ML19329F840
| ML19329F840 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 04/17/1980 |
| From: | Guilbert J NRC COMMISSION (OCM) |
| To: | Joseph Austin, Gibbon T, Sauter G NRC COMMISSION (OCM) |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19329F841 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-80-303, FRN-45FR36082, RULE-PR-50 NUDOCS 8007110242 | |
| Download: ML19329F840 (4) | |
Text
- rye J.,.~ 3-
.y.4...,
...., ; p
.. p.,f..
.,,.,<x.. g:~:.a.~.yc
. v. ;..... u.
- 4. -
.;r,f...*
. 6.:;.
' s.; J.. :., *
+.
- v a
s
.L;,
4,. o- ),,. Ws,%
, OM
-:- a t ~-.,;:
%o,r. :..* :. : ;. :.. s t;~s:: <.:..
.?.,".:!.+::.' ??'.
~~.
.p*.
? A '.7:. L. ::. :::~q.;.:, UNITED STATES B. :;
-W '. W.*5. ~.':'.*..*. W,
... I- 'F_E. ~:.: '5.
.v.
.C.C..a,re 4... g
.." :.'. f..t.....r. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION.'r:.M.....
_E.E. W,...
t < ',ie-k 2
e
.r gs :
. W ASHIN GTCN. D.C. s,,,c555.:,..
. e..
....... ~.. *.,.~. 1. ::~. :.. : : '
t......... : < ?. s.,.,. s :
?....s.
s e
.o
. :~ -*.
yG.%:-'*
. ~:
.. r. :........,..u., :..- y..
.*;:- - '....,~. ; :::...-..
~
%., ystiss,
...w.....-
- .r....
- s.. o
.;. ?..,.
- . s...
a~-
..s..i,.>.2...
.n.
..'...,~a. c. 3.-..
. ;.. : - :..L
~.
p
.~...a.
-c.~.:
...,..w...c...,
.= D.(..
. ~...
s
,u
, o w e,.. v;.= n,.
,,U.** n.o
' '... s.
s s,*.&:-
...2-
.m.....;;.s.. ':*,v.p:,4 : Q '~ d.... ;
.. :::.:.r.:. :.: ::. z:..c:r:. 'W.~r'.5.i='-
. W:: ;.k
., ; W.
- '. 4., <
p --
.. s;-
. ::.:.r.-e.?.n. e :...v.x. 4.,:. ; ;. t:,,
.-r. 7. ;,. - r f.:p.s :,. :;x...g..a.
- - -- npr.11. 37,' 1980 c
.s.c g
...;;m., :
~%
? *...';',* *..% -.
.~.'s..2.,'.?
z*
^:
.*",..s...-
. - - ~. ~. -
-. ):.e ;':.,%..,,...gr..D Q: f.:a'.;. %..
. CFFM:E O F T H E '....'.,* *..
-~.couys:noNER ~:: 5 ). *q.7.'.',,. $::..,-r ;1 ;; C...T c..Kp"_:.
.a
..s
- '. :-w r.r y... ~. -v..,:.3.s.c.':a.,y:.p.. ~,.gm..;.;..>p'g
.:.mg. n. :. 7,g g....
,9,, _.. y._
,.,_. ;; L., ;3.._:.q:..
..a
...e.,
r.
9
<-. r-
.,~.. - -
~ - "
w e-
,,..... ;, s
... 3;y.. c,.
.f;.,.... g.g.
.s.,.
... Note..f.or.:;. _. George.Sa. ter.".
u
.... John Austin.5 -:
.r.: c:.g
.. - h;.,'
. s.,
- .;;..f.V
.. F4/'
7..
.cv.
.t
. 7.a Herb.Fontecil1a-.
E.'.
.....~ ;.. ".. ' '.. '. ".. -. '
'.... ~v:...
. Tom Gibbon.# N.'.'
.c....
...sa...:.:...
,.s...
~ - '~ -.. F..r...om. ::...... John-. Bun.be. t.
... c.... :,= r. '; :.. =.. :._.
r
.. ~.,..
..:.. ; :.' ~ l..
Subject:
.,:. s ;..".-: e
. FIRE PROTECTION RULE ~.(SECY-80-88)
Y.
/
Mr. Kennedy concurs 'in -the changes proposed in George Sauter's memorandum of April 16 subject to revisions noted in the attachment.
Attachment:
As st.ated s. ;..
t cc:
S. Chil k, SECY-
~
W. Shields, 0GC
.~
t
.THIS DOCUMENT CONTAIN W POOR QUAUTY PAGES i
g g-t*..
~ 22
=
8 0 0 711 O p~
~
. 4 n.,.
.~.,t,<c.' s v,s;y.'.
e.-
a.-
.1
..,...s..,n.
1...
,.l...
.v-
- e....
r.-
s
?.* *
- :. '.j.t. -.,;,'-i ~. :".:.
..r.... :. %. :a:. '.!._h.$. W..:..:.~;
a
- :~L '.',.-
-..:7 h v.
u. s.~.: y.. e. =-..s.,.
.. 1. s.,.m.=.w.i
.=z::_ w:;:m... x
. n.:. :..:.. :.%...., g.... - 2 :
- u.., o
~*
.; q :.:
- n.:.
. : u..... : r-;.: 3:
rg.. :.y-..-.
r o
.. ~.
.:..,. ::.... :=..
".i
. g _0th'er fire crotnetion' criteria'th'at haVd'Eist :0s6d"by.the staff during f.;..-..
? Y;,=.M.m ;.'.p'l ant-s.
.-; -O.+w:i c.::y4.. :. - :p.-n7'm-p- - P...:w.
.7
-. t.-
' W.'.L oecifi.r-fire orotection trecram reviews are' co:ntained an:. ":
., '. d t s 'o.
^
e-w A ;: ~:
n:< :.m.:u.s..T. :::h.=w=. ?.v.r e
~
.w..
Acce5 dix A to' BTP 9'.5-12;.:.: n-.w. -7.
v:W.n :.."The combinat' ion' of the"cuidance c:mtaine
.. :n...
w.--:- :'. i- -. ~
- J.'-
.9
.,3....
..c.....
.,..w.
.....:... ;.:. v....
X....?Ac,... m. dix A -to' BTP.9. 5-1,... w
.:,w... ;..
- .,,~....
.a:
s.-..
and the;recuirements set forth i.n this croocsed.
c' cen rule define the essential elements for an acceptable fire protection Drooram at r'.: lear cower clants' docketed for Construction Permit
~. ^ :.='. ; y..
- w. :s..l :. n :.:=- m y;- +.
y.:?...:..:, _ w.u.c
~
T orior'to"Ouly 1,19767 for. demonstration of comoliance with General o
... jr... :* -*, iw 'M*:,Qh &. r.
E.~.
T...esien Criterion 3 of Accandix to 10 Ci R Part'.30.~ Similar accentable
.......... v. ?.
'.: '.. =' *r... _ oui d an c. m.-...:..,:e WoroVide.d'in~3TPt9- -UTor ~ nucle.ar tower clants dockete
....... =...
.., _.s :......,.
.. ~
...s..g....,.,
for Construction Pe'rmit after ~0',ly' 1,- 1976. "These-i'e..Eiatiens-state.
u
^hese-n, e-preteenea-r.egi4 resents-fer.aweisar-pswer-fae'ii4 ties-that-are -
r
.r.
- a. a. e._c $. d. e ar's. d=..a..n. S..t. _J_=
E a.t. * *. I. *. - '.' a c., L.3 5. F e. # 2 P. *..c.
f.*
.c.:. *. I. _* I. n,'- e * *> ^ *.' c' l. U ^..*. E. * *. * *' I. *. * *' I. a.i e.
'Asr-2-s"-Appen#k. A ^e-12-ETR-I9r--The.prepcsed-AppeanF.-Ts-spesidies-he'h S p. d s n-an d-s p es ?n e-re s,wi reme nts-e f-an-a s e'e pt ab l e-n r e-p re t e e t? es-pre g raa w
J.
.t.
3._
All modifi. cations.[(except for alternatefshutd6wn~ ' capability) would be recuired to be impleinented. by November 1, icBO,
-, '-- ::d cm. P.r:.,
.',..'-,2.,
-.-......te._.,_ : __
o,.,,, I.._.. u n_ _
_ t,.,
- e, s_
, t -
.t.
.,,.,,,,e
- e. _.
.t u u.
,- _ s t.e
-,. <,,,. w,.., t.,..
- f..,.-,_...s t
.t. ___._.._,......._t..,,,,..
..._u,:.,,
.t_,:_-
. w.,s s,
...:..,s
. _- _ a. _.,,.,.<__A.,-._
t.
...t-t,-.._a....-,.e_..,
' t i'.=
>l.c..~".
ADO 'NreeT.1
~
- ^
.a e
p.
y k
e e
~
- n..%
- ... f ;: w.r.a. g 4.:.o :-vp.sw h o-Q:n :4 f .' ' '
- Q.
' :.*'.?*:~, '.
.,.'.... - ).h.l'.h &._. w.k' "E'.E i &%. in% o.c :cu c.o gmM& hiEcd
.. k.:n.
.~ e -
.c.. q t,.
.,--:..-,~,=
r.,...
=
N. g.
).%...s;.'.P,.w._,.Q%._ s..,M. ~m:.:.?..l. M.,m.N.&.. _.-*: i -nW&.e. 5.y a s r lh k '
w htM. :. '..,...,,
c
-. y).M.
... g._, g......
. inserti.2
_ Enclosure..A. pa.ge ;5a S....: z.r, N.=.
. :.l,,;: $2'i.T!nL.* 8kWG.5.u. vim.:.i.%u:d.G.W3.:
,,,..,_.c.
s.M M :.: %."-
esst foggoo(ca' u
~
e Co=missign ap' rove an'e tensif:6 # @'. [l,;
.))
inv ived a e@* ell-e s own.
'Si
".he, sue searaijea(',.te'C f own rid h ye b und r.discu o.-
7.../.. fo
~
"an;icipa :es
,.ro v e,' if a wed.to u fo ipue o{ng Vf5.-
niss
'.. ~ ex ensia No lan uid be. 1 rata.
af r.
. t; 7:
~ ~ ' ^
Nodembe - 1, r
e ap roved by'th chission '
980 'o eyorld xte. ed d
'f.atibns (,an xcep for - + rn te r dedqcat sht.kown unless 11 m 2
C
/
caphbil ty) h a
een imp 1 mente.
e m.issi n recbanize tha Wa'
~
feW ins n
ap v
.ha. prey ces). bee ive t
diric,o,4 rticu ar lic '1 ee
.. .1980.,tenjVth
'to >x impi me, atio dah'sforsomethes 1,exh npn.
on a case-
-ca e.
atio s be., nd 'oveyer 1,.
g
/ he Co..iss'en
. l'
.. -bas' to d inegwhe p "..'.. '.*. e w ens io n y.et e propriat15er ontinued a yrova1\\or'some're isio of*cha
.N 3
. _.. d..-: : :....... -,- W m...nc. M. '. - :c.. <- 6.: h,,u M.::..:... i.... 5 *e_
w-
- v..M..,.
.- -.: :- a..,
For alternats'or dedicatedishutdown capabil.ity,fthe,. proposed rule specifies..
f
.w 1
~
4 O.dmplementatiorA.h'Which' depend-o6iwh'ich'liind of capability is -to be --.
?
7
' implemented and whether the plant is under.' review in the Systematic
' M Evaluation Program 1(SEP)*.-Mor-non-SEP-plants', the' proposed implementation
~
)
- p " ', S1 for. alternate shutdown capability and December 1,.
)
A m-2-
24 '- @ E 198f for 'ded'icated situM6sii'fajab11ity'.
~
~ 1.3c'ehiiees do have committ'e'd to 0
earlier. implementation dates will. be expected to meet those_ m i tments., ffA..k 4
For SEP plants, the' proposed implementation 4:.m'Tre December 1,1981 for alternate shutdown capability and October 1,1982 for dedicated
~hutdown capability ~.
Licensees Qill be requiied to submij clans and
~
s schedules to meet these implementati.on deadlines by W 1,1980 (non- ' gw.
.SEP p'lants') ind November 1,~1980 (SEP plants').
The Comr.ission may
- ~-
revise the implementation deadlines for SEP plants to earlier dates following r
l completion by the NRC staff of its review of the, status of fire protection at those plants.
The staff review is espected to be completed in i'.-
Ah0 gust,1980...46 ' ; Z f ~* I N N-i n '- - ; ' ~ M
.i
'~
a. '. E q..'?v
.s# n:':t.';brT i
w w.u.
cy
,;4. C C
'E'
.nh.b w w M. *..W m W "
W.. -.....
...c-g d cdA.
w k so.~ N iet<e. h. TM "c*? ""a
' ; 9 y
.7.- y g j.
gi & E r a A..+ a2 d ~ M A '^f. h
- M w*%
y%'"1.. *O V9 L Q.z,.%L:.ve).h~ f. ". y' w :.mu.-a A.u_. c.e.
e-r 4
D.
g"
, k k,M o e w+M b uu~
ba.M - (^.
QQx.s -y qv9 mW{-<. n L uf&va>.ma. Gu W a g.u y v,. N.-cP ;A..u a-L-
- > L,*".^* *-
w.;
o.y p.JteJ. !o.'t,r.9 :,.a J M -u.^~gMP
-3 1
- Plants unoer review in tTie SEP include Palisades, Dresden 1 *and 2,
^
0yster. Creek, Hillstone 1, Ginna, Haddem Neck, San Onofre 1. La Cro;;se.
Big Rock Point, and Yank,ee Rowe.
~
e r
e
-,---,-------.-,---,,n.-.
s
~-
- 14. w.,&
. :.. *... L.. ~,i
- y,. y 'a~%;- +1W. *. w r. -
- :s.:4;.'.~-
6 * '- ' :;.
t..
~
3*
N, '.,..
. g.
.?:.... :-:.:w,;;xa...., q,;;.y ;
- . u '.c y.;-? r..
- .- m 'q.- %'
T.
.a. J.
r-
- -,...- ~....:..,
~
..hI..
}1*
. s ;..y
-.y::. ::. :.- -
.....;C. - -
.~
". ~ -
.~ t I ns e.....,... :-:..
- n...'.' - %::.:.~;. %:rt 3 ;. Enclosure. A,;.p:sge.13a.... ~T.T.
,.....a
.. <. n. w
-.x
, ~ -- ;.
.q -....
. J.
'. - l;.,
"'"i
....6. ;
4.2.e
. i y 4 D~N %~d *?[.i;%.9 h/Y "
,/ /.y.
.. -..e'. i' ; 2.- S.
+.0.'...'..
. (c)"The implementation'of.;thef requirements contained in' Appendii R to.
p;-
ithis part'(exciipt for;' alternate or dedicated. shutdown capability.).
i.
.2. '.
.... ;v :. t
...,,. tshall. be completed by November'l.1980 #c :, f:r ;n.d s. W s..
t
-,_, g =
h n o r.
. 2 M.
For alternate'or
-~
dedicated shutdown cap ~ ability, the following implementation schedule will apply.
.c.
.=
.. u......
(i) ' Plants' not included.ih the Systematic ~ Evaluation Procram (SEP):*
~
W '." ' ' Licensees implementino alternate ~ shutdcwn capability shall
... comp tete. implementation by"M 'lJ1981. 'Licen1 es who'have t ' ,previously. cemitted to"harlier'.~ implementation' dates.will' be
~ _'
e e.
g... u..
e k ected to'ineet..'the earlier dates.
Licensees im lementin
~
... ~.
f,'.'. ;. ~~ '
p...... December 1 1981 h Licensees shall-submit,;by'A M lf.lS80, dedicated shutd P
WK
_u
. v.6.. plan's and's.-
che'dulesWor~ meeting' these implementation deadlines..
-. v.u.
..-..:. ;:.. y m...
,,..,w.s. n y
.au
~
(i.i)' PGnts'includsd 'in't'he'SEP': *Liheh's'ees imp 1ementinglli.ernate -"-
='
t i
.,..,. e.0 +. ;. :. ' shutdown capability shall ccEplet'e implemertation by December 1 19Sh ~ licensees--impihmenting dedicated'shotdown shall complete implementation by October 1,1982.
Li'cr.nsees shall submit, by November 1,1980, plans and schedules for meeting these imple-
' mentation deadlines 4'."......~...'..-.....,".'...-,'..".'.'.....'".,.--.'.'.
1 J 4 3'. t.wa ccf a s ci A2..
w' r. r a -.... -
......~ ~. e.. w. 6 r.
w-
.Ar-
+
6V
..3 c
u,y we n.v
., g. A., EE,. E JAe
- s.,., !... E.
7 71 A 1- -
..n
.4 a.--
_-?._
y.. _.. A 1_
i C-~
we...
....w..
w w r.
?
" pm A y
- L..
T*
.....E 2.
,A.E
%aJ 4
L,.,.
9,4 J -- *
.t.
n
==: :
.r+
..g..
--r--ea
*. m.n,
= _ _..
=!' y,.
- v
=~
,3
=
,
L
.,y
. +..w
.,..s e.
... v
.. r..
+
9-.
C.th '.;w 4bMw b4, '
g
.... z. a t q %[. W M &
P L y &c :.K %_ ',M
- i.. ~
c
% > \\f.rkf i
& 4.w k Q v A M
\\
. yA %% 0w L_"_, %
Plants under review' in 'the SEP include Palisades, Dresden 1 and 2, Oyster. Creek, Millstone 1, Ginna, Haddem Neck, San Onofre l', La Crosse,
. Big Rock Point, and Yankee Rowe.
.