ML19323C975
| ML19323C975 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 04/16/1980 |
| From: | NRC COMMISSION (OCM) |
| To: | |
| References | |
| REF-10CFR9.7 NUDOCS 8005190485 | |
| Download: ML19323C975 (6) | |
Text
-__ _
~
- *p = ~
/
- e
~
g 0 95,0 0'
^
h'Q,L'-
[-
sQ
}f
..:.6 a ~>
y UNITED STATES NUCLEAR R EG UL ATO RY COMMISSION in the m atte r of:
AFFIRMATION SESSION 80-16 P1 ace:
washington, D. c.
D aie April 16, 1980 Pages:
1-4 I
INTERNATIONAL VERsATiM REPCRTERS. INC.
499 SOUTH CAPITOL STREET. S. W. SUITE 107 WASHINGTON. D. C. 20002 202 484-3550
.,a
=
caer sc.
i 1
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 1
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION I
i
x AFFIRMATION SESSION I
l 80-16 6
__________________________x i
7 l
l i
S l
l Comissioners' Conference Room 1717 H Street, N.W.
Washington, D. C.
10 Wednesday, April 16, 1980 I
i i
l 13 The Comission met, pursuant to notice, for
- 4 presentation of the above-entitled matter, at 3
- 45 p.m.,
John F. Ahearne, Chairman of the Commission presiding.
I' BEFORE:
17 i
VICT6R GILINSKY, Comissioner it RICHARD T. KENNEDY, Comissioner I
19 i
JOSEPH HENDRIE, Comission i
PETER A. BRADFORD, Comissioner 20 i
21 l
1 i
~
24 "5
i
% v n- % i r.
me seWMe ee8FMh. 9,WErf, S e. Wrft 197
- =. s.
I t
=
c_
lA I
paar c.
t i
PROCEEDINGS 1
i
@ubm kh%i
.f l
COMM. W :
The Commission meets for affirmation 2
i session.
John?
3 MR. HOYLE:
The first item for affirmation session is s
l SECY 80-156.
It is the disposition of ---
e 3
i s
8 (NOISE FROM AUDIENCE) i 6
COMM. KENNEDY:
Could we please have quiet so we could j 7
4 hear what we have to hear?
3 MR. HOYLE:
The first item has to do with the j
9 disposition of FOIA Appeal to the Commission.
The Commis-sion has voted five to nothing to withhold portions of 11 l
i two memoranda sad one complete memorandum.
This will be --
I i
COMM. KENNEDY:
This being 156 ?
I i
),
j MR. HOYLE:
Yes.
This will release additional --
33 an additional eight documents to the requester.
And
)
y may I have an affirmation of the proposals?
7 (Chorus of ayes) i t
13 l
MR. HOYLE:
The seconde. item is SECY A 80-39.
This i
I 19 i
is review of two ALABs in Sh,Mron Harris Nuclear Power 20 Plant case.
By a vote of four to nothing with Chairman l
21 Ahearne concurring in part and dissenting in part -- has l
I agreed to approve a memorandum and order in this case.
I l
Chairman Ahearne concurs in the decision that the I
i Appeals Board lacked authority to direct the Staff in r
this case but dissents from the decision not to grant
- % v. - ~ % o.c m souw c.sm rmarr. s.
. surre es7 i
%. L & M
I o
e i
2 i
pacc
.*c i
r l
the applicant's petition to review ALAB 581.
May I I
have your affirming votes, please.
l
~
~
(Chorus of ayes.)
j 4
I MR. HOYLE:
The third item is SECY 80-159.
This I
t 3
i paper requests the delegation of authority to regional l
6 directors to issue orders to licensees during an emergency?
7 l
By a vote of five to nothing, the Commission has approved s
a memorandum containing this delegation of authority with
?
the addition that the determinations will be made by ic i
the director of the executive management team.
May I 11 l
have your affirmation, please.
10 (Chorus of ayes.)
13 s
i MR. HOYLE:
The final item is SECY 80-119, an 14 ENO determination for the Three Mile Island accident.
By a vote of five to nothing, the Commission has approved g
the text of the determination which indicates that the'
-.o t
jg Three Mile Island occurrence was not an extraordinary i
i nuclear occurrence.
19 l
20 On page 21, there is a footnote in which i
21 l
Commissioners Gilinsky and Bradford indicate that they i
.I I
do not believe that the Heidleburg Report is relevant I
i i
l
- ~
l to this ENO determination.
With that, though, the text 24 of the determination has been approved by all of you.
i
~J May I have your affirmation, please?
% v n =- i c et SER,Me Ca8**W6 fMsW?, s. w. Wrft ter
_. _. u m
I 4
3 l
P AGE NC.
t
}
'I I
{
(Chorus of ayes.)
i i
2 MR. HOYLE:
Thank you.
1 i'
2 COMMISSIONER BRADFORD:
John,I want to be f
quoted as being against the issuance of disabling I
i license today.
i MR. HOYLE :
Yes, sir.
You will be recorded.
Okay.
You were not in the room at the time of the vote.
- f
~
COMMISSIONER GILINSKY: I must say I'm surprised the i
,r vote was taken.
10 l
CHAIRMAN AHEARNE:
I'm surprised you weren't in n
the room.
I.
MR. HOYLE:
You didn't say anything.
If you 13 i
had said that you wanted to hold the vote, I would I
la i
have held the vote.
13 COMMISSIONER GILINSKY:
I didn't realize you were right at the end of the meeting.
It's all right.
I,,
i It's done.
l 13 i
i l
t MR. HOYLE:
The meeting finished and you sat g
here.
'o 1
g 7;
j CHAIPMAN AHEARNE:
Well, wny don't you go ahead l
l i
g l
and allow Mr. Gilinsky to cast his vote.
We just I
23 j
allowed Mr. Bradford too.
I would vote we do that.
i 24 l
COMMISSIONER GILINSKY:
Well, I would have 3
proposed putting off an affirmation next week, but anyway
%vsnne x
a.e e CAN 99 Er?, s. e. 27fTT 157 I
wee.esusTO.a. 3. a m
I C
a 1
VAGE N C.
i i
9 0
j i
e i
j you just proceed.
i.
(Whereupon, the hearing was adjourned on April
- I
~
16, 1980.)
j d
i A
i s
I
!}
7 I
1 i
9 l
10 l
il I
t 9a ao 5
13 l
ld t
15 id es l
18 i
i I?
20 l
a1
)
4 i.
l M
i 1
44 I
i ab
=
lavTtpundTW:pe% Vtmaanse Apu:zettprL leuc l
ase scntThe C.AN STurtIT. E e. Erf?! 187 8
waan=*=CTD=. 3. O amus