ML19318E634
| ML19318E634 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 07/27/1988 |
| From: | Rubenstein L Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Raby T NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF STANDARDS & TECHNOLOGY (FORMERL |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8808040176 | |
| Download: ML19318E634 (6) | |
Text
.
t 5
. July'27, 1988'-
i
)
4' Mr. Tawfik M. Raby i
N-17 Secretary Building 235, Room A106 National Bureau of Standards Gaithersburg, Maryland 20899
Dear Mr. Raby:
Enclosed are my ballots for ANS-19.1 "Nuclear Data Sets for Reactor Design i
)
Calculations" (Reaffirmation), ANS-19.3 "The Determination of Neutron Reaction Rate Distributions and Reactivity of Nuclear Reactors" (Reaffirmation),
ANS-19.3.4 "The Determination of Thermal Energy Deposition Rates in Nuclear-Reactors" (Reaffirmation), and ANS-19.4. "A Guide for Acquisition and Documentation of Reference Power Reactor.Physics Measurements for Nuclear Analysis-Verification" (Reaffirmation).
i I have voted "approved" for ANS-19.1 and ANS-19.3 and "approved with comments" for ANS-19.3.4 and ANS-19.4, and have included the required comments.
i Sincerely, t
I original signed by i
Lester S. Rubenstein, Assistant Director l
for Region IV and Special Projects Division of Reactor Projects - III, IV,-
V and Special Projects Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation f
Enclosure:
l As stated j
i l
DISTRIBUTION:
i ECentral File z
l
'NRC PDR' PDSNP Reading 4
j-EHylton AAdams i
CMiller l
LRubenstein-L._..- O
- See Previous Concurrence gf03 i
PDSNP*
PDSNP*
AD:PDSNP*
ADR.
EHylton AAdams:cw CMiller LRubenstei 07/21/88 07/21/88 07/21/88 07/47/88 hl r}ibi esoso4o176 880727 J((
CF SUBJ i
j RD-7-3 kC 4)
_,__y...,
y_. _,,..
,,,,_,,.,,s
,,,~,,,,,,,_.,,m.,,,,
,...m....._m...,,....,, _., _
. p ung g'o UNITED sTATES
~g 8'
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION n
E WASHINGTON. D. C. 20555
,/
July 27, 1988
- ,+
Mr. Tawfik M. ktby N-17 Secretary Building 235, Room A106 National Bureau of Standards Gaithersburg, Maryland 20899
Dear Mr. Raby:
Enclosed are my ballots for ANS-19.1 "Nuclear Data Sets for Reactor Design Calculations" (Reaffirmation), ANS-19.3 "The Determination of Neutron Reaction Rate Distributions and Reactivity of Nuclear Reactors" (Reaffirmation),
ANS-19.3.4 "The Determination of Thermal Energy Deposition Rates in Nuclear Reactors" (Reaffirmation), and ANS-19.4. "A Guide for Acquisition and Documentation of Reference Power Reactor Physics Measurements for Nuclear Analysis Verification" (Reaffirmation).
I have voted "approved" for ANS-19.1 and ANS-19.3 and "approved with comments" for ANS-19.3.4 and ANS-19.4, and have included the required comments.
Sincerely, b
N S-
.r_ m &
Lester S.
enstein, Assistant Director for Region IV and Special Projects Division of Reactor Projects - III, IV, Y and Special Projects Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulacion
Enclosure:
As stated
.. ANSI NIT CO@HWtstC LOALQtf#g i
ANS-19.1 Nuclear Data Sets'for Reactor Design Calculations
]
Document:
(Reaffirmation)
BALLOT DUE:
July 29, 1988
-i I
X Approved j
Approved with Concents 4
Not Approved j
Not Voting (Note - all "Approved with Coments" and "Not Approved" ballots Coments:
must include coments.)
J 1
1 8
i
\\
i d
i
.OkudthahM Th27fQ cy j
Return ballot to:
Signature Lester S. Rubenstein j
T. M. Raby N-17 Secretary 2
1 National Bureau of Standards USNRC Building 235, Room A106 Representing i
Gaithersburg, MD 20899 1
a d
0 i
~
ANSI N]7 COMMITTEE BALLOT
]
i ANS-19.3 - The Determinazion of.Neutron Reaction Rate Distributions Document:
and Reactivity of Nuclear Re.actors (Reaffirmation)
BALLOT DUE:
July 29, 1988 i
I X
Approved l
i I
I Approved hith Coments i
1
)
i Not Approved l
)
Not Voting j
(Nete - all "Approved with Coments" and "Not Approved" ballots j
Coments:
must include coments.)
l 1
l I
I
\\
1 J
.i i
1 4
N j
l i
i i
l Ltb rfn f(,
s, Eeturn ballot to:
Sighature Lester 5. Rubenstein T. M. Raby N-17 Secretary National Bureau of Standards USNRC Building 235, Room A106 Representing Gaithersburg,is 20899 i
-.._,._,.._...._...___........__..._,.,_,_....~.,,...._I
ANS3 N17 COMMITTEE BALLOT Document: ANS-19.3.4 - The Determination of Thermal Energy Deposition Rates
~
in Nuclear Reactors (Reaffirmation)
BALLOT DUE:
July 29, 1988 l
Appreved
]
)
X Approved with Comments Not Approved Not Voting
]
Com=ents:
(Note - all "Approved with Comments" and "Not Approved" ballots j
must include comments.)
Section 2 Scope. The statement is made that the scope is limited to the reactor core. However, items such as the pressure vessel and biological shielding is discussed.
Section 3.2 Glossary of Terms. Should be in alphabetical order. The term Kerma introduced in Section 5 seems to belong here.
Section 7 Documentation. There is a typographical error in the first line.
i i
[k'2 7 h I Ldd L
~1 Return ballot to:
Slgnature Lester S. Rubenstein T. M. Raby N-17 Secretary National Sureau of Standards innpr Building 235, Room A106 Representing Gaithersburg, MD 20899
--=-*e-
- --=. -., - -,, -,, _,,.,,
ANSI N17 COMMITTEE BALLOT ANS-19.4 - A Guide for Acquisition and Documentation of Reference
~
Document: Power Reactor Physics Measurements for Nucicar Analysis Verification (Reaffirmation)
BALLOT DUE:
July 29. 1988 Approved X
Approved with Comments Not Approved Not Voting (Note - all "Approved with Comments" and "Not Approved" ballots.
Co=ent s:
must include com:nents.)
Section 6.3.2 "Best Estimates" when recommended by an ANS standard should require justification if possible.
4 i
4 J
.U 1
- l i
d C
')
Return ballot to:
Ibid E d 7 77fSk Signature T. M. Raby Lester S. Rubenstein N-17 Secretary National Bureau of Standards USNRC Building 235 Room A106 Representing Gaithersburg, MD 20899 6
v
-