ML19329B373
| ML19329B373 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Davis Besse  |
| Issue date: | 08/19/1975 |
| From: | Moore V Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Harold Denton, Maccary R, Stello V, Tedesco R Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8002040790 | |
| Download: ML19329B373 (1) | |
Text
l f'
D c
P ;] hL ee V. Stello, Assistant Director for Reactor Safety R. Tedesco, Assistant Director for Containment Safety R. Maccary, Assistant Director for Engineering H. Denton, Assistant Dimetor for Site Safety 60-3 %
DAVIS-BESSE UNITS 2 AND 3 - STAFF FIVIEW 0F PARTICULAR AREAS REGARDING REPLICATION 14, 1975 (Enclosure '
Sumary of Meeting) Held on August
Reference:
to this Memorandum As a result of the referenced meeting with the applicant, ?ir. Rusche has dincted the staff to meet as soon as possible with the aoolicant to discuss certain design considerations that the applicant contends could jeopardize his efforts to replicate Unit 1.
In order to carry out Mr. Rusche's directive, we have set a meeting date of September 3,1975 in Room 372, East West Towers. At this meeting the applicant will present his justification for the design's not meeting staff positions as evidenced by our Qls and 02s, and will address the reasons why he believes the proposed design is adequate. The staff l
should be prepared not only to point out the staff's positions and how the design does not satisfy them but also to orement the bases upon which the positions have been developed; i.e., the ba<.,round reasons why the staff considers these factors to be of significant concern to safety.
The staff should be prepared to evaluate the acolicant's oroposals by considering the equivalence in safety between the procosed design and the means the staff would normally consider acceptable.
l Also enclosed, besides the referenced meeting summary, is a list of l
the applicant's items of concern. For each item there is a brief l
descriotion of the problem and a listing of the staff's questions l
that are pertinent.
So that as much as possible can be accomplished at this meeting, I ask that your Davis-Besse reviewers refamiliarize themselves with the application and be prepared for detailed discussion of their areas of concern.
If the reviewer is not familiar with the historical background of the contested positions, I suggest you considor having l
the branch chief, or other senior member familiar with the background, attend the meeting.
The LPH, Bob Benedict, will set up a timing for the agenda so that reviewers will know when their subjects will be addressed.
l 8 0 02 0 4 0~l4i0
e-g W,
r
- Please let me knm as soon as possible if there are any matters that will conflict with the scheduling of this meetir..,.
Voss A. Moore, Assistant Director for Light Water Reactors, Group 2 Division of Reactor Licensing
Enclosures:
1.
iteeting Sumary 2.
List of Areas of Concern for Replication ecs w/ enclosures:
B. Grimes J. Knight L. Shao V. Benarcya G. Lainas J. Collins J. Kastner T. Ippolito T. !!ovak S. Pawlicki F. Schroeder R. Boyd W. Rutherford V. floonan K. Kapur R. Kirkwood DISTRIBUTIO!!:
R. Woods R. Boyd K. Kniel P. Atherton R. Benedict J. Shapaker A. Ungaro LWR 2-2 Reading F. Cardile Docket file C. Ferrell J. Potter K. Kniel R. Benedict L. Engle LWR 2-2 d. LWR 2-2[-
WR-pf-
_g#foo re____
t
'e.-
RBenedict:ng KKnie L _
Y
.... - =. -
i 8/19/75 _
. 8/ /9 /75 -. _8/-,ld/75 -
~ '
- e....v==~'-v~v'-.'e=.'a-*=='==
pic.ne imo.,.s>> Amos o24o
-,