ML19308C027

Responds to Jd Carlton to DW Montgomery,Jd Carlton to Jh Taylor,Wc Butt to Hf Dobel & Hf Dobel to DW Montgomery W/Info Re Pressurizer Safety Valve Requirements

ML19308C027
Person / Time
Site:	Crane
Issue date:	09/14/1967
From:	Dobel H BABCOCK & WILCOX CO.
To:	Montgomery D BABCOCK & WILCOX CO.
References
TASK-TF, TASK-TMR NUDOCS 8001170799
Download: ML19308C027 (3)

Text

1

)

arf L o

THIS DOCUMENT CONTAINS r

P0OR QUAUTY PAGES 3

.... p..

t

u. c, s

s s

4

.t

=

• c

p. p

- g r..., *.

.,.-. g.... %,.u 3,

,...,.a

.,... ~.

4.

a n._

m...

L..

..........,2 a.

...a.

pu....,. g., ~.. 3 c.,.,.,.. v..., e :. )

Ct..

tu.: ?..n ec.2:s:

~h' t !.

wy:n~.' =c 1.

t s

e

s m.

rm - -- ;

e),.

y e...... n p.n,,..p.v...v.

-.. 5s s.......

.......m

., ~.

s.... ;....,.y j. a v.c e m - e ut.. i.. g c.c. u,.s e i,. '

~

~

~~~

't E.-f. 2 (1)

Ietter rm J. S. C:-iten to 3. L'. r.. tr;;;e e f, c:,te.3 ry,cr.',y.- : 3, Iy',

Cub.1tet t "fre.:

-i; r itifer it.tyt ti:i g."

d (2) Le.tcr fre, J. C. Cerittu to J. H Terrier, drtei }*:.:ra 2, IM7, Id Jc:t:

• Free s,4.xiu:r irtet.ti<nt Eoc.:ir c.tr.te, '

i i

O) letter IIr: P. C.1:00 to I:. 7, Dckl, dt.tel.'ane 22, J357, f

CCJ:.rt: "ric:.iriter Ede t~ V:.1vec. '

l (M Te.tter ft~.. M. T. I' ml i c. D, k*. I'.'. rw-7, cc tM Jc.17 3, 1957, c

l L'c.t'f e:t s ' htat :r' r:r L. ~ety ':cive L.@ e;f es:,. ' '

l.

i L:f trt- : (h) J'.-Ove rc 0 07:*m ' ~'. '..h-t te 'r '.tell fr.t. h l* cr:ac.it: Ecl*.t.r vrl';

?. t',.t's r < ~~ --' ~' t hrr.e-v-" v.l. t - t :n <m h p-ir c 2 t af& vil re c e. L1,'ce' t;A '.*.1 cubstgarnt presr:riters. h c.ir.o re:t,-~ctsied the.t v2 tot ir.r.tr.11 r. pilct r.t'.va.ted j

rafc77 ve.1 e.

Enteeq.ter.t to the Trepter. tic: cf that ree: ::-rds.tica, vs h: to itr:W.

a letter of ir:tet to Ercreer Ind:::riec (P..r ell, E.r.ni..s, L ldere Divir.ica) to aj

e. llc r th=a to procte'i with the develop-:::st of a half capacity 3X),000 lb/hr safety 1

valve.

4

/.ialtie.:!1 revie.r cf t% ct.*ety ce.1ve reirc :ct.t: b: be ta ex-.le'ed vit' in the 7: :t tw r :.;a ; c.: 1 the 7::70:2 cf t".!: re.-.r.rtr.d r..1: t o r;:.ccir.2 ti.c ceccletir : t uw.t-13 tr:a this r cviev.

i j

Os I.::cstt 17,1%7, U:szer:. Crrnen, Ced, M-rch -it, It:tt, Etever.:, end Tctle: :.:t t*,d. ire.: the b.c2e;rxrd trf citin; the pres:u-2 w.t.fety valva:. m pertir..t a

e

.i pcirts in thic r.ee'.1:y; r.ro sutrt.rit.ed, c.s re.11ov3:

s 1.

01:o P.d,0C0 n 'h c*c ::1'y is r r:11 frc.".e! r rb:r, in 1 *e.1 en c cae r: c-r,3 r. d v.it. cre-si s e Mcr.t rm ic

• s t i r, n

wr. ual r*"r r >

cfft0*. from ta: 7.rtt?'.'ci:.*r r t y vr.lver., i t let*,1 ca t1 La.itir.1 prets.t.-lier r'.s : V:hr? cf T;3 ta, r :1 ic 1: e1 cn tb r::-i: a crp ;ttd T.'.nitive r.: _?r.ter co.rfitter.t.

It v:.: 7.n:.;r.1 en it:.; tt:m j

r0rt cent.itivo perr.:reter in C.: s.'.r.lycis 1:t:'k; t o cc.f erf ve.lve rce.:Irt;;:::- 1: the cri poir.t s're tL: LU a Trc, sre rec. der trip c.,i ir, thir. tr.:0ycim it vi.: r.stard to be c.t J reir t

v s

j Te, A trsarient irmiving c c:cp 3c.1 ene::';e fr n 1C0', to ed rewr ic I

.)

con = of the varet eJvi la c::cer.ticily W:.1 is ter:.s of orespecascre i

g i

proteet!on rc.Tairc ta17tc to tLe tremele:t (p:ritneel fellevi:e n

[

]

rytten bluh t while r.t fall pwcr.

In either of these trc:uients r n_ m. WW K

-- W3 i

_.-.....- -. ru. w.,. i....a... - - - -

- l, n

DTpWM Wn\\,

m a t

l 8001170 s

4

'-,..,,..,,,,,,.y.,_-

- m

,,,,r_-

a...Z

,yn, e ye e ed.wh t.d.a " _ _ _ -..

.M=.-**

amer a,*1'"*..

Sm bees 4.e.me.i

=e wu.as w

al # essa.s e.

a

.._t L

- M e se o..

• * " ~ * * - -

o d

1 E

sw, s

2 l

the r.nr/ 1~1c:: rn--1N.i to prt e'r ?. rc*.etc.:- t:!i s i.th0 t ricm f

relin 08'/50 (-~

h.Q tbet.Ull:7 to r.::.lece t',1c rir:.7 f1Ct.- !c; Ic.:t t cc:r.is, W :.rrn;uee eo.: : ;c;,n.cd :4.ta pg 07

/.s r-ry 20::.1 in Ee1-rcme: (!), c:c inenit.;.na c; r4 r;kt cet'.L,*.1 t r.ht; n.1--. c n rc,m Lt., c;rt. 11:.,:

to L:' :CiritJ2y W c.rc tw:1s c ;,1mg t

j 1':dr;- thr' 1tr. t

.h !2 l :-z-L, } r tc, e :1::, y--t*, tM llc 1:Ther Lir::.< rci tM j

c4c;r.; cf the &m r:. 2.ir.7

r.. ev f., t '. r e ce-.:.c ci.23 ; em ese: 1:. Ec;cze:cs i

3

(.23 EM (M, c:

P Lu.14 =

.,3 e',n :* '-- ? c:? di?r/; cal-c -

-a Ob :;t sicao v;M: r ;.r / y,.1;$ V:,cing, 11.

5 I

t. L. EWun c' rtd 1::o e

. r d ei.c. e i r.c-e se re ;.0s j

tcCa?cdir.; hic :.marir:.vi tri.h re.cc:y v:.tvr to t'.n c nvectic,nt.',. utiilty in.tatry.

iba 1.cy Otentice.: ir.vehet vcie:

f t

1.

Ces t he tlarew'*cy w.We Lt. lct.tif1ca in vies cf tro fe. tuert 7

A.

CC r: Y.J.70 3c ht,4 i' C115Ltl* usicca it fiNt lifer, cf.1 th': tre.r.Ji::tc c pr. ;ca to c r.re vdve tdico cre unlitely.

b.

i.::2 7:t.bc.ilt'.-

. ; t c. ctfcif Tc.Wa VIU ai Sh opc tccr S

it. M00 c is t.ll, '. :c, t -1: jutificeth.3 for it thr:3

.L

.i V:.; %t.l u 4:c.s a f, c;ict.

{

2.

In thre c::7 tolff. l r'itiev.in f:r the pilz.0 c:tyr.t:1 c f:ty 7:.1 vet It tr.* C ven11-/ ccreed thr.t r. thre-vc:t vc.lvo ces.L1 r.;; be &.:stifici ja vie ; c '

)'

the r.tova fcetort. In ciiitica, it cppea.rct1 that the prir.cipd reczm fe:-

j c:*:16ering a r.ilot t.ctuated v nte are:

i r

j 2

Its ir.el:.cica de,es g?=1t a reccetien in r-e;' fice re;ainr::st.

g t

i 2.

It r-iiths the pirat in ecse:tidly the cc a fecv. c.2 p ::cated

(

in th Iccles tr.1 renccre::t pre.v in.

1 3.

Iilct c t;n tci v:,1w s r:.re fc=ilier c a tic:frc.ble c,:Wrt<strees i

on & thility phnt red, ter.ce, hrve cza c:.n.ctin:; sc-41

?

j

&:: ciditic0al pht thic'.2 v.a not brc'.3dit cat in the previva-ly cent c:.r.d dir.e ratir. s a

f u tt:0 the ces er c pil;t t. casted vrJve doc: red.m Os vs.*.her recro c70.tttirr:

t1~a reviru.*c'.: ;41c'1 r~ ~t c.hrr.r$ et k :'-oc:$ La t% 7'.antirer EP t,y racc}

i.e., nn clar;i to full c;ca ym;itica is Icxr rc-ac.r.1c.

In vie-s of th; c' :n, ve ero revhhg c tr re:ere.te:tien teccc.ited in re.r:se.co (4),

i It ir. r.c t r ee:c.t -A ;.1 ttct n 2: dl tvo hdf cr* nw r'~

10r-hu crie v2.Wc:

cf.S c. pt t it.1 er ::'.ty pilot r.ctutte::1 valv: vith I'.) c:neit.tcl citext v 1";. -i^rd.c vill gr.:.it in.t Cd. tics of n rz'.11cr sp;r;; iciva rr.,; cyct.;r ins:14 in C a r.N.1:u.rl:.:r.

3

/e en r.ifitics to efritt cho c;:c.y c'.i pilot octent ca vc. ires, l't is svr.ntel ths).

rc ec:4 fact thcts tes cett,Kntna cm toin;; es~;pleccate/ to trth o'l'er U' - rh t.:

cf.s or the othc? cct0/. ccue:1vv.b1f clone Ichile trcasic:t; cycr;rcasm prctecties i

s, I

t i

O M~' n. e'..

s o

w a :L u m-

.a ii 3

g -

n g

I t

4

'esamesw ir,.s,ans=e-*--wme s-aw tmu,.f-n r-+c4 _

(:

e

.o-0 o.

4

-Q

'm J l

3

/.i s.

?

g or t':0 V 2 cc:per. intr. catt hr 117n thic bty t-e%*r.

f.: r. r%.ce s. tert r :. !.e 11.*:r o l

t t btlieve tv ef. c. del h: 11e t.U. rc: nl ce hich17 I tra-Ale trent*J ar.te vity. r? r.-

l tnd it: Its: If. 4.;r 1 ::.1: v:c vi:h the pilct c t :r,ta, v.1ve.

It s.v;.2d te a c;:rM e

}

if thir, rt:Tr *Si L: Ifr.e c ria te ry,1h.1 to tha tr.; -ic.'.r.

en e:te.d VLe t Ic.;;a C.3 i

4

' n r 1:'.1~r t re r):': te: V:t (:e to the t:.11 cr =2 c: *.12 " cycl * *. f2 tr.5..e cc. rr: aux I

. 4 tSie rhv&, t.:t be t. rt re..c i seter in u.it!..Mh (c:idir.r. h~. t9 cr r rer-Irv 3 70trctica al*y thrt.t.11 to rpti tc.w:r. the tiry tai pihL cr.!,=r tr./. vt.11 c:2.

1

/ D of thic t'r.?, we L ve to elcer defiritica t,f the r:- " cr re.fc'cr vc1xc re :tre-n r.t t, 1.tootc0 ter tr:ntic.tr. the., less t*.m f ->r T.-

r t m t -f m;.

17 c w c4 t.his j

lette, Ibecrc. Ihacr.cr.ny ri/cr Cievor a.re t ce; tested:

j 1.

To c= firm th.t til ruch trraelents heve lets rtrism merpeer.ure T2tt?ctics rcph;.nnt,: thsa the 1W: pu p r.its:. tics, or 2

To d': fine ths evc:j cscure protecties rep.f rene::tt, fer Ic.:e t*. :.

to':r :sm c7 crc'!.cs, cr 4

4i 3.

To inficcte cca this type of fr.itreadicci vill te cvr.1161c,

=

6 f.st fdt:; that the c. pror.i crtLir.td r.Mw ineo:?:: :.*.!

.e. t-o Lair cc,:-ity cede 1j v:17ec cnA c. pilot a.ct2.z:c.1 velve vill be cce< c;;t.no, va it.ttr.$ t.a ;.:cas.1 to l

. C ' rdep r:recifica. tic.ac fe: tLe pilct r.:';a.te.1 n.?- e t:u to C:.lcLe res!.c c..:ilectics 1

cr t?.e tirte-rey - elte, ns.tr c~---".tc tr.ed to r;gre:Leted en ti.ic lttte:.

1

?

T.iDt212:57.

I 1

1i es: JWerchent j

i p Tsea r-t l'02.rtt I

TC cic-i

'C-t.41yny d

. i j

0=:treet li:pertrent (5) fw.h Y,. h i

rufen 1

- -r' %

CIhberf C3tevens 1

m iltc4

(;Eucyt.srn - Esrberten d

n i

i 1

i 4

l O

l It D*fD

%D'W N l;

A M NW

=

6

.4 1

0 5

4 9 -

d

^

""*M

'e,.

,,e,

.--*=----s-em--.===.-

,..-