an organized synergistic approach to provide a breadth of experience and state-of-the-art' technical knowledge which'would be difficult to duplicate with full-time govern-ment employees.
A continuing committee such as the ACRS also. remains current with respect to nuclear safety. issues,-including related reactor operating experience and safety-research, and provides a collegial judgment regarding these issues that would be impossible.to duplicate by use of individual, part-time consultants on a case-l by-case basis.
Through the ACRS, the public and the Congress are provided assurance that an independent technical review and evaluation of nuclear reactor projects and safety issues is accomplished and an opportunity for public input during ACRS'
. meetings is assured.
20E,-
During-this period, the Committee held 12 full Committee meetings.
Portions of these meetings were closed and time spent in closed sessions occupied approxi-mately 7 hours8.101852e-5 days <br />0.00194 hours <br />1.157407e-5 weeks <br />2.6635e-6 months <br />.
Approximately 1 hour1.157407e-5 days <br />2.777778e-4 hours <br />1.653439e-6 weeks <br />3.805e-7 months <br /> of the closed sessions involved discussion of _ safety-related information which was classified, proprietary, or was related to de-tailed plant security arrangements.
The other 6 hours6.944444e-5 days <br />0.00167 hours <br />9.920635e-6 weeks <br />2.283e-6 months <br /> of closed sessions involved discussions of internal agency management and personnel practices, including information the release of which-would have constituted a clearly unwarranted invasion of personal privacy if made public.
1 i
l
' ~
y y
f ".,
' ' T.[
U g i*
,Q
. ANNUAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE MEMBERSHIP LIST :
,",',\\'x p
lh
- lNSTRUCTIONS:
Complete one form for EACH committee existin0 any time durin0 the fiscal year (1o-01 to 9-30L For tiem :B, List members' cirectly.on this-form, or attach 30ency list contatnm0 feQuested Otto.
- 1. DEPARIl4N1 OR AGENCY ;
- 2. COMM61 TEE OR 5VDCOMM4ITEE (Full name, as chert 9 fee 3.F45 CAL ttAR NRC' Advisory Committee,on Reactor Safeguards 1989.
1
- 4. Nat4. ORGANtIAllONAL li1Ll.. AND AGENCY ADDRES5 OF DESIGNAIED FEDER AL OFFICEll:
s Mr. Raymond-F. Fraley, Executive ~ Director USNRC/ACRS~
. Washington', DC' 20555' 5.-10f AL NUMBER OF ALL ' MEMBERS SERVING DurJNo FISCAL YEAR 10.
- 6. LIST OF MEMBERS SERVING DURING FISCAL YEAR (NOTE: Indicate chairperson (s) by placin0 an asterisk (#) to the lef t of name.)
MEMBER NAME OCCUPATION (OR AFFILIATION) _
Ketirea rianager, nuciear uperations aupport. uupc Carroll, James C.
Mr.
1 Pacific Gas & Electric' Catton, Ivan Dr.
rroressor or tngineering, vept. or riecnanicai,.
Aerospace and Nuclear Engineering,'UCLA.
L Kerr, William' Dr.
Froressor or nuclear engineering-University of Michigan
. Lewis, Harold W. Dr'.
Professor of Pnysics, Department of Pnysic5 University of California
.Michelson,' Carlyle Mr.
Ketired U1 rector, Oft 1Ce for Analysis ano.
Evaluation of Operational Data, USNRC
~ CRemick,. Forrest J. Dr.
Associate Vice-President for Research and Protes of Nuclear Engineering, Penn-State
' Shewmon, Paul G. Dr.
Professor, Metallurgical-Engineering Department Ohio State University
.Siess, Chester P. Dr.
Professor Emeritus of. Civil Engineering University of Illinois Ward, David A. Mr.
Retired Research Manager, E.1.. du: Pont de Nemour-
& Co., Savannah River Laboratory Wylie, Charles J. Mr.
Retired Chief Engineer, Electric-Division, Duke Power Company 1 %
.ma
~.ac.-
. v
.+*'t.
n '_;;d.
w'1 k,',1s - w%g%u,,i w--.;r_
~[.a.;
J,, ~, n,.,
J
, ~,
"4
)4*
+,,
. v
~.:d m-W p
4 4
i:'4'
&,43 [n'>
7
'r #
Q t~a y.54_3
. ;Q t, n.,
bi g:*.-; _
~M' :.
- . M
- t i. F
-.. r < (
s
- .A '
&nf h a' v i s _. Y W_ r ' r i
.c e
en y
- t J.f t )
. w~ ~ -,'-. ;' bjd {
- y 6.9 9
.- i P; 1
+
- 1
.l
-i u T. e.
,r. -
s-t
.a
- =
+
J 4'
l?'
p t
..p h..:,%],'k.,a ':.
G 0, l
. )' i J3 d'
- 4
,f(.
3 a:. %,
- m.,#m n,i,..
m
- .Pg
- c. \\
d<
- c...:
a.
z
,,g ga m.
,.4;' ' '
,) '
c.
,. g> F s.<
, h kM.h5 Y
<(.
i i;7 @%
I'9 M
a
~.
n
.y i:' !
.j..-
igs--
p(.:.y&g,Q l [
-l
,I
-,l s
i +
+
(
7,,
/. -.
g
_h.3-_.--
@ 4^... sC z Ad'v' 7isory Committee oncReactor Safeguards-afi 4j
.f; t J
1 e
.a E M,;
1,. iOCCUPATIONAll GROUPS: l Tota l, Number ; of; Members : by,0ccupa t i ona l Codel
^ 3)
. -u a
i m
l.
E?
Occupational Code:
05'
'101 TM a
h.
Number of Members:L Y
. 'T '
o
'4
'. I hh a
. d
h[
6 s
,y-i, j
[h /,'fD
- i. I L
s-
.i 1.I J1 4'
ih y.N s.
i
- q' w,
O
-:- y
. ;,k i,v{ '.,
/ j' [ ;
[ f, l1,'
.l
-%5{[4 y
.4
'{
4-
-f.
m
.:I'
()I - i ',.
'f g
Y.'.~[
n.
- y
(
},
m'
- k 1
'., z
_., _y(
- + 5[
4
,'p
!n.
.I b_
"e L
h 9
., O
,\\J.
l}
e.
b
)
4
.0.'
+,
T ns t.9 l?
'> ;. 3
? ( ',I
(
.'4 7
1 3._-
1w".,
1.+v.c a
.g
.-Y
(,
sF g '
'm'4
'n), g'
'.{
4
,p N
it 2
4
(
- h;
")f-
- b,
- y.
=
')^
,1 Y![
- If Y
f4g 3'1) {. i 9
a r
3 ) ik
.-1
.t
'I
'h y
~
4' 1'
(
\\
)
.h.g
'd(
4
')
t
- i..
<y 4
[
s
, -; l
- 'i r l 'b..
.1f.h
,[ fI m.
..~
i..._......,
.:,,-..:...---..<----,*"-~"*'""*"'*" ' ' "
g
- - i.
. ~
.mWV. L
.,..y)-
% !,". h 2 h' T 'f' _QQ'.' _ jd' " '.
-v%-
-+4 z
4 r ~
I
\\
- lmT hn:S yf *E. '-G_, __ a. 9 ejk ;, %y, J
Ly~[
%.?
I.d' o
m.
3
_{
I y? ? Nm'{Q; q,c:-
- $m[Mp %,%,[3.
D'
_t
~.
3 s
't~^h
}-u-A,
(
n
.',~h 4
g
.j ) -
i, s
el-mc y- -(,' $~4l m, % 4 W;d -r,!4.il q t, r,v.
,3
~
o.r
=--M-
- [ _
u w.
4
.,r 4_
f !. -g-;.
s e
w W. a u,,-
o oa W
- 4 c
4 r. y
'd--
s t
iM f fakw t.
4 r
i <
y.;. WQ, %.1%@~ 4
-,i@n.' l..
Y c>
-c.
6:
Q.i 2
n
.- u n--
i.'
+-
)
k
- S
, 9 / dpd r
'i i
d
- ')
l'.&!:V ffji:
e iJ q _' -
din:
7;r a -
a. '#'s.f
.-~am
,..'..)i' o
l
.g
/2
.1 4
1 s
n'. r.
5d{,
1 -
h., b /.,,
i
,n %s.-..
f.
7 i
.I,..
.;;&l,yq
-l ip g
1.: C;.y
!. )?
",}.m.
- }
0 -
-g~..
1 jit,N ;lJ"& ';
\\p
,71 k.
' l U. yE:
. { :,)
$!y, ' j 3
s.
i.
Zh;
[
.r 9% af M D> s
.m n p' R.5(Advisory..c-w-
u,,
m.
-Committee lonfReactorJSafeguards?
c D
c a
3 c -.3.
- H $s w[. y.s.
.+
m r
Of'kW ll: < f *
- c 4
w g-e, 1f 4
m 1$
$, p, m.t..%x?2 W !!NDUSTRY' GROUPS:6
- Total 1Numbercof Members b...
.,..ycIndustry Code; a
m s. -
c 3.
o
..~-
%%Tc LInSustryCode:
- 01 L O2 i A.
- 03. ' '
~
fNumbercof Members:-
?
S wu a w '
L Tn' 3
7 Jb-A MC L
m
-yg:;;r z.g i ;;; _
y.
'. '::% '. ':-hh.
);
s 7
o
' tis
'xcn__
E s
e, kA y.5 g
-a
- e
'+
b 1
4
?
k 4
4 %y.s;g-
~.c-q u,
up',
4 O.
^
,. 'P y
- t 74 so,
~f.'
F t,.h; a m
a c
2
- p AI d, #. i..k.
e,.
- d. [
S.,
-'h
'(,.
- , Ni '
. iI.
' Y,j
'- T s, u e..
4
- C.. -0
- A. i.
.; :. 7 7
529.
- i 14
.;g i
r
-k.
tIi-
,3 i
i :
,a
..:1'
.'[
a".v*
- W' 2
L p
s i ;
\\
f I
S I
,5g
.R-
". ( 4~he'1 4 '
]
e 4
,-1 4
s t
--of
- 4. [ ^. 4 s:
.;g
- g
- =
=y n-
- y4 s
t t
'\\_,
d i
Y i
- m... -
.g<' y r e
,n_
r
$t. g
,,' ( m w Q-}:
, i gy, n
,e e
i,,
1 I
j 4 Q.
- f L
,5'iG, 3 ::-
i s
i f 4
3
%' b
.f i.3 y
pL7
-')
i e
m
..'.-i q,'Y
{_
J 4
5-bi n
.t i
+
- &.,i l
~
E. >m.
i t$Q v
- t vu
., + Y
- h
= - . [ d, P a, m' ! -p u g. _,. s I h jh ,jr .4. i lk l, s 4 V ( t ( l w ' tf ( l.
- --,.t fA 9
iQ,. s y ? % i: J ii., t i {;- ]h ; ...,-n.--s, ..w + W. o + m-i t ' ', b W 'g n - i a l ygn ~, u ?s.,-. \\ r ~. - ,m......-. . ~. _.,, -. _ _ _, < s .s .,m. +,r u.,.-+
j ' ANNUAL REPORT- - REVIEW CF FEDERAL ADYlSCRY CDMMITTEE '* * * '* [,,$' ],'g*,,' [ ' "' INSTRUCTIONS: Complete one form f or E ACH committee existing any time curing the fiscal year (10-01 to 9-30). Cite All dates. j numerals (Month, day, year). If additional space is necessary, use Section F " Remarks
- on the reverse, j
- 1. DEP AR TMEN T OR AGENCY
- 2. F 45C AL Y E AR
) NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 1989
- a. COMMinEE OR susCOuu aTEe w e nome es en.,i.,e.
Advisory CommitteeOn the Medical Uses of ' Isotopes SECTION A - COMMITTEE STATUS
- 4. a5 TMIS COMMIT TEE NEW DURING Fl$C AL YEAR 7
- 5. CURRENT CH ARTER DATE
- a. EXPECTED RENE WV AL 7. EXPECTED TERMINATION DATE DATE DATE O YES No 04/04/89 04/04/90 aA. MA5 THI5 COMMITTEE BEEN TERMINATED DURING eB. SPECIFIC IER MIM A T 60N AU THORITY (if by low, aC. AC TUAL TERMINATION D A TE FISCAL YEAR 1 (if "YES". complete items eB and aC) cite U.S.CJ
} YES @ NO NOTE: If box 98 or DC is checked complete tiems 10A and 108 and provide a brief explanation m " Remarks".
- a. AGENCV RECr""5NDAT 60N FOR COMMIT TEE FOR NEXT FiSC AL YEAR 10 A, 15 LEGISL ATION REQUIRED 105.15 5UCH LEGi3LATION TO MERGE OR TERMINATE?
PENDING OR ENACTED 7 { A. CONTINUE B. MERGE O c 'caula^te vis ao O ves ao SECTION 8 - COMMITTEE AUTHORITY AND TYPE
- 11. EST ABLiSMMENT AUIMORIIY (Cnect ONLY ones A. SPECiriC Atty oiRECTEo sY L Aw
- 8. AUTHORizEo ey law O C. AGENCY AuTHoRITv
[ o. PRE 31DENTIAL DIRECTIVE
- 12. SPECIFIC ESTABLI5NMENT AU THOR IT V til by law.
l3. kFFgvj"D ATE OF
- 14. COMMITTEE IvPt (Cneca litTHER A or 5. and C. if -
cite U.s.Ca ^ 42 U.S.C. Sec 2201 July 1958 O A. AO HOC '
- 8. CONTINUING C. PRESIDENTIA
- 15. DESCRIPTION OF COWITEt (Cneca ONLY ones C. SCIENTIFIC /
A. NATIONAL B. NON-SCIENTIFIC TECHNIC AL POLICYlisSUE P ROGR AM PROGR AM
- 0. GRANT E. REGULATORY F. OMER ADVISOR Y ADVISOR Y ADVISORY REVIEW NEGOTI A T ION
($pecifp SECTION C - COMMITTEE ACTIVITY DURING FISCAL YEAR iaA. TOT AL NvMBER OF 105. Lisi REPOR I TITLES AND DATES (Montn. can l' REPOR TS 1 y " Review of Transcript Of hearing on November 7, 1988..." l-
- 17. NUMBER OF MEEi!NGS
- t. DATES & ALL Mtt nNGs (Monm. cap A. OPEN B. CLOSED C. P AR TIALLY CLOSED D. TOT AL (A = S
- C)
F. DATES OF OTHER ACTIVITIE5 (DescriDe en "Remerns ') 1 l. SECTION D - COMMITTEE COST ' NOTE: Express costs m whole collars. (00 NOT use decimals. K, M, N/A, or leave blank, indicate "O". if soolicable). CURRENT NEXI l-
- 10. OESCRIPitON FISCAL YEAR FISCAL YE AR (Actual)
(Estimate) l (1) NON-FEDERAL MEMBERS 1,980 8 2,000 A. PERSONNEL (2) FEDERAL MEMBERS (Prorated salary) 5,739 5,739 PAYMENTS (3) FEDERAL SI AFF (Prorated salary) 0 0 (4) NONMEMBER CONSULTANTS 0 0 (1) NON-FEDERAL MEMBERS 1,652 12,000 B. TR AVEL (2) FEDERAL MEMBERS 0 0 PER IEM (3) FEDERAL STAFF 0 0 (4) NONMEMBER CONSULT ANTS 1.905 0 C. OTHER (rents. user charges, graphics, printing, mailing, etc.) 175 400 D. TOTAL > $ 11,451 4 20,139 f'
- 19. FEDERAL ST AFF SUPPORT YEARS EXPRESS IN FULL ilME EQUlvALENT (FTD YEARS USN) DECIMAL TO THE NEAREST TENTH (e.g. 0.0). >
O.1 0.1 l [ (FIGURE $@ULD CORRESPOM) TO DOLLAR COST IN ITEM 18A(3). A80VEJ h ~-GENERAL SERVICES ADMINISTRATION _ GS A _ FORM [-820-_HjRW, _7-Jll
s.i f,
- i
-l 1 r.3 W ', SECTION E CIMMITHE ACCOMPLISHMENTS ANO JUSTFICATION - (CImplete this sectGn ONLY 'for committe:S where items 4 "NO*. BA 'NO* and 9A *Contmue* ar ' iga. pg3CRigt NOW THE Cr""flITEE ACCOWL65HE5 (T5 PURPOSE By e checked)~ ON AGENCV OPERAT80NS. BE A6 SPECIFIC AS POS$18LE AND INCLUDE WORKL s . \\ (Attached): I { =- F95. DEUCRIBE THE BALANCE OF 64h4ER5 HIP (N TERMS OF POtNIS OF V l[ W REPRESENTED AND FUNCTIONS PERFORlWD. (Attached). t i::- .if .20C. DE5CRIBE THE FREQUENCY OF MEETING 5 AND THE RELEV ANCE TO CONTINVING INE COMM41 TEE. I 1 1 -(Attached) i i 'l I.. 1 l 1
- l
- 200. EXPl AIN WHY THE ADVICE OR 6NFORMAllON C ANNOT BE OBTAINED FROM OTHER SOvRCES.
l>
- )
L (Attached) l i i i i l-i I { ' 20E. 4F APPLIC ABLE, EXPLAIN WHY II WAS NECESSARY TO CLOSE AND/OR PARIlALLY CLOSE COMMIT TE I 1: N/A -l l' a -f,.- II"ufMARas SECTION F - REMARKS i 1 1 -GS A FORM T-820-H BACK(Afm 7-L
y; - 4.< a. .x ' 'AlWUAL ADVISERY CEMMITTEE MEMBERSHIP LIST. '" "* f" [,'[' [ " . INSTRUCTIONS: Complete one form f or E ACH commstlee existmg any lime durmg the fiscal year (10-01 to 9*.30). for lism 6. List members directly on this form, or attach a0ency list contammg requested data. a ,T"BWAu rures t on Aarucy a, c e rzivirt on suecosesstrrE vuis name, es enerioree
- 3. Fiscal veAn
'NRC Advisory Committee'on the Medical Uses of Isotopes ~ 1989 NAN tZ AlioN AL 14TLL. AND AGENCY ADDREs3 oF DESIGNAIED FEDER AL OFFictR: Francis A. St. Mary Division of Industrial and Medical Nuclear Safety, NMSS Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.- 20555 Mail Stop 6-H3 o - 5. TOTAL' NUMBER OF ALL MEMBERS SERVING OURING FISCAL YEAR 9
- 6. LIST OF MEMBERS SERVING DURING FlSCAL YEAR tNOTE: Indicate chairperson (s) by placing an asterisk (e) to the lef t of name.)
!I MEMBER NAME I OCCUPATION (OR AFFILIATION) -Collins Vincent P. (M.D.) Medical Director. Houston Institute of Cancer Res. Diag. 'aCunningham, Richard E. Director Division of Industrial and Medical Nuclear Safety, NRC DeNardo, Sally J.-(M.D.) Associate Professor, Radiology /Nuc. Medicine, Univ. of California 4 Goodrich, Jack K. (M.D.) Nuclear Medicine Radiology Associates of Erie' Griem, Melvin-L. (M.D.) Director, Chicago Tumor Intitute University of Chicago Herrerra, Nilo E. (M.D.) Director, Dept. of Laboratory Med. DAnbury Hospital Pohost, Gerald M. (M.D.) Director, Div. of Cardiovascular l- ? Disease, University of Alabama j Wabster, Edward W. (Ph.D.) Director, Div. of Radiological Sc. l' l Massachusetts General Hospital Woodbury, David H. (M D.) Director, Nuclear Medicine Westland Medical Center (3ENERAL SERVICES ADMINISTRATION GS A FORM T-821-H (REV. 7-89)
n' v. ..m ( 3 h 'NRC ADVISORY. COMMITTEE ON THE MEDICAL-USES OF IS0 TOPES (0774) FY1989 ANNUAL REPORT 20A cont. HOW COMMITTEE ACCOMPLISHES ITS PURPOSES' The NRC staff believes that both licensees and the public in general benefit when recognized experts provide advice to the staff on certain medical issues in which NRC's standards may be unclear or inapplicab_le and when these experts can provide advice on rulemaking and other initiatives at critical stages t throughout their development. In response to the Commission's directions to NRC staff to develop a rule on quality assurance.(QA) in radiation therapy and other issues pertaining to the medical use of byproduct material, in November 1988, members of the ACMUI met.in public session and received comments from the medical community on ways to improve QA procedures. A report and analysis of statements.made at the meeting was submitted to the NRC staff for their use in developing the Commission's proposed rule. 208 cont. BALANCE OF MEMBERSHIP The Committee's membership started the year with 5 physicians, a medical physicist, and an NRC staff member who chairs the Committee. Two physicians, a medical physicist, and a medical technologist were added to the Committee during the year. The members, well-recognized specialists in their own-fields,. ~ are from different parts of the United States, represent such private office-and hospital-based practices, represent teaching and non-teaching hospitals, l and include two women and one minority member. The physician-members' i-specialties include diagnostic and therapeutic radiology, internal medicine, L cardiology, nuclear medicine and pathology. The scientist-members have broad . backgrounds in radiation safety, in medical physics associated with both l L diagnostic and therapeutic uses of radiation and radioactive materials, and radiopharmacy. The technologist member has experience in both nuclear medicine and hospital administration. 20C cont. MEETING FREQUENCY 1 The Committee meets approximately once a year and is publicly convened to T ' discuss controversial issues with the potential for wide impact. / 200 cont. WHY ADVICE CANNOT BE OBTAINED FROM OTHER SOURCES The information and advice obtained from the Committee members is not available i. .i L through other NRC resources because NRC has no physicians, medical physicists, pharmacists, or practicing technologists on its staff. There are no other sources for obtaining advice from such a body of well-recognized experts in the specialties needed. I w +-- v m. ...m
.~ l 1 .g ANNUAL REPORT REVIEW OF FEDERAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE * ' ' '[,,* 'h",'g*,'x g' ' " ' " " 4 INSTRUCTIONS: Complete one f orm f or E ACH committee existing any time dormg the fiscal veer (10-01 to 9-30). Cite ALL Cates 6 numerais (Month, Cey, year). If addmorial space is necessary, use Section F, *Remerts* on the reverse.
- 1. DEP AR TME N T OR AGENC Y
- 2. f i5C AL vt AR NRC 89
- s. COMun m OR wsCCwunm (si rie ne. s ene, mea, r
~'i v ? o. a s .t r.t u c. m... c. i t n.in .1 FM r on" .re i isl a e i 1m . Adva sory. Panel,,.for.'i.tje : Decont,amiDattw tofLTtMr2ing. : t 3 ! : n,x 9 i; iiri n m - ,.e mn n : $ECTION A - COMMITTEE STATUS ' d. 15 T N 5 COMMs1 TEE NEW DURING FI5C AL YEAk?
- 5. CURRENI CHAR TER DATE
- e. EXPECTED RENEW AL
- 7. EXPEC TED TERMIN A1 ON D ATE DATE DATE.
vis >O No 11/28/88 11/28/90 eA. na.s Twis COMMITTEEn C At ye ART m vis,.E.N. TERM._ ihalf D DU.R I.NG BE eB. 5.P E.C IF IC TERMIN AT ION AUTHOR iT V (if by low. eC. AC TU AL TERMIN A T ION DATE iei nom se n eC n v.s.ca vts E NO NOTE: If box 9B or 9C Lt Checked, comDiete items 10A and 10B and provide a brief explanetton m "Remerts".
- a. AGENCY RE C OMME ND Al lON FOR COMM6TTEE FOR NE XT Fi3C AL YE AR ICA. 15 ttGi3L ATiON REQUIRED 105.15 50CN tE015LAllON 10 h4RGE OR TfRMINATE?
etNDiNG OR INACI(D? Q A. CONTINUE B. MERGE C. T[RMINAtt vi$' Q NO O vis O No SECTION B - COMMITTEE AUTHORITY AND TYPE
- 11. [51 ABgi5NMENI Au1NORi1Y (Checa ONiv ones O A 5'rc *'e^t'v o'Reeiro ev t AW
- e. AutNORizeo av taw g e. AceNCv AutNORirv t o. eksiioiNt At oiticiive
- 12. SPEC AFic E51 A86 65NMENT AVINOR617 (81 Dy law.
ene u.s.Ca
- 13. EFFINORdv C T iv D ATI, OF I4. C OMM s T TEE TYPE (Checa ';iTMER A or 5. eno G, et AU esee pnew 42 U.S.C. Sec 2201 10/1/80 A.Ao NOc
- s. cONtiNuiNo
- c. PRisierNiiAt
- 15. Dl5CR IP TION OF COMMITEE (Checa ON$v one) t C. SClfNTiFIC/
A. N AllON AL B. NO*v$Cl!NTIFIC T(CNN LC AL FOLICvtS$Ut PROGv4M P R OGR AM o.ORANT f.RECutATORY
- 7. OTHER AovisOR v -
ADv lSOR v ADVISOR v REVIEW NE COT I AT ION (Spetit vl { SECTION C - COMMITTEE ACTIVITY DURING FISCAL YEAR i lea.. TOT AL NUMBER OF 168. L iS T R EP OR 1 1 TLES AND DAf ts (Montn. cey> l Rt90Ris. 0m ' ' 01 Di ( f, t.1 h It'? s, 31 ^' N' 'ONE' ' ". G7*1 ' i th ! ? 9'11 J.hs I (:ll b.') * ? I M%: 9!'O ?i c: 0 ' ' 'J ' .JI' 07
- 17. NUMBER OF ME E ltNGS
- t. D A m OF ALL MEEIlha (Month, car)
A. OP E N
- e. CLOSED C.PARTiAtty CtO5ED D. TO1 Ac iA. e. C) 10/25, 2/16, 4/13, 9/21 l
,4 0 0 4 F. D ATES OF OTHER ACTiv4 TIE 5 (Desce,De in 'Remeras1 \\ 1-SECTION D - COMM4TTEE COST NOTE: Express costs m wnote doliers. (00 NOT use decimals, K. M, NIA, or leave bient, maicate *O*, if eDoliceDie). CURRENT NEXT
- 18. DESCRIPilCN FISCAL YEAR FISCAL YEAR (Actust)
(Estimate) (1) NON-FEDERAL MEMBERS U U A. PERSONNEL (2) FEDERAL MEMBERS (Prorated setery) U V l PAYMENTS (3) FEDERAL ST AFF (Prorated selery) 1p yqq (4) NONMEMBER CONSULT ANTS 1p70n n n (1) NON-FEDERAL MEMBERS 3nqp innn )
- 8. TRAVEL (2) FEDERAL MEMBERS AND n
n PER OtEM (3) FEDERAL ST AFF ggj 97n (4) NONMEMBER CONSULT ANTS n n C. OTHER (rents, user energes, greDnics, prmtmo, mailing. etc.) I rariSC r l plS/ H00m/ Aua ) 0 dQnd Gnnn D' T TA'
- $ 24397 e 25070
- 19. FEDERAL ST AFF SUPPORT YE ARS EXPRESS N FULL TIME EQUIVALENT (FID YEARS USIPC DECIMAL TO THE NEAREST TENTH (e g. 0.0). >
(FIGURE SHOULO CORRESPOPO 10 DOLLAR COSI IN ITEM 18A(3). ABOVE.) 0.5
- 0. 5 GFNFRAI RF R W'F R A nkAlkiltTD ATinki
0 SECTION E - COMMITTEE ACCOMPUSHMENTS AND JUSTFICATION ~ (Complete this section ONLY f or committees where items 4 "NO*, 8 A *NO*, and G A *continve* era checked) l CNfaATfoN et As sN$ As eo'siiBLfAw!f $t("p$*[de$4((N$CA Oft U aEnsTE.' A sA The panel met four times during FY88 to consider a variety of topics including the licensee's proposal to place TMI-2 in-long term storage, the detailed operation of the Accident Generate ' Water Processing System, offsite radiation monitoring, and the licensee's schedule for completing defueling. On October 24, 1988 the Advisory panel met in Washington, D.C. to provide the Commission the Panel's position on various issues and inform the Commission on. Public concerns in TM1 site area. In the yst the panel has been responsible for modifying the NRC's Regulatory activities in the cMQp effort. M. DE5CR IBE THE B AL ANCE OF WWE R 5M 6P IN TERM 5 OF POINTS VF view REPRE5ENTED AND FUNCTION 5 PERFORWD, The Panel is composed of. local citizens, scientists and politicians. It includes members tha are both supportive as well as critical of the actions taken by the licensee and regulatory .. agencies. A number of scientific disciplines are represented, including engineering, health physics and physics. The Commonwealth of Pennsylvania is represented, as well as local government. The Panel functions as a collegial body that, after hearing reports by various organizations and discussion among the members, votes on various positions or resolutions ano communicates them to the NRC Commissioners. 70C. DESCRigt TML FREQUENCY 05 MEETINC5 AND ThE RELEv ANCE TO CONisNuaNG THE COMMIT TEt, The Panel has in the past met between four and 12 times per year. The frequency of meetings is dependent on the number of issues before the Panel and perceived public interest. The frequency of meetings is sufficient to justify continuance of the Panel. "N'i$iEip"Yl*pIEposeoT"6e*PYn'ef'fl Th'$FoWM d"'foNWAYfzed conduit to the NRC Commissioner informing them of the concerns of the local citizens regarding the TMI-2 cleanup effort. Thi _ purpose is site specific and requires input from people in touch with and able to communicate with the public. 20E, IF APPL IC ABLE, E XPL AIN WMY iT W AS NECESSAR Y 10 CLOSE AND/OR P AR TIALLY CLOSE COMMsTTEE MEE T IN GS. l l Not Applicable l L SECTION F - REMARKS l CC A r esm. T. O *1n a a nanu _
Y - .e_ . 9: ^ .f i ' si, l r ((\\' i g ANNUAL-ADVISORY COMMITTEE MEMBERSHIP LIST ((],',*,'[' ' " ' I h' '. INSTRUC11oNS: Complete one form for E ACH committee existing any time durme the fiscal year (10-01 to 9-30). For tiem 6. List members cirectly on this form, or ettech agency hst containing requested cate. .1. DEP AR IWNT OR AGENCY.
- 2. COMM41 TEE OR 5v8COMM4ITEE (Fut6 name, as chartof te
- 3. Fl5G AL YE AR
'NRC . Advisory Panel;for the Decontamination of TMI-2' 89 t ( d. NAW. ORGANilATION AL I4TLI.. AND AGENCY ADDRES5 OF oE5IONATED FED (R AL OFFICER: Michael, T. Masnik : ^ U.:S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C.- 20555-1
- 5. lotAL NUMBER OF ALL' MEMBERS SERVING'oVRING FISCAL YEAR fl
- 6. LIST OF MEMBERS SERVING DURING FISCAL YEAR (NOTEt indicate chairperson (s) by piectng en esterisk (#) to the lef t of name.)
MEMBER NAME = OCCUPATION (OR AFFILIATION) l l Gersuky, Thomas M. Director, Penna Bureau of' Radiation Protec-Luetzeichwab, John W. Dr. Professor 9 - Marshall, Elizat'eth N. Real Estate' Agent Miller, Kenneth L. Health Physicist
- florris, Arthur E.
Mayor ? Rice,-Frederick S. Financial Consultant . Robinson,-Gordon E.'Dr. Professor Roth, Joel Salesman Smithgall, Thomas D. Real Estate Broker Trunk, Ann D. Housewife Wald, Neal Dr. Professor f - GENERAL SERVICES. ADMINISTRATION. etar^-- ' " "
m. L 7 [ , 2, 7 e ANNUAL REPORT REVIEW OF FEDERAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE '" $oS A N ' nu sNSTRUC TIONS: Complete one form f or E ACH commitlee existing any time curing the fiscal year (10-01 to 9-30). Cne ALL Catsl numerais (Month, car, yearl.11 accitional sDace is necessary..use Section F, " Remarks" on the reverse,
- t. DEP AR IMENI OR AGENCY
- 2. FI5C AL TE AR United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission 1989
- 3. COMM6T1[E OR SUBCOMMtITLE (Fun name as chartereo)
High Level llaste Licensing Support System Advisory Committee SECTION A - COMMITTEE STATUS
- 4. IS IHt5 COMMilIEE NEW DURING F e5 CAL YE Akt
- 6. CURRENI CHAR TER D AIE
- 6. EXPEC TED RENEW AL
- 1. EXPEC TED TERMiNAllON D All DATE DATE O ve8 Bao' 8-4-87 8-4-89 4A. HAS IHIS COMMIITEE BEEN IERMIN ATED DURING
- 48. SPEC IF 4C IERMIN AliON AUINOR4TV (itbysaw, aC. AC TU AL TERMIN AllON DATE FISCAL Yt AR7 tif "YES*, compieto stems 48 ano aC) cete U.S.CJ 0 vis Oao terminated in FY 89 Charter's two years expired 8-4-89 NOTE: 11 Dox 98 or 9C is checkec, complete items 10A and 108 and Drovide a Drief explanauon in
- Remarks".
- 9. AGE NC Y R MEND AllON FOR COMMiITEE FOR NEXI FISCAL YEAR I
5 % A A T 40N REQ UIR ED 106.15 5UCH LEGI5LAT TON huRGE OR TERMINATE 7 ENDINO OR ENACTED 7 A. CONiiNUE OSMeact O c ' tam >a Ate O vt* No Ovis Owo SECTION 8 - COMMITTEE AUTHORITY AND TYPE
- 14. ESIABLISHMENI AulHOR 41v (Cnecei ONLv ones A. SPECIFIC ALLY DIRECTED BY L AW B. AUTHORIZED BY L AW Li C. AGENCY AUTHORITY
[ D. PREsiDENilAL DiRfCTIVE
- 12. SPEclF 6C EST ABLISHMENI AVIHOR al y tit Dy saw,
- 13. EFFECTIVE D Alt OF
- 14. C OMM t T TE E TYPE (Cneca hlTHER A or 8, eno C il cite U.S.CJ AU THOR IT Y appropriate)
Commission decision 7-20-87 g A.AD nOC
- e. CONiiNuiNo C. eResiDeNii 15, DESCRIP TION OF COMM4 TEE (Cneca ONLv one)
C. SCIENiiFIC/ A. N ATION AL B. NON SCIENilFIC TECHNIC Al, POLICYilSSUE PR OGR AM PROGR AM D.CRANT E. REGULATORY F. OiMER _OADvtSORY ADvlSORY ADvlSORY REVIEW NE0011 A TION (SD4CafW SECTION C - COMMITTEE ACTIVITY DURING FISCAL YEAR 16 A. IOIAL NUMBER OF 106. Lis t REPORI IITLES AND DAIES (Month, cays REPORTS none-none
- 17. NUMBER OF MEEllNGS E DAT[5 QF ALL MEETING 5 (Month. Ody)
A. OP E N B. CLOSED C. P ARIIALLY CLOSED D.10T AL (A. B
- C' N/A F, DATES OF OTHER ACliv4 TIES (Descries,n Romeras ')
none none none none N/A SECTION D - COMMITTEE COST NOTE: Express costs in whole collars. (DO NOT uso decimals, K, M, N/A, or leave blant, incicate "O", if applicaele). l CURRENI NExl
- 18. DESCRIPTION FISCAL YEAR FISCAL YE AR (Actual)
(Estimatel (1) NON-FEDERAL MEMBERS A. PERSONNEL (2) FEDERAL MEMBERS (Prorated salary) l-PAYMENTS (3) FEDERAL ST AFF (Prorated salary) (4) NONMEMBER CONSUL T ANTS (1) NON-FEDERAL MEMBERS
- 8. TRAVEL (2) FEDERAL MEMBERS PER IEM (3) FEDERAL STAFF (4) NONMEMBER CONSULI ANTS C. OTHER (rents, user charges, graphics, printing, mailing, etc.)
D. TOTAL s s l'
- 19. FEDERAL ST AFF SUPPORT YEARS EXPRESS IN FULL TIME EoVIVALENT (FTE) YEARS USING DECIMAL 10 THE NEAREST TENTH (e.g. 0.0). > !
(FIGURE SHOULD CORRESP0tO To DOLLAR COST IN ITEM 18A(3). ABOVE) o GENERAL SERVICES ADMINISTRATION GS A rnnu 1 -un-w mu u
g..- ANNUAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE MEMBERSHIP. LIST 1N IER AGENC Y REPORTS CoNTR( n- ,,,,,,,,_xx, ' INSTRUCTIONS: - For item 6,' List members directly on this lofm, of 4titch 80ency list c l:
- l. DEP ART 64NT OR ADENGv.
L CoWITEg oR 8v5CoMMilitt trual name, as enerteree L>
- 3. F 43G AL YE AR High Level Waste Licensing. Support System Advisory USNRC Committee 1989
' 4. NAMt. ORGANi2AllONAL I4TLl.'. AND AGENC Y ADDRE55 oF D(5eGNAlgD PgDERAL QFFiGER; p i Donnie H. Grimsley i . Director, Division of Freedom of Information and-Publication Services U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission-Washington, D.C. 20555 l . 5. TOTAL NUMBER -OF ALL MEMBERS SERVING DURING FISCAL YEAR ./q
- 6. LIST OF MEMBERS SERVING DURING FISCAL YEAR (NOTE: Indicate cMirperson(s) by placing en esterisk (8) to the lef t of name.)
MEMBER NAME OCCUPAllON (OR AFFILIATION) J Swainston, Harry W. State of Nevada Murphy, Mal State of Nevada Davenport, James State of Nevada Touslev, Dean R. Yakima-Indian Nation Saltzman', -Jerome' U.S. Department of Energy Echols. Stan U.S. Department of Energy Kassen, melinda Environmental Defense Fund Ortman. David Friends of the Earth Mrnft. Steven P. Edison Electric Institute Mnneenmorv.-Nnncv Edison Electric Institute 911kove. in v Attornov for EET/UNWMG
- Olmcrend tJi l l i nm U.S. Nuclear Reculatory Commission enmnenn. Fvnncin C.
U.S. Nuclear Reculatory Commission unchen1. nnnnic 01nrk Connev Lan Veens. Nevada GENERAL SERVICES ADMINISTH ATION
y i
- \\
l ] 'C ..r. ANNUAL REPORT REVIEW OF FEDERAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE ""'""d',$'],',','[g" '" "" INSTRUCilONS: numerals (Month, cay, yestL If additional space is necessary, use Section F,
- Remarks
- on
- 1. DEP AR TMEN T OR ADENCY 2.f45 CAL VEAk NRC 1989
- 3. COMM4ITEE OR SUDCOMMaITEE Wull name es charterea>
s Advisory Committee on Nuclear Waste t SECTION A - COMMITTEE STATUS
- 4.. IS THIS COMMllIEE NEw DURING f e5 CAL YE ART
- 5. CURRENT CHARTER DATE
- 4. EXPECTED RENEWAL 1. EXPEt;TED TEltMINAleON DATE I y
DATE DATE YE g NO. 05/18/88 05/18/90 NA BA. NAS THIS COMM4TIEE tit N TERMINA1ED DURING aB. SPECIFIC TERMIN AllON AUIHORIIV (if by sew, aC. ACTUAL TERMINAllON DATE FISCAL YEART (if "YE8*. 40mplete items e6 end aC) cite U 37.J YES @NO . NOTE: 11 box DB of DC is checked. complete stems 10A and 108 are previos a brief explanation m
- Remarks.
- a. AGENCY RECr"MNDAllON FOR COMMtITEE FOR NEXT f 45C AL 4(AR iOA. 45 LEG 15L AllON REQUIR ED 106.15 5UCH LEGISL AllON TO MEROE OR TERMINAIE?
PENDING OR ENACTED? Q A. CONTINUE ]8. MERGE C. TERMINATE [ YES C NO. [YES ]NO SECTION B - COMMITTEE AUTHORITY AND TYPE 11.15TABLtSHMENI AUTHORIIY (Choct ONL'r onea O A. setci'ic^'tv oiRicito BY LAW ' B. AUTHORIZED BY LAW ] C. AGENCY AUTHORITY [ 0. PRESIDENTIAL ' OIREC11vt
- 12. SPECIFIC ESTABLl5Hn4NI AUTHORIIY (H by law.
cite u.s.c.)
- 13. EFFIHoR AYDATI. OF14. COMMITTEE TYPE (Check i; LINER A er 5. eno C. d C16V AU eopropriate 42 U.S.C. Sec 2201 5/18/88 O A. A0 noc e co~tlaviao O c 'R55'otaliAt
- 15. DESCRIPTION OF CM_HIEE (Checa ONLY one)
C. SCIENilFIC/ t A. NAfl0NAL B. NON SCIENitFtc TECHNIC AL !i POLICvit3 SUE PROGRAM PROGRAM
- 0. GRANT E. REGULATORY F. OTHER ADVISOlt Y -
ADVISORY ADVISORY REVIEW NEGOilATION (SeecJyl SECTION C - COMMITTEE ACTIVITY DL:stlNO FISCAL YEAR l 16A. IO1 AL NVMBER OF Ie6. L45I REPORI IIILES AND DAIES wiontn. c.;v) l REPORis l j. 15 SEE ATTACHED l }
- 17. NUMBER OF MEEllNGS L DAIL5 QF ALL Mtt HNG5 Mnth, Odp A. OPEN D. CLOSED C. PARIIALLY CLOSED D. IOTAt (A = 8
- C)
SEE ATTACHED F. DATE5 OF OTHER AClivillE5 (Describe en *Remerts ') 6 0 4 10 SECTION O - COMMITTEE COST l NOTE: Express costs in whole dollars. (DO NOT use decimals, K, M, N/A, or leave etank, indicate "O*. If apphcaOle). 1 CURRENT NEXT
- 10. OCSCRIPitON FISCAL YEAR FISCAL YE AR (Actua0 (ggtp) _
(1) NON-FEDERAL MEMBERS 40.732 4 78,E18 A. PERSONNEL (2) FEDERAL MCMBERS (Prorated salary) PAYMENTS (3) FEDERAL STAFF (Prorated salary) tdU,bbd did,bbi (4) NONMEMBER CONSULi ANTS 40,873 40,000'- i-(1) NON-FEDERAL MEMBERS j D. TRAVEL l9,199 24,200 (2) FEDERAL MEMBERS PER IEM (3) FEDERAL ST AFF 3,115 4,400 ( (4) NONMEMBER CONSULI ANTS 20,844 26,400 C. OTHER (rents. user cnar00s, graphics, printin0. maihng, etc.) 34,045 53,500 U' I
- l 8
439,466 8 540,285
- 19. FEDERAL ST AFF SUPPORT YEARS EXPRESS IN Fult-11ME EQUIVALENT (FID YEARS UStB DECIMAL 10 THE NEAREST TENTH (e.g. 0.0). >
{ (FIGURE SFOULD CORRESPOD TO DOLLAR COSI IN ITEM 18A(3). ADOv0 Sea w
g-7 p 3 ,.a r-. s [
- [-.
SECTION E - COMMITTEE ACCOMPLISHMENTS AND JUSTFICATION ' (Complete this section ONLY for committees where llemt 4 *NO*. 8A "NO*, and 9A
- Continue
- are checked)
. 394. DE5CR IBE HOW IHE COMMtITEE ACCOMPLt3HE5 415 PURPOSE BY 5HOWING THE EFFECT OF COMMIITEE REPORI5. ADvlCE. OR RECOMMENDA140NS ON AGENCY OPERATIONS. Bt AS SPECIFIC AS POS$1BLE AND INCLUDE WORKLOAD INDICATORS AS APPROPRIATE. SEE-ATTACHED - M. DE5CR15E THE BALANCE OF WW:5 HIP IN TERM 5 OF POINT 5 OF VIEW REPRE5ENTED AND FUNCTION 5 PERFORIAD. SEE ATTACHED' -1 l l INCRisE THE FREQUENCY OF MEETINGS AND THE RELEV ANCE TO CONTINUING THE COMMIT TEE. SEE ATTACHED-l i l M. EXPLAIN WHY IME ADV4CE OR INFORMATION CANNOT BE O6TAINED FROM OTHER ' OURCES. e .i SEE ATTACHED 1 i i i - IW"4 APPoiCAstt. ExPLAie. wHv it wAs NECE5sARv 10 CLOSE AND/OR PARTIALLY CLO5E COMMIITEt VEETIN05. SEE ATTACHED 2- -{ SECTION F - REMARKS - 2 8. BEMARKS GSA ronu T-820-H BACK(nEV. "-09
[&9 , m q- [.'. w
- ,7 i
s i if NRC ~ Advisory Committee on Nuclear Waste .SECTION C e .16B. L< . REPORT TITLE DATE' 'c -Comments on the' Proposed Deletion of Section 20.205.from the 12/30 Proposed Revision of 10 CFR Part 20, " Standards for Protection r LAgainstRadiation"(SECY-88-315) Draft Generic Technical Position: Guidance'for Determination 12/30 [ of Anticipated Processes.and Events and Unanticipated Processes and Events Comments on Advance Notice.of the Development of a Commission 12/30 Policy on Exempti' ns 'from Regulatory Control for Practices Whose o Public Health and. Safety. Impacts are Below Regulatory Concern. ' Topics Raised by ACNW During the October 27, 1988, Meeting 01/04 with the Commissioners Activitiessof ACNW Concerning High-Level Waste Management .01/25 Wes't Valley Demonstration Project ,01/26 s Final Rulemaking on 10 CFR Part 61 Relative to Disposal of 02/24 Greater-Than-Class C Low-Level Radioactive Wastes Proposed Waste Confidence Decision by the Waste Confidence 05/03 Review Group. Draft Technical Position on Postclosure Seals in an Unsaturated 05/03 . Medium - Proposed Commission Policy on Exemptions from Regulatory Control 05/03 Management of Mixed Hazardous and Low-Level Radioactive Wastes 05/03 (Mixed. Wastes) ACNW Review of NRC Comments on Doe Site Characterization Plan 07/03 Rep'orting Incidents Involving the Management and Disposal of 07/05 p Low-Level Radioactive Wastes Comments on ACNW Review of the NRC Analysis of the DOE Site 08/21 Characterization Plan Comments on Technical Position Paper on Environmental Monitoring 09/19 of Low-Level Radioactive Waste Disposal Facilities a i
- b=-
m t
y . ze 13 3 . ~
- ' x x
- , '
- f
- NRCf
..L O P
- Advisory Committee on Nuclear Waste l
" 117E.- DATES OF ALL MEETINGS O> 0 .12/21: '01/23-24 '02/21'-23' 103/23 104/19: L 04/26-28 [ 05/11: O l 06/13. 06/28-30 N 09/13-15 h 1SECTION E
- i n
120A.. The Advisory ' Committee on-Nuclear Waste ( ACNW) was established by the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission in June 1988. The ACNW'is tasked in its charter- ' to, '" report to and advise the Nuclear. Regulatory Commission (NRC) on all. aspects.
- of nuclear waste management,-as appropriate, within the purview of NRC's regu-latory responsibilities.
The primary ' emphasis will be on disposal of high-level . nuclear waste but will also include other aspects such as handling, processing, ' transportation, storage, and. safeguarding.of nuclear wastes includino spent-Lfuel, nuclear wastes mixed with other hazardous substances, and ural. um mill tailings. In performing its work, the Committee will examine and r'eport on specific; areas, of concern ~ referred to it by the Commission or designated' rep-resentatives of the: Commission, and it is authorized to undertake other studies and activities.on ;its own initiative, as appropriate to carry out its respon-sibilities." y IACNW reports (except for any which may contain classified material) are made .part of the.public record. Activities of the Committee.are conducted in accor-dance.with the Federal Advisory Committee Act which provides for public atten-dance at.and participation in Committee meetings. The ACNW membership, which is ' drawn from scientific and engineering disciplines, includes individuals experi-enced-in geosciences, radiation protection, radioactive waste treatment,. -environmental engineering, nuclear engineering, and chemistry.
- During fiscal year 1989, the ACNW reported to the Commission and others on'a t
variety of issues, including: The Proposed Deletion of Section 20.205 from the Proposed Revision of C 10 CFR Part 20, " Standards for Protection Against Radiation" (SECY-88-315) Draft Generic Technical Position: Guidance for Determination of Anticipated Processes and Events and Unanticipated Processes and Ever.ts Advance Notice of the Development of a Commission Policy on Exemptions from Regulatory Control for Practices Whose Public Health and Safety impacts are Below Regulatory Concern
p '9<._. 3 y ,7, r c I C' '
- NRC,
-.. Advisory Committee on Nuclear Waste ( 1 West'. Valley Demonstration Project Final Rulemaking on 10 CFR Part 61 Relative to Disposal of Greater-Than-Class C Low-Level Radioactive Wastes-t Proposed Waste Confidence Decision-by the Waste Confidence Review Group -Draft Technical Position on Postclosure Seals in an Unsaturated Medium s 1 Proposed Commission Policy on Exemptions from Regulatory Control lianagement of Mixed Hazardous and Low-Level Radioactive Wastes (Mixed Wastes) NRC Comments on'_00E Site Characterization Plan for the High-Level ' Waste Repository 1 Reporting Incidents involving the Management and Disposal of low-Level. Radioactive Wastes .iy NRC Analysis of the DOE Site Characterization. Plan for the High-Level Waste Repository Technical Position Paper on Environmental Monitoring of Low-Level l Radioactive Waste Disposal. Facilities i In performing the reviews and preparing the reports cited above, the ACNW h' eld 9 -full Committee meetings and I working group session. The ACNW also met with the 'i l Commission on 2 occasions to provide direct advice and discussion of the issues in 1 2 0 B.' -the report #noted above. 1 The. Nuclear-Regulatory Commission,. on the basis of the ' technical review functions outlined in the Committee's charter, appoints ACNW members from scientific and engineering disciplines with three prerequisites in mind: outstanding scientific and technical ability, balanced and mature judgment, and willingness to devote the time required to the demanding work involved. The pool of persons so qualified is limited. At the end of September 1989, the 1 Committee included three. members from academic institutions, and one member who is an employee of a national laboratory. There has been a conscious effort to 'obtain: members with backgrounds that can address the difficult and diverse questions associated with radioactive waste disposal. This permits and fosters -a concentration of scientific proficiency within the Committee, together with a diversity of viewpoints and perspectives, which provides assurance that ade-quate, independent open discussion and analysis of the potential hazards of 1 nuclear waste can take place. ] During FY 1989, the membership has included engineers and scientists experienced in radioactive waste management, health physics, chemistry, nuclear engineering, environmental engineering, geology, geophysics, and seismotectonics. 4
g ] 3' ? NRC. O [ Advisory Committee on Nuclear Waste Of the current incumbents on the ACNW, two were drawn from the Advisory Commit-tee on Reactor Safeguards (ACRS); one, a former NRC office director, was select-s ed directly by the Commission; and a fourth was proposed for nomination by a i i technical society. It is expected that future appointees will be nominated in a manner.that will provide for increased public involvement in the nominating process; that is, the NRC will issue public announcements soliciting nominees to maintain a panel for appointment of members as vacancies occur. This will provide an opportunity for nominations.to be received from the public, including organizations such as public interest groups and technical societies. The diversity of viewpoints presently represented by current ACNW members is broadly based from the standpoint of special fields of interest, employment experience, and scientific or technical specialty, These membership charac-teristics provide the Committee with a balance of highly qualified technical-experts in the fields necessary _to carry out the Committee's mandate. 20C. The ACNW and its working groups held 10 meetings during FY 1989. The number of meetings held is directly related to the review schedule and scope of efforts on the high-level waste geologic repository, the number of criteria, guides, and technical positions referred for review and comment, the number of special reviews requested by the NRC, and topics of particular concern / interest to the Committee. The full Committee plans to continue meeting on approximately 8 out ~ of the 12 months during CY 1990. Full Committee meetings generally run two to three days and cover a variety of topics (review of the site characterization plan and related NRC staff analysis, technical positions on high-level and low-level waste issues, briefings and reviews of rulemakings, etc.). For particularly complex issues, the ACNW holds working group meetings where addi-tional time and expertise can be brought to bear on an issue and the subject g developed prior to full Committee consideration. If the Committee is to con-tinue to meet the requirements of its charter, it will need to continue to meet at least on a similar frequency in the future. 200. l The Advisory Committee on Nuclear Waste is an independent organization which is mandated to perform certain specific functions and provide advice to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission with regard to the potential hazards of all aspects of nuclear waste management within the purview of the NRC. The Committee is unique i-in that there exists no comparable body composed of acknowledged experts in the field of nuclear waste management whose mandate is to provide the Commission -with independent advice in this area. The Commission necessarily has its own expert staff on whom it relies in the day-to-day regulation of nuclear waste. However, there is no other advisory committee, within the Commission, with the current, broadly based knowledge of the ACNW which could be called upon for independent assessment of safety issues related to high-and low-level waste management and disposal. In addition, since ACNW members are part-time advisors with other full-time interests and activities in related fields, they generate an organized synergistic approach to provide a breadth of experience and state-of-the-art technical knowledge which would be difficult to duplicate with full-time government employees.
I J4
- p i
1.: j
- . - J' =
NRC. Advisory Committee on Nuclear Waste-. A continuing. committee such as the ACNW also remains current with respect to nuclear waste issues,-including related safety research, and provides a collegial judgment regarding these issues that would be impossible.to duplicate-by use of~ individual, part-time consultants on a esse-by-case basis. Through-the'ACHW, the public is provided assurance that an independent technical-review and evaluation of nuclear waste safety issues is accomplished and an opportunity for-public input during ACNW meetings is assured.- 1
- 20E,
-During this period, the Committee held 10 meetings comprising a total of approx-imately 152 hours.. Portions of 4 meetings were closed. Time spent in closed sessions occupied only about 4 hours. These closed sessions primarily addressed, .the selection of new members and were closed because they involved discussions of internal agency management and personnel practices,,and information the release of which would have constituted a clearly unwarranted invasion of personal privacy if made public. i M 1
un {_~, ' 8 f 8 ' 4 ..(.' 6 i
- c. ?':
' ANNUAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE MEMBERSHIP LIST 'N I(R AGENC Y REPOR15 CONTROL NQ osos osA-xx- ' INSTRUCilONS: Complete one-form-for E ACH committee existmg any time curing the fiscal year -(to-o1-to 9-3o). For item 6. List members directly on this form, or attach a00ncy hst contammg teovestoc date. ji!.
- 1. DEP ARIWNI OR AGENCY
- 2. CN^?tIIIt OR Sv5COWA41 TEE (Fuit name, as charterse i
- 3. F 15C AL YE AR
^ NRC- ' Advisory Committee'on Nuclear. Waste-1989--
- 4. H AW. ORGAN 6K AllONAL 161L),. AND AGENC Y ADDRE65 OF DESIGNATED FEDER AL OFFICER;
. Mr. Raymond ' F. Fraley, Executive Director USNRC/ACNW Washington, DC 20555 5, IOIAL NUMBER OF ALL MEMBERS SERVING DURING FISCAL. YEAR 4
- 6. LIST OF MEMBERS SERVING DURING FISCAL YEAR
- (NOTE: Indicate chairperson (s) by placing an esterist (#1 to the lef t of name.) MEMBER NAME OCCUPAilON (OR AFFILIAilON) Hinze,-William-J. Dr. Professor, Department-of Earth and Atmospheric-Sciences. Purdue University
- Moeller. ' nada W. nr.
Professor of Engineering in Environmental Healti-School of Public Health. Harvard University ISmith' ' r14 ffned V-le - nc-chancellnr. I!niversitv of Wisennsin _. S tai nd1 p r. Ma rt i n.1 - nr - Director, Chemical.Techralogy Division Aronnna Natinnal l a hnratney i \\ 9 e 4
- CE RFCn A I
['EntIInrP A rm a m a m a n e T n Avana
jf@$ e 30. 1 (y" ki-m y(" - 1 ,., f. 3 i P su. 4 gy%m.- u;;. .i ',,.; si s s 1 + e, V 4 1, .n w',.f 3,
- m. -
>g rir-t..e T i'n; g Advisory Comittee on Nuclear ' Waste
- ,t.
o. I .r. ~., ,asq .p ? gg,mA s-re g J0CCVPATIONAL GROUPS:. 2 t,' Total Number of Members' by Occupational Code l, w .c Occupational Code: -12 17.. 1 l Number of. Members:- 7 7. F. j, }- p \\ 4 t >. i U* ,9(
- s _
c. .i _ s .5 e' o
- s;
.1-p f. r E a i ) s i
- h. p
o * 't i r+ .t t,e.. t
- {
o. t s s J. ' ~ .h ff:, i l' l i.u
- ; G.,
,/.>. .-t j - (
- k y
a e 4 -r -7 ,7< t 4 t ., I i - - s w a t +I 6 t .5 t. 3 .Os 9 y g 5 n' _ J .h ) 4 y, " ';
- t
'f } s> r, f :. ; * '? o t w -3 3i '- i ? a. g t W.'. bi Q,. e r
- I 'p,.
k' -y -) e na.l %],ll 3_.. f u. r1h .t (. L-" di ', j -_., g'.' h ._,,_...,_,_..____...,_,,,...,__...,;.._.~.,....,....,,..' g . p.' klf. e' 4
=- _- x ist l 1 9 / ,E [ - -.. p t.. n:6. .- > W: ql. pp-' Q';,. % t E -~,s - : 1. - ' ?' g M + ,>_,l J! 3<.
- $ 4
- y _
3 di $w%,*f M,, (g - " W ? s s c m. S q, y.,e H Jg. + t A.R',. I .' j I 3 %, 1 u..-
- 5. )
t M. ' 3'
- D a.
r. e,, n3 7 s %) fj . f.. a I ? f < i .ie g :. o.,, d: _\\ ,b 'L;y - l .;. g-_ r s E <.,u. ,'e 1 u. r,. I, 4 p.., - L , Advisory Committee on Nuclear West AU ~ 4 e. w h, , 'i, b t 4 t ;. l p q ; 4. g.,,, - gJ-
- 2;; ?!NDUSTRY GROUPS::
(Total Number of' Members by?!ndustry Code-a, u ..g .i .u.. - p.. W.. L!ndustry Code:; ~02-03 + Number of Members::' 1 o ,s m.,
- L'.l "
p.
- e g,
Tn s u. .I 'F p -
- -h b
p 7.g-n: I ra r + s, s 'I Y ', t -g r V. L '. b'4 i] $ 5 1f i t [ w., es ' 4 c _.i x_. Y i > .y. t w n n c k.' -. I 4 s. k,'./ L,, s s t T .5 bi . r y _i s ( 2 r i,, i' .- p f i e w - t i 1 t.,. i '. i p; a; v. kk 5 y ;: y n .4n' M 4 1 k. t 1.. y j_' p g f } - t t w 9 f 4 j '?q-f i s b ': i U .6 jp - .L [ 'f p-,l Mj' ny i 1 sy +- ~.J'I i - QQ . ~~
,a ANNUAL REPORT REVIEW CF FEDERAL ADYlSORY COMMITTEE "'[sNs'A xx + INS T RUCTIONS: Complete one f orm for E ACH committee existing any time Curing the fiscat tear (10-01 to 9-30). Cite ALL cites n numerais (Month, cara yest). If acaitiUnal space is necessary, use Section F,
- Remarks
- en the towerse.
L DEP AR1 LENT OR AGlNCY 2.fibCAL vlAR Nuclear Regulatory Comission 1989 s.COMMaut OR sveCouuaus ow nameesenene,e. Nuclear Safety Research Review Comittee (NSRRC) SECTION A - COMMITTEE STATUS e.15 IHib COMM.Illt Ntw DVk iNG f iSC AL vlAk)
- 6. CVEkthl CHAkl[R DAll
- 6. EXITLIED R{N{w AL 1. [XI LCl[D TERMsN ATiON DATL DAI[
OAft g vie a NO 2/9/88 2/9/90 Perpetual S A. H A5 THil C OMMITIEt Bith TERMiN ATED DukiNG eB. 5FIC IF IC lERMiN AllON AVlHORITv til by 6ew, aC, AC T U AL TERMIN AT ION DATI FISC AL t[ Akt (If *Yl8', complete nemt $B 490 SC) Cite U.$ CJ vis M NO NOTE: It box 90 of 9C is checked, complete items 10A ano 10B anc provice a brief explanation m " Remarks".
- 9. AG[NCY R E C OMME ND AT ION FOR COMMi1 TIE f 0R Nt xT f i5C AL ~t E AR 10A. 45 LEcl5L A160N R E Q u iR f D 105, is suCH LIGl5L AliON 10 MERGE OR T[RMINAf t?
PENDING OR EMAC1tDi @ A. CON 71NU( O e. utRct Oc'tRu'NA't O vis No O vt8 ONoN/A SECTION B - COMMITTEE AUTHORITY AND TYPE 1). (51 AbLISHML N I AUINOkilY G nect UNLY onel A. $PICIP IC ALLY DIRf CI[D BY L AW ] B. AUTHORillD BY L AW ] C, AhNCY AUTHORitV [ D. Pkf SIDENilAL DIRECilvt E ECIF iC [51 ADLISHM[N1 AulHOR ll V tif b y low.
- 13. (FFEC T IVE DATE OF
" DDMMIT T E L Yt F[ (Cnecat IlTHER A of B. ene C, af. cite U.S.C.) AUTHORify appropriate: 42 U.S.C. Sec 2201 2/9/88 A.AD Hoc @ B. CONilNuiNo Oc.rRisioeNiiAt
- a. DisCRieuON Or COMvoit <Cnect ONLv ent>
C. SCl!N11FIC/ A. N AllON AL B. NON SCitr411FIC IE CHNiC AL POL IC vilS$Ut 8'R OGR AM PR OGR AM D.CRANT E. Rf 0VLAf 0RV F. OTH{R ADvi$ORY ,~ ADVISOR Y ADV 150R Y Riv it W Nf 00T IAt SON (Spac ete ~ SECTION C - COMMITTEE ACTIVITY DLMING FISCAL YEAR 16 A. 101AL hvMblR OF 16B. tiSI kiPOR : Isltt6 AND D Alt $ (Montn. 048 " ' 0* ' 8
- 1. Second Report of the Nuclear Safety Research Review Comittee (February 2
7, 1989)
- 2. Third Report of the Nuclear Safety Research Review Comittee (August 11, 1989)
- 17. NUMBER OF MEEllNGS E. DA45 P AM winNG5 (Monin ces l
A.OnN
- e. CLOstD C. r ARuaar CtostD D. TOTat ( A. e C>
Oct. 11-12, 1988; Nov. 3-4, 198B; Dec. 1 l 10RR-nor 19-1d. 1QAA* Mau 71-?d_ 1C 5 0 0 5 SECTION D - COMMITTEE COST NOTE: Express costs m whole collars. (00 NOT uso decimals, K. M, N/A, or leave blank, indicate
- O*, it appheaDie)
CURRENT NEx1
- 18. DESCRIPTION FISCAL YE AR flSCAL YEAR
( A ctual) (E stimate) ( (1) NON-FEDERAL MEMBERS 8 8,000 8 11,000 A. PERSONNEL (2) FEDERAL MEMBERS (Prorated salary) PAYMENTS (3) FEDERAL ST AFF (Prorated salary) (4) NONMEMBER CONSUL T ANT S (1) NON-FEDERAL MEMBERS 9,500 11,000 B. TRAVEL (2) FEDERAL MEMBERS PER EM (3) FEDF.RAL ST AFF (4) NONMEMBER CONSULT ANTS 700 2,000 C. OlHER (rents, user charges, grarhics, printing, mailt'ig, ele.) I " 8 18,200 8 24,000 l
- 19. FEDERAL ST Af f SUPPORT YEARS D; PRESS IN FULL TIME EoulVALENT (Fi[) YEARS USN) DECIMAL TO THE NEAREST TENTH (e 0 0.0). >
(FIGURE SOLD CORRESP00 TO DOLLAR COST N lifM IBA(3), ADOVEJ e t 415TRATION GS A FORM l-820-H (Rjv, 7-[:pd
+ ' SECTION E - COMh4TTEE ACCOMPLISHMENTS AND JUSTIFICATION (Comp!to this s;ction ONLY f tt committies wh re itemt 4 NO*, BA Wo', eno 9A "C:ntmve* are ch:ck d) " Se"UIse?Ed"Itfo*Ns"'eY'Is's!IEISAUoEAi StiiNhIisi*#cfe'E88lMlcAioWi"s"l!!a$'Mitl ^""'"' " " ' " " " ^ ' " Based on the recomm6ndations of the NSRRC, RES has established Broad Agency Announcements l (BAA) to expand the base of contractors providing s m ices to RES.- RES has also taken steps to expand and improve university involvement in its research activities. l l t F15. DE5CRl5E THE BALANCE OF MEMBER 5 HIP IN IIEMS OF POINT 5 OF v il'W REPRESENTID AND FUNCTION 5 PERFORMED. ~ The NSRRC consists of individuals with expert backgrounds covering the various' aspects of nuclear research. The Committee is made up of membership from industry, government, national laboratories and universities, I FOC. DEBCRIDE THE FREQUENCY OF MEETINGS AND THE k! LEV ANCE TO CONTINUING TH( C OMMIT T LE. I 1 Full committee meeting each fiscal year cycle. 4 Subcommittee site visits eacn fiscal year. i FUD. IXPL AIN WHV THE ADVICE OR INFORMATION C ANNOT BE O6T AINED FROM OTHER SOURCES. The NRC technical staff consists of hiq"v diverse and well' trained individuals. In spite of this fact, the National Academy of Sciences (NAS) in its report on revitalizing nuclear safety research in the U.S. recommended that a first i*ank advisory committee t be established to advise the Commission on its RES progr. sins. There are no other advisory + committees in NRC or elsewhere which have the diversity of vicq m uts and individual expertise capable of providing the in-depth advice contemple.ted by the NAS report. 70E IF APPLIC ABLE. EXPL AIN WHY 4T WAS NEC(5SARY 10 CLOSE AND/OR P ARTIALLY CLOSE COMMIT 1(( ME E T IN GS. N/A SECTION F - REMARKS 2 4. RtMARKS l l l GSA roRM T-820-H BACK(REv. 7-89)
.'e'- S-fo. -e-I AlpifuAL ACYlSORY COMMITTEE MEMBERSHIP LOT [ '[ " ', INsTRUCilONS: Comotete one form for [ ACH committee existing triy time curing the fisc6, tear (10-o1 to 9-30). f or item 6. List members directly on this form, or ettech egency list 'conteming roovesteo cate. r1enrmrer curTarr.cv-r, ccmom or suecowom evia a n.. enniv.e
- 3. Fisc AL v AR Nuclear Regulatory-Nuclear Safety Research Review Committee 1989 I
Commission 4, elAW. ORDAh 6Z AT 60hAL 1sTLl., AND AGEhCY ADDRLs& OF DE&iONAf tD FEDER AL OFFicIR: Dr. Robert L._ Shepard i Senior Research Program Manager Office of Nuclear Regulatory Research U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 l I 5,101AL NUMBER OF All MEMBERS SERVING DURING FISCAL YEAR fq
- 6. LIST OF MEMBERS SERVING OUHlNG FISCAL YEAR i
(NOTE: Incicate chairperson (s) by placing en osierisk (*) to the lef t of nome.) MEMBER NAME OCCUPATION tor Af flLIAllON)
- Dr. Neil E. Todreas Massachusetts Institute of Technology 5
Dr. Spencer H. Bush Battelle Pacific Northwest Laboratory Dr. Earnest F. Gloyna University of Texas at Austiti Dr. Joseph M. Hendrie Brookhaven Natir>nal Laboratory Dr. Warren F. (Pete) Miller, Jr. Los Alamos national Laboratory Dr. David Morrison, President IIT Research Institute Mr. Cordell Reed Commonwealth Edison Company Dr. Thomas B. Sheridan Massachusetts Institute of technoloay Prof. Richard Wilson Harvard University l Dr. Robert E. Uhrig (new member) University of Tennessee Dr. Herbert S. Isbin Consultant (Professor Emeritus, Univ. Minnesota) Dr. Sol Burstein (new member) Consultant (Retired Vice President. Wisconsin Electric Power Company) i Dr. M. L. Shoaf (resigned member) Princeton University Dr. N. K. Gupta (resigned member) Integrated Systems, Inc. r s t UENERAL SERVICE 5 ADMINISTRATION GS A F@RM T-821-H Ms%.y-ML
e 3 _ -. 'n + Y f r A9WUAL REPORT REYlEW OF FEDERAL ACYlSORY COMMITTEE '''''','NS I N ' ' " ' ! os INST RUCTIONS: Complete one form f or E AC6f committee existm0 any time durin0 the fiscal year (10-01 10 9-301 Cite ALL celes er 1 num;tals (Month, c6y, year).11000stiorati space is necessary, use Section F, "Remarts* on the teverse.
- 1. OtP Ak1 MENT OR AGENC Y
- 2. F iSC AL v t AR
] U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 1989
- 3. COuuints OR Sv8COMMaitt uvii nom. es eneri <..
Special Commitee to Review the Severe Accident Risks Report SECTION A - COMMITTEE STATUS
- 4. ib Ines COMMilltt Nlw Duk iNG F iSC AL vt Ak?
- b. Cv6&tNI CnatitR D ATE
- 6. EXPEC TED RENLvv AL
- 1. L AFEC TED ltRMiN AllON DATI DAtt DATE fBvis ONO June 16, 1989 None June 16, 1990 4A. MA5 TMs5 COMusTTil Btt N ItEMiN Alt 0 DukiNG
- 68. SPECIFIC TikMIN A TION AU T HOR 4 T v tif b y law.
6C. ACluAL TERMINAllON DATE fisC AL vt ART ttf *vts'. C0mpiele items SB ano SC) Cite U.s.CJ vis n; NO NA NA NOTE: tf-box 9B of 90 is checked, compiele items 10A and 108 anc provide a brief explanation m " Remarks *.
- a. AGENCY R E C OMME ND A160N FOR COMMillit FOR NEXT FiSC AL vt AR 10A. 85 LEGISL ATION R E Q u iR E D 105,15 EUCH LEGISL AliON
) 10 MERGE OR f tRMIN Af t? PtNoiNG OR ENACTEDt A. CONilNUt O
- MtRcr a c 'tRuiNatt Ovis a NO vis ONO NA SECTION B - COMMITTEE AUTHORITY AND TYPE
- 11. t51 AbL iSNMLN1 AV IM Qk il Y wneth (,)NL Y ones A. sPtCIFIC ALLv DittCTio liv L AW D a AutHOairro ev 'A*
I c ActNCv Au'HOairv E o. 'utslotNiiAt oikict've
- 12. EFEC IF IC (ST ABLISMME N T AVINOR1Tv tit ey now.
- 13. IFFIHOR*IVD ATL OF Id. COMM*Ilt! TvFt (Cnect iiiTHER A or B. eno C. it CTW one u.s.Ca Av eeeropriate>
s 42 U.S.C. Sec 2201 6/16/89 u A. Ao NOc B. CONiiNuiNG C. PResiotNTIAL
- 15. DE SCR iP f lON OF C OMM Tit (Cneck ONLY one)
C. sCitNitFIC/ A. N ATION AL B. NON sCitNiiFIC T E CHN IC AL POL ievnssut PROGR AM PROGR AM D.CRANT
- t. Riout ATORY F. O D iovisORv AovisORv o AovisORv O REvita ONioOriAriON Oise..TH*ER i
SECTION C - COMMITTEE ACTIVITY DURING FISCAL YEAR 16A.101 AL NUMBER OF 16B. Libl kl.POR I T altt5 AND DAlt5 (Month, cay > REPORis None None l
- 17. NUMBER OF MEE11NGS
- t. DATt5 Or Au mIiNG5 (uonth, op A. Or t N B.Ctc5tD C. r AR nAav CtOttD D. T Oi At ( A. B. C)
July 10-12, 1989 i Sept. 13-14, 1989 l 2 0 0 2 F D A165 OF OT"tR ACT'vii tt5 (Des.rio' la 's+meras") None SECTION D - COMMITTEE COST l NOTE: Express costs m whole collars. (00 NOT use decimals, K, M, NIA. or leave blank, inaicate "O", if applicable). CURRENT NEx1
- 10. DESCRIPilON FISCAL YE AR FISCAL YE AR (Actuali (E stimate)
(1) NON-FEDERAL MEMBERS 8 None $ None l A.FERSONNEL (2) FEDERAL MEMBERS (Prorated safary) PAYMENTS (3) FEDER AL ST AFF (Prorsted salary) 10,000 10,000 (4) NONMEMBER CONSULT ANTS l (1) NON-FEDERAL MEMBERS 65,000 70,000 B. TRAVEL (2) FEDERAL MEMBERS PER kEM (3) FEDER AL STAFF 5,000 5,000 l (4) NONMEMBER CONSUL T ANTS I E OTHER trents, user energes, graphics, printing. mailing, etc.) 20,000 20,000 ' T T*' 8100,000 8105,000 1
- 19. FEDERAL ST AFF SUPPORT YEARS EXPRESS IN FULL *11ME EQUIVALENT (FTE) YEARS UStrG DECIMAL 10 THE NEAREST TENTH (e g. 0.0).
(FIGURE SK)ULD CORREsporo TO DOLLAR COST IN 11EM TBA(3), ADOVE) l GENERAL SERVICES ADMINISTRATION GS A FORM 1 -820-H (REv. 7-89
r s> v SECTION E - COMM(TTEE ACCOMPLtSHMENTS AND JUSTFICATION (Compm this s ction ONLY tor committ:es where it:ms 4 "NO", 8 A *NO". and 9 A
- Continue
- sre check';c) i EAotSCN[aAttoN C A$3os IDL LIIDS Chd"AD 5 AWR 1L.'
$ $5 A t IC A o . At the conclusion of its work the Committee will. provide a report on the technical merits L of an NRC-contractor report which will be used to support NRC's Program of Regulation. At-its meetings in July and September the Committee began its review of the Severe Accident Risks Report with discussion and presentations from the contractors who prepared the report. s FW, p[3ER fBf THE BALANCE OF MEMB[E SMiP IN TERM 5 OF POIN15 OF VIEW EEPEESENTED AND FUNCI40N5 FERFORMID. Membership is balanced between national and international experts representing industrial, academic and national laboratory points of view. FR Nitrar mrnTtrucNCv OF uetiiNc5 AND ine RetivANCe iO CONiiNuiNo rne COMMiiitt. Two meetings held-in FY89, two meetings presently scheduled for FY90. FOD. EXPL AIN WHY THE ADVICE OR INF ORM AllON C ANNOT BE OBT AINED FROM 01MER SOURCE 5. Commission wishes to obtain independent views as to whether information presented in the Severe Accident Risks Report reflects state-of-the-art science and uncertainties in science are appropriately documented. The Severe Accident Risks Report is a highly complex, technical study. Committee members have extensive scientific and engineering backgrounds. Their expertise is not available i from other agencies or other adivsory committees. 20E. 4F APPLiC ABLE. EXPL AIN WNY 41 W AS NECESSARY 10 CLOSE AND/OR P ARTIALLY CLOSE COMM41 TIE MEE!aNOS. NA l SECTION F - REMARKS i t. REMARE S l i 1 '~ i GSA FORM T-820-H BACK(REv. 7-89) o
n_ . x. .go t- . o. }.. m 8' ANNUAL ASVISORY COMMITTEE MEMBERSHIP LIST '* * **'[,,I,,,',*,'[ * ' lNSTRUCTIONS: Complete one form for EACH committee artsling en) time during it4 fiscal year (1o-o1 to 9-30). i Tot item 6. List members citectly on this form, or ettsch egency list containing teouested cate. l T 5?FluTw=1 on Aotucy. L couui1Ttt oR suecouvilitt (Fuin name. es charteree
- 3. Fiscal vtAR U.S. Nuclear.
R^gulatory Commissior Special Committee to Review Severe Accident Risk Report 1989
- 4. N AW. DRGAntIAlloN AL TITLi. AND AGthcv ADDRES5 OF Ot51GNAItD FtDIR AL OFFic[R; Charles B. Bartlett Senior Research Engineer I
Office of-nuclear Regulatory Research U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 l l
- 5. TOTAL NUMBER OF ALL MEMBERS SERVINo DURING FISCAL YEAR 9
- 6. Lisi OF MEMBERS SERVING DURING FISCAL YEAR (Noits indicate chairperson (s) by placing en osierisk (u) to the lef t of name.)
MEMBER NAME OCCUPAllON (OR AFflLIAYlON) b
- Dr. Herbert J. Kouts Brookhaven National Laboratory Dr. E.H. Adolf Birkhofer Society for Reactor Safety (ERS) Fed.' Rep. Germar l Dr. Lars Hoegberg Swedish Nuclear Power Inspectorate (SKI)
Dr.. Harry Teague UK Atomic Energy Authority I Dr. Geo. Apostolakis University. of California, Los Angeles Dr. Wh. Kastenberg University of claifornia, Los Angeles Dr. Leo LeSage Argonne National Laboratory i Dr. Norman Rasmusen Massachusetts Institute of Technology t u Dr. John Taylor Electric Power Research Institute em l L k l V i 1~ CsENERAL SERVICE 5 ADMINISTRATION GSA FORM T-821-H (REV. 7-89 ,}}