ML19319C622
| ML19319C622 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Davis Besse, Perry  |
| Issue date: | 12/30/1975 |
| From: | Aiuvalasit A, Berger M JUSTICE, DEPT. OF |
| To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8002191066 | |
| Download: ML19319C622 (28) | |
Text
.. -,
~
s -
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA /1 NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of )
)
The Toledo Edison Comoany )
The Cleveland Electric Illuminating ) Docket Nos.'S s Company ) 50-duua (Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station, ) 50-5 01 A Units 1, 2 and 3) )
- )
The Cleveland Electric Illuminating ) Docket Nos. 50-440A Company, et al. ) 50-441A (Perry Nuclear Power Plant, )
Units 1 and 2) )
RESPONSE OF DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE TO OHIO EDISON COMPANY'S AND PENNSYLVANIA POWER COMPANY'S MOTION FOR ADDITIONAL DISCOVERY FROM THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE AND NUCLEAR PEGULATORY COI! MISSION STAFF THOMAS E. KAUPER Assistant Attorney General Antitrust Division JOSEPH J. SAUNDERS Attorney, Department MELVIN G. BERGER of Justice ANTHONY G. AIUVALASIT, JR.
Attorneys, Department
'of Justice Cecember 30, 1975 4
"002 191ogg A
_= , . - - . . - -.-. . . .
s s, UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of )
)
The Toledo Edison Company )
The Cleveland Electric Illuminating ) Docket Nos. 50-346A Company ) 50-500A (Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station, ) 50-501A Units 1, 2 and 3) )
)
The Cleveland Electric Illuminating ) Docket Nos. 50-440A Company, et al. ) 50-441A (Perry Nuclear Power Plant, )
Units 1 and 2) )
1 RESPONSE OF DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE TO OHIO EDISON l COMPANY'S AND PENNSYLVANIA POWER COMPANY'S MOTION FOR ADDITIONAL DISCOVERY FROM THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE AND NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION STAFF l
The Department of Justice (hereinafter Department) submits the following responses to the Ohio Edison Company's and Pennsylvania Power Company's Motion for Additional Discovery from the Department of Justice and NRC Staff (hereinafter Discovery Recuest) as r.,dified by the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board's Memorandum and Order dated December 16, 1975, in the above-captioned consolidated proceeding. l Answers made herein are complete to the knowledge and belief of the undersigned representatives of the Decartment as of December 30, 1975.
DI'SCOVERY REOUEST NUMBER 1
, Documents to be relied upon by the Department in support of this 1 1
allegation are as follows:
I
m e
218432; 218389; 218680; 218388; 218681; 218683; 218677; 218378; 218384; 218705; 218704; 219703; 218691; 218690; 218689; 218688; 218694; 218693; 218699; 218697; 218695; 218701; 218700; 218709; 218708; 218707; 218706; 218710; 218711; 218416; 218417; 218419; 218421; 218422; 218434; 218433; 218440; 218444; 218448; 218450; 218451; 218492; 218454; 218577; 218571; 218570; 218566; 218563; 218553; 218555; 218556; 218557; 218558; 218560; 218562; 218391; 218392; 218393; 218394; 218352; 218494; 218496; 218635; 218493; 218490; 218660; 218661; 218662; 218457; 218458; 218459; 218395; 218396; 218397; 218398; 218399; 218400; 218401; 218402; 218403; 218404; 218405; 218406; 218407; 218408; 218409; 218410; 218411; 218412; 218413; 218414; 213415; 218355; 218356; 218357; 218358; 218359; 218360; 218361; 218362; 218365; 218366; 218368; 218369; 218370; 218371; 218372; 218373; 218374; 218375; 218376; 218778; 218792; 218793; 218794; 218795; 218796; 218797; 218798; 208762; 20876;; 208764; 208767; 218643; 219028; 219029; 219030; 219031; 2_9032; 219033; 218638; 218639; 218641; 218642; 218645; 218648; 208608; 208607; 208606; 208605; i l
208493; 208491; 208489; 208488; 208609; 218605; 218580; 218580A; 218578; 218603; 218627; 218623; 207231; 207229; 208496; 208495; 208494; 207228; 207227; 207224; 218602; 218581; 218584; 211529; 211530; 211528; 218582; 218583; 2
l
. ..... w. * * * ' "
. s _
2 0410; 2 1169; 2 1170; 2 1177; 2 1174; 218686; 218812; 218697; 218811; 218813; 218814; 218685; 218714; 218713; 218716; 218719; 218717; 218721; 218720; 218727; 218726; 218759; 218722; 218742; 218746; 218745; 218'35; 218740; 218739; 218738; 218737; 218736; 218733; 218731; 218732; 218729; 218753; 218754; 218755; 218748; 218712; 218851; 218807; 218815; 218684; 218757; 218723; 218756; 218762; 218752; 2 1547;15-317; 15-318;15-319; 15-320;15-321; 15-322;15-323; 15-324;15-325; 15-326;15-327; 15-328;
,15-329;15-330; 15-331;15-332; 15-333;15-334; 15-335;15-336; 15-340;15-341; 15-342;15-343; 15-344;15-345; 15-346;15-347; 15-343;15-349; 15-350;15-351; 15-351;15-352; 15-353;15-354; 15-355;15-356; 15-357;15-364; 15-366;15-367; 15-368;15-369; 15-370;15-374; 15-375;15-376; 15-377;15-378; 15-379;15-380; 15-381;15-382; 15-383;15-384; 15-385;15-386; 15-387;15-388; 15-389;15-390; 15-391;15-392; 15-393.
Witnesses to be relied upon by the Department in support of this allegation are as follows:
A. N. Gorant William M. Lewis, Jr.
Powers Luce William Lyren
. 3
/
~, ~
. g-D.. Bruce Mansfield George W. Raike s
These witnesses will testify about Ohio Edison's enforce-ment of provisions in wholesale contracts which allocated customers and territories.
The Department will also rely on information contained in its Prehearing Brief, at 105-117.
DISCOVERY REOUEST MUMBER 2 Documents to 'be relied upon by the Department in support of this allegation are as follows:
2 2487; 2 1560; 219028; 219029; 219030; 219031; 219032; 219033.
Witnesses to be relied upon by the Department in support of this allegation are as follows:
William Lyren - In 1974 in response to requests by representatives of the Wholesale Consumers of Ohio Edison (WCOE), representatives of Ohio Edison refused to provide wheeling services.
D. Bruce Mansfield - Ohio Edison has a history of opposition to wheeling.
The Department will also rely on information contained in its Prehearing Brief, at 110.
4 e
DISCOVERY REQUEST NUMBER 3 (1) The Department will rely on the documents, witnesses, and information listed and referred to in response to Discovery Request Number .1, supra, in support of this allegation.
(2) Documents to be relied upon by the Department in sup-port of this allegation are as follows:
219028; 219029; 219030; 219031; 219032; 219033; Witnesses to be relied upon by the Department in support of this allegation are as follows:
William Lyren - Ohio Edison's industrial retail rates are lower than its whole-sale municipal rates, thus inhibiting Wadsworth and other wholesale customers from competing with Ohio Edison for industrial retail customers.
Roland A. Kampmeier - Ohio Edison has eliminated competition from its whole-sale municipal customers for industrial retail customers by charging the municipals rates for power which are higher than comparable rates it charges to industrial customers.
The Department will also rely on information contained in its Prehearing Brief, at 110.
(3) Documents to be relied upon by the Department in support of this allegation as as follows:
218416; 218417; 218419; 218421; 218422; 218434; 218433; 218440; 218444; 218448; 218450; 218451; 218492; 218454; 5
e
' ~
g ,
4 218577; 218571; 218570; 218566; 218623; 218618; 218613; 218596; 218598; 218600; 218818; 218612; 218588; 218615; 218606; 218594; 218591: 219028; 218029; 219030; 219031; 219032; 219033; 218F53; 218553; 218555; 218556.
Ir addition, the Department will rely upon the documents relating to Niles and Cuyahoga Falls listed in response to Discovery Request Number 1, supra.
DISCOVERY REOUEST NUMBER 4 Documents to be relied on by the Department in support of this allegation are as follows:
206681; 206667; 206669; 206639; 206638; 206629; 206602; 208222; 208038; 206350; 206351; 206336; 206334; 206331; 218608; 206929; 206B92; 206887; 206880; 206867; 206872; 206869; 2 5526; 2 5524; 2 5532; 2 5531; 2 5519; 2 5454; 2 5402; 206561; 206865; 208159; 206581; 206861; 206816; 206336; 206857; 206817; 208160; 206567; 2 2226; 2 2227; 206856; 206855; 206331; 206646; 206791; 206790; 206785; 2 2349; 206784; 2 1656; 2 1655; 206780; 206779; 206552; 206690; 206684; 206691; 206564; 206763; 206764; 206563; 206760; 206736; 20G562; 206594; 2 1775; 206937; 206637; 2 2293; 2 2292; 206634; 206630; 2 2360; 2 2263; 2 2264; 206632; 206628; 206794; 206503; 206625; 206626; 206624; 206623; 206622; 206603; 206605; 206759; 206558; 206757; e
6
.. ..e..oop.-- w. -- we w . .e . w e== _ - we we m a.---e-+ - y
~. --
. ~
206726; 206747; 206717; 206716; 206554; 206745; 206715; 206714; 208323; 206695; 206682; 208013; 206494; 206486; 208327; 207992; 2 2413; 2 2410; 206471; 207975; 2 2309; 206469; 207973; 206672; 206645; 206644; 206670; 206650; 206641; 206429; 206525; 2 2265; 2 2362; 208134; 208133, 208119; 208111; 208098; 206351; 206350; 206927; 206928; 219028; 219029; 219030; 219031; 219032; 219033; 206874; 218628.
The Department will also rely on information contained in its Prehearing Brief, at 104.
DISCOVERY REOUEST NUMBER 5
]
Documents to be relied upon by the Department in support of ,
l this allegation are as follows:
206175; 19000001; 219028; 219029; 219030; 219031; 219032; 219033.
1 Witnesses to be relied upon by the Department in support of j this allegation are as follows:
George W. Raike - In 1965, Ohio Edison refused to sell the Newton Falls municipal electric system power for resale thereby denying it the benefits of coordination. l The Department will also rely on information contained in its l Prehearing Brief, at 109. ,
l DISCOVERY REQUEST NUMBER 6 Documents to be relied upon by the Department in support of this allegation are as follows: _.
i 7
1 '
?
~__ _
213312; 2 5979; 2.5983; 213334; 213310: 2 5970; 2 5968; 2 5944; 2 5963; 2 5367; 2 5962; 2 5957; 2 5809; 2 5965; 218664; 2 5945; 2 5330; 2 5925; 2 5803; 2 5918; 2 5912; 2 5911; 2 5909; 2 5560; 2 5568; 2 5794; 2 5793; 2 5791; 2 5789; 2 5786; 2 5785; 2 5784; 2 5897; 2 5896; 2 5832; 2 5829; 2 5782; 2 5763; 2 5762; 2 5760; 2 5759; 2 5751; 215587; 2 5743; 2 5728; 2 5730; 2 5692; 90000156; 213305; 219002; 90000154; 90000157; 2 2729; 213309; 2 5338; 213306; 2 3431; 206037; 2 5336; 2 5334; 206028; 2 5749; 2 1654; 215587; 2 1646; 2 5384; 2 1653; 2 1649; 2 2559; 2 2562; 2 5631; 2 5404; 2 5687; 2 5428; 2 5684; 2 5664; 2 5676; 2 2755; 2 5706; 2 5406; 2 5647; 2 5648; 2 5649; 2 2719; 2 4053; 215327; 215336; 215338; 2 5654; 2 5646; 2 5650; 2 5613; 2 5631; 2 5633; 2 5411; 2 5628; 2 5622; 2 5621; 2 5603; 2 5414; 2 5416; 2 5427; 2 5585; 2 5572; 2 5573; 2 5426; 2 5423; 2 5424; 2 5425; 2 5530; 2 5084; 2 5512; 2 5510; 2 5448; 215400; 215404; 215415; 215419; 215424; 215425; 215426; 215427; 2 5487; 2 5495; 2 5480; 213315; 2 5488; 219028; 219029; 219030; 219031; 219032; 219033; 2 5351; 2 5999; 2 5354; 215700; 215701; 215702; 206027; 206065; 206064; 206063; 206062; 206060; 206059; 206057; 206055; 206051; 206050; 206049; 2 4823; 2 4828; 2 4823; 2 4839; 2 4846; 2 4847; 2 '4848; 2 4852; 2 1676; 8
9 l -
/
~ ..
2 1666; 2 1788; 2 1821; 2 1783; 2 1665; 2 1678; 2 1664; 2 1662; 2 1660; 2 1681; 2 1800; 2 1829; 2 1809; 2 1806; 2 1815; 2 1816; 2 1798; 2 1692; 2 1918; 2 1901; 2 1900; 2 1899; 2 1872; 2 1865; 2 1851; 2 1939; 2 1953; 2 1954; 2 1955; 2 1969;.2 1975; 2 1978; 2 2003; 2 2008; 2 2011; 2 201); 2 2015; 2 2022; 2 2046; 2 2049; 2 2065; 2 2118; 2 0297; 2 2592; 2 2633; 2 2686; 2 2691; 2 2696; 2 2550; 2 2561; 2 1683; 2 1679; 2 1685; 2 1691; 2 1716; 2 1734; 2 1721; 2 6005; 2 5984; 2 5988; 2 5985; 2 5996; 2 5994; 2 5991; 2 5998.
Witnesses to be relied upon by the Department in support of this allegation are as follows:
Howard A. Cummins George W. Raike Each witness will testify concerning their knowledge of the events relating to this allegation.
DISCOVERY REQUEST.NU GER 7 Documents to be relied upon by the Department in support of this allegation'are as follows:
218035; 218034; 219033; 218032; 217847; 217844; 217843; 210492; 218552.
DISCOVERY REQUEST NUMBER 8 Documents to be relied upon by the Department in support of 1
this allegation are as follows: -
-1 l l
I o
o \
208570; 218853.
- Witnesses to be relied upon by the Department in supoort of this allegation are as follows:
Clyde W. Frederickson - Mr. Frederickson will confirm the existence of the facts upon which this allegation is based.
The Department will also rely on information contained in its Prehearing Brief, at 108.
DISCOVERY REQUEST NU!!BER 9 Documents to be relied upon by the Department in support of this allegation are as follows:
217823; 217837; 217840; 217824; 217830.
The Department will also rely on information contained in its Prehearing Brlef, at 109-110.
DISCOVERY REQUEST NUMBER 10 Documents to be relied upon by the Department in suoport of this allegation are as follows:
218259; 218261; 213254; 218255.
The Department will also rely on information contained in its Prehearing Brief, at 108. .
. 10 a.
s
., _ m ., , , . -. -...-a-== %e + + + e6-* ==h e - me=* < **
- 6 % e mm. , one w. o me=* * ==ma =
- p** I
~ ...
s ,
DISCOVERY REQUEST NUMBER 11 Documents to be relied on by the Department in support of this allegation are as follows:
2 4931; 12000013; 12000024;15-404; 15-405;15-406; 15-407;15-411; 15-412;15-413; 15-414;15-416; 15-420;15-421; 15-422;15-423; 15-424; 218857; 219003; 219028; 219029; 219030; 219031; 219032; 219033; 218856.
Witnesses to be relied on by the Department in support of this allegation are as follows:
Charles Allen Marvin Luxenberg Herman Rogers Robert Urian .
Each witness will testify about Pennsylvania Power Company's (hereinafter PPC) policy and the implementation thereof, of restricting competition between municipal electric systems and PPC for industrial customers.
The Depirtment will also rely on information contained in its Prehearing Brief, at 111-114.
O 11 e
I f .
'I
- o - .--
DISCOVERY REQUEST NUMBER 12 Documents to be relied upon by the Department in support of this allegation are as follows:
11000024; 11000028; 11000029; 11000030; 11000034; 11000036; 219028; 219029; 219030; 219031; 219032; 219033.
Witnesses to be relied on by the Department in support of this allegation are as follows:
Charles Allen Herman Rogers Each witness will testify about PPC's refusal 3 sell partial requirements power to Grove City with the intent and effect of preventing competition with the municipal system for industrial customers.
The Department will also rely on information contained in its Prehearing Brief, at 113.
DISCOVERY REQUEST NUMBEF 13 Documents to be relied on by the Department in support of this allegation are as follows: -
219003; 12000000; 12000013; 12000024;15-404; 15-405; 9
12 O
w m ms e, -e g- wes-e 24 em amm moqpo m p .mempemoo m . =y 6
I '
^ "15-406; 15-407;15-411; 15-412;15-413; 15-414;15-416; 15-420;15-421; 15-422;15-423; 15-424.
Witnesses to be relied on by the Department in support of this allegation _are as follows:
Charles Allen Marvin Luxenberg Herman Rogers Robert Urian Each witness will testify about PPC's enforcement of territorial customer allocation provisions in PPC's wholesale contracts with municipal systems.
The Department will also rely on information contained in its Prehearing Brief, at 111-112.
DISCOVERY REQUEST NUMBER 14 Documents to be relied upon by the Department in support of this allegation are as follows:
219028; 219029; 219030; 219031; 219032; 219033.
The Department will rely on the information contained in its Prehearing Brief, at 113-114.
DISCOVER'1 REQUEST NUMBER 15 Documents to be relied on by the Department in support of this allegation are as follows:
12000049; 219028; 219029; 219030; 219031; 219032; 219033.
13
' j 1
l 1
- l l
1
-,.m .. ~ ~ . . . _ - - - - . _ _
--...p .
Witnesses to be relied on by the Department in support of this allegation are as follows:
. Charles Allen Marvin Luxenburg Herman Rogers Robert Urian Each witness will testify about PPC's refusal to file a rate for 69 kv service to its wholesale customers. .
The Department will also rely on information contained in its Prehearing Brief, at 113.
Respectfully submitted, lAlk 6 0 %, 12, MELVIN G. BERGER I :. . ( u - : ,.. ?
ANTHONY G. AIUVALASIT, J R. .
t >
Attorneys, Antitrust Division U. S. Department of Justice Washington, D.C. 20530 CU St*te of Washington District of Columbia Subscribed and sworn to before me this 29th day of December, 1975.
f$* ) NOTARY 4/ $~wAJ PUBLIC My commission expires 7 I/ '[
l l
.. - . . . . . _ . . . .. . . - . ~ . - - - - ---
--
- T-~
- . s. .
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA ,
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD' In the Matter of ) ,
)
The Toledo Edison Company and )
The Cleveland Electric IlluaADating ) Docket Nos. 50-346A Company ) 50-500A (Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station, ) 50-501A Units 1, 2 and 3) )
)
The Cleveland Electric Illuminating ) Docket Nos. 50-440A Company, et al. ) 50-441A (Perry Nuclear Power Plant, )
Units 1 and 2) )
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of RESPONSE OF DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE TO OHIO EDISON COMPANY'S AND PENNSYLVANIA POWER COMPANY'S MOTION FOR ADDITIONAL DISCOVERY FROM THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE AND' NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION STAFF have been served upon all of the parties listed on the attachment hereto by deposit in the United States mail, first class, airmail or by hand delivery, this 30th day of December 1975. ,
i f . cf II' i l_ b o L ). i~E.:h.t, la. . T.o.o Y*
r.
ANTHONY G. AIUVALASIT , J R.
Attorney, Antitrust Division ,
Dopart.nent of Justice
~
l
- l o
b
- -.. ..- %. . _ s.- -. -
....E*'
ATTACHMENT Douglas V. Rigler, Esq. Gerald Charnoff, Esq.
Chairman, Atomic Safety and Wm. Bradford Reynolds, Esq.
Licensing Board Robert E. Zahler, Esq.
F.oley, Lardner, Hollabaugh Jay H. Bernstein, Esq.
and Jacobs Shaw, Pittman, Potts &
815 Connecticut Avenue, N.W. Trowbridge Washington, D.C. 20006 910 Seventeenth Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20006 Ivan W. Smith, Esq.
Atomic Safety and Licensing Frank R. Clokey, Esq.
Board Special Assistant, Attorney Nuclear Regulatory Commission General Washington, D.C. 20555 Room 219 ,
Towne House Apartments John M. Frysiak, Esquire Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17105 Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Donald H. Hauser, Esq.
Nuclear Regulatory Commission Victor A. Greenslade, Jr., Esq.
Washington, D.C. 20555 The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company Atomic dafety and Licensing 55 Public Square Board Panel Cleveland, Ohio 44101 Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Leslie Henry, Esq.
Michael M. Briley, Esq.
Docketing and Service Section Roger P. Klee, Esq.
Of fice of the Secretary Paul M. Smart, Esq.
Nuclear Regulatory Commission Fuller, Henry, Hodge & Snyder Washington, D.C. 20555 Post Office Box 2088 Toledo, Ohio 43604 Reuben Goldberg, Esq.
David C. Hjelmfelt, Esq. Russell J. Spetrino, Esq.
Goldberg, Fieldman & Thomas A. Kayuha, Esq.
Hjelmfelt Ohio Edison Company .
1700 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W. 47 North Main Street Suite 550 Akron, Ohio 44308 Washington, D.C. 20006 Terence H. Benbcw, Esq.
James B. Davis, Director of A. Edward Grashof, Esq.
Law Steven A. Berger, Esq.
Robert D. Hart, 1st Assistant Winthrop, Stimson, Putnam Director of Law & Roberts -
City of Cleveland 40 Wall Street 213 City Hall New York, New York 10005 Cleveland, Ohio 44114
, Thomas J. Munsch, Esq.
Atomic Safety and Licensing General Attorney Appeal Board Panel Duquesne Light Company e Nuclear Regulatory Commission 435 Sixth Avenue Washington, D.C. 20555 Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15219 w*. m ;+e e *. .= e .ee,e e- .se e a--e- ape- . e- , +e. , -e m g. == -m-+- g .
David Olds, Esq.
William S. Lerach, Esq, Reed, Smith, Shaw & McClay Union Trust Building Box 2009 Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15230 Lee A. Rau, Esq.
Joseph A. Rieser, Jr., Esq.
Reed, Smith, Shaw & McClay Madison Building - Room 404 1155 15th Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20005 Edward A. Matto, Esq. ,
Richard M. Firestone, Esq.
Karen H. Adkins, Esq.
Antitrust Section 30 E. Broad Street 15th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 Christopher R. Schraff, Esq.
Assistant Attorney General Environmental Law Section 361 E. Broad Street 8th Floor Columbus, Ohio 43215 James R. Edgerly, Esq.
Secretary and General Counsel Pennsylvania Power Company One East Washington Street New Castle, Pennsylvania 16103 John Lansdale, Esq.
Cox, Langford & Brown 21 Dupont Circle, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20036 Michael R. Gallagher, Esq.
Gallagher, Sharp, Fulton, Norman & Mollison 630 Bulkley Building
- Cleveland, Ohio 44115 Jack R. Goldberg, Esq.
. Benjamin H. Vogler, Esq.
Roy P. Lessy,1Jr., Esq.
Office of the General Counsel Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.- 20555 ,
.