ML19330A024
| ML19330A024 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Midland |
| Issue date: | 09/22/1971 |
| From: | Kartalia D US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC) |
| To: | Sinclair M AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8007140781 | |
| Download: ML19330A024 (2) | |
Text
_
g
- f. ~
%, P 4 ;
w.~
M
- m. m
&y*MC$;M5Q' g.. @i W % :
.;-.s.
_-~.w y~,-,g~
.ff % E % e
[f
- j-Q@ t sep , ~@*Cett*V f f. %.gi.m,.r,#m,~; Q.$ k & gip p f,Q@
w
' ke,d.p f%Q
'w
%z
' t m ps.w%v..a.m#@, g
.y
_.~
.e p, a Bi p
m,,. m m w 3. g; @ R,o _g.
w A,..... m
.A
,.p.5,.i. 4 0 &am&,M W.lg6swpw.A
.,.,2,e
.an n
- s.. a,~. y& v.yh n
, g'%n;
.a.,x'.,,. : 'w.,l
+
+
J^r
, y -
.w;,m,.
q' g.i f<$' ;,p.ac
< r n, k
vn w
s~C:;WK&m&.d. Q,pmp%tlE e
4 x;y 4,-
[,
Q;.
r Mi g/ g v % g'T'" y & ? Q<j$1f f y'f [.
P
'.w w s+
,K e
,. + W /,
13
, r;;
a,.
q
% L > ~.t,.a %:* ~.,$ u, a gA '
Q~N G yQifQQy&Q M
e N /s.t r
?
w e
A Mg@ pnp. w.; W M S.'EP W2 %. g,3. x n
~
' Docket.Nos,x8. 50-329
};&%
- y m
'y M g$ @48@p @.y
- pf.pp W
< W W S W"pqM3'$s.jyy@C "MiQ Q %ge M
150-330 y
g.
~
- WA *
,,4 v W W Sfk W p Ww" bI^
96 ' MQ$dMMW 4THIS'DdCiNEWCONT IN i@S;M
' ' " 'm W T
.WFv7hMW QSMbi c '1 y: M3 g* 5 " f 18
[
7 [%$ 900fKQUALNY!.PAGES?[
%%Mk S
Midland, Michig'an 48640.l
~Osq.M N
+. <tA 1 M.a x
M
Dear Mrs.,
Si.nc,l,ai,r:,
PMc Q
'w$w$u qM
~
+
-a t-
- y L. ' ~..
,,...?
- oVE fx A,1 ELM WlWW
. - This. is in responsa to your.;; e. W.W'. ' Yn ' >
.. tr,.
. n.n....
WrO w
0 w
l tter.of September 2 1971,L '
TG.O ff$Qe%.),
5l:o~%,,= y yq.c.t..i,o,N u.w.y.g proce MG 7
of5the:AEC constFucti i.Epirhit enclosing aQ:
c e
>e. nuel. ear, pow ~er, plan-u
^~d e
9 s
n. q, < e. ~ m.dm s
F d s. <;. g&
Ms n-w m.
s U As"
- &m y 4
u..riy m
n
- N, m y F in_ you are. aware', thelQ'e,viden,tiary)hea;..i ~.
y
- 1 4 W p Qqy&,n
.. 9.. ; C&y,r W ' %j v e m.-
ringlin,this pro lceeding-began Q ;g;x.....,
~
9w M cedures..J.The, hearing was?inMidland on June"21,ll.971,Uafte
~
in f ?'
earing pro x U(OF;d' Z.W
- b ~ and ' July 23,;and, 'duringithi[de_ssion
- en ' seventeen day e
Ul periodUektems'ive oral and documentary.1 evMence was' received.en several ' safety-related issues in th J
~
^N[
' ing.~
OnfJuly 23, when <tlie" hearing wasL recessed, certain matt left for future considera, tion. '
e proceed ~
y~
w / %.,.c i~;
\\
ers were
'r1
.,3
...m 41, gm 4
The. principal pen, ding; matters,in the Midland p ;..j s x,
' + f:P y'
. a. -
-,w
(
s 4
n s.,g. g, p -
the question ef _ emerge,ncyJcore cooling ~ effectiveness ' g appear. t s
.m.
m y.y
. roceedin
-arising under~ the National Environmental policy Act of and questions, Qp/jhg For the reasons stated M
a >oed 'to. completion withbeloa' litf71s n' ot~possible ~ati this MQF w
'c
. respect s
. W., m a,te these mat MW.
spect to. the issue ofisse. 9~., ters.rpncy
.a j
First, with re.
m
< ~.y <vm,g
_ m 3-w:
n s Aw,#.
e xeffectiveness, the ComeWss< ion,;on June zy
.y acceptance 1 criteria',forEemergency More.coc, ling systensi~1971 l
.ef the implementation.ofethese ~ criteria, Cansumers Power; c
T a' pplicant in the' Midland proceeding), Jand sitveral othetap Company (the for power reactor construction pemits,' have'been ~
1.j y;. n py p cants regulatory staff to subalt additional information asked, by the AEC; g,;f.
Upon completien 'of its : review, the ' staff wil-1 forJstaff review.
. additional t.estimony in the Midland proceedin;,. if sppropriate, offer, 7_. <.5J ;
effecti,aness of the emergency core g
MM f
. utilized inithe. Midland plant.L ' ~icoeling sys,on. the s e
.@A-G M. eQ, $ posed te'be 4 5 f h. g tem pro r'
n y
s
' (
y4 7
N.s x x x : w,~n e,, n:,, m+. i{g a,,s,.
C. Rw g A E M M :' v(
-( l
' s 'A E
w
e
C W[I c
'd
.. ~
x e
%c.
,n
~ ~. & y v;~~ "A'",N.'
., Q?
a ap~ ~n wam en,b 3h' b :.
y
C;*d,p m., n-A 3*;
e e
n~.gpw f,,Mh.n fM uc. a d a w.c; d.
8007140 N
,i s
.w
,,. m x. y : m-.,,,m. w. mvm &e.& ~~~.r.m.<
vv <
.....w,~.,.w;m.,
s, ~ y;
.,.p m - v.w y.
_4
. u c..... <. < r
.. w.n q.e
.. s y
u, i..,.
-.. r r.
.s,
,. w:+..~m..,
. x s.
%}QQ 3 g'y-l '*y
~..
Q - y,.v, -.
~f o
V.
- s.
n~,;,";s 5
y y n.m.,m :, i,m x y/~
,w
,,c.
m,.
,c
- r. ;...i g.
- x., +...y.. m..n 4
e 4
4,
.~..n.,..;w;.s : ( 1. (m.
+
g s,
r,,
_-,.,n.
. ?.
.4. p ? Y m',
- f.,f +.., ~..s g q
3.s ce i
~ ~Mrs. Mary Sinclai.r.
a' 2--
4.
2.v:* !
T h
J D
a.,.
f, ' '
e 6
- S t..f ~, &. e 7. t,,... '.
~.'s Z ni, n' 7,, C ' :. -C -
/
l p
u m...,,
m i..k.
f,
, +,, -
l t fy,,
t 1
s..<....
a,,,'n
, c
.1 +,
a f.
~..,,
s.
,~.
y:
p 4 :isecond',lvith. respect. teL'matteis arising under NEPA, en September.9,'. inf% J
. ' ^
Nd.1971., the Commission. published revised regulations implanentinONEPA,AQQW
. 'Aj E which ~take into!accoisat~.a" incest' decision cf?the Unitad: States Cou'tMFME
~
r N.hef'Appea16for:1biRDistrictief'Celumbia. Circuit inith~e"cise ofRCelvstMMR
~2 R
" l 'C1iffs' Ceerdiasting Commi{ tee eCal?v4 MC et ?ali,.Nos.124",439-an
$J 4
g
[
Z4,871. TJuly_ Z3,41571J.7Thers regulattees Q 'ipp p
'. land plant.'; 1aythis" proceeding,~.as fn >othe, apply.te tha proposed ~ Nr TeJ,:
applica'nt', a further;NEPA review ky.:the ECm,enal information by regulationsjre,dreithe"sidnissiin of additi
' ~ h.
~
1 4 gulatory staff,'andJaaly gg itd::t, rev4aw' hy rtleecpresiding AtomiciSafety.and Licensing Board.h@leJedt d "1 1
c.Mr Q.:d.@hfcouriss$9MQQWt@ing copies [ fTQM.@f7)%
'iMM ofcthis y g In accordance' wit ion practice C Eamiplac lettercand y6vr letter of 5eptember 2.in:the' AEC Public' Documant Room 8cy.4.e 4
.R; m -+wnw
' y
. m..,,.. r n wn ; n.n'. ' v r. --
_ 1.
..d : @g'g@e.,.h 2 N n.t :w u m,n 2,e S.imeerel.y,... g ". -
W.UC i st: 4WMWeE W.
. ; A 8.,,c ;
w,',..@rd.,m.,U 1,
~..
/e..
- % Q *J g [,{
- .*rw._ f k h h,%j'.' & *p.*k'.! a ; f',.f l $ )Yy f.khw*.,h.
,ly; &c..h. 1$ ?
- j. '.
- S.<
-s T "f
h.3
' h '-4/ M P * ~
g
.f h
.Qth,(,l'h
- m.,$. <,.
~
u m m g
z.
-a
, Y.*7"g.RyQ%p*y ( s.q;HMQ,. %, cg.QWC.'W 1%M.%..d;;1 4 sp >,9,s,hg; ndp %. - p Q.
Q;g,,m.r (, %-; s.s.c..,-~ _ h,. y 3, ~
(
4 s'.
v
%.'$,&xy. W&g Rt
,S;
,~
a W.2 J
M 9 gp.
QQ:y.% s.f s,....
v s
l
' ~ ',
- y f
hu M,Md:.M.y Mficef e.f;the' General: CounselyyMHa.gAz. '
K, %,3.m.n:m; W*,L t R
n,a m W $,m. A b w% @;d'?..&'w,r> A,.u/n.1v
..t sw r r.,.n.
,, v.n.
e.
3
- 3.. m. m, g. sw.m
.ynr 1x,y fMh, ~... w.r y w~',pa g,
e G. y. m ;m, n. m,e.a.x.W1.W,0 W~ &
u.m
.r s w,;, ~ t;t,.s,.
.mA y eu sn
..m a
-4W v
e; 4
.t y7 n..
scc Ityroe Cherry,c Esq.*$;y.:~{'g.ar :..+,. c*c. e:y#;,y L.._.).,: :.x.gvy.,q. - -
pn saa x,,V %e qLqy. n ~ y ;W4
, s#8 e,s y:
2
e w j '* 1 i,
, M.$.
Ai.
'467 x
s..
jk.5 4
,.m. g r*
'. p* >.'.M-y.
.. y,
. m.,,, _' l,. *-~ 4. _ g y 1 -
w 3,
p t
o y
a.
-,w.
u
~
m
..t_
ru.
M,,g. md. m. p /,m,,,.
s. p:
m y.
, 7 9 a';. ; b. m
',i ', A U A. r y#w r.
n}v...
l s
3 m
? m..t..iid i4 D n.
.. _ ~.
lw
' 4'.
. A k ' '. Y
' I* }.%
.o
' ' ' ~
"bec
' Docket 'Fi,T,est W M,-lr.;N[M C W.
L l*2 :-%h
\\
M O
~f
,r c
I u,.,c REG,Ce,nt..ral,p m&p p W g y. %u p ;+r$
i
~b MW l:
~
w
- emb%
w e
.%.N m Un e
1 a ~,y.p :;,
~ f<2,:y.- A.ww %;p.
t o
~ go -
_c, A OR.L. *p P..,; #.,.,%.9 e m/ m h m@w M
eV%. v + - " M.. % -:.'m. u, 4.; a.#. yN
.-w4 c m s.
e,m
.s a m,,dWW)h%gfMM Wh..%.fJW w..
0GC 'R.~ea. d.ing~ E.ile/.d.l. p&.$.e@%Q MQ
[ $ M.yv,g,w,n hR ;DWCW y;
s..x ; "...s., r d'r.W wy
~
7 p:. glspAyy w.3 w DEKartals.r ca. Gh e
mp%w w..r
%.w u.
o s.
c-
, ~,
Q -R W &ren. Ff.w e w-..w w;%
.. : e pm e
W+3' W:
k Y,
N
- n h.
g w.; rw
&p p n,~-wm ~-w n,?:f~ s. -
. ?h,n.r W e.,,%
~
e
....,& r&n,. y f. h,f.p t y..w m*r p,.P: n, Q y:gf..
a.
e bN-aff,
..,b f.
.ff ~ ~. Y
.k.q.*/
IfI.
lllLn* f'.f., a a.
x w
.+
.MQ M.QM..y"'f gg.,%Q~ +.o.y&,6.r %%wn'? p+ k '
N
%;.~e},;
G-
%w%.; %.F. ' <w - ar?jq, 4 tm.. %,
- &a.g:. o%. u.c e
w Q.
ifs ML..
I, 5 ic < i.4?TM' nW.,@. %, yWg O
7m lv.- %
b w
Q o.ln s,t. ;g A #p,..w e
p, s
O q,p m 6, rw %
%-4J.
- r
. 8 2, y e 4 m M.'r., j G ),> U R $. Q C 1,@lf* $p.s *,
d4.h,g t-rx -
f... #
W M Q d:hD M 4 '-W i
M M.,&' Q:&r.u n.- 31 1:l,f '
6
,,,. i 1Wf.Y w.
f,u.
~
' i. :, :. M'.k ;
gy a.m.f,@p,..,Q. s. ;W, n.n%.. e.
r < w &-:K.y sg;!y m~.,,m., ms
>~i.'y
.n,,n,;.,3::m..&. !
y n" :
h.
- <n.
sW rr
- m. m
.w v
sxa +
a A.3 ; @a.w u x.
..a v
m-y.g;m.w q,., @t
+
7,.-
'~
- . ' m 1
3 J4-s-e e s -
..,v,g. w?Mvg-e.
+
a
/ s,.n u.
np -
y v.<c'N. y *s= M,7 4#4
.x
,... e. > w :..y.c> ~ % g $,h y..t.. - + e y 6 N 4,e,., t. w ig-G'& J. t.yW-a I
4,,w a. ;p+ yg, wp:
s,u t c
.y
' L~7 =' -
- 9.J
.W.
.3,.
y.
,ag w
.t., w.y
< a c.
m w
-n.y %. -
- v;,
% p.. v;p..a. y q -tc..v._Wm y c.n, >.m.
v
- m. :.
a
, - #..m p., p,..,. 9,$a.. g i -
sa.
3 :,. w n us a
.a a' t '. -
e
..ys
- w. w. a[g 'e-q;'s-f C *,*p,m, y
.3, e-;-
.-y3
. ',..s t -
? 5.
e
, o g.g.
.g ?% d ' - {% p 't p Jg pQ. %[. g,,.s y@j ~.y! lj y
.r, i
(y 8,
?
L.,.
% - g' W'
- . =f s.
. ? ' w~ >,; g ? n o... n. O ; QL,b s.iw& ry &l,N.:-4 vn M.r.~b4 tn 4 D Q# G :+x g g w#-
A. E ~. %%"J W AM r*%w
~
.m.
b {&.
e,
4i
- t. 3. &.
q
.F i
.J u a mwdi s
- 1a
- +=
v7 r
&e J W
~
< w:
~
es
.m-m's r s
-s o
, p.C '. -. g - ikg 3 o.
- vg< z t :. n4y.,%.. x. %- :y,:~.s,w* iji.'
..-e 3
g.arg e.
s ss 1
p=
w v
- A A
},' )., g$. $ mm'
%,..i & 5k%
l Gy W
dM'd{yMT.[ Mh2M/ gy%dt WM. j&
~ Q. f ' QL - $ - y;. 7 z g
. g $ *.%f' L M,% W*
?
.s h _._avh,pp y __ ema k[p<NNsh
@g n &wam=in4m#m, myyy.mmym g y.
m
- wwmg. gay m
m.
m_
m
~
fe%BC4 e (Arv.J-53) ABCM 0240].(([,}
s?.hjEsa[akde/ red'.2onner
.Ma p'Q %% AT[)
,