ML19323D537

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Revises Response to IE Bulletin 79-17, Pipe Cracks in Stagnant Borated Water Sys at PWR Plants. Due to Limited Physical Accessibility,Util Will Delete Six Welds from Examination Program
ML19323D537
Person / Time
Site: Davis Besse Cleveland Electric icon.png
Issue date: 04/29/1980
From: Crouse R
TOLEDO EDISON CO.
To: James Keppler
NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III)
References
IEB-79-17, NUDOCS 8005210650
Download: ML19323D537 (5)


Text

.

8005210 6 9 Q

s%

E""* Q TOLEDOggg JE April 29, 1980 Docket No.

50-346 Aouno P. Cnoun License NJ.

NPF-3 EllJ7" 14191253 5221 Serial No. 1-127 Mr. James G. Keppler Regional Director, Region III Office of Inspection and Enforcement U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 799 Roosvelt Road Glen Ellyn, Illinois 60137

Dear Mr. Keppler:

This letter is to identify a revision in Toledo Edison's response to NRC IE Bulletin 79-17, dated November 28, 1979 (Serial No.

1-106).

Page 2 of the response states "UT cxamination will be performed on twenty welds in thick wall piping which is part of normally accessible portions of systems....

This represents a twenty-four (24) percent sample and exceeds the requirements of paragraph 2(b) of IE Bulletin 79-17."

Due to limited physical accessibility at the Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station Unit I we are deleting six welds from the examination program.

By doing so, Toledo Edi will still exceed the ten (10) percent sample requirement of the bullet.. and remain in conformance with its specified requirements. Attached is a listing of the specific welds being deleted.

Yours very truly, k

(

RPC:TWH Attachments bt b/3 NAY 2 - 1089 THE TOLEOO EOISON COMPANY EOISON PLAZA 300 MAOISON AVENUE TOLEDO. OHIO 43652 I

8005210 oN

/

j'e Date /,['/ 7 Prepared 15y _

ACCESSIBLE PIPING WELDS FOR IE BULLETIN 79-17 Page 2 of 5 -

NONDESIRUCTIVE EXAMINATION-

'r,! ate /#~ b 7 ggf. /M" DAVIS-BESSE NUCLEAR POWER STATIO:!

DRAWItJG NO.

M-033

[-[

Reviewed DJf' dD

.[ l z Oh UNIT NO. 1 SYSTEM liigh Pressure Injection System CLASS 2

LIllE DESCitIPTIO!1 From liigh Pressure Injection Pump P58-1 to !!P2C and !!P2D, excluding full flow test line LINE Ir1FORMATIOff WELD INFORMATION o.

p.

m o

o Carbon o

o g

g g

!'"55.!'J.-

-!^ $S 5 '$

'a 8 e

e t,o Number 58 5

g o n. -

a8-3S-H o4 H U W

D.

Z 3 Z w

4"CCD-2 ATM Arm

.437 233D 11 - 8 33C-CCD-2-6A A

P-E

.051/.052

&6B FW6A E-P

.051/.052 C

P-E

.051/.052 FW7 E-T

.051/.06 Ultrasonic Test, ladder needed l1 33C-CCB-2-5 A

T-R 051/.06 2 "CCB-2 ATM Nil:

.375 233D G-5 33C-CCB-2-5 C

R-P

.051/.061 FW8 P-E

.061/.065 Ultrasonic Test, scaffold needed 33C-CCB-2-4 A

E-P

.061/ 065 Ultrasonic Test, scaffold needed C

P-E 061/.065 D

E-P

.061/ 065 E

P-E

.061/.065 F

E-P

.061/.065 FW9 P-E

.061/.065 Ultrasonic Test, scaffold needed e

s

Prepared By Dateh!',/'

~

ACCESSIBLE PIPItIG WELDS FOR IE BULLETIti 79-17 Page 4 of

'3-NOt1 DESTRUCTIVE EXAMIriATIO!

I.[Date//-[*7 (127, W[f/7[

DAVIS-DESSE IJUCLEAR POWER STATIO!!

DRAWItiG NO.

M-033 Riviewed Hyl,-._t'

/. -

J UNIT NO. 1 SYSTEM Iligh Pressure Injection System CLASS LINC DESCHIPTION Prom Iligh Pressure Injection' Pump P58-1 to llP2C and !!P2D, excluding full flow test line LIllE INFORMATION WELD INFORMATION y

g Carbon m

u o

o o

2 u

u 5mU.S.

.5.

U O

$ <d Content

,a o

w mH e+

H u E

eu o

o e

o A

Number 0 i k

O A. ~

Q E4 3

E-*

H oA H U (4

A.

Z 3 Z 2 "CCB-2 ATM Arta

.375 233D G-5 33C-CCD-2-10 FWll K-P

.061+

D P-E

.061/.065 C

E-P

.061/.065 Ultrasonic Test, scaffold needed A

P-E

.061/.065 B

E-P

.061/.065 W12 P-V

.061+

Ultrasonic Test l1 33C-CCB-2-5 B

T -P

.06/.061 From Tee to IIP 2C FW15 P-K

.061+

~

e 9

e Prepared Dy Date.

[77 ACCESSIBLE PIPING WELDS FOR IE BULLETIN 79-17 Page 5 of 5-NONDESTRUCTIVE EXAMINATION

[ReviewedDyl

[h.

?.. - M. Date // 'I-7[,,,

,j}f[jp DAVIS-DESSE NUCLEAR POWER STATION DRAWING NO.

M-033 UNIT NO. 1 SYSTEM Iligh Pressure Injection System CLASS 2

LINE DESCRIPTION Prom Iligh Pressure Injection Pump P58-1 to !!P2C and flP2D, excluding full flow test line I:

LINE It1FOlu1ATION WELD INFORMATION g-p*

.m o

u-Carbon o

o m

,4

,4

'l O

k4 e

kt c - --

c c

u o

v Content wmo o' -

x e.

o a

v *o

  • A o

--i m H

~4

0. -

.9 o.

E ew u

'o e

mom m

N

< 4 -* c o

M oo o

-4 c.

- (Percent)

Remarks

' Number 0 44 0

o d.C H mkM M o

~< o e o am-ce-as-H oW HU M A Z 3 Z e,

2 "CCB-2 ATM AMD

.375 233D G-5 33C-CCD-2-2 FW16 K-P

.061+

Ultrasonic Test A

P-E

.061/.065 Ultrasonic Test i

s 1

B E-P

.061/.065 C

P-E

.061/.C65 Ultrasonic Test

(

D E-P

.061/.065 Ultrasonic Test l1 FW17 P-V

.061+

4 9

83

=.

I

, g

  • i P

9 O

1 m

ce,

t me g

,I

~

+4-f -

%, e e

e O

9

,p E

e s-e p

9

[.';db.%.::t ' :[ 'ib. {? ? '" V7'y'.': / ' %.: ?'n?1-Q'? 'j,::Y '~-lql.Y:,':n :-l

  • '_r' g

g g

g.

M

e,

' !'. ' ' ' /'

Pr pared By Date

/

ACCESSIBLE PIPING WELDS FOR IE BULLETIN 79-17 Page 2 of 3-NONDESTRUCTIVE EXAMINATION ReviewedDy(',t Date //- I' N DAVIS-BESSE NUCLEAR POWER STATION DRAWING NO. M-033 I'l '

72 UNIT NO. 1 SYSTEM liigh Pressure Injection System CLASS 2

LINE bESCRIPTION rre a liigh Pressure Injection Pump P58-2 to IIP 2A and IIP 2B,. excluding full flow test line LIllE IllFOIUMTION

. WELD INFORMATION A

o.

m o

o Carbon a

o

.m

,4 QJ k

54

$mU S.

5-

$ $d Content a e r4 mH i

O. -

e-4 0

  • E E 44 o u

'O e

f h.

?-

Nwnber e

5, f

r end R m rks a

oA-ce-38-H oN H Q W A Z 3 Z

.J.

4*CCB-2 ATM Af18

.437 233D E-10 33C-CCD-2-12 A'

P-E

.051/.052 B

E-P

.051/.052 C

P-E

.052/.053 D

E-P

.052/.053 l

FW32 P-T

.052/.060 Ultrasonic Test 33C-CCB-2-15 4 A T-R

.051/.060 Ultrasonic Test k

2 "CCB-2 ATM Alla '

.375 233D C-9 33C-CCB-2-15.I B R-P

.051/.061 Ultrasonic Test, scaffolding needed';

C P-E

.061/.065 D

E-P'

.061/.065 Ultrasonic Test E

P-E

.061/.065 Insulation Covers Pipe F

E-P

.061/.065 Insulation Covers Pipe FW38 P-K

.061+

Insulation Covers Pipe f

1a I

.rl c

.r c.

' ' ~

  • I'

.,, [.,,J;..,. /,

.,i,-

S

~,

, : l.'

,. r, '.. t '

't U.:

,, g,... %..

~-

-