ML19331C095

Summary of 800722 Meeting W/Util Re Proposed Early Warning Sys

ML19331C095
Person / Time
Site:	Arkansas Nuclear
Issue date:	08/05/1980
From:	Vissing G Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:	Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
NUDOCS 8008140159
Download: ML19331C095 (13)

Text

[(

a p

[prer 3

e UNITED STATES y}>*c((gg NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

=Js

/

E WASHING TON,0. C. 20555 4

MT o 5 ggen Dockets Nos. 50-313 & 368 FACILITY: Arkansas Nuclear One, Units Nos. 1 & 2 (AN0-1/2)

LICENSEE: Arkansas Power & Light Company (AP&L)

SUMMARY

OF MEETING WITH AP&L OF JULY 22, 1980, CONCERNING THE PROPOSED EARLY WARNING SYSTEM FOR ANO-1/2 Introduction The purpose of the meeting was to consider and discuss AP&L's proposed early warning system for AN0-1/2. The requested participants of this meeting were the AN0 Project Management, the Emergency Preparedness Program Office (EPP0) and the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA). Each office except FEMA was represented. The attendees are identified in Enclosure 1.

Conclusions The licensee's proposed conceptual system consisting of 53 sirens,1800 tone alert AM radios and special provisions for handicapped persons appears to meet the objectives of NUREG-0654.

It was noted that the approval of the system would require the concurrence of FEMA. Such a concurrence could not be expected until after the installation and test of the system.

Discussion The discussion followed the outlines presented in Enclosure 2.

These outlines l

are self-explanatory and adquately presents the rationale for the development of the concept. The concept appears to be acceptable by the NRC; however, it was noted that FE!M would also have to accept the system.

This acceptance would be made at the local FEMA level and would probably not occur until after the system has had an acceptable test. The licensee is planning to have similar meetings as this one with state, local and FEl% officials.

, J,%

j 3.nJ am u

Guy S. Vissing, Project Manager Operating Reactors Branch #4 l

l Division of Licensing Enclosures & cc:

See next page 8 0 0 8140 $d;

AP&L July 22, 1980 Meeting

Enclosures:

1.

List of Attendees 2.

EWS Proposed Conceptual System Meeting Objectives cc w/ enclosures:

Mr. William Cavanaugh, III-AP&L AP&L Service List Members Docket File NRC PDR L PDR TERA NSIC ORB.Rda NRR Rdg HDentor.

ECase DEisenhut RPurple RTedesco TNovak GLainas RReid TIppolito SVarga DCrutchfield RAClark ORB Project Manager-GVissing Licensing Assistant-RIngram OELD AE00 - JHeltemes IE-3 SShowe MeetingSummary(16)

File-0RB#4 RFraley, ACRS Program Support Branch GZech J01shinski NRC Participants WLAzelson SRamos FPagano I

l l

h

ATTENDANCE LIST FOR JULY 22, 1980 MEETING WITH ARKAN5AS POWER & LIGHT COMPANY NRC AP&L Guy S. Vissing Don Reuter W. L. Axelson J. Ted Enos Steve L. Ramos Dale E. James Frank Pagano NUS CORPORATION FEDERAL SIGNAL CORPORATION Gary D. Hilbert Peter J. Cannon Marvine E. Anderson

L, EARLY WARNING SYSTEM ARKAN!;AS NUCLEAR ONE 1

i 4'

PROPOSED CONCEPTUAL SYSTEM 1

j JULY 22, 1980 a

e MEETING OBJECTIVES INFORM NRC 0F AP&L's CONCEPTUAL APPROACH RECEIVE NRC CONCURRENCE OF CONCEPTUAL. APPROACH TO AUGMENT:

DETAILED DESIGN OF SYSTEM CONCURRENCE BY FEMA, STATE A!1D LOCAL OFFICIALS ASSURE DETAILED DESIGN CONFORMS TO REQUIREMENTS.

3 i

i

i l

DESIGN REQUIREMENTS 100% POPULATION WITHIN 5 MILES WITHIN 15 MINUTES 90% POPULATION WITHIN 5 To 10 MILES WITHIN 15 MINUTES 10% POPULATION IWTHIN 5 TO 10 MILES WITHIN 45 MINUTES RANGE OF SIRENS - 100B OVER AMBIENT.

FEMA "OUTo0cR WARNING SYSTEM GUIDE" NUREG - 0654

...,.se,-.

3'

+, - - - - -

i l

SYSTEMS STUDIED SIRENS MECHANICAL ELECTRONIC

(

NOAA RADIOS AM TONE ALERTS, EBS AM-FM RADIO i

'~

TELEVISION s

BULLHORNS / PORTABLE PAS f

MOBILE SIRENS l

IELEPHONES - AUTOMATIC 4

e

-__.. _.. _ _ _. _ _ ~, _ _

INITIAL EVALUATION SIRENS, MECHANICAL EFFECTIVE, RELI ABLE, AND COST BENEFICI AL, NOTIFICATION IN H ?GHLY POPULATED AREAS.

SIRENS, ELECTRONIC EFFECTIVE, RELI ABLE NOTIFICATION IN HIGHLY POPULATED AREAS.

COST BENEFIT NOT AS GOOD AS MECHANICAL.

NOAA RADIOS GOCD EARLY WARNING SYSTEM BUT NOT AVAILABLE AROUND ANO.

AM TONE ALERTS - EBS GOOD INFORMATIONAL AND EARLY WARNING SYSTEM.

AVAILABLE AND COST BENEFICIAL.

' ~ ~ ~

AM-FM RADIOS GOOD INFORMATIONAL MEDIUM BUT NOT SUITABLE FOR EARLY WARNING.

TELEVISION GOOD INFORMATIONAL MEDIUM BUT NOT SUITABLE FOR EARLY WARNING.

l MOBILE SIRENS - BULLHORNS / PORTABLE PAS EFFECTIVE IN REMOTE AREAS AS BACK UP TO THE PRIMARY SYSTEM.

TELEPHONES, AUTOMATIC EXISTING TELEPHONE SYSTEM NOT ADEQUATE.

COST IS VERY HIGH.

ENGINEERING EVALUATION 1

SIRENS FACTORS CONSIDERED:

AVAILABILITY POWER SUPPLY TO AREA 14 P0t:ER PLANTS 9 SUBSTATIONS COVERAGE - 10DB OVER AMBIENT NOISE LEVELS

~~

TERRAIN BUILDINGS FOLIAGE l

l t

I

. =.. -

~

2 l

t j

i iti ENGINEERING EVALUATION SIRENS i !-

RESULTS:

4 l

= 85% (23,000) 0F FOPULATION WITHIN 10 MILES COVERED BY = 53 SIRENS j

i i

i i

4-l I-L 1-

..,..-.------..-=..=:.m

-.-=:.

l ENGINEERIt!G EVALUATION AM TONE ALERTS AVAILABILITY AM RADIO STATION WITHIN 10 MILE RADIUS 24 HOURS PER DAY BACKUP POWER SUPPLY ANXIOUS TO PARTICIPATE AUGMENT SIRENS IN SCHOOLS, HOSPITALS, ETC.

15% (4000) 0F POPULATION

5 PROPOSED CONCEPTUAL SYSTEM

= 53 SIRENS COVERING =85% OF POPULATION.

= 1800 TONE ALERT AM RADIOS (EBS) COVERING 15% OF POPULATION

=

TONE ALERT RADIOS MADE AVAILABLE TO PERSONS OUTSIDE SIREN COVERAGE AT NO COST, TONE ALERT RADIOS MADE AVAILABLE TO SCHOOLS, HOSPITALS, ETC. INSIDE SIREN COVERAGE AT NO COST, TONE ALERT RADIOS MADE AVAILABLE TO PERSONS INSIDE SIREN COVERAGE AT COST, SPECI AL PROVISIONS ON A CASE BY CASE BASIS FOR HANDICAPPED PERSONS IN ALL AREAS l

i t

.._x-

.... - -r n -

,i r

.. G.i..,. y L.' i.'-

i-

^:*_..2-M _d % D /~

,. e

,,3,

.J.'.*-....

1. 1".. g, ~....

~..

y 1[-f [.===.qg.3 g.).M..

,;.,e f.,7 * ',.,

'.g.**.-

?%

/ 4

,,g

/:...*1.i 0

1...,e.i,-

f m

~

g j,# /*

.IP,,2h.y,4' lt~"p w q..e.M '.

y !

g,41 P '..:..gr i a,W~.. "

.g j.

s, d,

j.

J. c :

?.

.n a..

v

.:, x i;-l;,w.., v,&. : g.

r.a.,. y..

..,.>. u s..

y.., \\ \\,..

, s.

q.

t

%.' i T-

-.a,

..,. %.y,.

.w 4-u

,.<..,... $, :,:r,, t.-

..,.a, g, n.y..

n.

t 1

t

.. 4.....:-f.,s..,.. s +

j p,~.w,. f,. g..,.,#

3

,t

' * *...y.. g-

..; a.. 1,s.... ~,....m.

i t4 3

.r,:.

n,,.,v,,.,.(

4%

. n p,.,,>4

%r.6 ' +* s.

. ~.,.

ag.

-e.'1E ndyi rar; j

t,; f

.., % s,. %m g

• 1s. Ja huq.y_.$ q 77 3

,5, :::r.

b b,,,n, f.,_-4.a'4 4

.w..

n.,

J a e j..

hN

g.,,p,,p; g~p g

,.p,' y t

.wg e.pg -

.[,

e.s, 3,

s v_

+.

},Y.. k

.7,fD,9..s. s&g, 5'..

jd.Q W.. /

_ +

u.ir

.x

)]

n I

j__; '

r;% ' 4 #g h y._

~ ~.

9 'HL

-.- i 7.b.,:q).s g.! u*%9,M

,.&.M.,d

..m h., Q.l p :

., m.,--+.

sg.q

-- ~.s,,

~

.yy

.I,. N

.. -.,. u c..g' S W-r-i

. s..,. ?*

.~

y

.,-.'.~.T.-

u: /

.... : Er.:

y l :s-

\\.

,l y az e!

<a,,

r e<.D...u.,.,s+.. -

.,,,, < o.

+:

r,g u i.

A..,s.n..

> M.

,,,. : V g

p

,, \\. t.

.u h. :..

.y r

r,

• "...a,

~,.

.F,r.

,m.v;; 9u/g-m,.y,,y a.,4. N. :,~

., /'***'%,

4 eM.

.p-y.

7 3 -

e.,

e

.y --

,y 2;,. -./

- i.p, y

~

e.a.c l f n >

.._,s.

9.{ y:.3 g3, u.-

j ni.j j i 1 ".+

,.. ~

W.'.-$.f!pt101.,g@p{.4.h.

if

,a

, a w" 7 e a

. mt

.a n e<*

,. e /, ~_ q:

Q v

..- t

.v-a

- *..w.m *g.):./J=ghy'ihl!ii

~~.i

• /

-N,

"' 7

'hg

'., !.;,w p)~ ('

j,

-Z --; $h.,!l S 'b.-.M,.l;

~/

p a-r -

Yh' N$$-f-l;f?

.,, ~~.

u D. :4 e 2 ':

. w. r;..,. %. \\< w _ :e -_ _ 3.. b :s'. c:j. @ R

?<..Y. f

.. h{1'*- l ~5h

? $

W' i

s.,.

i c

m.

.s

.2. m

.,u.-

-f., s. ; ',

/:

t.. <..

3.

.T W.. %._

w

-' s %.

- o

1. s y-

/

gI L. " mu --- -.F :L 'Di. [3d,,

g__.,,T.. m] 4. -- d..i

.. lf,. ni.

~ ~ " ~. '

jy y.

,m,.._ '_

<J. -,o.

g M..,.M,,f, p, -. a.e n.

.y x i!

,i.,<-

.. W-1

._,..ss

8 t.... A. +. a. <

f.>'>:.# ^/ y ! J,:

s-

."- e n

,)

Y

.m

. \\-

.c s,t,.

v. ", :.

~.

s:

7

. +s.~. 4, n

-y

.:a

=

, ~..

,o

~.; !,,.!y a.!- +' A,.

m L-+p y

' w

~.

d..m pv.. 2 -. g

_n _

s I

. h.

r

. 4 r;"

.- ---,,c,l /

i

.1 )., :

+

a.

s.

,rA..,

g.

..u.

u

. f.

k,v.,f,

l ni

..A.

c g

(.. ;. a<. '; *.

%_. l+ '

2.

./-

ts g_

i ss..,

,'\\\\

l s,:

__p p :.

l

w,' p-:. w(.,...'.. w. /..g. y q

, s.

g 2 *-

w m;.,.

., p,_ p_.

y

/ #,

Y-

. 5.>

9.

.l n..

i

• hk. #h c :.

4 1

l-

.I h

?

1

/.j.

yf

w;.,

~

..~

p

<t-

.....;..- -. g..

.~

n.

/,1

. g. 7

..., y

.J

.,i..,

. p.9 :,

t.

s s

4..

, \\,,

)

..-.p.

A.

i

---v ',f..c.-.i a. w,.,

.j.

i 3

,J.;.

t.

.. ir)

-p-e

=

%., ;i ',

, J..

.v.

f __ /

e

-- y *'

e s

• ~ ~~ t

)l L

- 4.., t

. g: :

p.~.,

t

. a

.I..

5,;

m I

.t

, -...4

__<.i

f. y.

.I.

~

si

.Q),.....,' iT &j; - ;u --

._c y 1

d i,.

m, f;.6y ' M

.~.

i-

.i }ll -

.1

.i 1

.llw;N?

[

.: 7,s

.,\\

~.

}.

e.%,:a

~~L;u T i'" ^

. f, f.a o. y;..

,J '-E, n

. y, (/

3

-Q..c., -,j (~ j % ]

g,, }. ~Ks. - 3..{y..

. Q

y., e ;- q s

. t. a, x..

z.

o t

.3

.. i f

a.

^ - - ^ - -

. - - -