ML19326A847

Memorandum & Order Denying Licensee Motion Requesting AEC to Amend 720412 Memorandum & Order & Notice of Hearing. Certificate of Svc Encl

ML19326A847
Person / Time
Site:	Davis Besse
Issue date:	05/02/1972
From:	Mccool W US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC)
To:	TOLEDO EDISON CO.
Shared Package
ML19326A843	List: ML19326A842 ML19326A847
References
NUDOCS 8003050753
Download: ML19326A847 (4)

Text

.. -

D! MET NUMBER

<W

/

PROD. & UTJL FAC, } o. 7&I 50;Kir,a g

. O UMi'

~

j MAY,'?

3725 S

,l cy. t *s. c-m r;

,V i N4 Jr On Apr!) 21, 1972, The Toledo Edison Company and The Cleveland Electric ;

liluminating Company (licensees) filed a motion requesting the Commission to amend its Memorandum and Order and Notice of Hearing dated April 12, 1972.

The motion requests the Commission "to require a factual denon-stration that Coalition and LIFE are in existence, that there is adequate authority to represent their purported membership, that they have actuall.y suffered an injury, and a particularization of the matters they seek to controvert in the forthcorning proceeding." The regulatory, staff, and the i

j.

Intervenors have replied.

Under 10 CFR 52.730, all. motions shall be addressed to the presiding Atomic Safety and Licensing Board in a proceeding which is pending before it.

Thus, although addressed to the Conmission, the motion should be before the. Licensing Board, in view, however, of the necessity for e

9 e

e--

4 eo os osc 753

P e

2 expedited action to comply with the requirements laid down by the c

Court of Appeals in Coalition for Safe Nuclear Power v. U.S.A.E.C.,

D.C. Cir., No. 71-1396, we will consider that question directly without consuming additional time by directing certification to us.

W'e read the above decision of the Court of Appeals as authorizing Coalition and LIFE to be parties to the show-cause proceeding. Accord-ingly, the licensees' motion in that regard is denied.

The licensees' request that Coalition and LIFE particularize the matters they seek to controvert in the forthcoming proceeding is entirely appropriate for considerition by the Licensing Board. We have emphasized i

on several occasions the importance of establishing, on as timely a basis as possible, a clear and particularized identification of those matters i

which are in controversy. This is especially significant where, as here, the proceeding must be conducted with utmost expedition.

Wb have no doubt tha't the Licensing Board will direct such particularization.

\\

UNITED STATES ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION By:

W. 8. McCool Secretary of the Commission Dated at Germantown, Maryland

~

this 2nd day of May

, 1972.

o

... ~

' ~'

~

. y,; y j,,, y g(,

cTtM 1; +i? CNIfl!TMI.

1 3

-In tb-matter r f:)

bcch t :.c. t.;-jl4

)

TO] iGC' hD1:1IlCO.)

' g, j' 7'2 eV CFhTIFICf.TE CP SEdVICE

_ I:Icieby certify thnt ccpies of the-Honrd's I;OTICE AIG ObDMg H+

EV]Dh!JTJ ARY IfELh1NG ivaued f.pril P1, J 972, in ile abcVe cantir ra

.i natter, t.ere served en the follcuing by deocsit in tle U. S. Mai)

~

or first class niil this'21st day of April, 3972:

1 4

i

.Jeroco Garfinkel, Esq., Chairman Dr. Joi n,-

h. Iynan

+

l Atemic. Safety and Licensing Beard bent. of Environmenta] Science:

U. S. Atcmic Energy. Commission and En;-inecring washington, D. C.

20$h$ -

University of Nert).-Carolina Chapel hill, horth Carolina-P75]l; Dr. Emmoth n luebke

-_610 Foxen Drive :

Donald li. liauser, Esq.

~

Santa Barbara, Calif. 93105 The Cleveland tlectric Illuminating Co.

Joseph Scinto, Esq.

P. O. dox $000 n6gulatory Staff Counsel.

C]eveland, 0 hic hh101 U. S. Atenic Energy Commission Washington, D. C.

20$h$

Gerald Charnoff, Laq.

e Shaw, Pittman, Potts & Trowbridre

-Leslie Henry, Esq.

910 17th Street, N....

Fuller, Seney, Henry & Hodge Kashincten, D. C.

20006 800 Owens-Dlincis BJ dg.

LOS Madisen Ave.

Mr. Glenn J. Samnson, Vice Toledo, Ohio 'h360h President, Power

'Ihe Toledo Ediscn Co.

= Russell Z..Baren, Esq.

h20 Madisen tve.

Brannen, Ticktin, Baron & E ncini Tolede, Ohio h3601 930 Ecith Building l ~ '

Cleveland, Ohio-hh10$

James 1. Enir.ht, Esq 633 Naticna3 dank '3de.

Mrs. Evelyn Stebbins, Chairman Toledo, Ohic-h360h Coa]ition for Srfe Nuclear Power 705 Elmwood hoad tir. Glenn 11.: Lau hocky River, Ohio ~ hh116 ht. 1, Box 326 Oak Harbor, Ohio h3hh9.

U hiss Vicki Evsns L.I.F.E.

Beatrice K. Bleicher, Esq.

1

' Box-15, University liall Coburn, Smith, Rchrbacher & Gibson Bowling Green Universitf 7th Floor, Tolede Trust' Blog.

Bowling Green, Ohio h3h03' Toledo, Ohio h360h l-

'1 f

E 4

4

.-4e--

"- * - = -"

^"

,n

..n..

m -

, -, -,- ~

I

_p A rt u.e c. halu r, t.a ri.

Hr. itogc r.:.. i]liarm

.Jamir.cn, Ulrich, burkhalter & hester n t.cr.ic r.nerry C( orci r.< tcr lh25' l..;tional City Bank dlag.

Mat e rf Chic icvele ment Leat.

CJ evej and, Ot.io hhllh 65. < u tt. Frcnt otrett e.s.. ::ox 3 Col r.r. s.illian U.

vnlker, Directcr Co3 unt.uc, Ohic h3; 3 S 1A:oartnant of Indurtrisl belatienc crno]d, H. D.

89] Ohi c, Dont. dri3 0ing

r....

Cc]unbus, Ohic h321$

virector c r !!ealth L hic Dent. of licalth 1:ont r. b]c l'eul.'. drown ht,'u Lart Tovn.treet ttr rney leneral, atete of C hio Cc]umbus, 0Lio hPP]6 J tt,t.c 1: cure cmnex C o] u.nt on, Ohio h3P]5 Envirena rtal "rrtr'etion Frency 1 cdr ; al, e t,4 vi t,iec

r., i< con 3 03 Ur nci a:.lc..i]li m c' erd arrineten, D.

0?h2 reistant 'tterney.leneral Jta'e cf lancas

?r neka, I ar: ;c, 66612

. ~ ^)

_, ;,- f

( A1,)*

y (.4l ((X/.

k Office of the Secretary H c

cc:

Valerio r.ilson v(iigu]attry Files we)] c Yore derfink3c

~.

%..