ML19329E900
| ML19329E900 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Midland |
| Issue date: | 06/14/1971 |
| From: | Murphy A Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19329E893 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8006180744 | |
| Download: ML19329E900 (10) | |
Text
.
g 9r m.s
, DOCKET twt.:i:EH O C C 5. - ;-
Q CD
'E00. &1811., FAC. BD-3g,gy,
-E JUN 151971
~
1.ETITED 3"'ATES OF NSRICA g, e. :.:c:n
'##*E[..
ATC:IIC E;r.2.GY CO:0 C OION iM-q;y#v'7]TL g
In the l'.atter of Dochet Nos. 50-329 50-330 C03SU:*3RS IG.TR CC:!PMiY
}
(Ilidland Plant),
)
PROlSCTIVE CRDER For good co.use appearing, it is hereby crdered that all documents or copics thercor furnished by applicant to counsel for intervenors which both counsel for app]icant and counsel for intervenors egcc cre to be coverned by this order, shall be Smi
'~A to counsel for the intervonors subject to the following
- tems, Unicss c.nd until otheruise ordered by the Board, l.
Counsel for intervenors vill not disclose, or permit to pc dicciosed any such document, its content, or any portion thereof, c:ccept to persons assisting him in preparing for or the trying of this proceeding or any continuation thereof.
2.
Infornatica obtained from any such document vill be treated as confidential by counsel for inter-tenors and any persons
'assicting him in prqar'ing for or the trying of thia proceeding, and shell be used solely in c'onnection with his preparation for or trying of this proccc-Jing or any continuation thercof.
z,4yIhii &
'" 8006I80 7 g
- ~
s..e 2-3.
Neither counsci for intervonors nor any persons assi: ting him vill r.che any copics of any such docu=ents.
1 At the conclusion of this proceeding and al2. appeals 1
therefron, counsel for intervenors vill return all such documente to applicant er its counsel.
5 Counsel for intervonors shall not r.c.ke th' esc documents available to any persons assisting hin in preparing for ~this proceeding or the tricJ. or any continuation thereof unless they first undertake
-in uriting to be bound by the provisions of this order.
For the Atemic Safety and Licensing Board 2.
/
mf5{k[
4,
- 'Y.:'s.., h.*
f Arthur U. Murphy, Chairman Het York, Ucu York June 11, Iyc /1 4
O e
1 a
)
. *,. =
l
., ~..
11PS'fHICTED i*
PUR3UA:lT TO ORDER OF ATOMIC SAFETY A!!D LICENSIlio DOAR'D
~
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA ATOMIO EliERGY COMMISSICI In the flatter of
)
00!!SU;.':hS PO'.fER C0:0.*/JiY
)
DOCKET HO3. 50-329 l'id1.nnri Plcnn, Unitu 1 and 2
)
50-330 LIST OF ARTICIPATED a.975 DOW OASE0US/ LIQUID
~
EFF1.Ur.;lTS TO EXTEil!!AL Ei! VIRO:lFENT s
Thin list of liquid and' caseous offluenta anticipated to bo dir. charged by Do.t at its M'idland Plant location into the atmo-or 1eceivin. utieains, rivers rtmi tributmdon in the,ycar nphemet 1975, in furn'ahed to the Sat;inau Intervonora for the limited purpoco cpeciflod its the Hearing Board'n June 21, 1971, Order (Tr. 1500- 2, 1511-10, 1601-5,. 2fl33-5 ).
Tho. list is nt'.bject to o d may'bo used only in accordtnce with, the rostrictive provi. lona of the Hoaring Board'c Juno ll;,
19'[1, Prot.oc"civo Order, unisso cnd until othorniac ordorod by the Board (Tr. 212I!-5).
Th.tt Order provides nn folloua t
t 1.
Councol for i'itorvono.yc uill not dinclona, or pornit to bo disclocod nuy uuch document, its content,
.or nny portion tharcor, c xcept to pornono accinting.him in prepn'.'ing for er thb trying of this proccoding or any cont.inuation therebf..
2.
Infor::..: tion cuta.1 nod from any ra'ch document ulll be t.Nntad na confincntial by counac1 for intorycnora and
- atj un, sin.in prepte:fing for or tho trying t.ny --parnonn ( 0: 6 1
8 Exh'ibit B
--~ - -
7
~,
of this proceeding, and shall be' used solely in connection with his preparation for or trying of this prococding or any continuation thereof.
3
!!cither counsel for intervenors nor any persons assinti:g hiu will mal:e any copics of any such documents.
4.
At the conclusion of this procccding and all cppe:als therefrom, counsel for intervonors uill return all nuch documents to applicant or its connucl.
5.
Counsel for interven,rn chall not make these document u available to any p: roons assisting him in pro-paring for this proceeding o' the trial or any continuation thercor unless they first undertaho in uriting to be bound by the provinions of this order.
s
\\\\
It la and hau been Don's contention from the inception of this aron of inquiry by the SaginaW Intervonors, that there is
~
no evidence of any cynergism with respcot to biological systems exposed to any chmnical compound in cor.bination Uith cr.pocure tu radiouctivity ar. the applicable icyclu given in Code o'f Federal Ecgulationa, Titic 10, Part 20 Saginmt has not adducced.any nuch evidence, denpite itn claim to the contrary.
Dou understands that the licaring Donrd's requent that it furnich a list of its anticipated 1975 cffluent$ in not b' aced upon any determination
~
l that nuch synergica may its fact occur, but solely to pernit Sacinan to conduct roccarch to determine if it can produce i
evidence of_ poccible cyncrgicm with rcepcet to the specific identified Doi. cfflucubs.
i i
The list includen al {cffluentodiuchargedinsuchamanner on to permit the conceptual ponn'ibility of phycical juxtaposition to radioactivity.
It doen 'not include solid unnte disponal by land-fill nor dcop uoll diapocal, an to ncither of which in there ray anticipried extelrnt1 c:nvironmantal concentration.
I i
o
-a-i Nt reficcts max.iraum anticiprited concentrations, based upon the asnumptions that the proposed !!idland Duc1 car Plant will bo operational so that Eou may discontinuc~ oporation of its fo:: nil i
fuol fired boilcrc, aild that projects undcriray, or authorised or c1carly needed to ract anticipated local requirements, will be conpacted in accor lance with schedules.
l s
This list is based upon Dtv's current information as of June 29, 1971.
Effludnts from any chemical plant necessarily change an products anc methode change.
Dow of cource is hopeful and believes that impl oyed technology will permit it to reduco the specified relcanes' in order to minimizo environmental impact The list furnishe ; relativo concentrations as initially directed.
Liquid offl tent concentrations, are given as relcased, and are: of course, cuhject to further dilution by the stream.
Atuonphm'ic concentratiomq at the nuclear cite are estimated using; ext: cmc atraosphoric conditj onc, Pasquill Typo F utability, I
a specific uind directJ;on touard the oito and 1 metor/socend vindspeed and these concentrations would exist only au long as tlicsc extNmc conditions prevail.
The monthly mean concontra-tions would be orders of magnitudo lower.
Houcvor, as pointed out at the Hearing, dounwind concentrations arc cxceedingly difficult to calculate bocause nources are distributed over 1,200 acrou of production operations and because discharges arc not necessaril;, at a continuous rato.
In addition, instrument ana1To' for measureuent of individual cospounds other than at the vent, are for the most part impractical beenuse of theirlcxtremely lou concentrations.
Accordingly, the lint roficcts averages and estiir.t en, not projections, uith a substantial probability of orror on tho ~ conuervativo nido.
Should evidence bo introduced by Saginau cufficient to catisfy tho Ucaring Docrd that nynorgic:-
t
~
2.
nicht, renult with respect to any of the effluents listed and tho levels of radioactivity which may* be releaned by the Midland
!!uclear Plant, then detailed specificationn as to qualititics, concentrations, unter flou and matcorolot;y and other appropriate l
conditions would be needejl in order to mal:c more precise calcula-tions for that specific offluent.
Morcocycr, of course, at that point the J! caring Board's inquiry nhould be focused on the naturo of the total offluent concentration at the relevant point - not Don's alonc.
Dou believo ' that the reason its effluents alone have been demanded by Sag:.na t, is only beco.uco Do'.I is an Intorvonor, I
i which is not a proper concideration for croating nn icauo, s.
.\\,. '
~
.g
- u s.
s, Is s
q.
- t
,~
1 5
..t.
O
,g g
S g
g s
~
..w.
~~
~ ~
s SD 19'/5 DOW LIQUID EFFLUEllTS ANTJCIPA")O HMCMIVIIIG STRSA!!S
. Effltten t Concentration
._ reg / liter InorganJ c Ca? ts Chlor.'( n (an Chlorido ion) 1133 Dro:nidu a (ac Bremido lon) 1.1 Sulfate (an Sulfat.o ion) 192 Dicarbo::::tc ' (as B tearbonato ion) 321
~
Sodiuu (as Sodan:a lon) 792 Calciurc (as Onleium lon) 113 Stront5ru (as Strontium ion) 2.0 Iron (to Ferric ion) 1.0 Aluninti.. (total r2.ctal, all focas) 1.0 Doron (r.c Borete ion, D 03) 0.9 2
- Hichel (total ant ul, all forms) 0.02 Copper (total rectal, all forma) 0.02 Zine (total metal, all form::)
0.2 Other hcavy matala
. Sunpended Solida 35-O.rge.nic compc,:,cnts CC Organic f.cich (such as acetic, glycolic) 1.4 Aljphau.c Ethers (such as polyglycol other, 4.0 methy ?:al)
Phenol 0.04 Aldchyder. - 1;ctonen (such methyl othyl kotone, 4.3 acetaldchyde)
Estern (:<uch an methyl acotate, octyl phthalato) 5.5 i
Polymer (cuch an methyl celluloso, polyncrylanido)
4.3 Aronatin
(nuch as styreno, ethyl benzeno) 1.2 All:y1 Ih.).iden (unch an methylene chlorido) 4.3 i
Aryl Halidca (z,uch as monochlorobenzene) 4.3 fi ~
Other her.vy mohn10 aro in trace quantitien and not abovo the background of the river unt,cr'used ec: nervice water.
DU Ho further current brenkdown in available, although uith rospect 10 thin category, roncarch ctudica havo.bcon conducter. to dotormine components.
N...
% ~ ~.
t s
e n-
(N MiTICIPATED 1975 pou aAcF.oUS EFFLUE:TS
. TO EXTEinlM, EliVIRONMi?!i?
Concentration Coucound:.,.
mWm3 I.
Hydtocarbons A.
Saturat.ed Alinhntic Hydrocarbonc isthane
'15.6 Pentano 0.04 CNethanc 57
-Iso-Dut rtn e O.2 licptano 0.1 Butano 0.1 B.
. Unnaturated Alip,hntic ligdrocarbona
.Dutenc..)
0.5,
Butadienc 0.2
.\\
Iso-Dutyleno 03 Acetylene 0.07 C.
Alkyl llalides lE hyl1TE.fcHde' 3.9
' Vinyl Chloride 1.0 Methyl 13rc:..id:
0.3 Ethy]ene Dichlorido 0.3 Methylene Chloride 2.9 Y.inyl Breuide 0.2 Carbon Tetrachlorido 0.1 Chlorol'o?. :a 0.1 Vinylidenc Ch3crido 1.1 Propylenn Dichlorido 0.7 Perchlorc a thylono O.08 OrCanic Dromidos 0.03 D.
Alcohols Hetholdl O.3 Ethanol
~
0.02 E.
Ethers if.0 Et?6y1 Ether 07
~
Glycol Etheru
/
0.06 F.
Aldchy de r., retonen,.Acetateu
/U.iil:7syiiF6' O.02 Acetonc O.09 i
Anotettc3 0.02 0
Thiu t;r.antity doan not : tolude rathnne vented froin bri.'lo Ucl).3 located t p to (1 d. :tt:nce of 20 uilen outsido tho i
plant boundary.
k
i Concontration Cor;po,u ndn mqhJ 0.
Acrylate lilitihyl ricthacrylate 0.001 II.
Anino !!ydrocarbons
~~
Anl.une 0.001 I.
Aro::atic IIvdrocarbonn Ben:ienc l.2 Ethyl Deracnc, Dicthyl Den::ene, 0. 11 5 Divinyl lienneno, Iso;iropyl Ecnnena, t Jitity3cthy.t. Dennonc, Ethyl Tolv.ono, Styrenc & Dit:: r 0.2 Vinyl Toluene-Toluono 0.11 Xylenc 0.1 a-Methyl Styrenc 0.06 Hapthalene 0.0011 Chlorinated Dentenes
\\
(r:ona, di, tri, totun) 0.02 Ethyl chlorobenuano 0.06 Ch3crinated Phenols 0.08 Phonel i.
0. 2 11 p-Phony) Phonol
- 0. lli Diphenv1 03:160. Diphenyl o-Phonyl Phono)
'O,07 Dutyl Phcuola f.
0.05 FC J.
Undefined A1.frhp,3,:ic and [.romatic Ilydrocarbonu 0.5 II.
.Dv..a.t M$ n ta A.
Inor;'anic Dunt die?Jtistion Par tict0.ato
.6.3 Calcina 0;:ide 0.2 Magneuiva Sulfato O.06 Calciu:.: Chloride
~ '
0.3 Soditta Chlorida 07 Drontido th:lta O.02 Diator.ccoun Earth 0,0011 Soditna Carbonato 0.02 11 Orr.:tn
- e !'uu t hinph. ::v.t 0.02 l'arabj ::ph enol Salicyc. tic Acid 0.1 0.07 C.
Polym r Dunt Vfn~ffiMne Vhloride/ Vinyl Chlorico 03 110thylcellulose 0.09 All:ali Ce))ulo:d Pi'.p 0.011 Ion H'.ch:u.;;e Jianin O.07 l'olyncrylnuide 0.05 s
n..o
-- + -
Concentration Cor.ipoundu indm3 D.
A,ricultural Chanicaln Sooj u:,i picaloro;tropionato' 0.02 Dit? thy] DJchloro Pyricill.ol 0.01 Butyl CMorophenyl Methyl, Methyl l'honphoraaidate O.001 Di:r.athy} 'Trichlorophonyl.?hocphorthioato
. 0.001 Pheno):y Herbicidea 0.00011 III. Acid Gar.ca Sulfur Dioxid liydrochlor.lc.*icid 0.0 1.1 Ch. lorn::o.lfonic Acid 0.009 Sulfur ' trioxide 0.007 Hitrogen 0:: ides (iiO-NOp) 79 Acetic Acid and Anhych'ide 0.07 Chloroacet$c Acida (1:ono, di, tri)
O.008 Carbonyl c'ilorido 0.009 Chloropierin 0.0011 Sulfur Dro:n.tCas O.006 Carben Dio::ido 2100 1
XY c liir:ecl.!ancot:' Chor ca?.c Acry)onitrilu 0.5 Aminer:
0.001 At:rnon '. a 0.02 liydro ;cn 21.0 Argon 6.3 Frcon' Halot;cn and 0::t.no
. 0.6 (01 BP2 and 0 )
0.02 2
3 Carbon Mono:.ide 11. 6 Ethylenc 0::100 O. li l'ropylene Oxide 0.2 s
i
=
\\
4 s g g
e t.
9, i
i e
I j
i a
4
-..