ML19331B164
| ML19331B164 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Midland |
| Issue date: | 12/13/1976 |
| From: | Brenner L NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE LEGAL DIRECTOR (OELD) |
| To: | Cherry M CHERRY, M.M./CHERRY, FLYNN & KANTER |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8007250854 | |
| Download: ML19331B164 (8) | |
Text
.
~
~ d
< m.
v.
December 13, 1976 i
l Myron M. Cherry, Esq.
THIS DOCUMENT CONTAINS P00R QUAUTY'PAGES Ch 9,
linois 60611 g,
In the Matter of Consumers Power Company (Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2)
Docket Nos. 50-329 and 50-330
^
Dear Mr. Cherry:
~
This is in response to your request on the record of December 3,1976 for the backup documentation used in support of the NRC Staff's direct tes timony. The following such documents are enclosed for your use:
1.
Letter from 0. Lentz, Executive Manager, ECAR to S. Feld. 0ctober 8, 1976 (with enclosures: Summary of ECAR Generating Capabilities with Projections; Exhibits I-C through I-P.of 1976 Response to R-362; Chart of Load Curve and Capacity; Daily Load Profiles; Kilo-watt Hour Data 1970-1976 for ECAR, Consumers Power, Detroit Edison).
~
p l
2.
Memorandum from P. Fine to Dr. Spangler, November 27,~1974, "Use of Average Load in Evaluating Heed for Power" (enclosing Letter to
~
the Editor Nuclear Technology Volume 24. November 1974, p. 260,
" Load Duration Curves" by A. J. Snyder).
^
6 3.
" Potential Fuels Shift - A Survey of Contingency Planning by Manu-facturing Industries in the United States", Stone and Webster Manage-ment Consultants, Inc. for Edison Electric Institute (flay 1976).
4.
Letter - Oak Ridge National Laboratory to J. O. Roberts, Novenber 3, 1976, enclosing CONCEPT Code Calculations requested by S. Feld for i
the Midland Nuclear Plant.
f w-5.
Letter - Oak Ridge National Laboratory to J. O. Roberts, November 3.
1976, enclosing 0MCST Code Calculations requested by Mr. S.,Feld.
6.
" Supplemental Testimony of Darrel A. Nash before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board, Wolf Creek Generating Station, Unit Ho.1 (March,1976)".
$ 0 *S Y t
f Y
i
""' C 8 *
.80072 sof59 O-.
.m,_.
-i--
l oavs >
.,_...__.c...,
+,,.. -
j Focia AEC.318 (Rev. 9 33) AECM 0240 W u. s. oovann-ant raiwisNG oFFICs31974 324.lOS b'j%h A
[
~ -
. i-* *
- 1 U '
~~
w a
..e-I i
22'.
FPC News Release "FPC Releases State-By-State Sumary of Gas Curtailment", September 9,1976 (attached is FPC Staff sumary).
23.
"EEI Load Management Report: A Conpendium of Current Utility l
Programs", Weekly Energy Report (June 21,1976).
24.
S. Feld working paper on base load demand analysis (superimposed on Figure 1.1-1 Consumers Power Company Load Duration Curve).
25.
S. Feld notes "Detennination of Type of Generating Facility Required" (June 1975).
i
- 26. Memorandum from P. Fine to S. Feld, " Example of Application of Base-Load Criterion" (August 11,1976).
27.
"The Effects of Price on Energy Conservation" Federal Energy l
Administration (August 18,1975).
28.
"The Effects of Price Consumption", J. V. Thornton, Public Utilities Fortnightly (issue not indicated).
29.
S. Feld working paper "0BERS Projections - Volume 4. States - 1972" (Projections for Michigan and U. S.).
f 30.
S. Feld notes on conversation with T. Jackson, Michigan Energy Administration.
l
- 31. " National Power Survey - The Adequacy of Future Electric Power Supply:
Problems and Policies", Federal Power Comission (March 1976) (Excerpts Dp. 37-43).
32.
Letter - E. Hawthorn, Chairman, MARCA Design Review Comittee to MARCA Council Members (March al, 1976).
i i
- 33. Western Systems Coordinating Council Reply to Federal Power Comission i
Docket R-362 (April 1,1976) (Excerpt p. 3-35).
-34.
Note - Consumers, Power Company Reserve Requirements, provided to
- HRC Staff October 12, 1976.
1
~.
v
- 35.. "The Design of Electricity Tariffs",2.C. J. Cicchetti, Public Utilities Fortnightly, August 28, 1975, p. 25.1 l
36.
" Time-Of-Day Rates May Not Shift Load", Electrical World, September 15, 1976, p. 138. -
j
^
- orric.
- l
_.. 1 _.
c..._ _
t l
_... =
e
_.._.o _
l
[...ac.g.m...,nu
- ...........................3...;...
~
9 l
f
- 37. FPC liews Report, August 7, 1975, pp. 47-74.
l 38.
U. S. Department of Comerce,1973 County Business Patterns (September 1974) (Excerpts).
I 39.
S. Feld notes - Analysis Based on U. S. Department of Comerce County Business Patterns Document.
40.
S. Feld notes on Mich'igan Gas Supply.
- 41. Federal Res: ~S Board -Index on Industrial Production (October 15, 1976).
42.
S. Feld notes on conversation with Mr. Armatidge of Federal Reserve Board regarding its index on industrial production.
I 43.
S. Feld calculations on increases in price of electricity or i
Consumers Power System 1973-1975.
44.
S. Feld - notes.on basis for 10,000 ' BTU per IGIH assumption.
l 45.
S. Feld - 1981 present value calculations for Midland and coal
~
alternatives.
j
~
46.
S. Feld - notes' on bases for capital cost estimates for coal and
~
j nuclear.
i I
- 47. ' S. Feld - notes on bases for' nuclear fuel costs.
r.
^
l 7;
48.
S. Feld'- notes on bases for thirty year plant life.
- o
~
49.
"What Others Think - The Economics of Power Generation". W. W.
Brandfon, Public Utilities Fortnightly (September 9,1976), p. 36.
- 50..S. Feld - supporting work papers on leveliging values.
- 51. Memorandum, D. Mul'ler t'o Environmental Projects Personnel, " Increase t,,;
.in Discount Rate",' August 13, 1974.
t
- 52.. "A Primer on Electric Power Supply", A. L. Toalston, Directorate l
ofLicensing,U.'S.lAEC(March 13,1973).
53.' A. Meltz - Table entitled " Midland Project - Cash Flow Under Various Al ternatives".
i
- P F'C ' *
' ouanaua >
' pats >
....~.&..0..
.. ~.-
Forse AIC.318 (Rev. 9-53) AECW 0240 W u. a. oovsanusN7 Painvena orrics: ten mae.see 1 -. u: ~. :<. GGn.
.ML
..n..,.-
m
.s
./
a 54.' Letter dated January 30, 1976 from NRC to Duke Power Company with attachment entitled " Report Evaluation:
Bt.W Operating Experience of Reactor Internals Vent Values".
l Letter dated June 2,1976 from NRC to Consumers Power Company, with 55.
attachment entitled " Staff Position - Format and Content of Final Safety Analysis Report for the Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2".
- 56. Letter dated June 8,1976 from NRC to Consumers Power Company with attachment entitled " Midland Plant Units 1 and 2 - Regulatory Guide Review".
l
- 57. Letter dated September 24, 1976 from NRC tt. Consumers Power Company.
- 58. Letter dated Sepf.emb r 24, 1976 from HRC to Consumers Power Company with attachment entitled " Midland Plant Units 1 and 2 - Regulatory Guide Review".
^
- 59. Letter dated September 25, 1976 from NRC to Consumers Power Company with attachment entitled " Midland Plant Units 1 and 2 - Regulatory Guide Review".
(Note:
this is not a duplicate of previous item).
- 60. Letter dated September 29, 1976 from NRC to Consumers Power Company with attachment entitled " Midland Plant Units 1 and 2 - Regulatory Guide Review".
(
1 l
- 61. Letter dated September 29,~1976 from NRC to Consumers Power Company i
with attachment entitled " Midland Plant Units 1 and 2 - Regulatory Goide Review".' -(Note:
this is not a duplicate of previous item).
i.-
l
- 62. Letter dated NoveP6er 26,1976 from NRC to Consumers Power Company.
t
- 63. Letter dated April 16.- 1976 from the ACRS to M. Rowden, acting Chairman of.!JRC (witn 8 attachments).
i f
- 64. Complete set of!NRC Regulatory Guides,
- 65. Safety Evaluation Report, Three Mile Island, Unit 2 (September 1976).
4 I
~
The following list of documerits consists of backup documentation used in support of the NRC Staff's direct testinony in this proceeding which are available from public sources and are therefore not enclosed:
1.
" Governor's Advisory 'Comission on Electric Power Alternatives, Final R2 port, Facts and Recommendations", Lansing, Michigan (August WM f'
I OFFICa b
., ~, - __
l w
l su=MA8dt %.
e&TS >
........-..r, 9
Foran MC 318 (Rev. 9 53) MCM 02 0 W u.s eovsmmasswv rainisme orricas sere.see-too
~ '. '
- i. NIE
. N..
1, _ _.. _ _ _,... _ _.
Y' n
/
l 2.' Energy Resources Council, " President's Ener9y Program, Monthly Progress Report" (August,1976).
}
3.
Consumers Power Company FPC Annual Report, form No.12. Schedules 12 and 13.
4.
Michigan Public Service Comission, " Evaluation of the Consumers Power and Detroit Edison 1979 Load Growth Forecasts", Staff study 1974-4 (Decenter 1974).-
5.
" Project Inderendence Report", Federal Energy Administration, Super-intendent of Documents U. S. Government Printing Office, Washington, De C.(StockNo. 4118-00029).
6.
" National Energy Outlook" Federal Energy Administration, FEA-N-75/713, (February 1976).
7.
1974)gy Crisis Alters, Power-Use Pat. tern". Electric World (January 1 "Ener 8.
"More Homes are Using Electric Heat". Wall Street Journal (February 18, 1974).
i i
9.
" Report of the 50th American Assen61y, April 22-25, 1976", the American Assembly, Colun61a University (Arden House, Harriman, New York).
1G.
" National Gas Supply and Demand 1971-1990", Federal Power Comission,
. Staff Report No. 2 Bureau of Natural Gas Washington, D. C. (February
'1972).
h
- 11. FPC ' Guidelines re Natural' Gas Customers, 38 Federal Register _1503 (January 15,1973).
l 12.
"1972 Census of Manu'facturers Fuels End Electric Energy Consumed",
U S. Department of Commerce, Bureau of Census (Washington, D. C.
. Government Printing Office, July,1973).
f 13.
"A Procedure for Estimating Non-Fuel Operating and Maintenance Costs for Large Steam-Electric Power Plants". ERDA 76-37 (October 1975).
i t
,. - s.
i 14.
" Environmental ^ Protection Study", prepared for Michigan Public
~
r.
- Service Comission by I.C.F. Incorporated, Washington, D. C.
(May,1975).
e OF FIC E >
~,
-...-....s.-...~
~. - - -
1 eVANAMEM t..
...-+a
^
D ATE >.
~
~~-a"**~-
forse AZC.*l, (Re. 9 5 H AECM 0240
' W u. e. eovenmusw? Paintime orrects tefa.ose t ee
(
_L 4+= s_
Aib_i x
w' * -
~ *'
co.
6 i'
In' addition to the documents listed in this letter, the NRC Staff of course utilized all documents filed in the formal Midland docket such as the Environmental Report, the Preliminary Safety Analysis Report, the Safety Evaluation Report, the Final Environmental Statement, the Affidavits by the Applicant recently flied before the Comission, etc.
Sincerely, Lawrence Brenner l
Counsel for NRC Staff
Enclosures:
ds stated
\\
cc(w/ encl.):
David J. Rosso Esq.
L. F. Nute,-Esq.
cc(w/oencl.):
Daniel H. Head, Esq.
Dr. J. Venn Leeds, Jr.
I Dr. Ermeth A.. Luebke, Esq.
Judd L. Bacon, Esq.
i Honorable Curt T. Schneider Howard J. Vogel, Esq.
Harold F. Reis, Esq.
Atomic Safety and Licensing.
~~
i Board Panel Atomic Safety and" Licensing Appeal Board i
j Docketing and. Service Section u
s c
t w
W-M-
, e%,
'k'.
s
~
f, l
r i
f
'Y
.L l
Y' l
euguaue >
D ATE >.
,,,5,,,,
Para MC.)l3 (Rev. 9 53) AICM 0240 W u. a. oovannuant pr. intine orrecen t era.eae.see
,,. Arc 1
,I..
~
i
i.
4
" State Projections of Income, Employment and Population to 1990",
l 28.
U. S. Department of Connerce, Social and Economic Statistics Admin-istration (reprinted from April 1974, survey of current business, t
t Volume S4, No. 4).
" Electricity Demand: Project Independence and the Clean Air Act",
29 Oak Ridge Hational Laboratory, Contract No. W-740S-ENG-26, funded by the National Science Foundation (November 197S).
"The Future of the U. S. Huclear Energy Industry", Joskow and Baughmr,
30.
Massachusetts Institute of Technology, prepared for l'ational Science Foundation (April 197S).
-31. '" Uranium Market Activities", J. Patterson, ERDA (Uranium Ind :.try i
Seminar, Grand Junction, Colorado, October 10,1976).
32.
" Uniform System of Accounts Prescribed for Public Utilities and Licensees", Federal Power Comission (April 1,1973).
" Construction Review", U. S. Department of Commerce (July 197G),
33.
34.
" Compound Interest Tables", Union Carbide Corporation.
Large aerial photograph (3' x 3') of Midland site, obtained by tGIC
- 35. ' Staff from Consumers Power Company.
" Standard Review Plan for the Review of Safety Analysis Reports for 36.
Nuclear Power Plants", U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Comission (NUREG-75/
087).
- 37. " Construction Status Report", U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (HUREG-0030-11 ).
The Staff is attempting to locate extra copic:, of Itcas 35 Note:
and 37 for your use. However, therefmay be some delay in obtaining them due to the short supply on hand.
In view of a possible time lag, you may wish to obtain these two docu-ments by purchase directly from the National Technical
~
s,
.Information Service, Springfield, Virginia, 22161.
T If you wish,'you may* contact the undersigned to make arrangements to inspect the documents which we are not enclosing at the Staff's offices in Bethesda, Maryland.
(
oat. >
r. ac.n, m..,.,n ucx n.
q..............................
.a 4
l
- 15. " National Energy Outlook - 1976", Federal Energy Administration.
I t
- 16. ~ "A Study of Coal Prices", Executive Office of the President, Council j
on Wage and Price Stability.
(Staff report, March 1976).
j 17.
" Price and Availability of Western Coal in the Mid-Western Electric l
Utility Market, 1974-1982", J. G. Asbury, Et_ A1., Argonne National Laboratory (October 1974).
18.
" Factors Affecting Coal Substitution for Other, Fossil Fuels and Electric Power Production and Industrial Uses", Congressional Research Service for the Comittee on Interior and Insular Affair %
i i
U. S. Senate, Serial No. 94-17(92-107)(1975).
I' 19.
"The Economics of Nuclear Power: A New England Prospective", State of Massachusetts Energy Policy Office (December 1975).
- 20. Consumers' Power Company 1975 Annual Report.
21.
" Michigan Census of Manufactures", Department of Commerce, Bureau ofCensus(April 1975).
22.
" Residential Energy Conservation Strategy", E. Hirst, Oak P.idge National Laboratory, Contract No. W-7405-ENG-26 (September 1976).
23.
"An Engineering-Economic Model of %sidential Energy Use", E. Hirst, I
et al., Oak Ridge National Laboratay, Contract No. W-7405-ENG-26, I
T0kliE/TM-5470,' July 1976)..
i t
1 24.
" Conservation and Efficient Use of Energy", Report of the Comittee i
on Science and Astronautics, U. S. House of Representatives, 93rd l
. Congress, Second Session (December'18,1974).
~
25.
"U.S. In'dustrial Outlet,1976 With Projections to 1985", U. S.
i Department'of Commerce, Domestic and International Business Admin-istration, January 1976.
- 26. "1970 Census of Population, Number of Inhabitants, Michigan", U. S.
Department of Comerce, Bureau ofl.the Census (July 1971).
s v..
27.
"1970 Census of Housing, Detailed Housing Characteristics, Michigan",
' U. S.-Department of Comerce, Bureau of the Census (April 1972).
h i
j
- orrica >
_,.,,,,, _j,, _,..
eunwawa p gAfg >
_.~
- u. e. oovanwnerne paintino orricas s,74 ose.see
. Forma AEC,)l3 (Rev. 9 53) AECM 0240
-w.
w w
w-
- W e.
_e.., - _. ~,
.,,,.7-.,-_.,,m,_.
,.,,.-w,,,,,,,,,,,.,,.y
,-%...,-,._,.7w,
,,,,.._9._.,--,..---,,7%e,-,c
4 q.
- 7. ' FPC News, Volume 9 Nuct>er 12, Table 3 (March 19,1976).
i 8.
Memorandum to Files from Paul Fine, " Projected Prices of Coal" (June 4,1976), enclosing Table 2. " Average Delivered Prices of Coal at Steam-Electric Plants", FPC News, p.10 (Novent>er 1975).
i 4
9.
FPC News, June 1976, pp. 11 and 43.
I i
- 10. Adequacy of Electric Power Fuel Supplies,1975 to 1985, A. Gakner, i
et al., FPC (38th Annual Meeting, American Power Conference, l
XFrTT 20-22,1976) (Execrpt, p.19).
11.
" Economic Analysis of Coal Supply", prepared for Electric Power Research Institute by Pennsylvania State University.(May 1975) i (Excerpt).
12.
" Report on Coal", from Status Report of the Ad Hoc Comittee on Energy Resources and Technology of the Atomic Industrial Forum, March 1975 (July 1, 1975 revision).
- 13. " Economic Comparison of Base-Load Generation Alternatives for New England Electric", Arthur D. Little, Inc./S. M. Stohler Corp.
(March 1975) (Excerpts).
14.
" Impact of Increased Coal Use on the Clean Fuels Deficit - Discussion Draft Report", Sobotka and Company, Inc., EPA Contract No. 68-01-2407 (February 14,1975)(Excerpt).
- 15. Electric Sales and Generation Data consisting of_8 pages telecopied to NRC Staff by Consumers Power Company, September 24,1976.
l
- 16. Consumers Power Company Responses to NRC Data request of October 12, l
1976 (October 21,1976).
- 17. Consumers Power Company response to NRC Data request of October 12, i
l 1976 (October 18.1976).
t l
- 18. Letter ^- G. Heins to S. Feld (October 11,1976).
l
- 19. Letter - J. H. C11mer to S. Feld (October 20, 1976).
- 20. Letter - R. Green to S. Echols (November 9,1976).
- 21. Memorandum to Files from P. Fine, " Rates of Growth of Electrical Requirements" (May 14, 1976).
orric s
- l suns aus >
e oaes >
F&ran AEC 31, (Rev. 9 53) AECM 0240 W u. S. SovanNusNT PAtNTING OFFICs31974.SSS=1SG 1
. m
.