ML19330A198
| ML19330A198 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Midland |
| Issue date: | 08/31/1976 |
| From: | Dircks W NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS (EDO) |
| To: | Griffin R SENATE |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19330A199 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8007150966 | |
| Download: ML19330A198 (7) | |
Text
.
C Distribution
/ Docket File PVitale MYTDF DRVassallo LO' l PM LCrocker August 31, 1976 EDO Reading MService 0:cket Wosdu-y2; W.R Readng JYore, ASLB am Su.ug Li9. #4 File IE(3)
ECPusche JMiller EGCase HDenton RSBoyd RHeineman Attorney, ELD VStello
':::' '!cror*oln ?cmrt P. orif fin CA (3)
.uicau al.uus Jeoate GErtter (00768)
..asnin ; ton, 2. C.
I.Jbio MGroff EHughes
,..c 2,-.x.i.Jr ac i.;ia :
SHilI
!.11: 100tCr 10 in !OJOCns3 tO ';'cCr COLOrrLA On nu.N3C J,
11/9 Gi tad lut.;Ur
_f 2..,...
ywL.
- w...s.4 m..,.....
u.
.... ~. -....,
i >.3 3.
n ^ "Orrn?"' " "<'a
'.W P11 ',' 49 9 M D C 'WI ra r.. : s uit c.jy v u oac ci %
4.'010 u.r.nC. :.ini;.;; ROC 10n.
..'.l u VO!, J 1.10 0 C.J -AL. _' UJ O JOLai J.
L :.:
J-uC
- rci.1..r.
ROW 7. T.icr0 nCarly !913tCa to tne CC01Vit1CS an rO.Mn31J111C1. s Of Cnc lMC122r.%ulJtOCy COr?C.15Sion, WO NVO agr9eG to ~;rdJarG tne re34nse.
- mto:: tion ;erm::r 2:c t.;o u.;innu ?1.mt ver 12:uca 2.v ::n Tecule :.:urw
' 'c la,. i
- .11.;: q a ;.:n::.,:u
.~.:11:. ar.:... u '.
- 1 31 r. ca
- - ~ -
_T.L.t J C; ; C.;O t l'.C '..ma. LJ 31 J..u..: c -. ~d w. 2 J.
al..,
s~....
..a MirQ. On C.41 i.010t Ji t*;13 4^,05fu jivnC.
2.
r:::nt 02:ici:n of the U. 3. Court of :.~~:21s fer tha District at Colue.ola, iielson Ae3nlic.an v. United States Juclear Requistory Ccamission,
.;nica is the su rject of t:.c tr.i; nc.Jsec, r clip:ings 2nclosea witn ar. drcwn's letter, coes not invaliaate tne ccastruction cerr.iits suica
' rare issueu for tne :tiule.nd Plant. 2ne Cc..ciloaica on August 1;,1375, in accorcance with its General State. ent et Policy on tna Environmental Effects of tha Urr.nium Fucl Cycle, crdared tnc rcepcning of tac clidl:nd croceeding for tne limited curpose of considering whether tne outstancing constructica,oermits snoulu ce continueo, n.ouuleu or susoenaco. Aue Court in recanoing tne orcer granting tne constructica cer. nits also utstructed tne C;. mission to reconsiver tne aracs of enargy conservation alternatives and to return tne recort of tne Advisory Comittee on Reactor Safeguards on the aidland Plant to tne Cccc.ittee for clarification or tna c.ciguities noted in the court's ceciaica. 'cae Conaission will co.wact a croceeding en tnaco i cues unen the d2cicica of tne court or acOeals in Aesalin,3n v. i<c.C ceco:.es final.
THIS DOCllMENT CONTAINS POOR QUAI.lTY PAGES 8007180 7g
rae doncraole dovert ie. dririin
.i-Ite Juclear acgulatory C0miasian'3 Final Enviren. ental dtatas:ent (FCS) for tr'e Mialana Picnt 2ccrerses tne cooling water supcly for tne uant ard une isoact ut u6e raket neat fro.a die giant ca use envireni.ent.
.'r.
to' n c.ay ccre to stauy tha ciccussica 0; tnic canter. :ic can :ina it in Section III.O.1, pagas III-5 tnrou;h III-20 of tu? FI'.3, a c00y cf nica is lccat.Sc in the Local 7,lic Locu.: cat F.cc.. in ta: Orcca D0u
'"~'*
Ln.rary ;.: l L..:;t.'t.
.'. cr:u:. 02,
.i.f i r.', d rai;=.
A.s incicatea in this discussien, tne im. net of. the plant on tne Tittacauacsee River, even caring cericJa of los 11cs, are accoctaolo. faic is cccc plished :.,y usc of an JO,J acra cooling pcnd wnica troviacs a ::: rvc sueny or coottna water ruc oiaat use aaa woien anow.s cae oisit tu voecate
'n 0.n OC3dntiallf c10JOJ c*fcl2 0001103 O'/U000.
.MO 730t2r 0 O f Lt"" 7.*'.] :
- l0002 i." CC I.0 < 3.'U.M r iC r
".iLi
"'2 C 200 3 C:? *tr 7'G i
b'f CONSUChr3 FO*..Or CT.73n? DOC 3 3r2 03:21 9 tr.J Cur 1ir,7 of tni5 Wnc't.
- a. tra.it tsit O li.1 in t st.,0 C ida -s i ~ l '. l Li u
,0: J CO ua*C i h.s
.4 C.::, A;i.31 Je t
1
!2k ; IO
.f. f 0 5.
,......m,,
' -.2
.'.iua:. :.
uw. :
.Y3 I
l l
l
Enclosure:
P.eferral of August 2, 1376 from Senator docert P. Griffin l
i b
i v,_ t 9
,vuq 1
' lh See Previous feKow'for Concurrence IT
, PDM NR WD NRR/D '
%j/ISR #4 E
.._J_..Oi..a CA p.p o,,, c,,
cker;pav EG
._BCRu,s, he.._ _.LV.Go s s ~tc k...
~ ' i.,.
.u N. - *
,' OD.. /..) 7. -./. 7. 6 0.._8/...../. 7 6..
08//,/'_) /76 08/
/76 08/
/76
..n i
Form AEC.318 (Rev. 9-53) ALCM 0240
- u. s. ooVERNMENT PWINTING oFFICEJ I974 524 tee
f.1e t!cnorecle icccrt 4. Griffin -.
- \\
'2 nest.'ucicar mjulatory Cor.n1Gaion's final d.nvirarcental deacaiaean (ii'3) for tue.tialanJ ilant acore!,scs tac Occling aatar su ply 10r taa plant t.kinpact of the reject aast fr07 t;re pir.t on the envir:n*mnt.
an.4
. r. ; roe 71."ay ccre to.Itudy crac oi.;ca.>sica of taic :.cttir.
.;2 can ria,.
. c.a
,u...va....u.
, r..
.u
- .f :.nica 1 ' 10c:t::! in t..c !.: 21."unlic cc:1: c.t m in t:'e ir?.ce 73r
- emrial Licracy at 1710.iest 'it. Anotews no.u, oialanu,.licaigan.
As indicated in enis uiscuasion, tne i. A vf t.ia plant x. tne fitta.,aa.:.ac o
."*.V0r, OV0n Citri"? Trlt"w1C Ot' 10 4 E !C**, ?r 9.?CC**rita010.
411 154 19 GCCO.T..iliuncu Uy 20 01 n wJ car e ccalli.9 ;ce
...1c.; 1;r.L 1 2 ;
c,. ;;r'.'
Ju/yly Ur 00011.6 J.v 'a tJC iM 'dll t u.:.e Ja'.d... l iG.1 aIIC,a 3 t.'i 3,'1!.d C 13 Gi!-0000 1 ;011;C it.
'. 3 la E '.C;ili...~1022-C',* 2i ';
as.a ei, Cura v.
uw.L G.
ui e as& : L.;;a -.. a 3 - ! '.J !..
C',
- 7.'.".'7?r : C r
' "'?",' 9:' "
- r 9 ^' 't ' ? V '9
O
- t '? i l'1 D
l' C f.
I tr.;s t i..'. a t L'.l O 1.'.[.20. tiO *. ~41.1 !"'.C '.10 ',"
10 ?!?'/1 O 7 r 2.!!OS:l*/
rCgy 1.0.tI.
c1.a.
?,
\\
N
\\
\\
\\
's
\\ s
\\.
\\
\\
CA See Previous Yellow fo; Concurrence
\\
08/
/76 DPM/ LWR #4 DPM/AD/, LWR DP NRR/D/D NRR/D
'N ED0 4i_,
LCrocker;pa_.v RCDeY u.ng -
4 [p*?.
EGCase BCRusche LVGossick o.,
.. e,
08/
/76-08/ g /76 08/ # 76 08/
/76 08/
/76 08/
/76 d
Fo,um ABC.)l3 (Rev. 9 53) ABCM 0240
- u. s. oova==us=? wan= vine orrics sore.sas. nee
Distri bution Docket tile PVitale NRC PDR DBVassallo Local PDR LCrocker ED0 Reading MService occket :;cs.30-329 NRR Reading' JYore, /.SLC and 6 310 LWR #4 File IE (3) s BCRusche JPiller EGCase l'Centon N
RSBoyd RMeineman
\\
Attorney, ELD VStello
...e.~.avc =le -r t r. ur i'""
CA (3) c.,it s 2tates'd: nata GErtter (00768)
.e:hin; tun, c. C.
D519 MGroff EHuahes ceae senatar orirrin:
ggjjj
- .1
- 1
- c:2r i in rca dare to ; car rc:.crra;. cn.; u.t -, E a. t..;.:{t;c tr::~ rnur can :lt12nt, ".r'.
M il . era
- i C11 ' ;,
< ; r i T.,
2t:-
t1- 7,
s u,o.
.a3 cortes.cNeum tm eiat q'.ms retert. t o t.-s
.or;7 re:3 3rca tt:
CT:: :7T:nt '.rini:tr:ti:n. X ;*::::, ::::: 2:. ; r :~::
- .ht::
' ' ~ "' '~ - ~
frCa *r..*2rO'.m core nearly relatc5 to tiie activitie; :nu r Opon;1siliti33 i
c_ :n2. clear 7.2pitt:tf ca.- iciica,..: n~ : c.r ' u -
- mr3 t= raczna.
C o.id Cr uc siCa ;<irG 1c5 a f G.e
- is ' ; L elaat 3.-cc l 3,;u.i;.N ta 2 7. Loa ic ch;r. s u
';m mi m en ener.m 15, L m m ti~ tm 2
&r-e: m:lic r i.- -
i~-
.~. w cccu _ctn r.r.e cami, _;L
_. r, a;> a ta.
c..._
- 1_ac.
- ma :ct c.u uaviren._:ntal ire.:t :.,2 cao.;r ;c n :1.nt.
\\
nie recent cecision or tne d. 3. Court or e.r~<mais :or tne 91 strict on Colur. cia, Ecl:en Aasall=_n v. United. Stat _es J.uhlcar P_.egulatory Comicaica, n
wnien is tne suo]cct ct tne two newstarcr cfloolng anclosec witn Mr. Crown's letter, does not invalidate tne construction carmits unica were 1:sueu for tne liiuland Plant. T.c Cc=ticcica bn August 15, 1975, in accordance with its General Stater.ent of irolicy on\\tne Environmental Cffects of the Uranium Fuel Cycle, orderca the reccening of tne Micland "rT?aci? for tne li. Sited par 7007 of cencidering
-'.e'"'.
the Out-tanding constructionpermitsshouldceccntinued,modifiedorsus) ended. W.e Court in remanding tne order granting the construction octr.?its also instruct 0c the Ccr.iccion to recensider tnc creac of energy conservati0n alternatives ana to return reoort of tne Adviccry C:enittee on Pecctor a
Sareguarcs on the Midlari Pinat:to the Coamittee tor clarificat' ion of the ar.ciguitics noted in tae court's decision. T.e Contission will ' conduct a croc2ecing on thace issues.han tae cecisica of tac ccurt of a@ecis in Ae alie.an v. W.C ceccrus final.
\\\\
N
-.m.
':!:e ncnotacle eccert P. 3rif fin %
nic..;ucicar.7d).11at0ry 10r=13rion': Final d.nvironnentai statament (rTS) for tne lieland Pli'.nt cuaressa tnc coolin3 water uurnly Let t.e 7 ant 1
ana taa 1.: pact of 'tne reject heat tro.n tae plant on tao environnant.
"r. _rS;n aav c.?re en stuo/ tna ciscucsion at tais Tatter. de can 2.ino it in uction 1:1.3.1, m':s nI-5 t.1 ram.1 III-20 01 tae : s, a cJn 4
g of wnica 13 located in 6c0 Local d:clic Locu:aent P.0cra in tne Crace Ecw
..2:..Orial 1.iccary at 1/lu.Mst St. Aauraws.<caa, al'. lana,,ilcui:;2n.
s A3 inoicateo in tnis al cusalon, t.ne is act af toe olantt in tne 'icta.,awa.saae
...--:... e......s
.... c i.., -
.4-4-
.y
..,..,.a
.~
- k'.cc.?."110 1CO OV U30 OI *n JaU Crc cCOiln i '20;u W11C.1 'JLcV1.M i.I cc.5drVe T.C.>ly O E COGling =.id tCr JOr 13**fNI.iO 3nd tal;2n 3110wO OTJ ";iant OJ c00 rat 0 c1 an c s ntially cla n c"clo coc110.a ; vat:c'.
s d.).2 ".21tt?r s 0 s.L". ;11:Li UC.v??t3 1n 00 _.ae.id.c.' r iO C. P.i C.e C2.23.d.sC'da w.a. ".;. Or.'.-%.Gr. T l.O*'
- T 1 ^ r ? 7.;'.J hw ',* 12 : Urt/ i." e O C *'J!il ' ' ' ~. Tf.
,. _.. _.,s.
.. ~
u m.
m..~.m.
.m.
.s t ;7.:o..:.
.r.m.
s N
inc'r.?l f, \\
s.
s
\\
t
~
J 3
1/
'.*/ Y hd',V DPM/L9R'I4
/C.0E CA DBVassallo
(-
08/,,7 /76 08/cg;/76 08/
/76 DPM/LjR{4 _
R DPM/AD/LWRs DPM/D NRR/D/D NRR/D ED0 o,,,,,,
/ I LCroc er;pav RCDeYoung RSBoyd EGCase BCRus.che Ly.Gog.sj ck su....
08/ /6 /76 38f f_76
.08/
L76
. 03/
LZ5 08/_
fl6
_08/
/76 Form ABC.319 (Rev. 9 53) AICM 0240 W u. s. aovsmausme paintime orrecas sete.sas. tee
Distribution Docket File DBVassallo NRC PDR LCrocker Local PDR MService ED0 Reading JYore, ASLB Occr.at uos. 50-3 3 flRR Reading IE (3) ana 50-330 LWR #4 File Jftiller BCRusche HDenton EGCase RHeineman RSBoyd VStello Attorney, ELD 22 4:ncr2:le RcMrt ?. 3rit11n CA (3) adtea 5cateu anata GErtter (00768)
.aaningtca, S. C.
';051g MGroff EHughes
.s
_cr.icnacerdridcla:
Shill PVitale
- in lottar is in rt
- cen o to ecur rcrarral on Tu:'ust 2, i-1/6 or 12 lat:er tcv.a,,wc ev..x.mm.c,.
2.
m.,,,a a.. 1 l
._..ua..,. '.; Li; iv M. 1M cerror--^r":7 initt'lly ms rerertwi e r9a.nargy w +cco w
'"' ' *"10 d i'.in100!Ot10n.. 0. 072, Cinc'2 r.r.e 404 jC0t...J.Ctar G J 1r
- 1*.:Ci:L rroel !1r. dro%D iCEO nGarly TClates to tua activities and rOG. Cad 1.011101e$
Ot tn3 !!U 1 car h*"53ulatory COIrission, we naV3 agreOG to cre0ar3 Cne reSConde.
. NtructiCn Kr.its ECr C10 11GlCna Plant Wre 13JuOd Jf LVJ ACO::10
".0! T/
w0a.L1J3ien G.2 ;JC" ?r 45,.f/
loa.u;.'..L'J J pr0Cr;Jt;u JuJalJ.'0^.!iaj. 110.1 OC'.Cic 2r N ;0 01 tJe cOvi uu)1Cl1 u.Mty s_+. cts at t.J.
G.C aal..t m.
_.c a.'.VirCIVani:1 1T?aOC JL
.;? J r J.C ON 310.a t.
Ee-*t!*st. W
-_ - V1 4_-
'* ~rL L._;L C... i;;iCN arJi22' i.5C&. in JC2':r:.=??*F^
, A.- Ca n,t;.::. :.*'L:~K'
~~lj 's:.: L.
k; _.. _, ; --isted-44 r_et---ti% -
- One-6 L. c.~. v...
^
rae recent decision of taa U. 5. Court of.Qqcal for tne Di:trict 01 Coluroia, delson Aest111 man v. United States e.dclear iteoulatory Coir.ission, ouicn is tr.e suoject ot cae two newucaper clippingu encie:.;au witu
- ir. Brown's letter, cms not invalidate tne consttuction' permits willea were issuod for the i41dland Plant. The Ccccissicn\\cn August l$,1975, in accoraance with its General Statement of Policy chthe Environmental Ertects of tne Uranium c'uel Cycle, oraereo tne reopentry or une hiaiand proceeding Icr tne limited purpose of considering wnetneq tne outstanding i
construction permita sncula ce continueu, maaitied or suseece ea.
rna Court in remancing tae order granting tne construction por. nits al o instructec tne Car.insion to reconsider the areas 01 energy c qcervation alternatives anc to return tne reocrt of taa Advicory C0raitteeNpn Acactor 30fogucras On tne ;11dland P1nat to tne C0=ittee for clariticatich O': tne anciquitics noteo in tne court's decision.
Ihe Co.a.tission will coitauct
+
~
...m w on tnese issues wnen tne decision of tne court of a;,ccais in Aecniiman v. GRC cecomes final.
1
.y
_q
r
. ~ w :w,
- s < n m.,, n,--, rm,,. s,,,.em m,.
.,,,.np a n a n a
, vve,.,y7.,um.
-r,7
,, 4 e
( %
.e g.,_
.m m ng L
[
F R OM;, -
L4" ACTION CONTROL DATES CONTROL NO
~
w..
r.c.
im.
co m oeAou~,
.n.n.
00768 AC M.0
$N/Ih TO:
M.-
PREDAPE FOR SIGNATURE UF:
"f N AL C EPLY l
we
.]
p.
3 9, \\,3,
,,c.m..,..
l
- f'f*T y
y ONF R _M$ M.__
r_, r d ts N i
OESOair' TION L iETTEH UMEMo O REPORT U O Tt*ER SPECIAL INSTRUCTION 5 OR RENIAR AS f
, e n e e ass ans ane u w. as e m m e im e em e -
im.ienn.wwe elsewis ar.:.cLtt.n u! u.a.4Lt.12.1 p11ct s n_n17
~
l r.ee i e 1 e1 beime s l
I
^
^
m_3 3 ;;e.r p 3 s t
l:CcuvE..T 0m '.c.
l 0.M::FI;AT1;.,j l
f
'Nusn-10
- p. AGES l
fc,3 tg;uv t
t 4
e WJ 5 7
- L H E q a dT R Y Ni).6 l
._3 N 3t ug 90
_ Fogg i
n i
.s._
Im_.11_ _1./g g
A50lGNED TG:
l DATE l
'.O L E C A L C 3.;E '.' T $',0
- s. _ u q,yriev.
l
' ' ' *
- Ii!!%i~
f
! r a4
.wa i M a
^.
I i
t.
g e
Cu uc..id
,U Te d r.
l t
e.
4
- t. t,,4r 4
i ev, i
l
- 2.. s L
- R'...,.,,,,..,
'-m-'
EX ECUTi\\, E OlHECTCH DOR 04H,.TIGNs
,n
..n,-
er..r..-
4 a 4 - #.5 's PRINCIPAL CORRESPONDENCE CONTROL