ML19329E632

Advises That Type of Aggregate for Const of Seismic Category 1 Structures Described in Amend 27 to CP Application Acceptable

ML19329E632
Person / Time
Site:	Midland
Issue date:	10/30/1974
From:	Schwencer A US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC)
To:	Howell S CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.)
References
NUDOCS 8006160413
Download: ML19329E632 (2)

Text

-

m.

~

O b M. m., p U d..

-,. ~ n =

w y

" -i4 '

O M S %c. _]

s i

.. ~w.p'

_l

~ g :y,_? ff. %f m jf. $r2kf;

,s.4 kNTi&

I

- SiNNM((

,ghfI((y$fh

[

hh N

. ~~ w mo w e m ; & 4.;~'q-

..w ew,-

8: w w..

- -.m

. %:2 l Q :'._"., -' _.:

-m

~~ 's

• - % e 3m

.a M w-prpp t,.

-r, a,2:

~Q 7

- ~~

.7

. ~-

• s v

1

.v W

~

OCT 3 0 1974 u

a

.i. s.!-

~.

x JJ W 'e E

.c..

Docket Nos. 50-32 a.

t;,f;"u. 4,e

1. x and 50-330 la M;'.eu *

'_ 0 o

_. c s.... %.a G.y - <c -. Y pt '

m.,

y.n'

,

~. -

p.y:.+ ~ ;, w w:;wa M %s. mn&:n n y xy.. x.y

.-: mp g

i a

s c..; m. ysy M Myy z

my.

" JMl, :.; ;' :

h=.A:.M &g-f c., y:c.c.=

. a :.r~

MC s.-Xp M = d 2Y

% :." %. k %*s M v j

s. :

. w. y.,2 fi -, 3w Gl L y'

,l

s< d

,..V

.,b. 4 ?

M W. e,g P.. %.C ' ':,' m.m' Ers -S. H HowellL suiw,'Q. a'~'.y. w;+;

... =p.a W

&w u..

.m :sw;.L -. ;W 5 % J nh

,c. *:% - s.Vice President :~&.:{gp &:

iW.

W M'L pany; g.u n~ # y~~.-s m-<. m.',.%-

n,-Q, m ~y. Ow&a 4

w

~

=c e

.~ m y

74 1 Consumers Power Com n w

212 West Michigan Avenue 4.jf ; g; 4ygggy >;%gggow wa.,..g. 4 gg

~

y.".-y.2 wX #

y

.,,_7

. m

-- Jackson, AHchigan. 44201., C E

-iTHIS' DOCUMENT CONTAINS M

m,1 ~ h ;

Dear Mr. Howell:

1 1'T P00R QUAllTY PAGEf ~

~

2

,7 Jr. -

.9

+

9 n-I4

~We have reviewed Amendment 27 to your application for construction ~ 4." - N~

em

., m permits and operating licenses for Units 1 and 2 of your Midinnd, oPlant.

iCh

. 9

, :T::.Z ; 4 Safety Analysis ReportiPSAR) that-destribe in detailinformationifQg!Qh

@ Z e on unwashed and washed aggregate to be used for all Category.IjQ:gF~5

. N%",ng.s q,, structures of t.he'.Mid1=nd Plan.t.,."fM,4%:

-A w m.

...e-

~

W ea.:.*9L. --..* e q Q ev s

.+

e L

g.

m 3 ~p@hq@..TW~ :*e*WEWFM

- s ^*

-e~

" ~d' @~n#c 4

WGMc ~

Mg 1 C "Use of Coarse Aggregate With Varied Percentage of Material

~

%s:JT 6.-

"i@1

.p' '

_ X Ef Passing the #200 Steve".. prepared by Bechtel Associates Profes-1 "%.W" MS4sional Corporation.of: Ann Arbor,1Michigang dated July 27/19747 i M@pg.7

m.,. you' indicate that tests show;the fines content of some samples'as' ' ~~. E-2"4

~

S /Qhight as'2.'Oh The ASTM Mpacincatiori'C-33 permits fines content 0 %$

%.5' 4up to L 5% " Tentative. revisions of ASTM-C-33, published in the 9; gif M-V 3

n1973. issue of. ASTM Standneds7 Part 10, permits the fines content ?.TXg&'.4

~

WGG%2to exceed the limit ofL5% when tests demonstrate satisfactory MM t 4fr SN3%performanc 9%sh%dMn

%hNia$$W569@kel the aggregateWWs/MNWMfNM@M MMi*

. @ b C*S 9 8 h M

.%n'KQJound to'be satisfactairy;a;cf your compression tests ammmmeyp.the'resnits hggM nd1he. type of aggregate ~ detailed in yourp

% d22 profided that due attention is given to the~ Qual 9N wMAmendmentl27,to;the'PSUt sill provide satisfactory-results in Y d

.WSeismic ' Category Latructures for the Midland Plant.Enits 1 and M&M. W;.

W.:mW c'onctete. N.cLfh! W % Q W'Pii & M 4 M 6 * % %. d?f NW,~

^o_..,

,v.

t

,R -

s

"['l=,

4 ;p f.g. *% e..,:- l., N E- '

Y Us.-2 Sincerely,

^ TS y_g.s.e @Q. 4 g t w w g.9*3::.C;.9, e$v D..Q.y h,... r ' [. &..A e k?

\\. ' 'A, Y'~

.. %,%.n h %.

-. ywx, w :.. r, 3 a..

u.

e u~

o k+g=x %4 4 3 >qggy..

4. f: *<;.yQ-Q t.w sW*~

n m A @%eqJ,@s <b,a e m

- 4 eq y

-v pu w e + -

(

f.p<,Qf. Qv..$ ?.g.y:y. y

~. ;.

Q-

.~Q;a

-QtlgtDA,, SlgDCd<bf+~='Nq w'**p u@$3 L~g

. g "zt.W y"a; M *f *'-

r

. m M

+ 4 #w..Mq a gs:wm, A.k,s *y.r : _:qs.g.w. Jfc ;n m

my-

• i-ui t

a.

w

.r

m p

c.>. A.. mN.,. ie.

w o w me.<-.v;p.

w':4 '=t"F.'MMf3 L3d $d&%4*NO MtMW. O'H'WCW9'ie.5'N W# W,.,....<.,

.o,h M T.*'# **#r :.A -," * 6 %: %'.,J / ' T *84 7 [ %

. wk.. +,..d4

' i a

.t g g"= P -

gg. MNp.

y Wupgh Light Water React 4

y MQ-njWpg%pmn;.m.,c^. ors Branch 2-SYgy;$T,$

t irectorate cf u nsingsgg_$.2 paw. 3 Wm

. w r w.

.=

8006160 4/3 f7

w

. _ n =.

- -g.

p-5 m.g%.@t,

,g

- - mg..

~

[

s, 3

a.

~

r

• p~"

$Q..

g.

~, f

.a

'?

y3 i

~

I OCT 3 0 1974 l

Mr. S. H. Howell

-2_

^ '

I ces: Harold F. Reis, Esquire Newman, Reis, Axelrad 1025 Connecticut Avenue, N. W.

Washington, D. C.

20036 Honorable William H. Ward Assistant Attorney General Topeka, Kansas 66601 Howard J. Vogel, Esquire Knittle and Vogel 814 Flour Exchange Building 310 Fourth Avenue South Minneapolis, Minnesota 55415 Myron M. Cherry, Esquire l

Jenner and Block 1 IBM Plaza Chicago, Illinois 60611 i

James A. Kendall, Esquire 135 N. Saginaw Road

~

':r Midland. Michigan 48640..

A>

Irving Like, Esquire Reilly, Like and Schneider 200 West Main Street Babylon, New York 11702 I

DISTRIBUTION:

~

Docket Files LEngle D

'; ~

~

j AECPDR TR'BCs-i

~~

~ :

3 '.;g ' ~

~ *

~,

j.,.%

LPDR EGoulbourne LWR 2-3 Reading LWR BCs 1

r.

K2 ~

~

VMoore ACRS:(16)

~'

ASchwencer FSchroeder AKenneke RKlecker R0 (3) i R0 III OGC

.ACarr, 0GC.

~

1 e

...v.

e

..,',,c.

. x7886/ _

L e.~

.y

~

gWR:2-3

' ~

C 4

~ '

LBEngl

~

ASttfencer N '

.J e - V._'.7 o...

"I ',;,,,.

• 10/29/74

~ 10/$,/74

' ~~

?, *:'._-a.__ % %__s.

. Foran ABC.315 (Rev.9-53) AECM 0240

.,.h

1. u. e: eovanunsamt enantime erricas so,4.see.s ee.,

,.s

,4,;

,.,.; j

(

. x.

,_ **igj

• A

! 2:1L.1,

~ '*^:" l w '. - f:

n a & 2" "M," ~-M ? *_.

k 7

.k-

--