ML19329E788

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Interim Deficiency Rept Re Misplaced Tendon Sheathing. Sheathing Rerouted & Alignment Revised.No Adverse Safety Implications
ML19329E788
Person / Time
Site: Midland
Issue date: 06/17/1977
From: Dhar B
BECHTEL GROUP, INC.
To:
Shared Package
ML19329E780 List:
References
NUDOCS 8006170942
Download: ML19329E788 (30)


Text

{{#Wiki_filter:_ .

      . ~ ~                                                 -                     - - _ _ . . . _

e.

 ', p g,.
                                                                               ,~

V. . , SUBJECT

                                               'MISPLiCED TENDON SHEATHINGS MIDLAND PROJECT BECHTEL JOB NO. 7220 FINAL REr0RT I

e Subsitted by: ~ /C l B. IDhar l O. .t' - ' :-^ I

                -i          Approved by: @ 4Y FA M s; G ot#                                                 l IR. L. Castleberry            -

Report Date: 6-'/3-7 7 , Revised: 8 " / 7--7 7- l l 8006170 t .

       - ~                                                                                _ - -     ._

9 INTRODUCTION This report summarizes Project Engineering's evaluation of. four mis-placed tendon sh'eachings, and completes Project Engineering's action required to resolve the problem. DEFICIENCY On April.19, 1977, a nonconformance to the project design documents was found, involving four misplaced tendon sheathings to be installed at approximate elevation 700'-704' in the Midland Unit 1 containment build-ing. As shown on the vendor drauings, these four tendons were to be . deflected downward to clear the two main steam penetrations at center *

                   'line elevation 707'0".       Contrary to this, two tendon sheathings (H32-036 and H13-035) were installed level, 'and two tendon sheathings (H32-037 and H13-037) were not installed in the local area directly below the penetrations. Concrete had been placed to a construction joint at elevation 703'-7" approximately one week before this nonconformance was found. This nonconformance was found by the survey team during pre-           '

parations for the next wall lift. The original design and "as-built" alignment of these tendons are shown in Figure 1. CURRECTIVE ACTION Project Engineering has reviewed the "as-built" condition and has studied various relocations for the affected *endons. Based on this review, it was concluded that the original design criteria could be met by rerouting one sheathing originally planned ,for below the penetration to a new-alignment above the penetration. Sheathing H13-037 can be installed below the penetration. There is a 14 inch clearance between the construction joint and the ' bottom of the penetration. This will allow a 6 inch clearance between the realigned sheathing (H13-037) and the edge of the penetration, and a 6-1/2 inch center-to-center spacing to the adjacent horizontal sheathing (H32-036). The 6 inch clearance to the penetration'is consistent with the recommendations of BC-TOP-5A, Rev. 3 (Ref erence 1), and the 6-1/2 inch center-to-center spacing between sheathings is consistent with the original design. The tendon sheathing-(H32-037).is rerouted above the penetration, necessitating minor adjustments of one adjacent tendon (H13-038). Both relocated tendon sheathings still allcw a minimum 25'-0" bending radius about the penetrations. The two level tendon sheathings (H32-036 and H13-036) do not require modifications.

                                                       .       .3                                                                                                 .J

3 ., -

The new alignment for the tendon sheathings is shown in Figure 2. The differential friction. losses between the reviced alignment and the original alignment have been evaluated by INRYCO, the vendor for the post tensioning system design. The results are summarized in Table 1. A typical force diagram for a dc51ected hoop tendon is presented in Figure 9. It is evident from the tabulated results that the friction losses in the ' subject tendons have been reduced due to this revised alignment. Lower f riction losses improve the capability of the con-tainment structure to resist forces like internal pressure. Hovever, the variations are small in relation to the applied force, and are considered insignificant.

The main steam penetration openings are 4'-6" in diameter, which is less e than two and one-half times the 3'-6" vall thickness. Therefore, the main steam penetrations are classified as small penetration openings, according to the provisions in BC-TOP-5A. In the original design, no special analysis was performed to determine the stresses in concrete around a small penetration due to prestressing forces. The stresses at the center of a small opening, deter =ined from the axisymmetric analysis for prestressing forces, were distributed around the opening taking into consideration the reduction in wall area due to the opening. This i analytical approach is consistant with the provisions of EC-TOP-5A. Dua to the the realign =ent of the tendons, none of the design parameters Y 1a ...

  • e,L l ~.: h.r.= ~ '- - ;;i n~,~f.',.2. ~r:! ; 2 ~ % _ ,~ ; ~',' .*_9~~ ~ "

calculations for concrete were required. Also, the new alignment satisfies all the BC-TOP-5A requirements adopted by the original layout, thereby eliminating the possibility of overstressing the concrete in local areas.

   -             The revised alignment requires cutting several penetration gusset plates (Figure 3) . The cuts in the gusset plates reduce the torsional strength
               ' and the vertical bending strength o2 the penetration assembly (sleeve, flange plates and gusset plates). To replace the torsional strength lost due to the cuts in the gusset plates, eight additional bearing plates were added as'shown in Figure 6.              The additional bearing plates vera designed to fully replace the torsional resistance provided by the portion of'the original gusset plates shown as a shaded region in Figure
7. To replace the lost bending strength, the penetration sleeve will be extendec, a new flange plate will be added, and external gusset plates will be positioned between the new and original flange plates, as shown -

in figure 6. The new external gusset plates will restore the stiffness that was lost when the' original gussets were cut. e m

t . 4 - The embedment hooks on the following rebars adjacent to the relocated-tendon H13-037 were cut to facilitate its installation:

1) One vertical #18 on each side of penetration at 77 (Figure 4)
2) Two . vertical #11 on one side and three vertical s
                                #11 on the other side of penetration at 1030 (Figure 5)
3) One hogi: ental #11 on one side of penetration at 103 (Figure 5)

To restore the strength of the wall to its original level, the anchorage , lost due to cutting of these hooks will be replaced. By examining documents on chemical composition of these bars, it has been determined that the subject bars can be welded. For one #11 vertical bar, a standard hook will be velded to the cut rebar. Due to space limitation , the other cut vertical rebars will use plug welded anchor plates to develop equivalent embedments of standard hooks. These details are presented in Figure 8. The hook on the one hcricontal rebar which was cut will be restored by a bar equivalent to the original design. The anchor plates will be grouted to ensure proper bear d-~ *nrfaces. The following design documents have been revised ..orpo-

                    ~=. 2's ;,:.: -:: :.:.: : 2 # '- Mr.:
1) INRYC0 drawings no. PS-lL2, Rev. 7 and PS-143, Rev. 6, Unic #1 tiall tendon locations
2) Bechtel drawing C-419, R ev. 2 - Liner plate
                     .          requirement - Penetration details' sheet 5.

SAFETY IMPLICATION The relocated tendon sheathings provide a design equivalent to the

                    . original' design. Routing one of the tendon sheathings over the main steam penetrations, instead of under the penetrations as originally planned, has no effect on the strength of the contain=ent wall. Also, the_ strength losses due to cuts in the penetration gusset platss and the cutoffs of reba'rs, both necessitated by the rerouting of the tendon sheathings, have.been fully replaced by the modifications discussed       -

above. Therefore, there is no adverse safety implications. REFERENCE

1) Bechtel Topical Report BC-TOP-5A, REv. 3
                              " Prestressed Concretc Nuclear Reactor Containment Structures" - Accepted by NRC.
              . - - ,             -.4                                                                   _ . _ _ _ _ . .     .

t

                                                                                               ~

TABLE 1 MI!!DHDI TE iDO:1 FORCES USED IN DESIGN *

                                                        ' Original Design             Revised Design Tendon. Refersace          Minimum       Distance       Minimum          Distance
                        - No .        Buttress-          Effective     from Ref.      Effective fro: Ref.
  • Tendon Buttress Tendon Buttress 2 Force (f t) Force (ft)

(kips) (kips) H13-036 1 1044 124.03 1097 133.37 H32-036 3 1050 146.61 1097 133.37 H13-037 1 1035 125.59 1045 124.78 H32-037 3 1029 156.37 1032 154.33 i nia-vao 1 Tess T.'.,7v3 .,0 - CC

  • See Figure 9 l
                                                                                                                                -I s.
 , v,e -

[ L l l p li i i .. .. . .. .. Ia..e. ', lT11l ll ll ll 1.1 'l l l L, lH, i 1 lE L I l' . i 'l 18 Ii 1. - si ii ii ii il  : U Il J ... '_. Iir-M l

                                'l111.111                                                   11            I r 1.1.                                   l l                                               l-                          Illi!I                                                                               o m l- 11                                                                                         i                                                                                                                       rr                                                       g ,g--

l 1 Il I r I r r r, r :

                                                              !!            !I              1 71 II II t__

II 9 2 IT-II . I 1. i I OO

                                .:            .p p .            _3          : ;                                          1
                                                                                                                                                                                       --                                             i_f(.                              r v,                               i ,

l l. l u, .n. aa g-r __.4

                                .                                                                                    i l

i; m2- _y q]l T"- l IT LI.: . __ 2_ r2-z ' <

                                                                                                                                                       .:                              4 I a.us 'l
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       ~
                                                                                                                                                       ~l                           3_.__,I                      ,
i. I; IH I ,!! !I I I .bijl  !-%1%/-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     "^

I!. 3 _l l l l'

                                                                 .i         is.           . . .

i . i.

                                                                                                                                                                                                          .o .                           '

a

                                                                                                                                                                                                         .._                             . '.r, '..,p.!LJ,_
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                . ~
       ,.. !!} , .. ,      .

4 \> .

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                ,                     (                  .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                          ,,e i                                             I e c.. rt.

i s l ll ll

1. l'
                                                                                   .,.,I   i l-         1 I I, l.. I s %.
                                                                                                                                                                                                  '/

{i .II . ...,t i p, g i i I"o) 101 .<l .'L l i ii i: i. i < - o . J .

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       .I A .-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                              } ..

I 1 1* I ! - " L l M  ! m :s jg *~ . , .' 3 gl .-  % b 3 gl __""." . f '? Q~ d ll t 4.' .

                                                                                                                     . r ,.p g. g .q _ p                                                                                   g.ig p               i ,:                                                                        @      ff

_. v.,;;d['!' g. ..f, .. gi

                                                                                           . . l'- l                - l -i - l.s I
                                                                                                                                                            ,        3
                                                                                                                                                                               ,t"'M.                -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                    ,1.-

j [ ,. . 11 fi n, tu

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   = 7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   ~

r o, i o i-cio, rjrl

                              ,1            II              Il              ll             l1          11                1I                  i 1 P                1                             s;/ y .,f II                                        l i                                      o                                            i.i

! pii i iT ii i I I i--4-li k g  ; I I =

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   !-       @ [3 52       2.- d            Ri,P
                                                                                                                                                        \                                                                                                                                                           d              o                  i   9Y N / f)13y 7--f l l. 2
                                                                                                                                                                      !i                                                                                                                                                     .,

P 'S l 1 . . - _.- , N' ' g , J.- . .A m e- d - F il 9

                    ,        I                                                                                I          g, l .'

i ,

t.dI kL-l /. t-).l;f;/ -. l g eo g eis
' ^" i ..
                    . --+ - t t-t- t-t -i - -t i o ig ,.2,3 : n!E r-                                                          UMI/'X.1                             /
  • o;> d'-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       ..S ':I P I
            -                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     J 6a o("r-
u. 4 4i
                                                                                                                                                                                   '. Ijkl
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   < .4                                                            e       -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                   ,'           *,                                                                                (t 3           t-    i.

n l ' I z RGp": d _.J 4 b .1lul

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 ? >
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   ~

l 'l I I I l I I l~ l I ! I JT4, i JTn l f li i i i i l i,y,~ilii J '/',bl .1 I I l 'f I ill x E l E.R, Git

   ,        ., i'. . ._; rt. r..r i nrt a: t rrl t-4.4 2-8 -l --' ':Wr!-4:?+k W'+ d=g o" d,,i-                                _ _;
                                                                                                                     ,..     .      .         ..     .,             i.,  !         ,.               l                      ,                                                                                      7         .: . .n a r.                        a
s. .
4. _

o , D o

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 ,,, ... m      , . ,e. .
u. o. t., u.o.,3
                                                                                                                                                                                                                           '                                                       ,,,                            I
l._.

e, :l . ,, . g . .g ., : g 7, ? ,e,' t 2,l 3 ; t 4 .

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           /. ), ~ a,             ,n 1 .1 .           II           .l .l .        ~ l .1
                                                                              .              :l 11              ei                  .                                        -
l :g  !.'

q ;, i,

I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             ;I     .3     7,1,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           ;I   I f   i                                             *)       j'ij
c. .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                ~

g gg .i I .I . I . . I :I . s.l .1 I :I O .i". .1. t i. .: .t.

                              -    . _i,               .,

is .._i., _1 -- _'s. ..i . i..,s_.l._l.r

i. l.W ,: ' . f F:

l- - 6 W + - i  ;- t + s,.

                      -                     -      -                    --           .m.

7 .;.;

g. ll 1I i 1- l1 Ii i I: - I i l --te* I l1
                         .! . .i . . . .i                       .i .l           .-.            .3!           : i .i e                              ae                 ii                    e a: i e                                                         *i 8                                  ~

l 1 i

                              .,a.,-...                . . . - - .                       .              --

i

                                                    -                                                                                                             ...          g. g.
                                                                      . _ _                              ' l! '               l I I

c, e l: r [-- C3 , T

                                                                                                                                                                                        ',alg-8,s' p z                    ,  a .,

g5 m o o c r- t- r-l 1 1 0c  ? 't i

                                                                                                  .e,i i      i                                                *
                                                                                                                                                                                    'a
                                            -+                .    .    .
                                                          ,=-           -                         ~ . . -                                                      r s

O_ I,

                                                                                                                                                                                   -    .a...nE. .
                                                                                                                                                                         -2             4
                                                                                                              '~

EI Gi @ o o

                                                                                                                                                               \D                  P- r- I'" l
                                                                              -.&                        !.                                                    z                       y O                          ;.                                                    <        m~         .         s 1-                  a ..o     T-
                                                                 ----                                                 ~

g r- .

                               -                                              o F

w= t t-O @ jL 0 s9 m  : l 6 1 W. l'~.

  • 7 -

dG r- r -

  -74                                                                                                                                                          6 9             ra ro ra co s C
 <W                                       \                                          p 8
                                                                                                     =-                                                        p a             O Oo o <

g

       *                                    (                                                                        ~~~ ~
                                                                                                                                                    -v         < 0              I   i   o     *
 ~5g   g                                     \                                                                         r0                                      y        z' N en N          ro t gz.. y                                                                                                         0        5 'O      ~    'O       "'

Q O

                                                                    -  /                          .,
c. -..  ! t- r I c Ij:

q- _ .v  : : m  % -- y . - _1 . . . - .-. .

                                                                                                      ,                                                  u   -

I '

c. .-- ,a
                                                                             .ev                                           .
                                                                          - - J.             / .I                  ~~

l

                                ,             S             I
                                                                      \ ((t$)/                      i n.. 2
a. _m:nnx v e g \ wk s i w_:m . .

Nx l

         -i I

w '

                                                                          \                                           -
          }                                                                 x
              .p. _..   -       - --       -     -

I- i

                                                                                                   !I                     i e                .
                                               ..*.M*              *     '

O . 4

                                 .                                                                  .e
                           .                                                     O ..                                                             .

I l t ' tD o 1 r- tu I

                                                                   ,               Nv.

t N I ~

                                                                                                                                    . B i                                                          -

A H M us . A g #

  • N N
                $*. H
  • O O A O N O . e H H , O
                      ~                                                                                                           O o              l                                                        .. .                                    g c4                                                                                                          r4      ed N                                                    _.M                   h ie                                                 l R d' S.
              'W      c              i     ,                                     -

gg A4  % MW ' bd

                @$g H

u.

                                                                                ~O m    *
                                                                                                                                           =

U1 V

                                                                                "g                                                         C N

5 C" H 0 0 ko D @ J .@ E is O tu ~

                                                        -h d
                                     +   -

k, _ a l.'

            .                                                CO                                                                                       l 1
                                                                                                                                                      ]

l l g r-1

  • ll l .

4 , e

  • l

.I i 5

   . .- . .i                                          -                                                      '

_f -M,riN ~ STEAM FENETRA .ON '" i

          \                        ,/                                                                        .
                                                                                   /,
                                                                          +

TORCH sdp fcuTS .

                                                                                           ~
                                         !y       _
                                    /            -

STIFFaiER 1 .

              -                m
                           ~ '

__ r -

                                    .. _f MAIN STEAM FENETRATION
                                                                                                                                                        ~

f

           \                             -
                                                                                  ~x
                                      /                                               .7 a

I l 9 9

  • vm sws e

e 6

                                                        '                          STIFFE:ER 2 1/P.9
                                +r                  (' -

l D J 4 FICURE 3 SilEET 2 OF 6 f I -+

                                                                                                 . . . _ . _                      ,, 4

i.'.,.... XV2'M _ _

                                                                               .,     ..                              cx
                                                                              .*                                       /

' STIFFENER 3 ,

                                                                                                                   .\

I

                                                                                                           '5/gljy
                                                .                        o
                                                                       /
                                                  //                                                    -
                                               ./ /
                                                    .4                                                                                                                                   '
                                                                                                                      /                                                              _
                         \
                                                                                                                                                  \
                .        T MAIN
                    ..J..._.       STEAM PENETRATION [._ . .-~~ .                  .
                                                                                                                         ,/
                                                                                                .                        h, l
                                                                                  .
  • T V1'.h ___
                    -                        STIFFENER 4
                                                                        /

s ll

                                                                 ./'
                                                               +                                                                    -

s

                                                                                                                       /
                            ),
                                                                                                                                                     \
                           .. MAIN STEAM PENETRATION #._.'.

FICUR 3 51tEFT 3 0F 6

   +
                                                                                                                             *"~r       -----        - - - - . . - _ , . , _
      .                                                                                                                                 I-m                                 ,
                                                     ^
                                                                                                        ,,...                  1
                                                                             ; :s .o-. ) g s.
                                                ......s,
                                                                                     .s.
                                                                                           ..-                        ./ -

l >

                                                                                                         .. .~I/2             q
                                                                                                                                 -+

STIFFDIER 5

                                                                                                                 -6.
                                                              +,-   f 9                                                    .-
                                                   ,- /

x - _-

                                                                                                                                              \

7

                  . [kMAIN STEAM FENETRATIO
                                                                                                                                  \
                                                                                                                                     /
                                                                                       .                                          Q
                                                        -                                                      . _v,n
                                                                                                              -~

STIFFENER 6 __ )

                                                                          /
                                                              \

s .

                                                                                                                                  /                  -
                                                                                                                                               \
                         )
                       .-~. : MAIN STE              IM FENETRATIONd ~~'

FIGURE 3 511EET 4 0F 6

      ~ - - - . - - - - .

I*F *

                                                                                                                                                  -d'....j-     -

l . . ~ . . . . . _ . . . ; ., .

                                                                                                         .        ..          . .              . .,                          /

i

                                                                                                                      .                   .. _,:                   p~ny
                                                                                                                                          '~        ~ ~ ~ ~

STIFFE!IER 8 - .,- . N

                                                                                             ,/.. .

b _ U

                                                         .                           . .i , .-
                                                                                 / ,g.
                                                                             . i ... -
                                                                                                                                                                           /                                                     .:
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        ~
                                                                                                                                                                                                              \
                                                                                                                                                                                ~

MAIN STEAM FENETRATION/v , i'

                                                                                                                                                                                                                           ~
                                                                                                                                             *                                 [i t

l

                                                                                                                                                            .                    )                                            i
                                                                                                                                                          ._ .gty.A                                       .
                                 .                                                                                                                                           i STIFFElER 7                                               ,
                                                                                               /l /
                                                                                        ,/
                                                                                                                                                                             /
                                                                                                                                                                                                        ~
                                 ?
                                                                                                                                                                                                                \

_. . . . . MAIN STEAM PENETRATION #._ . 1 ' i FICURE 3 i SIIEET 5 0F 6 . D ~

                 ,                                                         -               -       - - .        -         y     , , , , , , , _ , . - -                         --,-,,v--.%77--,,               -,   4 -        *v         -

n , ON _. ":.~r MAIN STEAM PENETRA

                                                .. ... 7 1
            \]L                          l                           ]L                       .
                %s
                                                                                              .//                                            .
                  +                                                +                      +/

It

                                                                   ; Y-                 p' STIFFENER 9 I
       ~.                         ~

_ f

                                             -~

9/4"_ .

                                            /

g MAIN STEAM FENETRATION i

            -1 a                             3*                            {

h e-

             .                                            *4            _q                      %

s' + g 1 h O Y

                                                                                           +>h a                     _

STIFFENER 10

                              .                           fgya                                                               .

m .m l l x

                                                /

FIGUpE 3 SilEET 6 0F 6

                                                                             ~

m o .... .

                                                                       .... ,r      T7                     .
                                                                                                                                                                         ]

1 I s n GEL 707-0 . 4 t c f , l8,,SAR vv i , s, CUT

                                                                                                                                           ,s
                                                   ,                                                                                            t     u

____1 -gt 7oz- _7 V .x <- r

                                                  %                                i~                             =i.s ..,.~..i.

8 - t A -

                   ,        . .. i
                        .4.
                                   'y                                  l               l1. jo" 4 :,

4 i t il' y- .- ELEVATIO:' (LOOKING FRO:t CUTSIDE) FIGURE 4 l l , SHEET 1 0F 2

  • a l

I e c ~ ,

                                                                                                                                                           -g,-       ,-

O o

                                                                 ..~-
                                                                                                                                                                             ...}
                 ,r.
                                                                          -l                                .;

y 4 i. t l t.. ; p ;t {:- . . . , a  ?? /j a ., ,.. ..., .. g _

                                                                                                                                                                                   .l t                                                          .>.                t
                                                      *                ,'                                               i _ .e , - :2 *
                                ,-..                               . , .t                                                 $.- . . . ,e       L.;. , ,

a.-.. s

                                                                     -                                                       s ..r.                 .....
                   . . --!              r                       '.          ,

h .# j. .. . .. 1

                               ~~.-                         3. ] ,.

t L. - _ . -

                                      . i s
                      ... , . . ~ - -

t

                                                                  .n
                                                                                              .-          6. . j. . .. 4 ;
                                                                                                                                                        ". . v. . - :4 ..

3.,

g. . ' . . . ..-.s
                                                            , . 'l.'-
                                                          .*;                         ...s                            ,

f.,w-- .~

                                                                       -.                               ~
....-. .. , r. }-
                                                                   ,. .-~.p . .

t. n .- .

-; ..g.g
                                                                                                                                                        - <                   <.a}.

I-i., -. .c.rv u . . a . -

                                                            ,v...,. . . . .
                                                                                                                                                                 . . - . ~. f . ,j s..       .            a-~                           . ~.,.- z %s r-.                          . ~             _ ..

I'll0TOCPA111 OF EXISTI:';G RI:BAR AROL7;D Tile l'E! ETRATIO!: AT 77' FIGUni'. 4 SilEET 2 OF 2

h 103* . 7

                                                                                                                                - L /0 !t - C"
                                                                           +                                                                     .

l s-

           -.- ...e - , a r
           ~ , . _ - . _ . _           .

J.?ay :;:.y y '- c.";;. s ,/ VERTICALv T . r i w n

                 >         >o
                                                   ^g,                         ,

gg(j (EL gS'-7" ta~ u o n ta:g' -

                            ..u..
                                         .\ e.

q g 0 n/2 xl I-7 _ q .4-- . , , . i

                                 . > . _m                    <1                                  <
                                                                                                              "                 .                  1 i

n t i_to"~ -w l'_;o W," > l a 4 2'-l" , _ l HOOK ON THl6.' ' l HORIZONTAL cli . ~

                 . J.~REBAM CUT                                     -        .

l e'

                                                                    . ELEVATICN l

l (LC0itING FRCM OUTSIDE) 1 l FIGU2E 5 SILEET 10F 2 i

o f, - ,' ; e " . i' 3 [. - . . . .e

                                                                                                                                $                         *.J.s
                     ,      y.-                                                                                    1,
                                                                                                                                                 ,        -i-   ,
                                   .                                                                                ;                                    * ; i r.. .,.
                                                                                                                                                         ..u - :<.

r ~. . I. . r.

                                                                                                               .       ,                                                l
                                                                                                                                            -l -
                                                                                            .c .i .                                                                   ?

g ,- ,-

                                                                                                      ' vp j                     ,-         .
                                                                                                                                                                    ,l y                                 ;
                                                                                                                             . i                                   .
                                                                                               ..;/

l k ,.

  • w.
                                                                                                        ,/
    .                          . ~.                .   ,
l. f
             .l -                         .a.'

y-y:

   .                        %,....                     ,,                                    -                     r
           .s.
                                                    .,..w.           . .u
                                                                                    ,e/ 4,, .-                                        ?                            .)

L. ~c....

                                                                              /k,                         s,e                            '
                                                                                                                                                                  .;g
. 9e. . . ...,- .; -}
                                                                 /> ,g-/,c,  /*. ' <>,f-'
                                                                                                                                                        . . ;4
                                                                                                                                                                    .8
  \

i

                         -,              ,                .. . .       .>*p*,....'_.,.
                                                                                                         ~
                                                                                                                              ~:              ' .                    s.
                                                                                                                              .                     .          .-l
b. -
                                                               .           t         ,                                              . . ..

t.

             ' Ky ...                                                                                                                              s.              .l
, - 'yJ, , ,  !
                                                                                                                                                                  "}

J A .____. ..._.'m *'

                                                                                  ' f: -                                                      J P110TOCRAril 0F EXISTII;C REUAR ABOUND PE::ETRATION AT 103*

FIGURE 5 SilEET 2 OF 2 +e

                                                                                                                             j
                                                                                                                                 !1
                                                                                                         -)                                       Y                    \
                                                                                                         ,o                                                      t I                                             I
       ,                                                                                                           I                                                         ,.
                                                                                                         ..                                     *                        /               I
                                                                                                                                                                                    ,1 l

l(. e i i

  • i j 1.b. '
                                                                                           ,J       8 I

t,L

                                                                                               &                                                                      i L

Q s ..f

                                                                                           -                     N,                                           h, ].                    .

Il n=g f DC y --

                                                                                                                                                                                                ,/ //           ,;,m      -
                                                                                                                        - -.                                                               hf
                  .           n-I
                                                             -> s     ,,-        ,9       /,-

q

                                                                                                                                                                                                        /            W g' M
                                                                                                                                                               }
                                                                                                                                                                                                     /
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     'd 2 i-                                     ^i                                      ;
                   !A                                                                                                 J l
                                                        !                                                            is                                         l lI' I
                                                                                                                     "                                                                     J
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     %u.8
                                                 ~
                    .:                 /           g                           aw, l

t Es/ e 9' m

                                                                               -w                                                d He O-
i. #, E!

N \ 1

                                                                                                                ,]
                                                                                                                                  -                       t,' f A>$
                                                                         ,A v

g gn

                                                                                                                                 }W                        d

_2

                                                                                                                                                                                              =

y>c g ,

                                         /               J< O'_y-.._
                                                                   -         c   ...

__. g m 3 m

                                                                                                                                                                        't s                     M- r- 9
                                                                   .E 7
                                                                                     .         b-s<                               g                        s4 83 ya U                                   s tu B;
v. .ji r m c-
                                                -                                   , . . . ,         6                           %                I         s          .i:                 . .   .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     . _. n _i .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                       .                J
                      '.)Q 
                                                              -                                                                   -                       ..,                                M                                           ,
                                                                                   *4                                     :
                                                                                       '*J                                          I             l        -

O ,t-- ' _i (O

                                                                               ,                      ,)                            i             g S                                    w                       GO S

g  :. '

                                                                                                                                                              -                                        N                 m 2 I;
                                                                             ...'                        c m

s t x\ # '

                                                                                                                                                                                                    \

pr e 4.; 'P' 3,l , / -.! -Q j

                                                                                                                                                                                  ,nj(' h4 p w *wq
                                                                                                                             - ?<                           p-(7                                                                                                                                                                                           .
                                 ,, t            ... . ., 9
                                                                                                                                                                               '(TTF)g)'                                         /- v :

I

                                                                                                                                                                                                                 " j\             N' ' '
                                 =$                                                             E j                   ,
o \

s ii ,

                                    ~y                                                                  .u d                                                                 -                                  + _ _ _ . _

f -)C" hf~. l V2" i

                                                                                                                                                                                                         \ADfYl.I,Nn~.M
              <<               l i
                                                                                          ,S_i,..                          -
                                                                                                                                       'p                           (~~~.__ . 2RjNG !?

N FIGUP.E 6 S!!EET 10F 2

A .- ' '

                          ..f                      .

( ..

                                                            !k ADD'L ft. I /a"if 2P2% O'-  3                                '
                                                                                                                                ~-
                                                                                                                                 .Z. 10" l
   -                                          ' ~~[                            ( 8 - R EQ' D) -

p/ m h g ((

                                              -[~                      $                                                                      w

{ , ,

                                            \                            O
                                              \,/
                                               /
                                                                     "j4                                                       ' ..

O  %,

                                - 'N                          e
                                                                                                      \                          --
             *S I                                  % 7'. - N                                                         '
                                                   '~

ok -./OFTJONAL .

                                                   ,g-x n        '

it

                                                  . tu                                                                                                      n
                                                       .k
                                                                                                                                           ,j           g Y                     ~-
                                                                                                                                                     ~-
                                                                                                                           /                                "

sN, App'L f"k) ~ (*) REQ'D -

                                                  ,FA' ~,~'
                      ~ ::                     ,,<
                                                                                     ~
                                                                                              #[       ,

h,

                        #                          %j,                                      s
                                                                                           'ce AO
                                                                                                            '9
       ?o.

a4 // 0C g /, / I

                                                                                           .- ADP'L I /2" TH!CK. SLEEVE
                                                                                           ~

in

a. -- 'd ADD'L. J 2" TH!CK T41NG 8.
         !~<! !- E                    .

e p

                                                                                                                       ~ ' ' -
1. . _ . . .

If s r_. THis AR5 A' CF .-- 5" i GU55ET IS CCM51DERED  :

           /PECTtvE IN                O      .~ ~ ~I                                    e RE515 TING TOR\ 51 %Chi                                  lP
                            =
                                                'y
                                                 N /

(\ I!dTelE5LEEVE

                                                                                                                       ~~

w.

                                                                                                          ~
                                                %7'/                        .G U 3 5 E.T._ f2.

s

      '2 TWK, rLANGE P_
                                   ~~

N/

                                              /                                                       '
                                                               ~.CU T~ LiNE~.~___ __
                                                       \    _ TORS!CNAC.~' RESIST $ndi LF                                 '
                                                            'iHIS.. ARE A .CCMP5N S AT E D ;_                          ..

_b_Y__.. ADD _ElQMAL ~ LUG 5 _- DE51G[JCON51 DERAT CLE [ OFT AK :~_ ' . .. EOR TO

                  . _ .u...G U 55ETS ~ NOTC HE D                                              -~

_ T.~~ _ TEN DON ~~~ 5HEXTH 1RG ~ ~. ._. FIGURE 7

m....... . . .

    - ..                                                                        8 g_                                                    -

e, 1

                                                                       ..                                                        2 A

n i

                                                                                                                          -      u)                                                    '

I y dj t

                 \ s-                                   .g J                 c k                                            6
                       %                                 f-4                              F.                           =

o a g-5' a v. p lg-~ A a x3 b 5 2

                    -                                                                    $*                          tr aa^.e                 a
          < O w                                -                y-~ -

ns - el <o g- 4

           < e2 2

19 se

                                                                                                         =              f2~                   L)
            ~          g                     g            us f                          T                                                                     n y .t                                                 Y"                                                                                 \e ~

4) U .. ,. I  ? a

                                                                                                         ~'$             $00 #5 2u2                   2                2-
                                                                                                                                                               -                 i Li 2 ~0                                         .e
                                                                                      ~
                                                                                                          -l                 4n               u, 9.

r , s . .* dT j E $.u .2' Y Wo 0 2 *  :. W

                                            \~                                           2~

y 9 2 $ d* . -

                                 *      'n A .
  • Ox: V) w 1-2N /
                                                                    $            I
                                                                                  .m d                                tu tj P-              d                ~2 6                                           . ..y 2

4 2' T A2 {  %~ 2 r of S i (.- b V r

                                                                                          ]
                                                                                               ,                - - -                    . q ,q 5             g T [1 2 1

3 Wd il I  %

     -                            a=                                                              i                                              p .~t~ 2 oe                                                                                          .

4 lI

                                  ~1
                                                                                                               &c x

ya '0) 4' 2. I .I j> I ' d \

                               ~sg                 / .dl q7              1                                            "j r       a
                                   <m                       V C

uJ r km ' q t

                                                                                                                                                    - m ' f\1 Y

3 b ,,..

                                                                            ' .+T                                      -                          }d v*

f 3 l h: D A sn e 1 V $ f dsy b *ye235f E]'.:- 18 . h 3 Y Tfi

                                                 , m
                                                        , (                              ii                                                           J              d o s.

fb l l 0 v

       -         Nh                                                                i            :                                      '              dvi
                 = .1 ,

al 4 ^

                 *Ob w         q
= k en 4
                  $2 h ,j.                         .F l,                                          ' Q                    R             Gl V " .. / ~< u                                                   .ua i

FIGURE S SIIEET 1 0F 9

s- ,. 5 y 0 > m ,N1 ,.

                                                            ~                                                                                               a 4g                              .
                                                                                              . . l.. . .

m ' .:. 4

                                                                                                                                             -- r-                                      7 W--
                                                        ^ ~ ~ ~
                                                                                                            \__.\,-                                  s                  D'               *h
                                                                                                            .                                       ._ e              g.,

Ili[I __ ") y[.. - A L_i _ - _,_. 7 L 2

                    >                                                                                    \                                                 r                             \-                   -

L- Y

                   }                                  -

_= .. - l t e4

                                                                                                                                                            \
                                                                                                                                                                                          "I.                    $y I                                                   },                       N                                \t.)
                                                                                                                                                                                        ,9_.

2 y , _ .

                                                                                                                                          . .... -(-          '
                                                                                                                                                                                              ,                  30

(/ -d f' ( V h t

                                                                                                                                    \-                  ".g\
                                                                                                                                                                                          ~
                                                                                                                                                                                          +
                                                                                                                                                                                                                  )          -
                                                                                                              -n               --
t. 1_ .

(, 's l L y

                                                                                                                                                                                            -1
                                                                                                                                                                                            -        P              n i                                                     Nt F -p                                           i                   4       -

4. A o

                                                                                                                                      ,     /                                        Q                              <

b- - 21 g  :; z y 8

                                                                                                                                                                                                                     =

c3 {P t..g-5 i - i, - _ i 4 Bu7

                                                                                                       -                                                                          to .             1 d                              tt 0 *-4             -4
                                                                                                       $ l}Il n

a1 44 ,\i -se' $, - 5 2 4 -- r ul -- D M 71 b y *~3 1 O m y ) .i o a 4 t- - c - g._20 +, 206 o 9 2 2' - 1 l l . _ a S ;e . . -4 Q.- 333 o 0 ~ 4Ts s 1 '< 1 y B o > 7 a'07

                      ~

Ii p -

                                                                                                          -e qw           tu                      tb
                                                                                                         $ ~1                                                             xY*5              ._I                          b t--     i.n v1 -4 vi         .y                         -

L' ,

                                                                                                                     ..                           I
                                                                                                                                                                  -                                                     y-O b

_) Q - 4  % w - u e -

                                                                                          .&            n,                       .                                                                r-k                U                       !

d i-A @' G2 v ' , 4 o w iu r.- 3._

                          .                                                                . su                                                                                                           '
                         '2
                                     ~
                          .                                                              < $1-             a
                                                                                                              ~
                                                                                          -g               to 4                                                                    $5 sg                l ~-                    .
                                                                                          -                                                                            I

. g f - I i l ... i FIGURE 8 - 8' SHEET 2 0F 9 I .

4 g Eyss} A 4 S I 'f - l s j g Mtatt. S]M. fE'W '

                                                                         @ 'lY                                                    ,

gge-Alte.,3 PEP }tuc>oo

                                                                                                                                                     .5%ATH 4q Hl.S-o'6"l                                        ,

o -

                                                      -                                                                                                                        .-           r              -              i
                                                                                                                                                                          /

M Atu 6 td Elm, king S iFFE9En. Q c ,,,, e,, op m c. .

                                                                                                                                                                                    ,enn ,zww 4g         inquLegioea cP                -

l e ct e it. - - . t L lo s'-1 (c..s.>

                                                                                                                                                          .       -.          7 q           -i;              '

w

                                                                                                           /

j/ 1 _1 o _-

                                                                                                                                                      -2

__1u. n_eA,_e

                                                                                                                                                                            -         =_ ._ . 6,1.c-
                                                                                                                                                                                   --*4 l

g l:l sn. M i . - u"N - l (T.sur2ou 5HEATt4tilL7 Hs-osr, .- ,,  ! V. 7

                                                                                                                                                          ,          j-                                                       ,

o _ t

                                                                                                                                                                                  --A.             . - _ _- __

0 l  % -

                                                                                                                                                'Ia i                                                              }

2 Sg g o. -} - > ExtSJ.frIBtREGA:::. l'- Io _ MD \\**h <@T To ACCOMIAo oATF .

                                                                                     'I             .                                                                                    Testoow *EATains                       i Q-         t:E-Atte.::NMGr4T                    }

i: goo - YAc p AL_, EbbVA 8 ota AT Matt 4 $}%. {6tJE}rz A

                                                                                                                                                                                                                     --l

( A 2.itau]i-\ q *) cou]AtumeuT Look.tsc3 Ita) f (ouTsioe dF i 2:. y '

i. -
 ~ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ .

d upin q m pene. ,,  !~ g 3f s' 46 ,. v ( t e. Au e g r, coma siscqitie! q - Riv.,- os7 s . ulAAtu Sp4 $60&. b. ( , tenot SMfE"E" I N

                                                                                                                                                        )

i - . _M-.. TW) -f:. : . - - - - - .

                    "j

{ ~ ~ Wz' ( 5H '? A S i fIk-2%L,'ba.3 e . , g

                     ,   l          h          '
                                                                           ,           ..._r    0f$$o?
                                                      \~ \                                                                Mb.7oO'7(c.J.3

[ ". / __\ 4__ -- i

                                                    " ' ~ ~ -

6

                                                                             ~ b*I .4 I6 IEE E A " 6-{o. Hook-cot:: HEC oF f566t c.                                                            ^c c * "^ o *T*

Ta te ci4 To Aum $"T i I E'4ovm To . It4 stat.LAliou op CAF d i E'J*ou

  • EA'IH'"'t k'cALicoMee)J s G **** .
                                          <1 -

f tt;T, t L ELewge9 AT, M^m MN\- peneTiz.^i, ion . . I se Look.iseq 04 ) . (ou}sioe op, 'conysue:g . 1

                                                 =-       *-       *                                         ,
                                    .we

~l 4%-A L %,,

  .                 .          ,j                     ,
                                                                           . m.                                                                   _
                                                        'l }V 7 -~~

8 j b t/\A.,td 6tof605

                                         .                - l,p'                       ktkC) S)t?FGHCC {
                                                           !I                                f
                                                           /        .
                                                           //.s >
l. -
                                                           / /,
                                                           ,/      <.                           .

i

                                                                                                 ,                            Jeu =ons'reMatet~

I"

                                                  . . _br  'C L -.            I l

f

                                                    -                    ~s           l
                        -                        r                          i                    i/          /

l pr } -l . t

                                                                                     .$ ' \
                                            ,             ,.                  j I .'l o 5 - 7 [C d D g
                                                                                       \!

E._ , ou}dioE q9 ggi

                                                              % Ace   e Pf?E-Ft.ck.ED Fbov4AELS TYf?

14CM - Sucmk 4 tout (q2'. C.0Ld) W At.L.

                                  '                                                                                  o F-     bc1 pac.k.- (,$p ac c . ;g t ') e
   +

FIGUPI 3

  -e SIIEET 5 0F 9 g                         -                                                                                          - . .          -                    .,     -    w       g     m

O e e e-

                        ~

g $ _ l h

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    ,5     e    k                               .
                                                                                                                                                                                   ./                                                                                         -

I

                                                                                               ~
                                                                                                                       /
                                                                                                                                           /-            ~=                                                                                                      .

A I' l .-._ b a c o 4 it 5 12. W o k

                                                                                                                                                                                                                       /

a G e K 'Aid c) f- 7 i / eyw . g s l CI- ] /

                                   +                       cTYr.)              .
                                                                              \                        ---                                                                                                                                                                 !

i i  ; t.' .u l v_= . - - J.- / i ._g -

                                                                ^

g C M* L i

                                                    -                                                                                                                                                     .       1              . _.
                                                    ,                                                   . .                                                                                                       I w
                                                                                                                                                                                     '                             [

P l 3 I !IS !f" ' _- so' l l[db'[] [ i 'i l  ! OU b a r.39 FA.: & c.oo xjataaw"\ , WAt.L. . I ~ 1 .

                                                                                   @C.TlCN-     . . - -

e e, em m mese- e

  • 4 e e.eemiis GD FIGURE 8 SHEET 6 0F 9

= _ _ - _ . -- - _. __ . - . - _ _ . - - _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - - _ - - _ - _ _ - _ _ _ - _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - .

               .               .         .....m...   .

s. N ' e 1A Atu S p . (1 646: . f; 4' 2 Mr.q, .vg't? PEuf C E- .

/-

7//

                                     ,,e_
                                                                                                  ,                             I
                                     /.        '                           '

(ue4a11Sjp. Roc 4 4 . . r .

                                                                                                                                                      ^

Ph:2 gg . ggg c-ou}{5 trig 4 # C.cu Att4MEM} VJ4L o / / F i g'dXtS{,}ggooM SHEAIMM3

            !              N y7--
                                                                                         .I y             _
                                                                                            .            _ Eb. 303'-] (C. .l.)

1 5 ii U L! bAECUP DAC 6CitoL1 . t ' 4 - -- l t i b b FICURE 8 SHEET 7 0F 9 f' ( - - --- ---

i *====e... ,",, meeO Q e @ ' '

  • e 0
               , e.             e                                                                                                       e e

0 e r,u. . L ham s}M . IB# - uta STM6HEL k l . 4 I

                                                                                         /                                                                                                     .
                                                                                 /,t               -
                                                                                                                                                            *73
                                                                                                                                                                ,a    sequaq p.

s

                                                                                              ;                         h           1/

1 g P=---- 62" i !_

                                                                            /.,,                - . , -
                                                            ~
                                              - i          s., e                 .i                       1, - l g '          .

7./ _

                                                                                                            ./                   /
                                                      "-r     / r,. ;                                       .i .

me-

                                                                             .::-  / 1 's                     ..                            .

E'loI_1.(c3-) e d , e * ,

                                                     -             e        y
  • ap6 U

he fMdQ WOW ~

                                            "'                                                                                         gon - suqukap qcauT (A?nc. C ~33-
                                            > w 00 Stc& ,#A                        '

C of?. t7 ty PA/.'.k. (6 E' *. C Ml) 5

                                                    . co ,AwseM, $

Q ' h6CTIC R e t- , e I

    !                                                                                                           FIGURE 8 a

4 - SilEET 8 0F 9 i g_ _

                            .  +-

i . , , l _ *o.. ,

                  .;                                           m                                                                            '
                                                                                                                               ,                                                             e
                                                                                                                                                          -                                   I
                                                               /                                                                                                                          ..
                                                              .,,/ . ,
                                                           ", i     (
                                                           //   /
                                                            ,/ ,,-                                   .
                                                             / -> LM aim 6}M.p6c5.
                                                                            ,               k,1Ng qtFF61Jer t                                                                  ,

i

                                                                        /1.                                                                                                                     "

1 ' m! i t- Coz -

                                                                                                                                      ~~

gNc 9 SMEA}RI% i l _

                                                                                                         .goe           /
                                 ----e            . I-            l                        J ]N '      ,,           /,,

b (D '* ~

                                                               'll                                               ,/

g ll 17 -

                                                                         ' '                                                                    gh,]
                                           .4 18'P                '
                                                                      ,                 .         h-                             ,

n ' e o uJsc e p cra ,, peg.yAc'cp FlonA6'.~ TYPG cckr*/quuggy Mot 4 - SMrstNL cycauf (67%. <*.**b) (uA O C DCT PML (5{ U. C.'.St ) 6 8cTtol4 . M - i FIGUPI 8 a SllEET 9 0F 9 I t.

r [.:

                                                                                                                                                -1 5 0 2         ;

puRING OVER STRES5_-' 1602-y 4 18UTTRE55 '*1 , (402 < j,' ',,__ -x ( ~ 4.60TTRES6 636,1402 TIME LO65 i 1 Ill4<O -lo33, l' K' ._ 245.3 CONSTANT . . -

                                         ' 1203,4 K 1112.4 "          , ,105 6, I X .. E* K< I                                         ej;93-.7 g

p5/o,1 EFFECTIVn >,e 43*&g /,,iosi.exg

                                                                           ./            54,.7 g,                                                       :.
                                                                                                                                                         I
              DISTANCE FROM RE rERENCE BUTTRESS TYPICAL FORCE DI AGRAll FOR DEFLECTED IIDOP TENDONS F10URE 9.-

i

                                                                                                      ..}}