ML19329F614
| ML19329F614 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Midland |
| Issue date: | 09/24/1971 |
| From: | Kartalia D US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC) |
| To: | Goodman C, Hall D, Murphy A Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8007030396 | |
| Download: ML19329F614 (4) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:_- =- e.- .&-.d,_Q
- ng. *W-fS f Yf f
j' Y
g-M q 4TNls"dOCdENT CONThfNMN.'W 60' '," k %.n &
>G.
,):.
m:
v &.. WWp
. ( I O@:f v y.
e i 4. %
r4,
he s, -
- w.. hW0;k 4 g h*$
f ~3 ,p i yy ? w w s n h 8 N a N O s @d ri n$8ea W Dk kW 'I qum. tro. ts 1.dcru F '.3W,6pt.gMt#
- hh k;m.hfkkfhkk{ffhhk k _h AQtgpap[fh hi e vGm*ds:iiry=w=taswe..tta me1,***
eg==nM anan m
- ervu ors A
A m gregnest. rand: seasJdstatie= # sertata'ap a. cts-etthaivest' dias 4ppMPE t . w. deseec;se M g Et .searcs. sitedele er Further PressedimesxM 3 eerve.orsmo. ee..re s.caraw). eemments'on' _thsflapleton ,~,LOrdeFjlistadiis.eWK 2 .,c. Ptert"f /"0 F =Jf n b r b.a.i s. t e.cres,e. (+to49_prisfpel;sejectsisevered ~hy theiletter.&4tssX... gW s sp%%4Mi We ~ Mggegrfn;d Q QQups4Q@q#a& M C.MM. i awc}m rmKa1Mman&e.d.stsj.wf4e.> with res,.ct wb e QMi n 6 w em whmsonw Q%fw a.m twab. cst w .r.ie tayt masemetw.)erfurther eru otess s: 3 y @w %w %em : secs. 4: wh d f113e!msefvedlinicoptMdeievs the.sesreMrophasTiTi'me j [P 4 %g, heat" )Mitsc.ngpleten totaveners% jec t heeard; eh ~~ q ~ heigiif ag t <mei i, xi.gAstate:present meir evidenechtheTwom %ipm Xh i 4 pM(m ..ete t!L ~]ainiQelf(Th.9T97@8)2TAsSefuinderstand;theM_ . a.u.-t ,e,
- a..e _
m Mw61 s c isea. h(te in %'thatief rd W ul. ins at pu s p'the? intervenes. are'harred from reiterettss
- ($. V%_:
2 T QT&ts. arbeneat-imi)sesf187 'to.saha(t.a"brief en thefusistiony,jpdM @i Mimvelved.M. 2)J,3R.e,'se. chi.. y mssib_ee,njr,eviaod by the. 4 WWQns.th_M g,rgap4%.x &,wn..s sw[!M.:m.m.v%pM: m,p h Fat .o .<- is sggg s m m.
- a -
- . 4 s,
m o-2Msk t w.w m uR-m ms Q Mt. g. W TM yo g - 4 u 4a y, gd p M W mm ~wn/ctd.46 A t. A A j % w. u 4 7 p. ome. e y ? { ,J' ...m m .m hkk$k Y $- _.YYh hlW.nm.@n.mmmMMA%%M M W Y$bN. -.s bhhh $hN %%wd MMM J w - x. w. n w - ~ ~ m
f7RWW"j'WW.Wgg;c @- Napn,,RRTQV792K@aMMQ M Q [m 2,g w no m.m.wh ghi~.f'g $ f e m n%#&g@4i'j aM m : M -Qi; p jg@th ' ',,7 : ' jC [ y l5'eAg[ MkXM %s$ 33 g, 7
- J*
$.e. V ,a j e t g' + 4 w ?, %:tJ ^ $'4 Mmg.. p~,~g.m@Q d;; Myg. Q zs ms y o p.n. ~, ng.m, + &.,.,. e. c,,c y y.%e y.3;p;gw: M . p,
- .4 9
+ .x~w. m ~ e e 3, ;g- -:.,- m a. e r naa. <? n. , v y#., ,n.. y Z f. A, 4 . ~ ',_a, p. s,q .g ?,, c G, 'A g;lp.,g. e , n fy'j? y L G Ab.btf. ' %', a g - .c.,~py jpy? 99W 1 .{ ^ um S: Qw Q&& .i4 (<,. ? " ' _Q ~i A. .7, ,3 ly -. <, k ? '. c . ),;i -{ j' ant?^.. % :* Q u . gg ef a.showinpef' prejudice.ithere is ne' ressen w.olous. LIn th ~... 3}' (, ' ' qgy g,s.In_anycase,. the latervenors'.argunent is friv h %gk 4 o ,J%, hy;me Boar p[ *%%y.iiiiv.i.re..isr,1.t.dur..tes_ tim 5. irlfhMies', efier. s M.abD.Mi_ h... - teni nauthorizedlin. t.,isii W ais.ep ~ ica W suc a.proce al rum ugfis;u.i mnsfactbexpressly. 4 m ~~ m seat , m R auM.45(h) Jef ithe.fcommission's'?Rul'as of Practice"M W W2J i edi J
- J45 LSJM55k'intisMM' nerses Adwfaistrative"PreseMure"Ast,9dk%
E % thestprovidi n(o)jeitatie(aMauthe,riti, mis sim d d:Th& twterve 'idus proces's*eimteidien,T er WhidiMM A f ^ M 5ee Y v NC U3tl iU48W414 '.(1944) M5ee al se Tenda /Adad niaa.d g e ,1Qirrst we = h 'Theatise 514 SQ988 s$ $D ' i ' NUM, T$bSBN $y$nMY)y&* /94y+N&sMRWMg&f ' N O !&E $IQ3De inteFvuiners failureite*f1Te certain w'r C& j%Ek f 0 i tx3 -thdarrtho%fs p? ef 7Augesti261 the p p ky c % y y a c y m s m q w g M N p % YA;
- R
' order Mapleton'~ intervenors wemito haveW 5 jftled, en es befse Septeder 15D1971, thef r written feWdenes on UMMW # A testantions 'III and IV.effthe16*eff , 3Ginterveners.eence hasibase$ffleM a[er of pmeffdated, July' 8[197,1 . IMs s,meh'evi their letterjef Septieder 14, beQdh e lattsmyt;%$ 'l n ii lyEte?fusttfLeh'is7 default len WeTground'nat theWNMdM Qs $7@GSeptembet15' 1,t, ' nte'40lGAPastE50 h ?.W4vtolatiian :sf;Jt: aoyMachbefisig$Y&k. shoct[T %M M es u eas nab 4B w)Q,Wf%%;W'#the 4f11jngN@ete$MM@%(hfl%$@$$g$W% W 19 y Qd&by L , reasonable 9 "Ji/,h : Vi Isleur, view, i-ofsSeptember 15fisitentipel) $4l 7 OgunderineMijenessLthacendefMs eaeR MieTNapletondateFv Wbeeis/p' rtjes,tidi,diti@3ta$kvensl< Cent iti m ressuffag(forfmora eisi'nine?siendsWThTpiM%e e %$ d; 5
- erisinal ;petitieaKte eentainedVapenT'aMalT ~t!innsYerHiosiinh gradiologicallnaiefd similaffte s
a anslIII Morisever%wiMMP$ %thet;they,1971, theiseerd specifica1Ty:advis'ed the J%1913. ?weeld beingi1 red {te"fl.1e wEttten'evidesce win respe i L h Qthese' contentions.(Trd3210) Wheve'experiesiced;neWffisug(NIf the intervsno .gdtligentiin;the investigatio f and_ preparation of ~their cases. they wouldy'F i'ntmoetingithei$ Septemberils filins,4W f k.e ee m pt b., y t o te I E w.,me M4a(e sesy*moom. eswei ApmdpusWAelcKrart:seradeed,--s nem e sn i nansistent oh- [On utiousyppensiEofipest$ sam.1 yiiict(th 15e g ly e m queraseect A appusettenwe1atedtethecestssisesp] NyKf),1. eses mgw;efstheiag : rihetyagentsfunde(, AsadW EnergQc WpeniM nglsubeit sa.iisW 3
- appiteentwenvin report.and meArcsregulaterrstaff's ww
%bMMdetaiTediesi'rsusionfalfi" _ [Jegsalfbazard(raised MC &. 396tleeJissuinsTpetbatik11 JQhis preiisionislearifTapplin thWDhk p M 6uuYg M M @Q@?N & hC&w y@g g&M Q LQ.8 %ws&giesti %Q&er w%WQgi WWE W W &k 8k Y d f j!L i pq ee v sew q gygg gg n suwex'intervenerstserved vinteeir.mwwwm wmaww % A@Mgrittshort W hMM+Re-W<1etterrah affidavit'a~ n np&px 3Themapleton " h C = h "or.c w" ". y"M by u.a W 3 m
r'
-===-r=- --*===-C e- [ s' y An e ? W E hk h ht 7 k n%TA#4m_hmmwnMMM. M.MwM&% m. ..g g m n ac:e s in. w se M acutoeee p " W M M.--_ M W W W W @ N.W W A W W M M-4 m..
m - m.._ m m wr w e w w; w m.<
- P,eW W W PC p MT...y Q.7, B7 m
zm< n QW m '6 $m. mem. . AlQS ;% ' SP ww o ? j & j:m : &m p s-W mm :.~ y qf n y ,y, -~ ..%, u,. . -me;e ww .s s ., v. ut y y6 4 M:s s. w 3;M P ' 2 ., " w ,, a, r. ~ c.g,. .~ 2 ,% m., a : g,mw.hrre o ~ e - -u y g;.; - L.h,. y v m
- = s j gm.q-..q.y w
~qy ~ ~ + 3. m .a ~ m,%v y mn%3d;- %,n va, d DM.. .u @M.,.[n.gM %f. 1 - ( o [$u ' 1
- 4
,#$m 1 '1 n s 4 7 , p{
- s a relates, in our judgment, to an environmental issue. We assume, MyFMM Mtherefbres that the Eckert affidavit is not an item of evidence to; flp p%
,4. y E IW#which itk s taff aus t mspond Tunder_ section 'I.A.3? of.the= Boar ~ [
- m[f k
-mmwg.,w;Agditional witnesses "f%. h orM cl: W pQ W$ s a ['.*M.n-Q 'y;W+;' u ;@*n&,h.d,gq.y[o,&,4 4. i ~M c n c ,y(:Meiare; opposed to the.11ntervonorstatte . q4 4~ 's n u
- y W.3y%.p.gs Q.,. 4. Q,.,( '3 w-(?"'% nt'
. -
- X, W.
gy W :.9., .,+ p'g 3 - 9' E. P pjg Ip up meWW .Af i 4 t Y ' AlisLtoAclude;four_ additional. witnesses :on radiological, matters.;g;g dp ; a MFo'r the, reasons statedfabeVeJwe :belteve that thefintervenors fy j 'b@Mi:foffeilted any right to prosestl e'vi jf M Qtsh gre the interveiersTon1Yindi~ological coni!ast'icis".2Morenve$R f m]the proposed testimony.ofitmo, of 7ths witnesses (Whitelow and Lyon).fg$, yg ; . %c as. described in the intervenors' s to go beyond the. m % scope of Contentions'IIIfandiIF.i. letter,. appear.In?any event, these fo ~ .gM K - V should have been identiffe'd'in?the July ~ 8 " offer of proof" 5Mi/JW $$n. W p l /. k W R W M Q W W M & b M W & W k % Q $ % Q % $ @ $h 1%mp .pAddidions"to"the 'risiord'stter Sebtainer'3071971 yp% ?MR@2WNW)W%: orderief:Aug% 25U MfMMKynWiM5@M Mbx R% i ag 4The;noards ust 26hce.ntemplate_s = no; additions: tolthe.r%id j - ? v w fatter.se E M4Misi@ptember W1971f on issues 'etherJthan ECCS.anienvironmentalcWFFA ~ s d W 4tnaf ".[t]hn31stinctionibstween environnintal a'nd3on-environmenta ~ ' g i Tis'suesf>is;"not.31eerfandlmeydia subject to' diffe, ring f4$$ uup xm m e.n p% ,ym gg'%g~ g.gn > 2 2In.leur. view',:jQ:pyq'w n.m - g;;g, :p : n g m+ yy q q3,\\ pp ~ .a q;sQM Q.., \\ the~ Beard s ; ruling was proper.. Asnoted. above,'the Board Mgy.g:r laspects of the applicatienjelated t5 fthe Cowedssion's e ~ g L ~ @dfd h
- reiguirements under the' Atomic Energy Act pendtag" submission ~ of the'.'
? applicant's enviremmentilrspoitland 'the staff's detailed "statenienL]M%W4? e ..... v %;Thisf directive provides,411Rourludgment ? ample.~authoriti Tfor;theMddME9 9 ~ f,@TM.gtheigenseJenXissuesTotherithar ECC3]ndJenviron.monta g mMshouldl. net;be permittedjtc gek[more ~ %I. oficomp1.eting WW J m M @d A % %en~vi_ro.nmental,r.e. port ~ an.
- p. M Wadditi6(al' time,rvonorsd?t.h. e stafff.sMetail_adis.t_atem C
%. M issues,mthe.;1nte rshou~ld be givenLan appropriate amounige in whiih a to ?prepa,re thei r /cas eWn 's 0cM, i s sbes'.M@ e n WMGM?&@bM@MF. f W$ KR c~.~ W yM.BWW9%MSMMMPwsM&:s@@gMg;;bg W WW Oty\\ j f f Q+ yJ6. f L ~ % % g s+ g h.q: q W .pw ww~g 4 n gy ua q k y Qg:j, Q.M@Q h p;QQgfggy3QYn%jf !;g u dlThe.JMaple'. ton in.terve,nor&.mm'QlQ"also tb.the mgmmm mw iQ J c+a s ob
- !cefyNegust 26iwhich requ.jec,t. ires them to file, s"withinR15. days afte c
n a s e w De 46 'n 4 m$ Mefithe applicant's'next filingfen ECCS"? a detailed statement ef theWM@ e eip't A ME 7 ' Kaf3$riatureJof the affirmatWe:ICCSTavidenen which thef intend:to'effer~1n F - s SM$this$ proceeding.M&m@sw@$m%$.@%
- Mn5M9%ww$h@MU y
F
- FSSW8, m:maM&www w me m%
m.aw sw war n memp samm m"& %mpaQWWW MPOW gym s&e%m apn QQfLM DMW MWk W M4C M,MM M MN D s9FMM M @ M @ MiddE GIMNdMfMM M 6 % c4.uemp p ws+ -- m%yaommsm*mmmhe
3 - ptwggy@ggrMygg"[;qqyyyygggyqfV g m.w aw% g,% e aW wye % m; evm w M NW & G .h 'm
- .y%qn4 :a % n %:ih M %. Q
- %q.g.m,PyA %x,.m g.; y 7 ye
>? Q ; WAgW +, .t v w.. ;%m ys: Os AQ.9b.w.% ~ ~y ~ .t
- n
. t.~ .ww , ' 4 _ o,q Mg?a y.;4, e : q 'f.x %. ,9ppgy v v. 's[ c u m w ,M, M > ;q -)- k> rf.h i ' .,[ ((. . Mc. a % g, ( ,,v. 4 .- s. r g
- 5. ; y, p, v w.
- .s ww g~ +,,
n .c e. .n r
- y-a~
on ECCS matters until the applica We believe that this ruling was also proper. The intervenors cannot reasonably defer all preparation py4 , has;eade itsfnext filing. ;Much information on this subject is availM%gMp ' < fabli.3 'e.th's interveeorsioW(and should be $nderireview by th t 6 s. I Me ;see no rea5ciWhylth'e? interveners should. not be71n'a posttien ~tdM . W*.M i,. $,fi.le a substantiaidstateneint'at the time'specifiedlin the~ Board's $WMh4 g.g.?ffytKgsh4 rdgrG y @ ; g g g g M L y M y ; p p p p Qc 7 9._,m&w.g.pg.gog. 7 mpc;a. 4gg..p.;Q.y.' m .cWovCw uh te wca:4 c g A N W M,,; u. 4 g p & g s A j. #g.3:n ye,;
- v e
57( 47@r. Discovery on enviroguental issues ng A@3MWyc n ;.@The' Board's orderlof..-Augek;t:20di. rect @s all t pa .gsygg s pw;gggggm.%g gN s Ygjyg i m . E ~ $forddisaieverfWeniifenmental ' issues by; Septa directs Ithe intervenersjto. file ;by Lthe same date ;af preliminarylpdd istatement. of th.eir. <'viaus-en anvironnental quostions.g he i.nterveners W > h, T c abject to these,: ruling.. > J s on the ground that they.. linconsistent' with. A.,,A 1, are ^ " Appendix' D 'te 103CFRIPartlnl0. mWOp6 MyhWQi@a ws m&m$ : MM 5 yl'T Mv)y & e m, w
- i f - W~ W. m u n.. y am?2 :x v.m.u
..%+., Pending ;submi~ssionlof3the ap i l..uding ~alken.viion%iN:& %;'?gggY $@%@WRT ~ $.< t n V. Q mental, discovery.,d;.$ , r;P.id.e.. Mo ' n. ot. f re.ed Appe,6d'.ix1 D 'as. .c eport a.. . GF .~ M,? V: &..g m..#.@#pgstaff!.s,Jd, eta 11edis. ta..te_me.ntkMu, cant.'s 4) c u. c.h,environmenta1Jd.i y.g g>.gg;,",g,itlengthe 1 ntervenors surely ca_sco.very-nt, W.MMi y~. as . lace n..ow.m.In. ~dd 1 mm 4 q-p 'e at% W ren'vihin Th~ n w y@d W ...- n n.im. ental 'tssuesMi'a"this, pro 5e.e. d'ing.5, e Md gp at.~erve. ners,,tef tco.urse,vaar:b.es in theirjeesta a -~- qd ~ a .. n W W e a u 2 abang. pon the basis cofine. ~. %t %~me_nt. :.Jhis. ast's_Ta. tnv.,ir.onm. e.n. 'tal ?(op e f. .Wir the applic ~ ason for pastpon 's iled - s. tate 7 A, W n y q m,.Ais ne re.
- y
.bewever g wha %:. ;gg;,,, v' W-4 )HQ4rd,W 9 h%g,7 %p_gg; p.3%- 3 .v u h 9M.... x _.p. w ~~ s w#; l:m, a r my su1 A puyg~ggg 51ncerely y. m w"y' cf W i " Bfk { k : W.l G.R ours, p~p
- f. n y -
- g,M Y,Alg'g
.z es -p 1 v.3 a w y M y: . n;n. nggi .,, x.m,,, a ep.t w. ,m~w.
- ,.w
- y. ;,. g
~. m m . n. i...-- /., yv- .. g a we m um ~n~ .me m u. x.. m.u. ~ ,.%.we m e a. n.a;- w.e~aa. e: O h,% 3fAfr$n&.,. $. v*%m e. N'.~ W O T W j~r V,$, w m ~ e u fffJ'#Wl ' ;.7,m$.;; %ga WkW .m, fan:%..... & m~%,f,:d &. w, j 1 f5 A.. >Y e .WW..a. gy 95 f. 3 .&eS?'; %. M: 4. C. .L y r A O M.-i l %yY. a 1 MDN@gh.Wf!WM@g@WM Bevid.EEK . Q* ~ WWl@:.W w.tMM"M ve M R FdhMJM,mm:@MCounsel. foC 7:@W g@ t M.u.d. gbweW: d W A C Re w sp gulatoryj $taff,$y- =~ N_j WCf8 n %e 5p.M Imev wn w< e. KA.-Q,?c s n. 9 As % p - ~. M y wmn =c w.s - w%wr~ CWW
- wl &
!W m7 s = n 4Lww % Va e 2 - C' M.. M.a.h.ard,inivMsleiiiM.E..sM. W:W d.% qf u s 2 e L+.f% WM MW ? - Robertjl MM o m c Harol~d;P.- treveshisq.4BAM_c-6. ~.,Suri thn Es. q ~~- > e,n.b,e El les-e. m.n n mrw .- ~.3 OGc awe eew*NNc g p @g z;REGlCentral Jilesenm w&wwwmMMM m i WN^ %-8 s $ N1111am:J.2 81asteQEsq.Q/ $lyNng1ChstrWEsiqhhiM@M.APublidDo'cument Room W MQ[8WM r. ~ .y). ^ Y DRL M Q i. 7 Mjhy M M,d J J ymltonin.: Wessel'ifsqMMSmW DEKaftal'in]M ' s MJemas W = C % K nyOn py ~ 4MAIMe1AnWells' 1EsqWM.T*iAf; James % N.70'ConnorJ Es~q.Q J M W W P W. 7 L i M M d $ p@ N AMMIrving lik,e"';Esh"pWW' - "I@M' s W YJ ~;M N f! k N 'C *M Wed WW2 % ^ A t m er 4 4 i WJ % -na...m.evs s oy V. -a z-y. -w s eses, w ,m s m - % GC? ; Wm% lD$B.. 3W> -O MEwMW h( 1:'h f: h br0$.l PWW W . 4 - 2 w y W gg$ui. ',w.f~ g:nWygi%W:= A M Mrk Devsd Cemqi4M(Q 46$@i.WMM aN %> W&p@ Ws ai A LM .Kaitilihinka.h. igg ardti Mw x .,-o..- .,n. m n. -ww ~ wg- ~ n., ,n . nm,p Y. I k/*/ / -l l m_ a,c.m m m..neuav.g nwn & s w:n_, m-- w.m-gw m o w MW ,n ~~ ~ . - ~ - -.. -}}