ML19312E927
| ML19312E927 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 05/12/1980 |
| From: | NRC COMMISSION (OCM) |
| To: | |
| References | |
| REF-10CFR9.7 NUDOCS 8006180176 | |
| Download: ML19312E927 (7) | |
Text
_. - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ - _ _ - _ _ _.
P D W l
3 ILb/18 1
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 2,
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 3
PUBLIC MEETING i
4 AFFIRMATION. SESSION 80-21 g
5 8
6; Nuclear Regulat6ry' Commission ~
e7 Room 1130 a,
7 1717 H.-Street, N.W.
A Washington, D.C.
O e
Monday, May 12, 1980 d
9 2.
PRESENT:
10 Affirmation Session 80-21 was convened, pursuant to h
11 '
notice, at 3 : 00 p.m.
it d
12 z
y 13 l CHAIRMAN JOHN E:. aHEARNE l
14 COMMISSIONER VICTOR GALINSKY U.
2 15 COMMISSIONER JOSEPH M. HENDRIE
.ax g
16 COMMISSIONER PETER A BRADFORD i
f 17 NRC STAFF PRESENT:
p 5i 18l 5
l SECRETARY SAMUEL J.
CHILK E _. _
E I
2 s
19 l 2
"e n;
j E
9 20 i t
)
t PT N-
,I 21,
i -
,7
( f3 S
~
~
22 O
i (J l 23 !
j i
10 24 i j
l i
I 25 80b6180
/7 1
i ALDERSON REPORTING COMPANY, INC.
2 I
3
_P _R _O _C _E _E _D _I _N _G _S 2 i CHARIRMAN AHEARNE:
We have a short affirmation session 3
so perhaps if you could keep the noise level down we could immed-i 4:
iately go to that.
l s
5l Sam.
4.
a j
6l SECRETARY CHILK:
The first paper is SECY-A-80-49.
R i
4 7l The purpose is to secure Commission approval of a draft order e
e.]
8 draf ting the Acting Chairman of the ASLBP to constitute a d
9!
hearing board.
The Commission has unanimously approved that z
l
^wg 10 l order indicating that if hearings are held they should focus on z
=
i II changes of the technical specs and not on TMI Unit 2 cleanup E
Y 12 ! or whether TMI 2 should be allowed to operate.
Commissioners 3
I ag 13 l. Gilinsky and Bradford, preferred to leave the precise scope
=
t z
-5 I4 ;. of the hearings to the board's discretion as long as the partic-b j.
15 ular contentions are relevant to the changes in the tec.
specs.
l y
16 f They agreed to renewed operation of TMI 2 is not part of the pro-n E
I7 ceeding.
Would you please affirm?
_T 3
I8 !
CHAIRMAN AHEARNE:
Aye.
=
8 I9,*
g COMMISSIONER GILINSKY:
Aye.
i 20 !
COMMISSIONER HENDRIE:
Aye.
2I li COMMISSIONER BRADFORD.
You got the wrong number.
i 22,
SECRETARY CHILK:
80-49.
t 23 COMMISSION BRADFORD:
No.
If all of us af firm our votes,'
24 with just John and Victor voting do you think you are going to wind 25 up with an order?
l i
r ALDERSON REPORTING COMPANY. INC.
3 I
SECRETARY CHILK:
I thought you had approved the order 2l with those reservations.
I guess I had asked previously as to s
l I
3 how to represent you.
4 COMMISSIONER BRADFORD:
Doesn't it say at the bottom l
0 3I I am taking a walk?
N I
6l SECRETARY CHILK:
That is on the other paper.
R
- S 7
COMMISSIONER BRADFORD:
I thought it said it on this s
j 8
one too.
d 9
COMMISSIONER GILINSKY:
That is right.
z oy 10 lI SECRETARY CHILK:
I only intended that you take a walk, z
i 5
4 IIl not to particiate on this one.
B l
I I2 !
COMMISSIONER BRADFORD:
I think I have to take a walk 5
1 g
13 {
on this one too.
=
'A i
5 I4 COMMISSIONER HENDRIE:
Should we review the bidding.
o
=
I 15 g
SECRETARY CHILK:
It depends on how you charactertize
=.
\\
I6 3
the vo te.
-A f
I7 !
COMMISSIONER BRADFORD:
Now that you are back, John,
=
w g
18 I will just take a walk.
19 'l SECRETARY CHILK:
Would you affirm your votes?
g i
20 l CHAIRMAN AHEARNE:
Aye.
2Ili COMMISSIONER HENDRIE:
Aye.
22,
CCMMISSIONER GILINSKY:
Aye.
l 23 SECRETARY CHILK:
The second is SECY-A-90-42, the 24j request for hearing on Point Beach.
In this case the Commission i
25 by majority vote -- the Chairman, CommissionerKennedy,Commissionhi i
I l
1 ALDERSON REPORTING COMPANY. INC.
i
l l
4 I
l jl Hendrie constituting the majority -- Commissioner Bradford i
2j and Gilinsky dissenting.
And I understand in this case Com-l 3l missioner Bradford will not participate, i
I COMMISSIONER BRADFORD:
Since there has been a slight 4
I change even to what I circulated to you last, since this is the a
5 A
l 6j last item on the affirmation session why don' t we quick it over a
I in the 42nd Discussion Session.
7 8
SECRETARY CHILK:- This is the last item.
You circu-3 lated a dissentz 9
i h
10 COMMISSIONER.BRADFORD:.
I would just call that dissent z
h 11 l to your attention and then I will drop out as I promised you.
<3 d
12 CHAIRMAN AHEARNE:
That is your dissent?
Z 3
13 COMMISSIONER BRADFORD:
Yes, sir, a
4
=
g 34 CHAIRMAN AHEARNE:
That is his dissent.
Thank you, NC!
15 Peter.
E 1
)
16 !
COMMISSIONER HENDRIE:
John and I approve your dissent 3
A g
j7 or your right to make it.
E j
18.
CHAIRMAN AHEARNE:
Tnere are many famous quotations that!
E 19 l support your 'right to dissent.
3 n
20l Sam.
33 l SECRETARY CHILK:
There are~three of you r then voting
,)
i i
l on the order that was circulated to you cirecting the board, the ll 22 i
23 panel chairman, the panel or board, and determine whether a 1
24 hearing is required and giving them other instructions.
We have l
l l 25 Commissioner Bradford's dissenting views which will be attached.
i Il t
l ALDERSON REPORTING COMPANY, INC.
Ij
5 1
Commissioner Bradford will not participate and select.
The will 2
of the majority will be accomplished, Commissioner Kennedy 3
having voted with the majority and would if he were here.
4 Would you please affirm?
e 5
CHAIRMAN AHEARNE:
Aye.
A9 3
6 COMMISSIONER HENDRIE:
Aye.
m Rg 7i COMMISSIONER GILINSKY:
Let us see ---
N 8,
CHAIRMAN AHEARNE:
No, it is too late.
dd 9
COMMISSIONER GILINSKY:
No, I am not going to change zo t
10 my vote but what I wanted to raise is the question of the E
5 11 Commissioner voting before he has seen other Commissioners ' views.
<3 ti 12 CHAIRMAN AHEARNE:
Dissent?
z E
d 13 l COMMISSIONER GILINSKY:
Had you seen those?
E i
E 14 l SECRETARY CHILK:
The change was circulated to all the d
I u!
15 ! offices.
w=
16 COMMISSIONER HENDRIE:
His office had seen it.
B W
N 17 COMMISSIONER GILINSKY:
Say no more.
E l
=
i 18 !
COMMISSIONER HENDRIE:
Dick is absolutely faithful
{
19 ; about calling his office every day.
I have never been able to do n
20 ! it myself but he is just ironclad about it.
I CHAIRMAN AHEARNE:
And I guess I wouldn't want to i
21 l
22 necessarily joint a principle that every change in view means --- l l
23 COMMISSIONER HENDRIE:
Preventing a vote.
i l
24 CHAIRMAN AHEARNE:
Yes, sir.
l i
25 COMMISSIONER GILINSKY:
But we are not talking about l
ALDERSON REPORTING COMPANY. INC.
6 a vote of those present.
We are talking about the votes of j
I 2l those absent.
But as long as he has seen the materinis ---
CHAIRMAN AHEARNE:
The representative of his office 3
l 4j is not against.
COMMISSIONER GILINSKY:
Fine.
e 5
E n
s ends $
6lt (Thereupon, at 3:10 p.m.,
the hearing was adjourned.)
e O
\\
E, 7
I 8
n dd 9
I i
i E
10 i=
E 11 c
I 3
i E
1 y
13 l
=
i E
14 !
E i
k
=
15 :
3[
16 l s
i 17,
x 5
5 18,
E 19 !
x 20 !
21 !
i 22j 23 24l i
i,
25 f
.ll ALDERSON REPORTING COMPANY. INC.
a -=.
lO This is to certify that the attached proceedings before the NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION in the matter of: Affirmation Session 80-21
- Date of Proceeding:
May 12, 1980 Docket Number:
Place of Proceeding:
Washington, D. C, were held as herein appears, and that this is the original transcript thereof for the file of the Commission.
Joan Gill Official Reporter (Typed)
. s..
/
C /t Official Reporter (Signature) o
,., _ - _ _ _ _.