ML19331E073
| ML19331E073 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Crane  |
| Issue date: | 08/28/1980 |
| From: | Lewis M AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED |
| To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| References | |
| ISSUANCES-SP, NUDOCS 8009050425 | |
| Download: ML19331E073 (3) | |
Text
THIS DOCUMENT CONTAWS
' M. &'
Lewie e/28/e0 h
l POOR QUAUTY PAGES.
l UJ'ITED STATES OF 181 ERICA V
LTCLEAR REGUIATORY CCI.iMISSICII w
~'
?>
g IEFORE '" MC:.IIC SAFETZ AITD LICEN3II!G E0ARD
-c.
V,.,
,, e, In the matter of r
~,
l i'.
.2,5,i
V Docket No 50-289 %
?.ietropolitan Edisnn Company H'
'4, (Three f.:lle Island Nuclear
)
Reabart )
' gyj._
Sittion, Unit No 1)
J.'iTF3EUCR LE'."IS"S MOTI0'i FOR A CORRECTIOli TO THE RECORD AHD AN EXTEliSION TO A BOARD CUESTION.
M&O dated 8/20/80 page 13:
"Any party may within ten days following service of this order mahe reccami.ndation for the modification of specification of the board's questions or present arguments... "
Tr 2383 Dr Jcrdan"Is it an important part of restart that instruments outside of containment also be environmentally qualified in the Starf's opinion?"
Tr 2385"(T)here has not been any instrument 4 failures outside of containment which have contributed to the accident."
'?crrection to the reccrd: There hs.ve been failures in both instrumente, and equipment which did contribute tothe accident at EiI#2 on 3/28/59.
Ecuitme-nt which failed outside,cf centaicent which contributed to accident.
Vent header (which ic leahing) Page 59 Rogovin Zepert.
This allowed radioactivity to exit at dangerous and unexpectsd tices increasing the exposure of the surrcunding community.
{
Charcoal filter media, In answers toInterrogater -r to Lewis Centention both Licensee and ctaff admit that less radioac-- = 'edine wculd 1
have been relsaced during accident if filter me_.
nad been changed on a more frequent schedule.
Instrument failure cutside of containment which m: rtbuted to accident:
1 Tage 21. RogcVin Report " Hey, we're getting cc:-r Eilt of the floor drains.
The aux building sunp is overflowing."
i Lack of inctrumentation er failure of instrumen;ation allowed the sump to overf1cw wit,hout any warning. Instrumentation here might have given clues to speed proper action to mitigate the accident.
"The sanple line has just gene up to c00 rems and hour."
Subsequent cacpbing of radioactive liquids during the emergency cauced at laaet two v or: erS to be expored greatly rc 4
0i over 7
the legal allovablec. P crer instrumentaticn en thece sampic lines tight have minimised that expecures and citigated those particular consec,uences of this adcident.
8 009 0 5 0 YM h
OTF$n CONSIDERATIONS.
2 Finally thetprogress at TMI#2 is being done in such a dangerous and glip' shod ma,nnor as to endanger the operation of TMI#1 and the entire area.
I come to "chis conclusion thru the following d6cuments which have only recently arrived in my possession.
NCR EII /80-14 Page 4 No 5 Weekly Boron Analysis The licensee is now beyond the 7 day technical specification surveillance frequency and notified the TMI Program Office on Friday 8.8.80.
3CR /IMI 80-125Page 4 No 4. Weekly Baron "nilysis " unable to analyse" Power Rea ctor Hera Events Vol 2 No4 July 1980" unplanned Boron Dilution."
In a undamaged reactor in cold shutdown, weekly boron dilution readings do not change significa1tly$
unless there xi is a reason.
TAI #2 is not an undamaged reactor. There are geometries and reaction going on inside that reactor which can only be guessed at. What those geometries and reactions will do to the boron dilutio n isanybodig'sguess.
Yet the 2 I Program office has determined that the cleanup can proceed without the required weekly boron analysis.
thzi This lack of reqirement for boron dilution analysis just is Y
anexample&fthekindofdangerousandslipshodoperatio[fs going on at #2.
This dangerous and shoddy aperation will affect
- 1 if there is an unplanned recriticality at #2.
Many structures outside of the containment are iruly dangerous.
Specifically the fuel pool has been brought up as a beard question in Docket No 50 272 Salem Fuel Pool Expansion. I respectfully Docket request tht the Board peruse the 18 April 79 order from 50-272 to see if there is ay reason to incorporate it into the Board Questions in this proceeding. [eac/c5ek Relief Sought :
I' respectfully urge the Board to add a Board Question :
Are there any structures outside of the containment which nedd be qualified for reasons of safety?
Specifically fuel pool, operations at OdI!2 which can endanger the operation of #1, and any other instances that pose an unacceptable or possible danger to the operation of TMI#1.
Respectfully submitted, j
Marvin I. Lewis
-; f 6 4 / Ac N -
/
215 CU 9 5964.
i i
?
ora.\\TED CQh?QMD:?C CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I caused a true and correct copy cf the foregoing i"~~~~~.=-=-.n..--.,..e.,.,,.-.,.
j dccument,(j __.;c;.w ;_.gA;;.;p.q;gg. ggg.g;g:l.
3,7 n.,.-+ 7 f, ] {. y g g /
. -- ----.t.m w ----
3
(,.'-9.:..i.GE-;.A J.W.-6%J;.f, to be placed in the United States mail, first-class, postage prepr:
=.ddressed to the persons listed below:
Ivan
'mith, Chairman At:=- Ic.fety & Licensing Scard Panel U.S
_ ear Regulatory Ccmmissicn Was..;. :n, DC 20555 Dr. Tr :er H. Jordan 851
+st Guter Drive Ca.s [..i:;e, iN 37830
.,,,'3M ',.,.
,.-j p,
N Y,. s.
k, '-
Dr. Linda W. Little
.,/.m..'.
h,,
~
e s.
'1
,,~% s h' "i 5000 He:- nitage Drive
.3
'~
i:
c' Raleigh, NC 27612 r>
.n...,3...i. ~,b.,. /
George F. Trowbridge, Esquire
- u. e.ur 1-
-. i s
i.
7.f,,'
Shaw, Pinman, Parts & Trowbridge [4
/,
,'"e, ;,,. -'y 1800 M Street, N.W.
j'x'..
,,./
2'c3&,:.,. J
~,
Washing *. n, DC 20006 Decketing and Service Section U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Executive Legal Director U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Gf
m%~.
}-
.d s.;'i.u.
- 9..
/. ' -
is x.-
_.. _ [
/
\\
~ 90
/
.. fn
[
O'h kkb Dated: tjg r/,1980
I !*>
4:
UNIED STAES OF RERICA ggiB die y'-
NUCEAR EGCLAICE COMISSION lE4
~
+d Q.e +l.'
EEFORE 'IF.E A'ICEC SAEIY AND LICENSITG 30ARD of g
T,d
?
w CD In the Matter of
)
)
Docket No* 50-272 FUBLIC SERVICE EI.ECIRIC & GAS CCt9AU'l
)
)
(Salen Nuclear Generating Staticn,
)
(Spent Fuel E:gansien)
Unit No. 1)
)
ORDER As previously anncunced cn March 15, 1979 attheSpecialPrehearii Conference, and en March 29, 1979 in the Order Following Frehearing Ccnference, an ' evidentiary hearing has been scheduled in the ebove-captiened :stter en Mrf 2,1979 in Sale =, New Jersey.
2.e evidencia: r hearing shall begin ia: 9:30 a.m. ca May 2,1979 in de Free F.olders Meeting Pccc (Pocn No. 7), New Salem Cctn y Cot = -
house, 94 Market Street, Salen, New Jersey.
The Scard wishes to add the folicaing ccestiens for discussien at the ha* +.g:
1.
To st.at ex:ent did de accident a: ?ree Mile Island affec: the spent fal pool at that site?
2.
If dare had been an e.xricsicn er "ael dm." a: T:=ee Mile Island, st.at affect su.ld char have had t=cn the i
o v4C
,qoco m 3 6
.-, spmt fuel pool? To stat enent wculd it hree rattered how :nch spent feel sas preset at the peel?
3.
If an accid.mt such as the cne at Taree Mile Isind occurred at Sale, to stat enent wculd the accidet affect de spent fuel pool? If m explcsica er "relti~n" cccurred at Sale, to stat erent snild that affect de spat feel pool? To stat erent wculd it have rac.ered hne =ch spent feel sas present at de pool at Salc?
The 3 card desires that de Licensee and de Staff preset at de hearing statever evidr.ce is necessary to address de above cuestiens.
SO OEu.r w.
FOR ZE A".UEC S!JETY.CID LIQ 3SH;G 30.13D I
' m A A. C.
h,ec;aryL..t_2.ou.in,ca:.:x.
a r
s Dated at 3edesda, Ma:-fred
$ is leth day of Ap-il 1979.
m
'-