ML19329F477

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Responds to ASLB 711222 Order Inviting Comments Re Ultimate High Level Waste Environ Effects.Does Not Object to Proposed Ruling.Suggests Des Be Changed to Environ Rept
ML19329F477
Person / Time
Site: Midland
Issue date: 01/14/1972
From: Kartalia D
US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC)
To: Goodman C, Hall D, Murphy A
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
References
NUDOCS 8006300675
Download: ML19329F477 (2)
v • d • e


Text

%

.s g,

JAN 14 d7h

- af ".

~

THIS DOCUMENT CONTAINS POOR QUALITY PAGES Arthur W. Murphy, Esq., Chairman Dr. Clark Goodman Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Professor of Physics Columbia University School of Law University of Houston Box 38 ef

,?

. ~3801 Cullen Boulevard

.435 West il6th.$treet

"^

. Houston, Texas 77004

,~

,^

New York, New York 10027

... ~

4 Dr. David 8. Hall'

f - Z I / - '

~

' l-

~

Los. Alamos Scientific Laboratory Los Alamos, New Mexico 87544 In the Matter of Consumers Power Company Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2 Docket Nos. 50-3294nd 50-330 Gentlemen:

This is in response to an order dated December 22, 1971 by the '

presiding Atomic Safety and '.icensing Board (Board) inviting comments

.on the following proposed ruling:

~

,,,.t,.

y zg,,

,w

.+

7

..;~

"[T]he environmental effect of-ultimate high-level waste storage are not an issue in this proceeding; neither the applicant in its draft environmental statement, nor the

' staff 12 its detailed statement is. required to consider 2

4 the effects. of high-level wastes after they leave the repmcassing plant, nor will any party be permitted to 1

, fatroduce evidence with respect thereto, or inquire into

', - l such effects by wa lof; interrogatory.or otherwise. Pursuant!.

E.

J;.

to Section 2.730(

'of<the Rules of, Practicey,the fuling ofw f9'.

w ',',:g,d. V W the Board,is dul 7

p f referred to the Appeals Board for further M W' y

G$

& ;c

%W WnqW

  1. #?,&Q

. ym.hpr.oceed1agn."r MD$w&q:,q, z:.4...# mua. pW.3p> %,ab e

b;. w..A r. M * % x, %+n m w$ w.m

.a.

,m t w:n w

.a, we

, g

4 Q.y JMbts.is,totfafism the:

Boarf.that' we have ao Isbjection :tehhe'sestamem.W;,p.

e V vfiG-of this:preposed'rulingh Me would:suggestiboweverathat the terur.geQug y f g* 37 y edreft'envem emental statement" fa the second clause be ch F

h4 9 M '.*eavironnestal @ w".5 4 %a facerely.- rQ-D J e

,.7.

m,

..m,.,..

g%; wyw",;r7S m.y.~

a e

y m ;

w.

g

~. c

\\

v

~

\\

,~

.s t 8'0.0,6 3 0 0 ";/3." p=1 -., s David. E. Xartalia -

e.

~

1-Counsel for AEC Regulatory Staff ; " l~ '

N epage z

. CC:

.0GG r w OGC f _

ne' M N: ' H. '

i ! ^4

. '.s. c omer >

DJJ:,% %;.;;a.8:9M: #-#

14afrMTFEng.v ' 'elhardt Wlb;,9p/0

..t p ;% W W e y ";g

' * % :..q.;:3 %$ '.

'. ~. -

l r'f.f,'~

- ?* / y. *% r

~ l.R:..

. -i

,.y W

_ senmar >

7 yfyy;;.f;,jg ~ :N;

/ &.1

,Ij'*f-j$[ Q.', O Y 3

?2q

~

-~

Perun ABC41sthw.9 53).AECM ONeg

-J %st 4 s eowemmasur enweea orecauwe-ear tse ;

7 ".

[*

. 7%. ig,gg4J alm ch g.M.,(,I-?M,eg 4 ?,;y'g t.v t-a v^ k '.'-:

E M _'b,a#,

, h." m v 2d C 'a.'iG MTIL rn j

y J

' W % m.

f.- M yT.f @w em s ybp W. p m /w.e%, %,w %m W w W. M '% w 2.M W W ?2 m w/p9r; e.esn m n x n y:b,.~ypw#g. p,,.mg...u.

arm. m, a

.d

e. 9-Whevegap@p.pwww+Fgtg o

r

t. a,

u Aw hw.

w a

ww

.p

y...

er w

y 4. m..,. :.w,.,w n. p w

,.. n

...w~

o.. h.,.n,r- -

+

wyx.,.,. y~..

g

.x,;w e yq;z.

x. -

,.w-y.o s

m

.. 3f 3; p' p.

. =. y.<

v,,

s.: - m,m,n w..

a

.: g:.a t., e. y

  • V 0 ~ ' '
  • = '

^l. rJ p%.,. g.~ 's %,, a

..- y 3:>

f-n '~,.

.~

.,v ?,. ' L s., y -

4.4 w

,-r?.

s ;

  • H. = -p~. < s r,, a y,. h..g *=* -.2.

m,

~

j.

+

~~ + v n.s u,. r :.

.m

,'A

' ' g% ^ % -

~ \\

~

r ~- '

.).

g

.g.

, t.1

=

.(=

, *+ s4 i

y y

_ a.<

,,,.p.

s,,,. y, g,

- s..

-, ~.,

t y,

cc: Irving Like Esq...

Robert Lowenstein, Esq.

Richard G. Smith, Esq.

Harold P. Graves, Esq.

Anthony Z. Roisman, Esq.

William J. Ginster, Esq.

.Myron M. Cherry, Esq.

Milton R. Wessel, Esq.

James A. Kendall,.Esq.

' James N. O'Connor, Esq..

c Algie A. Wells, Esq.-

'Nathaniel H. Goodrich, Esq..

. Mr.. Stanley.T.. Robinson,Jr.

E n

,m r-l c

,.a

,s 4

.* L eF

,g.'

g j

4.

~

=

=

^

I

,N 2

I g

,,h#

e p

'.J..,'

=-

,?

3 V*

>s

.. ~ -l i.. '. :..,. *. ' =.

2 :, n. -

4.'

e

'[

r, a.

y v'

  • _

A e' w, ps. e

-,+ 9

.n s

o

.o g

+

4 j f.* R.

fR ' r # i?,% }..??i %. g.2)- w, e' a. w_.'y '

  • f

?. $

Y Y

Q, h. '.*

k%.. ' x m.$ (**.s

. ? Q, %

w-w;N S f'm]'f

- ' * ?.

  • N ' : f ' a-3.~n, e._

e.,, s. ~ c f.n.$ m. c..

s.r

  • n.j s, y ( *_s '

A

.s

^q g

n-,,, QR ~

. m, t y w ?+%

w

?

,s e 9 p.y t

,. e ;..

A'.,Q R.-f{e.. -

's s; w,,, # ; ??. u;#.,*;flRJ.y.-

, w'e,4 ; ffQ

~.

.b %

  • w,.y.,: n w=a Q M

.m ; - y g 3

~ ;v., ',a. y e. e;;l,. ,9..',"

w

+<

'?*'.

~., -%

s 3

oa

-M.. %,,,-y n sn..34 ; o.f ym..o<

.ml. w w.a.s. u <%p;,v'

.,n.

v.ya s.s. n v..

m x s

w<

n.

,T %

e,

, r~.

A q 4.. m. w e %w% q gn &.

M.n.

t&w &.r,.g '.1. <yp6:.An V % ~? *f {*< f.A g.%'e. 4 l;:,.,,. v.t;L*:M % %:-c.;

N",c:..

g'

u.a.:;y'. C ',. gc r W,. w,(), ?.

np e

. ;'s 4

.p.

i W

v -

.:q %.h

- "d

. w 10 y u $

..W ' ^.wk,.: ; m, e g~y u.

w s

t m-

>~ - r n.g s-

.#A;m;p Mww M. n.,;*wyte...

, p &% [n.'.&;,r u ww.

c

?s -y' <

% W. %,a M

A

- s W*. %n.w~ ;.-yw.. u.g_H.+f.. v 9:M.X.v,:.' +.,,~q.?

., ~

, y rs

.a

. ~

: A*.4 :,..

.?.~.

~

n n.

. v.g w.g= n,,,e.n.q %.. &,.,r<;s*g~ n~ m%...em - y.e. ~v. e,..w wp n'A'..v.',-

u - 4 ;x-*!

--m-u%. ~.&ru, u f

,@s=

5 s\\ % w. n - p,1

, n.

> <- m r

v a

y.

n

. m. %,>..!.,. n. w., t.

< L u.,,

m, * ].-

p{,-'

.e

,,e.....

~

.' s,~. '

  • n.

.,.. n a

a n.

yan..~.c%.

.m

.Je'.

f; ;'.'. :.4-e f" la *' w ',,

,t

..e

,,/ ;_.,y

- 1

.e y/.

o s

,., ~ ~..-.

7-

, ; n.

,,=

./

b a

9 e

~

.i,-

  • p..

_[

..".A s

u P

g l

f.

s

,3 Y

.~

y qQ

. 4.., 5# ' (--T 4,w,

Q f.,Q, mp, M',

i f'{-M

.j

]y-

^

,3,%,-

e '.

Ni. ' ",. 9..

, y.,%, f,,.

)

.- 7 gjm

..-r.~<

m-

> >. ;j.,' y f *.

s'

.l

_ A. }, r.,J 'a n c->

r

.-~ ~ v m-

.~ '

m.-

,w

, ~<a

'C.y

?? *:.x+ -

, -,". ?.,.- e s, ~,

3. t it.

s..

~

a z

.- : <. ~; -

$,,3',s*fp*'v l' -(8l%$,7K,.

. f. ; 4 --p.

,'4. N'f so y p' M >

E ' J. ;-. c.f ' * % "; p\\ e N.Q

^.

'C L *.' :

f' ? 's ' '" 1. ;f

<~ - r

~ $ *W,>1-

.'_,, =.

.. y

. j; ? ~

^. ~

1

,t.

r.y

- n. !, ? ^

. s.f b 0.3,

  • W

~.;&,

c. -J '

n T;-M' ; c '

i g,.y ;e t

  • W;.2..; f
  • K.% 4 %,.lw. 4..Q

.d' A J,.. ~

N.

  • s f.C,.

-?U

' -, O d'W g

hN e

h

. $ $,, GC, _

MW 1,HYM h f){ &l' (W[h ;&

'$. :",'g *,Q?' 'h*f. '. fQ)'S

% ^2.. n. k.~. ' ; s X.s ; 4 2,:

  • * % : '.. i }

N' WJ nycy it en$.%1 a;# ft'Qf' '

'g, a. t$ d^

sh.*

[

-Q -

3

.

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML19329F477&oldid=4752241"