ML19331A996
| ML19331A996 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Midland |
| Issue date: | 04/03/1979 |
| From: | Gibbs M CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.) |
| To: | Cowan F, Kornblith L, Smith I Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8007240577 | |
| Download: ML19331A996 (2) | |
Text
ISHMA. LINCOLN & BEALE c~ m..m. s
.n. w
....,s
,,,_t.
e:..
as.- a.
an.,=,
ie s = a - s-= c c. u e:,c.. c,::........
"5 y, pj,:;,:g::n
..a 3oc..c..u..n
.e,;.3...cs.,
,, c.
r ; s. 5 E O *. : r. :',0 8 ass:: a ts I'
I O ' ' #*
I 000 3 E E #I I*
EI^**E *
- WE'
.*-as.ts 4 Sa%C
- .,p
.m 3s3 GE0*E 4A%
C* SON h e 3. a. w s t w t s.. #.
w
~ ~.
- *
- 0 *
- c"'.i t.*, *.*e x* s
~
e.,.
g 3.-.
3'2.
- E S.
- E C C
- E.E x 2 52 S S t
...t. w...a..e.
m..4w
.a..
c 2E%:..
Fag;E4
.a e O s a g g.,
,a,gge,.g g,,,g.y agaN p,
$stbawgat 3,, g % C. % C i 3,0 %
4:****
Q. 8 t *1 ' 4 ;.
- 5 E 4' A.* C L5 CS sawgg g.g eyg
,,gy
,,,, g ;,. gy a.
.se-3
.,C a.*,An; somms;m gg,% g, g.* *i A % 0
?>C was S aa w s*aN 4 0 9 C a* E. C *0 M%
3 C oaLO O. wi%Dt u C. su o s t C c 610 g. 01 S T EV E *e
- 4. 5 C.ar g e C..tr% 3*aa%3 staae 0, 0 s T g m La % c C.Ama t'v a h s 3 0 * *4 r e g t g e:C r. 3 0- e t* C
- 2C a r a-acc: *...3
.;-wwgG*E EO S C6k
- w. E A D *. s m.
- Awk w.5 cme:ggga a.0waa: O C. C a =
- a..F waw2Les
- C9tm? L.E3*gs
- Arg w.gegg go m ;C.e a n O C. 8 0
- C..
"O%A6 3 3. winin t a C AwiO J. Fs 5 C pt a scy s.goes%gge A. C e m e t, e t w cu m as me stnT w rbClhwam wamv L. F ITC =
cav c w. staw k p s.a. a r. p,m g..
?C4*v F. mCaiTZ J A M E S a. F.ET C M E A
- = s t.
Swa*CN L.
- t N G
- C e E m ? M. wm EE Lga a h = C w. r e a g g a paugga 3.stroggg s e s.a, ~
se s e,-..u e.
~^ar-+Ca nis w.m.-
.sv='a~s p
STtvtw m. h 7C40 PATRICIA M SwCENCY p ec = a t L L.s a ul t A tv h A L,C O P. G LC,y t m
.:.E.
ac c r LE.-
".c a
- E ' s a'"
are-aa= = T
'E s Co~aa s.- m :-sa.
- Auk C. L E w S C SIS JCmq W.TREECf m L t xa N C t *
- C = ** C y r a sa an g s a LOO".AN A C = A D G. Z A w A e t h c2.%.c.
s e - ~ c ae..r..
n y - 1
.e,. 9 / o,
., w 2
u e c. + a *
"u^
n'^14 ".'.,
a*.
~
e
,a. n..
.e..s-
- u.,
e, s c.
p-.
c.
4.
z Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Recula:crv. Ccmmission U.S. Nuclear aeculatory Commission Mashington, D.C.
20555 Washington, D.C.
20555 J-~~ r ~' N
/ k $ M '/. h..,
Dr. Frederick P.
Cowan
- 6152 N. Verde Trail
/Wh r -
's W '\\
e Apt. B-125
/ >'
- i f3 ' '., iy gS DOCUMENT CONTAWS seca aaton, Florida 33433 7
W P0OR QUAUTY PAGES
- ~,
c
.x cc
. s. -
ne:
Censumers Power Company Y
d' L
(Midland Plant Unit.,s 1 and 2).
'.M; r
Docket Nos. 20N.. 9, 50-230 w
s.. - ~..
,/-
C,e..
. g... =.n..
g :.,_.,_, W
- u. o. o~ e. = 1 r' - a h. e.=.~. #. *., C^".#o-".". a
.,. &o.s.4. m~:.
.,,,4
- : - m,.
- -- e-
. - :,- a et
- C c'. '~ #-
C'.<'a-."~-'c.'.*^-
^
.... u..s..-.~. s n... - s.: - c - r,.,,
=a
~'s'
- ^
,n--sg
-a c
.-s
=-
nas C1sCo"ereC a aCtua 01Ssta 3-t r O c G e C i n c., CCnsumers Power CemO.anV...
man; in the section of the Orc.er whlen cescranes tne coo,ing system fer the 3.idland Plant.
This misstatement does not alter the rulings made by the Licensing Board or any other substantive matter contained in the Order.
In order to ensure an accurate record, however, Consumers Pcwer submits this letter correcting the description of the cooling system to the Licensing Board and the parties.
.,.,c, s
..,, - u... ~, s.m.,... a., as:., m. - :,.. -
- ~,
. - -.a as 4...
.y
.n...--
.: e; e -.-
.-s.4
- u. %. a..... ~.. - - - - - ~ ~ ---..: -.
. =.,
- s..:,
.,. e,. 3 e
..-,.4
.....v..
--r
=%
- s. A : ~ *
- n== ; ;
o
..o:
.2
.l.
,.. -. =... * "; * *
. ~ - - - - -~~~~~
..z-4,.
4
= *
.~w..r.-.
- w.. ~ - =.. -- * * =-
~..,r-..-..
7'..
=..... -.
- 8E
.*.M.s. --- - -....
p.
e
.a
- .'.4. '
-*4
.De4
.4 6
8
.a 800724o 7p a
i
..a D. _. c.~,c..
,. o _. e _. _t u..a s.,
._. o _, _4
- u.,
-o
..o Pace 2 3._y
_2 _3 2,
_t o / o a
a
. ". s_
S_ _T _C _4.e - a g 4 T._e _ w "..
_1,0, ?_
A s _e a_ _ _4 b_ e_4_._s c..1_4..:
_e,. e. e_..
-u o-whereby heated water frcm the condenser passes directly to the cooling pond.
Mcwever the desien also antici-pated a relativelv small amorn of heated service water ccoled by blowdown cells.
FES III 5-8 and Fic. III-2.
The elimination of these cells, if such has indeed occurred, would not appear to provide an ade nate basis for Mr. Marshall's contention.
Order at 22 (emc. hasis supplied).
The underlined portion is incorrect in that it confuses two discrete features of the cooling system for the nuclear facility, one of which has been eliminated.
At the time the construction permits se c_ _ c l' o s "m e d, ' " a_
A e s _4
_# o _-
..".e
.'4_4 A _i n d
_3 _1 _= n c n
- a...e _' _aa d "._4 _1 _4 ' 4..c, c
3 both pond bicwdown cells (also called cooling tcwers) and a service T. hi _ # c.-...a _- we*=.
in' ended. ' o _ =_ A_ u r e. w.e b l e v. d c "4.7
, c _, _4.. :
a s".s a
..._,_e_-
Thc discharge temperature to 1*F above the ambient river temperature.
total dimensions of the three pond blowdown cells would have been 4 5 feet wide, 360 feet long and 60 feet high; these cells would have operatec anytime curing the year when the pond was.eing.cAcwn down.
c Environmental Report-Operating License Stage 510.3.3.
It is the pond blcwdown cells which have been eliminated from the Midland Plant design.
The service water cooline tower, wnica-1s retainec'in the current os.an for the nuclear r.ac111tv, is cesicnec to oterate curinc-
- " =..=.,. - = _ _ = _ - -. _.. -
e ee_-,_ca w_'.a-2:
.n
...2_,... = _,
wa- -,. wea- _...e_ _,., e_ -e-u-
_i =_ * '. e... re c-.a_ e "_ e _l ov. 9:'".
A m..e.".c.._4 cc_1 c_c'. c o' _#.: ' - w e _r,~"n.-
~
s e. _,.... _ c-
.. c-. _= - ' mow =_ _* _i s -...,o s e
^s # '.".. o. = _' _l
, =_ = u-k.. ".. c- ". _". : = "=so-c '-
- d. c' d
o by 71 feet and a height of 34 feet.
Environmental Report-Gperating License Stuge 53.4.2 and Table 3.4-2.
h
..e n ar _e =_ A_
- t. i.. _3. ".. 'a o u _' _d ce.=ues
."..a.
c.dk_'_^",..#.~-"....
c a '_ _' o,
~
.e c.f.
e_. 3
_4 n c. c.a d 4 c 1'.. c, d u " _4..e-e..m.
v a r
_4. ' k.e _d _- ", _ _. _d '. ";, " c- ". = _" e s_..
k
-~
. there will be less foccinc eliminated frcm the Midland Plant design, and icina associatec wl:n the nuclear r.acil. tv than was anticica"tec a the construction permit hearings.
It is there:cre c,vious c
tne time or o _ f c - __
w s
-n
...e..ic_1,nc nie u c =.,.n e
... a u-u-
...e. s m..m, n _, 4.,.
c e _e _: 3 u o.
.w e
.w,&
uw
,w
.wo admission on the ground of " changed circumstances" of Mr. Marshall's ma_
,, u s, :ne a censinc.
to icing anc roc.c.ine. errects.
1.
contention re2atine.
if Scard's conclusion that contention 5 is barred by res judicata is,
^*
_ =
.a_ : u n.
_ u. _; s c _' _ _" _ _ _ c _= _ _., _
.. a_ _c-
. =.. _ u.._e..~e,
u.
_n.
o -,... :
.-.....or
-m he,
%e
=%
.s e
s,..
.. -_ ve..-.._n'...
.y.
.2
_ %. 3.~_
m_...._...__
s.
k.
.7-J uw
_c..-_e
__c.
.