ML19309E525
| ML19309E525 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Big Rock Point File:Consumers Energy icon.png |
| Issue date: | 04/02/1980 |
| From: | CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.) |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19309E521 | List: |
| References | |
| IEB-79-14, NUDOCS 8004220581 | |
| Download: ML19309E525 (7) | |
Text
._
t
- o '
f.
e' 5
4 i
i
)
i l
FINAL RESPONSE
[
.TO I
I U.S. NRC IE BULLETIN 79-14 P
t FOR
'l 1~
BIG ROCK POINT NUCLEAR PLANT l
I I
CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY 4
i i
.[
-J t
l l
l a
.I i
i i
I 4
I iF
- i i
i i
. October. 31,19.79 Revision 1, April-2,1980 i
-.s i
o l
I.
I l
i i
I s
f I
1 i
i-t 8004s30
BRP/79-14 R1 vision 1 April 2,1980 Table of Contents Page 1.
INTRODUCTION 1
2.
ORGANIZATION 1
3.
SYSTEM IDENTIFICATION 2
4.
INSPECTION 2
A.
Period of Inspection 2
B.
Elements of Inspection 2
C.
Results of Inspection 3
D.
Insulation Removal 3
E.
Primary Coolant System 4
F.
Accessibility 4
G.
Verification of Pipe Wall Thickness and Pipe Welds 5
H.
ADDITIONAL INSPECTION Sa 1
5.
ANALYSIS 6
A.
Flexibility Analysis 6
B.
Seismic Analysis 6
6.
NONCCNFORMANCES 7
7.
RESOLUTION OF INSPECTION ITEMS 7
I 8.
CONCLUSIONS 7
l t
i
BRP/79-14 Ravision 1 April 2,1980 3.
SYSTEM IDENTIFICATION Current BRP systems were reviewed, and those systems having safety-related piping are listed below, along with the applicable Piping and Instrumentation Diagram (P&ID) drawing numbers.
P&ID SYSTEM 0740G40106 Steam and condensate system 0740G40107 Reactor cleanup, shutdown, and poison system 0740G40108 Radwaste system 0740G40lll Circulating, cooling, and service water systems 0740G40121 Nuclear steam supply system 0740G40122 Control rod drive system 0740G40123 Fire and post-incident cooling system 0740G40125 Ventilating, heating, and cooling system 0740G41003 Reactor depressurization system Appendix D of this report provides reduced copies of the record drawings which delineate the boundaries of safety-related piping in the various systems.
4.
INSPECTION A.
PERIOD OF INSPECTION Inspection was performed at BRP during the period from August 15, 1979, to November 10,1979.
Approxi-1 mately 6,000 feet of pipe and 420 supports were inspected as well as the associated in-line components (valving, etc).
B.
ELEMENTS OF INSPECTION 1)
The inspection was performed according to Field Procedure 1 which is included as Appendix E of this report.
2)
The essential items verified by the inspection are as follows:
a)
Pipe geometry b)
Support design, location, function, and clearance c)
Embedments d)
Pipe attachments 2
BRP/79-14 Ravision 1 April 2, 1980 H.
ADDITIONAL INSPECTION In addition to the piping designated in Drawing 0740G41003 (see Appendix D), piping from the safety relief valves 3
(SV-4984, -4985, -4986, and -4987) to the steam drum en-closure wall was inspected.
This additional inspection was suggested by the Region III inspector in an inspec-tion meeting on November 7 1979, at BRP.
i p
1 f
i
~
)
h i
i I
i I
53 i
AlfErJDI ! P I;VAI.UATintJS OF ITEMS tlOTED DUltitlG Ills P t;CT IOti (continued)
Daily CPco Discrepancy 141D Drawing Item Noted item iteport System for System Du Qn d nspection Itesolution 141 27 Iteac t or 0740G41003 The design drawing is unclear.
The existing piping configuration has depres-It appears to show that sug' port been compared to the configuration surization PS-109 is attached to line 103D used in the piping analysis, and the at the platform. Support PS-109 difference is acceptable.
is actually located above the platform.
142 27 Iteac tor 0740G41003 Details in Drawing 0740G11003 for The difference in clearance is not depres-PS-110 supports call for a significant and is acceptable.
surization 1/16-inch clearance between the Additionally, the clearance will pipe and pipe clamp.
Clearances decrease when the system is operating.
in all cases are greater, averag-ing 1/4-inch (pipe was cold when measured).
143 27 Itea c to r 0740G41003 f.ock nuts on the two 1-1/2-inch These nuts have been tightened.
depres-through bolts on support PS-Il3 surization are loose.
144 27 Iteactor 0740G41003 The restraint detail in Draw-The additional length and nuts do not 1
depres-ing 0740G11003 calls for pipe affect the function of the restraint surization clamp bolts to be single nutted, and are acceptable.
2-1/2 inches in diameter, and 10-1/2 inches long on all eight PS-llo supports.
All are actually double nutted, with a 2-1/2-inch diameter and 17-inch length.
145 27 Iteactor 0740G41003 The design drawing indicates These differences do not affect the depres-that base plates for PS-110 support function and are acceptable.
surization supports are typical (35 inches long from end to end and 5 inches from the end to the centerline of the bolt hole).
The four restraints on the C and D 1ines do not conform (31 inches long from end to end, UNN n < oc uM e-19
- =.;-
O
A l'i't.11D I X V 4
INA1.UATIOt3S OF ITEMS !JO' RED t>UHit3G lilSP ECTIO*4 (continued)
Daily CPCo Discrepancy P&lD Drawing item tioted item Heport System for System During Inspection Hesolution 2-1/2 inches from one end to the bold centerline, and S inches from the opposite end to the bolt conterline).
146 27 Heactor 0740G41003 The design drawing shows a Decause of the relatively close depres-distance of l'-9" trom the pipe spacing of supports on these lines, surization centerline to the top of the the dimensional change has an insig-grout under the basc plate for nificant effect and is acceptable.
PS-llo supports. Heasured dis-Grouting is as specified on the tance from the pipe centerline drawing.
to the wall was 25 inches for
~
the four ps-llo supports on 1ines A and B, and 23 inches for the upper PS-110 support on line C.
Grout thicknesses ranged from 3/4 inch to 1-1/2 inches.
147 27 Heactor 0740G41003 The lower PS-Il0 support on line A Anchor bolt evaluation was performed y
depres-had no washers under the nuts on in accordance with U.S. NRC IE surization two anchor bolts.
The bottom two Bulletin 79-02.
holes in the base plate appear to have been enlarged with a cutting torch and are partially visible around the nuts.
148 27 Heactor 0740G41003 The design drawing for PS-Il2 Anchor bolt evaluation was performed depres-supports indicate that the in accordance with U.S. NRC IE surization anchor bolts on the base platesBulletin 79-02.
have uingle nuts with washers.
PS-ll2 supports on lines D, C, and 1) have double outs with no washurs.
The PS-Il2 support on line A has three bolts with double nuts and no washers, and one bolt with a single nut and no wauber.
Da w to oe
'et 4 :o
'O eN F-20 No8
- 53 H.
O O
_ = _.. _ _
.. ~.,...
e 9
- A ppt:llDI X F EVAI.UATIOt4S OF ITEMS furred DUl(ING I tJSPECTIOfl (continued)
Daily' CPco
' Di:,crepancy _
P&Ip Drawing Item iluted I t esa yeert System for bystem During Inspection Resolution 149 27 i<ca c tor 0740G41003 The east corner of the lower base Anchor bolt evaluation was performed I
depres-plate on sut, port Ps-113 was cut in accordance with U.S. NRC IE surization off so tisat it would fit beside Bulletin 79-02.
dnother bdSe pldte.
G
}
9
]
5 E *I:
PM r-21
.5 i
~a C~
dB O
.