ML19329C920
| ML19329C920 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Davis Besse  |
| Issue date: | 09/12/1973 |
| From: | Farmakides J US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC) |
| To: | US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC) |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8002200898 | |
| Download: ML19329C920 (17) | |
Text
_ _ _.. _ _ _. _ _.._;.,_..
g
- ~" W u'
/Q,
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION In the Matter of
)
)
THE TOLEDO EDISOM COMPANY, ET AL.)
Docket Nos. 50-346
)
(Davis-Besse Nuclear Power
)
Station, Unit 1)
)
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE a
I hereby certify that copies of ORDER CORRECTING TRANSCRIFT dated September 12, 1973 in the captioned matter have been served per the attached Service List by deposit in the United States mail, first class or air mail, this 14th day of September 1973.
iaan G. Annexa Officg o/ p e Secretary of the Comm%sion
Attachment:
Service List ec:
Mr. Farmakides Mr. Scinto ASLBP E. Goulbroune N. Brown Reg. Files ASLAB 4
8 0 02 200 SW g,
,MIC ENERGY COMMido M
/:
/
/
j' UNITED STATES OF AMERICA ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION In the Matter of
)
g it
)
THE TOLEDO EDISON COMPANY, ET AL.)
Docket No. 50-346 u
)
(Davis-Besse Nuclear Power
)
Station, Unit 1)
)
SERVICE LIST John B. Farmakides, Esq., Chairman Leslie Henry, Esq.
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Fuller, Seney, Henry & Hodge U. S. Atomic Energy Co= mission 300 Madison Avenue Washington, D. C.
20545 Toledo, Ohio 43604 y
Dr. Cadet H. Hand, Jr., Director Mr. Glenn J. Sampson, Vice President Rodega Marine Laboratory The Toledo Edison Company University of California 420 Madison Avenue c
P. O. Box 247 Toledo, Ohio 43601 Bodega Bay, California 94923 Donald H. Hauser, Esq.
Mr.
Frederick J. Shon Cleveland Electric Illuminating Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Company U. S. Atomic Energy Commission Public Square Washington, D. C.
20545 Cleveland, Ohio 44101 Joseph F. Tubriay, Esq., Alternate Judge Herbert R. Whiting, Director Chairman Robert D. Hart, First Asst. Director
~
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Department of Law 4100 Cathedral Avenue, N. W.
City Hall Washington, D. C.
20016 Cleveland, Ohio 44114 Dr. Harry Foreman Reuben Goldberg,Esq.
Box 395, Mayo David C. Hjelmfelt, Esq.
University of Minnesota 1700 Pennsylvania Avenue, N. W.
Minneapolis, Minnesota 55455 Washington, D. C.
20006 Joseph Scinto, Esq.
Mrs. Evelun Stebbins, Chairman Francis X. Davis, Esq.
Coalition for Safe Electric Power Regulatory Staff Counsel 312 Park Building U. S. Atomic Energy Commission 140 Public Square Washington, D. C.
20545 Cleveland, Ohio 44114 Gerald Charnoff, Esq.
Russell Z. Baron, Esq.
Shaw, Pittman, Potts & Trowbridge Brannon, Ticktin, Baron and 910 17th Street, N. W.
Mancini Washington, D. C.
20006 930 Keith Building Cleveland, Ohio 44115 Director Ida Rupp Public Library Port Clinton, Ohio 43452 we -.
ITED STATES OF AMERICA
' A ~a cvsRGY COMMISSION
/
/
/
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
. _ __,j ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION In the Matter of
)
73 THE TOLEDO EDISON COMPANY AND
)
Tile CLEVELAND ELECTRIC
)
Docket No. 50-346 ILLUMINATING COMPANY
)
)
(Davis-Besse Nuclear Power
)
Station)
)
ORDER CORRECTING TRANSCRIPT The following transcript corrections will be made:
Page Line Change 14 10 line to read " response, we thought ".
14 17-21 Lines to read "We, therefore, thought to the extent discussed in our original response, that they, unlike the other contentions in Mrs. Stebbins' and the Coalition's original pleading, were adequately phrased."
14 24 "it" to "them".
15 11 Line to read " entitled ' Petition to Intervene',
we concluded".
15 13-14 ".
If" to ", if".
15 15 "it" to "them".
m, S
15 15 Insert "and" after "be",
c)
DOCKETED 15 16
", the" to ".
The".
USSEC li-SEP121973* j 15 20-21 ".
If" to ", if".
cmn et m:nuarr G
rra: 'rmes:
15 25
", or" to "in".
s.=a G
i
/
16 1
"was" to "were".
4 g
l
. fsge Line Change 16 4
line to read "We tried to specify that in our".
16 7-8 sentence to read "We expressed what it appeared she meant, which contentions therefore would be proper."
16 10 "was" to "were,".
16 11
" discussed, all" to " discussed tnam, proper.
All".
16 12 delete "and".
17 6
" haven' t" to "have".
29 13 "conunercial policy, and the law has" to " Commission policy and, therefore, has" 37 18
" asp ec t" to " accident" 42 18
" Regulatory Safety" to " radiological safety" 42 19
" Environmental Management" to " environmental matters" 43 2-4 sentences to read " Consequently, the Final Environmental Statement is adequate. In this regard, if it is admitted as an issue, the staff is prepared to present the FES as its evidence."
45 8-10 all lines after " appears" to "to be a blanket attack upon the adequacy of the staff's review pursuant to its responsibilities under the National Environmental Policy Act without specifying the exact nature of the inadequacy. This is what was meant by our response."
43 15 line to read "and on whien we can now present evidence."
47 23
"(blank)(blank)(blank)" to "the Final Environmental Statement" 48 5
"(blank) for spent fuel levels" to " standards for spent fuel containers"
. Page Line Change 48 18 delete "any".
48 20 line to read "results of that review".
48 21 line to read " compiled in the FES".
49 10
" statements to review" to " statement's review of".
49 11
" performance" to " requirements".
49 14 "7 on page 8" to "7.2.7 on page 7-8".
58 14
" shipping" to "Shippingport" 60 11
" condition" to " nature".
60 20 "due to" to " attributed to routine".
60 21 "would" to "will".
60 22 Insert a hyphen " " af ter " postulated".
60 22
" basis" to " bases" 60 23
" and" to " o f".
60 23-24 "26 to the extent" to "26.
To this extent,".
60 25
" to" to "for".
61 4
Delete ", in other words,".
61 5
" o f" to " in".
61 6
" contention" to " interpretation".
61 8
"did draw" to "has just drawn".
61 9
" play" to " nave".
61 9-10 line to read "this proceeding, since we now know what she meant by her contention."
9
. Page Line Change 62 24 "of" to "in".
62 25 "and" to "and the".
62 25 "her" to " the".
65 17
" benefit.
It" to " benefit -- that the AEC".
65 18 "they" to "their hazards".
65 18
", the" to "by the".
67 23
" precluded" to " included".
73 10 "inclusional" to "conclusional and".
74 24 "but" to " that".
74 24-25 "is not" to "has set forth'.'.
91 20 "short" to " shore".
111 22
" the" to " June".
112 1
" conference" to " hearing".
123 11 "wases" to " wastes".
128 17 "We had" to "We had initially" 128 19 "We are" to "We were".
128 22 "certain" to "were certain".
144 23 line to read "would be the list of witnesses who are expected to be".
165 9
"restrike" to " restrict".
216 13 "along" to "alone".
. P m Line Change 227 9
"of a lunch" to "over a lunch" 227 10 "the Board members the" to "the other parties the" 245 16
" naturally" to " nationally" 247 6
" exponent" to " component" 247 20 "No residential" to "No new residential" 249 2
" price inelasticity" to " price elasticity" 253 16 "am not" to "am familiar" 265 6-7
" dryers and ranges, but they have ceased promotion of the electric water heaters" to " dryers, electric water heaters, and ranges."
268 15
" LED" to "TEC" 277 8-9 "three hot days in" to "three o' clock in" 278 15 "4:00" to "4" 279 1-2 "minus, not interchange" to "minus net interchange
279 10 "196" to "19" 280 8
"196" to "19" 289 12
" offered" to " authored".
291 7
"They are assuming" to "The Rand report assumes" 293 23 "do not promote" to "do promote" 294 15
" transformation" to " transmission" 295 21
" concerned" to " conserved" 317 8
" bulk" to " bulb" L
. M Line Change 339A 18' Intervenor's Exhibit 7, under the Admitted In Evidence column, insert page 577 347 22 "themal Itaninescent" to "thermoluminescent" (and in all subsequent references) 351 24 "be" to "being" 378 5
Insert "MR. DAVIS: (indicating none)."
393 8
" fallout" to " falloff" 395 10 "20,000 on" to "20,000 pounds on" 398 11
" indications" to " fluctuations" 403 11 "toal" to " total" 407 8
"of your" to "of year" 407 9
"as times" to "at times" 407 19 "Bristow Bay" to " bristol Bay" 409 3
"is commented" to "was coussented" 430 5
" testimony" to " testified" 432 2
" area" to " air" 472 19
" Riviere," to "Regier,"
479 10
" county." to " counting."
492 2
" dozes" to " doses" 499 18 line to read "giving that document to" 499 19
" parties - the" to " parties the" 500 1
Line to read " Water Pollution Control Act Amendments of 1972."
v,
-e m,
Page Line Change 503 4
sentence to begin " Elevations in the" 504 7
line to read " time and" 506 4
" review" to " proceeding".
506 4
line to read "now involved" 506 10 "Dr. Hulman" to "Mr. Hulman" (and in all subsequent references) 506 14 "Mr. Charnoff, may" to "MR. CHARNOFF: May" 508 9
" data" to " datum" 508 14
" leak" to " lake" 508 22 Delete "and" and add a consna "," af ter " surge".
514 6
Delete "but some models available" af ter "models" 514 12
" practiced" to " practice" 514 23 "henever" to "whenever" 515 11 "date" to " data" 516 16 sentence to begin " Based on the" 516 7
"models" to "model" 516 23 sentence to begin "The inquiry is basically, should" 518 10 delete "the probably maximum criteria on" 522 24 "Blalack," to "blaylock," (and in all subsequent references) 524 3
"I was" to "he was" 524 4
"Giambusia." to Gambusia."
524 8-
" adaption to" to " adaptation to"
.g.
Page Line Change 542 14
" defects." to " effects."
543 23
" environmental report" to " Final Environmental Statement" 544 6
"prechlorine" to "fre chlorine" 549 22
" 12" to ". 20."
549 23
".12" t o ". 20. "
550 25 "my" to " the" 552 1
line to read "In Table 3.6 of the FES,"
589 2
" fission" to " fish" 591 16 "first word in the line to read " beta" 599 24 "MR. DAVIS" to "NR. BARON" 601 24 line to read " EPA in 1970" 602 1-2 lines to read " calculated the value of about 45 picocuries per liter, versus the 15 to 30 picocuries per liter given, so that our models" 603 10 "or thereabouts" to "at a maximum" 612 2
" technicality" to "technicalia" 623 2
" opinion" to "open pin" 623 4
" opinions" to "open pins" 631 20
" type" to " tide" 632 6
" transfer" to " transverse" 654 25
" rose" to " rows" 655 7
" rose" to " rows" l
9-Page line Change 682. 12
" unit type nuclear" to " Unit Type - Nuclear" 682 17
" capital" to "CAPC0" 685 2
"1958" to "1985" 695 13 "tur" to "true" 698 12-13 line to read " engineer he is presumably" 701 16
" Arthur" to "Dr."
703 25
" Liability" to " Reliability" 703 18 "he did" to "he did not" 714 1
"a collection of the models" to "the collection in this model" 714 12
" heavily" to" relevant" 715 5
" reasonably" to " reasonably constant" 715 24 "ef fec t" to " neglect" 717 2
"effect" to " neglect" 718 5
" identical" to " infinitesimal" 722 18
" operated" to " operation" 722 20
'.' chemical" to " biological" 729 13-14 "401B.
" to "401 certification.
Or does the savings clause elimindte that?"
734 9
Delete "3" 736 21 "in these" to "if needed" 748 15
" gaseous" to " liquid" l
l i
4 P m Line Change 753-4 The doctanent identified on lines 9-11, Tr. 753, should be incorporated following Tr. 753. Ace-Federal Reporters are making arrangements for the distribution of this docssnent.
766 18
" hearing" to " review" 769 11
" expound" to " respond" 770 1-2
" Statement is the Reference," to " Statement. The Reference, is".
770 8
"- " ' to " birds" 771 4
"is" to "was" 779 10 "the mills" to " Waltz Mills" 793 21 "G-2" to"6-2" 807 4
" Hassle" to*"HASL" 815 14 "for delineating" to "for purposes of delineating" 815 15 "ones we are" to "ones you are" i
824 22
" Board wants to" to " Board wanted to" 824 22
" clear what's" to " clear on what" 824 23 "the issue." to " issue was admitted."
S24 23 "on the issue" to "on that issue" 824 25 "very clear that" to "very sure that" 825 13
" struck from that" to "strick with that" 827 5
" evidence.)" to "evidance with portions striken as stated.)"
11 -
M Line Change 828 9
"of the recedent" to "into" 841 19
" tests" to " installations" 842 19 "predictibility" to " predictive ability" 842 23
" appropriate parameters" to " appropriate dispersion parameters" 842 24
" contamination" to " deposition" 843 6
"in air" to "in ambient air" 844 16-17 " forms of meteorology in the Atomic Energy report and" to " form to ' Meteorology and Atc c Energy',"
845 5
"a projection" to "an injection" 845 9
"or temperature" to "or chemistry" 846 3
" temperature interface" to " density interface" 846 4
"the inversion" to "the suboidence inversion" 846 12 "drobes" to " drogues" 860 10 "stanmary" to " sum" 861.
22
" Exhibit" to " Exhibit 8" 865 16
" vale" to "value" 867 16
" Thermal luminescent" to "Thermoluminescent" 873 10 "W-24" to "T-24" 887 19
" volume" to " column" 891 7
"available" to " variable" 892 1
"'I mean" to "' Assuming" 892 14
" January" to " February"
. Zage, Line Change a
895 7
" position of the operational safety" to " Division of Operational Safety" 901 12
" presents" to "coupares" 901 13 "1969" to "1959" 906 7
" paragraph" to " Table" 907 2
" fit, if you recall" to " figure,"
909 7
" limits" to " error limits" 909 20 "Zwickley (7)" to "Sewickley" (and in all subsequent references) 910 1
" month and the" to " monthly" 910 23 "was added to" to "to that of" 915 13
" positioning" to " deposition" 930 18 "too late," to "to light" 936 25 "1970" to "1971" 940 16 "in transit" to "in transit duration" 948 25
" insignificant" to "significant" 956 16 "NUS," to "NUS, for" 960 3
" received to receive" to " received" 960 16 Delete "from his model" 960 19
" direct witne-ses," to " direct witnesses" 960 17 line to read " Statement from his standpoint" 963 9
"Plumbrook" to " Plum Brook" (and in all subsequent references)
-w.,
. M Line Change 965 24 line to read "T-24, which is in Sandusky, I believe that it's in a" 965 25
"- " to " building,"
966 15 line to read " biological hazard" 966 19 line to read " factor of two" 967 19 "2, Beth" to "2 & Duff" 967 23
" central" to " centroid" 968 7
line to read"90 mr" 971 10 line to read " spectrum of nuclides" 976 23
" assistance" to " assistants" 985 8
"0.042" to "0.942" 990 15
" asset" to " assert" 990 18
" Dosimeter f 1" to " Dosimeter # 10" 1009 17 "14" to "15" 1012 8
" Drinking" to " Surface" 1012 23
" discovery" to " vicinity" 1022 10 "look" to "looking" 1022 12 "was 43" to "with 43" 1025 19 "quedtions" to " questions" 1029 8
" graph" to " grab" 1030 19 "under" to " understand" 1032 2
"you" to "your"
. Page. Line Change 1040 22 "1972" to "1973" 1041 21 "like to hope to" to "like to" 1042 8
" record completes this" to " record is completed this" 1042 19 "of administrative" to "of an administrative" 1043 5
"before it." to "before it today."
1053 4
"19-A' to "19-D" 1081 7
"1972" to "1973" 1089 21 "but a repetition is not in our best interest." to "but repetition is not of interest."
1096 12 line to read "own mind attribute" 1097 6
" strong, strong disagreement" to " strong disagreement" 1097 8
"immediate and" to "immediately and" 1108 10 "Rowe" to " Roe".
1110 3
"And backfill material" to "The fill rock of the dike" 1113 14 "rather" to "and" 1114 23 "inme" to "in time" 1116 7
"We will. Perhaps" to "We will recess... but perhaps" 1116 8
" advisable -- how do the" to " advisable to ask -- how the" 1117 19 "is clear" to "is very clear"
. Pag Line Change 1117 24
" relevancy of" to " relevance of" 1117 25 "not clear." to "not at all clear."
THE ATOMIC SAFETT AND LICENSING BOMtD dohnB.Farmakides, Chairman Issued at Washington, D.
C.,
this 12th day of September, 1973.
i e
I l
,.