ML19329A531

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Redacted Transmittal Letter Dated July 29, 2019 - RAI Response, Renewal, Model No. F-431
ML19329A531
Person / Time
Site: 07109310
Issue date: 07/29/2019
From: Soleimani M
Best Theratronics, Ltd
To:
Document Control Desk, Division of Spent Fuel Management
Garcia-Santos N
References
Download: ML19329A531 (7)
v • d • e


Text

fle5t~

Thetatronlcs*

. * : Director; Division of SpentFuel Man~gement * *.

  • *. Office of Nµclear Ma~erials Safety* & ~.afeguards

..' *: U.S. Nucteat.Rt:1gulatory Cqnimi~si6n : *

. * :.'. :* :. : : : ~r.-... :

?/ __

6 /

.. ** t:f *-:-:. : *

  • .. **.-Washington,; 1lC;~05$5-0001 *

Attn*:. Document Control Desk : :

S_ubj~ct:J~equest for lriformailori.(R~oewal of Model _No.. 9310).

413fvb:irch Road*..

Ottawa,' Ontario :

Cana~a K2K OE4 *..
  • .. r~1:a13:.591~2to9.

. July 2~.- 2Q19 :

.

  • Reier~nces;... :Girci~ *san'ios:: N9ntia;. ~Re:.. Request for_infomiaticin:* Re'r!ewar ~f.Mc:id_ei *No: F431 :* EiiJ~ii=.

. *. :n:iessage:to: Edna sacay: 14:June 2019.. * -

  • This i~tter-i1fi11*re$ponseto-y9ur:requestf6r infc>rmation datecfJµne 14. 2019* reg,;1ri:llng the Glarificatfcin-~nd..
. : missing 'iiJfo_rrilation within the F431*.consolidat~d renewal appiicatiort The ~afety: f.nalysis R~port for -tli~.F.-. *

...43.1. Transport Package, INfTR l913 F.:431, h1:1s bEien re~ised to version D, whe~e ti)~ infor:r'l)ation de$Cribed

  • below has beer:r incorporated. Enclosed are brio copies of the* IN/rR 1913 F:431.document, one proprietary
  • and one non:.prcipnetary: An affidavit accompanies ttiis wntten r~sponse requesting to withlio1d: parts M toe * *

. INffR 1913 f-431.d(icu_ment,: including drawings containing.propr:ietary informatio_n; from~i.Jblic disc.losure: *. *

The revi_siohs to th~ SAR tjocumentare sta~ed.belo:w: Th~ response follows in the ~~n:ie founat ~s th~ email':.*.

received from I\\Jls: Garcia: :

1;.IVIL0419'7.0402:(April 16,2:qo4}.:.

.. a:** co~sqlidate.*d applicati9.n c1a~ficati~n: * *

  • i.-... Item 2.4,_: pieas~: see *drawing F64~101~*oo(sheet :1 of2 (lefttop)~ T:he warning

.ii.- :. '

' statement is visibly painted-on the:top of the transport package,

  • item. 2.6 :... The ASTM A193,.Gr. B8 bolts are referred to *j1:r Pimi 2:6.4.:t And...

again they are*11sted in.thedrawin1iF64$101*-oq1; -~heet.1 df 2 a~ it~m 19...

Re.lated hex. nuts ASTM A194,J3rade.8; Class 2 are li_l5fed in' the drawing*

F643101-001;_Sheet.1.of:2as*i_tem20 *. :...

iii.

Dr:awll'.19 is to read FB43101-00.1. The se~tioh 7 :2 contains now: the detailed

  • :
  • listing for p'rep13nng GC-1 OP/300(J' for shipment and therrefere,:rice tq IN/OS 1 Bl;lt.. *

. :i:'431:was* removed. O.n. the drawing F643101-00.1, Rev'Kthe Note 8 is still. * *.

  • . reievarit~na notto be remmiecL....

. IJ; *. Table 4.2 ~as update*cifroni 2004 _to-inc!~de th~* cu,ren:tly: inanuf~cfur~ci :anp used CS 1:QO *

.. spi.ir'ce iliodei.: '

' G.: 'The tQtal rna:Ximl!m activity of.the gimma cell, sourca*models t;-3000:and C:3001 are * '

  • .... : 113. TBq; which has been updated.from revisi9ti C.
2;

.ML0420_40293 (J~ly:16;.2004) ::.

. This letter *wa~ to. advise the USNRC abciufthe inorEiase ir1 ~olt length for. two. USN~C registered :

. traiispQrt pac;:kages: F-4;30 & F0431. DWG No. *e4:'3001.:.oo'HSheet 1, Revisi9_n.Kand :sheet 2,...* *

F<evision D)was n9t incl_uded in:ttie_colisolidated:application.as it contains information qrrthe F'.": *.

430 tran$porf package onl{ Re.levant inforn1aticin* pert~{ning ~p th~ F-431: fran$port: pontai!ier:is : :.

provid~dinbW.Gl\\lo; 643101~001:.

  • : 3;..'.fli1L0420802:84:.(July 21; 20.04):..
  • The "Assessment of the. F.430 Tie-Down. Collar: Baited :Connection'; calculation,has been added to**
  • the S_ A. Ras_* :S_edion.2A.~ an_ d Appendix.* _2. 10._8. *. :..

-7* 0.

  • }J~?(~: :

.

  • Page 1 ofi.

').

    • *

.. *. Th*e "Assessment of the* F~43*o:tie-Dowrt Colla"r Bolted* Connection'; calcuiation has been added :to

.

  • th.e -~AR:as :sectiOrJ 2.:4.. q ancl Appendi~ 2.:10._lt.*. *

. : 5,. ML11308A474 (Octo_ber. 2:1, 2011) *

. Fig, H )\\1ain C_omp~ri~nt!,.in.iNrrR*1~13 SAR has bee~ r~pia*ced vyith" p_ages_4 and 5-from INffR

  • *: 6087 and ate n.amed.1.fa arid.1, 1b.:No.affi~av,Us ietjuired. : *. *
  • 6. * -* ML16224A932 J.Ml1.6224A9~.o (Feb t5,/012): *.*. *

. :

  • fig:.1.1 *Main Gomponer:its in:IN/TR 191*3:SAR:has*l::le.eh replaced with p"ages 4 and:5frorn IN/TR *
  • 608i and are nam_ed L1 a anch.1b, No affida\\'.it isrequired, :

_* 1: :* MP20790138.(M~r9; 2012)-:

. The Suppl~"menta~ SAR to_~ the.F430 :Transport Package INirR 6088 F430.(CJ.has be~ri added _to the Appeindix 2.10.3:urider 2.10.3J:>: Ali refere_n_ces in* 1NtrR 11J13:to APPEi°ndix 2;10.3 has been..

  • changed to Appendices 2.10;3a and 2.10;3b._ : :

. *. ::8. *. ML15198A208 (ML 1~181A090.(Jurie. 8.,.20:15)::

.*...

  • Appendix_ 5.5: f has been. eidded_to include the :cu.n:ent Registry of ~adioactiiie Seale.cf Sources i:iric:i :

.* oe"ices _N_o. NR~1301~t-Ft92~s; dated:MaY:15;. 201s.:

  • . : 9.. : As per:C(mditiqri 5.(a)(3), _"DraVl(irigs;"'Revision 6; :of the.Coe for the:Model No. ~~431: includes qri :

... Drawing :No. F643101~001; Sheet 1; R.evisi~n J,:and Sh"e~t 2,: Revision E. These drawings ate : *.

  • *. enclosed arid no affidavit required; Updates _between* the revisio"ris ar~* described below:

. a.. F643t01-00f stieeH qf2: From Rev} J.to k :..,_Therel was no design changElfrom Rev.) t6

K. The change ih revisiortis* orily to.refle1,tchange to revisiorfotthe sh.eet 2 of 2*.
  • Please.
  • see small t~ble "Revision Stc1tos*:* on the bottoiTr oftiie drawing.: -*...
  • h.

F643101~00f sheet 2 of 2: From Rev. E*to F -"Revision frorri E to F was fo introduce. *

  • improvement arid.standardization to the plywood bracing. construction, The same bracing.: -- *
  • can* be useMor unit with or units without 8dditiona1 ~ecurity feature:.* * * -* *
  • Thank you :tor y~ur consideration ~ii this ~~tter. If you have.~ny f~ither_qoesticins ple~se contact m~ atthe *

. * *: *information bel_ow, dr Edna Sacay at edna.sac~y@thertar~nics.ca: *.

. : : Mojgan.Soleimani

  • .
  • Director ofQuality & Regulato"ry Affairs; RSO * : *

- Phone: 613~591-2100 x2766

E.nclosures: : :. : **:... * *_ *:... :.

. 1::

  • ll'!ffR 1913.F-431 (0), July 24, 2019.:.:F~431 Transport Package SafetyAncilysisReport.;,:

Proprietary Information _ *.. *..

  • 2. _*. IN/TR 19t3Fa431 (0.), July 24; 2019.:.: F~43tTransport:Pac~age Safety:Analysis Report-:-: Non:.

. proprietary Information.. * *

3 *.

.. 4:.* Orawing No,.F643~01~001, Sheet 1, Revision J. :_.*

- 5.. Drf;lwin.g.No,:Fp431Q~~OOL She.~f.2,-Rev:isi_on E.:

.

  • page 2 of2..

/

        • ~*:

t*.¥.ID:*

-e~

  • Theratronics:::

413 M.:1rch Road Ottaw.i:l; :Ontario Canada K2K OE4. * *

  • Tel.: 613-591-21.0P:: :*.

. Affidavit iflj~µpport of )'Vi\\h.holding llflfe>rrnation t:rorrf public

    • Disclosure: Request

.. LYictor Moga, the uncl~r~igned, being duly. iW.orn, hereby makeJh:eJollowing staterrients in conformanc'?:.:..

with the proyisions of 10 CFR 2.3QO:.. *.

  • 1 :: *
  • 1 am*over the c;ige of 18 and am a r~$iderit of Ottawa; Obt;:i.rio Canada. I havS: personal knowledge::. **.
: : : :. : : of the facts.h.ereih:and I suffer nq legal.. Qipabilities.
2.

I am:the Manager of Tectmlcal Services for Best Theratronics Ltd) and: in this role I arn auihor:ized

. : :. : : to review the information provided and make these statements.

3. Best theratronics is providin{rthe USN RC: documents in support of a Request for Renewal of USN RC.Certificate of. Compliance USA/93101B(Uk96 (Certificate Noi 9.3:1 o, expiring June 30;
  • 2019) and the Jisted sections, aii per attachment, corifaio information that shou id he withheld trbni.:
public 9isclosure:
4. Best Thetatronics Ltd.. is.the owner of these.doct.iments.
  • 5;. : The basis for this :withholding request:is that the inform.iltioh contained within.th~ documents is.

pro.prietaiy and comrilerdal. confidential. The. doc.urnents provide in:di:lpth manufactLlring.and:

ser:\\/icing inforrnati.on pertaining t_o products s*old:by B~s.t _Theratronics. AtlcliU_onally, docunierit I_Ds...

. **denoted with an asterisk are considered security related information, based on content revealing..

. : acc~ss to source: dr'avv~r~ an_d _detc\\.iled dravVi11gs..
6.. These: dcicu_m_e_nts. are held :in corifidence. by Best :Theratron.ics Ltd. :and has peen. transmitted to.....
  • and received by the United States Nuqlear Regulatory Commission in con'fidenqe. * *
7. Docun:ierit contents are nof available through_ pu,blic means. Documehts are only provic;led:to Best

. Theratronics;'.subc:ontracts and r~glJlator$ on: an as~ne.ede.d. basis.. : : *

  • *
  • 8;.
  • Rel.e.a.se of the docurr:ientP to tbe public coulcl Jes.1,1lt in commercial bc:lOJl.to Best:Tlierc;ttroniqs _for.:

the. following reasons:*

. : a. * * :Bes;t Theratronics has :sp_ent considerable funding. qn <;:Jeveloping the. products and*:.:*

serviqing procedures, *

. I;). _Pµblic release.of.tbe information' would PJOVide:cornPetiton, in:;;ide-knowledge to Se.st Theratronics'* prod0cts* and servicing procedures, and

..

  • c. * :Bes;t Theratronics currently.h.old$ the majority.mark.et share within.thi$ specific product..

area an~ :could lose that*competitive advantage if t}Je information contai)Jed within the

.documents is. publicJy available........

.9... The information.contained in this. aff.idavi_t is to=thebest of my_knowledge tr.uean<;:J correct.**:.: **

sWO,~ bOiore me this: ~3 d~~y:of_:_. *_* --J-1-11-,1J..,

0....

Lo""":

1

_. __, 2019. i~ the *CitY; ?f l?tta~a*, ;~~a~ib, Canada.

/

.()uJi/, cJiri fr1Vlper.

    • victor I.:.

Ma er of Technical Services

  • *. Best Theratronics Ltd..
  • Information to be Withheld from Public Disclosure Listed below are the relevant sections to be withheld from public disclosure and are blacked-out in or removed from the non-proprietary copy of IN/fR 1913 F-431 document:

IN/TR 1913 F-431 approval signatures Appendix 2.10.5 title Section 3.3.2 title Appendix 3.7.3 title Section 1.2.1-information related to the detailed construction of the overpack, including the use of polyurethane foam Section 1.2.2 - information related to the detailed construction of the overpack Figure 1.1-Drawing detailing the construction of the container and contents Figure 1.2 - Drawing detailing the construction of the container and contents Appendix 1.3.1 - Specification sheet removed Appendix i.3.2 - Referenced engineering drawing removed Section 2.1.1-Various areas detailing the structural components Sections 2.1.2.2.1 and 2.1.2.2.2 - Information related to brittle fracture and fatigue Section 2.3, including Table 2.1-Information related to material components used in construction of container

  • Figure 2.1 Section 2.4.1 Section 2.4.2 - Number and type of fasteners Section 2.5.1-Information related to the yield stres~ of the stainless steel and safety factor Sections 2.6.4.2 and 2.6.4.3 Table 2.3 - Number and type of fasteners Section 2.7.1.4-Information regarding foam crush Section 2.7.1.5-Information regarding G'*s and deceleration Section 2.7.2 - Information related to tearing of the outer skin and the polyurethane foam Section 2.7.3 - Information related to the foam, foam compression, and its ability to provide therma.1 protection Section 2.7.4-Justification number 1 Section 2.10-Appendix 2.10.5 title Reference number [7] blacked out
  • ' Section 3.1-Packages components Section 3.2 - Specific stress values and the type and yield strength of the bolts Section 3.3 -Yield strength of the 304L stainless steel Section 5 - Yield strength information IN/TR 1691 GC3000 (1) referenced in Appendix 2.10.4:

o Figures 1, 2, 6 -17 o

All pictures in Appendix E o

Appendix F, pages 1 and 2 of 3 page engineering drawing removed Appendix 2.10.5 - Title and entire appendix removed Section 3.2 - Information regarding Stainless steel and its sheer strength Section 3.2.1-Information regarding welds and stresses 2/3

'}

0,.

Section 3.2.2 - Information regarding shear stress Sections 3.3 and 3.4 Sections 3.5.1-3.5.3 Section 3.6 Table A2.10.7-1 Figure A2.10.7-1-Two components Figure A2.10.7-2 Section 3.1.1 Table 3.1 - Specific information Section 3.3.2 Table 3.2 - Partially Section 3.4.1.2 - Last two paragraphs Section 3.4.6 - Temperature sensitive materials Section 3.5.1.1-Last two paragraphs Section 3.5.1.2 - Last two paragraphs Section 3.5.2 Table 3.3 - Entire table and detail about thermal conductivity of crushed foam Section 3.5.4 - Second paragraph Section 3.5.5 - Reference to ductility of SS type 304L Section 3.6 - Reference [3]

.Section 3.7 -Appendix 3.7.3 title Appendix 3.7.3 -Title and entire Appendix removed C-1001 Special Form Certificate C-3001 Special Form Certificate C-1001 Sealed Source Test Certificate C-3001 Sealed Source Test Certificate Section 7.3 - Number and type offasteners Figure 7.1 Section 7.4.2 - Number and type of fasteners Section 7.5 - Type and torque value of fasteners Section 8.1.4.3 - Entire paragraph Section 8.1.6 - Last sentence regarding polyurethane foam Appendices 9.3.2 and 9.3.3 -All contents removed 3/3

Security-Related Information Figure Withheld Under 10 CFR 2.390

Security-Related Information Figure Withheld Under 10 CFR 2.390

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML19329A531&oldid=4756276"