ML19329F626

Responds to Saginaw Intervenors 710810 Motion for Subpoenas to NSSS Vendors Competing W/B&W.Recommends Denial Due to Irrelevancy

ML19329F626
Person / Time
Site:	Midland
Issue date:	08/20/1971
From:	Kartalia D US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC)
To:	Goodman D, Hall D, Murphy A Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
References
NUDOCS 8007030418
Download: ML19329F626 (6)

Text

.

f;9 M U 1;.hy vyd,$l p g' W.[ '..

Y_..~ Y ' h E f

[-

a l

L}[

L d' g y %

y4.

W g.;

., [,7 5

4 -

2

., k.dks

"'t 'Y.h,%. ),

..Y w.m.

8, w.

'$f%fsp/!

C/skMMNk@..ni%$c%jftv7.d*T""99~%^'

N

,t i > %[Q6N4 L ';

ydy 3fW'E :*f'S' :' '

August 20, 1971

, e-a.

• $.: {.

'k,.k,

Q b WKi

.r r;A mp d

, # $ y'g),O es4 M fed $ ary

[

,9

,Q H

d t p, W M t o p +

l,54

^

!G

1. Eug clark seedman

+

M3%c"arp]g~...ssendig g y ens, % g g p M fesser K Phirsics'. Q,,

.. y Qgg 9

.htsenftr sheet.e rW stimrsit;r of Noustoa ijgsiggr4es"Wiit11% 54re'sh(Wr4%W 3801 Callen Basleverd I

1*

O v.W@t;:f-Y>.ddy y n$mesp%get@q,qggj%g;h,h.4m{Ay$$ES.

3.gg, pnq(Met 7agp/$ 4 c usten Texas ~. 71004 #y -

hM 5mit.

Ne j:a.

pzy m

u. :.

x-Wy.WN t

Tas Alaams SSfentific Laboretory P. 8. Rex 1643 THIS DOCUMENT CONTAINS l** h *

• N'*IC8 N POOR QUAUTY PAGES R,.,.Q A gmqy.g em. x n,

..NYhk fMk'$sgdimedlP%enti;;.uwtts T & 2thejhttdehtlonsumers Powe

?wh m

,$yEg $ H 3eshet W M -329 4 50-330

[

.h he

?:

l s#

..-- mfg $$W%%G$1r:

Q,

Y1. ?$kkhYh?

h$$.h0??W' A #? 5N"

?

1 h 1is 'ttue'.Segimes%M...:.# 1e'eter of August 10, N

,10Ft.ita~tuftbatraen of the Aemmec.5afety and Licenstag Bears (Board).

.s s m? f f f f i h ( Q f 0 h f Q q W ?p' V :n. m y geggewaten for m6peammi s j

pgr)hY.

9 lk 4 1

/C

. +

' AM

. paisme%mgesnesses< Twmede peritta av s

- rr

-e 3 eres es

,es, are,,,,14 4 54 I M MfA f

~.n.,DM,i@i864.$160sMg N h

$bMS p.. w

g. n

.gaw 5

Ji..

)

5, 1

e c

wF 7

9

(

{

,V,

.J Q - [%

d

'g

\\/

ha$w[ s 3339ed x.$ 9,yh A -Yh+& $g4$

r p~.

?.g e %

p.

5 w%nk $c-Q !,vpi T

+

,. n,., ;

se g

.;z

*S,pe ?%G ' k Q, $~. =.r

,~

, _ k.y Y'

h

-w

.- - f$f N b k k I h.f-'e d k 2 k *'

f.ih+

'M:wp s57

.r.c.cao.'.'C

' *' ' M.+-MMMYs

.t.rs # 4..?

..+a a.gggg≫ yawawgs-,w g p y y g g+

u ao 0 7 o s.o y f y

~ lqs~aM"6dQ

(

a MBC5

-m--.amt

?

4; w

~s

%g

~ I N08 trtet;

. CJ j > #vM..,

.y*.

C. ]gM.{.D s.MQ, MMMhtes%es't4 antimeVhoudttes."Inc.Lv. W.Wm agd I

j W M' M'f 6,

!R' Columbia 1 Circuit'in talvert C'iffs%

T CASC Res7 M,sar and114.sn, July;n.1w

-, we no longer 6.s eye that'any useful pervase'would be served by the suberissionthat the re A E.

i

.of interim proposed findings.' 'It is our posit onshould be closed, subject to d

13,1971, ste.the entest assessary and appropriate pursuant to the further J,through July thelesert's decision.;

M,C30esertasie,ePmAssaking anedsted by %QQ~4;s%

QGT

.Q

%k&a w.a.Q, q.x,m,4..dh,a Gi iy.ing*QQ@;-wem%bh gb lw Board and'the parties %y.

<f e

~^fy9 &m$ h '

"' tpagyyspen M *t'eFe(Me-Court.'s desistenTeQ:r(4hJ @

g.~ f. m wa M p#M'<

.. c f

..m.

5/gffg/ '

C + W ;

sshe' deteruses4e?effleJU W M4 m % @ @!n d qu, %n6 M9 h

/M W %p/W

../wiM%q7;tts;gy:steiMesVteidQ @@Mf"m:e"If@#19efetyfgM@

j?

ftoysddfYd. W N3 3

W'd2:!!K M(t% gsas $ndt hakeni.te detek~11eest?s?

) and possible @A W@d eta pM;j% @Wla jed.

QP A4$ a)leW14e

~

W

'J M e miastion'and eeLapp it. ' ' ~

- 9:

~

" M P modifications er, supplements therete;:q q 5 - + ;.. ;

, (m p%:

i i

_ _ __the scope of future' proceedings;

,'(b)

~

.*%:n m x.<, 9 m.w, :1. " Retice?ef hetring; and

[

hlt n

e t; # *,k M QW6MiGGRgf%%Q.%;&;Q&%wd..

h 0<. ' %,Mi$y$pg(georgenersF burden e(potag' forsrd"in i

dtstr

.:tp%Weniapp11 east"assertadly has';nst,mede a4g*WWw -

~

G mWMw.

phtmaw m @e.-.3@Qg.gg M M

~

y.g m n u n.. m w y w :

&e%w;;M % '

_ 3 : p. j et~ $

EWWQ$x.9...

w w n* p.y%A menwg&

nm*yc

%M95M,;M., p@},p%.s&@%w$!NR8. MMg QSfy y we xm

- - 5; ( y,fti%, i rgw.cMW-

~u-d.e w

.~

te1. Court.Sta the Calvert Cliff 6.. decision, ~ordereduts c

,,,m..

e y@a AsEastat'atesa? _,

...m.

4 WW AAspear-By3toAesnie~

yu Mas,ionkr-ifendingMj$p -ne pressedless.to a ameter weepestV j%?pher;tef Mf m

yh d~eMk

.MU

,.... ~(,, e,a,,me : e,..

,,,,,,g,j %r n;+

wissma g.

~ pCvery' kely'oeunter-d.. n.f.y n.

wy

~

m,.

a y m QN%

e

/.

7 y

8e y"

W tt y

'BM4.,

v j'

4<

y g @Ap*[a p.

ih[

V. C; i$l} '

b3 o,..-

es.

7'3.sMy, ten

• s % A,s e :g

. gyp

'.' Yf ) y -

M ' ??/

s s

an; TNN) f ysyC3%

m M ) y$71[ h'~ J M leIed M 0ensi k O

~ *s'

~

fs".Mfi

[i 9 9 ;i T Nths7

~

"il ih/#

^ '

eimatkas'sjest affected by w n m:x 7

gg. [tM c

• dl.zy%wyyhf.Q y;gq, a g;gjy Qq;, gg. 3_5 r.a qwwww%') ' y

' " [ n*'A gy. m ~

'I yy[:,q,w

+."E %i g g y n

• t-3l gap,?

s gi

' Aqjf

't :

i ji" %*rVWp w

xKWG N

MV

? g4,gU. y d5,W N:s c. :

u.

t

...w s

u h%;

w' A rt, em YI

~

Q

~

N

n e

.t

.4 1

^ %+.

Q.

-_.h.i % 4f $ Q w M y g ;. f.s i

(ECCS)'N,Y...f,.JM pg$

, ~n#,,

li decision.. TNs ' flor ensupla, at susk ffEasr suffitient materia

?

t avail'able for presente%1on se the emergeng sors emeling sys f 'l

.^^

1. ~

In our view, matters issue to warrant a fur for this Board to schedule such a hearing. considered in the in be treated in the

. jf Commission'sJaplementation of that decision shoulder te the Court's. d

Thus, l

.hiamaiiy is< eattara,esig@dered 9 ' (,, degelopmentV M[ record on matters, j. m <. p.

^ da respasingisOthe. record te V;g EqA 1%

j u s* se n s W g % f e m m {4 s B 4 M

etsbilerstheLeessideration of. environ-ffp%gl sp f

b Gi s e C issf;ttus

peau %t[ ' the?8smet'ssf Ws; guid N jc[7ge. esitest'2einoaapery'finiC M! M Tff5 @i:fd d E # s n WDe# st b a.,[g< muttiiR"ma J.

hi@(i@)

7AMb byelusta its piesftlks% matter ofI;j ?p. Ng 6 I

Miy

'47 ' Sagtnowi issunnes of ( eenstmetion peruf t for the Midland facilitiesF s

.benef1% ane19stal y ' 'G P ' '

19e staff still favors issuance of a pemit, the (b) that, ifstaff semit a proposed list of safety matters requiring re-decision which, Levaluation underX.PA in light of the Court s

'WWwith eesenet theimminW the other parties, would form the tters; having eevironmental e

m Ql@ Pef arboard' rel.18e%8iG9elsefety mam cor.ser e st.ff,ro,ese 4WVi@!p.

~ M.gwise way hich, with

.~ %,ilhas:sibiertenvfiiiiisubdila jesterfts be esasidered w easiepss 'mer4W?seher' parties, wseKfarm the W.31: for.

J sci %g$

R i44Y J of,Jenvirepsen,taf_issuais' to be 3._

x w %g g.h tseithB1 fag W 9l?y?UW;#W~ W RN&w w w

.engas

.e

,g g

yMr 3jw$%y02@Wdif9:

P M

gggg M.ah h above,, us M 11 eve ma4,

watref ammesy >

M M I

,,gg -

7 jfff,MO

! g $ g,l,i%

7 w %we m!$ W5eims.1!nfitineleak~ M M A

g, M

w'" (sned

m' a i i[*

%s aginff7 NE

' malfairs"sh@d,

yt.

i i

}

y

+.

I 3a P */

w p-5 L,

=

. :}-

~~ ~

j$$Mh;f j~

t G,(

?W 4

f

' $W.M1Q

• Y, jy I

W Wg

( 4W" ilabel eillthre@RYM$$dih@p@

NANM%s.tsted J

I,m 33 M.hh

- - ~

. e -~

s

.n 4

g MEN!NdWW#i$b C

6 d

-M MC#6 2

gQ

.2

c l

1 n

v'.vy.mf?kk3x 4

~ J no +

1. ,...Q.7.,q The extre:nely brosd scope of many of the document requests makes it

)

likely that, whatever the scope of this proceeding may turn out to be in the linkt. cf further Csemission. guidance, some of the requests will 6.vo.hahabjestsewMe on.

~

^ 't good eame and relevancy and may form

.e

'tsetikorM.?Nemover L it would'.be'...,ff$e.m.g t i, t A. Q.r'Selbastsiferi" ~ ~[

.y

- g g en u g w a,, g.

4Ag 7,;ww>

ggg p, g,.

q

~

gg, gg. 3 m %,,, y,,,, yserec3m. g e w,siet.

aei l

c3

' ly$ph pogre'e~2ths" tete? ~"R~ e filapassesMobitendi iteInihteh elianenterifarrangements /h

$4 f

4ssesstW16rsisTTf;uhethep there. areIY l

l e

d i,ygyg, ia'al

. ' ; decuinent resisess"is 'a '* good faith"- gy,g;g,p;;t hc 7

inteifveners.' aharacterf

,W attempt to begis discenary,5,but.we must nota eur distress at such

.M; patently frivolous requestit as the examples quoted below:

p.n "II.. All documents dealing wf th chemical explosions at Dow's g Mdland eeuplex,and e.laamhers., whether at a Dew facility or

. K, e j$p6Mtheasee;gazof2eenOasdemp16sien, the alprester of the n4h 'wf1his GiefpsurtjMjytarsggInts 'estegory fairly calls dp,4g;e.49 '

U

$p Net c

,s l

. w@

ib d Ts

+ a ? MQ$dgiginisteis, leis *Miifles@y=hirCaiylestWattavalved, g ;;:qgfg%

& &m g;g g: s*=s m g ma w

egya, erg,ig er se

.p w g,g g g, ppg g g, g g,qrp: y,g g g;r~g.g m hye wer aes.w tranda. e.e-s s

-4 r.

n.

,n

-3 mw

% 7":.;.pww+ vu mpV,. :f,e p@ith er Ahowing es reliability,

. ~,

• Ob 7; m ' b, 1.

."] f ;:-

-L t

+

J PdMfdecumentsideslirt w

!, c,. su. i W.theseui?ef'lestehemesOmiullterced outagefof!'esch nwr. learJWj d's#%,a; 3 1

&w w-y* Jl/%.

Y 'uk : 4.i W

en g#

h MW*:

ow

.t

• "db4

..pur e w<te m

l

,,m Gy)

'-ll.p:WM, y

. 'Y -

Y' f'

S v -

h

&.3 k

J g

15 Nd W

l h.

iWi l

9S$\\$&

~

^

M.g.if

'hineirede4aiset liestWeapa. \\l' %ve beren3 sus' ensfG1h 8:'

L m;w[M@ i e

te~ 'entagery ?sf{4m==i== tis '(tes.Lfkirly (:allk fo( the eencen-g-m:.g j

9 cedsamke, vents:iewes;had.upon u

see.

a y

a y

p g

4 w.

g g

gg

)

a, m

g r

4 bi i

m,- I t. _ _

a,

.6,,

o.

< hYe $4h.- @

~ @tki N

A..

n

s

.o %.S s..

n.

L, 9:

r- #6. iSaginaw intervenors^eppese' any reconvened adden'Jary sessions ~ ~ '[ 7. k)$

until all matters noted above have been resolved, and suggest that no prehearing conference be held until " substantial work requif by this letter has been accomplished."

ta e;4 e *W g & ' & k yj ' M ffh,

n.c' a. 4,

v;,.4 p - w w

. M vt!g$.j,i-4f,h f

dM

.,C

.. j.,. to!Mit,

,.tions frelatfggj) f9f.s j.c.W yayg%:..,f.,hy f Q,.g Q'

} Q Q u'nel( asfeensitorstated af th,e ether p J*

e.

3 reports as

) ;qd:;&

g

• ~'2~7A2Ni z

4 e.

jgl'.

Stitt 'Ceament R,v ?r

This setter has beceme aset

as a result of the Board's certification

~ +' 9 rief1questices 'te:g 2

Sie Atomfe 5a and Licensing Appeal Board dated

1. 1h.

j

.s g

' ~ %u %qh.. h[%

Angust 3 C 197T.

EMk@l{%MZQQ%a$p. =:

lAg{i,j?gg:

/

]%

g

%h edi' h kh

[Pfli g en V.a d l W " ;W A.

1. 2&

?

b f

b+

.a

'~

L8 M 7he.

sawletervenerg " move th4 Board fur an 'erder providing

' " W @Y #

iffler the Jesunnee:~ef sehgesses to three U. 5. light water nuclear V

N,h.. k.p b stees.

~

Wuesdessists;eespete vitit the app 11eogt's $:e '

kedE

.. ~,

~'1

.M-!

-tion %re; $ tio(== W M.-

hi Q e tL A she-

4

,h,g

~ " vener.. sM. EB.W,Wa. nother.

f

' tair! WWudMg' buti ~~

~0

d i

w 1

'V2-

~

3 3

A? n

!h' 9M W.,oemfmstiter'y.

" it Mya'epti '

M e.riteria ingd tihet,Jaecordingly. W4&iv r

, A. A e ; =3 4 wt11 set gipoidunneApurpose of,1 trine into whethe(if-J1 slee M "hast. avail'aElis!

• v

%@>&a..

dira m m W g a

^.

~E, ~ Wa;s W " " :noord,Vdatedc W is.. " 1(Cart.t

.d -

s.~

1;T

.J 5

w y. qagw. y ;Mw3. ms L%

tg.

"q r

=

J

1 l

f.'

~

d_

h

[

%'ry.~.jh';.

y.; j ' '.3 s ; +., ~. _

q y -

c

~

z

~c.y

..w d....,.. s..

m........

N I

fl,,

%lk'

~

.. :dy., n.,?T f

hresvar.,y.g. pas &Wel,,.4t; yg:.f,, W&

%/

~

e the@emisf 5efstabandlisensing Appeal Board, in its Memoran-y.

dum and Order dated August 16, 1971, in the Point Beach 2* pmceeding, stated

^ ?[I)n'a~yflven. [ reactor licensing] case, the only question

<M

%dered,is whether ~the proposed reactor satisfies O M k" dteTheV 41.sen%viuselwlthNes'pect:ta ~othen reactors at a M rementsA If so, the fact. that flNhM q 2

' imer 3' -. ~'

• Q &'M $$-if? %fk N k@%f 'i f5lk,YN's R&gy:f2 ' '.

siel Vb

..,3u;

$4

.;.,! % f \\.<; N 2 % + y M V,.

g.

4_,1htion for Subpoenas should beyy C n'i : " ",:::. A

.asfamp-

--y. '

g u-3;

,my A

' 4).gA.9, y; g y; 9,y >

,.- ww,.

a e.

2 w

1g% "y e

n Q,v g &.

, g e )2p1' ~ RUpectfully submitted.

. y, ;. a

e. i.,,.w.

-~

+Y it24 " 4g(f* # *f.

^*

.k

~'

1'%._ ) '

k

,.a

';.N f N 7 d 2.pijdfg 7 David E. Kartalia

.x. sr.L

.g up$

yp*S4sf

't Counsel for Rf.

g' g@h@ABC Regulatory Staff 2 4

4

.m f,

g l

• w @W@$N Af*,,..

i is W-q

} es_yg 1....*E.:P-. 4 rW l: igj y' % Qf61.Q 4 p?g Q., ?? f v ~' p~;.QG pg*g.g'y

" ~ ~ ~ ' ' '

y' y^

• ^

es w/o ensl:~tAnthony. L Reisman,'Esq,

m

%v.y%" '+ Y.;gf ' itsbert Lauenstein. Esq.

M

+ ;. n4

'QW R:

9mt

.ga 4.

'.h, +.

" g,fgQ:q. ; ?~ wa(ma^{ %. m:::W~.n:. '.

N

..G ;,..

n.e n p, n., ypp 1

r.

},. s

? %4 g,

-.s w

Qh h, eg gg%'Lp1ga&"g g y,

?

u w

f 4:

-h u

i-

?

q ce

,b e

'f 1

~

3

),:

Dr ;*

y m

s y.

~

g@nbm..h:.,mScp2 #.2a;p-erirtstons.

tPow,. &r ?@ $

%[J e

any and Y. ' '

(N(.N sconsin $'$' D.

> in

. Amif t

~'

.e 7

h m-m ceumser in sesen.. net) ear. pant.. unit q, Docket S

@sye ' a nJgq[i[ g' kh g

Y $sk@d5j j@@%Uppp+3 y.

dwna n._

s m7m agg 7 3Mg@

wr@gy (M t( W. Q 4 ] p p ( f.j [ $j Q f

~

$@gM

.f

~

p m # g s w e g g x n w [g g g g w a y q g n 3. m. ; q t p w,_ m p s u g a g g

-