ML19330B540

Motion to Compel Applicant Answers to 800611 Interrogatories.Responses Were Unresponsive to Questions. Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence

ML19330B540
Person / Time
Site:	Allens Creek File:Houston Lighting and Power Company icon.png
Issue date:	07/26/1980
From:	Marrack D MARRACK, D.
To:	Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
References
NUDOCS 8008050002
Download: ML19330B540 (4)

Text

..

r

.=.. ..-.. .. ...

. . , p.rzo co### c .

~2Y -** f f

- .g;~

.=- 97 e .

D . .". . .-3 b.; A .;e.7. . c.s A a

e I n. v.m.e . 2 .o s e

r.m., ,_.m nn ay --

. Cc, o . . .1.

e. 2 2. 01,-

EEFoRE THE AT0flIC SAFETY AND LICENSIN :- 32.' DOCUMENT CONTAINS 2 n t.ne L,.atter o., i POOR QUAUT( PAGES

• HOUSTON LIGHTING & POWER C0!G.GY Docket No. 50-466 ed 191/ g ,

( Allens ~rt ek Nuclear "renerating -

--: I  %

. . . . . ... , . n .4 1) - g 9J JUL 3 0192 > '1 nm.

v .u. Tea.- mn. n a. ..:r_ta n:. :LICAI'T *. O

. .AN.e'.'..#.'?'

WSush!

2 -. .

-..-..<.r n

.m. .

n, m.. 3. .,..m.r.2.3.cC a

n *a 0.5 7.? S O.r

. _1 1. .T IFa _-

F s

-M, S .# C".. 1. O T " . . I .s..O I,& 4. M ' J'l .

, .. _=..

_.. 1..n e nrm. C.R.. I e

" Clearly identify, including title, name of author (s), date and literature reference, of all documents you are relying

... - 4 . ...u -

0 .

m_..o ' .v .e .' 2.e.d .e....'=..e o r. '.'.a.

-- 3 ... . .a- ' ( s ' o ' ,- w a .-

'.. = .*. _e..._'s .e._i .o . .' _*. . e s c a.

.c._43 c-. - o a we ' e .'ow.'. . "

nterrogatory I attempts to have identified the docunents Houston

.ighting and ?cwer Ocapar.y ( Applican ) relied upon in the prepara:icn 1

and analysis of impacts of ?cwer Transmission lines as re: forth j

. .- ==_ e. a . a. v.:..:= r .e. .

. . or - .a . g .ea. . e. n a. .,. c.< s e ,a . . y. a. . . , .-r . .,.,, ., ; n. a. . .  :

in his response were identified in our submission cf th s contention.

The Applican has clearly avoided the issue of the d::u.ents relied 1 mon in his analysis of impacts of transnission lines over I agricultural land on. avifaunai as set forth in the FEIS and FS?IIS.

Until these answers are provided, I submit the Applicant is being

.- . .. -. ,, .e ..

s . . e. .:. ...

..-. _r o..o...c.emnw..

. . . .: v. -l l

l l

"Frovide the full names and addresses and C7's of all these $ l pers:ns who (a) took part in a.y way, or supervised, er a.aly ed data

[]

,_ , .. ......4=..,.

.* .c.r.

. . . . . . .. . t . ,/ .

l 8 0 annMa @2 1

m_._._. _ _ -

r ,

. _ ~ .

y,

, . t O

- - =a e 2 -

- - e mm.=

(t) State the centribution of each person naned in 5.a/ -'

i

.to the study 4./. the =ethods they used, the literature (title, authors and reference by journal title, vol., .

page, date) consulted by these persond to establish the ,

s- . .

o.

.. . validity, or otherwise, of all metho.ds each person used s

~. ~

c.in the conduct of their par: of the study, the quality

.1

. . . , control procedures they each used in conducting this study.

s -

'. / (c) provide CV's, cite the experience and any s ecial -

e%

training, studies, or directives received by those persons

- a. ' a. -- a. d '. o 4 . . ,.a/.

(d) State for the persons na.ed in 5.a/ the particular qualifications which -ive 5 them expertise in the area of the evidence from them, en which you are relying in the natter of Contention -2".

It.e *.pplicant's response is patently unresponsive.

.....u..

v e . . .. e ... . - m~- ~. v,..r,

. . . e.. , e -: .. =.c......a . ...

ne n..p-:cc...

e

c. -

..a a3=w

.S.=.". "o2

.. . ..y a ~. . .= *..a .d '- c. e". ' d a. .r. " ' .e c' b . *.>. . e t .f

. . , - e . s w- . . a l 2 . . .e ..=. .~ *. ' . . 3-

. .v. m m .. c.n .e.. 4 .c. .e...

4r - - . , . , . e...;dw.s.

vw..- m.

P. b. . , * - .1 c.fy 4 CET.'. .- a. s o ~c '. *. *. *. b. i e- -. 4- '

. a e s .c. . .*^e .".. . a .",D" o.*. s e *. o T . . . .c. . .* w* 3 :. w .~. ",", ,h, .

,s g 3 ,.

u, .........,,, ny,-. c,.. .g

.s ..o .

m:ncicg.lon

. a. s...,.-,. .c u.-.,. . . . . .

= . ..,.

any significant bird lesses along any of its transmission reu;es...."

In the answer to Interregatorv c

. a. the supposition is that Dr. F.G.

Ichlicht is indeed the person she has cene to these transmission line corridors and inspected the race in a thorough scientific a

..v..'o- d~=a* o r. - *

~ o . '. ~. c ' ' a '- s '.u

. . - . -- ac - . a. d '~- 9.-- A s .

l l

However, even if I intuit that Houston Lighting & power's employee Dr.F.G.Schlicht is the source cf the allegation of "no impact", it l l

l

p _. _

)

~ ~

2'G b-- O .,?

=.-

T is clearly impossible to intuit how Dr. F.?.Schlicht conducted the data collection, what methods he used, the quality control procedures, I

the analysis procedures used on any data collected, and overall ,

scientific integrity of the sc-called study leading to the production of sc-called scientific assessment.

Intervenor respectfully requests the NRC 3 card cc pel the Applicant to ar.'wer s Interrogatory V directly.

Sizilarly, the Applicant's answer to INTERR03ATORY VI.

"Frovide all the records, field notes, draft documents, menc-randa. , work notes, netations or other reccrds made by all persons involved in the matter of 4./, the Applicants studies of the impact of transmission lines on migratory waterfew1.

State the conclusion, if any, drawn from the study."

is unresponsive and undermines the in sgrity of the "Dise:very ?rocess".

Intervencr respectfully reques s The 3 2rd compel Applicant to a-.swsr the questiens dire::ly and ;roduos requested docu.ents, ree:rds,

. etc. , or compel the Applicant to admit he has no data, reports, re crds, or studies as clained.

26 July 1950 Respectfully submitted, .. .

/

f

/

/ .r -

( '

D. Marrach, Intervenor

~-

UNITED STATES O AMERICA

-

• NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

• O g

7 4 BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD .

. , . woo  ;.

In the Matter of G

g -

s

$l3 0@ W ,

~l HOUSTON LIGHTING'& POWER S .'

COtiPANY S Docket No. 50-466 r, /

(Allens Creek hueleur s N Generating Station, Unit S N o .' T ) S

,q,[

CERTIFICN'? OF SERVIC"  %[ M,'

o Ii I herebv certify that copies of the foregoing / e -

were serve [1 on the following by deposit in the United /"/

mail, postage, prepaid, or by hand-delivery. -

- Sheldon J. WOIfe , Esq. , Chairman Richard Lowerre, Esq.

Atomic Safety and Licensing Assistant Attorney General Board Panel for the State of Texas U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission P. O. Box 12548 Washington, D. C. 20555 Capitol Sta tion Austin, Texas 78711' Dr. E. Leonard Chentum Route 3, Box 350A Watkinsville, Georgia 30677 Stephen A. Doggett, Esq.

P. O. Box 592 Mr. Custave A. Linenberger Rosenberg, Texas 77471 Atomic Safety and Licensing.

Board Panel ,

Mr. John F. Doherty U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Coraission 4327 Alconbury, Washington, D. C. 20555 Houston, Texas 77021 Mr. Chase R. Stephens Robert S. Framson Docketing and Scryice Section M1deline Bass Framson Of fice of the Secretary of the 4822 Waynesboro Commission Houston, Texas 77035 U.S. Nuclear Regu.latory Commission Mashington, D. C. 20555 -

Carro Ha..nd e.r s teln

.1 Gregory Copeland 8739 Link Terrace 3000 One Shell Plaza Houston, Texas 77025 llounton, Texas 7'/002 Atomic Safety and Licensing Ms. Brenda McCorkle Appeal Doard 6140 Darnell U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Houston, Texas 77074 Conaincion -

Washington, D. C. 20555 Mr. W. Matthew Perrenod 4070 Merrick Jack limman, Esq. Houston, Texas 77025 1.owenstein, !!cis, !!ewman & Axelrad 1025 Connecticut Avenue, fl.W. Mr. Waync E. Rentfro h'asin naton, D. C. 20037 P. O. Box 1335 Rosenberg, Texas 77471 Steve Schinki, Esq.

Staff Counsel Mr. James M. Scott U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commincion 13935 Ivy Mount Washington, D. C. 20555 Sugar Land, Texas 774,78