ML19329D333

Notifies That 710220 Filing by Applicant Fully Answered Living in Finer Environ Challenge to 10CFR20.No Addl Reply Will Be Filed

ML19329D333
Person / Time
Site:	Davis Besse
Issue date:	03/02/1971
From:	Charnoff G SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE
To:	Jordan W, Skallerup W, Winters C AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED, Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel, OAK RIDGE NATIONAL LABORATORY
References
NUDOCS 8003050904
Download: ML19329D333 (2)

Text

,.

c-a~.

+

a.- 3+m{

.}c.

g.n n p..y 3 };p.f.g.;Gyf q% pQ yT.

/

m,

. ;.n.gn.M h

2:

N.

~N N NC8 %.h y -

. l

^

SHAW, PITTMAN, PoTTS,TRoWBRIDGE & MADDEN

[,

.....m,~.

C.. m., _. w-

. C. L.,...

... m,..,..... -

N.".va n't. 77.=

WAS HIN GTO N, D. C. 2 000 6 TE L.x:.4o s.,

~.y a

........,1,.

e

,3

..m.LO C M.RNOF, puitu,o..o.rwica

//

4

p. ft pe.,MT M.N LOM N

' '_ ?

C.W..NC MU8.T.R

\\

q.,

J..a,meCm Mac..Y

.muC. W. CMURCMcLL March 2, 1971 0,

1. 49

.. e. s a.*

i+

4..Lt... DelCMOL.O.d. J R.

r h.

N.mTIN D. ER.LL

+w

~

' 6

' ', c-A

.. C... s..... u.

A.f'g-.

r s.

....L....

p.0,.

.td.T.L.a

..anyu.swo s'f

.~

RNO jr y

Walter T. Skallerup, Jr., Esq.

Dr. Walter H. Jordan l y;

,. _. o Chairman Oak Ridge National

. A ' %,12.q4 )

~

Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Laboratory V W.G J.

1155 Crest Lane P. O. Box X l

McLean, Virginia 22101 Oak Ridge, Tenness e 37830.]f.

v.-

Dr. Charles E. Winters M.,.., g r,.

8800 Fernwood Road

. ". R Bethesda, Maryland 20034

1. • .as87 l

}

• > }.b;.; f,

y2 In the Matter of The Toledo Edison Company and ec[j.pyh The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company,

t. i QQQ '

Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station vc4 m

j Docket No. 50-346 O.. @m V l

w w..; g Gentlemen:

~

- n' d N ?.r m

"~ '

'S h

s m

1. 1

.Q,g l*y's t.t

~

l_-.

The Applicant has received and reviewed the Brief:

~ # ~;6 4

Regarding Challenge to 10 CFR Part 20 and Proposed Findings i

of Fact and Conclusions of Law filed in the captioned pro-

? #. T ceeding by.Living In A Finer Environment and William E.

'. $ ~.~.E#

Re'ny (hereinafter collectively called LIFE).

a

. f ;3.". 'b qQ:.g

3. p.,94&.,

On February 20, 1971,. the Applicant filed Proposed inQ.W Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law.

That filing included' N findings and conclusions relating to LIFU s challenge to the LhM validity of 10 CFR Part 20.

Those findings and conclusions fully consider.the matter presented by LIFE in its brief and 3.{yf.

M:

in its Proposed Findings.of Fact and Conclusions e,f Law.

Sb:.m

!^

Accordingly, the Applicant will not file any additional reply A%

to LIFE's brief and proposed findings relating to its challen6e /-Ch

. to 10 CFR Part 20..

1

_. A!:ci.:

,,. m

.~

S cerely WM A,

c.,

n.sm q-

,.;c N Q:'1 Q

~

~. '.

Ad.

. / ~,. $Ph@

J.

j GC/ mis e

t.

h.

, Gerald Charnoff

.: Qp

~-

Courrsel for The Toledo EdisonMgM

, [ [ 'J.j

.k.,. p Company.

.,,gg

. / -n s.

.~.7 7

, C. ;;,.

~ ~ ~ L y z fgg;.

,. f.*L':QT W

p:

.~

~ ;:..

.;'.~,

.i

,@;& 0._0 $.0

~

"~

w,s ~

r _ _. l.,.

,J.;.

b

_., c..%. il.1.#si

,.f,n

.~

< t z, _,2

. 1 M, a',.. ~. r"; m; l %% %.,

• g W '%s... ' ; C ;~ ".~...., :. T

. A hr

'S

~

.s m

em*H

,:e; ewer ~

Sl *<Wv+%,.tyf' 4 'sf ' V'.n

.& v i

e. - W i

[

^

mMmW:2:w_

"a

- n t;

3

..; -z, m.-.

~1 9 q d x :::.>

. g.-

y

..o -. y n.f,.<,Gy,. c.+km.ou ye

<,.c. c...,... s

.w.

n...n c n.

.,. x x.

. c v

.. 5 y

hjY, f.,

.7 b; lk Walter T. Skallerup, Jr.,'Esq.

~

m Dr. Walter.H. Jordan s r %" g4>.

". @4

A Dr. Charles E. Winters

't March 2, 1971 Page Two

. s W~.,A.

. < A~,v. -

. i

-4 m s s..

x s A,.

ym

.e l

n c,.tM,

, <u.. e.m.

Q,,.,...

.4 m. m

-p. ~pn -

k.

.i.c.pfg,m,.,.,

+c..

, Copies to:.

3 4

, : s p;w4

,,y

. s..

. m,

. ~, w 'L acW-

,n.,p..

c James P. Gleason, Esq.

W '. 4 =,

Dr. John C. Geyer

~

Mih v.:1X. @,

3 Mr. A. A. Wells s

su.

e?w%n'6

'G Mr. Stanle T. Robinson > Jr.

,..'N.

Mr. Thomas F. Engelhardt

' 'u

' J; s M.,

' 3 Mr. Roger B. Williams MMNa i

E. W. Arnold, M. D.

.j.%%

Mr. Harry R. Johnson-o ry, SfM Russell Z. Baron, Esq.

Beatrice K. Bleicher~

3.4?R~s n

Mr. Glenn H. Lau

.'". NNs W

g

., in:.e

.'t.= *d. b..,V ".

.[M g

s.

.. v; * '

g s

.j C.* M. - V.,

. -. (r, i y'--

-g..

is fg4 g.

"l> +,

+

_ e

. ',..~. W: +.% n.

.r.,

v..*w., n w~ ~.+..,

f 1 '

W i.

- W. 9.p'g ejm-

,w s

' ,p"ae,flf{~$Q/;

w.

- j,<

a, 4

5

,4 t,-

s W

}

y ~. 2

,t ;

3..

~

e n

y.,-

... 3. r.sm.s

~

g.

.;.. yy a.syyrg,.

~.;.

..c r -

.-est :,_. g:%.. i c p

,s

.r

.e Css b i' c.,,,

7 n

-=

' ',i_ r}..

-3 d W.1.%

s 3

.s/g *.w. = -

1 6

9 t

. "' H *- f> f

• 5.e, o

[4,

,4

-w

.,y

. i

• fG n -

s.

n,.4

~

,. ww

= 3'tcM., w e

%..m.P*'

' ~

. ;&g:

• l, s

n

. ~, '

- ~

4,

,e

,., p 0,.

,,: m f.w;$**'

.t-,

+, * > $. d -

• / g; N ^

4, 4 *'

,y.

Q w

- ~.

J '#

(

• J.4 n.',-

v,

e g

h ~ '

.,, g:. -.

.A

. ~..

'.< w ;' [*J~ f}-

(*.

L <:y'm.,'; t, Y

~

s n.

• * + g

...4 s

y*y

,,,\\ j g_ #,,

E.

[-

.ss' q*

n 4 e

.[-.

• 7 y

P' " h.*

(t,; %

s

=

f;

-),i Ay b

'y t

' I t

e, n

<w.

,r.

~ %

[9

'.,,~-?*

,-4'.

5 d

z. W'4.,,

4

.s.

,e

, < ',p~

t '

s

-s*

',.:.., a,s% 5 y F-t

> +

,,, ~

+

n

_. - w : f.. f -

l*j'

6%

s f..,4

,+

.m

.;i G.-

q f ~

~.,;f.g.;J,,

\\

s

.., '~ f_.

y.

,.~ m.e -..Q 3Q.f 1

~

^

7,N 4..

~

. y' ' %

, ; r,;,

-s.

Q.}: ;,

p3 )

4.'

X

,,(,

.. i,

,4

,e

. /".

b'...'.,. *,

, M.

[-

e M

y P

3

,e.m

.,.v.

.,j

^.

• u At' (p*$(

j 3

e 1

. E E'

q

• l t

s

1. , _ :n.p N

.;st.a n.2

,a t.,,,

f.. mg AweAna x

a

.s y

-,.. x m

,c/

.. <- +.

.n.., r %', 1.,y. M,.. m -...+. a e g-W p 2

, n.n..,,3,,.s; W =. v g ?Qf,f. w i 7..

,. y g..,;.

a '.

a;. *a.

.[2. ' *.'

.,, -[ N -

c :

e,

,./, i g,.,. g f. +8., u$

4

= +

<p.,A ~s.ay.. y a

.w.,

. <,4 s.=

. we,v *>-

..y s

a; i,3 3; "

,1.,.~f g,, p.% 4

.._as.:

.e-7 h.'1 "'

• . J. " 4 ' t{

G'p *{[j';'

J{ -

.,y h'-#,,5

'[* '

o,,]{

.. hbb>h 6

5 ww aa

, _ =.

n

., m.w - -

.- - - - -~ -=, -

--