ML19322D000

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Summary of Regulatory Review Committee 750822 Meeting 35 Re Proposed Reg Guide 1.XX Guidance on Being Operator at Controls, Proposed Revisions 1 to Reg Guides 1.40 & 1.92 & Proposed Reg Guide 4.8
ML19322D000
Person / Time
Site: Crane 
Issue date: 09/15/1975
From: Case E
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To: Gossick L
NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS (EDO)
References
RTR-REGGD-01.040, RTR-REGGD-01.092, RTR-REGGD-04.008, RTR-REGGD-1.040, TASK-TF, TASK-TMR NUDOCS 8002070571
Download: ML19322D000 (2)


Text

-

g umT: u <.ct s e i n e

f UrJnN Tir.c: tit,TC;;V cc..? ;<..)a

{.

.u:n n:a r a... o. c.. c w

<;rp 15 L:i Leo V. Co: sir.!:

.Emcutive Diri.ctor for Operations

!:".CUL.' TOT ( PG'.y r ~:gr0 S 'EVIE'! CC" !ITTCE ~. CTD:G l'O. 35, -

AUCU51 22, 1976 I

Tha Cof.ittee reviewed the fcilouing items:

1.

Proposed Peculatory Guice 1.XX, Cl!IDfd'CE 0:! BED 71 "0PEPl. TOR

!.: Tf:2 CO:D"0LS" FOP !. ilUCLE/,R P3'53 l'Lt.!:T an:! reccr.m.snded approval subject to the follo; ting comnts:

a.

The guiG should be impleii.cnted as rapi.ily as po:uihin u'.ilizinq c.npropriate warding in the I.:ple. ntation Section to accomplish this objec ti ve.

b.

The last paragraph of Section D (pace 1.XX-4 of i

y the drcf t) should lie deleted.

-c.

The phrase "In order to be considered" at the opening r.entence of Section C1 (page 1.XX-2) should be delettd.

d.

The sentenca beginning in Section Cl, line 10 on page 1.XX-3 of the draft should be revit.eri to read "The oparator at t'r. controls may be me:.ientcrily absent irr::: the designated area...." The lie,ita-tions on operator comentary absence should be defined-in the plant Technical Specific'ations.

c.

The last paraccaph in Section C1 (page 1.XX-3) should be deleted in its ertirety.

f.

The first sentence and the first word of the second sentence of Section C4 (page 1.XX-4) should be deleted.

4 This guida was characterized by the Com:nittee as Category III -

Cackfit raquired.

8002070 6 7 /

s.

. Q V

Lee V. 00ssich 4' L-4

}'

2.

Pro:osed Regt'latory Cuide 1.40 (Pevision 1), QtlALIFICATIO::

g TCSTS CF C0::rlt:C0;JS-;"tif '070r:s I!ETAU.E*.1;;S!!E t::9 OUTSIDE d, h*

CD:'i,": ' ?:T OF '.',"sT~':-CCOLCD l.dD GA5-C00L'a :F:LFT.f: PC 01 PilUT5.. : nct.L..;adm approval.

Tiiis 09i b vihu charceterized

\\3 -

by th2 Cc.aaittee as ategory 1 - no bacFri'..

3.

Prop =' TN"ision 1 of &culatory Cuid: 1.92, CD::3Il!Ii!G !:0E'AL HESFO':5ES.;:9 5?f.Till CO :Piql.:YS I:! SEIS".IC P.EEPC::5E A:'i. LYSIS i

epd ro..a tradot anpnriel subject to the follocling cornent:

4 a.

In Section D, lina 4 of second paraprcph (page 12 of dra ft) in". ort iiie V ords "by the st.f f after the ttord "used', dolcte the words "sub:nittals for" and replace the: da to "/.;wil 1,1975" with tL~ teards "the dat? of issue of t::is Edide" in the trio places V:here said dalc apper:.

This 9.:id: '.*as charat terized.by the Coraittee as Category 1 -

no bechfi:..

4 4.

ProposcJ !k wlatory Gtida 4.3, P:VIIIG;":2:!TI.L YECH:!ICAL SPECiriU;1u::5 FO:4 i'UC!.r'.?, P0"EP. PL?.;'T' 4.m; recootended V

appraal sus.i.:c t to the follo::ir.9 cm...:.:nts :

a. *la the Introductica, second colu.nn, paca 4.8-4 of c'rait, deltto in its entirety the paragraph i

tr finning "Since the purpose...." and ending with

".... r:ay ba I chc. r".

b.

The *.tundard "O ronths after issuance date of the c:.ide for cor.c. ant" should be used in developing the

{

1r,)lecentation Section.

1 c.

OELD should be asked to again revieri this guids in light of Coitnittee cor=ents, but it need not co:aa back for Con.iittee reviert.

This guid+ 1:n charactari:ed by the Cor.nittee as Category I -

no backfit..

M y

l i

Edson G. Case 4

2 Ch'iman, Psegulatory llequirer.ents j

i:eviet' Con.aittee I

cc: See next page w

--,-w r

v e-

--.rs

- -, - ~, -