ML19309G638

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Response to 800314 Interrogatories.Includes Info Re Pertinent Lers,Potential Witnesses & Bibliographical Matl Used by Intervenor as Background for Contentions
ML19309G638
Person / Time
Site: Big Rock Point File:Consumers Energy icon.png
Issue date: 04/03/1980
From: Oneill J
AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED
To: Gallo J
CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.)
References
NUDOCS 8005070280
Download: ML19309G638 (7)
v • d • e


Text

o 1 h M4e+ e =

9 8005070290 7 DOCKETNUffDER

{

USNRC 4,outn 2, 3cx Sh PROD,& UTIL FAc M 19 " City, Michigan h9664 G

1 APR 101980 > T

~-

~

~

W 1 3,1980 Office of the Seasley 3^

Mr. Joseph Gallo, Esquir Doc M p N For Consumers Pcwer Compa:.4 Rer;ardings Isham, Lincoln & Beale

. mig Rock Point g 'l 1980 y

Mg 1120 Connecticut A'renue, N.W. e Huclear Power Plcnt Washingten. D.C.

20036 Docket nuzicer 50-155 Daar Mr. Gallo This.is my answer to your interrogatories of March 14, 1980 You will note that my list of witnesses is extraemly tentativS I

am not being evasive at alls the point is that at this moment I have contacted only one possible witness.

Beyond a problem of inortia, the spectre of very high witness fees and travel expenssa has prevented me from contacting witnesses until now.

I am working on a more definite list of witnesses and financini arrangement that nibht provide suitable experts despite my severely limited funde.

I uncerstand the continuing nature of this set of interrogatcries, and will inform you promptly of any progress.

I shall sand you a latter within two weeks concerning witnesses.

Enclosed is an updated bibliography which contains nearly a.'.1 of the books that I have been reading, nn whole or in parto and which I use as background infennal; ion for my intervention.

I have marked those books that for:s substantial basis for my work, and when appro--

priate, have indicated the specific hontenticna and corresponding books.. Might I auggest that some of those volumes form a strong,trya responnible counter-balance to the position ad*nnend by the indus and. wotrid be very infomative reading for yourself?

I an' citing all of the incidents from the'" reportable occuranca" filathat I presently know of.

My confederates have dono significantly more research in the Public Document Room in the Charlevoix library than myself, and as soon as they chare the fruits of their labors with me. I shall forward.all appropriate information to you.

This holds true, of course, for any further research I may do as well.

Interrogatories 1,

Documents and Licensee Event Reports For Contention IIG Potential cask drop 9/22/"78 10/6/'78 For 15. corrosion.'and IIA, Routine releases of radioactivity:

All relate small to medium 8

'78 1

26P78-releases of radioactive water, all 8

  • 78 9

$78 related to the spent fuel pool or 9

'7 1

/'79

/*9 i

related equiptment.

10 79

'79 l

For VII, Plant safety history:

All of the ve.

b a

c

(

r. ::

  • T 7

/S ' '

1.

3 f s JU r.-. 4 6.. W. -

o.

.t;{,c.,;..

' : c r % cu= 3.Me t e. C inR...*, S.

. ~,

s

r I'0, IID, IlE2 and. IE3: ' ecr -

e.

t, a

. y

  • r necident. in 4hFN:pandedQ e.cequenEs'oM. altre-b.?p'c 2 Christa-7. sis'c Inter: cgatcry 9-30, 'tk/h.nt fudl^ peel:3.'T

13"Y'_' t '.I' Ahrraar3 't'o

' - L. '_.

Y.N W12 >

" Mr.rch 19.11930.

@, ? % A letter to f.r. Goller dated July. i g 1974 containc en '"

Attachment A", and cat 2rini is to be uced from this.

document, including, but, not restricted to pagcc. 22, n

3-11--3-14, (Safe :y Related Equiptment) cnd 7 '. h7 and Table 7-1,. (TtH3PONSE TO LOSS GF SAFETY E3LITED n 'J.,',

i

/ EQUI *fIENT.

, 7,

.v T

on steam c:plosica from I..clTYd I

"t

?

' bfq 11pctrie'y!qr, p:Co c Q.

fuel, see reading lint.,

s IBs, 'corrosien, IIA, IID, cnall to medium rolcarco of rb.T.f.k,-

M or

' "y

q. ace.

activiyr a

g

.Mg sm,[37@ti_on, pcgas 1U2-164 and Famin.

h adi g lict

'..b..<...-3 Criticality 31LC.l E i@3bnSL. pp 57-50 and bc dn, Rac' ins list.

l U. ud Food Chcin -

Cha~<t or b," ',7, Pomn. Gen, ar,.t$.on m:d,E,.nvi--onmental Chen.vo e

Marr.tl.diconbud. Mcading list.

.i plonr,qgdp;,,qg,. PmcJ.n.

4 w

u -
u...

~

Th3 German study on' criticality in a spent fuel pool.j -

Unfortunately,"1 do not havo thic ctudy On hand, but i

'it was handed cut and diccucsed at conc lensth atj.;,

'the pre-hearing cenferencoe and chould be familiars:

to you..Mr. Gallo..and the utility.

If you wiche 1; shall find it' coon,. and moro properly identify it.

mAlso for contantion IIE-3.,

r.

Mitncacae

'T.

(. z):. These arc ~ not' witnessas that. L pir:tgi to call, but.rathei.

' those that I wou'Id hopa to call. ' More information shall bei provided'as available.'~.

%:t

^

Contentions on releaso of radio' activity, the donc, tha health effects of released radiation, and accuculation of fission.prcducts in the food chaint t

Dr. Helen Caldicott. MD

.. y, Dr. Ernest Sternglass, Phd, Profdsser of Radiaision Physien g

s Sr. Rosalie:Bertel, Phd in aio Statistics.3 of Euffalo Contentiens.on corrosion and durability. affects of" compaction,Lcriticality,. accidental releases of radio-activity,; venting,cand plant cancgement hictory:

2

..s a

Dr. Richard Webb of Toledo r

Robert Pollard, a nuclear engineer, and member of the Union of-Concerned Scientists.

D*

]D

]D ]Yk U

e o Ju o JbuSU.

o t

~3s Plant History as revanled in documents in the Cha:levoin Public Library Public Document Room:

JoAnn Bior and Shirley Johns., members of the Concerned, Citizens for the Charlevoix Area valid witnesses

's by virtue of their long hours in research, and because the baeic of their. testimony will by the compiny's own reporto.

They may be called to introduco '

evidence on other contentions, drawing frca the company's reports.

The dccuments they will introduce will be reported later, when I have word from them.

Plant History:

An attempt will be made to call former and present

' employees of Consumers Power Ccenpany.

They are not na: nod here, partially because I am not clear on the rules governing witness who can be assumed to be voluctant to testify. er even downright hostile.

These questions will bb answered later as the problem becomes clearer.

In the meantime, Mr. Gallo, you may wish to educate ma on the treatment proceedure on unco-operative witnesses in a hearing before anNRC hearing board.

IID B-52 Bomber crash:

t An attempt will be made to obtain an imformed and qualified witness.from the USAF on the B-$2 problem, w

however the problems mentioned above may be prosent in this case also.

Sections ib, ic. id and to ara imposcible to ancwor at this timo, au explained above.

I shall answer in full these questions as soon as possible.

Hote:

It is highly likely that some or all of the above witnesces will be unable to serve as my witnesses.

I do not therefore limit myself to the above-named witnasses.

I shall inform all parties as econ as witnesses arscontacted, of' any new witnescos, changes, and further details.

I hops. Mr. Gallo, that those responsas'are helpful to you.

I.have answered you1' questions as well as I possibly can,.and to the best of my present knowledge, have withheld nothing.

I shall suppliment these answere shortlys write me if you have any difficulty.

Thank you for your patience.

Sincerely ym m

)

D,a I

~Q M

J ohn O'Neill II Intervenor l-Copies sent to all on thd qormal mailing listo Should the board dent ny request for relieffromthe 20 copy requirement I shall promptly supply the copies..

.o

... ~

W :.nc L: u t coa r. -.p..:,

c t :. i dpu :,2 -

  • m c, l - :x tr a 3
.tr.*?&'
  • C aM n; ::.:nsc::: sc;, al 1;> L.:t;;, : ca ' m;;r, n :;t:.m i.. 1 s.m e c. r.c.

t:::.: K n.n :2:C a.LLe M r,qn311.y,5a;3

0
-~.sr.t:cD.s 'P.

re:r 1:::::,,at W, c.r. M.tfB S:s :alCi c 1, T.,

J. rei,ectieabr Tn W1; c::? N.m W.. ir; 3-r. c.v.15.a - rr i. ace

w,: r:rt.t :".359 Effria)};;c..er.uttyu

- 't sa r.rf bn.t A.,1

.e.ww;yyrx..ennJon.muue 197

c ' gun ~~:.c.3 o ' L l or's (*f : E n.rn o u t.' : 6 4 L liWJ ; r c' t ccTC$

-.:,: L :.

-1 %

r

.v.v iv

. t.". a,. o

m. r.. ;.;. ~;e u cun.. L { O u 3 c ro '.t.,.no.

York-Pn11 un tin.:,

s.

.,:.tbod rtl .'.,,,,.,A c. TC. H.r ' "", -J u.-

w.

.7 n v L u

.aa;tt t.or.

. u. E. M i c;.tg 1 /..

.M.x'c t..a r M m%e ;- Cia cur t ty. M sk o o f th e p n c er.

r a..

i.u.l. M GG.

.acuingun D.l,.-

t.no rict.n Cnte r;.r Lne 1:wa a t.e f ar P.utlic Policy mor.rch.197C.

..y

,341,6"2 u 9 4.,~

N WCL T

.o c i. T.r, H31pa Y "Thn. ?!u c'. e te r Cc,it tr o ve r s y.

G r o onv i c h,,

Cc a.'

'y' Tuot Gyeteon NT47'~~~Mi?t usp LTPL

~

n

.'.,.t i z c r.,3

'n,.,

- ' u w i s., Richard i.,

T.h..e !:ucle:nr-Power Hubc1] i cin; The A'.cmic InductM !.s t.. 611 stru.n t, tan 79ric ; T w: V 2. '<.. n.

Pr:3 4,. '~W/ *. -

3d 6,f 4 Lou TCPL c

D kger, H. Pe,ar, Tho

t. :.o m i r. t_o t. c..b 112,h,,n.c. a t mec

';>-k-Cl w.m nn d S c hua t er,,

n.-,c,

331 4..,c

.o. ? 3 h en,i.

r:

. r, n u t,., Halph~g.ind /ibto tte - Jo hn.,,

The f:enri:e of A tc. m c h r y f',

- 1Mn Yorkf W.ulf. tr.i r to n.O Co '~D77a -

521,4335 hl24 tmMCL 614, f.

NAD LTPL

+-

...., ~.

n r.1k in Corot hy? ' tauclent Porir and it a britica.

1theca, tL o'! : "

oCornel'. Univcru ity Pres e, 17/1, 62.11 61 t:3ie imseCL i

. e vick,. ; C,holdon

.'The'Cordow A t o ml.

-boston:

boughton ::irn in

~

Co,,, J19 69.

. F4Y.,4 J$~ - no v

.TCPL

~

/ o > >. /.' a

..:f:

c y r.ovickJ Sheldon, 'The Electric w'ar; The Fight Over Nucienr"

~

Po ce r..

Can FEncleco : Clerru Glub nonks,, IV7E.

TSS.,7

-NOV LTPL i

.a

(

~Olson.

61cKinleyiC;.c Uriacceptnble Hick; The_ taucle'q,Porer

~ -

I

. Controversy,v tis p Pa rP. : Bantam Pc oKc,,

i v / o.

^ I. a,. ? ~~TS3~T ols :

LTPLe Pamphists from taorthwestern 2.lchigan College Librcry:

(From the Vertics Filei "I

<,etb maryih$ya, The.buc. leer fuel: -- -- h e Atom.ic lloot of t

,, s,

2 Problem M.-i,llatM under Atomic Power t

2DoMk ~Uene h Huclear_ [;oyier Controverayf Listsd under ' Atomic Po ter Planta.

l Greer. tiilliam,

'/Jr t.Do. Y o'n Do Wi th a De ad tauko ?

Listed under.'Nucioer rue.e.

mm n

~

9 3

h d,

y

=

e -.o e

.. I 1.., *.

[..,,...,,

.. ~............r.

.,.,.s.,,i.,,,

(..

.e

, : :.,1...,

, l' !.a ".., t_ ; } ', ! "..

.o-

,....,e.

'.r,......c.,-.-.-.s.

i

  • .(..,GIt

' L ;!

i '.' f ;;...

  • I ) l' a.d,' r. g I

.. U.. 9

.J.,, "......v....e,,,.. a e..

,**t...,,,.

^.

c...(.

.i...

r

..,.4

. d.1.

e a

.r.>

is 3

.-)

.......t.... f h,.,,..,....

...t

.G 44 v...

A,, 6 4.. -

...v.

.r.'

s..

.i.1

..,a a ' ::p a tarn t a f cubil"

?. NILL., sny;ulon c! M c.d ' u.t -

_c._nr...o..r.c. r..m. i. ~P ub l. i.c F.r: tu t h.

..n,..'.d.,.:..r !.. ;

h a.1 ", n..

Im1

.i fi I. l'.O V$I' L 1 C:11 1'l ). '.'

L. '. d. '.'.. -...

D T [C d10 0.I.

iQj [C1,,

t

~

^

A *, J.Tl 1'F)'.') 0 r l'1,. f.* ra L 0 s *'I f' '. I b,' 't n..

( 'a k I ' i 7

  • 6. 'l' I' 'I11

.6:

)

t 9 e. 7_., g o

  • s.. '

I.> s e.s..._s..

., _.t., c m....

Ai p

'/. e,1

.-. ', '. ;. * ' i t. s

  • c

}

.(,,.....,

c p.r1n. E [

u-w i..,

., s. v.:.:

..c. -( r.

c L,,.:3. mr1

.u

.: a st. :.v i,
  • ' "" 1 L ' : t et t',.*
  • Co ' i.t l L 6 ; o r.
f. : i nn i t'. 81
1.. i '.

.. G ; C 3.,.: a t. e.~o..L_.: '.,1. : ; : c_c '.. a f

.%. ::.e M.:.: _L e,..n..r r,., : :.

'.'.u.L c.u._x.'.'

1 ; i:,.

,gias,%bt,/O) 1

-.c.{.It..d...",.; t. t. 0 0.L.c_0,,1.O, r *f

.. n...

s....

m-. _

.- M 3 *. :; on.2diatien t.un g.

JJ. r. C Ver tice.1 fi).o )

r r.o., i c e > n gr.

a.. r,.,

f. a.a ).,.

. t... s..,.- _i.m,

r..

+.4 7,'. C G p : (

  • L,.;c '.,'..i._....

....O..,

, ss Q

C 1

.I'O 71 T*..

Iil.M O /', r,. U.n". C ( ; i ;,8,..; ' C j'..1 L i ? O 5 l.

', f.; h ' j

        • WU C M. lO C h,; if. 1

... ~,./ :.)

L 3.D..l' f.,: i rii.'.. M_M O.1.s'_:1 r...V._/ C. 9..t. C. 1976.,

idOO1G indV11 LIia1

.i~C AG Je Pt,K 1 O f.1 A n t t i; i Rj O.'..ic t i.i 3

. G,.. ' 4G e 4

'Zl-71 0 1 "NlUfQ D 31D fi

.:C,.'~. ' *Q U h i T. 3% 0 U r.

IU.

i' o. s..(

r.,-. i r.. d * + '. -.

...,-4.,.

i ra tr 7 r

,s.,,e... a.

  • 4 c q.

,1

.3

.t 1

~typ,.,.,

. s..

5 v.

u

..-.m.

/.r thur M/;,d.

I P

..oc..;r.. M.' m..

Co v, i t: s, David'A und Sqan 02,,

-a v ir c tmie.nta.l C. he n':c.,

Car.J.4r it's.a ha n. > 7 b.

ML. Ra,

)[q*fk3 Z. ') L 17J T o.%..' C,

'd'1 *r b1 ***b

  • C W

r e

.p

..v

..e_c. -.trLc %..:_...

nr

".tll rnm E and 1. to f f."'. '711b t.: N. c d c.,

sl

...c'.N.i c.h.i a n.

. a. e.f.o r.a l The Al t.e. r.i.u.. t..i.v..e.r:

..nu Ar.?,:

. induct.ri d Da vo l o p r.ca'. v. ; i c i o n, in c) t L t.r. t. :

>t S c i.. ^

2 te

t ch.

a, o n.<

and T e c.inolo g,y i, lu., r..

t ie r fn.e.... e.s.._o _

..tif c:' '.i r -...

Th. F ' t-E'.:1hharte Caro.l r.nd St e inhcr t,. Jc hn.

 ? n u e.r.,c, :R.u :. ;....:-..

F.n c rirr Y e a t". ed ay.a. To rt..Pr c rr,

.-a m.,

Dux. irv g>reSO p r.3 d s. C

. i A ilt

' O C O ', I 'i'J U

'.'.nd PrC it') U V 3 f ' 'T i. 0 V! '.

. o - +. ' '[l +

'J "

'.1. s y l' *.* e.. '.,

^

v' M r :..

A iA) ' s,2 s s.

. m.,

..O s e. I.f,.3

p..,...A d,a.

a.

s t

c *..

s p

,'p

^

  1. 4-I

.4 4

,.4 h

g

?) 0R 0Rfg _&

.,.m,

..aw o

^

haacinG List page 3 q.

., x-

~x c.e.

rer r.u.if il; S :eno: tics as if Fuoole dentes: hor, 1. T.

E.1111 la f.atter e d.

. !.o c torz: iiurper c: Hon 2.5 /C f

\\

,I lio s to G ganice i

,o 80icer.% Antho'ny4:, Sheldon,, Karin P., and Weiss Ellyn R.,

~

e NIMc 2iuclear Intervonore TreIning. Encal; An In_tervencr 8s Guide to Enc 1 cur Pcwcr Lmt Nuclear

,.?
Infor stion and hescurcu Service, Inc., 1536 Sixtuunth

'~

St. N% nahhinston D.C.

20036e (20B)-4 & OO45, 1976 gani::ind innual. ThcWar' ha L t.cr *a Leesub. 3M Lafayett%

s Sow; fork City, seu York; 10 013 43.50

~

s

..t

.. r.

e c

Linny of. those books.are e.vaila'cle in public librarices

~ nlonc, n1th Libraries that 1 knori have thago booko are lictod o the call numbe-a for the book *n that specific library.

These nu bors may -bs differant fron the numbers to. tha bock in anotber

library, check.1 S_ome; of; the backa are in fact pro-nucle.cr po ner = Theco are.lieted bhanuze they do carry soco usefui of radiation are arbitrarly cetf co.bo careful./, and esfa leyela informations :Fncte arid-data 'can be manipulated Gany of the books-listed aro available in paperback' and cen' be obtained or' ordered through local bookstorsa.

En cura ge your local.

I am not, f amiliar with' backs. in the Charlevo 1x Library,controv:: rey.

etcror to....

carry: good)bcoks on the nuclear aowcr but' thia Library Abbreviar. ions library has e 7:calth NUMCLS Northwesterr. MichiscJi Collego

~of epocific inf ormation on' Big Rock and'its

,:Libraryc cpen;to tt)o publica problems in tha public

?

Cocumenta rccms

> LTFL Lselend Towriship Pub 2.ic Library TCPL

Traverse City Public, Library
  • A Y

i

}.

Mer. ding List Paste 4 Co cner, he:y,.T,,J12, Eerertg of F53gri gn=rre gj the 35;Sm;D. Pjush r' 7crha Alfred A. Knopf 1976

~7 E q:. I~1;&. n r.E C a r 3 1Sl 2 m.V h l

Tu i~', ~0b ert, Thp, Neca. Tyr,ayqpy:

".rans13.ted by Christopher Trumr, New Yorkt ilarnar Bec::3, W79.

W 'rmav Ronort to the Prebi:'ent3 Ks.cney Conmission.,19/%

.sA.

4... h h I'".elete % gu3atory Co'r.icsion Special Inquiry Group, F.e a/in, "itcheb Cirector Th ae Mile Island:.A _Re rt to the C ow-d..e e i s ~~ m e

to tie,Zublic, Vol. I.

Washington, Goterncent Prinu.ng CTfic0, 14TO.

/ r.cc en, James, editor: Time Bomb A Euclear Render frcn the Pre.;c,rqc.ly

<adison, Wisconsin _tThe Progrsssive ' oundation,1900,..

/

firiironmental Action Foundation., 2tsphenson, Lee rr.d Z:cher, Cecrge, p

t editorc r. Accidentp1 il,i,1.,1, yg,rpan:7&g C,y g Aggint i'ueim>r FS1!ar.

Usw York: Harper and Roti.

4 P00R gggy

~

E to s'

e d

t.

O

{ ' *t.

e

'g.-.

f

-r

~

-+-e,,m

-e 4 %

e

-.A

_a-_-

f *:1.o

  • c

-e

^%

9 9

,e m O

a l

s_

=

.s e.'*-w N

4 e

e i

a i

. 48s

, - F.i

~

\\

S l

i l

'J S NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSlott DOCKETING & SERVICE SECTIOl4 GFICE G THE SECRETARY G THE COMMISSION Document Statistics a

Postmark Date

" ~

Copies Received l

Add'l Copies Reproduce 338 5,.cw Distribunon m

w 8

4 e

m m

.

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML19309G638&oldid=4801350"