ML19309C010
| ML19309C010 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | South Texas, Comanche Peak  |
| Issue date: | 03/13/1980 |
| From: | Cyphert S JUSTICE, DEPT. OF |
| To: | HOUSTON LIGHTING & POWER CO. |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19309C006 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8004080033 | |
| Download: ML19309C010 (30) | |
Text
cy w*x
,9' co w a G
ua:
()
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA g.
gjAg 17 jg50y jj 4
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION O! Cat!C3h CY D 223Gtib3 D
- CC3h p8 Before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Boar cv
,/
In the Matter.of
)
BOUSTON LIGHTING & POWER
)
COMPANY, et al. (South
)
Docket Nos. 50-498A Texas Project, Units 1
)
50-499A and 2)
)
)
TEXAS UTILITIES GENERATING
)
COMPANY, et al. (Comanche
)
Docket Nos. 50-445A Peak Steam Electric
)
50-446A Station, Units 1 and 2)
)
THIRD SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE OF DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE TO HOUSTON LIGHTING & POWER COMPANY FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORIES AND REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS The Department of Justice (" Department") hereby submits its Third Supplemental Response to Interrogatories 1/ propounded by Houston Lighting & Power Company ("HLEP") 2/ pursuant to agreement of counsel on February 20, 1980. 3/ The answers and information provided herein are complete to the Department's information and belief as of March 12, 1980.
However, as substantial discovery is still being conducted in these pro-ceedings, it may be necessary for the Department, pursuant to 1/ The Department previously supplied information responsive to this request in its Response to Applicant's First Request for Production of Documents and Answer to Interrogatories on Octo-
"ber 10, 1978, December 4, 1978 and February 1, 1980.
2/ First Set of Interrogatories and Requests for Production of Documents from Houston Lighting & Power Company to Antitrust Division, U.S. Dept. of Justice, August 1, 1978.
3/ February 25, 1980 letter from J. A. Bouknight, Jr. to Marshall E. Miller.
o Y000
Section 2.740(e) of the Nuclear Regulatory Commission's Rules of Practice to supplement or amend these Responses prior to trial to include any additional information which becomes available.
Department's Supplemental Response to HL&P Interrogatory 3(b) and 25(a)
Since February 1,1980, the Department has ascertained the following additional information in order to more fully respond to the above-mentioned HL&P Interrogatories.
The basis for the Department's contention that there are four relevant product markets in these proceedings i.e.,
the retail service market; the wholesale power market; the coordination services market; and the transmission services market, is the expert opinion of Dr. Gordon T. C. Taylor ("Dr. Taylor"), the Department's designated expert economic witness.
The general bases for Dr. Taylor's proposed testimony in these proceedings was already provided to HLEP in the Department's Second Supplemental Response to HL&P's Second Set of Interroga-tories, filed on October 19, 1979.
In addition, the specific bases for Dr. Taylor's proposed testimony in these proceedings will also be founded on the conclusions from his own factual investigation and review of the discovery in these proceedings.
(
Dr. Taylor revealed the status of his investigation and review i
as of October 25-26, 1979, at his previous deposition.
Since that time, Dr. Taylor has also continued his investigation and review of the discovery in these proceedings.
The Department
~
~ believes that Dr. Taylor presently will base his proposed tes-timony, regarding the aforementioned product markets, on the following information and data.
However, the Department believes that Dr. Taylor will continue to add to this list as his investigation and review of discovery continues:
A.
Industrial competition in a retail service market:
1.
Interviews in April 1979 of Texas Public Utilities Commissioners by Dr. Taylor; 2.
Interview on January 18, 1980 of William Rolwedge and Sid Walker, Esquire, Dow Chemical Corporation at Freeport, Texas, by Dr. Taylor; 3.
Interview on January 11, 1980 of George Knowles, Director of Energy Af fairs, Dia-mond Shamrock Corporation by Dr. Taylor; 4.
Interview in April 1979 of Charles Her-ring, General Manager, Lower Colorado River Authority ("LCRA") by Dr. Taylor; 5.
Interview on January 15, 1980 of Stephanie Coleman, Industrial Development Consultant, Texas Industrial Commission by Dr. Taylor; 6.
Published materials by the Texas Industrial Commission provided to Dr. Taylor at Janu-ary 15, 1980, interview [a list of these documents is attached hereto as Exhibit A],
7.
Interrogatory Answers of the City of Brownsville, Texas in these proceedings; 8.
Data in U.S. Census of Manufacturers (1976);
9.
Deposition testimony in these proceedings of Dr. John W. Wilson, economist for the City of Brownsville; Alfred E. Naylor, Manager of Planning at Gulf States Utili-ties Co.; James Eiland, Manger of Cap Rock Electric Cooperative.
t i
_4 B.
Yardstick competition in a retail service market:
1.
Dr. Taylor's knowledge of the different types of ownership of electric utilities; 2.
Retail service area certification by Texas Public Utilities Commission ("TPUC");
3.
Interrogatory Answers of the City of Browns-ville, Texas in these proceedings; 4.
Interview in April 1979 with Charles Cowden, Chairman, TPUC by Dr. Taylor; j
5.
Interview in April 1979 of TPUC Commis-sioners by Dr. Taylor; 6.
Interview on January 15, 1980 of Stephanie Coleman, Texas Industrial Commission by Dr. Taylor; 7.
Interview in April 1979 of Neil Johnson, Texas Electric Cooperative Association and review of documents in Mr. Johnson's of-fice by Dr. Taylor; 8.
Interview in April 1979 with South Texas Electric Cooperative by Dr. Taylor; 9.
Deposition testimony in these proceedings of:
Juan Nichols, Manager of Wood County Electric Cooperative; Walter M. Bowers, Division Chief of Power Marketing at Southwestern Power Administration; Donald D. Sykora, Vice President of Customer Relations at HL&P.
C.
Franchise competition in a retail service market:
1.
Interview in April 1979 with John Bell, Es-quire, General Counsel of TPUC by Dr. Taylor; 2.
Interview in April 1979 with L. E. Gross, General Manager, Medina Electric Coopera-tive and W. S. Robson, General Manager at l
South Texas Electric Cooperative; 1
l l
l i
j
l-l.-
-S-3.
Interview in April 1979 of Neil Johnson, Texas Electric Cooperative Association and review of documents in Mr. Johnson's office by Dr. Taylor; 4.
Switchover Hearings filing at TPUC reviewed by Dr. Taylor at TPUC in April 1979; 5.
Interrogatory Answers of City of Browns-ville, Texas in these proceedings; 6.
Interview in April 1979 and January 14-15, 1980 of John Bell, Esquire, General Coun-sel of TPUC by Dr. Taylor; 7.
Deposition testimony in these proceedings of:
Louis W. Howard, Vice President at Texas Power & Light Co. ; James D. Eiland, Manager l
at Cap Rock Electric Cooperative; Juan A.
Nichols, Manager at Wood County Electric Cooperative; 8.
Franchises sent to Dr. Taylor on March 10, 1980 and March 12, 1980.
(A list of orig-inal franchises is being provided to HL&P on this date pursuant to its July 17, 1979 subpoena duces _tocum.
The franchises are available for inspection at the offices of the Antitrust Division, in Washington, D. C.
i on reasonable notice.)
D.
Wholesale power parket:
1.
1978 Federal Energy Regulatory Commission j
Form 1 for Houston Lighting and Power Company and Texas Power & Light Company; 2.
Interviews in April 1979 of W. S. Robson, General Manager at South Texas Electric Cooperative and L.
E. Gross, General Man-ager at Medina Electric Cooperative.
3.
Interview on February 5, 1980 of Robert Gross, Southern Engineering by Dr. Taylor;,:.
e-
--"---m
- 4.
1977 and 1978 Annual Reports of Rural Elec-trification Administration; 5.
Deposition testimony in these proceedings of:
Louis W. Howard, Vice President at Texas Power & Light Co.; Walter Br>wers, Division Chief of Power Marketing at Southwestern Power Administration; Dr. John W. Wilson, economist for City of Brownsville; James D.
Eiland, Manager at Cap Rock Electric Coop-erative and Juan D. Nichols, Manager at Wood County Electric Cooperative.
E.
Coordination services market:
1.
Interviews in April 1979, and January 1980, of engineers at dispatch centers 1/ by Dr. Taylor; 2.
Interview on January 15 or 16, 1980 of Mr. Soderberg, Chief Engineer, LCRA, and documents inspected at his offices by Dr. Taylor; 3.
Discussion on Februry 8, 1980 with Dr. Wilson and Marc Poirier, Esquire, Counsel for City of Brownsville, by Dr. Taylor; 4..
Inspection at LCRA of Reserve Sharing Agreement of the South Texas Interconnec-ted System in April 1979 by Dr. Taylor; S.
Interview in April 1979 of Michael D.
Spence, Vice President at Texas Power &
Light Co., by Dr. Taylor; 6.
Data summary sheets from utility sub-missions to TPUC inspected by Dr. Taylor at TPUC in January 1980 [ copies are at-tached herewith as Exhibit B).
1/ North Texas Security Center, Texas Power & Light Co. diipatch center, South Texas Security Center, Central Power & Light Co.
dispatch center, and Houston Lighting and Power Co. dispatch center.
l t
l l
l I-.
7.
Deposition testimony of D. E. Simmons, Vice President of Corporate Planning at HL&P (9/25/79); Burl B. Hulsey, Jr., President of Texas Utilities Co.; Charles Herring, Gene-ral Manager at LCRA (Exhibits 9 & 10 of that deposition) and Walter M. Bowers, Division Chief of Power Marketing at Southwestern Pool Administration.
F.
Transmission services market:
1.
Interview in April 1979 of Michael D. Spence, Vice President at Texas Power & Light Co.,
by Dr. Taylor; 2.
Interview on January 15 or 16, 1980, of Mr. Soderberg, Chief Engineer -at LCRA, by Dr. Taylor; i
3.
Interview in April 1979 of William E.
West, Jr., Systems Operation Manager of the Systems Operation Control Center at LCRA, by Dr. Taylor; 4.
Discussion on February 8, 1980, with Dr. Wilson and Marc Poirier, Esquire, Counsel for City of Brownsville, by Dr. Taylor; 5.
Deposition testimony in these proceedings of:
Walter M. Bowers, Division Chief of Power Marketing at Southwestern Power Adminis-tration and Charles Herring, General Mana-ger, LCRA.
Exhibit C, attached hereto is a copy of the source of data used by Dr. Taylor as a basis for Appendix A, B and C of the Department's Supplemental Interrogatory Responses filed on February 1, 1980.
i Respectfully submitted, Susan Braden Cyphert Washington, D. C.
Attorney, Energy Sectioa March 13, 1980 Antitrust Division U.S. Department of Jur,tice Telephone No.:
202-724-6667 1
ggif F.KHIBIT A j^
W L c1 w ~ L Aux rns 4f.s. h +.0 Ln&
y 9
IMl?
'. * /
s
/
7 I
d4 _,
v W &M' M%
M78-tbf AMa& n Aw #4ekw+
W
&ae-f.7 hau-c.
6' L+ k e.
& </ w 9
3>ce ch&utu.J C ;:==s
& a<~ S & : n = ; 7 % ee t.
W-Jm d &
(-
y d:hernr
- d &w Ms A21m & Jr.E&1 jfrr Au "
~ #+a1 W W v
&Ju21.1k Amt.~ siJM%f-f< Ad.Je sAhts*
e
& cf.AM<a.P & %f n AtA<f52Mwesu<-e4nc/hab 63he 1
i
~
Txxa 1 eR<4ataa!&=++
0' J k-a-1 %, Gyrr</ r977 Gr20<44-< M, & 4&
&<r
... f
, ms 7
u
. M.n. u v s
.sm w ww.s
- n. <rn M M PA4X.e
?uk mk1kk, em o.
msmn=
L.r c'
C:
~
, EXHIBIT B CITY OF AUSTIN h
NET CAPABILITY PEAK DEMAND RESERVE ADDITIONS /RETIREM.4TS YEAR (W)
(M)
(M) 79 1,675 743 125.0 Fayette 1 - 275 80*
1,950 1,317 48.0 Fayette 2 - 275 81*
1,910 1,362 40.2 40 (retire) 82*
1,910 1,407 35.7 83*
1,910 1,460 30.8 84*
2,110 1.516 39.2 STP 1 - 200 85*
2,070 1,591 39.1 40 (retire)
}'
86 2,270 1,175 93.2 STP 2 - 200 87 2,270 1,265 79.4 88 2,230 1.353 64.8 40 (retire) 89 2,230 1,449 53.9
- Includes 500 Mi of firm sales to HL&P.
1 i
t
,q.
~;
~
~
NET CAPABILITY
- PEAK DEMAND RESERVE ADDITIONS /RETIREENTS YEAR -
(Pli)
(MI)
(W)
- 67/ x.9 p. 62y 79 (t gif" 671 15.0 80 772 730 22.7 San Miguel 1 - 270 81 896 Comanche Peak 1 - 44 82 913
[17 )
794 15.0 83 994 (G'O 864 15.0 Comanche Peak;2 -44 84 1,081
()%)
940 15.0 85 1.176 (2-y O 1,023 15.0 86 1,280 (g9 )
1,113 15.0 Unknown - 200 C
87 1,393 (ts.$
. 1.211 15.0 Unknown - 200 88 1,516 640 1,318 15.0 89 1,649 6 79) 1,434 15.0 Unknown - 200 1
Includes varying amounts of purchase power.
4
~
p.
CENTRAL POWER & LIGHT COPFANY NET CAPABILITY PEAK DEMAND
. RESERVE ADDITIONS /RETIREPENTS YEAR (W)
(W)
(m) 79 2,986
('d #
2,331 28.1 80 3,496 2,525 38.5 Coleto Creek 1 - 550
~
430 (retire) 81*
3,496 (1D 2,654 30.7 82*
3,496
($4)5 2,915 17.2 83*
3,496
{9;)5 3,037 12.0 84*
3,811 (f7g)5 3,167 14.7 STP 1 - 315 i
85*
3,811
[a5)5 3,309 12.0 86*
4,126 (l')$)i 3,468 15.0 STP 2 - 315 87 4,098 3,630 12.9 Okal Union - 118 l
146 (retire) 88 4,485 3,797 18.1 Coleto Creek 2 -228 Karnack'- 228 4
69 (retire) 89 4,699 4.005 17.3 Walker County - 214
- Includes varying amounts of firm sales to West Texas Utilities Company.
f h
4
')
CITY PtBLIC SERVICE. BOARD OF SAN ANTONIO NET CAPA8ILITY.
PEAK DEMAND RESERVE ADDITIONS /RETIREENTS YEAR (N)
(m)
(m) 79*
3,034
( SU) 5 1,914' t 58.5 80*
3.034 (fS)4 1,949 55.7 81 3,034 1,979 53.3 82 3,034 2,157 40.7 83 3,034 2,339 29.7 84 3.384 2,489 35'.9 STP 1 - 350 85 3,384-2,643 28.0 86 3,734 2,783 34.2 STP 2 - 350 87 3,734 2,928 27.5 88 3,734 3,088 20.9
.l 1
89 4,234 3,236 30.8 Unknown lignite - 500
- Includes firm sales to other utilities.
i 4
n
~
DALLAS POWER & LIGHT COMPANY MET CAPA8ILITY PEAK DEMAND RESERVE ADDITIONS /RETIREPENTS.
YEAR (144)
(pti)
(Pol) 79 4,056 2,681 51.3 Martin Lake 3 - 188 80 3,953 2,792 51.6 33 (retire) 70 (retire) 81 4,106 2,902 41.5 Comanche Peak 1 - 268 115 (retire) 82 4,036 3,011 34.0 70(retire) 83 4,230 3,119 35.6 Comanche Peak 2 - 268 75 (retire) 84 4,380 3,227 35.7 Forest Grove 1 - 150 l
85 4,567 3,353 36.2 Martin Lake 4 - 188 86 4,480 3,483 28.6 87(retire) i 87 88 89 f
1 l
1
. s,'
.n l
EL PASO ELECTRIC C0FFANY NET CAPABILITY PEAK DEMAND RESERVE ADDITIONS /RETIREENTS YEAR (W)
(W)
(W) 79*
960 (15)J 718 23.3 80 13033 775 33.3 Copper Station 1 - 73 81 1,033 845 22.2 82 1,033 909 13.6 83 1,229 984 24.9 Palo Verde 1 - 200 4 (retire) 84*
1,403 (91h 1,038 26.2 Palo Verde 2 - 200 26 (retire) 85*
1,403 (49)s 1,113 17.7 86*
1,603 (15))g 1,166 29.5 Palo Verde 3 - 200
~
87*
1,603
( q hs 1,223 23.5 88*
1,603 (g
1.275 22.3
[
89*
1,585
(#'d3 1,336 15.3 18 (retire) 1 i
- Fim sales to other utilities.
i I
i i
L -- -
~
-l p
GULF STATES UTILITIES COMPANY NET CAPA8ILITY*
PEAK DEMAND RESERVE ADDITIONS /RETIREENTS YEAR (W)
(W)
(W) 79 6,189 (W"k 5,477 13.0 66 (retire)
[i 53)p 5,511 15.7 Sabine 5 - 480 80 6.492 f
81 6,654 Gate)g 5.942 12.0 82 7,024 (t/50)7 6,274 12.0 Nelson 6 - 540 83 7.449 (f,odg 6,651 12.0 81g Cajun 3 - 270 84 7,790
[gBp 6,950 12.1 River 8end 1 - 564 85 8,371 d,59If 7.367 13.6 Cajun lignite 1 - 135 Nelson 5 - 549 56 9,012 (YNp 7,809 15.4 Lignite 1, 2, 3 - 600 Cajun Lignite 2 - 135 87 9,518 (Irs)7 8,262 15.2 L1gnite 4, 5, 6 - 600 88 10.118 (tap)p 8,741 15.8 Unknown -600 89 Includes varying amounts of purchase power.
i 1
e
~
(~
D
"}
HOUSTON LIGHTING & POWER COPFANY NET CAPA8ILITY PEAK DEMAND RESERVE ADDITIONS /RETIREENTS YEAR (M)
(W)
(W) 79 11,193 9,725 15.1 W.A Parish 6 - 660 80*
12,263
[9)g 10,150 20.8 W A Parish 7 - 570 81*
12,263 (54) 10.575 16.0 82*
12,563 (TotP)g 10,950 14.7 l
83*
13,103 (8Nr 11,375 15.2 W A Parish 8 - 540
[538)p l
84*
13,938 11,925 16.9 STP 1 - 385 Unknown - 750
[SphI 12.425 16.0 Lignite 1 - 700 85*
14.410 228 (retire) 86
,14.995 12,900 16.2 STP 2 - 385 Lignite 1 - 700 87 16,825 13,325 26.3 Allen's Creek 1 - 1,130 X L1gnite 1 - 700 j
88
,17,525 13,775 27.2 X Lignite 2 - 700 i
89 17,525 14,250 23.0 l
Includes varying amounts of purchase power.
i
9:
p LOWER COLORADO RIVER AUTHORITY NET CAPA8ILITY PEAK DEMAND RESERVE ADDITIONS /RETIREENTS YEAR (W)
(W)
(m) 79 1,478 990 49.3 Fayette 1 - 275 80 1,753 1,063 60.6 Fayette 2 - 275 1
81 1,753 1,141 53.6
-]
I 82 1,753 1,225 43.1 83 1,753 1,315 33.3 i
i 84 1,753 1,412 24.2 85 1,753 1,516 15.6 86 2,153 1,627 32.3 Fayette 3 - 400 87 2,153 1,747 23.2 88 2,153 1,876 14.8 89 2,553 2,015 26.7 Unknown - 400 1
i 1
r i
I l
i
p p
SOUTHWESTERN ELECTRIC POWER C09ANY NET CAPA8ILITY PEAK DEMAND RESERVE ADDITIONS /RETIREENTS YEAR (W)
(W)
(m) 79 2.614
(. 4 2,230 17.2 80 3,042 2,437 24.8 Welsh 2 - 528 81 3,152 2,653 18.8 82 3.620 2,863 26.4 Welsh 3 - 528 83 3,655 3,083 18.6 106(retire) 84 4.281 3,318 29.0 Pirkey 1 - 640 85 4,304 3,573 20.5 86 4.530 3,843 17.9 Dolet Hills 1 - 320 i
36 (retire) 87 4,638 4,088 13.5 Waggoner Ranch 1 - 50 38 (retire) 88 5,132 4,343 18.2 Karnack 1 - 266 Coleto Creek - 266 36 (retire) i 89 5,413 4,613 17.3 Walker County 1 - 317 i
4
.r-m.
m..
- SOUTHWESTERN PtBLIC SERVICE C0WANY u
NET CAPABILITY
- PEAK DEMAND RESERVE ADDITIONS /RETIREENTS YEAR (W)
(W)
(W) 79 2,787
((,Q p 2,024 37.5 CZ 30 80 3.125 2,571 31.5 Harrington 3 - 338 81 3,125 h
2,743 13.9 82 3,653 h
2,920 25.1 Tolk 1 - 528 5.6 (retire) 3.109 17.3 24.8 (retire).
83 3,647 84 3,622 4
3,295 9.9 3,491 18.9 Tolk 2 - 528 85 4,150 e
86 4.150
=
3,700 12.2 11.3 (retire) 8 (retire) 3,920 20.7 Roberts 1 - 60 87 4,731 g
88 4.731 4,154 13.9 19.5 (retire) f 10 (retire) 89 -
5,320 e
4.388 20.9 Roberts 2 - 600
)
Includes varying amounts of fim sales and purchases.
b i
1 i
i l
(--
p q-TEXAS ELECTRIC SERVICE COW ANY NET CAPABILITY PEAK DEMAND RESERVE ADDITIONS /RETIREENTS YEAR (N)
(N)
(N) 79 6,023 4,000 50.6 Martin Lake 3 - 338 80 5,997 4,203 42.7 26 (retire) 81 6,381 4,416 44.5 Comanche Peak 1 - 383 82 6.336 A,636 36.7 45(retire) 83 6,697 4,867 37.6 Comanche Peak 2 - 383 22 (retire) 84 6,997 5,109 37.0 Forest Grove 1 - 450 150 (retire) i 85 7,043 5,362 31.4 Martin Lake 4 - 338 292 (retire) 86 87 88 89 9
w
r-r
^
\\
TEXAS POWER AND LIGHT COWANY NET CAPABILITY
- PEAK DEMAND RESERVE ADDITIONS / RETIREMENTS YEAR (Pti)
(MW) 5 (MW) 79 7.353 4,732 55.4 80 7,353 5,500 33.7 81 8,281 6,240 32.7 Sandow 4 - 545
~
Comanche Peak 1 - 283 82 8,281 6,630 24.9 83 8.664 7,030 23.2 Comanche Peak 2 - 383 84 8,814 7,450 18.3 Forest Grove 1 - 150 85 9.652 7,910 22.0 Twin Oak 1 - 563 Martin Lake 4 - 225 86 10,264 8,390 22.3 Twin Oak 2 - 563
~
87
~
10.457 8,910 17.4 Unannounced - 263 70 (retire) 1 88 10,737 9.450 13.6 Unannounced - 140 Unannounced - 250 110(retire) i i
89 11,122~
10,012 11.1 Unannounced - 375 Unannounced - 250 240(retire) i Includes varying amounts of purchase power.
. as
r
,m m:
WEST TEXAS UTILITIES NET CAPABILITY
- PEAK DEMAND RESERVE ADDITIONS /RETIREENTS YEAR (M)
(W) 1 (W) 79 1,065 (ii) P 819 30.0 80 1,068
[p/)p 937 14.0 lif 81 1.102 y)g 985 11.9 82 1,153 1.030 11.9 83 1,203'.
gy 1,075 11.9 84 1,259 gjp 1,125 11.9 85 1,314 (2(,oj 1.174 11 9 86 1,366 (7 2j. f 1,223 11.7 87 1,439 gg 1,277 12.7 okla Union - 365 88 1,573 yf)g Coleto Creek 2 - 96 1,335 17.8 Karnack - 96 60 (retire) l I
~
1,395 17.0 Walker County 1 - 59 89 1,633 (3.3) 1 Includes ' varying amounts of firm purchase power.
l i
i I
i I
i
EXHIBIT C W
AcAl:
'* [
f ys As y &
i)
Fe2c Rn o/2.
9 ME-s + FM &w/ Obme M k 4. m A A nd M s 1977 0k-++<-1 w & Cmy =+A y 4 (911 RS Q
- 3) M A A M A % &
b n 7A24-was CA r,.
e dbA<~
<<79. gg S. y 4)MC% w &d
/977 W /f & h_D f
Merf t-7
(
fr. S.
.g A
- ggg, 5)&d&hu-rW AmAf 0 d 4 e S& w=es'
/rre-m1 ma, yy
(
A erk.
nads n
, M Jess %.P A w
i' q
p n
m. & ~ m.)
l
{ }[111km
-,-a
,--v.--
,-.,-.,,,,.n-.-w
.,-,,,,.,,--,.,-m
,-,--er,--.-~
,---.a.
,,~
,e /
.\\
v ad March 10, 1980 F
DM::SBC f
60-415-105 t
BAND-DELIVERED l
l Dr. Gordon Taylor l!
Suite 304
- i 2600 Virginia Avenue, N.W.
Washington, D.C.
20037
~.
Dear Gordon:
Att5ched are the franchises received to date and a list h
describing such franchises.
. s 1
Sincerely yours, Susan Braden Cyphert Attorney i
Energy Section Antitrust Division Attachment 4
1
' I
,1 Y
),
k
.; l
- f i.
C l
\\
E
.I
/
p.
Franchises received as of March 10, 1980 Denison - TP&L 25 yrs Clute - HL&P 50 yrs Farmers Branch - TP&L 45 yrs Forney - TP&L 50 yrs Euless - TP&L 50 yrs Bedford - TP&L 50 yrs Jersey village - HL&P 50 yrs Galveston - HL&P annually Balch Springs - TP&L 50 yrs Brownwood - TP&L 20 yrs Athens - TP&L 20 yrs Richwood - HL&P 50 yrs Pasadena - HL&P 50 yrs Bellaire - HL&P 50 yrs Humble - EL&P 50 yrs Seabrook - HL&P 50 yrs Missouri City - HL&P 50 yrs Lomax - HL&P 50 yrs Addison - TP&L 50 yrs Belton - TP&L 25 yrs Allen - TP&L 50 yrs Grapevine - TP&L 50 yrs De Soto - TP&L 50 yrs 9
6 6
e i
l
e*
tJNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE W AS4BINCTON, D.C.
sesse l
j u
m.
March 12, 1980 m e.a e
and maar se Behina. d Num DAK:SBC r&O-415-105 i
' BAND DELIVERED Dr. Gordon Taylor Suite 304 2600 Virginia Avenue, N.W.
Washington, D.C.
20037
/
Dear Dr. Taylor:
Attached are franchises received to date along with a list describing such franchises.
Sincerely yours, Susan Braden Cyphert Attorney 1
Energy Section Antitrust Division Attachment._._..._
S g
l I
L._o
.., x,.
/
e.
$ranchises received March 12, 1980 Ft. WortEs TESCO 10 years Breckenridge TESCO 30 years
'Duncanville TP&L 50 years Forest Hill,
TESCC 50 years I
Eastland TESCO 50 years Arlington TESCO 30 years Edgecliff TESCO 50 years Seymour
,TESCO 10 years Cedar Hill TP&L_
50 years Iowa Park TESCO 10 years Henrietta TESCO 40 years
. Benbrook TESCO 99 years Magnolia 50 years HL&P Katy HL&P 50 years i
Hillsboro TP&L 20' years O
em S
e O
e e
E
.., e UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board j
In the Matter of
)
BOUSTON LIGHTING AND' POWER )
Docket Nos. 50-498A CO., et al.(South Texas
)
50-499A Project, Units 1 and 2)
)
)
TEXAS UTILITIES GENERATING
)
Docket Nos. 50-445A l
COMPANY (Comanche Peak
)
50-446A Steam Electric Station,
)
Units 1 and 2)
)
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that service of the foregoing Third i
Supplemental Response of Department of Justice to Houston Lighting & Power Company First Se t of Interrogatories and Requests for Production of Documents has been made on the following parties listed hereto this 13th day of March, 1980, by depositing copies thereof in the United States mail, first class, postage prepaid.
Marshall E. Miller, Esquire Alan S. Rosenthal, Esquire Chairman Chairman Atomic Safety & Licensing Board Michael C. Farrar, Esquire Panel Thomas S. Moore, Esquire U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Atomic Safety and Licensing Commission Appeal Board Panel Washington, D. C.
20555 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Michael L. Glaser, Esquire Washington, D. C.
20555 1150 17th Street, N.W.
Washington, D. C.
20036 Jerome E. Sharfman, Esquire U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Sheldon J. Wolfe, Esquire Commission Atomic Safety & Licensing Board Washington, D. C.
20555 Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Chase R. Stephens, Secretary Commission Docketing and Service Branch Washington, D. C.
20555 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Samuel J. Chilk, Secretary Washington, D. C.
20555 Office of the Secretary of the Commission Jer'ome Saltzman U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Chief, Antitrust and Commission Indemnity Group Washington, D. C.
20555 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C.
20555 l
l
j.
l l
l Mr. William C. Price Michael Blume, Esquire Central Power & Light Co.
Fredric D. Chanania, Esq.
P. O. Box 2121 Ann P. Bodgdon, Esq.
Corpus Christi, Texas 78403 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission G. K. Spruce, General Manager Washington, D. C.
20555 City Public Service Board P.O. Box 1771 Jerry L. Barris, Esquire 4 Ban Antonio, Texas 78203 City Attorney, Richard C. Balough, Esquire Perry G. Brittain Assistant City Attorney President City of Austin Texas Utilities Generating P.O. Box 1088 Company Austin, Texas 78767 2001 Bryan Tower 4 Dallas, Texas 75201 Robert C. McDiarmid, Esquire Robert A. Jablon, Esquire R.L. Hancock, Director Spiegel and McDiarmid City of Austin Electric 2600 Virginia Avenue, N.W.
Utility Department Washington, D. C.
20036 P. O. Box 1088 Austin, Texas 78767 Dan H. Davidson City Manager G. W. Oprea, Jr.
City of Austin Executive Vice President P. O. Box 1088 Houston Lighting & Power Austin, Texas 78767 Company P. O. Box 1700 Don R. Butler, Esquire Houston, Texas 77001 1225 Southwest Tower Jon C. Wood, Esquire W. Roger Wilson, Esquire Joseph Irion Worsham, Esquire Matthews, Nowlin, Macfarlane Merlyn D. Sampels, Esquire
{
& Barrett Spencer C. Relyea, Esquire l
1500 Alamo National Building Worsham, Forsythe & Sampels San Antonio, Texas 78205 2001 Bryan Tower, Suite 2500 I
Dallas, Texas 75201
' David M. Stahl, Esquire Isham, Lincoln & Beale Joseph Knotts, Esquire Suite 701 Nicholas S. Reynolds, Esquire 1050 17th Street, N.W.
Debevoise & Liberman Washington, D. C.
20036 1200 17th Street, N.W.
Washington, D. C.
20036 Michael I. Miller, Esquire James A. Carney, Esquire Douglas F. John, Esquire Sarah N. Welling, Esquire Akin, Gump, Hauer & Feld Isham, Lincoln & Beale 1333 New Hampshire Avenue,.N.W.
4200 One First National Plaza Suite 400 Chicago, Illinois 60603 Washington, D. C.
20036 l
l
d* *
- Morgan Hunter, Esquire Robert Lowenstein, Esquire McGinnis, Lochridge & Kilgore J. A. Bouknight, Esquire 5th Floor, Texas State Bank William J. Franklin, Esquire
., Building Lowenstein, Newman, Reis, 900 Congress Avenue Axelrad & Toll Austin, Texas 78701 1025 Connecticut Avenue, N.W.
Washington, D. C.
20036 Jay M. Galt, Esquire Looney, Nichols, Johnson E. W. Barnett, Esquire
& Hayes Charles G. Thrash, Jr., Esquire 219 Couch Drive J. Gregory Copeland, Esquire Oklahoma City, Oklahoma 73101 Theodore F. Weiss, Jr., Esquire Baker & Botts Knoland J. Plucknett 3000 One Shell Plaza Executive Director Houston, Texas 77002 Committee on Power for the Southwest, Inc.
Kevin B. Pratt, Esquire 5541 East Skelly Drive Assistant Attorney General Tulsa, Oklahoma 74135 P.O. Box 12548 Capital Station John W. Davidson, Esquire Austin, Texas 78711 Sawtelle, Goode, Davidson
& Tioilo Frederick H. Ritts, Esquire 1100 San Antonio Savings Law Offices of Northcutt Ely Building Watergate 600 Building San Antonio, Texas 78205 Washington, D.C.
20037 W. S. Robson Donald M. Clements, Esq.
General Manager Gulf States Utilities Company South Texas Electric P.O. Box 2951 Cooperative, Inc.
Beaumont, Texas 77704 Route 6, Building 102 Victoria Regional Airport Mr. G. Bolzan King Victoria, Texas 77901 West Texas Utilities Co.
P. O. Box 841 Robert M. Rader, Esquire Abilene, Texas 79604 Conner, Moore & Corber 1747 Pennsylvania Ave., N.W.
W. N. Woolsey, Esquire Washington, D.C. 20006 Kleberg, Dyer, Redford & Weil 1030 Petroleum Tower
'R. Gordon Gooch, Esquire Corpus Christi, Texas 78474 John P. Mathis, Esquire Steven R. Hunsicker Baker & Botts 1701 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W.
Washington, D. C.
20006
- Susan B. Cf ert, Attorney Energy Section Antitrust Division r
Department of Justice i
--