ML19329C537
| ML19329C537 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Davis Besse, Perry  |
| Issue date: | 06/19/1975 |
| From: | Coufal F Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| To: | |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8002140903 | |
| Download: ML19329C537 (12) | |
Text
-..
4
[
O a
5 =*
e UNITED STATES OF AMERICA i
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION In the Matter of
)
)
THE TOLEDO EDISON COMPANY AND
)
THE CLEVELAND ELECTRIC ILLUMINATING
)
Docket Nos.50-346A COMPANY
)
50-440A
)
50-441A (Davis-36sse Nuclear Power Station,
)
Unit 1)
)
8' y &, < ~,:,,
~
)
THE CLEVELAND ELECTRIC ILLUMINATING
)
)
Gl;-lp YA
,k N
(Perry Nuclear Pcwer Plant,
)
Units 1 and 2)
)
J g 7; g g ~; *7 -.p 3
q
-l--
- '.U
- ',C3 c
REPORT OF SPECIAL MAS]
D
/
cu ; v.-
At the direction of the Licensing Board, I have reviewed the documents produced by CEI with regard to which work pro-duct or attorney-client privilege is claimed.
l Documents listed on Attachment 1 are draft agreements, leases, letters, testimony and other papers which have received either no distribution or distribution only to other CEI attorneys.
I find those documents to be within the work product rule and privileged.
l Documents listed on Attachment 2 are communications among attorneys employed by CEI or between CEI attorneys and their consultants or between CEI officers and employers and CEI atterneys which were made for the purpose of obtaining or giving legal advice and which were intended to be 0
. 8? i " 703_M
confidential and were not distributed outside the CEI
" control group" as that term is defined in Natta against Hogan 392 F.2d 686.
I find these to be within the attorney-client rule and therefore privileged.
i i
In Attachment 3 are listed documents similar to those 1
in Attachment 2 but which have originated with and been distributed among some or all CAPCO me=bers.
Relyire on Wigmore (Mcnaughten Revision) Section 2312, I find these to be within the attorney-client privilege.
1 I' is divided into four parts each of which lists documents which I find are not privileged.
Part 1 lists documents which may have been written by or to an attorney but which are essentially reports of events, facts or circumstances which are within the knowledge of the parties or which are letters transmitting materials which may or not be privileged.
I find no intention that such information be kept confidential.
I have deleted part of documents numbered 27, 34, 88, 517, 834, 844 and 855 because the deleted parts contain i=pressions, conclusions or interpretations which are within the attorney-client privi-lege.
Part 2 lists documents not privileged because they l
originated wit'. or have been distributed to persons outside the privileged group.
Part 3 lists documents which I find i
I.
y
---w w
r
=--'
='F'
W-'
4 i l 4
to be business rather than attorney-client or work product related.
Part 4 lists documents regarding which privilege l
has been waived.
l I have not received document numbers 2129, 2158, an unnumbered document dated December 23, 1974, written by D. H. Hauser and two documents dated December 17, 1974, written by J. N. Bernosky.
O il;)t Nd t
Frederic J. Coufal '
V Dated at Bethesda, Maryland, this 19th day of June, 1975.
'}.
}
k
)
8
,--v
,_es,
..-s.
ATTAC*-DENT 1 h
C
,ff JU. _'
25 606 "i
/
40 606?
41 607 L*1-
/'
45 611 45(a) 613 46 614 47 617 49 618 50 621 56 646 61 647 64 714 65 718 66 719 71 720 73 721 73(a) 725 78 728 79 853 80 890 86 891 105 2053 109 2147 110 2161 151 2162 171 2163 186 (a) 2164 518 2165 522 2166 534 3008 593 3013 599 3014 600 3052 603
'~
c...
c-
. S.
5
/
ATTAC1 BENT 2
\\}\\
g /!Y 1
123 171 585 743 889 2051 2114 4
124 172 588 746 892 2052 2115 5
125 172 (a) 596 747 897 2054 2117 6
126 173 597 758 2001 2055 2118 7
126(a) 175 601 760 2002 2056 2119 9
126(b) 178 602 761 2004 2057 2120 10 127 179 609 762 2005 2058 2121 11 128 180 612 763 2006 2059 2121(a) 12 129 184 615 764 2007 2060 2122 i
17 130 187 616 765 2008 2061 2122(a) 18 131 188 619 767 2009 2062 2123 19 132 189 620 770 2010 2063 2124 21 133 191 622 771 2011 2064 2124(a) 22 134 192 623 772 2012 2065 2125 24 135 193 629 773 2013 2067 2125(a) 26 136 194 631 774 2014 2068 2126 28 137 195 632 775 2015 2071 2126(a) 29 138 196 633 776 2016 2072 2127 30 139 197 634 781 2017 2073 2127(a) 31 140 198 635 782 2018 2075 2123 35 141 199 650 786 2019 2076 2125(a) 36 142 200 657 789 2020 2079 2129 38 143 201 665 790 2021 2081 2129(a) 42 144 202 668 791 2022 2082 2130 77 145 203 669 796 2023 2083 2131 i
81 146 204 671 802 2024 2084 2132 84 147 205 673 803 2025 2085 2133 94 148 206 674 804 2028 2086 2134 98 149 212 675 815 2029 2087 2135 99 150 213 676 819 2030 20S8 2137 100 152 214 677 820 2031 2089 2143 101 153 215 678 823 2032 2093 2152 104 154 508 679 824 2033 2094 2153 106 155 512 680 825 2035 2095 2154 107 156 516 703 829 2036 2096 2155 108 157 519 705 831 2037 2097 2156 111 158 525 706 836 2038 2098 2157 112 159 527 707 837 2039 2099 2157(a) 113 160 532 709 840 2040 2100 3001 114 161 533 710 842 2041 2101 3021 115 162 541 711 843 2042 2102 3022 116 163 549 722 846 2044 2103 3023 117 165 553 724 863 2045 2104 3024 118 166 554 727 864 2046 2105 3025 119 167 555 733 867 2047 2107 3026 120 168 558 734 871 2048 2108 3027 121 169 566 735 877 2049 2109 3029 122 170 574 740 888 2050 2110 3031 2111 2113 l
l
ATTACIDfENT 2 CONTD.
3033 3056 3036 3057 3038 3060 3041 3061 3042 3062 3043 3063 3044 3068 3045 3071 3047 3072 3048 3073 3049 3075 3054 3078 3055 3079 l
J t
i l
\\
j ATTACIDENT 3
)
2 543 3
544 & 544 i
8 546 14 547 15 548 16 550 1
39 551 51 552 s 'p,,, g,' -
52 556 8
N 53 559 Ti~'J i
54 560 r.,
a 1
55 561 J
e 57 562 i
fiI l
58 570
..\\
ci.
J.'
4/
- a;(
s\\/
i 59 577
.N g
58 67 716 68 731 69 732 70 744 72 751 74 753 75 756 76 807 82 865 83 869 89 870 90 3004 91 3005 92 3006 93 3007 208 3009 511 3010 513 3011 514 3012 521 3015 523 3016 526 3017 530 3018 531 3019 4
535 3020 537 3030 540 3040 542 3076 i
I l
ATTACICC,~2 4 Part 1 23 750 27 752 33 754 34 755 57 757 60 766 88 769 95 793 103 798 174 799 f,. 's ' ' ' '%,
185 801
.( ;'/
s 186 821
,c/
190 827 w.
207 828 4
Vf}
209 834
-C
- b;
~~
/ri 517 844
^ ' '
524 848
- g'f) 529 852
,s 30 is 575 884 579 885 580 894 582 897 583 2066 591 2070 626 2077 630 2078 648 2079 651 2142 658 2146 66'/
2151 670 3070 717 2077 749
ATTACIDENT 4 Part 2 37 784 87 788 830 9
835 210 838 563 839 573 841 576 843 578 845 581 848 584 873 f2 '.5
' w 590 2003
- 7',
j 592 2027 624 2043
/ N'
'1 e44 2136
/ : '/
Y 653 2148
'i "9
~~
959 2150
~i
" ~" - ;
0 3028 ir, N/
)
23 3037 74 3039 A
Y 74 757
ATTACEMENT 4 Part 3 31(a) 847 32 2080 48 2083 182 2106 183 2112 183 2138 216 2139 217 2140 218 2141 587 2144 625 3003 642 3034 644 3035
' 645 3046 741 3050 766 3058 769 3059 ew 817 3064
'?,/. MQ,s
,[
S 821 3065
' '.)\\
822 3066
/
826 3067 832 3074 a
?i ni y y c
sei
's
.\\
,/s.
' Q J, 3 ' 5, /
- 0.,,
O#f g
=
ATTACEENT 4 Part 4 176 854 713 893
. N m)-Mh
\\/
I/ \\
N N \\
- Ly
,i
\\ :.
7-lI l 6.*
~
%e 4 e.,.
y c-
. r
\\
\\
Le_
.i
'4
,/
(*
n v 4,, %,/. i
~
_,,q,r/
m
,{-If# ]S
~
~
U::IT".D 5;
- TT.S
' ' A:',:CA
!!CCLEAR RECULATC:'7 CC:J:ISSIO:;
In P :.tter of
)
)
TOLE:0 EDISO:I CO::PANY, ET AL
)
Docket ::o.(s) 50-3'6A (Cavis-Besse Nuclear Power
)
50-4a0A Station, Cnit 1)
)
50-441A (CLE'JELANO ELEZRIC I'fE4I:GTI. ' )
)
(Perry Nuclear Power Plant,
)
Units 1 and 3
)
SERVICE LIST I hereby certify 3;.t; topies of REPORT OF SPECIAL MASTER dated June 19, 1975 in the captioned matter have been served on the folicwing by deposit in the United States mail, first class or air rail, -his 20th day of June 1975:
Douglas Rigler, Esq., Chairman Gerald Charnoff, Esq.
Foley, Lardner, Hollabaugh Shaw, Pittman, Potts, Trowbridge and Jacobs and Madden 815 Connecticut Avenue, N. W.
910 - 17th Street, ':
W.
Washington, D. C.
20006 Washington, D. C.
20006 John H. 3rebbia, Esa.
Donald H. Hauser, Esq., Managing Atomic Safety and Licensing 3 card Attorney Alston, Miller & Gaines Cleveland Electric Illumin. ting 1776 K Street, N. W.
Company Washington, D. C.
20005 Publir Square Cleveland, Ohio 44101 John M. Frysiak, Esq.
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Reuben Goldberg, Esq.
U. S.Nuclea r Regulatory Co= mis s ion Arnold Fieldman, Esq.
Washington, D. C.
20555 1700 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.
W.
Washington, D. C.
20CC6 Steven M. Charno, Esq.
Melvin G. Berger, Esq.
Pe ey Public Library Antitrust Divisien 3/33 Main Street U. S. Department of Justice Perry, Ohio 400S1 Washington, D. C.
20530 Director Ida Rupp Public Library Port Clinton, Ohio 43452 h{f Of (
3 f'sh ~f y' i
bec:
Mr. Rigler
~ ~-
T Of fice,ott the Secretary or the Cc=mtssim Mr. Rutberg f
Mr. Braitaan L3g;. Files ASLAB ASL3P
..~
s