ML19322C413
| ML19322C413 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Crane  |
| Issue date: | 11/08/1979 |
| From: | Streeter J NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III) |
| To: | James Keppler NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III) |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19322C410 | List: |
| References | |
| TASK-TF, TASK-TMR NUDOCS 8001170289 | |
| Download: ML19322C413 (4) | |
Text
.g gae y-4,
.g
.g tn..i. DS.T.s ic is c
(~.-)
NUCI E M F.EGU'_ ATOP.Y COM.;iSS:0.N
,.,., !O,. l,i.
- r. :o t
y u.
- -..'. '. T
- 3. D r
1 c.,..
i,,.....,...,.-e
...,.s
)
......us e.. e, 1 c, c,
..c.
i L
h l
l
.4
...... - r..
7 0 2...
C..
s..'ll..
~..
~. =..-. o., n _= = '.. e
- n....= >. -. i -
s-s r.s.:..,..-~..=.~4.
r
". O c. '. *.
.3
.. C
.No2.,.c.
ng s
u r c - O,.
.c a.
. "..?
r.
q
-.-r.-
s L.c. L p. q p r ( i.t.w T -.
-.. w-r r.m
...n., u c r.;.s3_7 a
..i..
a.-
Cr --
s..;.. r.. t " q T.
A.
~ * ".. *. '. 3 -~ q T..i ?.%.* ~ ?_. *. 5 b w t'.*
- C..C T /.. ' b D. ~r.D (-- S..*. L..-
.._T Q-v
.. Lou
?.'-*.
- a
- 7 n...
.~
1 a.
1.w
.C....,
1.,.,...
a, L...n...
wL. L
..\\,
s
-w
-1 c,.
,CC,U
_4.3
. m. 3L
.na c...o,"%
.s c.,O, 3 C...
.J..,..
C
.c.._-
- .c O--
e.
,,,,,. 4 e, C w ~
.w-..
w'.
c_L.
- g-
.w
.t'
- V
~. o. h :.., C o~ ~..~ g.e.,.p e.. = ~..n
.O-6.q a. t r uoc,....
e.i g e... a. c. ~. 5, c.e. v.. n,. ~.... c-
~.q=.
m. s....
z-w
- c.pO _...n Cwn.g-,.
ciC _,
- c.,:. i,e n
,.ep
.S3
...l.05 es.
..a
- .,.4.. e
.:.2 t..c
...c.
ses..
+
5
., L, S u.
A o. 3 e..%. S,.... e r ' a, C v.., c. n, %....
,a.n:. n.4 e... o.... n <., c e w
w cc.
- .. u
. t. y
..c.
.i = C ' L E. E '.. #.
C.. ' t 6.rO.o' D, O.c.: #_ b_ _' s l
.. 4.c _i ' # 4 ". ~
- r. _" C " ~. 2 *. # s^ ^..
'a C.' a *. l.# ' a. #.
- 1 e-3 p.
22eu O
.ncSc-.
.,.....e, c,,
. e. -. L s,.'.n...
t '.,. e.
7:.
L at
. c... e., :~. _..:
- .~..
.c..
- _n.
'. z. c. c p,.
-.4
.~.n C. e _=...1. _ ' >-
_>=..*~...'.~.v..,am.._'..~.
.. e C '... -c.. m=. o.. '.. ' '. '.. '... -. ' - '.....p e-
...e,.
-g _ a.
u w n o, r*. S - - -
1.* 1' t '.-'. O '
- c"..'..
". c^ a.'- c. w * ~...M.
t 6' -"."..d_#'.' '.'..t' '..'2'.3' w -'. #.
$e
.w..
v_
2 3 COU'.ti Cf O*h6rE inV01'.'E d.
YOU.?ill rECEll tha;.r. FOSt=r a::3re55EO his s..:. l z
.O..
4 -
C.. e...,
2 a.4C.i u..: S.
"n 3-
..c,,.
(s,
- z:
e., m...~s u.
u we...--
- ..,:use.
...c...
...s._w..
33.c c..~
}: c3,
.t 1 c,
- 0..
- e..,. g.,,. :
i
=)
e u
.g
%...u
... ) 1.,. W Lw,. -
-s')J ETE S hep 3). e r e
v.
J DiraCtor
.-t..., s..
- e. n..
.. u c. u 2
nS
_C. 0u J
.26
$8 8001170 2h
3
.s, U.... - n S a m..
s-
...scu
.s Je t r;UCLEM T;E 3'JL ATOPY CO.*.'.M!SSION r.
a,... l, l
.,..e e
-:..a 7.._.~.
s~_
s
,, =. e.....
......,.n-
.w.-, c. _. n o_. q
. o.. o.
e
- 54. '.~20 FC.:. :
James G. Keppler. Director
- :.u. :
. ctreeter, C n..ier,.,uclear.qupport q
~ection,.
-..e. 2:. : -- -.
_c.. 0...
.T.v. n..a. r...:.- ' I S f.r. _-..'. u-
.c r..~..r.. _... '.. T '.-
.y..
p e
.o r.pe z. c.: T
.=.= : _c _, =_ -.. : - n..~.. _ _.... o..
. u..:
- 1. - e r r_ = v..
- ,c.
. t _.
u.
..1 T.:.:m:.:..sh L:.
_r _a._p-,-
w
~nis nemorand c is intended to brine
- ycur attention what I consider to O
te substantive in:orrect and misleading statements in the " Report cf The Fresifent's Cs :ission en the Accident at Three Mile Island" and the
.suppcrting staff " Report cf the Office of Chief Counsel on the Nuclear negu.atory _cn=tssica.,
_.inese incorrect and mis 3_eacing statements are
. =..l a *. *. '. *
.74.-d'n-G.C..d.
(
=-a.
.t c.#
.h. a. r e p v- - *_
_- a y 3
."..d
- .o ha
.e 4c-1 c:ntainec in Section VI.S. (pages 167-174) of the su.crcrtino staff report.
... i s ~. h ' A ' '. '3 t. ; a. s
'a'i t g_ it s apparent inaC11117 tC reso.)Ve Safety conctrns
..i i s e : wi-hin its staff. and is specificalli related tc 'ir.
~. ^res ell's testinony bef:re -he :-resident's Commissic; on August 22, 1979.
.' thcugh -he issue cf IE not being able to resolve safety issues -. sed by inspe::crs is discus sed in the Cverview and Findings sections of the report, i-is not apparent that any of the Reccmmendaticas were based uo.cn anv.
Fresident's C:: ission concerns in that area.
However, in a matter of such significance"as the evaluation of the Three Mile Island accident, it appears to me to be of uttost icportance that even the findings be based upon eccpletel) fa:tual information.
Even if overall cenclusions remain unchanged, I believe it o be vrcng to suoport ccaclusions with inforcatica which is incorrect.
Tne substantive inccrrect and misleading statements I want to bring to your attentica, al'.ng with my clarifyin,a ccaments, are as follows:
c.1.. _. _ r. T.
In
.-_<q one Ia,_n insreetcr raised the issue o., coeratcr termination cf H.I during the September ISie incident at Davis-Eesse.
For sore 5 ::nths, none of his efforts produced any action."
(Finding 3.9.d.) :An alcost identical statement is in the first paragraph of
,a-,
,:: c :.
..u _
e,w o, c.c r,-po..
.)
n 3_
A--
6 A
.y.
re..e+
.t,.
~-ag
.s-~.e.c:cc v.
u
. k. n s e, v
.. - e. =..b. t;.-
1.,4. n_ n e. -
.s
--u.
19.,.c, the inspector,s pcst:Icn was rev:ewec an:,. suppcrtec by te ( t.ne ir.=.rectcr's superviser) and this su.pport was conve. red to the licensee
. (Sap em'a.-
- c. C
.c..'u - 15, 19 e s'.
- 2.. + ' _e.
_4 - a.
'. ', ' 2 '< S ) *-" a.
' 4 c o_..s c a.
tg a.
c s
c - - d
- g a '
--La y..ld. *...
.h,
,<ene C :q u,. O, ' c a s 'J o ". o ~f r a"~w~ u '" I "
- -* ~~~
~.-"
r -
-y
.q w. _ g y :. a ta. 4'O T Le nn..., a d...:
_~
e n-
.bo C.ptew..Ac..
} c. 7 7 '. a."..t 4 " 7. *..
.A. s '
.. a g
u..a
. v.
...1..
c.
. k. t_
r i*,3 sn 's
.e.,:...
. b. s_
i.f c e.s n e u,.d D..c +..,a T T.T 63 22 1u w-.
e-4
..au w
3
--u
- 5. gym.b..
.L.-.
. ' _ C.t.c.C'.
cC.4.,q e-i " y.
- D A.'. 2.".d
.=. a n
..v...
u
.... :ne.O J. procedure on, crecaer ia, 13e.
to give 11:ensee cac1,1e:
L
~ : nn.n 2,
-o gu,-__.- - 3,_ f._e
..,r,
_o ye g,- s u.- c u.
r.v. e-a, a
p
~:- u,-
3 u-m
.s
-m.is.3- "as.rav' "a3 "_",
.'-a_
' ". s p a. s. e. a n m' r.. a v-a nace-w,.
o- _n,
- 3. c.. 3,
a t.,. ns :oun: to ce._nacecuate.
_.2ne 11censee agreed to cane :urtner revisions to the procedure an'.those revisions were cade January 6, 1v a.
n_,thcugh the inspector cid not reviev the revisiens during u.
als tast visits to avis aesse in a nua rv. an _: c o rua rv.
- 9, 1 3
r,..e a.w a_ d t' a - 'o'.i o".'
3 t ' a_
P...f.i c'
a_n_
c..da.
' s..a.2 na.d
- b =_ ", w o u _' d 4
a hav^ been acceptable to te if I had examined ther prier to the T"I C...<,_,.
_w.
T. h,
4v.as
- 3e.2-
- -
2
- 6.,. 3 3
- 3. 2.
p. I ',..., t.
-+- 05 c
1 v..,
.r
,_a-.
...b
->>'r-
..-.c gs*.o.
.aC
- "2. C ' ' ' d.
m ";
'9 c '.h..
_b a.
b' 4..s p a - c o ".' _c. c ,D e. ". 4 s O.-
~ '
-s
. e s-c _~ m.'".a r
m
.4u,.3
a e p i
.n,.
T..u..t a s d:m.. cnu a
s a. is.c
..,. cm.un was
.....s c 'r.. a c e
- , v _- * '.. s a #. '6 =. - d ' s c o s =.. y J#
- e. ' a....r. a r.
c n c'.e. 1 C.u..~. 1
..o
- h. 'D * #. - - '.. a.
w a
a
<.,,- m e r. o.. 3.2.
tto i.r. e 3.1 o, w.m.
c o n. 3 -,..,.i v *. tha-.T,C C c.... _' s s 1'.,.....e
.u.
. c Therefore, the report statement that none of the inspector's efforts pr:duced any action f:r 5 conths is in error.
c,nT c, sT linu,ing
,.e..:. g:ves :ye abcVe cescribed statement as an examp_.
v e o:
._: ins ectors avine cl,:1ct tv. havin s a.,e tv. issues L er raisec considerecewiny.in tne o:fice.
s e ricu s iv.
CO.' a'"~.'~i d The above described c =ments indicate that the catter received serious ccasideration vitain..egion I.
- r. ne re. ore, it is 1_,.ogica3_ to use c
h a_ sa.esv l.e s t a.
c o _ - a... _4 _- ~.-=
. e...,. ". e s a c u.- ' -e o...i 3"m.ps as s inact.,3 y
_c an examp e o:. i c;
.. ity sericusly ac. dress safety issues.
b TM"A"~ '..'t'."* ~1 L _
_he _,ast sentence o., the second paragraph of pagt, i c, S c :. tn.e suc2ect t
staff report is worded se that one could reascnably ccnclude that :he NRR project nanager advised the inspector that the it.spector was actin 8 bev.ond the sec.ae of his resF.onsibility in.ursuine 'the.atter.
5 b
e
d
.s -.. s.
.l s-...
.gg.
2 a
s...
s -
s.....L.. :
.T. C,..
.c a...J.
-b, da.g.3.*.
nr t-
, e n
. ~.....
.?.,2. c. s ' 7 1 1.. o..c 1./.
e.t p o, d. 4G, wa.
oa 1
-. s.;, 1.2 tm...e me. r
-pg.-.a w ac.
.w s
. t. s.,
- x.,..v: e.,.O j. -
o as 6-.
..wa.
a..
g.
.-w w.
gu.., 8 n..
e..g
..c.,... c...;.,....,
... e.,
. 2
...c
. ~ ~
., s - a c. t e r.. s 3 pg... c....n. y r,.n C. :w.
.e
.u:Cu. % :.. l Ce. s. n g.
L~.
,C:
v: e
..,' d U0fC '. I.
no
.~
6-Gbav'
-V
- l perf>ra.
.-__g.,,..
. a.,...G
/.:.,. 3
- 7 O.
- r us.....
- r. e,.. n.. a.- J (,, v. :.'ne q., c.f a
.....a..
.w.
e-
.,r...
4.:
. u -b-
.s,.
2.".
C *. '.* I. # h a.
.d a
"w.%'.'..t'.""'
'w O
.# '..# ". "w ' 'c '.
'w ' s- *sM.". S t..* l.lO s
.be.
.t
-. -... w m..: s e.r...T
. o..r
- 2..-.1 1 r. e.
r.
.e 3
c-aus s
a c...
u.
s te c..e.l..4 u
g w
.*5ste.
n
,,a..--
3....s...b i
s
%>..,3.. '3..
- 3. u ' l %
.t.,.:.71
.e. 3. s..; e,s
.s.2.
.-... p,.. _.. ;
M.
. C a.Sya'1
....g
. n...m...~.. t..e $4,3.
_~o=.
9..
1.
. 3n.
.m.........
- .--e,.
..w-..3
.o e. a c...
3,. r.c. g..C
.'.*.C'.a..
_. ~....,. _
.4.,.
- e.... u. g,.....=.
.u
.u,.1 f..,,,,n.
,,, o.c
.u,
...~
.. =.
-3.
,-3.,
1
, c.. s..a. a_ =. ' n' - w. u".i..,-.c V4. c..- c. =. '1 ' s. L. a.
2-...
.w
.r. -a. c a. D 4 e ~....-
.g
. s
,:=.
.v.. a. e.p.../.,=.,.. :.<
u
=,.:1,..... ;..
u.
s.
en,
-..,.r.a.u,n-c.-
n..:
2 3.
,s e u.,..
. e :.. ~. ~ ' a.
Il. =. o
- 4. ' e*..
.-e f. a
.r a. d
- o. m
- c apparently is the pressurizer level cff-scale ics problem described in..
..,.1.a s. n.._ _ -, c
..n.
co_...,,
u...
c t
pc.
.e.cta.
o
.c
,,,....t-7 a: Mr. Stelic actually stated was that the pressuri:er level nrc.blems t
3...
t en:cunterec curing tre N.crencer,s, ire,, Davls -esse translent uere s ' c - 4 # i a ~-.. '. a -
- w.. a. - -
- t s,w. 4za-
. e.t c.
b
.l a.. a. l 'o m h., *. -.
u'".1. 3 a
~ ~
- n' a. ~ "41'
.e--.
s y...
v 6
c C ; ; a. ~-.
w.
. h.. y
....J.,..3..
..n
.4.. k. a.
..1.,.~-...A....
s.,n he.
2.
c.. _ _. r. :. w L..
c
.s..
t.s.e,. l D - uOC... ! n.,1 -
s..
a
.. a
. 6.%.
..a...a au e
,...k...
. 4.:.
.c..r.w..
cuw2....,
. c t t a....,.
- e... '. u u :...,e.
4... 1..... ~ y,.
.J. u r,,,m,. t, l.
2 s.
.... s
..w 3
..... n; v
- t t,
'1 1*y.
n C.+ a - v..i '.
.e
. e S. 4...e.e..
. n $ c,g. a....b c..
- 3. C.. o,
.T b t c ~.c.
a..
a
.da s
s
.u Concerned tha. the Fresident's cc:nissicn right draw incorrect conclusions
- ..,,. w
. 4.
,. c. c,m.
4c 4
-3
.. u. "..
u.e3 i1,c.. c. c, v-...,ue...
.,a
.v.
o..
n s a. r e e u.' *6,
I.had a telephone discussion with Mr. S. Eelfman of tae President's Cc..
.i s. s-.
..:.## anu" a *. c.,o t e d
- o ^. x... a s s..". ". - '.. w U...#o r.u n _= w. l v,,
a 4
a..,s
.,,c....
.r........
.1..c..s...
~..
.. s. ; e
.e.,4
. t...
2 u.
c c.
s........
a.a.;u
....s....
...a...w e
.c-
-... u. ; _v.1 r. -
it. * /:c.
.(...~.'.c_e.....
~u 4
w
,.ect. g r.w C1 $ p c. A A.4 lu aga a
4 c
nn..
S.- te.a..,.-c c~? [. s.. a b e c..-
e c
u e
%. w. 4. e 4 4.
.T had be - d ;0See by-
+..
-x--
1 42..a
.4-w....-,w e.
O _,p.
O
-u-w L
w unceri".an,. h s t'nat rcup cou..ic critictre supervisor" invcivement in tre
)
.e' r
eaa L 4..
e. 3, 3 *s : 133u S.. ; t.g. n. *s ta. t..n 5.. ~
- s b. ^ O "." * " t ".'1. *. ';
4
'n
- a "g C S e "..* T.'.'.) a.
- e.
a ca. -, _. ~ _c.. 3.-
.c up e q.,..s. C "..
e
?
.c..;. A
- k..,
. n,.
.q... n C o..
.. S S. C m.,,,. 2
- n.. e n.2
.O
-..e.. e s- --. b., 4.,. g.i..S 0.-
-...... a
-ao.
o w
..r. e
.e o--
v.: ~ y.
.D e. n S. d a n u ' s ( O.w 15 510.n.
'c~ a_.f. v. a. w.n. e. e s.
4 s
C.-
n c dic6 ne...b a.n f.
g.
O e.2. 4.2.. *w
- g 3. = #.: - k. 4.S g.a e t..
,. o c. - * :. 7..'..
w.
.. e c, o a.t --
- p.,. +w you
.-4
.-_.)---.-
w-csg,..
. b. 23 a
C O *. ';'
v.
'. k'. #. S D e _-'.O " 2.". A ' '.*3 s' <
,.r C ~. * *- l ' ' 4."M "U..-
"O
'u'."."- '?= ~I c.
oC.. ~.' 5 31C ne rs,De:O re tr.el: 01SCUS51Cn.
s.-
%w ' x.
s Streeter, unter.
- a. y
~.
';uclear Senport Section 1 e
(C..
n.
g e. g
. _ - a n.a
.e.
O w
.W 9
.