ML19329C761

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Amend to DOJ 750905 Response to Utils' Interrogatories & Request for Document Production.Statement Added to End of Part C of Answer to Interrogatory 2 Re Territorial Allocation Agreement
ML19329C761
Person / Time
Site: Davis Besse, Perry  Cleveland Electric icon.png
Issue date: 10/14/1975
From: Berger M, Charno S
JUSTICE, DEPT. OF
To:
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
References
NUDOCS 8002190879
Download: ML19329C761 (5)


Text

~

. . ~

.- p . \t/ *)$

.t.. .. .. . . ,:. v ,a-_, ., s. ,. ,.:. s OF ts ,a:.n,ICA NUCLc.l? R; Z LATORY CC:iMISSION i

BEFORE TH: ?.TO::IC S's?ETY AND LICENSI:IG BOARD

)

In the Matter of .

1 The Toledo Edison Ccmpany )

The Cleveland Electric Illur..inating ) Docket No. 50-346A Company )

(Davis-Sesse Nuclear Power Station) )

)

The Cleveland Electric Illuminating ) Dochet Nos. 50-440A Company, et al. ) and 50-441A (Perry Plant, Units 1 and 2) )

)

The Toled.o, Edison Company, et al. ) Docket Nos. 50-500A (Davis-Besce Nuclear Pcwer Station,

) and 50-501A Units 2 and 3) )

AMEND:1ENT TO THE RESPONSE OF THE DEPAP.T:ENT OF JUSTICE

.q m. o. r r c.,, - e e T . . m.

  • e n , e r m.so-o. .r. r, c . m. . i n. m u.r o.wr. . .n g g g r,.

mm s 6

.. . r s . -..-. . _

Pursu;nt to S c ction ? . 7.' G le ? cf cha Carr.i/ sic n 's F le s of

' c.c a by Practice (10 C.F.2. 5 2 . 7 N ', e ) ) , the '.Lp.trtmann o f Jus tic:

amends its respensc cf September 5, 1773 to the Applicantc' interrogator 20s The Department's answer to Interrogatory Number 2 should na amended by adding at the end of part "C" che following statement:

Beginning at some time prior to :iarch 1965, and con-tinui.ng there;ftar, Ohio Ediscn and Ohio Pmter C:r-a.nv engaged in a terr'.ccr_al 211c ctio.. agr - .i c, :c. n a; foreclosing competition in suneIv.ing electric c.ower. .

The Department makes this amendment pursuant to its obliga-tiens under the Rules in that, at the time of its initial answer, it was wholly unawarc of tne facts ur:lerlying the amended caswer.

The Departmant further asserts goed cause for the amari ent in s1

. . . . . - . . . . . . . - - . . . . . 8002190399....

. s that information relating to the alleged agreement is contained, in part, in doc. ents .;; u g h t frcm the Applicants during discovery.

These documents .er; m . produced by the Applicants, nor was any explanation given for t..eir failure to produce them as required by the Department's document request. The Department, by letter of even date, has specifically requested certain documents which we believe to be in the Applicants' files and which bear directly upon the amended answer.

Respectfully submitted, h

q s s ./ r,/

s. n,. ,, - t

- _ we STEVEM M. CHARNO

.e-b'd~rt/U C %.

iiELVIN G. BERGER

...~._ ._ ._

Depart.r u_ of Ja;  :

Washington, D.C. 2u330 City of Washington District of Columbia Subscribed and sxcrn to before me this A.r.> th dav. of Octcher, 1975.

/ Wl/ W/

// ? his N L. E ~6r M

'. N d PUBLIC -

My commission expires

~ - -

' " *e " ' ~ c' 18 m

- --- ~.. - ~ - ... - _ . , . . _ _ . _ . . . . . . . _ _ , _ . _ . _ _ . . _ . , . . . _ _ _ . . . . .

C:::D STATE 3 OF A'iERICA

.7,.,.-- .

a . . G, .uc

. . . . . . .n. 3.,.f Crv ,..I.,.S_.t . .. O,7 c,.z-,,.,,.

...u .c,.,-,..2

c. . n..D yIc.r..--,IG m . . . a 1. nO m .

.a In the Matter of )

)

The Toledo Edison Ccr72ny )

Dccket I;o. 50-346A The Cleveland Electric Illum:.natina - )

Company )

(Davic-Besse "uclear Pcwer Station) )

s. . . .

3, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating ) Decke :io s . 50-440A Ccmpany, et al. ) and 50-441A (Perry Plant, Units 1 and 2) )

)

The Toledo Edicen Cc-v.ny, et al. ) Decket ;Ics. 50-500A (Davis-Besse Nuclen Power Station, ) and 50-501A Unity,C and 31 )

^"

C " R'.' .?. .? . ' L'". s*.

. r ur o "v A~t

.c.' r .s t m' A . ,. . .

.,_...a.

.. g ,. . .

.. s

..c. ,..;..,,,-.._.. n .w..a . a . .

.. m. . :. u .. d n a . . . ... . w. , ,, : uD...,..-.,a.)

.L-. .-':~...

n: ..a .. .. ' .-  :. :. . -

p. - ,...,L.

-, . .s -

L. ,..r.,

. 12 e . s ,,.-.

s v t. --2 0 u.. pJ;

, , , , . . ........,q

,,...,,)

.s.,.. A.

,r -, . ~ . . , , - . -

. . . - . L .- v . . . i ;.

I,,e v. . . ,."L <.-". . ,.m .3 ." r snO r. ..o w D. t s o.a.. 3, 4

a .,.C. .L. r$..> r. / L.-- - m. ." .r s...

...*r.

.... . . . m. tm V~7~ L b ~ I C ,. <.- ^.,,

.-nu . c e..n ...m.~-.,.,n...m....,...-

A rc.tr. m ..,,,, .1a t, ,a u- _ . ,, . .u,..a

. . - . J ,,, a. . .,

2 ;. s a. . u... ... -

C u '. .-.. ';.  !'..',,'. .'..'.'.

a'2.-...' a. ~^ ^.. ' ' ' ' .' # .' . ' ' . '. ~ . ~ -.

--. . 2.' 1'ia-- - . . . . . . " . . . . .

attachment hereto by deposit in the United States ~:il, first class, airmail or by hand delivery, this lith day cf Occober 1973.

3

( G ..-. . .-

.r

}s*/

[wm mk *' * .\

STEVEN M. CHAR:;O Attorney, Antitrust Division Department of Justice i

m

4

~ -

..,,,.7 .

. h L .% u..s..

r. ..m khe L Douglas Rigler, D, _ 3 Andrew Popper, Esquire C.'cirman Benjamin H. Vogler, Esquira Atc:Si. : Saf2ty anc. L:^v.3ing Roy P. Les3y, Jr., Esquire

. Boar Office of the Cenoral Counsel Foley, LctJ..or, Holl:eaugn Nuclear Regulatory Ccmmission

& Jacobs Washington, D.C. 20555 815 Connect cut 7.re., ..

Washington, D.C. 1 306 Gerald Charnoff, Esquire William Bradford Reynolds, Esqu' r a Ivan W. Smith, Esquire Shaw, Pittnan, Potts & Trewbridga

4. Atomic Safety and Licensing 910 Sevan teenth S treet, N.W.

Board Washington, u.C. 20006 Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Lee C. Hewley, Esquire Vice ?rcsident & General Counsel The Cleveland Electric JJhn M. Frysiak, Esquire Illuminating Comoany Atomic ,S,9fety and Licensing Post Office ac:s 5000 Board Cleveland, Ohio 44101 Nuclear Regulatory Ccmmission Washington, D.C. 20555 Donald H. Hauser, Esquire Corporate Solicitor Atomic Safetg and Licensing The Cleveland Electric

. ~ . . . , , . . . ,w-. , .a. .n. .: ,.' . . r ...x._.

..--,..,--ar_ ".s 7' .-*

^$3.: a . . . n. , 1 3.--

, i1

.u

. . . 3.- .u.~., D . u~* . s .. . .

Fr 2P '. . . . .' ara 3 JChn 2.anCdal~;, Ir., E N L '. J 2 Ch.ef, Pus 1 C 2 roc 2caings Cc::, Lt: ~fcrd 3rc: 7 o..=

.y ..-

.x w..,..,,'.s.

Office of the Secretary Washington, D.u. 20036 uclear ac;ulitcry Commission J . asni.:;;cn , _.C. 20535 Ca_u; 2c:_;ff. ~_ - 7 u _ r a m.:..,, c,...-

. _ _ . . . _ .,.;.._...._,,..:..,i_s... ., m Abraham Braitman State of Chic Office of Antitrust and State Ecuse Indemnity Columbus, Ohio 43215 l Nuclear Regulatory Cctmission Nashington, D.C. 20555 Karen H. Adkins, Esquire Assistant Attorney General liarbert R. Whitting, Esquira Antitrust Secticn Robert D. Hart, Esquire 30 Eas: 3 road Street Law Department 15th Ficor City Hall Columbus, Ohio 43215 Cleveland, Ohio 44114 Leslie Henry, Esquire Reuben Goldbarg, Esquire Fuller, Henry, Hodge David C. H3almfelt, Esquire & Snyder 1700 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W. 300 Madison Avenue Suite 550 Toledo, Ohio 43604 Washington, D.C. 20006

Thcmas A. Kayuha, Esq.are James B. Davis, Esquire Ohio Edison Company Robert D. Hart, Esquire 47 Ucrth Main Strae. Director of Law Akron, Ohio 443C3 City of Cleveland 213 City Hall David M. Olds, Esquira Cleveland, Ohio 44114 Reed, Smith, Shaw & . ; ; h r.;

747 Union Trust Buill;..; Lee A.Rau, Esquire Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15219 Joseph A. Rieser, Jr., Esquire Reed, Smith, Shaw & McClay Mr. Raymond Eudukis Suite 404 Director of Utilities Madiscn Building City of Cleveland Washington, D.C. 20005 1201 Lakeside Avenue Cleveland, Ohio 44114 Wallace L. Duncan, Esquire Jon T. Brown, Esq" ire D u n e - :, , O r r. n , ..einnerg

& Palmer 1700 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W.

Washingt7.f, D.C. 20006 Edward A. Matto, Esquire Assistant Attorney General Chief, Antitrust Section 30 East Broad Street

..ar n a was, Ohic 43213

^

.S :c .. Firestone

. ; ; c 1. . : Actorne General

.:itr;rt Sactica

  • 2s Eas: 3rcad Street 15th Ficor Columb-;s, Ohio 43215

'J;c t:r T . Graanslada, Jr., Esquire Principal Staff Counsel The Clevaland Electric Illuminating Company Post Office Sox 5000 Cleveland, Ohio 44101 Rchert P. Mone, Esquire George, Greek, King, McMahon

& McConnaughey Columbus Center 100 East Broad Street Columbus, Ohio 43215

- - .-.- .. .-- - - -~~~ - -

- ,